Kohei Suzukia,
Kota Katayamaab,
Yuji Sumiia,
Tomoya Nakagitad,
Ryoji Sunoc,
Hirokazu Tsujimotod,
So Iwatad,
Takuya Kobayashice,
Norio Shibataa and
Hideki Kandori*ab
aDepartment of Life Science and Applied Chemistry, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Showa-ku, Nagoya 466-8555, Japan. E-mail: kandori@nitech.ac.jp
bOptoBioTechnology Research Center, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Showa-ku, Nagoya 466-8555, Japan
cDepartment of Medical Chemistry, Kansai Medical University, Hirakata 573-1010, Japan
dDepartment of Cell Biology, Graduate School of Medicine, Kyoto University, Kyoto 606-8501, Japan
eJapan Agency for Medical Research and Development, Core Research for Evolutional Science and Technology (AMED-CREST), Tokyo 100-0004, Japan
First published on 7th April 2021
The M2 muscarinic acetylcholine receptor (M2R) is a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) that responds to acetylcholine (ACh) and mediates various cellular responses in the nervous system. We recently established Attenuated Total Reflection-Fourier Transform Infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy for ligand binding to M2R reconstituted in lipid membranes, paving the way to understand the mechanism in atomic detail. However, the obtained difference FTIR spectra upon ligand binding contained ligand, protein, lipid, and water signals, so a vibrational assignment was needed for a thorough understanding. In the present study, we compared difference FTIR spectra between unlabeled and 2-13C labeled ACh, and assigned the bands at 1741 and 1246 cm−1 as the CO and C–O stretches of ACh, respectively. The CO stretch of ACh in M2R is close to that in aqueous solution (1736 cm−1), and much lower in frequency than the free CO stretch (1778–1794 cm−1), indicating a strong hydrogen bond, which probably formed with N4046.52. We propose that a water molecule bridges ACh and N4046.52. The other ACh terminal is positively charged, and it interacts with negatively charged D1033.32. The present study revealed that D1033.32 is deprotonated (negatively charged) in both ACh-bound and free states, a suggested mechanism to stabilize the negative charge of D1033.32 in the free M2R.
M2R is one of the best studied GPCRs, and its structure and structural dynamics have been reported by X-ray crystallography,11–13 cryo-electron microscopy,14,15 and NMR.10 Fig. 1a illustrates the structure of the active state that binds an agonist iperoxo, and highlights the binding site composed of D1033.32, N4046.52, and a tyrosine lid (Y1043.33, Y4036.51, and Y4267.39). The antagonist binding form of M2R was also reported.11 While these structures provided useful structural information, no structures have yet been suggested for the binding form of acetylcholine (ACh), the native ligand, and the ligand-free form. Therefore, it is unknown how key residues respond to the binding of ACh. For instance, it is reasonable to postulate that D1033.32 is deprotonated in the ACh-binding form to stabilize the positively charged ACh. Yet what is the protonation state of D1033.32 in the ligand-free form? And how do N4046.52 and tyrosines alter their structures before and after ACh binding? A similar question is equally applicable to ACh itself, namely how is the structure altered upon binding to M2R?
Fig. 1 (a) Crystal structure of the active M2R in complex with agonist iperoxo (left, PDB: 4MQS), and the enlarged ligand binding site (right). D1033.32, N4046.52, and the tyrosine lid (Y1043.33, Y4036.51, and Y4267.39) constitute the binding site of iperoxo, whereas the structure of the native ligand, ACh, remains unknown. (b) The acetylcholine binding-induced difference ATR-FTIR spectrum, which is reproduced from ref. 18. (c) Gauche and trans forms of ACh. Previous FTIR study of methacholine and acetylthiocholine revealed the gauche form being the conformation of the native ligand.18 (d) Chemical structure of ACh and the 13C-labeled position in the present study. |
Stimulus-induced difference Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy is a powerful, sensitive and informative tool to investigate protein structural changes that accompany biologically important functional processes.16,17 Although light has been the ideal stimulus for difference FTIR spectroscopy, we attempted to extend the application of ligand-binding to GPCR by using Attenuated Total Reflection (ATR)-FTIR spectroscopy. Fig. 1b shows the first difference FTIR spectrum thus obtained for ACh-binding to human M2R.18 The measurements were performed in membrane lipids, which is more native than in protein crystal (X-ray crystallography) and in detergent (cryo-electron microscopy, NMR, and DEER). A small amount of the sample (5 μg) is another advantage of difference FTIR spectroscopy.
In a previous study, we compared the data for ACh (Fig. 1b) with those for methacholine (gauche-conformation preferable) and acetylthiocholine (trans-conformation preferable), concluding that ACh binds with M2R in its gauche conformation (Fig. 1c).18 Positive and negative bands in Fig. 1b originate from ACh-bound and free M2R, respectively, and the bands at 1666 (−)/1656 (+) cm−1 indicate a helical structural perturbation upon ACh binding. In addition, positive peaks at 1741, 1687, and 1246 cm−1 are possibly due to the vibrations of the carboxylic CO stretch (D1033.32), carbonyl CO stretch (N4046.52), and phenolic C–O stretch (Y1043.33, Y4036.51, and Y4267.39), respectively. It should be noted, however, that the difference FTIR spectra contain signals of ACh, which also possesses CO and C–O stretches (Fig. 1d). Therefore, we are able to interpret vibrational bands only when they are assigned by using isotope-labeling. In this study, we synthesized 2-13C-labeled ACh (Fig. 1d), whose difference FTIR spectra were compared with those of unlabeled ACh. Vibrational assignment of the CO and C–O stretches of ACh provides structural insight into not only the ligand, but also the protein moiety such as D1033.32 and the Tyr lid. The mechanism by which ACh binds to M2R will be discussed based on the present FTIR observations.
The 1800–1700 cm−1 region is characteristic of protonated carboxylic acids, although the frequencies for deprotonated carboxylic acids (1650–1550 cm−1 and 1450–1350 cm−1) overlap with other vibrations and their identification is difficult. D1033.32 is probably located at the position in contact with ACh in the bound M2R, as is iperoxo (Fig. 1a). As ACh is positively charged, D1033.32 is likely to be deprotonated for the charge balance. In contrast, the protonation state of D1033.32 is unclear in the ligand-free M2R. If D1033.32 is protonated in the free form, the bound-minus-free difference FTIR spectra should exhibit a negative band at 1800–1700 cm−1. The 1741 cm−1 band was shifted to 1698 cm−1, while a small positive band remained at about 1750–1730 cm−1 for the 2-13C-labeled ACh (blue line in Fig. 2a). This possibly originates from protonated carboxylic acid, which will be examined by the measurement in D2O below.
Fig. 2a also shows that a positive peak at 1246 cm−1 of the black spectrum reduced the amplitude in the blue spectrum by half, while a positive peak newly appeared at 1216 cm−1 for the blue spectrum. The isotope shift is clearly shown in the double difference spectrum (12C minus 2-13C spectrum) in Fig. 2b, and the spectral shift by 30 cm−1 coincides with the calculated value using a reduced mass for the 12C–O and 13C–O groups (28 cm−1). Thus, we assigned the band at 1246 cm−1 as the C–O stretch of ACh. It should be noted that we also observed a peak at 1246 cm−1, whose amplitude is similar to that at 1216 cm−1 (blue line in Fig. 2a). This suggests that the band at 1246 cm−1 is composed of multiple vibrations, including the C–O stretch of ACh. In addition to the tagged peaks, there were some spectral deviations between black and blue spectra, which is also clear in the double difference spectrum (red curve in Fig. 2b). Nevertheless, no clear positive/negative peak pair was observed.
Fig. 3 The effect of deuterium on the spectra for unlabeled (a) and 2-13C-labeled (b) acetylcholine. Black and red lines are the spectra in H2O and D2O, respectively. |
In a previous paper, we also studied the binding of atropine to M2R.18 Unlike positively charged ACh, atropine is a neutral antagonist. From the effect of deuterium on the atropine-bound M2R spectra, we suggest the possibility of D1033.32 protonation of both bound and free states. However, atropine also contain a CO group, and it is difficult to identify the protonation state of carboxylic acids in the presence of the CO ligand. In this sense, the present spectral analysis (Fig. 3b) is more convincing, and we conclude that ligand-free M2R contains a negatively charged D1033.32.
Previously we tentatively assigned the positive band at 1687 cm−1 to the CO stretch of N4046.52, as it exhibited a 6 cm−1 down-shift to 1681 cm−1 in D2O (Fig. 3a).18 This spectral feature was also the case for 2-13C-labeled ACh (Fig. 3b), which is consistent with our previous interpretation. It should be noted that these peaks diminished in atropine-bound M2R spectra.18 Therefore, the hydrogen bond of N4046.52 with an agonist, but not with an antagonist, plays a crucial role in the formation of an active structure. This view is supported by previous crystal structures of inactive11 and active M2R12,13 as well as previous mutagenesis studies.12
The positive 1246 cm−1 band for unlabeled ACh exhibited an up-shift to 1249 cm−1 in D2O (Fig. 3a), suggesting that this band originated from the C–O stretch of a tyrosine residue. However, as can be seen in Fig. 2, the band at 1246 cm−1 is split into two peaks for 2-13C-labeled ACh. Fig. 3b shows that the positive 1216 cm−1 band is unexchangeable H–D, which is consistent with the assignment as the C–O stretch of ACh. On the other hand, the positive 1246 cm−1 band was up-shifted to 1250 cm−1 in D2O. An upward shift is characteristic of the C–O stretch of tyrosine. The amino acid residues, Y1043.33, Y4267.39, and Y4036.51 are part of the hydrogen-bonding network that forms the “tyrosine lid” of the ligand-binding pocket that excludes solvent entry,4,19 and site directed mutagenesis of these tyrosine residues leads to impaired agonist binding.4 Therefore, the positive band at 1246 cm−1 in Fig. 3b probably originates from the tyrosine lid. A corresponding band was not observed in the atropine-bound M2R spectrum.18
It is known that sodium binding allosterically modulates several GPCRs such as the adenosine receptor,20,21 suggesting that physiological concentrations of sodium ions affect functionally relevant conformational states of GPCRs. Here we tested binding of sodium ions to M2R. Fig. S2† clearly demonstrate the difference spectra between 140 mM sodium and potassium ions coinciding at the baseline, both in the absence and presence of ACh. This observation excludes sodium binding to M2R under the present conditions. It should be noted that one approach alone is not suited for rejecting the hypothesis that sodium might interact with this particular GPCR. However, the present ATR-FTIR spectroscopy was applied to the purified M2R protein in lipid membranes, which was gently attached to the IR prism in buffer solution. Therefore, the present in vitro measurements are performed under the most physiological conditions. In addition, vibrational signals are enough sensitive to distinguish the sodium binding. We thus safely conclude no sodium binding to the purified M2R protein in vitro. It is intriguing to test sodium binding to other GPCRs by ATR-FTIR spectroscopy, which will be our future focus.
Previous IR multiphoton dissociation experiments reported three peaks at 1751, 1778, and 1794 cm−1 for ACh in the gas phase.22 ACh is a flexible molecule, and the terminal CO group is able to interact with the positively charged terminal in a folded conformation, which probably explains the CO stretch at 1751 cm−1. In contrast, the remaining two bands at 1778 and 1794 cm−1 are very high, corresponding to the CO stretch without any interaction. Therefore, the CO stretch of ACh in M2R (1741 cm−1) has a much lower frequency than the free CO stretch (1778–1794 cm−1), but is very close to that in aqueous solution (1736 cm−1). One may believe that polar aprotic solvents such as dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) provide better control than in the gas phase, but it is not the case. Fig. S3† shows that the CO stretch appears at 1744 cm−1 in DMSO. Although DMSO solvent is regarded as no hydrogen-bonding environment, it is likely that Ach forms a folded conformation in DMSO, which enables the terminal CO group interacting with the positively charged terminal as observed in the gas phase (1751 cm−1). These facts indicate that the hydrogen bond of the CO group in M2R is very strong, as strong as in water. We will below propose a structural model based on the present observation.
The C–O stretch appears at 1254 cm−1 in aqueous solution, which is 8 cm−1 higher than in protein. IR multiphoton dissociation experiments reported three peaks at 1186, 1201, and 1205 cm−1 as the C–O stretch of ACh in the gas phase.22 Whereas the addition of water molecules in the cluster increased the frequency in gas-phase spectroscopy,22 in our study, a comparison among the gas phase, aqueous solution, and protein did not provide important structural information, unlike the CO stretches. Fig. 4a and b show a small isotope effect at 1400–1350 cm−1, which was also observed in Fig. 2b. On the other hand, other vibrations exhibited no isotope effect.
Fig. 5a compares the two peaks of the CO stretch of ACh in protein (black line) and in aqueous solution (orange line). Although the concentration of ACh was identical (1 mM), the black peak is one order of magnitude larger than the orange peak. This is presumably because of the increased concentration of the former, as M2R molecules are attached at the surface of the ATR crystal, to which ACh is specifically bound. Fig. 5b is the normalized spectrum, where the orange band was multiplied by 7.5. As is clearly seen in Fig. 5b, band width was much broader in solution (full width of half maximum (FWHM): 17 cm−1) than in protein (FWHM: 4.9 cm−1). This indicates a more heterogeneous structure of ACh in solution than in protein. This is reasonable since ACh is free in solution, but restricted in the protein environment.
This is also the case for the C–O stretch of ACh, where the peak at 1246 cm−1 (Fig. 3) was much larger than the peak at 1254 cm−1 (Fig. 4), and the band width was much broader in solution (FWHM: 21 cm−1) than in protein (FWHM: 9.3 cm−1). Since the 1246 cm−1 band contains protein vibrations, we used the spectra of 13C-labeled ACh. Fig. 5c compares the two peaks of the 13C–O stretch of ACh in protein (black line) and in aqueous solution (orange line). Fig. 5d is the normalized spectrum, where the orange band was multiplied by 3.3. The band is much broader in solution (FWHM: 23 cm−1) than in protein (FWHM: 7.0 cm−1).
Fig. 6 The acetylcholine-docked model in the gauche conformation, obtained based on the crystal structure of the active form of the M2R (PDB ID: 4MQS) using Schrödinger suits 2019-3 (Schrödinger, LLC, NY, USA). A water molecule is manually added in the model. |
The H/D-sensitive 1687 cm−1 band (+) in Fig. 3 is most likely attributable to the CO stretch of N4046.52. Note that the corresponding negative band is absent. As the CO stretch of N4046.52 must be present in the free form, the signal amplitude of the CO stretch is intensified upon ligand binding. In the model structure of Fig. 6, we propose that the CO group of N4046.52 is the hydrogen-bonding acceptor of the bridged water, which also forms a hydrogen bond with the CO group of ACh. Such a strong hydrogen-bonding interaction between the ligand and TM6 yields a specific structure at the intracellular surface, leading to the activation of G-protein. We reported that the band at 1687 cm−1 diminished in the antagonist atropine-bound M2R spectra, suggesting the crucial structural role for forming the active structure, a view that is fully consistent with previous structural and functional studies.11–13
The other terminal of ACh is positively charged (Fig. 1d), which probably interacts with negatively charged D1033.32. D1033.32 is a key residue in M2R, whose protonation state is of great interest as it is highly conserved.23,24 Although FTIR spectroscopy is good at monitoring protonated carboxylic acids, spectral overlap of the CO stretch in ACh was problematic. By using 2-13C-labeled ACh, in this study, we were able to identify vibrations of protonated carboxylic acids. Interestingly, the present study concluded that D1033.32 is deprotonated (negatively charged) in both ACh-bound and free states. It is well known that the pKa of carboxylates increases in the hydrophobic protein interior.25,26 There are no positive charges nearby D1033.32, and there must be a mechanism to stabilize the negative charge of D1033.32 in the free M2R. One possibility is that the water-containing hydrogen-bonding network stabilizes the negative charge at D1033.32, and that the negatively charged D1033.32 would be the driving force behind the binding of positively charged ACh. ACh is a flexible molecule, but there are strong interactions at both termini, one is a hydrogen bond with N4046.52 and another is an electrostatic interaction with D1033.32, stabilizing the extended conformation of ACh in the gauche conformation.
The present 2-13C-labeled ACh study also shed light on the “tyrosine lid”. The positive 1246 cm−1 band in Fig. 3b was up-shifted to 1250 cm−1 in D2O, and the up-shifted nature is characteristic of the C–O stretch of tyrosine.27 Therefore, the signal originates from the vibration of tyrosines, presumably from the “tyrosine lid”. Note that the C–O stretch of the tyrosine lid exists in the free M2R, but only the positive band was observed, as well as the CO stretch of N4046.52. The reason is probably the same between N4046.52 and the tyrosine lid, namely that specific interactions intensify the IR absorbance of each. The positive signal of the tyrosine lid was absent in atropine-bound M2R spectra,18 as was the CO stretch of N4046.52, suggesting their important role in signal transduction. Although we did not show the tyrosine lid in Fig. 6, these tyrosines must be located in contact with ACh, similar to iperoxo (Fig. 1a). The gauche conformation of ACh is probably stabilized by the tyrosine lid. Since this vibration is known as an indicator of the degree of the proton-donating state in the hydrogen bond on the phenolic O–H group,28 detailed analysis will provide further insight about the interaction of the tyrosine lid in future.
The present study successfully identified the CO and C–O stretches of ACh. Structural information was obtained not only for ACh, but also for protein, including vibrations of side chains such as N4046.52, D1033.32 and the tyrosine lid. These side chains contribute to the restricted environment of ACh in M2R, which differs from the free structure and enables the activation of G-protein. Such structural differences between ACh-bound and free M2R were most significantly seen in the amide-I region at 1670–1650 cm−1 (Fig. 1b). In fact, the peaks at 1666 (−)/1656 (+) cm−1 are largest in the mid-IR region, and their frequencies are attributable to the α-helix. Helical structural perturbation is a key issue to understand the molecular mechanism of G-protein activation by GPCR,15,29,30 where active M2R structure shows a large helical displacement of TM6. We previously reported agonist- and antagonist-specific amide-I spectra,18 and the functional correlation of amide-I signals is intriguing. The detailed investigation with various ligands is in progress. Structural changes of M2R activation may also involve structural changes of lipids, as shown in the H/D insensitive bands at 1750–1700 cm−1 (Fig. 3b). In contrast, M2R did not bind sodium ions both in the free and ACh-bound forms (Fig. S2†). The structural insight obtained in the present study will lead to a better understanding of the activation mechanism of M2R, which will be utilized for drug development. In addition, accurate measurements for the entire mid-IR region (4000 to 1000 cm−1) were a real challenge in ATR-FTIR spectroscopy of biomolecules, but we successfully obtained the difference ATR-FTIR spectra upon sodium binding to a rhodopsin KR2 in aqueous solution.31 As the frequency at 4000 to 3000 cm−1 provide rich information about hydrogen bonds, the measurement for ligand binding to M2R is out future focus.
For ATR-FTIR measurements, detergent-solubilized M2R was reconstituted into asolectin liposomes with a 20-fold molar excess, whose lipid/protein ratio is considerably low. However, detergent-solubilized M2R contains certain amount of lipids, and the real lipid/protein ratio is higher, though it was difficult to quantitatively estimate in the present study. The detergent molecule was removed by incubation with Biobeads SM-2 (Bio-Rad). After removing the Biobeads, the lipid-reconstituted M2R was collected by ultracentrifugation. After several cycles of wash/spin, lipid-reconstituted M2R was suspended in a buffer composed of 5 mM phosphate (pH 7.5) and 10 mM KCl.
To consider the effect of a hydrogen bond via water, we added a water molecule in the models obtained above. Then, with the Prime program, induced-fit was calculated against the water molecule by constraining the receptor. Since two conformations of acetylcholine were redocked to obtain two models, we obtained four gauche-formed acetylcholine-docked models. Finally, we selected the one that showed the best docking score as the acetylcholine-docked model.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1ra01030a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |