Andrea Lambertia,
Alessandro Virgaa,
Angelo Angelinia,
Alessandro Riccib,
Emiliano Descrovia,
Matteo Cocuzzaabc and
Fabrizio Giorgis*ab
aDepartment of Applied Science and Technology, Politecnico di Torino, C.so Duca degli Abruzzi 24 10129, Torino, Italy. E-mail: fabrizio.giorgis@polito.it
bIstituto Italiano di Tecnologia, Center for Space Human Robotics, C.so Trento 21 10129, Torino, Italy
cCNR-IMEM, Parco Area delle Scienze 37 43124, Parma, Italy
First published on 9th December 2014
Stretchable plasmonic nanostructures constituted by Ag nanoparticles on flexible elastomeric matrices are synthesized and used as surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) substrates. The structure consists of silver particles deposited by DC sputtering on polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS). The optical transmittance spectra show marked dips related to plasmonic inter-particle short-range interactions. The substrates show noticeable Raman enhancement allowing detection of R6G at very low concentration. Under mechanically controlled stretching, the interparticle gap sizes change yielding a reversible spectral shift of the plasmonic resonance. Experimental results are validated by 3D modeling. When such a resonance matches the Raman excitation line, pronounced enhancements can be achieved, optimizing the SERS regime. Taking advantage of the PDMS matrices, these tunable SERS-active substrates are integrated in microfluidic circuitry fruitfully exploitable for on-chip label-free detection.
The major contribution to the SERS effect is played by the electromagnetic enhancement, where light scattering is enhanced by the local optical fields close to metallic particles after excitation of localized surface plasmons (LSPs) at resonance conditions. The plasmonic properties of metallic nanoparticles are strongly dependent on their type, size, shape, composition and aggregation state, as well as the dielectric environment.7,8
The most common types of SERS-active structures exhibiting the largest enhancement effects are clusters of silver and gold nanoparticles (NPs) in suspension or grown on solid substrates. This synthesis approach is based on the reduction of metal salts9,10 or direct growth by physical vapor deposition and laser ablation techniques.11,12 In the last decades, several top-down approach based on lithographic techniques have been developed such as electron beam lithography (EBL)13 and focus ion beam lithography (FIB).14 These techniques allow the production of uniform SERS substrates with fully controlled shape and size of the arrayed plasmonic elements, leading to a controlled electromagnetic coupling between metal nanoparticles. Despite the high SERS efficiency of such substrates, the involved technology presents some drawbacks concerning with cost, process complexity, small area of the structures and long manufacturing time. Alternative methods such as nanosphere lithography and soft lithography15–17 have been developed in order to mitigate the above mentioned issues.
In the framework of the synthesis of SERS-active substrates, the fabrication of tunable plasmonic nanostructures is crucial for most of the applications.17–20 Actually, the higher Raman enhancement are obtained when the wavelength of the LSP resonance of the nanostructure (λLSPR) is close to the excitation wavelength (λexc) or better when the λLSPR is between the λexc and the wavelength of the typical Raman signal (λRS).21
Recently, some work has been devoted to plasmonic gratings, nanospheres and nanoparticles assembled on elastomeric membranes whose optical response can be easily tuned through strain actuated with respect to the polymeric substrate with fruitful application in SERS spectroscopy.22–25
In this work, we discuss an easy and low cost method for the fabrication of SERS active substrates with tunable surface plasmon resonances based on Ag nanoparticles sputtered on polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) membranes. The plasmonic tunability is controlled by mechanical stretching of the elastomeric membrane, yielding a change of the interparticle gap sizes. This work is aimed to the integration of the metal–elastomer nanostructures in microfluidic devices that can be mounted on a microscope stage of a Raman spectrophotometer operating in backscattering configuration.
Concerning the fabrication of the microfluidic device (see Fig. S1, ESI†), the PDMS mixture was casted into a dedicated mold with a straight microchannel (10 × 0.7 × 0.05 mm) connected to two pillars (resulting in inlet and outlet wells in the replica). A hard mask was used for the microfluidic device in order to confine the NPs only on the ceiling of a microchannel. The microfluidic element (with Ag NPs on the channel ceiling) was manually mounted on another PDMS membrane by means of the “stamp and stick” bonding.27 In detail, a thin layer of PDMS mixture was spun on a glass slice and then selectively transferred to the microfluidic chip using a stamping process. The chip was then bonded to the PDMS substrate by thermal treatment at 70 °C for 30 min.
Fig. 1a shows a large scale optical photograph of Ag NPs grown on several PDMS slices. The color of the metal–elastomeric structures, whose typical morphology is evidenced in the FESEM micrograph reported in Fig. 1b, is strictly dependent on the plasmonic response. Such a response is checked by transmittance spectroscopy performed in the near UV-visible range.
Fig. S3 (ESI†) shows some representative Ag NPs sputtered on c–Si substrates in the same synthesis conditions of the silvered PDMS membranes; the conductive substrate allowed to obtain high resolution viewgraphs and a careful analysis of the particle size and inter-particle gap dispersion. As expected, at low sputtering current (20 mA), the nanoparticles are nucleating and growing without any coalescence process, at higher current (40 mA) the nanoparticles increase their size and the coalescence increases their density shrinking the average gap between them.
As shown in Fig. 2, all the transmittance spectra of the silvered PDMS membranes are characterized by dips corresponding to plasmon resonances ascribed to enhanced absorption/scattering processes related to either LSP coupled to individual particles or yielded by inter-particles interactions. It is worth to underline that beside the NPs morphology, the effect of the dielectric substrate must be taken into account both for the LSP resonance energies and for the fields spatial localization.28,29 However, the influence of the different pre-polymer and curing agent ratios used for the synthesis of our PDMS membranes on their refractive index variation can be considered negligible.
Fig. 2 Transmittance spectra of samples obtained under different synthesis conditions; labels #1–#5 are referred to the same specimens of Fig. 1. The spectra are vertically shifted for clarity; the dashed line is a guide to the eye emphasizing the plasmonic dip positions. |
For densely packed NPs assembly, the major contribution to enhanced light scattering is played by the particle aggregation state. This promotes the occurrence of ‘hot spots’, where the coupling of LSP resonance within two (or more) very close NPs yields a huge concentration of the EM field.30 Molecules located at this plasmonic hot-spot can boost their Raman activity, with SERS enhancement obtainable for the smallest inter-particle gap size.31
The well-known mechanical properties of the PDMS matrix32,33 allow the control over the inter-particle gap distance through the modulation of the external uniaxial strain on the elastomer substrate. Interestingly, the plasmon resonance measured in the transmittance spectra can be tuned by applying strain to the PDMS substrate decorated with Ag NPs. Fig. 3 shows the transmittance spectra of different plasmonic substrates under several applied strains (0–50%, the percentage of the strain was calculated by measuring changes in the substrate total length before and after deformation). When comparing the transmittance spectra, we observe that each specimen is characterized by a broad plasmonic resonance, subjected to a typical blue-shift when the uniaxial strain, and consequently the average inter-particle nanogap size, are increased. This means that the main contribution to the observed plasmonic resonance can be attributed to inter-particle plasmonic interactions. This behavior is in agreement with other theoretical and experimental studies concerning with the analysis of nanoparticle dimers characterized by different nanogaps.34,35
Fig. 3 Transmittance spectra of different plasmonic substrates under external strain (0–50%). The insets show the dependence of the resonance wavelength on the applied strain. |
We choose to apply strains in a range 0–50% since previous experimental studies on PDMS prepared with various mixing ratios did not evidence any hysteresis behaviour.36 In fact, the plasmonic spectral shift of our membranes is found fully reversible after stretching–unstretching cycles (see Fig. S4, ESI†).
In order to get an insight on the optical response of our samples, we have developed a simple model consisting in a dimer of Ag hemispheres deposited on a PDMS substrate. The sphere diameter is 12 nm (i.e. the average size of our typical particles) and the inter-particle gap is tuned in the range d = 1–30 nm. We studied the near-field EM intensity spectra within the dimer nanogap by COMSOL Multiphysics software (3D Finite Element Method). As clearly shown in Fig. 4, the EM near-field intensity spectra (incident electric field polarized along the dimer axis) are characterized by multiple resonances. In particular, the lowest energy mode, which dominates in intensity over the higher energy modes, is subjected to a blue-shift and to an intensity quenching by increasing the inter-particle gap.
The multiple resonances are better evidenced in the semilogarithmic plot of Fig. 5a. Actually, for large inter-particle gaps, two resonances can be found in the visible energy range for an incident electric field polarized along the dimer axis. The lower energy mode is subjected to the above discussed blue-shift by increasing the dimer gap showing a peak splitting for d < 5 nm. On the other side, there is a higher order resonance whose energy is almost independent on the dimer separation. The phase analysis (not shown here) evidences that the lower energy mode (marked as resonance I in Fig. 5a) concerns with two coupled dipole moments oscillating in phase (symmetric mode), which can be referred as bright plasmon mode. Instead, the higher energy resonance (marked as resonance II) corresponds to an antisymmetric mode due to dark plasmons.37 The fields intensity distributions (Fig. 5b and c) show that at resonance I the EM field is enhanced and tightly localized within the dimer gap, while at resonance II the field is localized at both ends of the hemispheres, with a weak intensity. Thus, in elastic and inelastic light scattering processes the high energy mode can be neglected.
Fig. 5 (a) Field intensity spectra of Fig. 4 shown in a semi-logarithmic plot (without any rescaling). Near field intensity distribution for inter-particle gap d = 1 nm (b) at the low-energy resonance (I) and (c) at the high-energy resonance (II). |
Despite the simplicity of the computational model, the results are coherent with the experimental data dealing with the unpolarized transmittance spectra discussed above. Actually, the width of the plasmonic dip featuring the transmittance measurements is much broader than the dominant peak resonance of the simulated spectra, but this can be merely attributed to the overlap of neighboring resonances due to the inter-particle gap size distribution and the polydispersity of individual particle sizes characterizing our samples.
The same SERS analyses performed on sample #1 and #3 (see Fig. S5, ESI†) show much higher limit of detections since the plasmonic off-resonance conditions (λexc = 514.5 nm, λLSPR_SAMPLE #1 ∼ 442 nm, λLSPR_SAMPLE #3 ∼ 465 nm).
Fig. 7 shows a comparison of R6G Raman spectra acquired on sample #5 using different excitation wavelengths with and without mechanical strain applied to the elastomeric membrane. For excitation at 647 nm (far both from the substrate plasmon resonance, and from the analyte electronic resonance), the Raman spectrum shows only modes related to the PDMS matrix such as CH3 symmetric and asymmetric bending at 1262 cm−1 and 1412 cm−1 respectively.39 For excitation at 514.5 nm (close to the particles plasmon/R6G electronic resonances, λLSPR = λexc), the typical RG6 vibrational modes related to xanthene and phenyl rings are easily detected at 775 cm−1 (C–H out-of plane bending), 1184 cm−1 (C–H in-plane bending in xanthene ring), 1364 cm−1, 1512 cm−1, 1575 cm−1 and 1650 cm−1 (C–C stretchings).40 The Raman signal at the same excitation wavelength is strongly quenched by stretching the substrate (50% strain). This is consistent with theoretical expectations considering the blue shift of the transmittance dip of the SERS substrate corresponding to a plasmonic off-resonance condition.
Recently, Ag NPs decorated vertical nanowalls in PDMS on Silicon microfluidic devices were fabricated.42 Differently from this work, an all-PDMS microfluidic chip with a tunable active area were synthesized. The NPs are grown on the ceiling of a microchannel and then bonding on the backside another elastomeric membrane. The schematic structure of the sensor, the operating configuration and the digital photographs of the as prepared device are reported in Fig. 8.
All-PDMS optofluidic devices have advantages over the conventional rigid substrate-based devices in their flexibility to conform to the underlying object as they can be wrapped onto curved surfaces and can be easily cut into different shapes and sizes. Moreover, like for the bare PDMS membranes, our microfluidic device shows the SERS tunability controlled by the uniaxial mechanical stretching (see Fig. S6, ESI†).
Fig. 8d shows the SERS spectra of R6G injected in the chip exciting the analyte along the channel. The collected data demonstrate a good homogeneity of the Raman signal along the microchannel, with a Raman intensity fluctuation markedly lower than the fluctuation measured on the free surface of sample #5 (relative standard deviation RSDdevice = 19% vs. RSDmembrane = 43% over 1 mm of linear scanning). This good degree of measurement repeatability is possible thanks to the microfluidic approach that allows to uniformly distribute the molecules on the Ag NPs network.
Finally, a SERS-active substrate has been integrated in a microfluidic device, characterized by the above discussed SERS tunability, showing promising capability for highly sensitive on-chip detection.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: 3D schematic of the microfluidic device fabrication process, customized tensile strain device, as well as Raman spectra of R6G injected in the stretched and unstretched microfluidic device. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra12168f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |