Thanh-Binh
Nguyen
a,
Phung-Ngoc-Thao
Ho
a,
Chiu-Wen
Chen
b,
C. P.
Huang
c,
Ruey-an
Doong
d and
Cheng-Di
Dong
*b
aInstitute of Aquatic Science and Technology, National Kaohsiung University of Science and Technology, Kaohsiung, 81157, Taiwan
bDepartment of Marine Environmental Engineering, National Kaohsiung University of Science and Technology, Kaohsiung, 81157, Taiwan. E-mail: cddong@nkust.edu.tw
cDepartment of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Delaware, Newark, 19716, DE, USA
dInstitute of Analytical and Environmental Sciences, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu, 30013, Taiwan
First published on 18th November 2021
A NiCo2O4 nanoparticle (NP) and sulfur codoped hollow tubular g-C3N4 (NiCo–S@CN) catalyst was synthesized by a hydrothermal pyrolysis method and used to remove pharmaceuticals, exemplified by the antibiotic tetracycline (TC), from water under solar light irradiation. The synergistic effect of NiCo2O4 NPs and S@CN nanotubes in the Z-scheme heterojunction significantly enhanced the photocatalytic reactivity of the NiCo–S@CN catalyst, under solar light, toward TC degradation. Factors such as catalyst dosage, pH, TC concentration, and temperature that controlled TC degradation in synthetic and natural water media were studied. Langmuir–Hinshelwood kinetics were observed in the photocatalytic degradation of TC over NiCo–S@CN. The photocatalytic performance was the best at the catalyst dosage of 200 mg L−1. The initial effect of pH on TC photodegradation over the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system was as follows: pH 7.0 > pH 11.0 > pH 9.0 > pH 5.0 > pH 3.0. Moreover, NiCo–S@CN exhibited high TC degradation efficiency in multiple cycles while it remained chemically stable with undetectable soluble metals in the treated water. Results of electron spin resonance (EPR) and radical trapping studies indicated that holes (h+) and superoxide radicals (O2˙−) were the main reactive species for efficient TC removal in the Z-scheme/solar light system. Overall, results demonstrated that NiCo–S@CN was a novel Z-scheme photocatalyst for the remediation of pharmaceutical-contaminated water.
Environmental significanceThe presence of antibiotics in the environment has attracted increasing public attention because of potential adverse ecological and human impacts. Sunlight-active photocatalysts with high efficiency and recyclability provide friendly and sustainable solutions to the control of hazardous chemicals such as antibiotics. Herein, a NiCo2O4 nanoparticle (NP) and sulfur codoped hollow tubular g-C3N4 (NiCo–S@CN) photocatalyst was synthesized by a hydrothermal pyrolysis method and used to remove pharmaceuticals, exemplified by the antibiotic tetracycline (TC), from water under solar light irradiation. The NiCo–S@CN catalyst exhibited excellent solar-light-responsive photocatalytic activity toward TC degradation because of the synergistic effect of NiCo2O4 NPs and S@CN nanotubes in the Z-scheme heterojunction. The finding is expected to open a new avenue for fabrication of Z-scheme nanocomposites for water treatment in particular and environmental remediation in general. |
Recent years have seen a surge in interest in the creation of solar-light-active photocatalysts owing to the potential applications of such materials. Photocatalysts activated by solar light can be utilized to degrade hazardous organic pollutants in wastewater in an environmentally friendly approach under ambient settings.5 Graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4), a metal-free visible-light-responsive photocatalyst, has lately raised considerable interest in water splitting and environmental remediation applications because of its low cost, strong photostability, easy bulk production, and attractive optical characteristics.5 While the g-C3N4 photocatalyst has been extensively explored in recent years, it still has not been widely applied in environmental remediation because of low visible-light utilization efficiency, rapid charge carrier recombination, and small specific surface area.6 Fortuitously, after years of research efforts, there have been significant breakthroughs in enhancing the photocatalytic activity of g-C3N4, in particular by g-C3N4 heterojunctions,7 heteroatom doping,8 and dye sensitization.9 S doping has recently gained widespread interest because of the ease of synthesis, low environmental impact, and high photocatalytic activity of products. In particular, S doping effectively modifies the band structure, improves the charge carrier separation, decreases the bandgap energy, and increases the light absorption range of g-C3N4.10 Nonetheless, unfortunately, S-doped g-C3N4 (S@CN) still has limited photocatalysis reactivity without further surface modification. Therefore, there were attempts to further enhance the photocatalytic reactivity of S@CN through the synthesis of Z-scheme heterostructures to efficiently separate hole–electron pairs.11–13 The Z-scheme has gained considerable interest because of its enhanced redox capability and increased photocarrier lifetime among classic type II systems.14 Recently, Umeshbabu et al. have reported that NiCo2O4 nanoparticles (NPs) have a narrow bandgap, high electronic conductivity, tuneable valence, and low cost.15 However, NiCo2O4 NPs still suffer from limited activation efficiency because of limited dispersivity and rapid charge recombination.16,17 Hence, it has prompted us to couple NiCo2O4 NPs with g-C3N4 hollow tubes to produce efficient Z-scheme photocatalysts to enhance the photocatalytic degradation of recalcitrant chemicals, specifically antibiotics, under solar light irradiation.
The present work aimed to design and synthesize Z-scheme NiCo2O4/S-doped g-C3N4 (NiCo–S@CN) for the heterogeneous photocatalytic degradation of persistent antibiotics exemplified by TC. Scheme 1 illustrates the design and synthesis of Z-scheme NiCo–S@CN by a hydrothermal method followed by pyrolysis incorporation of NiCo2O4 NPs and doped S atoms, using L-cysteine precursor, on g-C3N4 nanotubes. Various surface analysis techniques were conducted to characterize the physicochemical and light-responsive properties of the NiCo–S@CN catalyst. A series of photocatalytic experiments were performed to investigate the feasibility of the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system for TC degradation as affected by variables such as pH, catalyst dosage, initial TC concentration, temperature, and water matrixes. Additionally, the kinetics of TC degradation over NiCo–S@CN under solar irradiation was studied. Radical scavenging experiments, EPR, and Mott–Schottky test aided in establishing the degradation mechanism. The catalytic stability of NiCo–S@CN was evaluated in six successive photocatalytic TC degradation cycles. In addition, the change in COD and TOC during the course of TC degradation was monitored to estimate the degree of mineralization in terms of the change of average carbon oxidation state (COS). To the best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to study the photocatalytic degradation of antibiotics in aqueous solutions using the Z-scheme NiCo–S@CN heterojunction under solar-light irradiation.
Fig. 1 (a–f) HRTEM images and (i) SAED pattern of NiCo–S@CN. (g) Size distribution and (h) lattice spacing of NiCo2O4 NPs. |
EDX elemental mapping showed the presence of C, N, O, and S elements on the S@CN. All the elements were uniformly distributed on the surface of the hollow tubes (Fig. S2†). Such an intriguing structure is expected to provide sufficient surface area and reactive sites for facilitating pollutant transport and increasing light absorption.
High-resolution TEM (HRTEM) further revealed the surface structure of S@CN-doped NiCo2O4 nanoparticles (NiCo–S@CN). Incorporation of NiCo2O4 into S@CN retained its 1D tubular structure during the second synthesis stage and stabilized the NiCo2O4 nanoparticles by forming well-defined 0D/1D heterostructured NiCo–S@CN with intimate interfaces (Fig. 1a and d). Fig. 1b and e show that the electron-dense areas appear dark because of the high atomic mass and electron density of metals in contrast to non-metals, which indicated the presence of NiCo2O4 nanoparticles on the surface of 1D tubular S@CN. Obviously, NiCo2O4 nanoparticles appeared on the entire surface of the NiCo–S@CN composite (Fig. 1c and f) with a homogeneous diameter of approximately 5 nm (Fig. 2g), rendering the original surface of S@CN rougher. The result showed that S@CN contained a variety of functional groups capable of chelating metals, i.e., forming chelates and stabilizing metal-based nanoparticles on the surface.18 The corresponding high magnification of the HRTEM image obtained at the edge of hollow tubes clearly exhibited distinct lattice fringes of metal oxide particles with interplanar spacing of 0.25 nm, which was in accordance with the (311) lattice plane of NiCo2O4 (Fig. 1h). The crystallographic information based on a spotty ring pattern obtained by selected-area electron diffraction (SAED) showed that NiCo–S@CN clearly exhibits a polycrystalline structure, in which the diffraction rings of CN ({002} and {100}) and NiCo2O4 ({311}, {400}, {440}, {511} and {531}) appear, according to JCPDS#87-1526 and JCPDS#00-020-781, respectively (Fig. 1i).
Fig. 2 (a) TGA, (b) DSC profiles, (c) XRD patterns, (d) FTIR spectra, (e) UV-vis spectra, and (f) corresponding bandgap of CN, S@CN, and NiCo–S@CN composites. |
Energy-dispersive (EDX) X-ray analysis in conjunction with HRSEM revealed the elemental constituents of the NiCo–S@CN composite. The EDX spectrum showed the presence of major elements, i.e., C and N, together with minor elements, i.e., Ni, Co, and O (∼5 wt% NiCo2O4 constituent of the composite), due to the low doping level of NiCo2O4 (Fig. S3a and b†). Noticeably, the elemental composition derived from the EDX spectrum revealed the Co:Ni atomic ratio of 2:1, which agreed well with the chemical formula of NiCo2O4 and confirmed the presence of doped metal oxide nanocrystals. Note that the trace Cu was from the Cu grid. As can be seen in Fig. S3c,† the elemental mapping of the 1D tube verified the uniform dispersion of all relevant elements across the tube without apparent separation. Thus, based on the structural morphologies described above, it is clear that NiCo2O4 nanoparticles were successfully loaded on the S@CN hollow tube and displayed an intimate heterojunction between S@CN and NiCo2O4.
TGA/DSC technique was used to examine the thermal behaviour of catalysts prepared at temperatures in the range of 30 to 1000 °C under a static air atmosphere. Fig. 2a shows that CN was stable in air, weight loss began at approximately 480 °C, and CN completely decomposed into CO2 and NO2 at 650 °C. Interestingly, S@CN had a lower decomposition temperature (approximately 450 °C) than that of pristine CN. S-doping of the CN graphite-like structure through thermo-condensation of L-cysteine and dicyanamide in the solid phase altered the local packing motifs in the tri-s-triazine ring and weakened the van der Waals forces of the stacked layer structure, thus strengthening the thermal stability of the composite.19 In the case of NiCo–S@CN, the decomposition temperature began at 350 °C. The weight loss remained unchanged in the temperature range between 685 and 1000 °C. The results indicated the presence of metal oxides in the S@CN framework and became catalysts that facilitated the thermal decomposition of the composite and weakened the cross-linked rings of CN. Based on the high thermal stability of NiCo2O4, the estimated oxide content in the NiCo–S@CN composite was 4.8 wt%, which was close to the theoretical doping level.
The DSC thermogram clearly shows that all three materials, i.e., CN, S@CN, and NiCo–S@CN, exhibit the same decomposition reaction feature, as demonstrated by the appearance of wide exothermic peaks in the temperature range of 130 to 1000 °C (Fig. 2b). The exothermic decomposition heat increased from 67 to 94 W g−1 when CN was functionalized with sulfur owing to the enhanced decomposition of S@CN accompanied by the ready release of carbon-, nitrogen-, and sulfur-containing gases with high heating value. The exothermic peak of the NiCo–S@CN composite dropped to 33 W g−1, possibly because of NiCo2O4 doping that enhanced the crystallinity of the composite and restricted the decomposition of S@CN into volatile molecules.20
The crystallographic structure of the catalysts was characterized by XRD measurements (Fig. 2c). The XRD pattern of the CN catalyst exhibited two distinct diffraction peaks at 2θ 13.1° and 27.3°, which were well indexed as the in-plane structural packing motif of tri-s-triazine {100} and interlayer periodic stacking of the graphitic structure {002}, respectively (JCPDS#87-1526). The signal intensity of the two characteristic peaks of the S@CN catalyst were lower than that of the pristine CN due to lattice distortion by the loading of relatively large S atoms in the graphitic structure of CN and subsequent increase in the spacing between graphitic layers and decrease in layer thickness.21 Meanwhile, two additional peaks at 2θ 36° and 44.6° of NiCo–S@CN were assigned to the {311} and {400} planes of NiCo2O4 (JCPDS#00-020-781), which further demonstrated the successful loading of NiCo2O4 on S@CN. However, the peak intensity corresponding to NiCo2O4 was particularly weak owing to the low loading level of Ni and Co precursors with respect to other elements.
FT-IR spectra in the wavenumber range of 400 to 4000 cm−1 revealed the surface chemical composition of the catalysts (Fig. 2d). All three catalysts, i.e., CN, S@CN and Ni–Co–S@CN, exhibited identical IR absorption bands, implying that S and NiCo2O4 doping did not alter the π-conjugation of the CN skeleton. A sharp peak at 806 cm−1 represented the characteristic breathing vibration of tri-s-triazine rings of heterocycle-grafted CN, whilst the typical peaks in the wavenumber range of 1200 to1650 cm−1 were widely known as the stretching vibration of the aromatic C–N heterocycle.22 In addition, the broad peaks from 2900 to 3630 cm−1 were ascribed to the stretching mode of O–H and N–H bonds, possibly associated with the uncondensed amine groups and surface-bound water molecules. Note that S@CN exhibited no discernible variation and peaks of S-related groups because of low S content or overlapping of vibrational spectrum by the C–N bond. There was only a N–H peak shift from 3197 cm−1 to the higher wavenumber of 3286 cm−1, indicating the replacement of N element by S in the CN graphitic structure.21 However, NiCo2O4 loading greatly decreased the peak intensity between 2900 and 3630 cm−1, implying (i) the successful connection of NiCo2O4 NPs to the CN heterocyclic substrate via strong surface complexation with functional groups (–OH and N–H) as binding sites and (ii) homogeneous distribution of tiny 0-D metal oxide, i.e., NiCo2O4, on the surface of S@CN that limited the interaction between IR and multifunctional groups, as demonstrated in HRTEM images. Notably, the stretching vibration bonds of Co–O and Ni–O in the composite occurred at 543 and 643 cm−1, respectively, indicating the presence of metal oxide as previously reported.23 Thus, the FTIR results further confirmed the formation of a heterojunction between NiCo2O4 NPs and S@CN tubes.
The optical properties and electronic bandgap of the catalysts were characterized by UV-vis diffuse reflectance. Fig. 2e shows that the original UCN displays an absorption edge at ca. 488 nm. In contrast to pristine CN, the absorption edge of CN after S doping, i.e., S@CN, exhibited an obvious redshift of the absorption edge to approximately 518 nm, which demonstrated that S doping the CN framework could greatly broaden the spectral response range. Therefore, the colour of CN turned from yellow to light brown after S doping. Chen et al.24 have reported that doping of S on CN significantly enhances the visible light-harvesting capability, photogenerated charge separation, and surface charge transfer efficacy because of multiple reflections within the porous structure and high spin density of the catalyst. Note that NiCo–S@CN also exhibited a systematic redshift to longer visible light of 532 nm because of the broad absorption spectrum of NiCo2O4 in the UV-to-visible light region.17,25 Consequently, modification of NiCo2O4 remarkably enhanced photon absorption in the visible light range and the separation of electron–hole pairs. The macroscopic colour that shifted from light brown to dark brown also demonstrated the beneficial effect of visible light harvesting. Additionally, the bandgap (Eg) of CN, S@CN, and NiCo–S@CN, obtained by the Tauc method, was 2.54, 2.40, and 2.32 eV, respectively (Fig. 2f). Results clearly demonstrated the enhancement of the visible-light-harvesting capability of the NiCo2O4 and S@CN heterojunction.
XPS technique further characterized the chemical state and bonding of the NiCo–S@CN composite. Fig. S4† reveals the presence of C, N, S, Ni, Co and O elements on the composite. The XPS spectra of C 1s exhibited three different peaks at 285, 288.5 and 294.1 eV, corresponding to CC, C–NC and sp2 carbon, respectively (Fig. 3a).26 There were two major peaks in the S 2p orbital (Fig. 3b). The first peak at 169.2 eV was attributed to the C–S–C bond, while the low peak at 170.2 eV was formed by substituting C in the CN graphitic network (S–N bonds).10Fig. 3c shows the three deconvoluted peaks of the N 1s orbital, which were assigned to the sp2 hybridized nitrogen C–NC (399.1 eV) in the triazine ring, tertiary nitrogen in N–C3 groups (400.4 eV) connecting the C6N7 motif, and C–NH (403 eV) as a result of non-condensation of amino groups, respectively.27Fig. 3d shows the O 1s orbital of NiCo–S@CN in which the fitted peaks at 529.4 and 532.7 eV were assigned to the oxygen lattice in the bimetallic oxide (Olatt) and surface-adsorbed oxygen (Oads), respectively. The Olatt species were formed by metal oxygen bonds (M–O–M), whereas the Oads species belonged to the surface-adsorbed hydroxyl-like group (M–OH) or oxygen vacancies.28 The Ni 2p was convoluted to Ni 2p3/2 and Ni 2p3/2 at 856.6 and 875.1 eV, respectively (Fig. 3e). Additionally, two corresponding shake-up satellite peaks of spin–orbit doublets, at approximately 863.7 and 881.4 eV, respectively, appeared. The fitted peaks at 856.4 and 873.2 eV were indexed to Ni3+, whereas other fitted peaks at 857.6and 875 eV were attributed to Ni2+.29 Similarly, as shown in Fig. 3f, two distinct Co species and two shake-up satellites were identified based on the Co 2p spectrum. The fitted peaks at 781.3 and 797 eV were ascribed to Co3+, whilst the other two fitted peaks at 784.3 and 798.1 eV belonged to Co2+.30 Note that the atomic ratio of Ni to Co was 1:2, which agreed well with the stoichiometric ratio of NiCo2O4.The above results confirmed that S atoms and NiCo2O4 nanoparticles were successfully incorporated onto the surface of CN tubes at a high degree of dispersion.
Fig. 3 High-resolution XPS spectra of (a) C 1s, (b) N 1s, (c) S 2p, (d) O 1s, (e) Ni 2p and (f) Co 2p of the NiCo–S@CN. |
In order to elucidate the effect of specific surface area on the photocatalytic activity of catalytic materials, N2 physical adsorption/desorption was performed to determine the texture parameters, including BET specific surface area (SBET), pore volume, and pore distribution. The N2 adsorption–desorption isotherm of the catalysts (Fig. 4b) showed a type IV isotherm with an H3-type distinct inflection at P/P0 between 0.7 and 1.0, indicating the presence of a well-defined hierarchical porous structure with high abundance of various mesopores in the hollow tube.31 The SBET of S@CN (57.11 m2 g−1) and NiCo–S@CN (54.67 m2 g−1) was 3.7–3.9 times greater than that of the pristine CN (14.74 m2 g−1). Furthermore, Barrett–Joyner–Halenda (BJH) profiles (Fig. 4c) showed the presence of mesopores and macropores in the size range of 2 to 140 nm. It is noteworthy that the higher pore size distribution profiles of S@CN and NiCo–S@CN indicated the presence of a more highly porous nature of these two materials than CN. The pore volume of CN, S@CN, and NiCo–S@CN was 0.10, 0.42, and 0.37 cm3 g−1, respectively. The pore diameter of pristine CN is mainly centered at a narrow size of 2.8 nm initially. S doping widened the pore size distribution in the 2–140 nm region of the mesoscale, due mainly to spontaneous pore formation triggered by gaseous release through thermal polymerization.32 Interestingly, due to the homogeneous distribution of NiCo2O4 NPs on the S@CN surface, the NiCo–S@CN catalyst exhibited bimodal pore structures with peaks at approximately 48.7 and 74.8 nm, individually, which facilitated faster diffusion of pollutants into the catalyst pores and increased the photocatalytic reactivity.30 In conclusion, the larger surface area and pore volume of NiCO–S@CN contributed greater adsorption and external/internal diffusion of TC molecules to the photocatalyst.
The photocatalytic TC degradation over the photocatalysts followed pseudo-first-order kinetics (eqn (1)). The observed rate constant (kobs) was determined from the slope of the linear ln(Ct/C0) vs. time (t) plot, i.e.,
(1) |
Photoluminescence (PL) technique well characterizes the efficacy of suppressing electron–hole pair recombination and the lifetime of charge carriers in semiconductors.22Fig. 4e shows that all three catalysts display the maximum emission peak at around 624 nm at an excitation wavelength of 310 nm and room temperature. Among all the photocatalysts, pure CN exhibited the highest PL intensity, which suggested the largest recombination rate of photoinduced charge carriers and hence limited photocatalytic activity.33 On the other hand, S@CN showed a dramatic decrease in PL emission intensity upon doping of S heteroatoms, indicating a longer lifetime of photoinduced electrons and effective separation of electron–hole pairs. Indeed, S atoms acted as trapping centres for photogenerated electrons in the mid-bandgap and thus improved the carrier mobility of pure CN.34 Noticeably, NiCo–S@CN exhibited the lowest PL peak intensity with respect to pure CN and S@CN. Coupling NiCo2O4 with S@CN promoted interfacial electron transfer efficiency while retarding the recombination of electron–hole pairs. Therefore, more charge carriers were available for the photocatalytic degradation of TC than that of pristine CN; that is, the synergistic effect of S atoms and NiCo2O4 NPs significantly enhanced the catalytic activity of CN. Furthermore, Stoke shifts on the emission wavelength of the catalyst were likely related to the change in bandgap as determined by UV-vis spectroscopy. Additionally, the lifetime of photogenerated charge carriers on all three catalysts was further investigated by time-resolved PL decay spectra (Fig. 4f). Three processes controlled the lifetime of charge carriers: non-radiative (t1), radiative (t2), and energy transfer (t3).35 The mean lifetime of NiCo–S@CN was 7.11 ns, which was significantly longer than that of S@CN (5.53 ns) and CN (0.63 ns). The PL and time-resolved PL spectra demonstrated a significant increase in lifetime of charge carriers of NiCo–S@CN (positively associated with the high efficiency of electron–hole pair separation), which was one of the major mechanisms that facilitated the photocatalytic reactions because of the unique structure of NiCo–S@CN.
Tricarbonylamide, phenolic diketone, and dimethylamine are the three major functional groups of TC, with the acidity constants (pKa) of 3.3, 7.7, and 9.3, respectively. TC can be present in aqueous solution as cationic (TCH3+), neutral/zwitterionic (TCH2±), anionic (TC−), and dianionic (TC2−) species (Fig. S7a†). The point of zero charge (pHpzc) of NiCo–S@CN was around 3.4. Results showed that the degradation rate was slow under acidic conditions. At pH <pKa1 (3.3), a strong electrostatic repulsion between the positively charged NiCo–S@CN and TCH3+ species impeded the degradation reaction due to inefficient contact among reacting species. Likewise, electrostatic interactions hindered the adsorption of TCH− and TC2− onto the negatively charged NiCo–S@CN surface at pH >7.7. The adsorption behaviour of TC on NiCo–S@CN as a function of pH was further studied in the dark. When pH was in the range of 5 to 7, cationic TCH3+ was deprotonated to TCH2±, which resulted in increasing adsorption between the negatively charged catalysts and zwitterionic TCs.36
Fig. S7b† shows the Langmuir adsorption isotherm of TC on NiCo–S@CN as a function of pH. The data fitted well with the Langmuir adsorption isotherm (r2 > 0.99) (Fig. S7c†), demonstrating the monolayer nature of TC adsorption on the homogeneous adsorbent surface. The maximum TC adsorption density (qm) at different pH values, calculated from the Langmuir adsorption isotherm, followed the order pH 3.0 (5.1 × 10−2 mmol g−1) < pH 11.0 (6.3 × 10−2 mmol g−1) < pH 9.0 (9.3 × 10−2 mmol g−1) < pH 5.0 (10.2 mmol g−1) < pH 7.0 (15.9 × 10−2 mmol g−1) (Table S2 and Fig. S7d†). The KL (log) value, an indication of the strength of the TC bond with the catalyst, was relatively larger in the pH range of 5 and 11 than that of 3 due to strong interactions between the NiCo–S@CN surface and TC species (TCH2±, TCH− and TC2−) (Fig. S7d†). The result showed that neutral pH favoured TC adsorption onto the surface of NiCo–S@CN, thus enhancing photocatalytic degradation. Furthermore, the abundance of hydroxide ions improved the photocatalytic degradation of TC because the increasing number of anions in solution under basic conditions (pH 11.0) drastically accelerated the production of ˙OH radicals via reaction with photogenerated holes (h+).37
OH− + h+ → ˙ OH | (2) |
It was assumed that the photocatalytic TC degradation was a surface-mediated reaction and strongly reliant on the catalytic sites on the photocatalyst surface.22,38 A limited number of active sites on the NiCo–S@CN limited the rapid adsorption of TC onto the photocatalyst surface, which significantly decreased the reaction rate constant. Langmuir–Hinshelwood (LH) kinetics was used to describe heterogeneous catalytic reactions as follows:
(3) |
(4) |
Furthermore, the Eyring equation was used to determine the enthalpy (ΔH) and entropy (ΔS) for the photocatalytic TC degradation process by the following equation:
(5) |
The crystal phase and chemical valence of the spent NiCo–S@CN catalyst were evaluated using XPS and XRD methods. Results showed that the XRD spectrum remained unchanged with no appearance of any new crystalline orientation after six consecutive cycles (Fig. 7c). Additionally, the chemical composition of spent CoMn2O4 exhibited an oxidation state of Ni and Co compatible with that of fresh NiCo–S@CN (Fig. S10a and b†). The molar ratio of Ni2+/Ni3+ and Co2+/Co3+ were only slightly different from that of the fresh catalyst, implying the preservation of the oxidation state of Ni and Co in the solar light activation reaction with respect to electron transfer. Above all, the results demonstrated that the NiCo–S@CN4 catalyst was highly durable, reactive, and capable of heterogeneous photocatalytic activation toward the decontamination of antibiotics from water.
The effect of water chemistry, commonly encountered in field scenarios, on the catalytic performance of the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system toward TC removal was studied using real water media including tap water and lake water. Fig. 7d shows that TC was completely degraded in all three water media in 30 min following the rate constant of lake water (4.36 × 10−2 min−1) < tap water (5.61 × 10−2 min−1) < DI water (6 × 10−2 min−1) (inset of Fig. 7d). It is interesting to note that the conversion of TC in terms of TOC was significantly higher in DI water (78%) than in tap water (64.3%) and lake water (36.7%). As a result, the degree of TC mineralization appeared to be inhibited in tap and lake water. The decrease in TC mineralization was ascribed to competition for reactive oxidation species (ROSs) between the main constituents of TOC (i.e., hydrophobic, transphilic and hydrophilic DOCs) and TC (Table S3†).6 Regardless of the possible presence of inhibitory natural organic matter in tap and lake water, the photocatalytic TC degradation efficiency over NiCo–S@CN remained high, indicating that the present NiCo–S@CN /solar light system was able to generate highly selective radicals in abundance for TC oxidation in real contaminated waters.
Fig. 8 (a) and (b) Effect of different quenchers for TC degradation in the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system. EPR spectra of (c) ˙OH and (d) O2˙− radicals generated in the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system. |
Results confirmed that h+ played a major role in the photocatalytic TC degradation at 69%, whereas O2˙− and OH˙ radicals were secondary ROSs contributing to TC photodegradation at 34% and 47%, respectively.
Electron spin resonance (EPR) in the presence of 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline N-oxide (DMPO) as spin trapping reagent directly revealed the production of ROSs in the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system. Fig. 8c shows the DMPO–HO˙ signal with 1:2:2:1 intensity distribution in EPR spectra for all three catalysts under simulated solar light irradiation except for the control run under dark conditions.19Fig. 8d shows that there was no O2˙− signal in the dark; however, the quartet-line EPR signals (1:1:1:1) could be obviously found after all catalysts were excited by the simulated solar light.42 Furthermore, both the DMPO–HO˙ and DMPO–O2˙− signal intensities of NiCo–S@CN were stronger than that of CN and S@CN, implying more OH˙ and O2˙− production in the Z-scheme heterojunction between NiCo2O4 and S@CN. The result of radical scavenging assay and EPR analysis confirmed the formation of all three reactive species (h+, OH˙ and O2˙−) in the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system, and all played a role in TC degradation in the photocatalytic process.
To gain insight into the photocatalytic mechanism, a Mott–Schottky plot was constructed to establish the CB potential (ECB) of the catalysts, being created at a set frequency as a function of the applied DC potential, E. Since ECB is nearly identical to the flat band potential (Efb), it may be determined according to the Mott–Schottky relation,43,44i.e.,:
(6) |
(7) |
Fig. S11† shows that the positive slope was a typical characteristic of an n-type semiconductor of the as-prepared catalysts.43 The flat band potential of CN, S@CN and NiCo2O4 was −1.11, −0.97, and −1.3 V vs. Ag/AgCl, which was further converted to −0.91, −0.77 and −1.10 V vs. normal hydrogen electrode (NHE), respectively. For many n-type semiconductors, the ECB is about 0.1 V more negative than its flat-band potential. Therefore, the ECB of CN, S@CN and NiCo2O4 was roughly −1.01, −0.87 and −1.2 V (vs. NHE), respectively. The valence band potential (EVB) can be determined by the empirical equation, EVB = ECB + Eg. Consequently, the EVB of CN, S@CN and NiCo2O4 was 1.53, 1.53 and 0.33 V (vs. NHE), respectively.
Fig. 9 illustrates the reaction mechanism based on the direct Z-scheme heterojunction during the heterogeneous photocatalytic TC degradation on the reaction surface site of NiCo–S@CN catalysts. Confirmed by UV-vis reflectance spectra and Mott–Schottky results, in situ S doping changed the electronic structure and induced surface states near the bottom of the conduction band of CN, leading to a narrower bandgap (2.40 eV) and a downshift of the valence band from −1.2 eV to −0.87 eV. The result was in good agreement with EPR measurement that the signal intensity of HO˙ and O2˙− radicals of S@CN was lower than that of pure CN due to its lower reduction potential. Solar light irradiation of S@CN and NiCo2O4 photogenerated e− and h+ pairs on the CB and VB, respectively. The photoexcited e− on the CB of S@CN (−0.87 eV) migrated favourably, via the built-in electric field of the Z-scheme heterojunction between S@CN and NiCo2O4, to the VB of NiCo2O4 (+0.33 eV, NHE) because of a favourable redox potential difference.21,45 As a result, the strongly reducing e− on the CB of NiCo2O4 (−1.29 eV) and oxidizing h+ on the VB of S@CN were retained for subsequent reactions. In the conventional heterojunction system, if h+ from the VB of S@CN (+1.53 eV) migrated to the VB of NiCo2O4 (+0.33 eV), the oxidation potential of the accumulated h+ was not strong enough to directly oxidize TC species, which contradicted with the results of radical scavenging experiments.14,24,43 Therefore, the photocarrier transfer on NiCo–S@CN should essentially follow the Z-scheme mechanism, which reduced the probability of e−–h+ recombination.
The holes created at the VB of S@CN took part in the direct oxidation of TC, yielding by-product CO2 (pathway 1), while the electrons at the CB of NiCo2O4 were trapped by dissolved oxygen to produce superoxide radicals [E0(O2/O2˙−) = −0.33 V] (pathway 2).41 Nevertheless, holes lacked sufficient redox capability to create hydroxyl radicals [E0(OH/HO˙) = +2.38 V].33,41 As a result, hydroxyl radicals were generated indirectly. The superoxide radicals could be reduced to peroxyl (HO2˙) radicals [E0(O2/HO2˙) = −0.05 V] (pathways 3),5 and then further reactions of peroxyl radicals via pathways 4 and 5 resulted in the formation of more potent ROSs, such as highly reactive HO˙. Meanwhile, HO˙ and O2˙− radicals contributed directly to the oxidation of TC and further mineralized the degradation intermediates during the photocatalytic process (pathways 6 and 7).
(8) |
Results showed that COS increased from −0.52 to 1.3 as a function of oxidation time (Fig. 10a), which clearly indicated significant TC mineralization on NiCo–S@CN during the photocatalytic oxidation reaction.
Although complete degradation into small organic fragments and CO2 will decrease the toxicity of the parent compound,47 TC degradation intermediates can be more toxic than their parent compound.48 The toxicity change of aqueous solution was assessed with Microtox using luminescent bacteria (Vibrio fischeri) during 60 min of TC oxidation process. Fig. 10b shows that TC, at the original concentration of 10 mg L−1, exhibited a certain degree of biotoxicity to V. fischeri with a bioluminescence inhibition ratio of 52.3%. The inhibition ratio gradually decreased to 46.7% after 30 min, indicating the possible formation and accumulation of some highly toxic intermediates. Furthermore, the inhibition effect was significantly decreased to 5.7% after 60 min of photocatalytic treatment, which was much lower than that of the original TC. The results implied that although highly toxic intermediates were produced in the beginning period of the reaction, they could be further degraded into non-toxic chemicals and ultimately converted to relatively non-harmful CO2, HNO3, and H2O by ROSs generated during solar light activation of Z-scheme NiCo–S@CN.
To gain a better understanding of the TC degradation pathway in the NiCo–S@CN/solar light system, ultra-performance liquid chromatography coupled with time-of-flight mass spectrometry detector (UPLC/ToF MS) analysis was employed to identify TC oxidation intermediates. Fig. S12† shows the MS spectra and the possible molecular structure of intermediates from TC degradation (Fig. 10c). The photogenerated ˙OH favourably attacked the C11a position of TC because of high electron density at this position and generated the primary P1 product (m/z = 459). Further radical oxidation and rupture of the ring structures yielded P2 (m/z = 277), P3 (m/z = 186), and P4 (m/z = 167). These intermediates were subsequently converted to carbon dioxide, water, and other mineral substances. The results revealed that NiCo–S@CN was an effective solar-light-sensitive photocatalyst for the degradation of antibiotics such as TC.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: SEM/TEM images of S@CN, XPS survey spectra of as-prepared catalysts, kinetic curve, TOC removal efficiency, TC speciation and zeta potential as a function of pH, XPS spectra of NiCo–S@CN before and after photocatalytic degradation, Mott–Schottky plot, and MS spectra. See DOI: 10.1039/d1en00888a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |