Jump to main content
Jump to site search

Issue 34, 2019
Previous Article Next Article

On the estimation of crystallization driving forces

Author affiliations


For accurate estimation of crystallization driving forces, activity coefficient ratios need to be estimated. Activity coefficients in saturated solutions can be determined from solubility data if accurate pure component thermodynamic data are available. However, activity coefficients in supersaturated solutions can normally not be determined experimentally. In this paper, we investigate whether standard activity coefficient models fitted to data on saturated solutions can be used for estimation of activity coefficients in supersaturated solutions. For this purpose, we use equilibrium data for 9 polymorphic systems, for which activity coefficients can be extracted from the solubility data for each polymorph, respectively. The 3-parameter NRTL and the 2-parameter Wilson equations are fitted to the data for the more stable form, and are then used to predict the activity coefficients in the solution saturated by the metastable form, i.e. a solution that is supersaturated with respect to the stable form. It is shown that the predictions of the activity coefficients in the saturated solution of the metastable form deviate significantly from the corresponding experimental data. The activity coefficients along the solubility curve of one polymorphic form do not contain sufficient information to distinguish the influence of concentration from the influence of temperature, and accordingly the fitted equation cannot provide an independent characterisation of the influence of concentration on the activity coefficient. If the data for two polymorphic forms are used simultaneously in the regression, the models can provide a better estimation of the true driving force in crystallization processes.

Graphical abstract: On the estimation of crystallization driving forces

Back to tab navigation

Supplementary files

Article information

14 May 2019
01 Aug 2019
First published
01 Aug 2019

CrystEngComm, 2019,21, 5164-5173
Article type

On the estimation of crystallization driving forces

M. Sadeghi and Å. C. Rasmuson, CrystEngComm, 2019, 21, 5164
DOI: 10.1039/C9CE00747D

Social activity

Search articles by author