August J.
Rothenberger
a,
Harrison M.
Bergman
a,
He
Li
bc,
Miao
Qi
b,
Yunfei
Wang
b,
Yi
Liu
*bc and
T. Don
Tilley
*ad
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of California, Berkeley, California 94720, USA. E-mail: tdtilley@berkeley.edu
bMolecular Foundry, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA. E-mail: yliu@lbl.gov
cMaterials Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA
dChemical Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA
First published on 12th November 2024
Conjugated ladder polymers (CLPs) are difficult yet captivating synthetic targets due to their fully unsaturated fused backbones. Inherent challenges associated with their synthesis often lead to low yields, structural defects, and insoluble products. Here a new method to form CLPs is demonstrated, utilizing a high-yielding dimerization of annulated zirconacyclopentadienes to form cyclooctatetraene (COT) monomer units. The resulting COT-containing polymers form rapidly in a single ladderization step from the bis-zirconacyclopentadiene precursors and display Mn up to 29.7 kg mol−1. The polymers represent rare examples of CLPs with negatively curved rings, resulting in the observation of unusual properties. The rigid tub-shaped COT units embedded in the backbone imbue the polymers with microporosity, exhibiting BET surface areas up to 555 m2 g−1. Additionally, the remarkable solubility of these CLPs in organic solvents enables the fabrication of thin films showcasing high dielectric performance with a discharged energy density as high as 6.54 J cm−3 at 650 MV m−1.
The use of negatively-curved rings to form contorted and flexible nanographene materials has been the topic of many recent studies,12–17 but their use in CLPs is less explored.18 To date, there are still no methods of generating negatively curved rings in high enough yield for the synthesis of high molecular weight CLPs. Müllen and co-workers first incorporated eight-membered rings into graphene nanoribbons of Mn = 2.1 kg mol−1via Ullmann coupling (Fig. 1a),19 although these rings are planar and did not display the characteristic “tub-shape” of cyclooctatetraene (COT), possessing greater similarity to a biphenylene sheet.20 A similar perylene diimide (PDI) nanoribbon was synthesized by Zhong on an Au(111) surface.21 Recently, Jiang reported the use of Ullmann coupling to generate chiral PDI dimers and tetramers containing negatively curved eight-membered rings with high dissymmetry.22 This iterative approach to the synthesis of oligomers highlights the inherent challenges of generating linear COT-containing ladder polymers. In 2023, Coskun synthesized a three-dimensional polymer network containing COT and biphenylene moieties via benzyne dimerization (Fig. 1b).23 This initially generates a mostly linear biphenylene polymer, with appreciable COT crosslinks only being introduced during a separate thermal treatment at 400 °C to induce an intermolecular rearrangement of the polymer backbone. The resulting polymer is insoluble, limiting characterization of molecular weight or the efficiency of the COT generation step. The materials displayed high surface areas and gas absorption selectivity, showing promise for membrane applications of COT-containing materials. During the preparation of this manuscript, Feng and co-workers reported the synthesis of a ladder polymer by cycloaddition of a bis-cyclopentadienone with a cycloocta-1,5-diyne at 265 °C (Scheme 1c).24 The success of this approach is predicated on the use of established Diels–Alder chemistry,25,26 which requires a pre-made COT building block to install negative curvature. Additionally, the high Mn ∼26.4 kg mol−1 and low dispersity of 1.15 are achieved after separation of fractions by recycling size exclusion chromatography. In each of the former cases, molecular weight and defect density are non-ideal due to COT formation occurring via two distinct reactions, either via successive Ullmann couplings or an intermolecular rearrangement. The development of approaches that utilize a single, concerted step to generate COT promises to circumvent these issues.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 (a) Synthesis of COT 2 from zirconacycle 1. (b) COT-containing polymers Poly-3 and Poly-4 from bis-zirconacycle precursors 3 and 4. |
Such a reaction to generate a COT ring was previously described by this research group, whereby phenanthrene-annulated zirconacyclopentadiene (zirconacycle) 1 is converted to COT 2via a cyclobutadiene intermediate at room temperature (Scheme 1a).27 It is hypothesized that this occurs by dimerization of two transient phenanthrocyclobutadienes through a [4 + 2] cycloaddition and spontaneous rearrangement, affording a COT ring rapidly at room temperature. In this report we improve the efficiency of the reaction to enable its use for polymerization to obtain two COT-containing CLPs with different aromatic backbones, each displaying high molecular weight (Mn > 26 kg mol−1) and low dispersity (Đ ≤ 1.52) (Scheme 1b). Both resulting polymers are highly soluble in common organic solvents, enabling the fabrication of thin films as high-performance dielectrics.
The polymers were also characterized by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-time of flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry, which gave molecular weights consistent with those determined by SEC analysis. Poly-3 displays a prominent repeat unit of 854 m/z corresponding to the mass of the monomer unit visible to about Xn = 26 (Fig. 3a). Similarly, the MALDI-TOF pattern for Poly-4 possesses a 914 m/z repeat unit visible until Xn = 28 (Fig. 3b). Infrared spectroscopy was utilized to confirm the presence of cyclooctatetraene moieties in the backbone of the polymers. The spectra of 2, Poly-3, and Poly-4 were compared to a simulated IR spectrum of 2 calculated at the B3LYP/6-31g level of theory. Representative COT vibrations were found at 1606, 1504, and 1241 cm−1 (Fig. 3c) across all spectra, demonstrating shared COT functionality between 2, Poly-3, and Poly-4.
The polymers display broad resonances in NMR spectra, due to the unsymmetrical substitution for the COT repeat unit. This is reflected in the 1H NMR spectrum of monomeric 2, which has 24 unique aryl proton resonance peaks.28 Introduction of repeat units leads to further complexity; thus, the ratio of aryl to alkyl resonances is more informative. For both polymers, the resonance ratio nearly matches the predicted values of 1:
1.38 for Poly-3 and 1
:
1.80 for Poly-4 (Fig. S1 and S3†). The 13C NMR spectra are similarly broad for both polymers, with peaks in the aryl region between 155 to 125 ppm and resonances for alkyl groups between 35 and 30 ppm. Very few other peaks are visible in the 1H spectrum of Poly-3 at 3.43 and 3.28 ppm, indicating a highly selective polymerization with minimal defects. Similarly, in the 1H spectrum of Poly-4, small defect peaks are present at 2.98 and 2.13 ppm. These likely correspond to annulated cyclobutene resonances, a plausible source of quenched chain ends.
UV-vis spectroscopy was utilized to determine the absorption onset for samples of Poly-3 with increasing molecular weight (Fig. 2c). Normalized at the maximum absorbance peak for the sample of monomer 3 quenched before exposure to CuCl2/DABCO (labeled as 0 min) the samples show a red-shifted absorption onset as Mn increases up to about 14 kg mol−1 at 15 min, indicating that the effective conjugation length along the polymer backbone occurs between 11–16 repeat units. Similarly, a red shift is observed in the absorption onset for Poly-4 samples (Fig. S13†), corresponding to a maximum between 12–18 repeat units. Samples of COT 2, Poly-3, and Poly-4 are weakly fluorescent, displaying emission peaks at 455, 474, and 489 nm, respectively (Fig. S12†).
The incorporation of negatively curved COT rings embedded in a rigid ladder backbone makes Poly-3 and Poly-4 promising candidates as polymers with high intrinsic porosity.29 The polymers were subjected to nitrogen adsorption measurements at 77 K and showed substantial uptake at low relative pressure (P/P0). The calculated apparent Brunauer–Emmett–Teller surface areas (SABET)30 of 421 m2 g−1 and 555 m2 g−1 for Poly-3 and Poly-4 indicate that the polymers possess significant microporosity (Fig. S20†). Evaluation of pore sizes in the two polymers with non-local density functional theory (NLDFT) using a carbon-slit model revealed a microporous region with pores between 10.9–13.5 Å as well as some mesoporosity extending to pore diameters of 120–220 Å (Fig. S21 and S22†). Microporosity likely results from the negative curvature of the rigid COT monomer units forcing inefficient packing of polymer chains while the meso- to macroporosity may result from void space between polymer particles. The polymers have surface area metrics similar to other COT-containing networks,23 but are noteworthy due to their ideal solution processibility amenable to castings of thin films.
The rigid structures of Poly-3 and Poly-4 imbues them with high thermal stability, such that they display relatively high decomposition temperatures around 350 and 325 °C, respectively, as measured by thermal gravimetric analysis (Fig. S14 and S15†). Neither possesses observable glass transition temperatures within the thermally accessible range (Fig. S16 and S17†). Additionally, neither polymer displays reversible redox events as determined by cyclic voltammetry (Fig. S19†). This is consistent with the behavior of monomer 2, which shows four irreversible reductions between −2.2 and −3.5 V vs. Fc/Fc+ (Fig. S18†). The inability to access an aromatic COT dianion showcases the polymers' resistance to planarization and deformation of the polymeric structure.
The solution processability, thermal stability, and wide window of redox stability prompted us to consider these polymers as thin film-based dielectric materials for energy storage applications,31–33 for which ladder polymers have been identified as promising candidates.34,35 Indium tin oxide (ITO) coated glass substrates served as the conducting substrate (see ESI for casting procedure†). The films were analyzed by grazing-incidence wide-angle X-ray scattering (GI-WAXS) to reveal an amorphous distribution of polymer chains (Fig. S23†).
At 103 Hz, films of Poly-3 exhibit a dielectric constant of 3.68 and a loss tangent of 0.0546 while films of Poly-4 displayed a dielectric constant of 3.56 with a loss tangent of 0.0302 (Fig. 4a and b). This reduction is attributed to the presence of –CF3 substituents which leads to a decreased overall polarizability. This phenomenon has been observed in various CF3-containing dielectric polymers,36 such as fluorinated polyimides.37–39 Few traditional conjugated ladder polymers have been subjected to thin-film dielectric studies, but a planar poly(benzimidazobenzophenanthroline) CLP has a dielectric constant of 8.3.40 Due to the rigid microporous nature of Poly-3 and Poly-4, the lowered dielectric constants would be expected due to the decreased packing density of polymer chains.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) Frequency-dependent dielectric constant; (b) frequency-dependent dielectric loss tangent; (c) discharged energy density; (d) energy efficiency of COT polymers. |
Poly-4 achieved substantial discharged energy density, up to 6.54 J cm−3 at 650 MV m−1 (Fig. 4c). In contrast, Poly-3 possessed a lower electrical-voltage endurance which limited the film device's capability to withstand higher electric fields, resulting in a maximum discharged energy density of 4.47 J cm−3 at an electric field of 550 MV m−1. Further details concerning the dielectric breakdown strength of the films are provided in the ESI.† Under the same electric field, Poly-3 exhibited an energy efficiency that is inferior to that of Poly-4 (Fig. 4d), which is likely attributable to the higher polarizability and larger dielectric loss with to the absence of –CF3 groups. With the increase in electric field, the lower energy efficiency of Poly-3 further decreased. In contrast, Poly-4 consistently exceeds 85% energy efficiency even at high electric fields of 600–650 MV m−1.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc06902a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |