Hamza Shaili*a,
Elmehdi Salmanib,
Mustapha Beraichc,
M'hamed Taibid,
Mustapha Rouchdia,
Hamid Ez-Zahraouyb,
Najem Hassanaina and
Ahmed Mzerda
aGroup of STCE-Energy Research Centre (ERC), Faculty of Science, Mohammed V University, B. P. 1014, Rabat, Morocco. E-mail: hamza.shaili13@gmail.com; Tel: +212604710051
bLaboratory of Condensed Matter and Interdisciplinary Sciences Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences, Mohammed V University, Rabat, Morocco
cLaboratory of Physics of Condensed Matter, Department of Physics, IbnTofail University, Kenitra, Morocco
dCSM, LPCMIO, Ecole Normale Supérieure, Mohammed V University, Rabat, Morocco
First published on 17th November 2021
The inorganic stannous-based perovskite oxide SrSnO3 has been utilized in various optoelectronic applications. Facilitating the synthesis process and engineering its properties, however, are still considered challenging due to several aspects. This paper reports on a thorough investigation of the influence of rare-earth (praseodymium) doping on the microstructural and optoelectronic properties of pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3 perovskite oxide thin films synthesized by a two-step simple chemical solution deposition route. Structural analysis indicated the high quality of the obtained phase and the alteration generated from the insertion of impurities. Surface scanning illustrated the formation of homogenous and crack-free SrSnO3 thin films with a nanorod morphology, with an augmentation in size as the dopant ratios increased. Optical properties analysis showed an enhancement in the samples optical absorption with wide-range bandgap tuning. First-principles calculations revealed the exchange interactions between the 3d–4f states and their impact on the electronic properties of the pristine material. Hall-effect measurements revealed an immense decrement in the resistivity of the films upon increment of doping ratios, passing from 7.3 × 10−2 Ω cm for the undoped sample to 4.8 × 10−2 Ω cm for 7% Pr content, while a reverse trend was observed on the carrier mobility, rising from 2.5 to 7.6 cm2 V−1 s−1 for 7% Pr content. The results emphasized the efficiency of the simple synthesis route to produce high-quality samples. The current findings will contribute to paving the way towards expanding the utilization of simple and cost-effective chemical solution deposition methods for the fast and large area growth of stannous-based perovskite oxides for optoelectronic applications.
Inorganic stannous-based perovskite oxides ASnO3 (A = Ca, Sr, Ba) represent a promising range of TCO candidates receiving growing interest as a non-toxic and eco-friendly alternative to their lead-based counterparts.4,5 Perovskite oxides are also regarded as very attractive hosts for doping, allowing for facile engineering of the characteristics of the pristine material. Furthermore, this attractive type of oxide is considered an important class of materials to be integrated into a wide range of applications, such as in ceramic technology as components of dielectric materials and gas-sensing applications,6 as substrates for superconductor applications,7 and in solar cell applications, mainly as electrodes for photostable perovskite solar cells.8–11 In contrast to other perovskites, such as the manganites AMnO3, stannate compounds add to their usefulness the absence of Jahn–Teller distortion.12,13
Among the stannous-based perovskite oxides, SrSnO3 is drawing great interest owing to its superior physico–chemical properties with enhanced performance on doping. Additionally, the constraint of larger bandgaps in this type of perovskite can be potentially overcome through the insertion of impurity elements to generate visible-light-absorbing sub-gap states. Recently, rare-earth elements have been extensively employed for the engineering of the properties of SrSnO3; in particular, lanthanum (La) has been utilized in several works for the capability of achieving a higher conductivity of the material and wide bandgap tuning. La-doped SrSnO3 thin films are considered a promising candidate in numerous applications, with a particular interest in optoelectronic devices.8,9
Several doping attempts employing other rare-earth elements have been conducted to modify the characteristics of SrSnO3.14–17 To the best of our knowledge, praseodymium (Pr) has never been utilized as a dopant to engineer the properties of SrSnO3 materials. Often, the synthesis procedure followed in the growth of SrSnO3 thin films is carried out using physical methods, including pulsed laser deposition18 and radio frequency magnetron sputtering.19 A limited number of reports have employed chemical methods; for example, the polymeric precursor method.20
Commonly, the previously mentioned synthesis routes utilize a complex and multi-step growth procedure, where complex, non-practical and expensive methods are employed alongside high annealing temperature and expensive substrates. In the present study, an easy-to-manipulate and cost-effective chemical solution deposition method (spray coating) has been adopted, allowing fast deposition onto a conductive substrate (Si (100) substrate, in our case), and its effect on the quality of the as-synthesized samples has been evaluated. Above all, a high-quality orthorhombic phase was achieved at a relatively low calcination temperature (800 °C) in comparison with previous reports. A doping process was conducted to engineer the properties of the SrSnO3 thin films using the rare-earth element praseodymium. The films were intensively characterized to identify the effect of Pr3+ ion insertion into the SrSnO3 host lattice, with a particular interest in the optical and electrical properties. Moreover, a theoretical part was included to support the experimental findings by performing ab initio calculations based on the density functional theory. The theoretical part allowed the identification of the doping effect on the electronic properties and its eventual effect on the overall properties.
The lattice parameters were calculated to determine the crystallographic defects on the orthorhombic pristine structure and the impact of doping fractions on the lattice parameters distortion by means of the following equation:
![]() | (1) |
Fig. 3 illustrates the variation of the calculated parameters as a function of the dopant content. The values for the pristine sample matched correctly with previously reported results for the SrSnO3 orthorhombic structure.17,25 It was noticeable that the substitution of Sr2+ by the Pr3+ in the SrSnO3 pristine structure generated strain along all the axis, as indicated in Fig. 3a. The lattice parameters (a, b and c) showed the same trend, where the lattice constants were increased upon Pr addition. This decrease may be attributed to various factors, such as the concentration of the dopant, defects (vacancies, interstitial, dislocation), external strain developed due to calcination temperature and the difference between the ionic radii of Pr3+ (1.18 Å) compared to Sr2+ (1.44 Å), which should result in compression in the pristine lattice. However, the experimental values showed the opposite, this may be due to the partial substitution of Sn4+ by Pr4+ (coordination = 6) (r(Sn4+) = 0.69 and r(Pr4+) = 0.85), which allowed an increase in the lattice parameters as indicated earlier through the decreasing intensities. The structure remained orthorhombic and was not tailored by the insertion of different ratios of Pr3+ into the SrSnO3 lattice. The crystalline size was calculated using the Debye–Scherrer's formula:
![]() | (2) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Calculated parameters of the pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3. (a) Lattice constants and (b) crystallite size and FWHM variation as a function of Pr content. |
Vibrational analysis of the material under investigation is essential to emphasize the purity and crystallinity of the prepared samples and to identify the dopant insertion effect on the vibrational modes of the pristine structure. Therefore, this part consisted of an in-depth analysis of the samples employing both FT-IR and typical Raman analysis at room temperature. The FT-IR analysis results of the films with different concentrations of Pr recorded at room temperature within the region of 450–2000 cm−1 are shown in Fig. 4. The orthorhombic phase of SrSnO3 with the Pbnm space group had 25 IR active modes at Γ of the Brillouin zone, given by the irreducible representations:
ΓIR = 9B1u + 7B2u + 9B3u | (3) |
The undoped sample showed multiple modes at different positions, starting with the widest one at 1464 cm−1, which was attributed to the N–O band linked to the nitrate present in the precursors. The bands between 2800 and 3000 cm−1 were assigned to different types of O–H stretching. The band at 1033 cm−1 was attributed to the asymmetric stretching vibration of Sn–OH bonds, while the bands located at 840 cm−1 were attached to O–Sn–O asymmetric stretching vibration of SnO3. The band at 612 cm−1 was due to the presence of stannate (SnO32−) vibrations.26 The peak located at 524 cm−1 was attached to the presence of stretching vibrations of Sn–O bands, and this trend confirmed the existence of SnO6 octahedral tilting in all the compounds.27,28 Several extra weak peaks appeared between 400 and 500 cm−1 and were associated with the Pr–O molecular vibrations originating from the octahedral coordination PrO6. Indeed, the FT-IR analysis results confirmed the presence of metal–oxygen vibrations with the detection of other active IR modes, which was consistent with the XRD analysis and confirmed the effective formation of the SrSnO3 compound in the orthorhombic structure.
Raman analysis of the samples collected at room temperature was performed to determine the local structure of the samples, to better inspect the presence of secondary phases, and to identify the Pr doping effect on the vibrational modes of the pristine structure, as presented in Fig. 5. According to previous extensive Raman analysis, the orthorhombic phase of SrSnO3 has 24 active Raman modes presented as follow:
ΓRaman = 7Ag + 5B1g + 7B2g + 5B3g | (4) |
The equation contains four antisymmetric with two symmetric octahedral stretching modes, four bending modes, and six octahedral rotation or tilt modes. The remaining eight modes are associated with the strontium cations. The Raman analysis of the undoped SrSnO3 thin film revealed several vibrational modes with two intense peaks located at 225 and 256 cm−1, corresponding both to the Ag mode.26 Multiple other peaks were detected at 111, 145, 160, 402 and 634 cm−1 and also matched with the usually recorded Raman modes for orthorhombic (Pbnm) SrSnO3.26,29 All these modes were due to the first-order Raman scatterings, which is a signature of distortion from the ideal cubic perovskite because, in ideal perovskites, no first-order Raman scattering is possible.13 As the dopant ratios were inserted, a slight shifting in position was observed, particularly for the main modes. The Ag active mode for the doped samples showed a slight shift towards a higher wavenumber (231 cm−1) when compared to the undoped film (225 cm−1). This revealed that the Pr3+ cations had effectively replaced the Sr2+ sites and consequently affected the Sr–O bonds. No change in modes was observed. Thus, the doping process had no effect on changing the modes or altering the structural properties of the pure sample. Furthermore, an intense decrement of the modes intensities was observed with a slight fading of the smaller modes. The Raman analysis, thus, further authenticated the formation of the orthorhombic SrSnO3 (Pbnm) compound with high crystallinity.
Morphological properties scanning is a substantial step in evaluating the quality of prepared samples and thereby their effect on the stacking and construction of the anticipated devices. Hence, a full thorough scanning of the surface quality was performed by means of field emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM) alongside energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDX) to evaluate the modifications induced by Pr doping on the quality, grain size and composition of the films. Fig. 6 exhibits the FE-SEM images of the pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3 films deposited onto Si (100) substrate and annealed at 800 °C. Fig. 6a displays a top-view image of the prepared film. The samples generally possessed textured, crack-free and homogeneous surfaces with a uniform distribution along the substrate. The image manifests the efficiency of the synthesis route followed in producing high-quality and uniform films. Moreover, the micrograph in Fig. 6b displays the formation of high-density nanorods with varying sizes for the pure film. It is noticeable from the images that small spherical grains were formed, which may be attributed to the limited number of Sr and Sn clusters and secondary phases. By increasing the dopant content, an augmentation of the size of the nanorods was observed and the size continued to increase as the dopant fraction increased, as presented in Fig. 6c. This augmentation demonstrated the effective insertion of Pr ions in SrSnO3 pristine lattice, as mentioned earlier in the structural analysis results, indicating the correlation between the structural and morphological results. Fig. 6d displays a cross-sectional view of the prepared films. The thicknesses of the films were measured as being between 180 and 200 nm, indicating the high quality of the prepared samples and their compatibility for facile device stacking.
EDX analysis and atomic mapping were performed to analyze the compositional elements of the prepared samples and the distribution of the elements along the prepared surfaces. Fig. 7a illustrates the EDX data collected for the pure and doped samples. The results confirmed the presence of sufficient quantities of the main elements (Sr, Sn, O), indicating the high purity and near-stoichiometric nature of the samples with a rich oxygen content. The detected Si signal was assigned to the Si (100) substrate as a result of the difference between the thicknesses of the films and the high EDX interaction volume and penetration depth of the electron beam. This may slightly reduce the accuracy of the EDX quantitative analysis. Furthermore, the existence of the dopant element Pr was confirmed in the doped films with the variant ratios added as gathered in Table 1. The stoichiometry was slightly unbalanced as the dopant ratios increased. Furthermore, elemental atomic mapping was implemented to further probe the distribution of the elements along the surfaces and their quantification with high precision. The mapping images confirmed the presence of the main elements with equal distribution along the surfaces of films. In addition, the images show an orderly repartition of the elements with a higher concentration for the oxygen element and a small fraction for the Pr element.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 (a) EDX analysis spectrum and (b) atomic mapping (Sr, Sn, O, Pr) images of Pr-doped SrSnO3 thin films. |
Samples | Atomic percentages | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Sr | Sn | O | Pr | |
SrSnO3 | 23.93 | 24.21 | 51.86 | 0 |
SrSnO3:Pr3+ (3%) | 23.73 | 24.19 | 51.28 | 0.8 |
SrSnO3:Pr3+ (5%) | 23.49 | 24.24 | 51.07 | 1.2 |
SrSnO3:Pr3+ (7%) | 23.37 | 24.22 | 50.71 | 1.7 |
Since rare-earth elements are well known as an effective dopant commonly used to engineer the optical properties of metal oxides, the optical properties of the films were collected to assess the trivalent Pr3+ insertion effect on the absorption and band gap tuning of the pristine film. Consequently, the UV-Vis-NIR absorption spectra of the pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3 thin films are illustrated in Fig. 8a. All the films exhibited strong absorption in the UV light region (200–400 nm), with a notable decrement in the visible region, which continued to decrease exponentially as the wavelength value increased in the near-infrared (NIR) region. The absorption edge of the doped films was slightly shifted towards higher wavelengths as the Pr fractions increased. In addition, the dopant incorporation caused the absorption to decrease in the UV light region and increase in the visible region and onward, showing a reverse trend from the undoped film. The results manifested the effect of Pr3+ insertion on tuning the optical properties of metal oxide materials, which has been reported before.17 It could be clearly seen that the doping process enhanced the photon-absorption ability of the films in the visible and near-infrared region, which is quite suitable for optoelectronic applications. To further evaluate the doping effect on the band gap of the samples, the band gaps of the pristine and Pr-doped SrSnO3 were calculated using a Tauc plot:
(αhν) = A(hν − Eg)n | (5) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 (a) Optical absorbance as a function of the wavelength. (b) The plots of (αhν)1/2 versus hν and (c) band gap variation of the pristine and Pr-doped SrSnO3 thin films. |
This part consists of theoretical calculations that were mainly carried out to uncover the nature of the bonds formed between the different elements and to investigate the electronic and optical properties of the material under investigation. Herein, the calculations were conducted in order to strengthen the experimental findings regarding the properties of the pristine material and to inspect the effect of the strongly correlated 4f state of Pr insertion on the electronic and optical properties of the SrSnO3 perovskite compound. Therefore, the results from first-principle calculations will permit an overall assessment of the alterations on the properties of the material under investigation. Fig. 9 exhibits the projectile and total density of states of the pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3 compounds calculated using LDA and SIC-LDA approximations as a function of energy. For the dos produced by regular LDA, the conduction band minima (CB) of SrSnO3 is composed essentially of Sr-3d states and a negligible contribution from O-2p, while the valence band maxima (VB) is largely dominated by the O-2p states. The calculated band gap was estimated at 2.46 eV. Commonly, regular LDA approximation usually tends to underestimate the optical and electronic properties of the material under investigation, leading to the non-consideration of the exchange and the correlation effects in metal oxide materials and causing important self-interaction errors.30 This underestimation of the band gap by LDA is due to the lack of a discontinuity in this exchange–correlation potential. Thus, the self-interaction correction (SIC) was integrated to enhance the accuracy of the obtained properties. LDA-SIC approximation is generally viewed as an extension of regular LDA, where the Kohn–Sham wave function is projected onto a set of localized basis orbital's and the SIC approximation is governed by the energy difference between the energy gain due to hybridization of the orbital with the valence band and the energy gain upon localization of the orbital.31 After the SIC correction, the band gap increased to reach 3.12 eV as expected. Typically, doping a semiconductor obligates the Fermi level to shift towards higher energy values due to the fact that the doping process enhances the stability of the compound corresponding to the low energies. Plus, the Fermi energy shifts towards the conduction band after doping and this is due to the fact that the valence band shifts into the lower energy region much more than that of the conduction band. The application of SIC approximations permitted properly dealing with the 4f states in SrSnO3 lattice doped with the rare-earth (RE = Pr) compound due to the existence of f-electrons. As for the SIC-LDA approximation, the same applies to the conduction band, with growing domination from the O-2p states spotted in the valence band, as can be seen from Fig. 9. After the first doping percentage was inserted, a major contribution from the Pr-4f states was observed, especially in the valence band, and the band gap decreased to 2.53 eV. For the 7% Pr content, we can notice that the contribution of the Pr-4f states increased and dominated both the valence and conduction bands, leading the band gap to shrink and further reduce to 2.12 eV. This decrease in the band gap was mainly attributed to the 3d–4f strong exchange interactions. Previous works reporting rare-earth doping indicated a similar outcome; for instance, Abdul Majid et al. reported that the 3d–4f exchange interactions are more fragile than 3d–3d because of the strongly localized nature of 4f orbitals in rare-earth atoms.32 A first proposition that provided an explanation of 3d–4f interactions was suggested by Campbell.33 Similar to that, Brooks et al. further discussed in detail how 4f localized electrons polarize 5d states, which then interact with 3d orbitals.34 Indeed, the DFT calculations permitted an accurate and overall analysis of the electronic and optical properties of the pristine compound alongside inspecting the effect of the rare-earth (praseodymium) doping on engineering its properties in a constructive manner. The results confirmed the fact that the Pr3+ incorporation enhanced the optical and electrical properties of the samples.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 Calculated partial and total density of states of the pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3 (a) 0% with LDA approximation, and (b) 0% with LDA-SIC, (c) 3%, (d) 5% and (e) 7% Pr content. |
Assessing the electrical properties of thin film materials and the defects generated from impurities insertion is essential to evaluate their potential for optoelectronic applications. Therefore, it is important to conduct a thorough evaluation of the electrical properties of the prepared samples and the alterations resulting from the doping process, thereby evaluating their potential for further applications. The electrical properties of the pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3 thin films were collected at T = 300 K to unveil the semiconducting nature of the films, and to examine the alterations on the conductivity and carrier mobility generated from the Pr3+ doping effect. Fig. 10 displays the collected electrical properties employing the van der Pauw configuration in the presence of a magnetic field and their variation as a function of doping content. The values of the Hall coefficient (RH) indicated that all the samples had n-type conductivity, as indicated previously.16,17 As for the films resistivity, an immense decrement was observed upon the doping ratios increase passing from 7.3 × 10−2 Ω cm for the undoped sample to 4.8 × 10−2 Ω cm for 7% Pr content. This proves once again that rare-earth element doping (in our case praseodymium) is effective in enhancing the conductivity of oxide thin film materials. For the carrier concentration, a reverse tendency to the resistivity was detected, where the value for the undoped sample jumped from 3.4 × 1019 to 6.1 × 1019 cm−3 for 7% Pr content. The same variation was noticed on the carrier mobility, which increased from 2.5 to 7.6 cm2 V−1 s−1. The increment of the carrier mobility by the doping insertion effect was suggested earlier by the structural results and FE-SEM scanning by the augmentation in the nanorod sizes. Thus, the Pr-doped SrSnO3 thin film possessed superior electrical properties in comparison to the pristine material, showing the capability of Pr3+ as a dopant to enhance the characteristics of stannous-based perovskite oxides.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 Electrical properties (resistivity, carrier concentration, and mobility) of the pure and Pr-doped SrSnO3 films as a function of Pr content collected at room temperature. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |