Federica
Rulli‡
a,
Guillem
Sanz-Liarte‡
b,
Pol
Roca
b,
Nina
Martínez
a,
Víctor
Medina
b,
Raimon
Puig de la Bellacasa
a,
Alexandr
Shafir
*bc and
Ana B.
Cuenca
*ac
aBISi-Bonds/CRISOL Group, Dept. of Organic and Pharmaceutical Chemistry. Institut Químic de Sarrià, Universitat Ramon Llull, Vía Augusta 390, 08017 Barcelona, Spain. E-mail: anabelen.cuenca@iqs.url.edu
bBISi-Bonds Group, Dept. Química Biológica. Institut de Química Avançada de Catalunya, IQAC-CSIC, C/Jordi Girona 20, 08034 Barcelona, Spain. E-mail: alexandr.shafir@iqac.csic.es
cCentro de Innovación en Química Avanzada (ORFEO-CINQA), Barcelona, Spain
First published on 7th March 2024
The synthesis of BN-containing molecules, which have an interesting isosteric relationship to their parent all-C cores, has drawn a great deal of attention as an avenue to alter and tune molecular function. Nevertheless, many cores with embedded BN are still hard to synthesize, and thus, further effort is required in this direction. Herein, we present an integrated approach to BN-containing polycycles rooted in an exceptionally clean B–N condensation of amines with a tri-allylborane. Having released propene as the only byproduct, the resulting BN precursors are seamlessly telescoped into BN-containing polycyclic cores via a set of additional methodologies, either developed here ad-hoc or applied for the first time for the synthesis of BN-cycles. As the “sharpening stone” of the process, BN-embedded naphthalene, which has previously only been obtained in low yield, can now be synthesized efficiently through propenolysis, ring-closing metathesis and a new high-yielding aromatization. As a more advanced application, an analogously obtained BN-containing bis-enyne is readily converted to BN-containing non-aromatic tetra-, penta- and hexacyclic structures via ring-closing enyne metathesis, followed by the Diels–Alder cycloaddition. The resulting air-sensitive structures are easily handled by preventive hydration (quaternization) of their B–N bridge; reverting this hydration restores the original Bsp2–Nsp2 structure. In the future, these structures may pave the way to BN-anthracenes and other π-extended BN-arenes.
Fig. 1 (A) BN-isosterism illustrated through BN-mapping of ethylene, and (B–D) some common unsaturated ring structures. |
BN isosteric replacement thus allows for even a small molecular core to be mapped onto a range of BN isosteres to potentially give diverse physical and chemical properties. This has sparked a great deal of interest from groups working in areas ranging from medicinal chemistry3 to new organic electronic materials, as the mapping of BN onto polycyclic aromatic (or heteroaromatic) ring structures (PAH) can lead to cores with improved optoelectronic properties.4 Taking naphthalene as the smallest PAH archetype, the energy levels of π-type molecular orbitals have been altered by mapping the all-carbon core onto several possible BN-isosteres,5 including the historically important bicyclic azaborine 1 (Fig. 1C).6 Potentially very interesting but much less explored are the BN isosteres of fully or partially saturated polycyclic molecules, such as the decaline-type derivative 1′ (Fig. 1D).7
The need for new synthetic tools to unlock the full potential of BN-isosterism is reflected in game-changing advances from several laboratories for the production of BN-containing mono- and polycyclic aromatic cores,1,8 including impactful N-directed electrophilic borylation protocols,9 ring-closing metathesis (RCM) of diolefinic aminoboranes,10 or late-stage diversification of BN heterocycles.8b Nevertheless, efforts are ongoing to find more efficient ways to produce certain classes of polycyclic BN-containing cores, with challenges including the poor yield (see below) of the synthesis of BN-containing naphthalene 1 (shown in Fig. 1C), difficulties in accessing BN-containing acene-type cores, or the synthesis – and handling – of non-aromatic BN-containing cycles.
We now show how such aromatic and non-aromatic polycycles can be prepared and handled through a combination of virtually quantitative proto-deallylation of the B-allyl moiety, norbornene-aided aromatization, core extension via ring-closing enyne metathesis/Diels–Alder manifold, and product handling via interim B–N hydration.
With 1 serving as a building block for a wide range of BN targets, from simple BN-mapped naphthalene derivatives to extended BN-perylenes14 to emissive core candidates (Samsung Display Ltd),15 we envisage that improving its synthesis might have a positive impact in a number of areas in the field.
Hence, as an alternative path to 2, we proceeded to expose B(allyl)3 to a solution of N,N-diallylamine in CH2Cl2 at 0 °C, resulting in a species tentatively identified (via1H NMR, see ESI†) as the acid–base adduct 5 (Scheme 2A). When heated to 45 °C, this adduct gradually evolved to tetra-allyl aminoborane 2, reaching complete conversion after ∼48 h. Seeking to shorten the reaction time, we opted for a solvent-free approach in hopes of enabling a higher-temperature process and doing away with the subsequent solvent switch in the RCM step. Gratifyingly, dropwise addition of N,N-diallylamine to neat triallylborane at 0 °C, followed by heating the resulting adduct to 65 °C, led to visible bubbling, and after ∼6 h, the formation of a clear liquid, shown by 1H NMR to be the remarkably clean neat tetra-allyl species 2 (Scheme 2A).
Scheme 2 (A) One-pot two-stage sequence to convert B(allyl)3 to bicycle 3. (B) Comparison of DFT barriers for 4- and 6-membered transition states for the proto-deallylation step. |
This efficient reaction of an N–H substrate with organoborane appears to be unique for B(allyl)3 and does not extend to non-allylic trialkylboron derivatives.12 In the original 1961 report, this reactivity difference was rationalized through the low B–Callyl bond energy.12b It is important to note, however, that while any NH amine-organoborane adduct could in principle undergo proto-dealkylation via a 4-membered transition state (i.e. NH proton transferred to B–C carbon), allylic boranes are uniquely capable of propene elimination via a 6-membered transition state. In line with this reasoning, DFT modelling revealed a barrier of ∼40 kcal mol−1 for converting 5 to 2via a 4-membered transition state, which would be common to allyl- and alkyl boranes. However, this activation energy was nearly halved (ΔG‡ = 21 kcal mol−1) for the propene elimination via a 6-membered TS, which we believe to be the real reason for the enhanced reactivity of B(allyl)3 adducts in this process (see Scheme 2B).
As propylene gas was the only by-product, the freshly obtained tetra-allyl precursor 2 was employed directly in the subsequent metathesis step. In a 16 mmol run, newly formed 2 was simply dissolved in CH2Cl2 and treated with the Grubbs first-generation catalyst for 16 h, leading to bicycle 3 in a 72% overall yield (1.53 g) upon distillation.
Having established one-pot access to 3, we briefly turned our attention to the final aromatization step, in which losses of up to 80–90% (!) in yield are generally incurred. The large quantities of undesired BN-tetralin 4 formed when using the Pd/C-cyclohexene system13b (see Scheme 1) not only divert a large share of the precursor away from the target but also hamper the product purification. Since 4 presumably arises from the shuttling of an H2 molecule between two unsaturated rings in substrate 3 rather than H2 being passed off to the sacrificial acceptor, we wondered whether this side process might be suppressed by uncovering a more efficient H2 acceptor. To put this into practice, the catalytic aromatization of 3 with Pd/C was tested in the presence of a range of olefins (6.5 equiv.) at 70 °C for 24 h (Scheme 3). While simple cyclic and linear olefins still led to significant amounts of undesired 4, the use of norbornene led to BN-naphthalene being formed with an unprecedented 92:8 selectivity (see ESI Fig. S1†). We note that the chemoselectivity of reaction tracks with the enthalpy of hydrogenation (ΔH°) of the acceptor in the order cyclohexene (−28 kcal mol−1) < 1-hexene ≈ t-Bu-ethene (−30 kcal mol−1) < norbornene (−33 kcal mol−1).16
Scheme 3 Evaluation of hydrogen acceptors in the Pd-catalyzed aromatization of 3 to 1. a Conducted in neat olefin acceptor. b Using cyclohexane as solvent. |
Following additional optimization, the aromatization of 3 was conducted at 110 °C in the presence of catalytic Pd/C and 3.5 equiv. of norbornene (neat), affording 1 in an 76% yield, a major improvement over the prior art. The streamlined process was then carried out on a multi-gram (32 mmol) scale (Scheme 4). A neat 1:1 mixture of B(allyl)3 and diallylamine was heated to 65 °C for 16 h; the as-obtained 2 was then diluted with CH2Cl2 and treated with the Grubbs first-generation catalyst to afford 3.1 g of 3 (72% over 2 steps) upon distillation. Finally, the aromatization over Pd/C in norbornene (3.5 equiv.) produced 2.33 g of target BN-naphthalene 1 upon column chromatography (75%), representing an overall yield of 54% based on starting B(allyl)3.
Encouraged by this result, we also sought to extend this approach to substituted bicyclic BN-cores by applying the RCM reaction to more challenging internal alkynes. To this end, doubly arylated precursor 8 was prepared via Sonogashira coupling and subsequently deprotected to dipropargylamine 9 (Scheme 5B). This compound reacted smoothly with B(allyl)3 to afford new aminoborane 10 in good purity. As anticipated, enyne metathesis in this case proved to be more challenging, with initial attempts using the Grubbs first-generation catalyst leading to little-to-no conversion. Nevertheless, we were pleased to find that switching to the more active Grubbs–Hoveyda second-generation catalyst and raising the temperature to 45 °C led to the selective formation of the target bicyclic structure 11, as confirmed by GC-MS and 1H NMR analyses (Scheme 5B).
With the new bis-diene aminoborane 7 in hand, we proceeded to explore double Diels–Alder reaction as a way to access new BN-doped polycyclic cores.18 Our initial test involved heating 7 with 2.4 equiv. of acetylene dicarboxylate (12) as dienophile in toluene at 80 °C (Scheme 6A). After 12 h, the GC-MS analysis of the mixture showed nearly complete consumption of 7 and formation of a new major species with m/z = 355, which would be consistent with the mono Diels–Alder adduct. A small peak with m/z = 525 was also observed, hinting at the possible formation of the target double-Diels–Alder product 13. Fortunately, increasing the amount of dienophile to 4.0 equiv. and temperature to 110 °C led, after 15 h, to the formation of the target tetracyclic aminoborane 13 as the major product (Scheme 6A). We note that given the hydroscopic nature of the product, unequivocal determination of the stereochemistry of the compound (i.e., cis- vs. trans-adduct) via NMR was hampered by the difficult purification of the crude mixture. After a number of unsuccessful attempts, we wondered whether product manipulation might be facilitated by temporary quaternization of the boron atom. The addition of H2O to a solution of crude 13 in Et2O led to the precipitation of hydrate 14 with a B–N bridge present in HN⋯B(OH) form.19 Compound 14 proved to be air-stable and could now be readily purified using reversed-phase (C18) column chromatography or simply by repeated washing.
The clean 1H NMR spectrum of 14 now clearly revealed the presence of a single diastereomer with a symmetry element at the B–N bridge, as evidenced by a single characteristic set of diastereotopic B–CHH signals (0.78 and 0.11 ppm, Jgem = 13.7 Hz), along with a sole olefinic resonance at 5.61 ppm (2H) (see Scheme 6B). Given that the hydrated (H)N–B(OH) bridge precludes the possibility of a C2 symmetry axis, the two halves of bicycle 14 must be related by a mirror symmetry (Cs), which is only possible if 14—and, by extension, 13—is a Diels–Alder cis-adduct. This conclusion was confirmed by single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis of 14, which not only showed the cis-adduct configuration but also revealed the trans disposition of H and OH groups on the hydrated B–N bridge (Scheme 6C).20
At this point, we wondered whether the BN-hydration could be reversed to recover pure adduct 13. Initial attempts to chemically remove the water molecule, including with Burgess reagents, met with little success. However, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of 14 revealed a well-defined endothermic weight loss of ∼3% at 162 °C, in line with the release of a water molecule (Scheme 6D). Translating this knowledge to the preparatory scale, a sample of 14 was heated under vacuum to ∼160 °C, which indeed resulted in the formation of BN-tetracycle 13 in >90% purity. This transformation was accompanied a change in the 11B NMR chemical shift from ∼0.0 ppm for 14 (quaternized borane) to 40 ppm for 13. The latter value is typical for related Bsp2 aminoboranes, including 3 (41.2 ppm) and 7 (40.6 ppm). We believe that this approach, which we dubbed “interim hydration,” may prove useful for the purification of other moisture-sensitive non-aromatic cyclic aminoboranes through temporary protection of the BN unit via the reversible addition of water or other protic agents.
Continuing with our exploration, the double Diels–Alder addition between 7 and maleic anhydride led to the formation of hexa-cyclic species 15, as evidenced by a GC-MS peak with m/z = 381 (Scheme 6E). Although the compound was not isolated, subsequent reaction with H2O led not only to the hydration of the BN bond but also the hydrolytic opening of two anhydride rings. The 1H NMR spectrum of resulting species was complicated by the apparent lack of any symmetry and included two olefinic CH resonances at 5.60 and 5.42 ppm, along with three discernible COOH resonances in the 11–13 ppm region. Fortunately, X-ray-quality crystals of the product could be grown via slow diffusion of Et2O into a MeOH solution.20 The solid-state structure revealed that this lack of symmetry was due to one of the carboxylic acid moieties undergoing condensation with the B–OH group to form a 6-membered mixed B–O–C(O) anhydride ring, resulting in an overall pentacyclic core (16, Scheme 6F). The 3D structure also revealed a trans-endo-endo configuration, indicating that the initial Diels–Alder cycloaddition took place with two dienophile molecules approaching opposing sides of bicyclic precursor 7 in an endo configuration.21
Having successfully applied the newly developed sequence to polycyclic targets 13/14 and 15/16, a number of future applications can now be envisioned. For example, this opens the door to BN isosteres of certain natural polycycles and of course, to the preparation of BN-containing polycyclic aromatic compounds, including access to new BN-tetracenes via 4-fold aromatization. En route to the latter goal, preliminary experiments show that heating 13 with Pd/C in decane (180 °C, 48 h)22 produces new species 17 with aromatized external rings (Scheme 7), as observed from two characteristic 1H NMR doublets at 7.81 and 7.20 ppm. The product was found to be hydroscopic, with 1H NMR spectra typically presenting varying amounts of BN-hydrate, observed as a second set of doublets at 7.66 and 7.16 ppm. Similarly to the isolation of a BN-hydrate shown earlier, purification via reversed-phase column chromatography (C18) produced a mixture of 17 and 17·H2O, which could be fully converted to the rather clean hydrate form (see ESI†) through the addition of water. In line with our interim hydration strategy, the dehydration of 17·H2O at 160 °C under vacuum led to clean 17, which was characterized by a peak with m/z = 522 (M + H, ESI+).23 The 1H NMR spectrum of the product showed, in addition to aforementioned aromatic doublets (2H each), two broad singlets arising from N–CH2 (4.38 ppm, 4H) and B–CH2 (2.28 ppm, 4H) groups of central rings.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2297111 and 2297112. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc06676b |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |