Open Access Article
Rong Sun†
a,
Hong Huang†b,
Ye Xiab,
Youchao Liub,
Xingquan Taob,
Jun-Long Zhang
a,
Bing-Wu Wang
*ac and
Song Gao
*ad
aBeijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences, College of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, Peking University, Beijing, 100871, P. R. China. E-mail: wangbw@pku.edu.cn; gaosong@pku.edu.cn
bSpin-X Institute, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou 510641, P. R. China
cSchool of Chemical Engineering, Guizhou Minzu University, Guiyang 550025, P. R. China
dGuangdong Basic Research Center of Excellence for Functional Molecular Engineering, School of Chemistry, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, 510275, P. R. China
First published on 26th January 2026
Ratiometric optical thermometers have attracted significant interest due to their high accuracy, self-referencing capability and strong resistance to environmental fluctuations. However, most reported systems rely on doped materials, where random donor–acceptor distributions and batch-to-batch variability hinder reproducibility and restrict practical deployment for high-precision temperature sensing. Molecular ratiometric thermometers with precisely controlled donor–acceptor distances and fixed stoichiometry serve as promising candidates, yet remain largely unexplored. This work reports a dual-center emissive 3d–4f binuclear complex [ZnLSm(OAc)(NO3)2] (ZnSm), constructed using a Schiff base ligand (L). ZnSm exhibits two well-correlated emission bands at 485 nm (ZnL) and 644 nm (Sm3+), enabling quantitative temperature readout over a broad temperature range of 233–333 K with excellent reversibility and a high maximum relative sensitivity of 3.4% K−1. Spectroscopic analyses and theoretical calculations reveal efficient ZnL-to-Sm3+ energy transfer mediated by the bridging Schiff base ligand, accounting for the temperature-dependent dual emission. Moreover, ZnSm can be readily processed into a transparent and flexible poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) film (ZnSm@PMMA) while retaining its ratiometric thermometric performance, thus greatly enhancing its applicability for practical thermal mapping and device-integrated sensing. This work presents a robust molecular design strategy for developing high-performance, dual-center emissive ratiometric optical thermometers. Furthermore, the readily distinguishable color change in the visible range for both ZnSm and its film highlights their potential for advanced optical anti-counterfeiting and information encryption applications.
To address these challenges, optical thermometry,15–20 which harnesses the temperature-dependent photophysical response of a probe, has emerged as a leading approach due to its remote, non-contact nature, high sensitivity, and high-resolution imaging capabilities. It principally employs two main strategies: tracking temperature-induced changes in either luminescence lifetimes or emission intensities.15 Early optical thermometers primarily relied on the absolute change of emission intensity with temperature. However, such single-intensity-based methods suffer from poor reliability due to fluctuations in excitation power, probe concentration and optical path. Alternatively, lifetime-based methods can offer high sensitivity,15,21,22 but their implementation is highly technically demanding. More importantly, this technique is inherently limited for dynamic measurements that fall within or below the probe's lifetime,23 making it ineffective for rapid thermal mapping. In this context, ratiometric intensity-based thermometry presents a compelling alternative by correlating temperature with the intensity ratio of two distinct emission bands.24 This ratiometric approach inherently eliminates the necessity of additional intensity calibration and mitigates signal interference from both environmental changes and instrumental fluctuations, ultimately leading to enhanced accuracy and high stability.
Rare-earth-based thermometry17 is highly appealing due to the unique luminescent properties of the shielded 4f orbitals,25,26 including long luminescence lifetimes,27 as well as narrow emission peaks at well-defined positions that can be easily distinguished from background fluorescence.28 Multiple rare-earth luminescent materials have been developed for temperature detection,17,29–38 primarily based on the doping method. However, achieving identical concentration and quality across different batches of doped materials is challenging. Furthermore, the efficiency of energy transfer critically depends on the donor–acceptor distance, which is inherently random in doped systems and can only be treated statistically.39 These limitations reduce the accuracy of the resulting thermometers and greatly constrain their practical application as high-precision temperature sensors. In contrast, molecular complexes offer a highly promising strategy due to their precise synthesis, ease of modulation and suitability for large-scale production. Among them, molecular complexes featuring dual emission centers have emerged as a particularly compelling yet largely unexplored strategy. In particular, heterometallic architectures provide precisely defined spatial arrangements of the ligand antenna and rare-earth emitter, together with fixed stoichiometric ratios, enabling controllable and reproducible energy transfer efficiencies40 that are highly advantageous for constructing ratiometric optical thermometers. Moreover, the structural and photophysical tunability of these complexes provides a versatile platform for tailoring their emission characteristics.
Here, we present such a class of dual-center emissive complex [ZnLSm(OAc)(NO3)2] (ZnSm, 1R,2R-H2L = [6,6′-((1E,1′E)-(((1R,2R)-1,2-diphenylethane-1,2-diyl)bis(azaneylylidene))bis(-methaneylylidene))bis(2-methoxyphenol)]), constructed using a Schiff base ligand as the bridging unit. ZnSm exhibits characteristic narrow emissions of Sm3+ (560, 599 and 644 nm), along with a broad emission centered at 485 nm originating from the ZnL moiety. Notably, the intensity ratio between the red emission at 644 nm and the blue emission at 485 nm shows pronounced temperature dependence over a wide range of 233–333 K, with a maximum relative sensitivity of 3.4% K−1, making it suitable for constructing high-performance ratiometric optical thermometers with excellent stability and reversibility. To the best of our knowledge, such a high relative sensitivity ranks among the highest reported to date for ratiometric luminescent thermometers. Importantly, this temperature range covers the physiological window, rendering ZnSm particularly attractive to bio-related thermal monitoring,10,18 such as cell or tissue temperature tracking, and thermal control in microfluidic bioreaction systems. Additionally, its temperature-responsive emission color change can be utilized as a trigger for optical anti-counterfeiting and information encryption.41–43 Combined experimental and theoretical investigations indicate that the triplet state of the bridging Schiff base ligand plays a crucial role in the energy transfer process, with its energy level well-matched to the Sm3+ excited state, thereby facilitating well-correlated dual-emission response. Furthermore, ZnSm can be readily processed into a transparent and flexible poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) film while retaining its ratiometric thermometric performance, greatly enhancing its practicality for device integration.44 By constructing such a dinuclear complex, this work successfully achieves temperature-dependent dual-center emission. Compared with single-center molecular ratiometric optical thermometers and doped materials, such dual-center emissive systems provide greater structural tunability, enhanced opportunities for performance optimization and higher measurement reliability, shedding light on the design of high-performance ratiometric optical thermometers.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Molecular structure of ZnSm. (a) One of the crystallographically independent heteronuclear units. (b) View of the packing arrangement along the crystallographic a axis. | ||
Motivated by the above dual-center emission behavior observed at room temperature, we then investigated the temperature-dependent photoluminescent (PL) properties of ZnSm to evaluate its potential as a ratiometric optical thermometer. As shown in Fig. 2a, the emission intensity at 485 nm of ZnL decreases substantially due to the thermal activation of nonradiative decay pathways, whereas the intensity of Sm3+ 4G5/2 → 6H9/2 transition at 644 nm increases with rising temperature in the range of 233–333 K. This temperature-dependent PL behavior may arise from the energy transfer from ZnL to Sm3+ ions via the bridging ligands, and the underlying mechanism is explored (vide infra). Strikingly, the luminescent color of ZnSm gradually changes from green to orange-red and finally to red when it is irradiated with UV light as the temperature is raised from 233 to 333 K, as shown in Fig. 2b. This reversible and visually distinguishable luminescent color change within a practical temperature range enables potential applications in advanced optical anti-counterfeiting and information encryption.41
Theoretical calculations were performed to elucidate the electronic structures and the origin of the temperature-dependent dual-emission behavior of ZnSm. The calculated relative energy levels of the ZnL moiety and Sm3+ ion (Tables S4–S6), along with the possible energy-transfer pathway, are illustrated in Fig. 2c. The triplet excited (T1) state of the ZnL moiety is located at 20
595 cm−1 (485.6 nm), consistent with the observed broad blue emission. In contrast, the energy separation between the singlet excited (S1) and ground state (S0) is 28
418 cm−1 (351.9 nm), which is much larger, indicating that the short-wavelength emission originates from the transition from the T1 to S0 state. This assignment is further supported by the long lifetime (∼µs) of the 485 nm emission. Electronic structure calculations of Sm3+ reveal that the low-lying multiplet 6HJ (J = 5/2, 7/2, 9/2) states are located at 0–324, 1117–1499, and 2459–2808 cm−1, respectively, whereas the excited 4G5/2 state lies in the range of 18
665–19
607 cm−1. These calculated energy levels agree well with the experimentally observed emission bands, corresponding to transitions from the lowest MJ sublevel of the 4G5/2 excited state to the respective 6HJ (J = 5/2, 7/2, 9/2) states. Importantly, the small energy gap between the T1 state of the ZnL moiety and the 4G5/2 state of Sm3+ (∼2200 cm−1) favors thermally assisted ZnL-to-Sm3+ energy transfer, whereas the much larger T1–S1 gap (7823 cm−1) renders reverse intersystem crossing (rISC) inefficient. Upon heating, thermal activation enhances the population of the ZnL T1 state, thereby facilitating energy transfer to the Sm3+ 4G5/2 state and resulting in the intensified 644 nm emission. Furthermore, the T1 spin density is predominantly localized on the bridging Schiff base ligand (Table S7), mainly distributed around the bridging oxygen atoms that coordinate directly to Sm3+. This proximate localization, together with the short O–Sm distance (∼2.4 Å) imposed by the coordination geometry, provides a favorable orbital-overlap pathway for efficient intramolecular Dexter-type energy transfer. Collectively, the thermally enhanced energy transfer strengthens the long-wavelength Sm3+ emission while suppressing ZnL emission, giving rise to a distinct and reversible luminescent color evolution.
Such an energy-transfer process was further verified by temperature-dependent lifetime measurements (Fig. S8 and S9). The lifetime of the Sm3+ 4G5/2 → 6H9/2 transition at 644 nm increases to 50.6 µs at 333 K, representing a 20% enhancement compared with that at 233 K. In contrast, the emission lifetime of the ZnL moiety at 485 nm decreases by nearly 5% over the same temperature range, indicating that the ZnL T1 state is increasingly depopulated through thermally enhanced energy transfer to Sm3+, with nonradiative thermal quenching also involved. These opposite lifetime changes confirm that the temperature-dependent dual-center emissive behavior of ZnSm benefits from the ZnL-to-Sm3+ energy transfer process.
| ln(I644/I485) = 0.03186T − 10.4888 | (1) |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Ratiometric thermometric performance of ZnSm. (a) Temperature-dependent emission intensities of the ZnL band (485 nm) and Sm3+ band (644 nm). (b) Temperature-dependence of the intensity ratio (I644/I485). The red line represents the fitting results using eqn (1). (c) Reversibility of I644/I485 over six heating–cooling cycles between 233 and 333 K. (d) Temperature-dependent relative sensitivity (Sr). The solid line serves as a guide for the eye. | ||
Sensitivity is a key figure of merit for temperature sensors, and a proper sensitivity metric is essential for evaluating and comparing different thermometric systems. To enable quantitative comparison across thermometers operating via different mechanisms, the relative sensitivity (Sr) is commonly employed.47–50 For ZnSm, Sr can be calculated according to eqn (2):
| Sr(T) = (∂(I644/I485)/∂T)/(I644/I485) | (2) |
As shown in Fig. 3d, ZnSm retains high sensitivity (Sr > 1% K−1) within the broad temperature range of 253–333 K when measured at a concentration of 1.0 × 10−5 M, reaching a maximum value of 3.4% K−1 at 333 K when measured at a concentration of 1.0 × 10–5 M, which ranks among the highest so far for ratiometric luminescent thermometers (Table S8). Such a wide operating range combined with outstanding sensitivity meets the criteria of good-performance thermometry.
Beyond conventional doped luminescent thermometers, ZnSm integrates two emissive centers, ZnL and Sm3+, within a single, well-defined molecular framework through deliberate molecular design. This binuclear architecture enables stable, highly sensitive, and reproducible temperature-dependent dual-emission behavior. Owing to the shielded nature of 4f orbitals, the f–f emission of Sm3+ exhibits fixed positions, narrow linewidths, and long-wavelength characteristics, whereas the ligand-centered ZnL emission is located in the short-wavelength region. Such intrinsic differences in emission origin and spectral position effectively minimize spectral overlap between the two emissive bands, allowing clear peak discrimination and accurate determination of emission intensity ratios, which is critical for achieving high relative thermal sensitivity. In addition, many ratiometric thermometers are constructed based on a single emissive center, particularly those exploiting the fine structure of excited- and/or ground-state multiplets of rare-earth ions to generate so-called “hot” and “cold” emission bands.37,38 In these systems, the operational temperature range and sensitivity are largely dictated by crystal-field splitting and the energy gaps between Stark sublevels. While this approach has proven effective, precise modulation of excited states in rare-earth ions remains challenging due to the inherently rigid nature of the 4f electronic structure, which can limit further sensitivity enhancement and flexible tuning of the working temperature window. In this context, the dual-center molecular strategy employed in ZnSm provides a versatile alternative. Guided by the Dieke diagram, the excited-state energetics and emission behavior of rare-earth ions can be rationally anticipated. By pairing rare-earth ions with organic ligands possessing appropriately matched triplet energy levels and enforcing fixed donor–acceptor distances through tailored coordination architectures, property-tunable dual-center emitters for ratiometric thermometers can be constructed.
| ln(I644/I485) = 0.0044T − 1.0986 | (3) |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Preparation and ratiometric thermometric performance of ZnSm@PMMA. (a) Schematic presentation of the preparation process. (b) Temperature-dependence of the intensity ratio (I644/I485). The red line represents the fitting results using eqn (3). (c) Temperature-dependent relative sensitivity (Sr). The solid line serves as a guide for the eye. | ||
The macroscopic and reversible luminescent color variation is conducive to intuitive temperature readout without the need of specialized instrumentation such as fluorescence spectrophotometers. The temperature-dependent chromatic evolution of the ZnSm@PMMA film was quantitatively illustrated using the Commission International de L'Eclairage (CIE) 1931 coordinates (Fig. S15), showing a continuous shift from green (0.2660, 0.3119) to red (0.2827, 0.2507) upon heating from 233 to 333 K. Thus, the temperature information could also be directly estimated through naked-eye color observation referenced to the corresponding CIE coordinates, offering a convenient and low-cost visualization strategy similar to commercial pH strips. Collectively, the reliable ratiometric response and preserved temperature-sensing performance in flexible film form highlight the strong potential of ZnSm@PMMA for practical thermal mapping and on-site temperature diagnostics.
CCDC 2270399 for ZnSm and 2503173 for ZnGd contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.53a,b
Footnote |
| † These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |