M.
Ben Khalifa
*a,
L.
Wiesenfeld
b and
J.
Loreau
*a
aKU Leuven, Department of Chemistry, Celestijnenlaan 200F, B-3001 Leuven, Belgium. E-mail: malek.benkhalifa@kuleuven.be; jerome.loreau@kuleuven.be
bLaboratoire Aimé-Cotton, CNRS and Université Paris-Saclay, Orsay, France. E-mail: laurent.wiesenfeld@universite-paris-saclay.fr
First published on 16th April 2025
Observations of molecules with C3v symmetry, such as CH3CN, are particularly valuable in molecular clouds as the rotational transition selection rules of these molecules allow them to serve as gas thermometers. Interpreting their spectra in non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (non-LTE) conditions requires accurate collisional rate coefficients, especially for interactions with common interstellar species like H2. In this work, we present a five-dimensional potential energy surface for CH3CN in van der Waals interaction with H2 (1Σ+), computed using the CCSD(T)/F12 method and the aug-cc-pVTZ basis set. This potential energy surface is fitted with analytical functions suited for scattering calculations. Cross sections for rotational transitions in collisions between ortho- and para-CH3CN and para-H2 (j2 = 0) are computed using the close-coupling quantum scattering method, across energies from threshold up to 150 cm−1. These data are essential for interpreting interstellar CH3CN emission lines and advancing our understanding of diverse astronomical environments.
CH3CN was observed in a wide variety of astronomical environments, both in our Solar System and beyond. It has been first identified in the Sgr B and Sgr A molecular clouds.2 Since then, several studies focused on CH3CN, including in gas affected by the passage of a shock wave such in L1157-B1,3 in comets,4 in protoplanetary disks,5 in cold dense cores,6,7 as well as in extra-galactic sources.8 Recently, CH3CN was detected towards the circumstellar disk around V883 Ori9 and it is also a constituent of the atmosphere of Titan, Saturn's largest moon.10,11 CH3CN is likely to be formed on icy grains from reactions involving CH3 and CN radicals and injected into the gas phase as the icy grain mantles desorbs CH3CN at temperatures above 90 K,12 or directly in the gas phase by electron recombination of CH3CNH+.13
Due to its large abundance, its prolate character and its large permanent electric dipole moment (μ = 3.913 Debye),14 CH3CN shows strong rotational lines in the millimeter and sub-millimeter bands, making this molecule a useful probe of temperature, density and physicochemical conditions of the environment where it is detected. Furthermore, methyl cyanide displays a large number of rotational lines with the same k and different j (Δj = 1 and Δk = 0, where j is the rotational quantum number of CH3CN and k is the projection of j on the C3 molecular symmetry axis) that can be observed simultaneously in the same frequency range.15 The intensities of such transitions are related to the excitation temperature, which can be estimated without being affected by calibration errors or apparatus functions.
Because of the low density of most astrophysical regions, the populations of the energy levels cannot always maintain local thermodynamical equilibrium (LTE) with the ambient gas. In such conditions, interpreting the CH3CN emission spectra, in terms of temperature, density, and column density requires solving simultaneously the radiative transfer equation and a set of statistical equilibrium equations for the molecular energy levels. A knowledge of the collisional rate coefficients for the excitation of CH3CN by the main background gas, usually H2 molecules, He atoms, or in some cases H atoms, is then necessary. The set of rate coefficients for the excitation of CH3CN used in non-LTE models is often based on the data computed by Green,16 which were obtained at what is today considered a low level of theory. The collisional excitation of CH3CN by He atoms has been the object of recent studies,17–19 which showed major differences with the data from Green.16 He is often considered as a proxy for the spherical para-H2 (j = 0) due to their similarity. Although this approximation is useful to simplify the study of the collisional excitation, it is often found that collisions with H2 display a different behaviour than with He, warranting separate investigations.20,21
In the following, we present a study of the rotational (de-)excitation of CH3CN induced by collisions with para-H2 (j2 = 0) at energies below 150 cm−1. A detailed summary of the construction of the potential energy surface (PES) for the interaction of CH3CN and H2 considered as two rigid rotors along with the fitting procedure of the PES is reported in Section 2. Section 3 describes the low-energy dynamics of collision. We end with conclusions and future outlook in Section 4.
To define the collisional complex, it is customary24,25 to employ a 5D Jacobi coordinate system (R, θ1, ϕ1, θ2, ϕ2) as shown in Fig. 1. The origin of the coordinate system is in the center-of-mass G of the CH3CN and one of the hydrogen atoms of CH3CN is located in the XGZ-plane. The GXYZ frame coincides with the main axes of inertia of CH3CN, with the GZ axis defined along the C3 symmetry axis. The position of the center of mass of H2 is characterized by the coordinates (R, θ1, ϕ1), where R is the length of the intermolecular vector R that connects the center of mass of CH3CN to the one of H2 and the polar angles (θ1, ϕ1) are the spherical angles defining the orientations of H2 with respect to CH3CN. The H2 orientation is set by the spherical angles (θ2, ϕ2) in the frame (parallel to the GXYZ frame).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Jacobi coordinates system used to describe the interaction of CH3CN–H2 van der Waals complex. The origin of the reference frame is at the CH3CN center-of-mass. |
The geometry of the symmetric top molecule CH3CN is defined by the following parameters, which correspond to the ground-state average values reported previously by Le Guennec et al.:26r(N–C) = 1.156 Å, r(C–C) = 1.457 Å, r(C–H) = 1.087 Å, and ∠(HCC) = 110°. In the case of the H2 molecule, a bond length rH–H = 1.448 bohr was used, corresponding to the average value of the vibrationally ground-state geometry.
The ab initio calculations were performed with the MOLPRO (version 2019)27 quantum chemistry software package. We first examined the mono-configurational behavior of CH3CN–H2 wave function by carrying out multiconfigurational computations with the CASSCF approach.28 The electronic wave function is mainly described by only electron configuration with statistical weight around 0.95. Monoconfigurational coupled cluster methods are thus expected to be suitable to accurately describe the electronic correlation.
As a second test, we established a comparison of various methods and basis sets by computing the interaction potential for several molecular orientations. The computational method used as a reference for our closed shell system is the coupled cluster method with simple, double and perturbative triple excitations [CCSD(T)] with the complete basis set extrapolation (CBS)29 limit technique. The basis extrapolation was performed using the aug-cc-pVXZ (X = D, T, Q) basis sets. At all selected geometries, the counterpoise scheme of Boys and Bernardi30 was used for the description of interaction energies E(int) as follows:
EX(int) = EX(CH3CN, H2) − EX(CH3CN) − EX(H2), | (1) |
One-dimensional cuts of the interaction energies as a function of R are presented in Fig. 2 at fixed angles corresponding to the global minimum of the PES (θ1 = θ2 = ϕ1 = ϕ2 = 0°, see below). We used both the standard CCSD(T) method31 and its explicitly correlated variant CCSD(T)-F1232 with basis sets aug-cc-pVXZ (aVXZ for short) of increasing size. The analysis of these benchmark calculations shows that the potential computed at the CCSD(T)-F12/aVDZ level is already of better quality than at the CCSD(T)/aVTZ level, despite the much smaller computational cost. While the explicitly correlated method overestimates slightly the depth of the well compared to the CBS results, Fig. 2 shows that the CCSD(T)-F12/AVTZ approach achieves an accuracy comparable to the reference CCSD(T)/CBS (D, T, Q) results.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Potential energy (in cm−1) of the CH3CN–H2 complex,computed at different levels of theory, as a function of the distance R for the fixed orientation θ1 = θ2 = ϕ1 = ϕ2 = 0° (for which the global minimum of the PES is found, see text and Fig. 3). |
In addition, the use of the larger aVQZ basis set only leads to a minor improvement of the interaction energy at the cost of an important increase in computational time. Since the CCSD(T)-F12/aVTZ and CCSD(T)-F12/aVQZ are almost indistinguishable, we chose the former to compute the full PES of CH3CN–H2, an approach that is customarily employed to study weakly bound van der Waals complexes.
We present in Fig. 3 various contour plots of the 5D-PES of the CH3CN–H2 complex. Each contour plot allows a visualization of a slice of the PES depending on two variables, which are indicated by the axis labels. The three remaining coordinates were kept fixed.
The global minimum (GM) of the PES is found at R = 8.5 bohr for the orientation θ1 = θ2 = 0° (where ϕ1 and ϕ2 are undefined) with a corresponding energy of 239.5 cm−1 below the dissociation limit. This corresponds to H2 co-linear with the C3 axis of CH3CN, on the side of the nitrogen atom. This is similar to results found for the interaction of symmetric tops with H2, such as for ammonia.33 The GM can be seen in the 2D contour plot shown in panels (a) and (b) of Fig. 3, which display two-dimensional cuts of the contour plot along (R, θ1) for θ2 = 0° and either ϕ1 = 60° or ϕ1 = 0°. When keeping the orientation of H2 fixed to θ2 = 0° and relaxing θ1, the PES displays a local minimum with a well depth of 207.3 cm−1 at θ1 = 101° when ϕ1 = 60°, that is, when H2 is located between two of the three H atoms of CH3CN (see panel (a) of Fig. 3). When ϕ1 = 60° (H2 in the plane formed by the C–C–H plane, panel (b) of Fig. 3), the local minimum is shallower, with an energy of 165.9 cm−1. In both cases the local minimum is separated from the GM by a local maximum of about −17 cm−1. For other orientations of H2 the PES displays local minima again, as illustrated in panel (c) of Fig. 3. The interaction energies of the various minima and transition structures highlighted in the Fig. 3 are given in Table 1, along with the corresponding value of the coordinates. Fig. 3 shows that the interaction potential between CH3CN and H2 is attractive in the long-range, but that it is strongly anisotropic, especially along the θ1 coordinate. This anisotropy will play an important role in the rotational energy transfer of methyl cyanide during the collision.
Geometries | R | θ 1 | ϕ 1 | θ 2 | ϕ 2 | V |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
GM | 8.5 | 0 | 60 | 0 | 0 | −239.5 |
LM | 6.1 | 101 | 60 | 0 | 0 | −207.3 |
TS | 7.9 | 56 | 60 | 0 | 0 | −17.2 |
LM | 6.4 | 95 | 0 | 0 | 0 | −165.9 |
TS | 7.8 | 56 | 0 | 0 | 0 | −16.5 |
GM | 6.3 | 95 | 0 | 90 | 90 | −156.3 |
LM | 8.7 | 180 | 0 | 90 | 90 | −114.6 |
TS | 8.2 | 142 | 0 | 90 | 90 | −86.1 |
In the rigid-rotor approximation, the C3v symmetry of CH3CN requires that m1 be a multiple of 3, (m1 = 3n, n integer). The C∞h symmetry of H2 requires that only even l2 terms need to be included (l2 = 2n).
For a given distance R, the 5D-PES was fitted according to the following expression:
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
For each value of the intermolecular distance R, the values of the interaction energy computed on the grid of 1000 random orientations were fitted in a linear least squares procedure to determine the angular coefficients. We started the fit by minimizing the number of angular functions to T0000 function and we increased the number of function as long as the fit kept being more accurate (enough terms in the expansion) and reliable (enough ab initio energy points to define all terms). The best compromise between the number of ab initio energies per distance, accuracy of the fit, and number of fitting functions was found for values: m1 ≤ l1 ≤ 12 for CH3CN and l2 ≤ 2 for H2. The final set was then composed of 181 angular functions. This set was used for all 37 intermolecular distances. In the long-range and minimum region of the PES (R ≥ 5.5 bohr), the fit is better than 1%. A somewhat larger error is found for smaller values of R, thereby limiting the precision of the fit at higher collisional energies. Finally, we performed a cubic spline interpolation of the coefficients throughout the intermolecular region (R ≤ 30 bohr) while at long range (R ≥ 30 bohr) the PES was extrapolated by a simple power-law behaviour Vl1m1l2l(R) = B/Rβ, suitable for the dynamic calculations, where the value of the parameters B and β depends on l1, m1, l2, and l. The long range extrapolations were finally smoothly connected to the cubic spline interpolation by an appropriate switch function given below:
![]() | (4) |
We illustrate in Fig. 4 the variation of the first five radial coefficients (Vl1m1l2l) along the R Jacobi coordinate.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Dependence on R of the first Vl1m1l2l(R) expansion terms in eqn (2) for CH3CN–H2 with l ≤ 3. |
EJ,K = BJ(J + 1) + (A − B)K2 + DJJ2(J + 1)2 − DJKJ(J + 1)K2 − DK4 | (5) |
The rotational constants and the centrifugal distortion constants of CH3CN are given by B = C = 0.3068 and A = 5.2470, and DJ = 1.27 × 10−7, DK = 5.90 × 10−6, and DJK = 9.44 × 10−5 (all values in cm−1).35
The presence of three identical H atoms in CH3CN results in two nuclear spin states, namely ortho-CH3CN (total hydrogen nuclear spin 3/2) which correspond for k = 3n (n integer), including also k = 0, and para-CH3CN (total hydrogen nuclear spin 1/2) with k ≠ 3n. Since ortho–para-transitions are forbidden in inelastic collisions as well as through radiative processes, the two spin modifications of CH3CN can be considered as independent and separate scattering calculations can be carried out independently.
Once the analytical PES was successfully integrated in the MOLSCAT computer code, the state-to-state rotational cross sections of both nuclear spin species, para- and ortho-CH3CN, in collisions with para-H2 (j2 = 0) were computed using the exact time-independent close-coupling (CC) method.39 The diabatic log derivative propagator40 was employed to solve the coupled channels scattering equations. Total energies up to 150 cm−1 were considered and the reduced collision mass was taken as μ = 1.92134 atomic mass units (isotopes 1H, 12C and 14N). We do not take into consideration the hyperfine excitation in CH3CN molecule because the component splitting is not resolved by the astrophysical observations.
We computed converged cross sections for transitions involving levels up to jk = 133 for ortho-CH3CN (rotational energy Erot = 100.524 cm−1) and jk = 134 for para-CH3CN (Erot = 135.268 cm−1). We started by testing the integrator parameters, which were adjusted to ensure convergence of the rotational cross sections over the entire energy range. The integration limits were set to Rmin = 2.5 bohr and Rmax = 30 bohr. Furthermore, the rotational basis was defined in order to include all open channels along with several closed channels to insure proper convergence of the cross sections with respect to the size of the rotational basis: For ortho-CH3CN (resp. para-CH3CN) convergence was achieved with jmax = 18(19) for Etot ≤ 50 cm−1, jmax = 19(20) for Etot ≤ 100 cm−1 and jmax = 24(25) for 100 ≤ Etot ≤ 150 cm−1, respectively. As the number of coupled equations and the computer time required for their solution increase quickly with the size of the rotational basis, we have used the cut-off parameter Emax = 1300 cm−1 to eliminate some highly excited levels. By assigning values of 1 and 0.05 Å2 to the diagonal and off-diagonal tolerances respectively, the convergence of the inelastic cross sections was ensured within better than 5 per cent for all inelastic transitions considered here. For example, for the total energy Etot = 100 cm−1, Jtot = 45 ensures the convergence. A proper description of resonances requires the accurate generation of cross sections especially at low energies. The density of the energy grid therefore varies with the total energy and cross sections were computed every 0.2 cm−1 at low energy and every 1 cm−1 at the highest energies.
As the ortho and para levels of CH3CN cannot be converted in inelastic collisions, the cross sections were computed separately for each nuclear spin species. Fig. 5 highlights plots of the low energy dependence of state-to-state integral cross sections for dipolar (Δj = 1) and quadrupolar (Δj = 2) transitions with Δk = 0 for ortho-CH3CN (panels (a) and (c)) and para-CH3CN (panels (b) and (d)) in collisions with H2(j2 = 0).
All excitation cross sections exhibit a similar energy dependence: They increase in magnitude from their respective energy thresholds, achieve a maximum, and subsequently decrease with increasing collision energy in the range examined here. Moreover, as it is expected, due to the small values of the rotational constants and the comparatively large depth of the PES, all inelastic cross sections exhibit a dense resonance structure at low energies for collisions of both nuclear spin modifications of CH3CN. These are a combination of both Feshbach and shape resonances resulting from the decay of quasibound states of the CH3CN–H2 complex, supported by the van der Waals well. As the kinetic energy increases, the resonances become smooth and less pronounced.
For both ortho and para-CH3CN, we observe in Fig. 5 (panels (a) and (b)) that cross sections corresponding to transitions with Δj = 1 and Δk = 0 (e.g., 20–30 for ortho-CH3CN and 21–31 for para-CH3CN) are comparable in magnitude to transitions with Δj = 2 and Δk = 0 (e.g., 20–40 or 21–41) at low energy. However, the cross sections for Δj = 1 transitions decrease more quickly with increasing energy, and above collision energies of about 50 cm−1 the Δj = 2 cross sections become significantly larger than those for the corresponding transitions involving Δj = 1. Transitions with Δj > 2 are comparatively much smaller (not shown). Such findings confirm that for the ortho- and para-CH3CN–H2 colliding system, a general propensity rule towards Δj = 2 transitions can be expected. In order to examine the dependence of cross sections on the variation of the quantum number k, we display in panels (c) and (d) of Fig. 5 the cross sections for rotational transitions corresponding to Δj = 1 and 3 with Δk = 0,1, and 3. A clear dominance of Δk = 0 transitions is noted, hence, a strong propensity rule on Δk = 0 component can be outlined. Such a result is not surprising since similar behaviors were also found for the related collisional system CH3CN–He.17
We compare in Fig. 6 our results with the corresponding cross sections for CH3CN–He collisions, which were calculated at a similar level of theory.17 We turn our focus to the case of para-CH3CN excitation with initial level jk = 31 and present cross sections for four transitions that correspond to Δj = 1 and Δk = 0, Δj = 2 and Δk = 0, Δj = 1 and Δk = 1, as well as Δj = 2 and Δk = 1. Significant differences can be observed between the present results and the cross sections of CH3CN–He in the whole collision energy range considered. For the 31–51 transition (Δj = 2, Δk = 0) the shape of the cross section is similar for the excitation by H2 and He, although the magnitude is larger for excitation by H2. For all the other cases the cross sections for excitation by H2 are much larger than the corresponding ones for He, especially for transitions with Δk ≠ 0 where the difference is more than an order of magnitude. Significantly, there is no constant linear scaling between the present cross sections and those for CH3CN–He, which confirms the relevance of the new calculations. Furthermore, as one can also observe in Fig. 6, another important difference is that the inelastic cross sections for excitation by H2 are characterized by a denser resonance structure than for excitation by He. This is likely due to the large difference between the well depth of the two interaction potentials: while for the CH3CN–He system, it is about 55 cm−1, the well depth of the PES in our calculation is more than four times larger (239.5 cm−1), which allows the potential to support a much larger number of quasi-bound states.41
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Comparison of cross sections for the excitation of CH3CN by para-H2 (solid lines) and He atoms (dashed lines) for selected transitions with Δj = 1 or 2 and Δk = 0 or 1. |
The PES was then used to investigate rotational energy transfer in CH3CN–H2 collisions, with H2 in its j2 = 0 state (para-H2). Collisional excitation was investigated for energies ranging between the threshold and 150 cm−1, and inelastic cross sections associated to rotational transitions in ortho- and para-CH3CN were computed using the quantum close-coupling method. Propensity rules which favor transitions with Δj = 2 and Δk = 0 were found for both para- and ortho-symmetries of acetonitrile.
The accurate PES presented in this work and the associated scattering calculations are a first step towards obtaining a full data set of rate coefficients for the rotational excitation of CH3CN, which should significantly help the interpretation of interstellar CH3CN emission lines observed with current and future telescopes. In turn, this would allow to better constrain the abundance of CH3CN in molecular clouds, which is crucial to understand the chemistry of cyanide species in the interstellar medium. In future work, we will extend the scattering calculations towards higher collisional energies, enabling the computation of the corresponding collisional rate coefficients. These rate coefficients can then be compared to those corresponding to the excitation induced by collisions by He atoms, but also by ortho-H2, which cannot be inferred from the para-H2 rate coefficients.42,43 The impact of these new data in non-LTE radiative transfer models can subsequently be evaluated.
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2025 |