Liya
Thurakkal
a and
Mintu
Porel
*ab
aDepartment of Chemistry, Indian Institute of Technology Palakkad, Palakkad, Kerala, India
bEnvironmental Sciences and Sustainable Engineering Center, Indian Institute of Technology Palakkad, Kerala 678557, India. E-mail: mintu@iitpkd.ac.in
First published on 22nd November 2022
A novel class of organic polymer (OP) with customizable functional groups in the backbone and side-chain was designed and synthesized to remove toxic Hg2+ ions from contaminated water within 30 seconds using a simple spin column technique. The two-step synthetic strategy, which takes only one hour to synthesize a pure polymer from low-cost starting materials, effectuate in use for real-world applications. By changing the backbone and side-chain functional groups, their physical, chemical, thermal, morphological, and porous properties were tuned. The key functional group ‘dithiocarbamate’ was strategically incorporated in the polymeric backbone to remove toxic Hg2+. From the screening of synthesized materials, one candidate was effective in removing 99.9% Hg2+ ions from a wide range of contamination (5–400 ppm) via adsorption. By spin column technique, Hg2+ ions were removed in 30 s. The material was completely recyclable and thus reusable up to three cycles. It was also effective in purifying contaminated real water samples, including lake water and tap water. Taken together, this class of material has the potential to be exploited as an economically friendly candidate for various environmental related problems by tuning the structure as per the prerequisites for the application.
Water impactThere is a perpetual need of materials for the effective removal of highly toxic mercuric ions from contaminated water with a balance between performance, economy and labour costs. This work reports a class of material that can be synthesized quickly and can efficiently remove mercury using a novel adsorptive separation technique (spin column) within 30 seconds even from real water samples. |
15–19 and by gas storage20–22 due to their high adsorption capacity. Hyper-crosslinked polymers, polymers of intrinsic microporosity, covalent organic framework, conjugated microporous polymer, porous aromatic framework etc. included in the family of OP.23 When compared with similar advanced materials such as the metal–organic framework or natural adsorbent materials, OP is superior in various properties, among which functionalization and tuneability are of paramount importance. The tunable functionalization of a material is an indispensable property when dealing with the use of materials for multiple applications. The scope of tunable functionalization of the material aids in modulating the physical and chemical properties of the material based on the requirement for application. Motivated by this, we have developed a novel class of OP that has access to tuning its physical, chemical, thermal and mechanical properties via customizing on-demand functional groups in both the backbone and side-chain. This class of material is stable and insoluble in water, and thereupon can be widely exploited for the decontamination of water.
The advanced technologies and industrial development for human perks have harmed the environment, causing air and water to be polluted with toxic heavy metals. Mercury has acute toxic effects that seriously harm the central nervous system, cardiovascular system24 and can cause congenital disabilities25 when exposed to its metallic and ionic forms. Mercury existence in air, water and soil is classified mainly in three forms: (i) metallic mercury or elemental mercury (Hg0), (ii) inorganic mercury (Hg+ and Hg2+), and (iii) organic mercury (methyl or ethyl mercury). The environmental condition is also a factor of mercuric forms. In oxidation conditions, HgCl42− and HgOH− prevail. Moreover, in reduction conditions, sulphur forms dominate (HgS2− and CH3HgS−) and alkyl forms exist in intermediate conditions. Unlike other toxic heavy metals, mercuric ions form methylmercury biochemically, which is highly toxic and easily absorbed by the body, even causing death.26 Hence, it is highly recommended to remove mercuric ions before conversion to methylmercury. Chemical precipitation,27 electrolysis,28 ion exchange method29etc. are a few techniques to remove mercury. Adsorption by physical and chemical methods is an easily accomplishable and cost-effective method for metal removal.30 MOFs are suitable for easy modification, greater recyclability and selectivity, and effective adsorption, but they have low or moderate stability. At the same time, COFs have limited modification ability even though they have good adsorption, improved stability, and sensitivity.31 In comparison, OP offers high removal capacity, tunable surface area and pore size, room for modifications for various structural changes, stability, and so on.32 The most important property of a material for use in a real-world application is balancing the cost and activity. A material with all of these properties is still a long-term goal in polymer and material chemistry, and our system is on its way to achieve this.
The soft-soft interaction between sulphur and mercury resulted in many thiol-functionalized materials for mercury removal. Porous materials with high surface area and high mercury uptake capacity were reported.33,34 These materials showed good removal properties, which was worth the comparatively tedious synthetic approach and the presence of a harmful thiol group. Herein, we put forth a de novo, fast, two-step, cost-effective and less laborious strategy to synthesize functionalized OP, which can effectively remove toxic mercury ions up to 99.9% in 30 seconds. Unlike other removal systems, dithiocarbamate esters have been functionalized in the polymer's backbone to interact with Hg2+ ions. A unique advantage of these systems is that a wide range of functional groups can be incorporated in both the backbone and side-chain to generate the material with on-demand property based on any required application. This material is an example of a functionally tunable organic polymer, which can be used as a highly efficient and rapid mercury removal system for fast, low-cost and large-scale production.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Two-step synthesis of DTC-OPs (DMF: N,N-dimethyl formamide, RT: room temperature, PEG: polyethylene glycol). | ||
Interestingly, the polymerization worked well when the substituents on the N atom of the diamine is an aromatic group, which could be attributed to the ease of polymer formation due to the probable alignment of the monomeric units by pi-pi interaction. At the same time, the second reaction was more versatile such that any alkyl, aryl or hydrogen substituted diamines can be utilized based on the property required. Therefore, the pendant functional groups (R1, Scheme 1) to synthesize the chloroacetylated diamide were considered as benzyl and naphthyl. Meanwhile, hydrogen, methyl and benzyl were the functional groups in the diamine (R2, Scheme 1) used in the polymerization reaction. These amines can be of different lengths, so the polymer's chain length and other properties will differ. An important functional moiety, dithiocarbamate (DTC), was also strategically tailored to the OP for various applications in material and biomedical sciences.27,35–37 For the proof-of-concept, we have synthesized four polymers with varying side-chain functional groups and monomeric chain lengths (Fig. 1). DTC-OP1 and DTC-OP2 were obtained as powders, whereas DTC-OP3 and DTC-OP4 turned out to be a gummy elastic material, which became glassy in nature after drying them in a hot air oven at 100 °C. This glassy material was powdered using a mortar and pestle for further studies (Fig. S3†).
The material characterization was carried out by infrared (IR) spectroscopy, 1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and energy dispersive X-Ray analysis (EDAX). In the IR spectroscopy, the formation of the products was confirmed by the appearance of new peaks in the vicinity of 1050 and 1100 cm−1, which were absent in the starting material (Fig. 2a). These peaks are attributed to the symmetric and asymmetric stretching of thiocarbonyls. The product also showed characteristic peaks at 2923 cm−1 (stretching, C–H), 1640 cm−1 (stretching, amide C
O) and 1435 cm−1 (stretching, C–N) (Fig. 2a). The peak of C–Cl present at 550 cm−1 in the starting material was also absent in the products, confirming the formation of the material. 1H NMR also confirmed the formation of products by the appearance of signals corresponding to the protons present in the material (Fig. 2b). The EDAX data provided the ratio of each element present in the material, confirming the given DTC-OPs (Fig. S4–S7†). Elemental analysis was also carried out, and it was observed that the% composition matches with the calculated% with a few deviations (Table S1†).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 a) IR spectrum of the starting material and DTC-OP. b) Stacked 1H-NMR (400 MHz, DMSO-d6) of DTC-OP. | ||
The porous nature of the materials was studied by nitrogen sorption analysis, and the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area at 77 K was calculated from the isotherm obtained in physisorption analysis. Pore volume and average pore size distribution were also calculated from the analysis (Table 1). It was found that the order of the surface area of the materials is as follows: DTC-OP1 (91.49 m2 g−1) > DTC-OP4 (35.83 m2 g−1) > DTC-OP2 (27.20 m2 g−1) > DTC-OP3 (10.41 m2 g−1). The isotherm of all of the synthesized materials showed a hysteresis loop that indicated the hierarchical porosity. The nitrogen sorption isotherm of DTC-OP1, which showed the highest surface area and highest pore size distribution by non-local density functional theory (NLDFT), is given in Fig. 3 and in Fig. S8–S10† for other materials. It could be observed that these nanoporous materials contain maximum pores of the size 2 nm. At the same time, they also possess pores of the size ranging from 2 nm to 15 nm. This hierarchical porosity provides better reachability of the adsorbing material towards the chelating sites. The hierarchical porous nature of the materials was evident from the scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis. The SEM image of DTC-OP1 and DTC-OP2 differed from the SEM image of DTC-OP3 and DTC-OP4 (Fig. S11†). As mentioned above, the appearances of the former DTC-OPs were different. Thus, the morphological study by SEM appeared distinctive. The powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) studies of the former and latter sets of materials also showed variation. The powder samples of DTC-OP1 and DTC-OP2 appeared to be semicrystalline in nature, whereas the glassy materials of DTC-OP3 and DTC-OP4 appeared to be absolutely amorphous in nature (Fig. S12†). The above results indicate that different physical properties were obtained by modulating the pendant functional group and monomeric chain lengths of the materials.
| Material | BET surface area (m2 g−1) | Pore volume (cc g−1) | Pore size (nm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| DTC-OP1 | 91.492 | 0.0719 | 1.7055 |
| DTC-OP2 | 27.198 | 0.0414 | 3.114 |
| DTC-OP3 | 10.406 | 0.0137 | 2.508 |
| DTC-OP4 | 35.828 | 0.0375 | 2.173 |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 a) Nitrogen sorption isotherm of DTC-OP1 at 77 K. The solid shapes represent adsorption, and the hollow shapes represent desorption. b) NLDFT pore size distribution of DTC-OP1. | ||
The thermal properties of the materials were studied by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). From the TGA, it was observed that the materials were stable up to 214 °C to 246 °C based on their structure (Fig. 4). The glass transition temperature (Tg) of each DTC-OP was calculated from DSC analysis, and DTC-OP1 showed the highest Tg of 177.9 °C followed by DTC-OP2 (137.5 °C). DTC-OP3 and DTC-OP4 indicated their distinctiveness by the lower Tg values (Fig. S13†) of 121.9 °C and 123.2 °C, respectively, as expected. Unlike the other reported OP, the synthesized DTC-OP3 and DTC-OP4 exhibited an elastic property before drying. To explore the elastic property of these materials for various applications, the storage modulus and loss modulus of these materials were calculated. It was found that these exhibited suitable elastic properties (Fig. S14†).
The mercury existence in air, water and soil is classified mainly in three forms: (i) metallic mercury or elemental mercury (Hg0), (ii) inorganic mercury (Hg+ and Hg2+), (iii) organic mercury (methyl or ethyl mercury). The environmental condition is also a factor of mercuric forms, such that in oxidation conditions, HgCl42− and HgOH− prevail. Meanwhile, in reduction conditions, the sulphur forms dominates (HgS2− and CH3HgS−) and the alkyl forms exist under intermediate conditions.38 The dithiocarbamate (DTC) units in the backbone and the porosity of the materials were utilized for the removal of Hg2+ ions from the contaminated water samples. The soft–soft interaction between the sulfur in the DTC with Hg2+ ions brings up the ions towards the material, and their porous nature aids in the accessibility of the ions towards the chelating sites. Preliminary screening of the adsorption study was carried out with all the synthesized materials with 5 mg of the adsorbent and 400 ppm Hg2+ solutions. It was observed that DTC-OP2 showed the highest uptake of Hg2+ from the solutions, followed by removing 99.9% of Hg2+ as measured by inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES) (Table 2). Even though DTC-OP1 showed the highest BET surface area, the highest removal was showcased by DTC-OP2, which may be ascribed to the largest pore size of DTC-OP2 compared to the other materials (Table 1). DTC-OP1 showed the lowest uptake of Hg2+ (41.8%) at this given concentration, which also showed the smallest pore size in the physisorption experiment. Thus, DTC-OP2 was set as the best material among the four for the effective removal of Hg2+-containing water samples, and further studies were carried out with this material.
| Material | Mass of the material taken (mg) | Volume of the Hg2+ solution taken (ml) | Concentration of the Hg2+ solution used (ppm) | Concentration of the Hg2+ solution after adsorption (ppm) | Uptake capacity (mg g−1) | % removal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DTC-OP1 | 5 | 4 | 400 | 232.8 | 133.76 | 41.80 |
| DTC-OP2 | 5 | 4 | 400 | 0.286 | 319.77 | 99.92 |
| DTC-OP3 | 5 | 4 | 400 | 182.92 | 173.66 | 54.27 |
| DTC-OP4 | 5 | 4 | 400 | 122.44 | 222.05 | 69.39 |
The experimental set-up for the Hg2+ removal was prepared relatively simpler such that a mere stirring of the contaminated water with the material resulted in the removal of the toxic ions from the water. Adsorption analysis was carried out with the best material DTC-OP2 at various concentrations of Hg2+ ranging from 50 ppm to 800 ppm. The uptake capacity corresponding to each concentration was calculated. The uptake capacity increased linearly up to 500 ppm and was saturated at 800 ppm (Fig. 5a). Thus, the maximum uptake capacity was 413.7 mg g−1, outperforming many reported materials. The removal capacity was revealed to be 99.9%, and the instrument sensitivity did not permit to measure beyond that (Fig. 5b). The obtained data were fitted with the Langmuir adsorption isotherm by non-linear fitting with a correlation coefficient = 0.999 (Fig. 5a inset). Thus, the adsorption was completely mono layered in nature. The SEM image showed the Hg2+ ions adsorbed on the material as white particles (Fig. S15†), and the EDAX spectrum confirmed the presence of Hg2+ on the surface (Fig. S16†). The material was regenerated after an acidic wash with conc. HCl, followed by a water wash to make it neutral again, making it ready for further adsorption of Hg2+. The material DTC-OP2 showed 99.9% removal in the first and second cycles, and 94.1% in the third cycle (Fig. 5c). So, DTC-OP2 proved to be a potential recyclable candidate for removing toxic Hg2+ from the water samples.
The fast and highly efficient removal capacity and the reusability of the material directed us to design the column separation of the Hg2+ by using DTC-OP2 as the adsorbent. We tightly packed the material fitted in between cotton wool in a glass column, and added the mercury-containing water through it (Fig. 5d). The Hg2+-contaminated water that eluted through the material was collected and analyzed for Hg2+ ions by ICP-OES. It was observed that the eluted water was devoid of Hg2+ in a short time with a removal capacity of 99.7%. The reusability of the column after the wash increases the applicability of the system (Fig. 5d). This column set-up was advanced by the use of a spin column, where the contaminated Hg2+ was passed through the material loaded in a spin column fitted with a frit. The solution was eluted through this column in 30 seconds by spinning and showed 99.9% Hg2+ removal. Subsequently, improvement was made in terms of the time, labor and high-throughput. When compared to the stirring technique followed by filtration, the spin column is advantageous in terms of time by reducing an extra step of vacuum filtration. The regeneration of the material is also much easier, as the washing and drying can be done repeatedly within a short time. As they are available in different sizes, the selection can be made based on the requirement. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report for the utilization of a spin column for metal removal studies. We are also the first to report the complete removal of toxic metal ions from water in 30 seconds, which includes the filtration of the material. The competitivity studies were also carried out with Hg2+ and other essential non-toxic elements. The material has shown to be effective for the removal of Hg2+ selectively without removing essential elements like K+, Na+ and Ca2+ (Table S3†). DTC-OP2 was found to be capable of removing 99.9% Hg2+ from the solutions of acidic and basic pH as well (pH = 4 and pH = 9) (Table S4†). For the removal of Hg2+, the studies were carried out in real samples (lake water and tap water), which contained all types of contaminants and competing ions and compounds. The material showed >98% removal (confirmed by ICP-OES) in real lake water samples and tap water (Table S5†). The scalability for real applications was also studied by carrying out the adsorption experiment in a higher volume (40 mL) with the lake water sample.
000
000× magnification. The quantitative analysis of mercury was done using an inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES) instrument (Perkin Elmer Optima 5300 DV). Thermal gravimetry analysis was carried out in a Perkin Elmer Inc Thermal Analyzer STA 8000. Differential scanning calorimetry was performed in a NETZSCH DSC 204F1 Phoenix. X-Ray diffraction studies were carried out in a Rigaku XRD Smart lab, 9 kW system. The rheometric analysis was carried out in Ares G2, TA instruments. Physisorption analysis was carried out in Quantachrome ASi Qwin, version 5.21.
:
3 system of ethyl acetate and hexane, and visualized under UV light. After completion of the reaction (15 min), the excess chloroacetyl chloride was quenched by the addition of sodium bicarbonate solution until the evolution of CO2 ceased. The reaction mixture was extracted by ethyl acetate and water, and the organic layer was passed through anhydrous Na2SO4. The solvent was removed under low pressure, and the product was obtained with high purity.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2ew00727d |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |