Shengyao
Chen‡
ab,
Jiyou
Jin‡
b,
Wenxiang
Wang‡
b,
Shu
Wang
b,
Xiaoshan
Du
b,
Feng
Wang
cd,
Lijun
Ma
b,
Junqi
Wang
b,
Cong
Wang
*e,
Xinzheng
Zhang
*a and
Qian
Liu
*ab
aMOE Key Laboratory of Weak-Light Nonlinear Photonics, TEDA Institute of Applied Physics, School of Physics, Nankai University, Tianjin 300457, China. E-mail: zxz@nankai.edu.cn; liuq@nanoctr.cn
bCAS Center for Excellence in Nanoscience, National Center for Nanoscience and Technology &University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China
cCAS Key Laboratory of Nanosystem and Hierarchical Fabrication, National Center for Nanoscience and Technology, Beijing 100190, China
dCenter of Materials Science and Optoelectronics Engineering, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
eCollege of Mathematics and Physics, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, China. E-mail: wangcongphysics@mail.buct.edu.cn
First published on 17th August 2024
Two-dimensional materials and their van der Waals heterostructures have emerged as a research focal point for constructing various innovative electronic devices due to their distinct photonic and electronic properties. Among them, anti-ambipolar devices, characterized by their unique nonlinear electrical behavior, have garnered attention as novel multifunctional components, positioning them as potential contenders for building multi-state logic devices. Utilizing the properties of few-layer As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2, we have constructed an anti-ambipolar heterojunction device. At 300 K, the device exhibits a peak voltage (Vpeak) of −3 V and a peak-to-valley ratio (PVR) close to 8 × 103, and the PVR can be modulated by bias voltage. Furthermore, by characterizing the anti-ambipolar attributes at different temperatures ranging from 80 K to 330 K, we have elucidated the thermally tunable feature of the device. At 330 K, a certain PVR (∼103) and a large Vpeak (∼−16 V) are obtained, while a PVR exceeding 108 has been achieved at 80 K. This temperature-related sensitivity empowers the device with significant potential and thermal tunability in various applications.
However, to date, the comprehension of the mechanism behind anti-ambipolar behaviors remains the main requirement for in-depth and extended investigation,21 and although recent studies have begun to explore the temperature-dependent anti-ambipolar characteristics,31,32 there remains a lack of comprehensive research on ambipolar behavior across a wide temperature range. Specifically, the influence of temperature on the PVR from 77 K to 330 K has not been thoroughly investigated. Additionally, the design and fabrication of appropriate anti-ambipolar field-effect transistor (FET) devices using vdWHs pose a huge challenge, thereby impeding the advancement of logic devices founded on this distinctive characteristic.21,33–35 Recently, arsenic phosphorus (As0.4P0.6), a material synthesized from ultrapure gray arsenic and red phosphorus,36–38 has attracted more attention. As0.4P0.6 with high carrier mobility and a narrow bandgap of about 0.36 eV typically exhibits p-type behavior. This is a suitable material for building devices, inspired by black phosphorus (BP)-based FETs.39,40 Also, palladium diselenide (PdSe2) is an emerging air-stable n-type dominant 2D material, with high room temperature mobility and a widely tunable bandgap (0.03–1.3 eV).41–43 Considering band alignment and material properties, As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2 are suitable materials for constructing p–n heterojunctions and probable anti-ambipolar devices.
In this study, we have presented an anti-ambipolar device built upon the vdWH composed of As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2. Our research demonstrates the realization of high-performance thermally tunable anti-ambipolar devices, where the drain is implemented using As0.4P0.6, the source employs PdSe2, and the heterojunction area serves as the channel. At room temperature, a PVR of ∼8 × 103 and a peak voltage (Vpeak) of −3 V can be attained. In particular, we uncover the thermally tunable sensitivity of the anti-ambipolar device, which can be used to finely tune the PVR and Vpeak of the device via the temperature. At low temperature, we achieved a PVR exceeding 108. Furthermore, as the temperature reached 330 K, the anti-ambipolar characteristics were suppressed to a certain degree. Our work presents a heterojunction device fabricated using the previously unreported combination of As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2, aiming to contribute to the field of anti-ambipolar devices. We believe that the distinctive behavior observed in the PdSe2/As0.4P0.6 heterojunction, particularly its thermally tunable anti-ambipolar characteristics, offers valuable insights and potential applications in multifunctional device design.
An optical microscope (OM) image of the fabricated device is shown in Fig. 1b; the white dashed frame outlines the PdSe2 and the red dashed frame outlines the As0.4P0.6. Raman characterizations of PdSe2, As0.4P0.6, and the heterojunction area (PdSe2 as the top layer) are shown in Fig. 1c. The A1g–B11g, A2g, B21g, and A3g modes of the PdSe2 are positioned at 143, 206, 222, and 256 cm−1, respectively. Furthermore, the three peaks of As0.6P0.4 at 253, 349, and 430 cm−1 correspond to the A1g, B2g, and A2g modes, respectively. The characteristic peaks of both PdSe2 and As0.4P0.6 can be seen in the Raman spectra of the heterojunction, indicating that As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2 remain unchanged after the formation of the heterojunction. Fig. 1d shows an AFM image of the heterojunction, measured along the white dashed lines in Fig. 1d, respectively. Thicknesses of 8.38 nm and 4.03 nm were obtained for the few-layers of As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2, respectively, as shown in Fig. 1e and f.
Utilizing heavily doped silicon as the back gate, individual characterization of the transfer curves for PdSe2 and As0.4P0.6 was conducted, as depicted distinctly in Fig. 2a, prior to measuring the electrical properties of the heterojunction. The transfer characteristics obtained reveal that the current through As0.4P0.6 augments concomitantly with increasing negative gate voltages, indicative of its p-type behavior. On the other hand, the current of PdSe2 exhibits an inclination to increase in response to both positive and negative gate voltages, with a minimum current manifesting at a gate voltage of −30 V, which corresponds to the OFF state and unequivocally signifies a preponderance of n-type dominant ambipolar behavior. The output characteristics of PdSe2 and As0.4P0.6 under diverse bias voltages are respectively illustrated in Fig. S3 and S4 (ESI†), evincing an absence of pronounced rectification. This suggests that the contact potential barrier between the electrode and the material is minimal, ensuring that the electrical tests can accurately reflect the intrinsic properties of the materials. Based on the p–n behavior exhibited by the two materials, the As0.4P0.6 side is designated as the drain electrode, while the PdSe2 side serves as the source electrode.
Fig. 2b shows the transfer characteristics of the device under several forward biases, manifesting pronounced anti-ambipolar properties. When the gate voltage is below −30 V, the device is primarily in the OFF state. With increasing gate voltage, the current gradually increases under a constant bias. When the gate voltage is over the Vpeak (∼−3 V), the current exhibits a decreasing trend that is similar to negative differential conductance. It is observed that as the bias voltage increases from 0.2 V to 2 V, the magnitude of the current decline also increases, showing increasingly prominent anti-ambipolar properties. The mapping plot of this phenomenon is clearly illustrated in Fig. 2c. To further investigate the current variation within the gate voltage range of −30 to 20 V, the PVR is calculated by taking the ratio of the maximum and minimum currents. The resulting PVR curve demonstrates a monotonically increasing trend, and the PVR can reach a maximum of approximately 8 × 103 at a bias voltage of 1.8 V, showing the high performance of the anti-ambipolar characteristic at room temperature.
The transfer curve, demonstrating an analogous negative differential transconductance phenomenon, has engendered our focal interest. Fig. 3a illustrates the transfer curve at Vds = 0.5 V. The transfer curve can be divided into four regions. In region I, the back gate voltage is less than −40 V, and the PdSe2 channel is depleted, which results in the minimum drain current and indicates that the device is fully turned off. In region II, the back gate voltage is about −40 to −10 V, the bias current starts to be dominated by the PdSe2 channel, and the holes in As0.4P0.6 and the electrons in PdSe2 are gradually accumulated and participate in the current transport, leading to the ON-state in the entire p–n junction. In region III, the back gate voltage is about −10 to 15 V, and it is partially pinched off due to the depletion of electron carriers in the As0.4P0.6 channel being much faster than the increase in the PdSe2 channel, causing the decrease in overall channel current. On the other hand, the whole device cannot be completely turned off because of the small band gap (0.326 eV) of As0.4P0.6 and the strong capacitance screening effect, which is similar to that in BP.44 This phenomenon leads to the device having two OFF-states, and the ON/OFF ratios are about 104 and 102, respectively. In region IV, the back gate voltage is over 15 V, the PdSe2 channel regains dominance and the current in both channels starts to increase. In conclusion, the transfer curve can be modulated by the gate voltage.
The energy band diagrams of this heterojunction under gate voltage are shown in Fig. 3b. The band diagram of PdSe2/As0.4P0.6/SiO2/Si before contact is shown in Fig. S5 (ESI†), showing a type-II band alignment between As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2. The energy positions of the valence and conduction band are referred from previous reports.36,45,46 The gate voltage can provide the unique behavior by controlling the bending of the energy band in the channel region. When the forward gate voltage is less than −40 V and the bias is forward, both As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2 are p-type, with their Fermi levels close to the valence band, the barrier formed at the interface between As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2 hinders the hole transport, resulting in the device being in an almost completely OFF state. As the gate voltage is increased, PdSe2 transitions to n-type, and the Fermi levels are close to the conduction band. The energy band of PdSe2 bends upwards and the energy band of As0.4P0.6 is pulled downwards, reducing the barrier between the two materials. Under forward bias, electrons transfer from PdSe2 to As0.4P0.6, while holes transfer from As0.4P0.6 to PdSe2, resulting in an increase in current. However, when the gate voltage exceeds −10 V, although the energy bands of As0.4P0.6 continue to pull downwards, further reducing the barrier and allowing electrons to transfer from PdSe2 to As0.4P0.6, the holes in As0.4P0.6 are rapidly depleted as the gate voltage increases. This significant reduction in hole transfer from As0.4P0.6 to PdSe2 results in a decrease in current. When the gate voltage increases to exceed 15 V, as the energy bands of As0.4P0.6 continue to be pulled downwards, a type-I heterojunction is formed, allowing a substantial number of electrons to transfer from PdSe2 to As0.4P0.6, leading to an increase in current. With increasing gate voltage, the current of the device initially increases and reaches a peak at Vg = −10 V and then decreases, demonstrating obvious anti-ambipolar behavior. Here the band alignment between As0.4P0.6 and PdSe2 has a shift with a change in gate voltage and thereby regulates the transport of electrons and holes within the heterojunction, which is crucial to the anti-ambipolar behavior.
To further understand the transport of the PdSe2/As0.4P0.6 heterojunction device, the electrical transport was also investigated at different temperatures and different directional drain biases. Fig. 3c shows the Ids–Vds curves on a semilog coordinate at low temperatures when a 2 V forward bias is applied. It can be noted from the curves that the gate voltage control of the band bending is still present at low temperatures and that the gate voltage of the device in the OFF state increases as the temperature decreases. The two OFF-state voltages of the anti-ambipolar increase from −40 V and 20 V at 300 K to −35 V and 45 V at 140 K, respectively. At temperatures below 100 K, there will be no PdSe2 channel-dominated electron transport, and the current will not increase again after the gate voltage has increased to the threshold, as the thermionic emission is completely suppressed. Considering the different electrical transport behavior after complete suppression of thermionic emission,47 the devices were warmed up to further investigate the effect of thermionic emission on the devices. As shown in Fig. 3d, when the temperature of the device rises to 330 K, it is obvious that the current change resulting from the gate voltage modulation of the band bending disappears. It is thought that as the gate voltage pulls the valence band of the As0.4P0.6 near the PdSe2 conduction band, the drain current is maintained rather than falling rapidly due to the strong hot electron emission, which suppresses the ambipolar characteristics.
Fig. 3e shows mapping of the Ids at 140 K for the device as functions of Vg and Vds. This mapping diagram clearly illustrates that the band bending can be regulated by gate voltage at 140 K to produce two OFF-states at Vg < −40 V and 40 V < Vg < 60 V, and can return to an open state again at higher gate voltages, making this anti-ambipolar characteristic well-suited for the fabrication of logic devices such as inverters. In Fig. 3f, Ids mapping at 330 K, shows the disappearance of the second OFF-state and the reduction in the range of the first OFF-state as the device warms up, indicating that at 330 K the device is only in the OFF-state when the gate voltage is about 40 V, demonstrating flexibility in the construction of multifunctional devices.
To gain a more profound comprehension of the anti-ambipolar characteristics of the device, the study of the device at different temperatures is further investigated, as shown in Fig. 4a. At Vg = 2 V, the anti-ambipolar properties exhibit pronounced temperature dependence, notably manifested in the discernible shift of Vpeak. At 300 K, the Vpeak stands at −3 V. As temperature decreases, the Vpeak experiences a slight augmentation, reaching 20 V at 80 K. Conversely, with rising temperature, the Vpeak undergoes a declining trend, eventually reaching −16 V at 330 K. This phenomenon shows potential for the construction of multifunctional logic devices. However, at temperatures exceeding 300 K, the peak current (Ipeak) depicted in the transfer curve registers a decrease compared to the low-temperature regime. Considering the varying OFF-state currents at different temperatures, further characterization of the PVR across different temperature conditions is presented in Fig. 4b. Notably, as the temperature descends to 80 K, an exceptionally high PVR surpassing 108 is attained. This signifies an unprecedentedly high PVR value, emphasizing the outstanding performance of the device. Even at temperatures around 330 K, the PVR remains consistently above 103, reflecting the ability of the anti-ambipolar device to maintain excellent performance at higher temperatures.21 At low temperatures, thermally excited carriers are suppressed, resulting in an extremely high PVR. As the temperature increases, thermal excitation leads to more carriers being excited from the valence band to the conduction band, increasing the carrier concentration. Consequently, more electrons and holes participate in conduction, which may increase the device's current. Additionally, the carrier mobility increases with rising temperature, further enhancing the device's conductivity. These factors may contribute to a reduction in PVR. As for Vpeak, the increased carrier concentration and mobility at higher temperatures reduce the voltage required to reach the peak value. Vpeak and PVR, as two critical parameters for evaluating anti-ambipolar devices, exhibit robust performance across a wide temperature range. Notably, the changes in Vpeak and PVR with temperature are inversely related, enabling precise control of the device's Vpeak and PVR by adjusting the temperature. This allows for flexible modulation of the anti-ambipolar behavior. These characteristics indicate that it is possible to modulate the PVR and Vpeakvia temperature adjustments, and thus achieve a degree of thermal tunability of the anti-ambipolar behavior, which offers new avenues for the design of multifunctional logic circuits.
When the gate voltage is −40 V, the device is in the OFF state and exhibits reverse rectification. As the gate voltage increases, the reverse rectification effect gradually decreases, as shown in Fig. 4c. At a gate voltage of −20 V, the device changes from reverse to forward rectification. When the gate voltage is at 10–20 V, gate voltage regulation of the band bending reduces the forward bias current from 10−6 A to 10−7 A. With a further increase in gate voltage, the reverse current gradually increases due to the dominance of the current generated by hot electron emission, and the device again shows a tendency toward reverse rectification. Fig. 4c shows the relationship between the corresponding rectification ratios and the gate voltage, which implements the conversion between reverse and forward rectifications.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4cp02937b |
‡ These authors contributed equality to this work. |
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2024 |