Mohamad Abou-Daherab,
Hassnain Abbas Khan
a,
Georgian Melintec,
Sarah Komaty
b,
Javier Ruiz-Martinez
*b and
Aamir Farooq
*a
aClean Energy Research Platform, Physical Sciences and Engineering Division, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST), Thuwal 23955-6900, Saudi Arabia. E-mail: aamir.farooq@kaust.edu.sa
bKAUST Catalysis Center, Physical Sciences and Engineering Division, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST), Thuwal 23955-6900, Saudi Arabia. E-mail: javier.ruizmartinez@kaust.edu.sa
cImaging and Characterization Lab, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST), Thuwal 23955-6900, Saudi Arabia
First published on 12th April 2025
This study investigates the synthesis and catalytic performance of nano-confined manganese oxide (MnOx) on SBA-15 for ethylene oxidation. A “med-synthesis” approach, involving dry impregnation of manganese nitrate on as-synthesized SBA-15 via grinding, was employed to achieve high MnOx loading and controlled dispersion within the mesoporous channels. The resulting catalysts (xMn/SBA-15d) were characterized by XRD, SAXS, TEM, TGA, and XPS to understand the impact of MnOx content on structural properties and catalytic activity. The results demonstrate that the dry impregnation method leads to well-dispersed MnOx nanoparticles within the SBA-15 framework, even at high loadings (up to 30 wt%). In contrast, wet impregnation resulted in larger MnOx particles and a loss of the ordered mesoporous structure. The nano-confined MnOx particles exhibited excellent thermal stability, resisting sintering even after prolonged exposure to high temperatures (550 °C) under reaction conditions. Catalytic testing revealed that the 20 wt% Mn loaded on SBA-15 via the med-synthesis approach displayed superior activity for ethylene oxidation compared to the wet-impregnated counterpart, achieving complete conversion at lower temperatures. In situ TEM studies further confirmed the stability of the nano-confined MnOx particles, highlighting the potential of this med-synthesis approach for developing highly active and durable catalysts for volatile organic compound oxidation.
Transition metal oxides are widely studied in the literature for hydrocarbon oxidation.12 Among these, manganese oxide-based catalysts are reported to be among the most efficient transition metal compounds for oxidation catalysis, and they are environmentally friendly as well.13 However, the catalytic performance of MnOx nanoparticles as oxidation catalysts has not been fully recognized. In particular, little attention has been paid to the catalytic behaviour of MnOx catalysts in oxidation/combustion reactions at low temperatures (e.g., below 300 °C), which are usually performed with noble metal catalysts.14–17 Generally, the catalytic activities of transition metal oxide catalysts are lower than those of noble metal catalysts. However, the inherent advantages of metal oxide catalysts, such as low cost, high thermal stability, and high mechanical strength, make them a promising alternative in several catalytic applications.18,19 Therefore, the controlled synthesis of MnOx nanomaterials has attracted considerable attention from both academia and industry perspective.20–22 Recently several reports on dry impregnation of metal precursors have achieved high dispersion with well-controlled particle size.23 Generally, inorganic precursors are first introduced into the channels of host materials, such as mesoporous silica, and then metal precursors are calcined to produce metal nanoparticles with replicas of the confined space.24,25 Several mesoporous materials like CeO2 and ZrO2 have been used; however, due to their low surface area, their performance remains less attractive.26,27
Since the first synthesis of SBA-15 by Zhao et al.28 with a hexagonal pore network, the tuneable pore size has facilitated the accommodation of larger molecules, mitigating mass transfer limitations compared to other conventional metal oxides. Therefore, the inert nature and inherent hydrophobic properties of SiO2 make mesoporous SBA-15 a promising support material for the incorporation of various active compositions.29,30 Extensive research efforts have gone into the modification of silica-based materials with active nanoparticles, with two main strategies for the synthesis of silica supported materials: the “one-pot” method (or pre-synthesis method) and the “loading” method (or post-synthesis method).31 With the “one-pot” method, the silicon source and the active metal precursor are mixed, and they subsequently interact with the template to form a porous framework. This method is simple and results in an atomic-level mixture of active sites within the porous material. However, adding extra heteroatoms to the framework could disrupt the ordered mesoporous structure and cause further collapse during calcination.32–34 The “loading” method mainly involves first preparing a stable mesoporous silica matrix and then adding the active component to it ref. 35–37. Several variations of this strategy have been reported in literature including impregnation,14 deposition–precipitation,38 graft hybrid,39 colloidal immobilization,40 and vacuum calcination.41 A notable challenge with this method is the distribution of active species, such as nanoclusters of metals or metal oxides, within the elongated pore channels. This distribution may be susceptible to sintering effects during high-temperature calcination. Moreover, achieving high metal loading inside the channels of SBA-15 remains challenging.42
An intriguing alternative is the “med-synthesis” approach, positioned as an intermediate method between pre- and post-synthesis techniques. In this approach, denoted as med-synthesis, the template is retained within the pores. Med-synthesis holds the potential to amalgamate the advantages of both pre- and post-synthesis approaches. This includes achieving a well-distributed active phase and maintaining a defined structure, offering a promising compromise in the realm of porous material synthesis. In their earlier work, Zhu and Sun's group43,44 reported the existence of extraordinarily confined spaces between the silica walls in the as-synthesized SBA-15 (as-SBA-15). By efficiently utilizing this space, a high degree of monolayer dispersion of active metal oxides with high loading can be achieved. The nano-confinement of metals within SBA-15 pores via the “med-synthesis approach” is accomplished by dry impregnation of metal precursor over as-SBA-15 via grinding. This method employs pluronic P-123 in as-SBA-15 as a surfactant to assist in impregnation and agglomeration prevention24,31,45,46
The incorporation of high metal loading opens the door for the utilization of transition metal oxides as an economical alternative to noble metals such as Pt which is considered an optimal catalyst for hydrocarbon oxidation applications.42,47
In this study a manganese precursor was directly incorporated into as synthesized SBA-15 by employing the med-synthesis approach using solid state grinding of the precursor (Scheme 1). The subsequent calcination in air was conducted to obtain the resultant material which where denoted as (xMn/SBA-15d). Manganese nitrate was used in the preparation of the supported systems due to the ease of removing nitrates anions during the calcination. The best performing catalyst prepared via dry impregnation was benchmarked against manganese oxide catalysts synthesized by the wet impregnation method. The controlled crystal growth has gained significant attention for several oxidation reactions, specifically low temperature CO and hydrocarbon oxidation,48–50 and in this context, this work investigates synthesis of MnOx on SBA-15 support by controlled dispersion. This study also aims to enhance the understanding of the catalyst structure, dispersity, and catalytic properties of MnOx nanoparticles for ethylene oxidation, which is crucial for mitigating the impact of unburned hydrocarbons on global warming.
Analyzer 5500 (TA Instruments, US) was used to analyze thermogravimetric (TGA) properties of the samples. Measurements were conducted under an air atmosphere with a flow rate of 20 ml min−1. The samples used had an approximate mass of 4.0 mg.
Textural properties of the catalyst were evaluated by N2 physisorption in Micromeritics ASAP-2020 equipment. Catalysts (300 mg) were first degassed for 5 h at 150 °C. Specific surface area was calculated in the relative pressure range of 0.01–0.2, assuming the N2 molecule has a cross-sectional size of 0.162 nm2.
Catalyst morphology was probed using a TEM Titan Themis microscope. To record the in situ evolution of MnOx particles with temperature, K3 direct detection camera was used. Surface compositions and chemical states were analyzed by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy on a XPS Amicus. High-resolution X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (HrXPS) using a Kratos Axis Ultra photoelectron spectrometer (Kratos Analytical Ltd) was employed to analyze the chemical bonding states of the FAC anodes. Prior to analysis, the samples underwent Ar+ ion beam etching for a duration of 30 minutes. The HrXPS measurements were conducted using a Kratos Axis Ultra DLD spectrometer with a monochromatic Al K X-ray source, operating at 150 W and an energy of hν = 1486.6 eV. The spectrometer was equipped with a multichannel plate, delay line detector, and maintained a vacuum level of 1 × 10−8 mbar. The entire survey spectra and high-resolution spectra were acquired at fixed analyzer pass energies of 160 and 20 eV, respectively. The binding energies were calibrated using the C 1s peak set at 284.8 eV. Analysis of the XPS spectra was performed using CasaXPS, a commercially available software. The fitting method described by Biesinguer et al.52 was employed for spectrum analysis, and a Shirley background was applied to the Mn 2p3/2 region.
Mn loading in the prepared catalysts is quantified using a wavelength dispersive XRF spectrometer (Bruker S8 TIGER WD-XRF).
To evaluate the apparent rate constant, calculations were performed under the following assumptions:
(1) The rate expression is assumed to be first order power law that is dependent on ethylene partial pressures, i.e., r = kPC2H4.
(2) The occurring reaction is assumed to be complete combustion.
(3) Atmospheric pressure, isobaric conditions, throughout the catalyst bed.
(4) Isothermal conditions throughout the catalyst bed.
(5) The change in total molar flow rate (Ftotal) is negligible since the ethylene stream is diluted (≤1% C2H4 in all cases).
(6) The absence of heat and mass transfer limitations and other parasitic phenomena.
To derive the expression of the rate constant, the change in the molar flow rate of ethylene with respect to catalyst loading is expressed as:
To investigate water resistance of the optimum dry impregnated catalyst and its wet-impregnated counterpart, tests were conducted under wet feed conditions. The inlet feed for these tests consisted of 850 ppm ethylene, 15% oxygen, 5% water vapours, and balance nitrogen. The gas hourly space velocity was maintained at 64000 ml gcat−1 h−1.
To investigate the thermal stability, the catalyst was exposed to elevated temperatures for 6 hours under reaction flow conditions. After keeping the catalyst under isothermal conditions for 6 hours, it was cooled down to 125 °C and the catalytic testing was performed by incrementing the temperature gradually until complete conversion was attained. Two tests were performed in the case of 20Mn/SBA-15d samples, where their catalytic performance was evaluated after their exposure to reaction flow conditions at 550 °C and 625 °C. For the case of 20Mn/SBA-15w, it was exposed to 550 °C. Moreover, time-on-stream stability test for 100 hours was performed for the best performing catalyst (20Mn/SBA-15d) at 225 °C.
The SAXS patterns displayed in Fig. 2 illustrate the distinctive features of the dry impregnated and pristine SBA-15 samples. The appearance of three diffraction peaks within the range of 2θ = 0.4°–3° provides evidence for the development of neatly arranged hexagonal pores. Specifically, these peaks correspond to the (100), (110), and (200) planes, which are indicative of the well-defined hexagonal (p6mm) pores found in SBA-15.53,54 These distinctive features of ordered pores are absent in the case of the wet-impregnated sample.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 SAXS patterns depicting the structural features of pristine SBA-15 and Mn-loaded SBA-15 samples at various manganese loading levels. |
Fig. 3 shows thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) curves of the polymers P-123 which is used as a template for SBA-15. In the TGA curve for P-123, weight loss started sharply at around 50 °C and was complete at 250 °C. The observed thermal decomposition of bare as-made SBA-15 shows a single weight loss of 47 wt% at about 120 °C, which is associated with the decomposition of the triblock copolymer P-123 slightly embedded in the siliceous pore walls. We identified 221 °C as a critical temperature point, attributed to the onset of manganese nitrate decomposition. Weight losses observed below 221 °C are assigned to the release of surface and structural water, while at temperatures above 221 °C the decomposition of nitrate resulted in the release of NOx gas and a further substantial weight loss of 35 wt%. Sample 20Mn/SBA-15w calcined in air shows a substantial decrease in weight below 200 °C due to lower onset temperatures for the release of water and manganese nitrate decomposition compared to bare manganese nitrate.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 TGA curves of (a) P-123 template and Mn(NO3)2·xH2O and (b) TEOS condensed on P-123, and 20 wt% Mn loaded on SBA-15 at a heating rate of 10 °C![]() |
N2 adsorption and desorption isotherms were measured on all samples to evaluate the surface and structural properties. The N2 adsorption curves are presented in Fig. 4, and the data are summarized in Table 1.
Catalyst | Surface area [m2 g−1] | Pore size [nm] |
---|---|---|
SBA-15 | 518 | 8.5 |
10Mn/SBA-15d | 397 | 10.2 |
15Mn/SBA-15d | 358 | 9.8 |
20Mn/SBA-15d | 361 | 9.7 |
25Mn/SBA-15d | 354 | 9.9 |
30Mn/SBA-15d | 340 | 10.3 |
20Mn/SBA-15w | 320 | 20.4 |
Both pure SBA-15 and xMn/SBA-15d samples exhibited adsorption isotherms of type IV with hysteresis loops, which are characteristic of nanostructured materials with uniform mesopores. The adsorption and desorption isotherms showed a large increase in the relative pressure (P/P0) ranging from 0.6 to 0.8 for SBA-15 and from 0.5 to 0.7 for MnOx on SBA-15, which is caused by capillary condensation into the mesopores. N2 adsorption data presented in Fig. 4(a).
Table 1 show that the pore diameter and surface area comparison of the prepared catalysts. The specific surface area of SBA-15 was found to be 518 m2 g−1. The surface of catalyst (xMn/SBA-15d) after calcination decreased up to 340 m2 g−1 for 30Mn/SBA-15d which is the highest loading in dry impregnation method. The highest decrease in area is noted for catalyst prepared by wet impregnation, indicating that the pores were progressively blocked by MnOx nanoparticles. In contrary to dry impregnated samples wet, impregnated one exhibited adsorption isotherms of type type III, which indicates the loss of ordered mesoporosity, which is in accordance with SAXS resultshe BJH pore size distribution (Fig. 4b) reveals a monomodal distribution for both SBA-15 and the dry-impregnated catalyst. In contrast, the wet-impregnated sample exhibits a bimodal distribution, indicating the presence of pores both on the surface and within the silica support.55
TEM observation results and EDS mapping of xMn/SBA-15 under vacuum conditions are shown in Fig. 5. It is remarkable that MnOx up to 20% did not grow significantly in size due to the nanoconfinement inside the porous walls of SBA-15. In the wet impregnation method, the particles are mostly on the surface and are not strongly encapsulated by thick walls. EDX mapping analysis was used to test the elemental dispersion of xMn/SBA-15d composites (see Fig. 5). The mapping images of 15–25Mn/SBA-15d demonstrated that Mn element was uniformly distributed on SiO2 after calcination. The xMn/SBA-15d composites have a stable structure under 550 °C. The effect was attributed to the interaction between SBA-15 and MnOx as well as the channel limiting effect.
The comparison for the manganese oxide particle size distribution of dry impregnated 20Mn/SBA-15d and wet impregnated catalyst 20Mn/SBA-15w is given in Fig. 6 with average particle size of 7.3 nm and 48 nm, respectively. The growth of particle in wet impregnation implies that the particles are already sintered when calcined at high temperature (550 °C) for the activation of the catalyst. In case of dry impregnation, the particles are not sintered, rather they remained intact.
To investigate sample stability under reaction conditions, TEM results for spent catalysts are reported in Fig. 7. The spent catalyst 20Mn/SBA-15d in Run-1 shows a slight increase in particle size after 6 hours at 550 °C as the average particle size is 10 nm. However, after exposure to reaction conditions in Run-2 at 625 °C for 6 hours, the average particle size of 20Mn/SBA-15d increased to 16.7 nm, which gives an indication on the thermal stability limit of this catalyst. In the case of wet impregnated sample, the average particle size increased after Run-1 from 48 nm to 54.1 nm. The average particle size distribution for the spent catalysts is reported in Fig. S1 (ESI†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 TEM images of spent catalysts after thermal stability catalytic testing: (a) 20Mn/SBA-15d at 550 °C, (b) and 625 °C, (c) 20Mn/SBA-15w at 550 °C. |
Since atomic movement is easily influenced by temperature and partial pressure of gas surrounding the sample, adjusting the reaction temperature can change atomic dispersion and modify catalyst surface defects, thereby affecting reactivity. We utilized in situ TEM to investigate the behavior of MnOx particles under controlled gas conditions and temperature variations. The dynamic evolution process of uncalcined 20Mn/SBA-15d catalyst under increasing temperature and switching oxygen/nitrogen conditions was monitored with TEM measurements. In Fig. 8, TEM measurements are taken at conditions closely resembling air conditions: 80% N2 with 20% O2 at a total flow rate of 1 ml min−1. Pressure was maintained at 1 atm, and temperature was ramped from 175 to 625 °C with a ramping rate of 1 °C min−1 and intermediate temperature intervals of 350, 450, and 550 °C.
When the temperature was systematically increased from 175 to 625 °C, MnOx particles remained elusive until the temperature reached 625 °C. This observation indicates a temperature threshold for the appearance of MnOx particles in the given conditions (shown in the inset of Fig. 8). Further investigation involved continuous heating at 550 °C for 60 minutes, during which TEM images were captured. Surprisingly, despite the prolonged heating, there was no discernible evolution of particles from the MnOx material.
To validate and understand the particle growth phenomenon, we elevated the temperature to 625 °C. This additional temperature increment was chosen to confirm and observe any subsequent changes in MnOx particles.
In Fig. S2 (ESI†), we examined the particle growth under a specific temperature condition of 550 °C. To capture the potential evolution of MnOx crystals, we conducted a series of sequential imaging experiments at a slightly higher temperature, namely 625 °C. The imaging sessions were performed at specific intervals of 15 minutes, 45 minutes, 1 hour and 45 minutes, 2 hours and 45 minutes, and finally, 3 hours and 15 minutes. This approach aimed to assess whether MnOx crystals exhibit growth at 550 °C over an extended duration.
Across all TEM image frames obtained from sequential imaging sessions, a consistent observation emerges: there is no discernible evidence of particle growth at 550 °C even when subjected to prolonged durations. This absence of observable growth underlines the stability and resistance of MnOx crystals to significant changes in size or morphology under the specified temperature conditions.
Fig. S3 (ESI†) presents in situ validation of the growth and sintering behavior of MnOx particles. TEM images were captured at a temperature of 625 °C for varying durations (5, 30, and 60 minutes) to observe the sintering behavior of the particles. Upon analysis of both STEM and TEM images (top and bottom, respectively), MnOx nanoclusters are apparent on the SBA-15 surface. The particle size increased with time from 6 nm at 5 min to 14.5 nm at 60 min (see Fig. S4, ESI†). This result is consistent with the ex situ results of spent catalyst at 625 °C, where in both cases the average particle size increases with temperature. It is worth noting that due to the limited resolution of STEM imaging in in situ gas conditions, the clear identification of MnOx particles is very difficult. Moreover, due to the sample thickness and complex morphology, even small changes in focus/astigmatism can disrupt the image of small Mn oxide particles or it may highlight some defects in the SBA-15 structure that could be mistakenly identified as highly contrasted Mn oxide particles.
The resistance to sintering, as evidenced by the images, provides valuable insights into the robust nature of MnOx particles within the SBA-15 framework. These observations contribute to our understanding of the thermal stability and behavior of MnOx particles under the specific conditions explored in this study.
From Fig. 8 and Fig. S2 and S3 (ESI†) it is evident that there is diffusion of MnOx particles emerging on the surface and migrating from the edges to the center. This observation is consistent with the recorded video Video S1 (ESI†) showing Mn migration across the surface with temperature elevation from 350 to 650 °C. We postulate that the facilitated Mn migration is due to the presence of P-123 in accordance with its proposed role in enhancing metal dispersion.31,45,46
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was conducted to elucidate the surface chemical state of manganese (Mn). The atomic concentration of elements on the surfaces of 20Mn/SBA-15d and 20Mn/SBA-15w samples obtained by XPS are given in Table 2.
Catalyst (s) | C 1s | O 1s | Si 2p | Mn 2p |
---|---|---|---|---|
20Mn/SBA-15w | 10.67 | 57.37 | 30.82 | 1.14 |
20MnO/SBA-15d | 7.48 | 59.55 | 29.56 | 3.41 |
As shown in Fig. 9, high-resolution XPS spectra of Mn 2p core level was acquired for both samples. Subsequently, spectral deconvolution was employed to fit Mn 2p3/2 spectrum, using a combination of the standard references, namely MnO2, Mn2O3, and MnO.52 Notably, the results revealed the absence of MnO2 in both samples. In the case of 20Mn/SBA-15d catalyst, the presence of manganese was determined to be primarily in the form of Mn3+ oxides, whereas in the 20Mn/SBA-15w sample, manganese was found to exist in a combination of Mn3+ and Mn2+ oxidation states. The utilization of the wet impregnation method thus resulted in a significant reduction in the concentration of Mn2O3 to 69%.
To investigate bulk redox properties, H2-TPR profiles of 20Mn/SBA-15d and 20Mn/SBA-15w were recorded (see Fig. 10). The reduction process of MnOx into MnO by H2 is reported over the temperature range of 200–550 °C.56,57 This reduction pattern is observed in both cases of 20Mn/SBA-15d and 20Mn/SBA-15w. The 20Mn/SBA-15d H2 evolution showed a broad peak centered at 336 °C, which can be assigned to the highly dispersed MnOx (as shown in XRD and TEM results).58 The 20Mn/SBA-15w catalysts showed two consecutive reduction peaks at 285 °C and 352 °C and a narrow peak shoulder at 412 °C. Jacob et al.59 discovered that Mn3O4 is the main intermediate reduction product, the lower-temperature peak was ascribed to the reduction of MnO2/Mn2O3 to Mn3O4, and the higher-temperature peak is attributed to the further reduction of Mn3O4 to MnO. The two-stage reduction pattern in the case of wet impregnated sample indicates more heterogeneity in the manganese species compared to the dry method.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 H2-TPR profile of 20Mn/SBA-15 catalyst prepared by (a) dry impregnation, and (b) wet impregnation. |
The bulk average oxidation state from H2-TPR is calculated based on the metal loading and hydrogen consumption assuming the reduction of all Mn species into MnO with Mn2O3.56,57,60 Hydrogen consumption and average oxidation state for each sample are reported in Table 3. These findings align with our observations in the context of XPS measurements, suggesting coherence between surface and bulk properties of the MnOx in the synthesized samples. The higher oxidation state in the case of dry impregnated sample is attributed to the enhanced oxygen uptake by smaller nanocrystals, as the oxidation rate is proportional to the surface to volume ratio.61–63
Catalyst (s) | Mn2O3 (%) | MnO (%) | Average oxidation state XPS | H2 consumption (mmol g−1) | Average oxidation state H2-TPR |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
20Mn/SBA-15w | 31 | 69 | 2.31 | 2.64 | 2.45 |
20Mn/SBA-15d | 98 | 2 | 2.98 | 3.53 | 2.94 |
Fig. 11 shows the conversion profiles of ethylene using SBA-15 with different manganese loadings. By increasing the metallic loading from 10 to 20 wt%, the light-off temperature is shifted to lower temperatures by ∼100 °C. Catalyst activity decreases with further increase of metal content as observed with 25 and 30 wt% Mn/SBA-15 in dry impregnation. This trend suggests the onset of metal agglomeration, resulting in a reduction in the number of available active sites. The normalized conversion per Mn loading is shown in Fig. S5 (ESI†). The observed trend of increased activity with particle size growth in the 5–10 nm range aligns with the enhanced catalytic performance typically seen in transition metal oxide-based catalysts during redox reactions. Beyond this particle size range, the reduction in surface-to-volume ratio becomes dominant, leading to a decline in activity.64,65 In this study, MnOx did not exhibit well defined crystalline peaks in XRD pattens for Mn loadings below 20%, and TEM images did not reveal any observable surface nano particles at these loadings. However, at 20% Mn lading, MnOx nanoparticles within the postulated optimum size range (5–10 nm) were observed in XRD pattens corresponding to crystalline MnOx phases. Turn over frequency (TOF) values as a function of temperature are reported in Fig. S6 (ESI†); the results confirm the observed activity trends in Fig. S5 (ESI†) below 250 °C. The T90 value of 20Mn/SBA-15d is 250 °C while that of 20Mn/SBA-15w is 300 °C. This difference in performance could be attributed to the enhanced dispersion in the case of dry impregnated catalyst along with the higher average oxidation state. Shaheen et al.66 reported decrease in activity with increased crystallinity, which is in accordance with our observation where wet impregnated sample has more pronounced XRD peaks due to the agglomeration of MnOx nanoparticles. Another factor that explains the enhanced catalytic performance of dry impregnated catalysts is related to the abundance of Mn2O3 phases as quantified from XPS surface species. Mn2O3 phase in MnOx is considered to be a highly desirable phase in oxidation reactions.67,68
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 Temperature screening of C2H4 oxidation on supported MnOx/SBA-15 catalysts at a space velocity of 64![]() |
The best performing catalyst activity in this work exhibits superior catalytic activity to several manganese-based catalyst for ethylene catalytic combustion. The activity is compared with literature results in Table 4 on the basis of the apparent rate constant (k [atm−2 s−1 g−1]) at 150 °C.
Catalyst | Conditions | k [mol atm−1 s−1 g−1] | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|
a Conversion values were reported at 160 °C instead of 150 °C. | |||
Mn2O3 | 500 ppm C2H4, 10% O2, GHSV = 22![]() |
1.4 × 10−5 | 4a |
Fe3Mn1Cu1Ox | 165 ppm C2H4, 10% O2, GHSV = 60![]() |
No conversion reported | 69 |
Mn3O4 | 1000 ppm C2H4, 10% O2, GHSV = 30![]() |
1.13 × 10−5 | 70 |
MnCu7.5Fe7.5 | 500 ppm C2H4, 10% O2, GHSV = 20![]() |
1.93 × 10−5 | 71 |
Mn2O3-SG550 | 500 ppm C2H4, 10% O2, GHSV = 22![]() |
2.2 × 10−5 | 72 |
Ce55Mn45-SiC | 500 ppm C2H4, 10% O2, GHSV = 15![]() |
9.8 × 10−6 | 3 |
20Mn/SBA-15d | 850 ppm C2H4, 15% O2, GHSV = 64![]() |
3.04 × 10−5 | This work |
To evaluate the performance of synthesized catalyst under wet conditions (which represent more realistic scenarios for VOC catalytic combustion),15,51 conversion profiles are presented in Fig. 12. These profiles show that the catalytic activity of the dry impregnated catalyst surpasses that of its wet impregnated counterpart, with T90 values of 300 °C and 333 °C for dry and wet impregnated catalysts, respectively.
Thermal stability catalytic testing (Fig. 13) shows that the dry impregnated catalyst activity is maintained at 550 °C, while that of wet impregnated catalyst drops after the exposure to the same condition. This shows the higher thermal stability of dry impregnated sample. However, at 625 °C the activity of the dry impregnated sample drops significantly. These results are in accordance with the TEM findings where the catalyst deactivation is correlated to particle growth. The dry impregnated catalyst exhibited a stable catalytic performance at 225 °C, as shown in Fig. S7 (ESI†). These results are consistent with the recyclability assessments, where the light-on run showed no significant difference compared to the light-off conversion profiles, as shown in Fig. S8 (ESI†).
The choice between dry and wet impregnation methods for preparing Mn/SBA-15 catalyst significantly influences its catalytic performance and thermal stability in ethylene combustion. The observed variations in ethylene conversion rates and temperature dependencies highlight the importance of the preparation method in tailoring catalyst properties for specific applications. In comparison to MnOx deposited through conventional wet impregnation, the nanoconfined catalyst exhibited superior performance. In situ TEM studies provided insights into the growth behavior of the nanoparticles, highlighting their stability and uniform distribution within the SBA-15 channels. Furthermore, our investigation revealed significant advantages of the nanoconfinement approach in terms of catalytic activity. Specifically, the oxidation of C2H4 exhibited a lower T90 temperature (250 °C) with the nanoconfinement catalyst compared to the catalyst synthesized using wet impregnation (T90 = 300 °C). The temperature investigation, along with EDX color mapping, provided valuable information on the dispersion and growth behavior of MnOx nanoparticles at elevated temperatures. These findings demonstrate the potential of the nanoconfinement approach using SBA-15 for the development of efficient catalytic systems based on MnOx nanoparticles.
Our study highlights the successful synthesis and characterization of nanoconfined MnOx nanoparticles within SBA-15. The results emphasize the advantages of the nanoconfinement approach in terms of particle size control, dispersion, and catalytic performance. Further research and optimization of the nanoconfinement strategy could unlock new opportunities for the design and development of advanced catalysts for various applications.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ma01235f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |