Open Access Article
Mohamed
Alaasar
*ab,
Ahmed F.
Darweesh
b,
Christian
Anders
a,
Konstantin
Iakoubovskii
c and
Masafumi
Yoshio
*cd
aInstitute of Chemistry, Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, 06120 Halle, Germany. E-mail: mohamed.alaasar@chemie.uni-halle.de; malaasar@sci.cu.edu.eg
bDepartment of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Cairo University, 12613 Giza, Egypt
cResearch Center for Macromolecules & Biomaterials, National Institute for Materials Science, 1-2-1 Sengen, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0047, Japan
dJapan Science and Technology Agency, PRESTO, 4-1-8 Honcho, Kawaguchi, Saitama, 332-0012, Japan
First published on 13th November 2023
π-Conjugated molecules are of special interest for designing new materials with potential optoelectronic applications. Herein, we report the synthesis of new functional non-symmetric substituted triple-chain π-conjugated 5,5′-diphenyl-2,2′-bithiophenes. They have a long rod-like aromatic core unit with a 3,5-diheptyloxy substituted-pattern at one end and a single thioalkyl or alkoxy chain with variable length at the other end. Their molecular self-assembly was studied by polarized optical microscopy, differential scanning calorimetry, X-ray diffraction, luminescence and photoconductivity techniques. The shortest homologue forms an isotropic liquid phase with a broken mirror symmetry (Iso1[*]) beside smectic and 3D phases. Longer derivatives have no Iso1[*] or smectic components, and only exhibit 3D phases. The 3D phases are achiral double-gyroid bicontinuous cubic liquid-crystalline (LC) phases with a double helical network structure and Ia
d symmetry. Both the smectic and cubic phases exhibit photoconductivity, photoluminescence (PL), phosphorescence and electroluminescence at temperatures up to 150 °C. The smectic liquid crystals show weaker PL, but stronger photoconductivity; they could be polarized by an applied electric field, which turned a photoresistive device into both a photodiode and a light-emitting diode. Hence this work provides new functional bithiophene-based materials, which could be applied in optoelectronic devices. A prototype of such a device, namely a wavelength-measuring photodetector, is demonstrated.
d (Cubbi/Ia
d), which is composed of two interwoven networks with three-way junctions (Fig. 1a–c);28–31 the other is a triple network structure with the space group I23 (Cubbi/I23[*]) (Fig. 1b).32 In the Cubbi/Ia
d phase, the two interwoven networks have opposite chiralities, and thus the overall structure is achiral.33,34 In contrast, for the Cubbi/I23 phase, the network chirality cannot be cancelled out, and conglomerates of chiral domains are observed; therefore, this phase is marked with an asterisk, [*]. Note that chiral domains were also detected in isotropic liquid phases (Iso1[*]) originating from non-symmetric polycatenars.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Helical network structures of the Cubbi phases (a) the achiral double-gyroid Cubbi/Ia d phase and (b) the chiral Cubbi/I23[*] phase; (c) a schematic of a three-way junction interconnecting three network segments formed by the helical stacking of three molecules in the Cubbi/Ia d and Cubbi/I23[*] phases; (d) development of the helical twist by the clashing of the crowded ends attached to the rod-like aromatic cores in the networks, reproduced from ref. 25 by permission from Wiley. | ||
Sulfur-containing LC materials35–40 exhibit strong birefringence owing to the high polarizability of the sulfur atom41–43 and are of special interest for various applications including liquid crystal displays,44,45 LC lenses,46,47 lasers48 and fast third-order nonlinear switching.49
Recently we have reported the synthesis of non-symmetric [3+1] tetracatenars based on the π-conjugated rod-like 5,5′-diphenyl-2,2′-dithiophene unit terminated with three alkoxy and one thioalkyl chains (compounds Am/n, Scheme 1). We have characterized the structure and LC phases in those polycatenars, but did not investigate their optoelectronic properties and possible applications.19
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Molecular structures of the previously reported tetracatenars Am/n19 (top) and the newly synthesized tricatenars Sn and On series (below). | ||
Herein we report the synthesis and characterization of two new series of related [2+1] tricatenar liquid crystals (compounds Sn and On, Scheme 1 and Scheme S1 in the ESI†). We discuss the effects of the length and structure of the alkyl chains on the LC properties, and, importantly, demonstrate potential applications of these materials in optoelectronic devices.
Luminescence spectra were acquired with an FP-8300 spectrometer (Jasco, Japan) using a built-in Xe lamp filtered by a single-grating monochromator (intensity at the sample ∼10 mW cm−2) for excitation. The same spectrometer was used for spectral electroluminescence (EL) and photoconductivity measurements. Calibrated AM1.5 illumination (100 mW cm−2) was provided by a HAL-C100 Solar Simulator (Asahi Spectrum, Japan). Low-fluorescence silica was used as a sample support for luminescence measurements.
Doping with [6,6]-phenyl C61 butyric acid methyl ester (PCBM) was performed as follows: 5 mg of sample and 0.5 mg of PCBM were dissolved in 1 mL of chloroform, which was then evaporated at 60 °C.
Optoelectronic devices were prepared by filling commercial cells from EHC, Japan. The cells consisted of two glass plates coated with 20 nm of indium tin oxide (ITO). Epoxy spacers separated them by a distance of 2, 4 or 9 μm. The overlapping area between the top and bottom electrodes was 4 × 4 mm. Cells were filled in a vacuum, in darkness, at a temperature ∼5 °C above the isotropic temperature, typically within 1 hour. A small amount of powdered material was placed on the edge of a cell, where it melted, and was driven into the cell by the capillary force.
| Comp. | Phase transitions T/°C [ΔH/kJ mol−1] | a cub/nm (T/°C) |
|---|---|---|
a Peak temperatures as determined by DSC upon 2nd heating (H:) and 2nd cooling (C:) with a rate of 10 K min−1. Abbreviations: Cr = crystalline solid phase; Iso = isotropic liquid phase; Iso1[*] = isotropic liquid phase with spontaneously broken symmetry; SmC = smectic C phase; Cubbi/Ia d = achiral bicontinuous cubic phase with Ia d space group; acub = lattice parameter of the cubic phase.
|
||
| S6 | H: Cr 133 [23.0] SmC 142 [0.5] Cubbi/Ia d 196 [1.5] Iso |
9.9 |
C: Iso 193 [−0.7] Iso1[*] 179 [−1.4] Cubbi/Ia d 138 [<0.1] SmC 108 [−21.7] Cr |
(140) | |
| S8 | H: Cr 128 [34.8] Cubbi/Ia d 196 [2.6] Iso |
10.0 |
C: Iso 187 [−1.9] Cubbi/Ia d 110 [−23.9] Cr |
(140) | |
| S10 | H: Cr 130 [19.3] Cubbi/Ia d 193 [1.7] Iso |
10.1 |
C: Iso 185 [−1.4] Cubbi/Ia d 105 [−18.1] Cr |
(140) | |
| S12 | H: Cr 122 [28.8] Cubbi/Ia d 188 [2.7] Iso |
10.3 |
C: Iso 181 [−2.1] Cubbi/Ia d 104 [−27.3] Cr |
(140) | |
| S14 | H: Cr 113 [29.3] Cubbi/Ia d 183 [1.5] Iso |
10.4 |
C: Iso 176 [−1.3] Cubbi/Ia d 99 [−30.0] Cr |
(130) | |
| S16 | H: Cr 110 [50.5] Cubbi/Ia d 179 [2.4] Iso |
10.6 |
C: Iso 173 [−2.2] Cubbi/Ia d 97 [−45.2] Cr |
(130) | |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 DSC heating and cooling traces for compounds: (a) S6 and (b) S16. The inset in (a) shows an enlarged view of the Iso-Iso1[*]-Cubbi/Ia d transition on cooling. | ||
In the next section the molecular self-assembly of compounds Sn will be discussed, followed by a comparison with related On analogues (Section 3.3). Then we present their optoelectronic properties.
d LC phase is observed in a wide temperature range for all the reported tricatenars, except for S6, which has an additional smectic phase (Fig. 4d and S29). Its birefringent schlieren texture did not convert to a dark one under applied shear, as typically observed in the case of the uniaxial SmA phase. Hence, we assign this texture to the SmC phase, and this assignment agrees with XRD results.
XRD pattern of the birefringent S6 phase shows a single sharp peak at ∼1.8° (4.8 nm) and a broad halo at ∼20° (0.4 nm, Fig. 5a). Upon heating above 142 °C, the halo is preserved, but the low-angle peak shifts and splits into a doublet, which can be indexed to the (211) and (220) reflections of an Ia
d phase with a lattice parameter acub = 9.9 nm (Fig. 5b). This phase is consistent with the absence of chiral domains in the corresponding optical image (Fig. 4c).
The Cubbi/Ia
d phase is the only LC phase exhibited by the S8–S16 homologues, as revealed by the optical textures and the XRD patterns (see Fig. S27 for XRD, ESI†). Its lattice parameter acub = 9.9–10.6 nm (Table 1) is close to those of the previously reported Cubbi/Ia
d phases.17–19 For all members, there is a 6–17 K supercooling of the Iso–Cubbi/Ia
d transition compared to the Cubbi/Ia
d–Iso transition temperature on heating, which is a common feature for 3D cubic LC phases (Table 1).50
d phase is absent for the shortest derivative O6, and only the SmC phase is observed up to the isotropic point (Fig. 6 and S28). The SmC phase in both S6 and O6 could be aligned by unidirectional flow of the molten compound, as demonstrated in Fig. S29 (ESI†).
| Comp. | Phase transitions T/°C [ΔH/kJ mol−1] |
|---|---|
| a Peak temperatures as determined by the DSC upon 2nd heating (H:) and 2nd cooling (C:) scans with a rate of 10 K min−1. | |
| O6 | H: Cr 121 [30.7] SmC 197 [1.4] Iso1[*] 200 [<0.1] Iso |
| C: Iso 198 [<0.1] Iso1[*] 193 [−1.8] SmC 89 [−25.0] Cr | |
| O10 | H: Cr 118 [20.0] Cubbi/Ia d 198 [1.8] Iso |
C: Iso 188 [−1.2] Cubbi/Ia d 81 [−19.3] Cr |
|
| O12 | H: Cr 118 [38.8] Cubbi/Ia d 193 [3.1] Iso |
C: Iso 184 [−2.2] Cubbi/Ia d 86 [−49.2] Cr |
|
| O14 | H: Cr 106 [32.2] Cubbi/Ia d 189 [2.6] Iso |
C: Iso 182 [−2.0] Cubbi/Ia d 89 [−28.5] Cr |
|
Other On compounds exhibit only the Cubbi/Ia
d LC phase, like the Sn series. However, as can be seen from Tables 1, 2 and Fig. 2, 6, the temperature ranges of the Cubbi/Ia
d phase are wider for On than Sn polycatenars. This observation can be explained by the more pronounced bending angle resulting from the replacement of the ether linkage (C–O–C, 114°) with the thioether one (C–S–C, 99°),51 leading to a shift in the molecular shape from nearly rod-like to a more bent configuration. Additionally, this change is accompanied by an increased bond length (C–S, 1.82 nm) compared to C–O (1.45 nm),51 resulting in a decreased rotational barrier around the C–S bond (S–CH3: 8.4 kJ mol−1) compared to that of the C–O bond (O–CH3: 11.3 kJ mol−1).52,53 These combined effects lead to enhanced conformational chain disorder, reducing the stability of the Cubbi/Ia
d phase in the case of thioalkyl-terminated polycatenars (Sn) compared to their alkoxy-terminated counterparts (On).54,55
Comparing the phase behavior of compounds A6/n having three hexyloxy chains to Sn materials having two heptyloxy chains revealed the following: in all cases the melting and crystallization temperatures of A6/n derivatives are lower compared to those of Sn homologues because of the enhanced flexibility introduced by the large number of alkoxy chains in A6/n compounds. Both shortest homologues from the two series (A6/6 and S6) display Cubbi/Ia
d and Iso1[*] phases. However, the SmC phase was only formed by S6 and not by A6/6. This fact could be explained by increased twisting of the whole molecular structure because of the large size of the crowded end in the case of A6/6. Such twisting favored the formation of network phases rather than lamellar phases, such as the SmC phase exhibited by S6. The lattice parameter of the Cubbi/Ia
d phases is similar for Sn derivatives (acub = 9.9–10.6 nm, Table 1) and A6/n analogues (∼10.6 nm). However, tetracatenars exhibit additional three network phases, such as tetragonal and the triple network chiral Cubbi/I23[*] phases, which are not observed in any of Sn derivatives. A further increase in the alkoxy chains length, which was realized in compounds A10/n, leads to the formation of two different types of achiral double gyroid phases separated by the chiral Cubbi/I23[*] phase, and thus an overall phase sequence of Cubbi/Ia
d–Cubbi/I23[*]–Cubbi/Ia
d,19 which is not observed in the case of the newly reported tricatenars (Sn). This fact can be attributed to the smaller chain volume in Sn compounds as compared to the A10/n tetracatenars. Finally, replacing the thioalkyl chain by alkyloxy chain, either in the tricatenars Sn or in the teracatenars A10/n, does not alter the LC phases, and only slightly shifts the phase transition temperatures, as discussed in Section 3.3 and in our previous report.19
The newly reported tricatenars (Sn and On) complete the reported family of nonsymmetric polycatenar materials. In contrast to the (predominantly cubic) tetracatenars, the tricatenars exhibit linear SmC phases that can be aligned by electric field. This property is essential for the potential photoelectronic devices that are described in the following sections. Meanwhile, as demonstrated in Fig. S31 (ESI†), the cubic phases exhibit stronger luminescence compared to smectic phases, which may be important for optical applications.
Filling a symmetrical ITO cell with O6 created a photoresistor exhibiting quasi-symmetrical I–V characteristics and a short-circuit current ISC ∼ 50 nA cm−2 under AM1.5 illumination. This ISC value increased 10 times after poling, a standard procedure in LC transport measurements,56 which involves heating the material from the crystal into the LC phase to induce reorientation of polar fragments in the constituent molecules. The polar fragments in O6, such as carbonyl groups with a dipole moment of ∼3 D, as estimated by density functional theory, underwent reorientation in response to electric field (4 V μm−1 in this case) applied to the device, and cooling the material down into the crystal phase, locked its molecules in the oriented state. Poling transformed the O6-based device from a photoresistor into a photodiode (Fig. 7a). Its photocurrent under AM1.5 illumination was relatively small, presumably due to the weak absorption of visible light by the O6 compound, as evidenced by the photocurrent spectrum shown by the black curve in Fig. 7b.
To increase absorption of visible light in O6, we have doped it with 10 mol% of PCBM. As a result, ISC increased up to 6 μA cm−2 without affecting the phase transitions, as confirmed by temperature-resolved optical microscopy. This enhancement can be attributed to the accepting properties of PCBM and strong absorption in the visible range, which was imparted to the doped O6 sample as seen in Fig. 7b. We have attempted to further increase the ISC through heavier doping, but found, by combined optical and XRD measurements, that PCBM was precipitated at concentrations above 10 mol%.
Devices prepared by flowing O6 into a 4 μm-thick ITO-ITO cell retained their quasi-symmetrical nature even after poling. In particular, the sign of their photocurrent would change depending on the direction and wavelength of illumination. This phenomenon is known as dual-polarity photocurrent.57 It can be explained by a simple band diagram outlined in Fig. 8.
We found that for wavelength ranging from 300 to 700 nm the sign of photocurrent can be controlled by applying a small voltage (within ±0.3 V) to the device. Interestingly, the value of this “control voltage” remained almost constant irrespective of the light intensity within the range 1–10 mW cm−2. As a result, we could estimate the illuminating wavelength, with an accuracy of ±5 nm, by comparing the bias voltage resulting in a zero photocurrent with a calibration curve (depicted as a dashed line in Fig. 9). Although the calibration curve is a non-monotonous function that can have equal values for two different wavelengths (e.g. 0.15 V for 440 and 670 nm), this ambiguity can be resolved by noting the sign of photocurrent, which is positive for 440 nm and negative at 670 nm at the same 0.15 V bias.
Finding a zero-photocurrent bias was achieved with a simple electronic circuit equipped with a feedback loop. Combining this circuit with a photodetector based on the PCBM-doped compound O6, yields a prototype device that can estimate illumination wavelength in the 300–700 nm range without the use of bulky and costly optical dispersive elements.
The black line in Fig. 10a shows a characteristic room-temperature luminescence spectrum from undoped O6 excited at 360 nm. The spectrum consists of two overlapping bands centered at ca. 490 nm and 550 nm. When the luminescence is measured not simultaneously with optically modulated excitation, but after a 1 ms delay, the 490 nm band significantly weakens as compared to the 550 nm emission, indicating that the latter originates from phosphorescence. When emission is excited, in the same sample, not by UV light, but by electric current, only the 550 nm band is observed, and its time dependence under square-pulse excitation shows a lifetime on the order of 1 ms (Fig. 10b). Doping of O6 with 10 mol% of PCBM induces a new EL band at 725 nm, which can be assigned to the emission from PCBM molecules (Fig. 10a). Note that while the spectra of Fig. 10 were measured at room temperature, all the reported phenomena persisted up to at least 150 °C. They can be rationalized as follows: the studied Sn and On compounds exhibit a photoluminescence band at 490 nm and a phosphorescence band at 550 nm, they also exhibit EL at 550 nm, which results from the phosphorescence band. The EL spectrum can be extended from ca. 450–650 nm to 500–850 nm by doping with PCBM.
d symmetry (Cubbi/Ia
d), and an isotropic liquid phase with a broken mirror symmetry (Iso1[*]). Replacing the sulfur with oxygen in the thioalkyl chain retains the cubic LC phases and widens their temperature ranges. Photoconductivity, phosphorescence, and electroluminescence at temperatures up to 150 °C were found in both smectic and cubic phases. A protype of an optoelectronic device (a wavelength-measuring photodetector) was successfully demonstrated. Therefore, this work provides new functional nanostructured materials, which could be applied in optoelectronic devices.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ma00841j |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |