Renpeng
Guan
,
Elliot L.
Bennett
,
Zhiliang
Huang
* and
Jianliang
Xiao
*
Department of Chemistry, University of Liverpool, Liverpool L69 7ZD, UK. E-mail: Z.Huang49@liverpool.ac.uk; J.Xiao@liverpool.ac.uk
First published on 10th March 2022
Reported here is a new protocol for the decarboxylative oxygenation of carboxylic acids using a non-heme manganese catalyst under blue light irradiation with O2 as the sole oxidant. Featuring mild reaction conditions, the protocol allows readily available carboxylic acids to be converted into a wide variety of valuable aldehydes, ketones and amides. Mechanistic studies indicate that the decarboxylation and oxygenation involves the formation of active Mn-oxygen species.
Decarboxylative oxygenation of carboxylic acids is a challenging reaction, requiring a catalyst not only capable of promoting decarboxylation but also oxidation. So far, there have been only three reports, demonstrating the reaction via photoredox catalysis using molecular oxygen (O2) under mild conditions. Two of these require precious Ru or Ir photocatalysts,34,35 while the third produces a mixture of alcohols and ketones/aldehydes as the products (Scheme 1a).36 Other methods have been reported; however, they make use of stoichiometric strong oxidants, e.g. NaIO4,37n-Bu4NIO4,38 HgF2,39 Pb(OAc)4,40 PhI(OAc)241 and K2S2O8
42 (Scheme 1b), or rely on a high reaction temperature (Scheme 1c).25,43 Herein, we report a highly selective decarboxylative oxygenation of carboxylic acids to aldehydes or ketones by O2 (1 atm), promoted by a non-heme Mn(II) catalyst and visible light under mild conditions (Scheme 1d).
The use of benign and inexpensive O2 for selective oxidation with first-row, biologically relevant metal complexes as catalysts remains a significant challenge for the synthetic chemist.44–46 Over the past a few decades, some biomimetic Fe and Mn complexes bearing heme and non-heme polydentate ligands have been developed to catalyze the oxidation of hydrocarbons, alcohols as well as carboxylic acids with O2.37,44,47–51 However, significant drawbacks remain in most cases, e.g. the need for stoichiometric co-reductants and unsatisfactory selectivity due to poorly controlled radical-type pathways. To date, only a few biomimetic metal complexes are known that can catalyze the aerobic oxidation in a controlled manner without using a co-reductant.52–57 Following on from our recent study of aerobic cleavage of alkenes with a non-heme Mn(II) complex,58 we investigated the decarboxylative oxygenation of carboxylic acids to aldehydes/ketones by O2 with this and related complexes. Our findings are detailed below.
Entry | [M] | Ligand | Yield (%) |
---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: 1a (0.5 mmol), [M] (5 mol%), ligand (10 mol%), CH3CN (2 mL), blue light (465 nm), 45 °C, O2 (1 atm), 12 h.
b NMR yields, determined using mesitylene (20 μL) as internal standard.
c N2 (1 atm).
d Air instead of O2. ![]() |
|||
1 | [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] | — | 87 |
2 | Mn(OTf)2 | — | 0 |
3 | Mn(OTf)2 | L1 | 33 |
4 | Mn(OTf)2 | L2 | 46 |
5 | Mn(OTf)2 | L3 | 61 |
6 | Mn(OTf)2 | L4 | 90 |
7 | Mn(OTf)2 | L5 | 41 |
8 | Mn(OTf)2 | L6 | 64 |
9 | Mn(OTf)2 | L7 | 14 |
10 | Mn(OTf)2 | L8 | 41 |
11 | Cu(OTf)2 | L4 | 4 |
12 | Fe(OTf)2 | L4 | 16 |
13 | CoCl2 | L4 | 42 |
14 | MnCl2 | L4 | 53 |
15c | [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] | — | 0 |
16d | Mn(OTf)2 | L4 | 62 |
Under the optimized reaction conditions, a series of benzylic carboxylic acids were first examined to test the generality of this decarboxylative oxygenation protocol. As shown in Scheme 2, phenyl acetic acids bearing electron-withdrawing or electron-donating groups on the phenyl ring are all suitable substrates (2a–2o), affording the desirable aldehyde products in good to excellent yields. During our investigation, we noticed that phenyl acetic acids bearing electronic-withdraw groups were usually less reactive. For example, para-F-substituted acid 1d and para-CF3-substituted acid 1e showed low reactivity for the oxidation under above standard conditions, giving the corresponding aldehydes in 35% and 17% yields, respectively. However, the oxidation was improved by introducing a catalytic amount of sodium acetate as an additive (Scheme 2. See ESI for the detailed reaction optimization, Table S2†). 2-Naphthyl acetic acid and S-heterocycle acetic acid can be oxidized selectively to afford 2p and 2q in moderate yields, respectively. Secondary benzylic carboxylic acids are also efficiently converted to the corresponding ketone products in good to excellent yields under the standard conditions (2r–2u). It is worth noting that a range of amino acids including a dipeptide can be oxidized to the corresponding amide products in a highly selective manner, showing potential applications in bio-conjugate chemistry (2v–2y).
Notably, a variety of drug molecules with functionalized aryl acetic acid scaffolds were also selectively oxidized by O2 under the conditions developed. As can be seen in Scheme 3, the oxidation of naproxen, ibuprofen, flubiprofen, ketoprofen, ioxoprofen, isoxepac and indomethacin all proceeded successfully, affording the corresponding aldehydes or ketones in good yields (3a–3g). Moreover, this photo-Mn protocol showed its ability in late-stage decarboxylative oxygenation of vitamin E, affording the aldehyde product 3h in 74% yield. The relatively active benzylic C–H bonds, tertiary C–H bonds, and indole ring, which are prone to oxidation, remained intact, showing the high chemoselectivity of this oxidation protocol. The success in late-stage decarboxylative oxygenation of drugs or natural products demonstrates the practical applicability of this oxidation protocol in accessing new bioactive molecules.
The more challenging enoic acids and aliphatic carboxylic acids were also tested.59,60 As can be seen in Scheme 4, the CC double bonds in enoic acids, usually sensitive to oxidation conditions, remained intact during the oxidation (5a). Notably, long-chain and cyclic aliphatic acids with different functionalities, including ether, carbamate, and amide, are suitable to give the corresponding carbonyl products with blue or UV light irradiation (5b–5e), highlighting the high chemoselectivity and hence great application potential of this method. Secondary aliphatic acids without other functional groups were also oxidatively decarboxylated to furnish the target carbonyls in 50%–63% yields (5f–5h) under the irradiation of UV-light. Notably, the primary stearic acid and oleic acid could be oxidized to the corresponding aldehydes; however, low yields, as well as low conversions were observed (5i and 5j). In comparison with Macmillan's work in 2019,35 this protocol shows a wider substrate scope. Not only can the cyclic aliphatic acids be oxidized selectively, but also long-chain fatty acids, saturated and unsaturated, could be converted, which are usually challenging substrates.61
Although the detailed mechanism of the decarboxylative oxygenation reaction is unclear, a series of experiments were performed to shed light on possible reaction pathways. As reported by Boger's group,62 singlet oxygen (1O2) can efficiently transfer pyrrole-2-carboxylic acids to the corresponding ketones in the presence of rose bengal. Therefore, it is important to determine whether 1O2 plays a role in the photo-Mn enabled oxidative decarboxylation. As shown in Table 2, a range of well-known photosensitizers (Table 2, entries 1–4), such as Eosin Y disodium salt, Ru(bpy)3, Ir(dFppy)3 and rose bengal,58,63 which can generate 1O2 under blue light, were used individually as replacement catalysts for the decarboxylative oxygenation of 1a under standard reaction conditions. However, these photosensitizers showed a significantly lower catalytic effect. Furthermore, when an 1O2 trap, 9,10-diphenylanthracene (DPA) which is known to react rapidly with 1O2 to give an endoperoxide product (k ≈ 1.3 × 106 M−1 s−1),64 was added to the oxidative decarboxylation of 1a under the standard conditions (Table 2, entry 5), 2a was obtained in 70% yield, and no endoperoxide was detected. These observations appear to rule out the involvement of 1O2 in the reaction pathway.
Entry | Catalyst | Yield (%) |
---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: Acid (0.5 mmol), catalyst (5 mol%), CH3CN (2 mL), blue light (465 nm), 45 °C, O2 (1 atm), 12 h. b NMR yields, determined using mesitylene as internal standard. c Conversion was observed under the conditions reported in ref. 35 (see Scheme S2, ESI†). d DPA (0.1 mmol) was added. | ||
1 | Eosin Y disodium salt | 37 |
2 | [Ru(bpy)3·6H2O] | 19 |
3 | [Ir(dFppy)3] | 0c |
4 | Rose bengal | 4 |
5d | [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] | 70 |
Previous studies on decarboxylative oxygenation of phenylacetic acids by Mn-based enzymes indicate that the hydroxylation of C–H bond in the benzylic position is the initiation step of this oxidation reaction, which affords 2-hydroxy-2-phenylacetic acid as the key intermediate for the further oxidative decarboxylation process.65–67 Knowing this, several control experiments were performed to determine whether a similar hydroxylation process occurs as the key step. Firstly, the potential intermediate 2-hydroxy-2-phenylacetic acid (7) was subjected to the standard reaction conditions, affording 2j in 93% yield (Scheme 5, eqn (1)). This result indicates that 7 could be involved in the oxidative decarboxylation reaction under the current conditions. However, when the corresponding benzylic C–H bonds were substituted by two alkyl or phenyl groups, the desired decarboxylative oxygenation proceeded smoothly as well (Scheme 5, eqn (2)–(4)). In all cases, the ketone products were obtained, apparently via a C–C bond cleavage process due to the formation of the strong CO bond. This indicates the involvement of a radical fragmentation pathway. Additionally, no reactions happened when ethyl 2-phenylacetate (8) was employed (Scheme 5, eqn (5)). Meanwhile, 2r was afforded when (1-hydroperoxyethyl)benzene (9) was employed (Scheme 5, eqn (6)). These observations indicate that the acid moiety is involved and peroxide intermediates may be formed in the decarboxylative oxygenation reaction.
Further insight was obtained by following the kinetic isotope effect (KIE) (Scheme 6). Parallel reactions using acids 1a and 1a-d2 afforded the initial rates kHobs = 9.3 and kDobs = 8.8 mol L−1 h−1, respectively. Clearly, the cleavage of the C–H bond on the benzylic position is less likely to be involved in the turnover limiting step, considering the KIE value of ca. 1.1. This result lends further support to the notion that the oxidative decarboxylation is not initiated by the benzylic C–H bond hydroxylation.
Subsequently, the reaction of carboxylic acids with the [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] complex was studied with UV-Vis spectroscopy. As shown in Fig. 1, there is an obvious decrease of the absorbance of 1a at 230 nm when 1 equivalent of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] was added. In the meantime, compared with that of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2], the spectrum of the mixture of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] and 1a showed a significant absorption decrease at around 295 nm and 306 nm. These observations indicate that [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] reacts with 1a to form a new Mn(II) species. Further structural information of the new Mn(II) species was obtained by HRMS, which suggests that the carboxylate-coordinated [Mn(dtbpy)2(1a-H)(OTf)] is likely to be formed by losing a HOTf from the parent complex. Fig. 2 shows the experimental and calculated mass spectra of the molecular ion resulting from the loss of a −OTf fragment from the [Mn(dtbpy)2(1a-H)(OTf)] complex.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 UV-Vis spectra of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2], 1a and the mixture of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] and 1a without blue light irradiation (concentration of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] and 1a: 25 μM in CH3CN). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 HRMS spectrum of [Mn(dtbpy)2(1a-H)(OTf)] formed in the in situ reaction of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] with 1a. |
We envisioned that a Mn-peroxide intermediate may be formed by the reaction of [Mn(dtbpy)2(1a-H)(OTf)] with O2 in the decarboxylative oxidation under blue light.34,67 Thus, a mixture of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] and 1r, which was expected to afford [Mn(dtbpy)2(1r-H)(OTf)], was followed by UV-Vis spectroscopy with or without blue light irradiation. As shown in Fig. 3, an obvious absorption at ca. 685 nm was observed, when the mixture was irradiated by blue light under O2 (Fig. 3, green dash line). Notably, a similar absorption band was also found in the mixture of [Mn(dtbpy)2(OTf)2] and 9 without blue light irradiation under N2, which increased over time and then reached saturation before beginning to decrease (Fig. S4 in ESI†). Finally, the product 2r was formed in 60% yield after 60 min (Scheme S1†). These observations indicate that a peroxide intermediate may be involved and complexed with the catalyst in the process of decarboxylative oxidation. Comparing with the previous literature, the absorption at 685 nm is likely to arise from a Mn-peroxide species.68–70
Based on the observations above and previous literature,25,36 a plausible mechanism is proposed by taking the oxidation of phenylacetic acid (1j) as an example. As shown in Scheme 7, 1j firstly reacts with the Mn(II) precatalyst to form the intermediate A, which is subsequently oxidized by O2 to afford the key species B under blue light irradiation.44,71–73 The unstable superoxide radical attacks the benzylic carbon of the coordinated acid driven by the release of CO2, resulting in the formation of the Mn(II)-peroxide C. Further decomposition of the unstable species C produces the carbonyl product and a Mn(II)-OH species D, which reacts with phenylacetic acid, regenerating A.
![]() | ||
Scheme 7 A plausible mechanism of decarboxylative oxygenation of carboxylic acids (possible coordination of solvent or other molecules is omitted). |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: General information, preparation of substrates, optimization of reaction conditions, mechanistic studies, and characterization data. See DOI: 10.1039/d1gc04603a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |