Fei Deng‡
abc,
Xiangning Fang‡ae,
Qinglong Qiao*a,
Guoli Hanae,
Lu Miaoa,
Shuangshuang Longad and
Zhaochao Xu
*ae
aDalian Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 457 Zhongshan Road, Dalian 116023, China. E-mail: qqlqiao@dicp.ac.cn; zcxu@dicp.ac.cn
bSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Jinggangshan University, 28 Xueyuan Road, Ji'an, Jiangxi 343009, China
cKey Laboratory of Jiangxi Province for Special Optoelectronic Artificial Crystal Materials, Jinggangshan University, 28 Xueyuan Road, Ji'an, Jiangxi 343009, China
dSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, University of South China, 28 Changshengxi Road, Hengyang, Hunan 421001, China
eUniversity of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
First published on 30th April 2025
Malachite Green (MG) and its fluorogen-activating protein (FAP) pair are valuable tools for live-cell and super-resolution fluorescence imaging due to their unique near-infrared absorption and signal enhancement. However, the low brightness and photostability of MG have limited its use in dynamic imaging. In this study, we introduce a novel derivative, azetidinly Malachite Green (Aze-MG), which enhances the brightness of the MG-FAP complex by 2.6-fold. This enhancement is achieved by replacing the N,N-dimethylamino group in MG with an azetidine group, which suppresses the twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) effect, leading to improved quantum yield and photostability. Additionally, the reduced binding affinity of Aze-MG for FAP enables a buffering strategy, allowing the reversible exchange of photobleached fluorogens with free fluorogens, thereby ensuring stable fluorescence over time. This combination of improved brightness and buffering capability makes Aze-MG an ideal probe for live-cell and dynamic SIM imaging.
A promising strategy to maintain stable fluorescence over time involves using a “buffering” approach, where fluorescent dyes can reversibly bind to their targets.25 This allows free, non-fluorescent dyes in the surrounding environment to replace photobleached dyes on the target, sustaining a consistent imaging signal.26 This reversible binding approach has been effectively applied in organelle imaging, where dyes bind in an interchangeable manner to the organelle membrane matrix.27–29 Here, non-specific interactions are sufficient for binding, allowing for probe exchange simply by adjusting the hydrophilic or lipophilic properties of the dye to interact with the organelle membrane. However, designing reversible binding systems for biomolecule–substrate interactions poses greater challenges due to the specificity required. Unlike organelles, biomolecular targets rely on precise molecular recognition; even small structural changes in the dye can disrupt its binding affinity or specificity, making it difficult to achieve both strong binding and rapid exchange.
Rhodamine, which shares significant structural similarity with MG, offers insights into addressing MG's fluorescence limitations.30 In rhodamine dyes, a major nonradiative de-excitation pathway is twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT), commonly originating from alkylamino substituents.31,32 Studies show that non-alkylated rhodamine 110 and alkyl-substituted rhodamine 101 have quantum yields of 0.88 and 0.80, respectively, both considerably higher than that of tetramethylrhodamine (TMR) (0.41).33 Notably, Lavis et al. found that replacing TMR's N,N-dimethyl groups with azetidine rings effectively suppressed TICT, doubling its quantum efficiency.34 For MG, crystallographic studies of FAP-bound complexes reveal that the binding cavity is over twice the volume of MG itself.35 While aromatic ring rotations are restricted in this environment, the N,N-dimethyl groups in MG remain capable of free rotation within the cavity, likely contributing to TICT-induced fluorescence quenching and reducing the overall quantum yield.
In this work, we address these limitations by engineering a novel derivative of Aze-MG (MG3 in this paper) to enhance both brightness and dynamic imaging potential. Through strategic modification of MG's structure, specifically by introducing azetidine in place of the dimethylamino groups, we successfully increased the brightness of the MG-FAP complex by threefold. This modification suppresses the twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) effect, resulting in improved quantum yield and photostability. Additionally, we implemented a buffering strategy that enables Aze-MG to reversibly bind with FAP, allowing free fluorogen molecules to replace photobleached ones at the target site. This exchangeable binding capacity supports stable fluorescence over time and enables continuous dynamic imaging under structured illumination microscopy (SIM).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) Molecular structures of MG1–4. (b) Absorption spectra of MG1–4 in PBS (pH 7.40). (c) Computed frontier orbitals and energy levels of MG1–4. |
Prior research identified dL5 as an ideal FAP to switch on the fluorescence of MG1.36 We then evaluated the activating ability of dL5** to MG2–4. As presented in Table 1, the absorption maxima of all MGs red-shifted upon the addition of 4 fold excess of dL5**.21,35 Specifically, MG2–4 were red-shifted by 20, 32 and 15 nm, respectively, which were much smaller than the 40 nm shift observed for MG1. The absorbance of each MG further increased upon binding with dL5**, with MG3 showing a remarkable 2.6-fold enhancement, significantly surpassing the changes observed in the other derivatives (Fig. 2a). As anticipated, MG1 showed a fluorescence turn-on response to dL5** with a quantum yield of 0.12. Bruchez et al. attributed this phenomenon to the interactions between MG1 and residues located in both the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) and framework regions of dL5**. Notably, the dimethylamine carbons of MG1 contribute approximately 50% of the total contact area, a feature critical for fluorescence enhancement by restricting intramolecular rotation.35 The negligible fluorescence of MG2/dL5** in our study further supports these findings. The absence of dimethylamine carbons in MG2 results in reduced conformational constraints and a complete loss of fluorescence activation. While the azetidine carbons in MG3 exert a similar effect in the interactions. The MG3/dL5** fluoromodule emits fluorescence in the near-infrared region with a significantly higher quantum yield of 0.28, achieving a 166.7-fold fluorescence enhancement (Fig. 2b). Although MG4 contains julolidine carbons, its substantially larger molecular size likely weakens the binding interaction with dL5**, resulting in only 14.3-fold fluorescence enhancement with a quantum yield of 0.04 upon complex formation. The dissociation constants Kd of MGs to dL5** were measured using a ligand depletion assay at the emission maximum. The Kd values for MG1, MG3 and MG4 were determined to be 3, 16 and 61 nM, respectively (Fig. 2c, d and S4†), showing high affinity to dL5**.
Dye | λabs (nm) | ε (M−1 cm−1) | λem (nm) | Φ | Kd (nM) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
MG1 | 606 | 71![]() |
n.d. | n.d. | 3 |
MG1/dL5** | 646 | 102![]() |
675 | 0.12 | — |
MG2 | 549 | 31![]() |
n.d. | n.d. | n.d. |
MG2/dL5** | 569 | 39![]() |
n.d. | n.d. | — |
MG3 | 607 | 43![]() |
n.d. | n.d. | 16 |
MG3/dL5** | 639 | 113![]() |
664 | 0.28 | — |
MG4 | 646 | 54![]() |
n.d. | n.d. | 61 |
MG4/dL5** | 661 | 75![]() |
684 | 0.04 | — |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) Absorption and (b) fluorescence spectra of 0.5 μM MGs in the absence and presence of 2 μM dL5** (MG1–4: from left to right). Binding equilibrium analysis of MG1 (c) and MG3 (d) to dL5**. |
To investigate the structure–fluorescence relationship of MG-based fluoromodules, we conducted docking simulations. The 3D structure of dL5** (D50E mutation) was constructed using homology modeling based on the MG1-bound L5* (PDB ID: 4K3H) as a template.35 As shown in Fig. 3, the MG derivatives were positioned within the binding cavity formed by a symmetric antiparallel homodimer. MG2 and MG3 oriented approximately orthogonally to the dL5** surface, with their pendent rings extending outward from the cavity, consistent with the orientation observed in MG1. In contrast, MG4 was inserted into the binding cavity with its julolidine moiety protruding outside. The calculated binding affinities for MG1–4 were −10.8, −9.8, −10.4, and −2.5 kcal mol−1, respectively, indicating almost the same affinity for MG1–3. Although the results indicated that dL5** had a high affinity for MG2, fluorescence from the MG2/dL5** complex was not observed. This is likely because the crystal structure of 4K3H revealed that the methyl carbons of MG1 contributed approximately half of the total contact in the MG1-L5* homodimer.35 Therefore, the absence of alkyl groups on the nitrogen atoms of MG2 might allow free rotation of the aromatic rings within the binding cavity, resulting in fluorescence quenching and underscoring the significance of the azetidine group.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Molecular docking analysis of MGs. (Top) Frontal view of the MGs/dL5** complex. (Bottom) Spatial distribution of amino acid side chains in dL5** that come in contact with MGs. |
Briefly, we successfully enhanced the brightness (ε × φ) of the MG1/dL5** fluoromodule by 2.6-fold by replacing the dimethylamino group with a four-membered azetidine ring. While the affinity of MG3 for dL5** was lower than that of MG1, its Kd value of 16 nM was comparable to previous reports and sufficient for fluorescence imaging.21 Notably, MG3 exhibited a substantial absorbance increase of 2.6-fold, compared to a 1.4-fold increase in MG1, thereby enhancing its fluorogenicity. Additionally, the absorption maximum of the MG3/dL5** complex at 639 nm aligns well with the standard 640 nm laser used in fluorescence imaging.
With the enhanced MG3/dL5** fluoromodule, excellent biocompatibility and high stability (Fig. S5 and S6†), we further explored its application in fluorescence imaging. MG3 demonstrates rapid penetration into cells, with the cellular uptake of MG3 primarily mediated by clathrin-dependent endocytosis (Fig. S7†). Using a myc-dL5**-mCer3 fusion protein, we assessed the fluorescence activation capability of this fluoromodule in live cells (Fig. 4a). Similar to the in vitro responses, MG2 showed negligible fluorescence signals in the nucleus, and MG4 exhibited a high background fluorescence. In contrast, MG3 demonstrated excellent fluorogenicity compared to MG1, establishing it as a superior fluorogen-activating protein probe for live-cell imaging. We selected mitochondria and the endoplasmic reticulum as representative organelles for labeling and imaging with MG3. Plasmids containing dL5**, the fluorescent protein mCer3, and a subcellular targeting sequence were transfected into HeLa cells, followed by the addition of 200 nM MG3. As shown in Fig. 4b, MG3 (red) colocalized with mCer3 (green) in the two organelles, indicating that dL5** was appropriately expressed in various subcellular environments, effectively activating the fluorescence of MG3.
To demonstrate the capabilities of MG3 in super-resolution imaging, we first employed SIM to visualize various cellular structures (Fig. 4c–i), including mitochondria, cell membrane, microtubules, and endoplasmic reticulum (ER). MG3 effectively resolved the intricate structures of these organelles at the nanoscale. Adjacent microtubules that appeared indistinguishable under widefield were clearly discernible through super-resolution images, achieving resolutions of 127 nm and 147 nm (Fig. 4f and g). Furthermore, MG3 allowed for the visualization of the fine meshwork of ER, revealing an ER tubule width of 121 nm compared to a width of 316 nm observed with widefield imaging (Fig. 4j and k), further showcasing the high fluorogenicity and brightness of our probes. While widefield identified an ER tubule at 573 nm, super-resolution imaging revealed the finer structural details of the ER mesh, highlighting MG3's substantial potential for super-resolution applications.
Previous reports have indicated that MG1/dL5** is a highly photostable fluoromodule, making it suitable for super-resolution imaging of diverse cellular structures.24 Here, we further evaluated the photostability of both MG1/dL5** and MG3/dL5** in fixed cells under continuous 640 nm laser irradiation during SIM microscopy (Fig. 5). The fluorescence intensity of MG3/dL5** remained at 70% after 600 s, which is slightly higher than the 62% observed for MG1/dL5** (Fig. 5a). These findings were consistent with the outcomes of our confocal microscopy analysis (Fig. S8–S10†). We attribute the enhanced photostability of MG3/dL5** to the buffering effect of MG3 within the fluoromodules. As illustrated in Fig. 5b, continuous irradiation with the 640 nm laser reduced the fluorescence of MG3/dL5** to 58%. Upon cessation of the laser exposure, the fluorescence gradually recovered to 80% after 40 min. This recovery is likely due to the reduced affinity of dL5** for MG3, allowing fresh dyes to replenish those that were photobleached, a mechanism similar to the buffering observed in our previously reported fluorogenic probes.25–29
Due to its enhanced photostability, we applied MG3/dL5** for long-term tracking of mitochondrial dynamics through super-resolution imaging. The mitochondrial network was clearly identified under SIM. As shown in Fig. 6a and Movie S1,† we monitored mitochondrial fission over a 30-minute tracking period. At 9 min, the mitochondrion marked by a green arrow gradually extended to establish contact with a neighboring mitochondrion. This contact point underwent continuous changes over the next 10 minutes. Notably, significant deformation of the neighboring mitochondrion was observed at 16 min. By 22 min, the mitochondrion indicated by the green arrow exhibited a boundary and began to produce a small daughter mitochondrion. Subsequently, the mitochondrion marked by the green arrow remained in contact with the daughter mitochondrion, eventually leading to complete separation from the original mitochondrion. Additionally, multiple fission and contact events were recorded in the same region, highlighted by green arrows. Mitochondrial autophagy is also documented in Fig. 6b and Movie S2.† The mitochondrion marked by an orange arrow gradually swelled at the bifurcation point, transitioning from a slender linear shape to a spherical morphology at 8 minutes.
Using MG3, we also visualized the dynamic behavior of the ER, including the movement of ER tubules and the formation and disruption of ER networks (Fig. 6c). At 0 s, an ER tubule, marked by a white arrow, gradually extended and formed a new network by 40 seconds. This network subsequently gave rise to a new ER tubule, also indicated by a white arrow, at 80 s, which rapidly moved to form a triangular network by 120 s. The newly formed network exhibited significant dynamics and was not stable, gradually shrinking between 120 and 180 s and ultimately breakingoken apart at 220 s. By 400 s, a new budding point appeared in the same area (marked by a white arrow) and created a new network by 420 s, which divided the original network (outlined by an orange dotted frame) into two smaller networks. In contrast to the previous observation, the upper network gradually shrank while the lower network expanded, ultimately forming a larger network by 500 s.
Additionally, we observed a cell rich in rough endoplasmic reticulum (Fig. S11†) and monitored the formation and morphological changes of hollow regions within the rough endoplasmic reticulum (Fig. 6d). We selected three regions of interest (ROIs) – ROI-4, ROI-5, and ROI-6 – to examine the cavities, which exhibited different dynamic behaviors. The mature cavity in ROI-4 showed rapid growth after 60 s, followed by fluctuations in size, with a gradual reduction occurring between 160 and 260 s (Fig. 6e). Notably, newly formed cavities in ROI-5 displayed two distinct growth phases (Fig. 6e). The outline of cavity was marked with a colored dotted frame and the area was recorded. The first occurred in the initial formation period from 40 to 60 s, during which the cavity area increased from 0.03 μm2 to 1.52 μm2. The second significant growth phase was observed between 160 and 240 s, where the area expanded from 1.77 μm2 to 3.06 μm. This suggested that the expansion of cavities formed within the rough endoplasmic reticulum might involve multiple short-term phases of growth rather than a uniform slow process.
Moreover, we achieved dual-color super-resolution imaging of the ER and mitochondria using MG3, enabling us to monitor the movement of mitochondria being pulled by the ER (Fig. 6f).
At 20 s, a mitochondrion marked by a white arrow was completely enveloped by the green ER, showing stronger fluorescence at the contact sites. This phenomenon was similarly observed at 80 and 100 s. Furthermore, by 80 s, the mitochondrion, which was closely apposed to the ER, exhibited a curved morphology (indicated by a dotted line), reflecting strong interactions. At 140 s, the mitochondrion marked by a white arrow displayed high dynamics, being pulled upward by ER–mitochondria contact sites, leading to division at 380 s, during which the ER participated in this fission event. Notably, ER–mitochondria contact sites were found to define the positions of mitochondrial fission, and ER–mitochondria contacts were maintained throughout the entire division process, with the two compartments bounded by the ER tubule moving back and forth.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5sc01150g |
‡ These two authors contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |