Sungho V.
Park
a,
Lakshmi
Bhai
b,
Gahyun Annie
Lee
bc,
Ah-Hyung Alissa
Park
bcd,
Lauren E.
Marbella
b and
Jonathan S.
Owen
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, USA. E-mail: jso2115@columbia.edu
bDepartment of Chemical Engineering, Columbia University, New York, New York 10027, USA
cLenfest Center for Sustainable Energy, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, USA
dDepartment of Earth and Environmental Engineering, Columbia University, New York, New York 10027, USA
First published on 2nd December 2024
We report the synthesis and characterization of octahedral UiO-66 nanocrystals (d = 17–25 nm) terminated with amine, oleate, and octadecylphosphonate ligands. Acetate capped UiO-66 nanocrystals were dispersed in toluene using oleic acid and oleylamine. Ligand exchange with octadecylphosphonic acid produces ammonium octadecylphosphonate terminated nanocrystals with coverages of 2.6–3.2 chains per nm2 that stabilize colloidal dispersions in nonpolar solvents. Liquid phase 1H and 31P nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra of the linkers and surface ligands display line shapes that are broadened by slow tumbling of the nanocrystals. Octadecylphosphonate functionalized MOFs have up to ∼30% carbon dioxide absorption capacities compared to bulk UiO-66 after correcting for the ligand mass. These results illustrate the intriguing perspective that MOF nanocrystals can be characterized and manipulated like a macromolecular complex and represent an important milestone in the nascent field of MOF surface science.
As the nanocrystal size shrinks, an increasingly large percentage of the nodal coordination sites are displayed at the nanocrystal's surface. In the case of UiO-66, >5% of all carboxylates in the crystal are found on the exterior surface of nanocrystals less than 50 nm (Fig. 1). The high proportion of surface sites at this length scale facilitates the study of MOF surface coordination chemistry and can improve the performance of polymer-MOF composites, catalysts, and medical technologies.
Syntheses of several nanocrystalline MOFs have been reported, including UiO-66.13–17 The nanometer scale size is achieved by introducing high concentrations of monotopic carboxylates, so called “modulators”,18–21 and increasing the proportion of linkers beyond the stoichiometric ratio. These conditions produce crystals with zeta potentials sufficiently large to support electrostatically stabilized colloidal dispersions in polar solvents such as methanol and dimethylformamide (DMF) (up to 40 mV).22,23 However, under optimized conditions MOF nanocrystals precipitate from the synthesis mixture and are isolated as solids that can be temporarily dispersed by sonication. The dispersibility can be enhanced by choosing solvents that have favorable interactions with the linkers,22 and upon introduction of ligands to the nanocrystal's surface. A recent progress report reviews surface modification strategies that address MOF nanoparticle linkers and nodes.12 While linker functionalization is more common, the functionalization of nodal sites at framework surfaces is a relatively new endeavor.24
Long chain surfactant ligands, calixarenes, and polymers have all been attached to the surface of MOFs post synthesis.4,25–30 In some cases, colloidal dispersions in nonpolar solvents (e.g., toluene or chloroform) have been reported with short term stability, despite the relatively large particle sizes typically studied (>100 nm).26,30 A recent example functionalized the surfaces of UiO-66 nanocrystals (100–200 nm edge length) with crown ether containing ligands, which provided electrostatically stabilized dispersions in both polar and nonpolar media.30 Pure steric stabilization of MOF nanocrystal dispersions, on the other hand, is less common. Phospholipid capped UiO-66 of 25–220 nm has been dispersed in CHCl3 and the surface ligand coverage estimated to be 1.3 nm−2, which corresponds to approximately 70–80% of the theoretical coverage (1.86 ligands per nm2 on the [100] surface or 1.61 ligands per nm2 on the [111] surface).25 However, researchers have struggled to obtain optically clear dispersions with long term stability, possibly due to the fact that these coverages are less than half of typical ligand densities found on colloidal quantum dots or self-assembled monolayers on metal surfaces.31,32
Using oleylamine, oleate, and octadecylphosphonate ligands, we targeted sterically stabilized dispersions of MOF nanocrystals with dimensions less than 50 nm. Dispersibility in nonpolar media could lead to highly active catalysts with a homogeneous structure in solution.33 The large proportion of surface coordination sites of crystals on this length scale greatly facilitates the study of their surface coordination chemistry, using bulk characterization techniques. We use liquid phase and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to explore their chemical formulas and monitor the exchange of their surface ligands. We also describe their gas uptake capacity, which is sensitive to the surface coordination chemistry.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Synthesis and functionalization of UiO-66 nanocrystals illustrating the proposed stoichiometry of the crystal surface during ligand exchange. |
The nanocrystal size could be reduced below 100 nm by increasing the concentration of the linker (terephthalic acid), a strategy that was successful in a synthesis of NU-1000 MOF crystals ranging from 300 nm to ∼10 μm in length.36 In our hands, the nanocrystal size proved insensitive to the concentration of acetic acid, which appears contrary to previous reports. Instead, if the reaction is conducted without stirring, the acetic acid modulator does influence the nanocrystal size.23 The difference between stirred and unstirred conditions suggests the intermediacy of a gel phase that precedes crystallization, consistent with previous reports.37
Upon heating the mixture for several hours, the nanocrystals precipitate from solution and are isolated by centrifugation. The precipitate is then washed with DMF and water prior to functionalization with oleic acid and oleylamine followed by precipitation using methyl acetate and centrifugation (Scheme 1). The functionalized nanoMOFs disperse in toluene and are separated from insoluble material in a final centrifugation step (8000 rpm, 10 minutes). Oleate/oleylamine terminated nanocrystals prepared in this way remain colloidally stable for >3 months without sedimentation (Fig. S9†). However, additional rounds of dispersal in toluene, precipitation with methyl acetate, and centrifugation reduced the ligand density and reduced the dispersibility (see ESI†).
The ratio of oleate, oleylamine, linker, and acetate in the nanocrystals was measured by digesting a known mass of the sample in D2SO4/DMSO-d6 and recording the NMR spectrum in the presence of an internal standard (see detailed discussion below and ESI†). Similar quantities of oleate and olelyamine are observed and suggest mixed coordination as depicted in Scheme 1. The coordination of amine ligands to Zr6O8H4(acrylate)12 has been described.38
Ligand exchange was conducted by stirring the toluene dispersion of nanocrystals with octadecylphosphonic acid (∼1 equiv. per surface amine and oleate) at 60 °C, followed by two cycles of precipitation, centrifugation, and dispersion using toluene and methyl acetate. Greater amounts of octadecylphosphonic acid caused dissolution of the framework, which may be related to decomposition of the Z6O8 nodal cluster.39 The presence of bound oleylamine reduces the acidity of the mixture and is sufficiently basic to deprotonate monohydrogen phosphonate ions, albeit in aqueous solution.40–42 Coordination to the Lewis acidic zirconium only increases the acidity and favors the formation of the dibasic phosphonate/ammonium ion pair proposed in Scheme 1 and similar to motifs found on colloidal quantum dots.43 Unlike the oleylamine/oleate terminated crystals, the ODPA terminated crystals remain colloidally stable after three washes.
Exchange of the oleate ligands for ODPA increased the separation between particles and helped eliminate some of the aggregation visible in the STEM images. Hydrodynamic diameters (∼25 nm), as measured using dynamic light scattering (DLS), are in good agreement with the dimensions determined using STEM. The hydrodynamic diameters of ODPA terminated crystals are 10–15 nm lower than the oleate and oleylamine functionalized nanocrystals (Fig. S10†). Hence, our TEM and DLS results support the conclusion that ODPA treatment decreases the degree of nanocrystal aggregation and enhances the dispersibility.
Magic angle spinning (MAS) solid-state NMR (SSNMR) spectra are compared with the liquids NMR spectrum in Fig. 3. SSNMR spectra displayed significantly narrower linker signals than liquid spectra, which supports the conclusion that the NMR linewidth in the liquids spectrum is broadened by slow tumbling. However, the overall spectral lineshapes are similar. Both measurements support a relatively consistent and controlled ratio of ligands and linkers that is the result of our optimized synthesis and isolation procedure.
ODPA terminated nanocrystals display more isotropic signals, and narrower linker resonances (δ = 8–9 ppm) than oleate terminated crystals (Fig. S21†), that can be explained by their improved tumbling and lower degree of aggregation. At the same time, the sharp signals of free ligands are absent, which may be the result of a higher binding constant of the phosphonate headgroup and the tighter association of the ammonium ion as compared to the oleylamine ligand. The high affinity of phosphonic acids for early metal oxides is well established.47–49 Liquid phase 31P NMR spectra of the ODPA terminated particles display a broad peak centered at δ = 24.7 ppm with a full width at half maximum of 1600–2000 Hz, depending on particle size (Fig. 3 and S23†). This chemical shift and linewidth are similar to those reported for phosphonate terminated quantum dots.50
In the presence of an internal standard the 1H NMR spectra of the digestion solution allows precise determination of the linker and ligand mole percentages, including signals from oleylammonium and acetic acid. The mass percentage of zirconium (in the form of ZrO2) is measured by thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA) at temperatures up to 800 °C,34,51 from which the mole percentage of [Zr6(O)4(OH)4]12+ can be calculated. These results are compared with the ligand mole percentages determined by acid digestion and liquids NMR spectroscopy. However, this method underestimates the amount of ODPA, which has low solubility in D2SO4/DMSO-d6 (see ESI†). Hence, the ODPA content was determined from the 1H SSNMR spectrum by subtracting the contribution of acetate and oleylammonium ligands (determined following digestion) from the total aliphatic signal (see Section S2 of ESI†).
The mass percentages of linkers, ligands, acetate, and [Zr6(O)4(OH)4]12+ are shown in Table 1. The mass balance results indicate that the combined TGA/NMR approach is self-consistent. Interestingly, incorporation of modulators is relatively low (10 mol%), when compared to the ratio of acetic acid and terephthalic acid in the synthesis mixture (32:
1 to 73
:
1).52 Although surface hydroxide may be present, the FT-IR spectrum of nanocrystals prior to and after functionalization with ODPA has relatively weak signals in the v(O–H) region. Collectively, these results are consistent with a relatively pure sample of our octahedral nanocrystal model.
D (nm) | Zr6O8b (%) | Linkerc (%) | R′-NHxc (%) | ODPAd (%) | Acetatec (%) | Toluenec (%) | Total (%) | R′-NHxc,e (nm−2) | ODPAd,e (nm−2) | Total (nm−2) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a The error in D is assumed to be equal to the dimension of a single UiO-66 unit cell.
b Determined using TGA. Uncertainty in TGA mass measurement is 10−6 mg, hence the error is negligible.
c Determined from quantitative digestion and liquids 1H NMR (see Section S2 of ESI). Error in values determined from NMR peak integration is assumed to be 10%.
d From SSNMR integration of aliphatic signal (see Section S2 of ESI).
e Uncertainty in the ligand density was calculated from ![]() ![]() ![]() |
||||||||||
22.8(2.1) | 30.8 | 32.2(3.2) | 10.5(1.0) | 17.5(1.8) | 3.5(0.3) | 4.5(0.5) | 99(10) | 1.1(0.2) | 1.5(0.2) | 2.6(0.4) |
27.0(2.1) | 31.1 | 31.5(3.1) | 9.3(0.9) | 19.8(2.0) | 3.2(0.3) | 5.2(0.5) | 100(10) | 1.1(0.2) | 1.9(0.3) | 3.0(0.4) |
31.1(2.1) | 31.5 | 34.4(3.4) | 9.4(0.9) | 18.4(1.8) | 3.6(0.4) | 6.4(0.6) | 104(10) | 1.2(0.2) | 1.9(0.3) | 3.2(0.4) |
35.3(2.1) | 31.3 | 29.2(2.9) | 6.8(0.7) | 17.2(1.7) | 2.7(0.3) | 1.6(0.2) | 89(9) | 1.0(0.1) | 2.0(0.3) | 3.0(0.4) |
The areal density of oleyl and ODPA chains reaches 2.6–3.2 nm−2, which is similar to the density of carboxylates on colloidal quantum dots,53 and well below the density of crystalline n-alkanes (4.9 nm−2) (see ESI†). This quantity is approximately ∼2× the theoretical density of surface carboxylates on the (111) surface (1.61 nm−2) and consistent with the proposed oleylammonium octadecylphosphonate structure shown in Scheme 1. The relatively high density of chains helps explain the persistent colloidal stability of the final nanocrystals.
However, the measured density of ODPA is greater than oleylamine and slightly greater than the density of carboxylate binding sites. A portion of the ligands may exist in a monohydrogen phosphonate form, rather than the dibasic form with associated ammonium cations. Alternatively, partial decomposition of the nodal cluster may lead to other forms. In any case, the similarity of these data and the theoretical octahedral nanocrystal supports a picture where oleate, oleylammonium, and octadecylphosphonate ligands are bound to surface coordination sites, while modulators and linkers are associated with the interior of the nanocrystal.
Edge length (nm) | D (nm) | CO2 capture oleatea (mmol g−1) | CO2 capture ODPAa (mmol g−1) | Surface area oleate (m2 g−1) | Surface area ODPA (m2 g−1) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a CO2 uptake capacity was measured using TGA at 25 °C, under 1 atmosphere of CO2. b The yield of the 25.2 nm ODPA capped MOF synthesis was insufficient for a BET measurement. | |||||
16.8 | 22.8 | 0.157 | 0.311 | 152 | 369 |
19.8 | 27.0 | 0.157 | 0.360 | 140 | 379 |
22.3 | 31.1 | 0.162 | 0.378 | 148 | 392 |
25.2 | 35.3 | 0.171 | 0.351 | 81 | ndb |
Bulk | 1.786 | 1067 |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details, MOF chemical formula determination method, supplementary figures, BET/TGA/CO2 capture analysis, modelling, and liquid phase NMR spectra. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc06528j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |