Shiv
Kumar‡
,
Paramita
Datta‡
,
Anup
Bhunia
* and
Swadhin K.
Mandal
*
Department of Chemical Sciences, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research – Kolkata, Mohanpur-741246, India. E-mail: bhunia1998@gmail.com; swadhin.mandal@iiserkol.ac.in
First published on 8th November 2023
Sulfur-containing organic molecules such as sulfones are prevalent in pharmaceuticals and agrochemicals. Herein, we report the first transition-metal-free process for in situ denitrogenation of tosylhydrazones to produce a diverse array of aryl alkyl sulfones. We have used phenalenyl-based odd alternant hydrocarbon as a photoredox catalyst for denitrogenation of tosylhydrazones, where the phenalenyl acts as a potent oxidant to form a sulfinate radical intermediate from a sulfinate anion. We performed radical trapping, in situ electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), and fluorescence quenching studies to elucidate the plausible mechanism. This method shows wide functional-group tolerance, with applications in late-stage modification of various natural products with good to high yields. The protocol provides an easy method for the synthesis of sulfones.
To date, only a few methods have been reported for accessing aryl alkyl sulfones by utilizing tosylhydrazones as the source of the sulfur dioxide unit. In addition, tosylhydrazones are enormously important intermediates in organic synthesis, considering their role as precursors for the in situ synthesis of diazo compounds32–34 and metal carbenoids35,36 in various transition-metal catalyzed XH (X = C, N, O) insertion reactions,37,38 cyclopropanations,39,40etc. In this regard, substantial progress in metal carbenoid intermediates has been demonstrated by the groups of Yu,41 Valdés,42 and Zhao43 using catalysts based on transition metals, such as copper and iron, to access aryl alkyl sulfones via denitrogenation of tosylhydrazones (Scheme 1b, top). More recently, a photocatalytic strategy using an Ir catalyst44 has been developed to achieve denitrogenative sulfonylation of tosylhydrazones to furnish aryl alkyl sulfones (Scheme 1b, bottom). The proposed intermediate of the reaction, a carbene radical cation generated from carbene by a photooxidant, is an elusive intermediate due to the higher electrophilicity of the carbene intermediate. Our investigation began with a search for a transition metal-free alternative for efficient denitrogenation of tosylhydrazones to rapidly access value-added aryl alkyl sulfones. In this regard, we introduce a redox-active phenalenyl-based molecule as a catalyst. For over six decades, the odd alternant hydrocarbon phenalenyl (PLY) has been well-known for its applicability in constructing highly conducting materials based on its neutral radical state,45,46 its ability to act as a spin simulator,47,48 and its applicability in spin electronic devices,49 taking advantage of its easily accessible empty nonbonding molecular orbital (NBMO).50 Over the last decade, our group has successfully developed a number of catalytic redox processes of the PLY system through a chemo-redox pathway under homogeneous51–53 and heterogeneous conditions.54 Furthermore, very recently, our group reported the photochemical55 properties of PLY. In continuation of our program, we further sought to explore the application of PLY systems in photoredox catalysis, in particular for the development of the first transition-metal-free catalytic denitrogenation of tosylhydrazones to synthesize aryl alkyl sulfones.
In this work, we report a transition-metal-free denitrogenative transformation of tosylhydrazones to aryl alkyl sulfones (Scheme 1c). The tosylhydrazone undergoes base-mediated fragmentation to form a sulfinate radical and a (diazomethyl)arene, which eventually undergoes photoinduced denitrogenation to form a transient carbene intermediate. The in situ generated carbene intermediate and sulfinate radical then recombine to deliver the alkyl sulfone molecule. This redox-neutral protocol exhibits broad substrate scope and wide functional-group compatibility, enabling the late-stage modification of complex natural products and biologically active molecules. To probe the reactive intermediates involved in the catalytic steps, a series of investigations, including radical inhibition, trapping of intermediates, in situ electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) studies and steady-state spectroscopic studies, have been performed.
a Reaction conditions: tosylhydrazone (1a) (0.3 mmol, 1 equiv.), PLY(N,O) (5 mol%), K2HPO4 (3 equiv.), DMF (1.5 mL, 0.2 M), for 12 h under blue LED irradiation (456 nm). The yields are determined by 1H-NMR analysis (CDCl3) of crude products using 1,4-dimethoxybenzene as the internal standard. b Isolated yield. |
---|
The simplicity of the direct denitrogenative sulfonylation of tosylhydrazones under transition-metal-free conditions provided us an opportunity to carry out further evaluation of the substrate scope, which revealed broad compatibility and efficiency of the sulfonylation with a wide array of functionalized tosylhydrazones (e.g., 1a–1aa, Scheme 2). Tosylhydrazones bearing electron-donating alkyl and alkoxy groups at the para-position were converted to sulfones (2a–2e) in good to excellent yields (67–82%). Under similar reaction conditions, 3,4-substituted tosylhydrazone (1f) furnished a good isolated yield (66%) of the corresponding substituted sulfone (2f). The standard catalytic reaction protocol was also applicable for the more sterically encumbered 2-methyl tosylhydrazone derivative (1g), which provided a good yield (2g, 58%). Further, we investigated whether the position of the substituents in the tosylhydrazones had any influence on the outcome of the transition-metal-free denitrogenative sulfonylation process. Accordingly, the 3-methyl tosylhydrazone derivative (1h) was treated under identical reaction conditions, and the corresponding sulfone (2h) was isolated in 59% yield. Notably, the 4-phenyl tosylhydrazone derivative (1i), under the optimized reaction conditions, furnished a good yield of the corresponding product (2i, 66%). Polycyclic derivatives were also compatible with this catalytic method, with the alpha-naphthaldehyde- and 9-anthracenecarboxaldehyde-substituted tosylhydrazone derivatives (1j and 1k) producing the corresponding sulfones (2j and 2k) in moderate yields (38–61%). Furthermore, electron-withdrawing substituents at the para-position were also well tolerated, including fluoro (1l), chloro (1m), bromo (1n) and trifluoromethyl (1o) groups, producing moderate to good yields of the corresponding aryl alkyl sulfones (2l–2o, 54–66%). Furthermore, a tosyl hydrazone derivative bearing an electron-withdrawing substituent at the ortho-position (1p) was also well-tolerated (2p, 47%), indicating that the protocol is not particularly sensitive to steric hindrance.
To our delight, the scope of sulfone synthesis can be extended to a wide array of heterocyclic tosylhydrazones. A nitrogenous heterocycle with a pyridine moiety provided the corresponding sulfone (2q) in a moderate yield (45%). Similarly, other heterocyclic motifs can also be readily applied, including benzothiophene (1r), benzofuran (1s), and 5-methyl thiophene (1t) substituted tosylhydrazones, giving moderate to good yields (59–72%). To document the generality of the denitrogentive sulfonylation reaction, we treated tosylhydrazones derived from both cyclic and acyclic ketones, such as tetralone (1u), propiophenone (1v), and benzophenone (1w), under the optimized reaction conditions. All the substrates worked efficiently to derive the desired products (2u–2w) in moderate to good yields (29–53%). In addition, substituent variation at the aryl ring of the sulfonyl partner from neutral (Ph, 1x), to electron rich (OMe, 1y), electron deficient (Cl, 1z), and even heterocyclic compound (quinoline, 1aa) was tolerated well to give the corresponding products in good yields (2x–2aa, 51–67%).
The scope and functional group tolerance of the reaction was further examined with more structurally complex substrates including natural products and active pharmaceutical ingredients (Scheme 2). Notably, a primary aliphatic alcohol, namely a cetyl-alcohol-derived tosylhydrazone (1ab) was also a viable candidate, giving a 57% yield of the corresponding product (2ab). Meanwhile, a (±)-citronellol-derived tosylhydrazone (1ac), with an isolated tri-substituted double bond, remains intact in the final product (2ac), giving a satisfactory yield (65%). Given the importance of diverse natural products, tosylhydrazone (1ad) (derived from piperonyl alcohol, commonly used as an anti-oxidant) delivered a 54% yield of 2ad. In addition, nerol and geraniol-based tosylhydrazones were effectively used in this transformation, and moderate to good yields (2ae and 2af, 66–74%) were obtained. Likewise, a cholesterol-derived tosylhydrazone (1ag) was also a well-tolerated substrate and a moderate yield (43%) of the corresponding sulfone (2ag) was obtained. Further to this, derivatives of biologically relevant nopol and borneol-substituted tosylhydrazones (1ah and 1ai) were also efficiently converted to the corresponding sulfones (2ah and 2ai), highlighting the broad scope of the reaction. Furthermore, the sulfone derivative of a cyclododecanol-derived tosylhydrazone (2aj, 59%) was produced, revealing a straightforward route to biologically important aryl alkyl sulfone derivative. Next, to realize the general applicability of the catalytic protocol, a more inert aliphatic-alcohol-derived tosylhydrazone was explored. In addition to this, tosylhydrazone obtained from 1-adamantanol, treated under the standard reaction conditions, provided a 42% isolated yield of the corresponding product (2ak).
Next, to shed light on the reaction mechanism, a series of control experiments (Scheme 3) and spectroscopic investigations (Fig. 1) were conducted. The in situ deprotonation of 1a in the presence of K2HPO4 resulted in the formation of the diazo intermediate 3 (Scheme 3a), which was characterized by 1H NMR and HRMS.58 This experiment unarguably validates the formation of the diazo fragment in the presence of only base.59,60 Furthermore, during optimization, a carbene insertion product (2a′), was obtained as a minor product (Scheme 3b), which was characterized by NMR (1H, 13C) and HRMS. The formation of 2a′ can be explained by denitrogenation of 3 in the presence of light to generate a carbene,61–63 which undergoes an insertion reaction into the N–H bond of the substrate. Furthermore, for the generation of 2a′ from 1a, the presence of a blue LED and base are sufficient, and it does not require the PLY(N,O) catalyst (see the ESI†). These control experiments suggest that base-mediated formation of the diazo intermediate 3 triggers light-induced in situ carbene generation, which does not require the presence of the catalyst.
In addition, the use of the radical acceptor diphenylethylene (4) with 1a under standard reaction conditions provided the desired product 2a in <5% yield along with the sulfinate-radical-trapped product 5 (Scheme 3c), which was detected via HRMS [m/z 337.1262 (observed), 337.1262 (expected)]. This observation suggests the generation of a sulfinate radical during the PLY(N,O)-catalyzed denitrogenative sulfonylation reaction. Moreover, the formation of 2a was completely suppressed in the presence of 2.0 equivalents of TEMPO, which hinted at a radical-mediated pathway. The TEMPO-trapped hydrazone-tethered O-benzylhydroxylamine (6) was formed via a benzyl carbenoid (Scheme 3d),64 which was detected by 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy, as well as HRMS [m/z 570.2762 (observed), 570.2766 (expected)]. Furthermore, a cross-over experiment with substrate 1a and benzenesulfinic acid sodium salt 7 under the standard conditions led to the formation of alkyl sulfones 2a and 2u in a 1:4.3 ratio, suggesting the sulfinate anion was oxidized in the presence of the PLY to form the sulfinate radical and the reaction proceeded via a stepwise mechanism (Scheme 3e).
Next, isotope-labelling studies were performed to investigate the hydrogen source of the product. First, denitrogenative sulfonylation of tosylhydrazone 1a was examined under standard reaction conditions in the presence of DMSO-d6 as the solvent, yet no deuterium was incorporated (see the ESI†). However, the monodeuterated product 2a-d along with 2a were formed in a ratio of 1:3 in the presence of CD3OD (see the ESI† for details). This result indicates that CD3OD provides a proton at the benzylic position of sulfone 2a in the photocatalytic reaction (see the ESI†). Along this line, when D-containing 1a-d was used under the optimized conditions, 2a-d and 2a were formed in a ratio of 3:7 (Scheme 3f).
Next, we focused on the spectroscopic investigations of PLY by performing further control experiments. A mixture of PLY(N,O) and sulfinate (in DMF at 77 K) in the absence of light irradiation remains EPR-silent. However, after blue-LED illumination, a sharp signal was observed in the EPR spectrum with g = 1.996, which supports the generation of a PLY radical anion55,65 (Fig. 1a and b). These observations demonstrate a photoinduced electron transfer (PET) between sodium p-toluenesulfinate and the photoexcited state of PLY(N,O). This is further corroborated by an in situ absorption experiment of sodium sulfinate and PLY(N,O) under light irradiation (456 nm) for different time intervals (Fig. 1c). The absorption peaks corresponding to free PLY(N,O) undergo a sharp decline in intensity over time, followed by the appearance of a new band in the region of 550–650 nm, consistent with the generation of PLY-based radical species.55 This finding indicates the interaction between sodium sulfinate and PLY(N,O) upon irradiation, resulting in a PET from sodium sulfinate to the excited state of PLY(N,O), forming the PLY-based radical anion. Furthermore, Stern–Volmer quenching experiments (Fig. 1d) revealed that sodium p-toluenesulfinate (8) could quench the excited state of PLY(N,O) with a much higher rate constant in comparison to other reagents, such as a diazo compound, 1a and K2HPO4 (see the ESI† for details). These results suggest that the reaction proceeds through a reductive quenching process, in which the sulfinate anion undergoes oxidation by the photoexcited state of PLY(N,O). Finally, the quantum yield determination (Φ = 0.14) for this model denitrogenative sulfonylation reaction of tosylhydrazones disproved a chain mechanism (see the ESI† for details).
Based on the above experiments, a plausible mechanism is depicted in Scheme 4. The deprotonation of 1a in the presence of K2HPO4 takes place to produce nitrogen anion intermediate 9 followed by desulfonylation to provide sulfinate anion 10 and diazo intermediate 3.58 Next, in the presence of light, denitrogenation of intermediate 3 affords the corresponding carbene intermediate 12.62 In addition, light irradiation promotes PLY(N,O) to the excited state, which then oxidizes sulfinate anion 10, through a PET process, generating PLY(N,O)˙− and sulfinate radical intermediate 11. The resulting sulfinate radical intermediate 11 combines with 12, generating the benzylic radical species 13. The benzyl radical of intermediate 13 has been trapped with TEMPO and the corresponding mass of the compound was detected by HRMS (see the ESI† for details). In the next step, single electron transfer from the reduced PLY(N,O)˙− to intermediate 13 produces benzyl anion 14. Finally, the protonation of anion 14 furnishes the desired aryl alkyl sulfone product 2a.
The synthetic utility of the aryl alkyl sulfones has been demonstrated by deuterium labelling of the active methylene group (2a-d2). In addition, the dichloro-substituted sulfone 15 has been derived from 2a using hexachloroethane. Both reactions proceed via the base-induced deprotonation and substitution of two protons of the active methylene group. Moreover, the active methylene position has been functionalized with an aldehyde to form the β-hydroxy sulfone derivative 16 with a moderate yield and diastereoselectivity. Activated aryl alkyl sulfones are well-known reagents for vinylation reactions. Treatment of sulfone 2a with benzyl alcohol in the presence of a strong base, namely NaH, resulted in the formation of stilbene 17 (see the ESI†) (Scheme 5).
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3cy01194a |
‡ PD and SK contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |