Carla
Vilela
a,
Letizia
Cruciani
a,
Armando J. D.
Silvestre
a and
Alessandro
Gandini
*ab
aCICECO and Chemistry Department, University of Aveiro, Campus de Santiago, 3810-193, Aveiro, Portugal
bMaterials Engineering Department, Engineering School of São Carlos, University of São Paulo, 13566-590, São Carlos, Brazil. E-mail: agandini@iqsc.usp.br
First published on 25th January 2012
Monomers based on plant oil derivatives bearing furan heterocycles appended through thiol-ene click chemistry were prepared and, subsequently, polymerized via a second type of click reaction, i.e. the Diels–Alder (DA) polycondensation between furan and maleimide complementary moieties. Two basic approaches were considered for these DA polymerizations, namely (i) the use of monomers with two terminal furan rings in conjunction with bismaleimides (AA + BB systems) and (ii) the use of a protected AB monomer incorporating both furan and maleimide end groups. This study clearly showed that both strategies were successful, albeit with different outcomes, in terms of the nature of the ensuing products. The application of the retro-DA reaction to these polymers confirmed their thermoreversible character, i.e. the clean-cut return to their respective starting monomers, opening the way to original macromolecular materials with interesting applications, like mendability and recyclability.
Our interest in plant oils stems from the idea of applying previous knowledge on the use of furan monomers and furan chemistry to these substrates, through the joint exploitation of two click-chemistry mechanisms, viz. the thiol-ene and the Diels–Alder (DA) reactions.
The thiol-ene addition, known for over 100 years, is a well documented reaction,13–16 which has attracted the interest of researchers due to its click-chemistry character.17 It has been successfully used for the synthesis of star polymers,18 dendrimers19 and disaccharides,20 among others. In the field of oleochemistry, the thiol-ene coupling with plant oils or their fatty acids has been applied to prepare several monomers and polymers.21–27 For instance, Samuelsson et al.21 and Claudino et al.22 investigated the kinetics of the photo-initiated thiol-ene coupling of trifunctional thiols with methyl oleate and methyl linoleate. Bantchev et al.23 prepared sulphide-modified plant oils through the thiol-ene addition of butanethiol to canola and corn oils for such end-use applications as lubricants. Moreover, Türünç and Meier25 prepared a set of novel monomers derived from 10-undecenoic acid via thiol-ene additions in the absence of solvent and initiator, and their subsequent polymerization yielded a family of linear and hyperbranched polyesters with good thermal properties.
The Diels–Alder (DA) reaction, known since 1928, is another prominent example of click chemistry28 that has been studied very extensively in a variety of contexts,29–31 including notably the realm of furan polymers because of its potential in the preparation of various macromolecular architectures. These materials, based on renewable resources, possess, in addition to this important feature, promising properties in terms of thermoreversibility, mendability and recyclability.32–35 The important peculiarity of the DA reaction, apart from its click connotation, is its reversible character, illustrated here (Scheme 1) in the case of the coupling of a furan ring (diene) with a maleimide complementary moiety (dienophile), where the temperature is a key factor in determining the position of the equilibrium, which can be shifted heavily from predominant adduct formation (DA reaction), up to ca. 65 °C, to the predominant reversion to its precursors (retro-DA reaction), above ca. 100 °C.32–38 The kinetic characteristics associated with the course of the forward and backward reactions depend on the specific structure of the substituents attached to both heterocycles, and, of course, the reactant concentration, the medium and the temperature. The application of the DA reaction to polymer syntheses based on furan/maleimide reversible couplings has gained much attention in the last few decades. Two different approaches dominate this realm, i.e. (i) polycondensation reactions calling upon complementary bifunctional or polyfunctional monomers, including AnBm-type structures, and (ii) reversible cross-linking of linear polymers bearing pendant furan or maleimide moieties, based on the temperature sensitivity of the DA equilibrium.32,33 The fact that the forward DA reaction gives rise to both endo and exo stereoisomer adducts39 does not play a significant role in these macromolecular syntheses, since both participate in the chain growth.
Scheme 1 The DA equilibrium between growing species bearing, respectively, furan and maleimide end-groups. |
The present study, a follow-up to a preliminary communication that set the stage for this approach,40 describes the use of undecenyl compounds as suitable substrates for appending terminal DA functions, viz either two furan (A) heterocycles or a combination of a furan (A) and a protected maleimide (B) end-group. This was achieved by calling upon the thiol-ene reaction in conjunction with more classical chemical condensations. The ensuing AA and protected AB monomers were then polymerized through the DA polycondensation, the former with a bismaleimide (BB), the latter on its own, after liberating the maleimide moiety through the retro-DA reaction of the inert adduct.
As mentioned above, the basic structure chosen as a typical and viable plant oil derivative was ω-undecenoic acid (UDA), i.e. the prominent fragment arising from the pyrolysis of castor oil,41 together with its reduced derivative undec-10-en-1-ol (UDOL). Two approaches were adopted to append furan end-groups onto UDA (Scheme 2), viz. (i) esterification with furfuryl alcohol (FA) at the carboxylic terminal and ene reaction with FT at the unsaturated counterpart, or (ii) esterification with allyl alcohol, followed by a double ene reaction with FT at both alkenyl end-groups. In both cases, α,ω-difuran monomers (AA and AA′) were obtained and characterized. The corresponding alcohol UDOL was used to prepare the protected AB monomer (Scheme 2) through esterification of its primary OH end-group with the protected 4-maleimidobutyric acid (MBA) followed by the ene reaction of its terminal unsaturation with FT. The protection of its maleimide group in the form of its furan-DA adduct, prevented the premature DA polycondensation of the intrinsically reactive furan/maleimide moieties during its synthesis, purification and storage.37,38
Scheme 2 Synthetic pathways for the AA, AA′ and protected AB monomers. |
Both the bis-dienes AA and AA′ and the protected AB monomer were characterized by FTIR, Raman, 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy.
The FTIR spectrum of the AA monomer (Fig. 1) clearly showed the presence of furan heterocycle bands at 3111, 1600, 1503, 1375, 1215, 1070, 1009, 933, 885, 748, 597 cm−1,42 and of the ester CO and C–O bands at 1735 and 1150 cm−1, respectively.43 The Raman spectrum clearly indicated the presence of the C–S stretching vibration at 607 cm−1 and the absence of the SH band of the thiol moiety in the range 2590–2550 cm−1.43 The 1H NMR spectrum confirmed the expected structure through the appearance of typical resonances of the methylene protons of the ester moiety at δ 5.1 ppm (OCH2–2-furan), the methylene protons attached to the S atom at δ 2.5 (SCH2(CH2)n) and 3.7 ppm (SCH2–2-furan), and the furan heterocycle protons at about δ 6.2 (3-H), 6.3 (4-H), 7.3 (5-H) ppm for 2-furan–CH2S and δ 6.4 (4-H), 6.5 (3-H), 7.4 (5-H) ppm for 2-furan–CH2O, apart from the typical resonances of the methylene protons of UDA's aliphatic chain at δ 1.3 (–(CH2)n–), 1.6 (CH2CH2C(O)) and 2.3 (CH2C(O)) ppm. The 13C NMR spectrum, apart from the unchanged resonances related to the aliphatic chain carbons (δ 24.8, 28.3–29.3 and 34.1 ppm), showed resonances at δ 31.7 (CH2SCH2–2-furan), 57.8 (OCH2–2-furan), 107.2 and 110.4 (furan C-4 and C-3), 142.0 (C-5 of 2-furan–CH2S), 143.2 (C-5 of 2-furan–CH2O), 149.6 (C-2 of 2-furan–CH2S), 151.9 (C-2 of 2-furan–CH2O) and the COester peak at 173.5 ppm.
Similarly, the changes in the FTIR, Raman, 1H and 13C NMR spectra associated with the functionalization of UDA to give the AA′ monomer (Scheme 2) displayed the same features, confirming that the esterification and the thiol-ene reactions had indeed taken place equally well, as given in detail in the Experimental section.
The FTIR spectrum of the protected AB monomer was consistent with the structure shown in Scheme 2, by the presence of all the relevant peaks, viz. (i) the asymmetric and symmetric CO stretching vibrations of the imide group at 1772 and 1696 cm−1, respectively,44 (ii) the furan heterocycle bands at 3110, 1602, 1503, 1399, 1245, 1160, 1069, 1009, 917, 878, 735 and 598 cm−1,42 and (iii) the CO ester band at 1731 cm−1, together with the absence of the OH band of primary alcohols and the OH and CO bands of the carboxylic group.43 Although this technique did not succeed in detecting the weak ν (C–S) signal, its identification was possible by Raman spectroscopy with a band at 606 cm−1.43 The 1H NMR spectrum clearly confirmed this structure through the presence of the protons of the protected maleimide moiety at about 2.9 (CHCHCHCO), 5.3 (CHCHCHCO) and 6.5 (CHCHCHCO) ppm and the methylene protons of the ester group at δ 4.1 ppm (OCH2), as well as of the 2-furan ring protons at δ 6.2 (3-H), 6.3 (4-H) and 7.4 (5-H) ppm and the methylene protons attached to the S atom at δ 2.5 (SCH2(CH2)n) and 3.7 ppm (SCH2–2-furan). The 13C NMR spectrum of the protected AB monomer was also in tune with the proposed structure with, in addition to the carbon resonances related to the aliphatic chain (δ 25.8, 28.5 and 28.8–29.4 ppm), the furan ring carbons (δ 107.2, 110.3, 142.0 and 151.9 ppm) and the protected maleimide carbon resonances (δ 47.3, 81.0, 136.5 and 176.2 ppm), it was also possible to observe signals resonating at δ 31.7 and 64.7 ppm, which were readily identified as the methylenic carbons of the thioether moiety (SCH2) and of the ester group (OCH2), respectively.
The common structural feature of these three monomers, besides their terminal DA-reactive furan or maleimide functions, was the long methylene sequence, i.e. the flexible bridge joining them. This suggests that all the ensuing DA polymers, namely those derived from AA and AA′ with the equally flexible bridge joining the aliphatic bismaleimide (BMH), and that formed by the self-polycondensation of the deprotected AB monomer, were expected to have relatively low glass transition temperatures.
Fig. 2 Evolution of the UV spectrum during the DA reaction between FMS (0.1 M) and MM (0.1 M) in TCE at 65 °C during 7 h (spectra taken hourly) and then at 25 °C after 3 and 7 days. |
Scheme 3 Model Diels–Alder polycondensation between BMH and FS. |
The complementary bis-dienophile selected as the DA-polycondensation comonomer for both the AA and AA′ bis-dienes was 1,6-bismaleimidohexane (BMH), i.e. a monomer bearing, as mentioned above, an equally flexible aliphatic bridging structure, leading to the formation of polymers P1 and P2, respectively, as exemplified in Scheme 4 for P2. All polymerizations were followed by both UV and 1H NMR spectroscopy.
Scheme 4 DA polycondensation between the difunctional AA′ and BMH monomers. |
The DA polymerization of AA and AA′ at 65 °C, followed by UV spectroscopy for 8 h, revealed a progressive decrease in the optical density of the maleimide peak at about 300 nm, as shown in Fig. 3 for P1, accompanied by a corresponding increase in the viscosity of the medium. As reported in previous studies,36–38 the spectral pattern gave rise to an isosbestic point (progressive replacement of the maleimide peak at ∼300 nm by the absorption of the unconjugated carbonyl groups of the adduct at ∼260 nm), which suggested the occurrence of a single reaction pathway, viz. the DA condensation. The concomitant changes in the 1H NMR spectra (as illustrated for P2 in Fig. 4) displayed a gradual decrease in the intensity of the maleimide (δ 6.7 ppm, CHCH) and furan (c–H at δ 6.2 ppm, b–H at δ 6.3 ppm and a–H at δ 7.4 ppm) proton resonances at a rate similar to that of the UV spectra evolution and the simultaneous surge of the peaks associated with the three sets of protons assigned to the polymer adducts, at about δ 2.9 (10-H and 11-H), 5.3 (12-H) and 6.5 ppm (13-H and 14-H).
Fig. 3 Evolution of the UV spectrum of the maleimide peak during the DA reaction between AA (0.1 M) and BMH (0.1 M) at 65 °C in TCE for 8 h. |
Fig. 4 Evolution of 1H NMR spectrum of the DA polymerization between AA′ and BMH at 65 °C for 6 days (see Scheme 4 for peak assignment). |
Once these polymerizing systems had reached high conversion, both polymers were then submitted to the corresponding retro-DA depolymerisation at 110 °C, followed by 1H NMR spectroscopy. These processes were characterized by the reverse pattern with respect to the polycondensations, consisting in the gradual decrease in the adduct resonance (δ 2.9, 5.3 and 6.5 ppm) intensities and the corresponding growth of the furan (δ 6.2, 6.3 and 7.4 ppm) and maleimide (δ 6.7 ppm) counterparts, together with the decrease in viscosity of the solutions. Within a few days, the spectra revealed the presence of resonances of the starting monomers (Fig. 5 (b)), thus confirming the complete thermo-reversible nature of these systems. The solutions of the regenerated monomers were allowed to cool to 65 °C and a second polymerization took place (Fig. 5 (c)), emphasizing the reproducibility of these cyclic events, as previously reported.36–38
Fig. 5 1H NMR spectrum of (a) P2, (b) retro-DA of P2 after 3 days, and (c) second DA polymerization after 6 days (see Scheme 4 for peak assignment). |
The use of an AB monomer bearing both the furan and the maleimide moieties in its structure represents an interesting alternative for linear DA polymerizations, as already shown,37,38 since it provides the ideal initial stoichiometry. The synthesis of the AB monomer generated a molecule with a protected maleimide moiety in order to avoid premature polymerization. This stable furan-DA adduct became ready for polymerization after the in situ deprotection of the masked end group by the retro-DA reaction at 110 °C, which released furan and regenerated the maleimide moiety. The polycondensation could then be initiated by decreasing the temperature to 65 °C. The 1H NMR spectrum of the ensuing AB monomer, despite the evidence of incipient polymerization, clearly confirmed its total deprotection through the presence of the free maleimide protons at δ 6.7 ppm (CHCH), plus the absence of the adduct peaks at 2.9 (CHCHCHCO), 5.3 (CHCHCHCO) and 6.5 (CHCHCHCO) ppm.
The evolution of the DA polymerization of the deprotected AB monomer, leading to the formation of P3, was also followed by UV and 1H NMR spectroscopy and more qualitatively by the regular increase in the viscosity of the reaction medium. The progress of the UV spectrum with reaction time mimicked the features exemplified in Fig. 3, exhibiting again a characteristic isosbestic point. The 1H NMR monitoring of the polymerizing system revealed all the details of the progressive decrease in the signals ascribed to the unreacted furan (δ 6.2, 6.3 and 7.4 ppm) and maleimide moieties (δ 6.7 ppm) and the corresponding increase of those associated with the polyadduct protons at δ 6.5 (CHCHCHCO), 5.3 (CHCHCHCO) and 2.9 (CHCHCHCO) ppm. After the system had attained high conversion, the retro-DA depolymerisation was followed at 110 °C for three days by 1H NMR spectroscopy. The expected behaviour was once more observed, viz. the increase in the peaks of the furan and maleimide protons to the detriment of the adduct signals, as previously discussed. Thereafter, the system was brought back to 65 °C and left for a number of days in order to promote a second polymerization. The 1H NMR spectrum of the ensuing polymer was analogous to that taken at the end of the first polymerization, thus confirming the reversible nature of this polymerizing system.
The isolated P1, P2 and P3 polymers in the form of sticky materials were characterized by DSC and SEC. Table 1 shows their glass transition temperature (Tg), molecular weight distribution, weight-average degree of polymerization (DPw) and polydispersity index (PDI). The DSC analyses were stopped at 80 °C, due to the prevalence of the retro-DA reaction above this temperature. As anticipated, the Tg of these polymers was well below room temperature as a result of the flexible nature of the spacing moieties separating the adducts. The much higher molecular weight of P3 confirmed the advantage of using an AB monomer, with its intrinsically unitary A/B molar ratio. The SEC tracings showed evidence of the presence of cyclic oligomers, including the corresponding dimers, through the appearance of individual peaks within the distribution curves, as depicted in Fig. 6 for P1 and P2. Given the relatively low monomer concentrations used in these DA polycondensations, the occurrence of cyclization seems reasonable, as indeed already observed in a recent study on the DA polymerization of other AB monomers.38
Fig. 6 SEC tracing of P1 and P2. |
Polymer | Tg °C | Mw | Mn | DPw | PDI | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
P1: | AA + BMH | −40 | 6500 | 4500 | 10 | 1.4 |
P2: | AA′ + BMH | −28 | 9100 | 5800 | 13 | 1.5 |
P3: | AB | −2 | 16600 | 9000 | 37 | 1.8 |
It is important to emphasize that the fact that these polymerizations proceeded at a rather slow pace also stems from the modest monomer concentrations adopted here in order to allow UV and NMR spectra to be conveniently monitored. In practical terms, the same systems could obviously be made to polymerise more rapidly at higher concentrations, including in bulk. Another relevant aspect to be underlined here is that no attempt was made to optimize the other conditions for the DA polymerizations, so that the molecular weights measured for the corresponding materials do not reflect the highest achievable values.
Raman spectra were measured after 3500 scans with 4 cm−1 resolution using a Bruker RFS 100/S FTRaman spectrometer (Nd: YAG laser, 1064 nm excitation) at a power of 150 mW. 1H and 13C NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker Avance 300 NMR spectrometer operating at 300 and 75 MHz, respectively. Chemical shifts (δ) are reported in parts per million (ppm), relative to the internal standard tetramethylsilane (TMS, δ = 0.00 ppm).
Electronic spectra were taken with a temperature-controlled Jasco V-560 spectrophotometer using 1 cm Hellma Suprasil cells equipped with 9.9 mm quartz spacer and a quartz-to-pyrex graded seal.
DSC thermograms were obtained with a Perkin Elmer Diamond DSC unit using aluminium pans under nitrogen with a heating rate of 20 °C min−1 in the temperature range −90 to 80 °C.
The molecular weights and molecular weight distributions of the polymers were determined by size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) with a Varian PL-GPC 110 instrument equipped with an IR-PD 2020 light scattering detector, using N,N′-dimethylacetamide (DMA) as the mobile phase, a run time of 30 min and a column temperature of 70 °C. Polystyrene standards were used for narrow standard calibration.
A typical procedure applied to the use of 1H NMR spectroscopy follows: stoichiometric quantities (0.1 mmol) of the two monomers (AA or AA′ and BMH) were dissolved in 1.0 mL of TCE-d2, introduced in an NMR tube and the initial 1H NMR spectrum taken at room temperature. The tube was then kept in an oil bath at 65 °C and spectra taken at regular intervals. The ensuing polymers were isolated by precipitation into a large excess of 40–60 °C petroleum ether, followed by filtration, dissolution in dichloromethane and solvent removal under reduced pressure.
A fraction of the ensuing polymers was dissolved in TCE or TCE-d2 (1.0 mL) and the retro-DA depolymerisation reaction followed at 110 °C by UV and 1H NMR spectroscopy.
AB —The protected monomer (0.1 mmol) was dissolved in 1 mL of TCE-d2 and the solution brought to 110 °C while a gentle stream of nitrogen was bubbled through it for several hours to remove the furan generated by the retro-DA of the maleimide adduct. The unprotected AB monomer was then allowed to polymerize at 65 °C and the reaction followed by UV and 1H NMR spectroscopy. The ensuing polymer was precipitated in an excess of 40–60 °C petroleum ether, filtered, dissolved in dichloromethane and vacuum dried. Again, the depolymerisation of the DA polymer was carried out at 110 °C.
Work is in progress to further the insight into these systems and to develop other monomers based on furans and plant oils.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |