Md Ehtashamul
Haque
a,
Alvaro J.
Conde
b,
William N.
MacPherson
a,
Stephen R.
Knight
cd,
Richard M.
Carter
a and
Maïwenn
Kersaudy-Kerhoas
*a
aSchool of Engineering and Physical Sciences, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, UK. E-mail: m.kersaudy-kerhoas@hw.ac.uk
bMicronit B.V., The Netherlands
cCentre for Medical Informatics, Usher Institute, University of Edinburgh, UK
dRenal Transplant Unit, Queen Elizabeth University Hospital, 1345 Govan Road, Glasgow, G51 4TF, UK
First published on 30th November 2022
For many blood-based diagnostic tests, including prophylactic drug analysis and malaria assays, red blood cells must be lysed effectively prior to their use in an analytical workflow. We report on a finger-actuated blood lysate preparation device, which utilises a previously reported acoustofluidic micromixer module. The integrated device includes a range of innovations from a sample interface, to the integration of blisters on a laser engraved surface and a large volume (130 μL) one-stroke manual pump which could be useful in other low-cost microfluidic-based point-of-care devices. The adaptability of the acoustic mixer is demonstrated on highly viscous fluids, including whole blood, with up to 65% percent volume fraction of red blood cells. Used in conjunction with a lysis buffer, the micromixer unit is also shown to lyse a finger-prick (approximately 20 μL) blood sample in 30 seconds and benchmarked across ten donor samples. Finally, we demonstrate the ease of use of the fully integrated device. Cheap, modular, but reliable, finger-actuated microfluidic functions could open up opportunities for the development of diagnostics with minimal resources.
Notably, most of these previous microfluidic based cell lysis devices, with the exception of Baillargeon and Pourabed, need external connectors, tubing, and pumps, which makes their use laborious for simple procedures. Baillargeon paper-based solution offers an elegant simple solution but has two drawbacks: (i) it can handle only a limited volume of sample, and (ii) it has limited compatibility for downstream analytical procedures. In the case of Pourabed, despite the advantageous performance of the device, the requirement for the acoustic resonator to be manufactured into a double side polished (100) oriented silicon wafer sandwiched between two polymethylsiloxane (PDMS) layers, makes this device difficult to reproduce and difficult to scale-up at low-cost.
In this communication, we introduce a finger-actuated blood lysate preparation device, which utilises a previously reported acoustofluidic micromixer module (Fig. 1.a).11 Before describing the completely integrated device, which include a range of innovations from sample interface, to integration of blister on a laser engraved chip and a large volume one-stroke manual pump, we investigate the mixing performance of the acoustofluidic device on viscous fluids and human blood. Then we investigate a chemical-assisted blood lysis method and finally we detail the concept of the finger-actuated blood lysate preparation device and demonstrate its repeatability.
Fig. 1 A finger-actuated filtered blood lysate preparation device. (a) Isometric CAD view of the concept, illustrating seven functional elements. (b) Illustration of the acoustic mixing principles developed in ref. 11. |
Amongst all of these techniques, the acoustic vibration of bubbles, and resulting microstreaming effect, has become a widespread way to mix fluids due to their efficacy (fast mixing down to milliseconds). Such microstreaming acoustic mixing is often compatible with simple geometries and often utilises cost-effective actuators in the form of simple piezoelectric disks. However, most techniques reported to date involve complex prototyping methods.10 Our team has previously demonstrated a low-cost rapid prototyping technique for fabricating a simple but agile acoustofluidic micromixer module.11 This acoustofluidic micromixer is made up of two parts: a hard polymer cassette made of laser-cut cell-cast polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) sheets (Clarex, various thicknesses) that house the mixing chamber and a soft polymer made of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), which focuses the acoustic excitation provided to the chamber by a piezoelectric actuator (Fig. 1.b).11 Using this device, we have reported cfDNA extraction on 100 μL plasma samples ten times superior to a standard benchmark. Here, we sought to investigate the effect of viscosity on the acoustic micromixer performance. To this effect, two types of solutions were prepared. The first solution contained either 0%, 20%, and 40% glycerol in deionised (DI) water, while the second solution contained either 0%, 20%, and 40% glycerol in DI water spiked with 5% fluorescein (v/v). 65 μL of each solution was pipetted into the mixing chamber for a specific solution experiment. After loading, a piezoelectric diaphragm (7BB-15-6L0, Murata Electronics) was driven by a function generator (TG215, Thurlby Thandar Instruments) at 4 ± 0.5 kHz and 20 Vpp.
The mixing experiment videos were recorded with digital microscopes equipped with blue LEDs for excitation and a 510 nm emission filter (AM4115T-GFBW, Dino-Lite). Sample videos are available in ESI† Video S1. The recorded images were processed with the ImageJ software (version 1.53q) (see ESI† Section S1 for full details). Mixing performance of various glycerol mixtures at various time instances can be observed from video screenshots in Fig. 2.a.
As expected, the mixing performance decreases as the viscosity of the samples increases from 1 cP (viscosity of water at 20 °C) to 2 cP (20% glycerol) and 4.8 cP (40%). Moving liquids of higher viscosity from one region to another requires more energy, and because the mixer operates at a fixed energy, higher viscosity results in slower mixing. Despite the micromixer's slower mixing for highly viscous solutions full mixing of water-based solutions (0%) and 20% glycerol solutions was achieved in under 60 s while the 40% glycerol solution was mixed in under 2 min (Fig. 2.b), comparable to results that have been reported in another BAW based micromixing work.14 However, it is inferior to other acoustic mixers reporting millisecond-mixing rates. This can be explained by the fact that the volumes mixed here are much larger than other publications. As discussed in the next section, this can be advantageous for gentle manipulation of cells.
Upon arrival, samples of specific Hct values were made by adding or withdrawing plasma from these samples. 65 μL of each one of these artificially created samples was pipetted into the micromixer, followed by 65 μL PBS to assess the micromixer blood mixing capabilities. We applied the same image analysis technique as previously described (see Section S1†) although images were acquired with digital microscope equipped with white light illumination (AM7013MZT, Dino-Lite) instead. Fig. 3.a shows screenshots of the mixing experiment with the highest Hct blood sample (65%). Samples videos are available in ESI† Video S2. After 30 seconds, the human eye cannot distinguish any improvement in mixing. Image analysis (Fig. 3.b) showed that after 30 seconds, the mixing performance reach almost 90% for all Hct concentrations. However, statistical analysis demonstrates that there is no significant difference between the 30 and 60 seconds mixing time point, as well as between some of the 10 and 60 seconds mixing. This may be due to the fact that in some experimental runs (4 out of 48 measurements), the mixing appeared to occur more quickly than usual. Some frequency drifts from the analogue function generator may have caused the intensity of the streaming to change and resulted in a faster mixing. After 60 seconds, mixing reaches its maximum (97.5% on average across all Hct concentrations). Importantly, from 30 seconds onwards, all Hct samples performed identically in terms of mixing (p-values non-significant in all cases). This demonstrates that the performance of the micromixer is unaffected by the increase in RBC volume fraction from 30 seconds onward. While the device does not reach the performance reported by Pourabed et al., it should be noted that Pourabed utilizes continuous flow driven by pumps, in addition to active acoustic mixing, and that here much larger volumes of blood are handled in a static manner. The advantage of a static volume is that no additional control of fluid, nor pump actuation is needed.
In laboratory testing, hemolysis, or the rupturing of RBCs, is a serious concern that can result in inaccurately raised potassium levels as well as a reduction in pH, pCO2, and pO2 values.29 Therefore, it is essential to verify that the microstreaming-based mixing is not harming RBCs while in operation and is not resulting in inaccurate analytical data. To evaluate that, whole blood samples (45% Hct) were processed on the mixer after 1, 3, or 5 minutes of mixing to see if the microstreaming agitation would cause blood lysis. A full blood count was obtained before and after mixing using a haematology analyser (Sysmex XP-300, Sysmex Corporation, Japan). The comparison between the initial blood count (RBC and WBC) and the processed blood samples count, demonstrate that no RBC or WBC damage occurred during the mixing up to 5 minutes (Fig. 3.c).
When RBCs are damaged, they release their haemoglobin (Hgb) content onto the sample, hence free Hgb absorbance measurements in plasma can also be used to estimate the overall RBC lysis in the sample. This measurement cannot be directly taken with the Sysmex analyser since it has an in-built lysis step for total Hgb concentration measurement and a limit of detection of 0.1 g dL−1 limit, below the expected values for free Hgb in the absence of hemolysis. Therefore, collected samples were spun for 45 seconds at 12100 × g (Eppendorf MiniSpin Plus Centrifuge, Eppendorf, Germany), and absorbance measurements were measured on a spectrophotometer (Jenway 7315) on plasma after a 1:15 dilution with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS). A corrected absorbance by the Cripps method30 was calculated and a free Hgb value was obtained from an extrapolated standard curve (see ESI† Section S2). The results show no significant trace of excess Hgb on the processed samples up to 5 minutes (Fig. 3.b), confirming that, unlike acoustofluidic structures designed for lysis, our acoustofluidic micromixer is gentle on whole blood samples.31,32
Free Hgb absorbance measurements in plasma was used as previously described to estimate the overall RBC lysis in the sample. Our micromixer was able to lyse over 80% of RBCs in just 15 seconds, and 90% in 30 seconds. For complete RBC lysis, at least 1 minute of mixing was required (Fig. 4.b). The micromixer outperformed the benchmark in terms of lysing RBCs at all time instances until complete lysis was accomplished in 1 min. This can be explained by the poor performance of hand inversion mixing (the manufacturer's recommended mixing procedure) on small volumes. Additionally, to being superior to hand inversion, acoustofluidic mixing is also more reliable and is not as labour intensive.
Having demonstrated a rapid chemical-assisted lysis in just sixty seconds, we progressed to testing this on-chip protocol on healthy donor samples. Ten donor blood samples with hematocrit between 39.4% and 51.6% (respectively corresponding to 13.1 and 16.4 g dL−1 total Hgb) were acquired from the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service (contract #20∼11). Each donor sample was processed following the lysis assay manufacturer protocol (100 μL blood, 500 μL lysis buffer, 10 min) and following the on-chip lysis protocol as previously described for one minute. The total hemoglobin levels for the original samples were obtained from direct Sysmex reading (1:5 v/v dilution in PBS) while the hemoglobin levels for the processed samples were calculated as previously described (Fig. 5.a). The free Hgb of the lysed samples was found to be highly consistent with the total Hgb level of the original samples, demonstrating complete lysis. In addition, the bench lysis and chip lysis exhibit a moderately high R-squared value of 0.885 in their correlation (Fig. 5.b). Finally, all of the points are within the 95 percent margins of agreement for each lysis approach, according to a Bland–Altman analysis that we also used to assess the bias between the mean differences between the two lysis procedures (Fig. 5.c). This demonstrates the excellent performance of our micromixer, which lyses RBCs in just one minute, or one tenth of the time recommended by the benchmark protocol.
Microfluidic-based procedures are sometimes made cumbersome and laborious by external connectors, tubing, and pumps. However, handling of finger-prick volumes of blood at the point-of-care should be easy and intuitive. A range of microfluidic devices allowing fluid pumping without the need for powered actuation or precise-pipetting, so-called ‘finger-actuated’ devices, were first introduced by Qiu et al. in 2009.34 This concept was further developed by a number of other groups, but most notably Juhwan Park and Je-Kyun Park, and demonstrated with the generation of gradients,35 DNA extraction,36 blood typing37 and blood-cross matching test.38 The devices developed by Park and Park were manufactured in PDMS with standard SU8 based soft-lithography and displaced an average of 10 μL per stroke.
Our newly developed finger-actuated device uses a simpler, fast, manufacturing protocol based on laser cutting and solvent assisted bonding, which does not necessitate photolithography and cleanroom equipment. The device itself features seven layers allowing to connect the following features: (i) a blood collection device interface. The blood inlet geometry on the chip is designed specifically so that it can interface with the Minivette® POCT blood collection device, thus facilitating its use by avoiding unnecessary pipetting steps, but also providing enough actuation power to move the blood sample into a metering valve. (ii) On-chip buffer storage. We have embedded the lysis buffer on-chip in commercial blisters (150 μL Microfluidic Chip Shop, custom-filled with Roche RBC Lysis Buffer). Thanks to sharp needles engraved in layer 1, these blisters can be pierced upon a simple hand actuation which release the necessary buffer volume to lyse RBCs from whole blood samples (see ESI† Section S3 for details on fabrication and ESI† Video S3 for operation). (iii) Metering and valving functions. Two turning valves enable the sequential addition of two pre-defined volumes of lysis buffer, the movement of the metered blood sample and the isolation of the mixing chamber during the lysis. Manual valves have the advantage of being completely power-free and of simple design, driving widespread adoption.39–42 A turning valve can also easily become a metering element, and we used one of these valves as such. The hollow section of the valve shaft contains 15 μL. Once blood is injected by actuating the blood collection device, the turning valve is rotated by 90 degrees and the second blister is pressed, flushing the content of the valve into the mixing chamber. The design and prototyping of these valves are described in ESI† Section S4, and a video of the valve operation in available is ESI† Video S4. Once the lysis buffer and blood sample have been mixed and blood cells have been lysed, the lysate needs to be filtered out to remove RBC debris and other cells. (iv) Embedded filter. A Vivid™ asymmetric plasma separation membrane (Pall, GR grade, 12 mm diameter) sandwiched between layer three and five at layer four is used to filter the lysate. The entire content of the mixing chamber (130 μL) needs to be emptied and passed through the filters and ultimately delivered into a collection chamber. A video of the filter operation is available in ESI† Video S5. (v) One-stroke pumping function. In order to flush the blood lysate from the mixing chamber, a significant displacement of 130 μL is needed. The type of finger-actuated pumps previously proposed would not be suitable. By serendipity, a silicone cap commonly attached to disposable commercial vapes (ELF Bar 600) was found to have the perfect shape, flexibility and volume to displace the full content of the chamber in a single stroke (see ESI† Video S6). Using a blunt-tipped screw and a hammer, a 7.5 mm hole was cut into the top of the cap. This hole creates a favourable resistance ration and prevents backpressure from being created into the chamber and drawing back the fluid when the cap was released. For further precaution, the valve connected to the air cap can be closed after pressing the cap, to ensure full elimination of back pressure. The structure can be used as many times as required and does not need to be bonded onto the chip to function. (vi) Optical window. In the final step of the on chip protocol, the filtered lysate is displaced into an optical window. This chamber is made by a cut-out through the full seven layers of the device and closed by two glass cover slips (American Scientific Products, M6045-1, 18 × 18 mm). The interfaced optical interrogation module can be used to examine the filtered hemolysate using spectrophotometry and other common optical instruments (not demonstrated in this work). The design and prototyping of each of the seven layers composing the blood lysate preparation chip are presented in Section S5.†
To evaluate the reproducibility of the fully integrated device, we fabricated a set of four identical devices, and processed aliquots of an additional human blood donor sample on this set of devices. Fig. 6.a and .b respectively shows an exploded view and a top view of the assembled device. The top view is annotated with actuators elements. Section S5 and Fig. S4† gives further details about the design of each layers. Designs are available online (https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.21571695.v1). Briefly the seven PMMA layers constituting the finger-actuated card were laser cut (Epilog Mini 18 30W) and assembled by solvent-assisted thermal bonding technique.43 The prototyped chip is shown in Fig. 6.c. To operate the finger-actuated card, the operator followed these eight steps. Step 1: Verify that V1 and V2 are in vertical position. Step 2: Press B1. Step 3: Turn V2 horizontally. Step 4: Fill the Minivette™ device with blood (Fig. 6.d-i). Load Minivette™ and loaded onto the card in port P1 (Fig. 6.d-ii). Push on the Minivette until blood come through the other side of the valve V2. Step 5: Turn V2 back into vertical position. Step 6: Press on B2. You will see chamber 1 (C1) filling. Step 7: Connect the piezo electric actuator to the function generator and turn on for 1 minute. Step 8: Turn V1 and V2 into horizontal position. Step 8: Push on air cap (AC) to empty chamber C1 into chamber C2. Fig. 6.e shows the filtered blood lysate in chamber C2, after the full process. A video of an operator demonstrating the complete on-chip protocol can be found in ESI† Video S7. The filtered blood lysate was pipetted out of the chip after the full process, for characterisation. For the bench control, the same donor blood sample was mixed with lysis buffer (1:5 v/v, n = 4) following manufacturer instructions. Fig. 6.f represents the concentration of red blood cells and red blood cells debris present in the initial whole blood sample, bench sample after lysis and a short centrifugation (45 seconds, 12100 × g) and in the sample collected on the finger-actuated device. Some debris remains after the chip filtration, which may be due to a suboptimal assembly of the filter into the chip. This is an aspect for future optimisation. The on-chip and bench lysates were characterised by spectrophotometry as previously described. Since the dilution on the chip and on the bench are slightly different (valve metering volume 15 μL ± 2 μL and chamber volume around 130 μL), a relative absorbance measurement was performed. Fig. 6.g shows the absorbance spectrum normalised to the mean (550–600 nm) for four on chip samples and four on bench samples. Except for one outlier, all of the on chip lysate absorbance spectrum perfectly match with those measured on the bench. Hgb typically exhibits high peaks at 576 nm; however, shifting of this peak, can occur either as a result of changes in chemical characteristics44 or sample ageing.45 The on-chip outlier shows a similar spectra to the other samples, but is shifted with a peak at 574 nm. After carefully examination of the experimental videos, we suspect that a contaminant may have affected the sample properties. The comparison of the free Hgb absorbance values reveals a coefficient of variation (CV) of 15% for the on-chip lysate, compared to 4% for on-bench measurements. Without the outlier, the CV of on-chip sample would be 3%, in-par with the bench control.
These results demonstrate a range of useful features which enable effective sample preparation. The application of the findings and design features, are not limited to filtered blood lysate preparation. Similar features could be useful for the preparation of nucleic acids prior to polymerase chain reaction, for example. The device remains to be tested in conjunction with an optical detection system, or another kind of analytical system. This device is designed to be single-use and is prototyped in a fossil-derived plastic (PMMA). The single-use nature of the device brings convenience to the user, removes cross-contamination issues, and protects the user to harm with regards to potentially infectious samples, however this comes at a cost to the environment.46 Improvements on both of these aspects will be the subject of future work. In particular, virgin PMMA could be replaced by recycled PMMA (Re-PMMA).47 We have demonstrated the compatibility of our solvent-assisted bonding protocol with Re-PMMA.48 PMMA may also be substituted by sustainable materials such as PLA, or other sustainable biopolymers.49 If the final application involved a high abundance biomarker, the assay may also be deployed in a more sustainable paper-based format.
The features demonstrated here are using commercially available and cheap materials and protocols that do not necessitate expensive capital investment. The features presented can be used as a modular toolkit for point-of-care or point-of-use solutions. We hope they can help pave the way for more integrated and efficient on-chip protocols for the academic and industrial developments and facilitate exciting applications in human, veterinary or environmental health.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2lc00968d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |