Akiko Asano*,
Katsuhiko Minoura,
Yuki Kojima,
Taishi Yoshii,
Ryoya Ito,
Takeshi Yamada
,
Takuma Kato
and
Mitsunobu Doi
Osaka University of Pharmaceutical Sciences, 4-20-1 Nasahara, Takatsuki, Osaka 569-1094, Japan. E-mail: asano@gly.oups.ac.jp; Fax: +81-72-690-1005; Tel: +81-72-690-1066
First published on 9th September 2020
Ascidiacyclamide [cyclo(-Ile1,5-oxazoline2,6-D-Val3,7-thiazole4,8-)] (1) is a cytotoxic cyclic peptide from the ascidian, or sea squirt. Through structural analyses using asymmetric analogues [Xxx1: Ala (2), Val (3), Leu (4), Phe (5), cyclohexylalanine (6) and phenylglycine (7)], we previously showed 1 to exist in a conformational equilibrium between square and folded forms. In the present study, five new asymmetric analogues [Xxx1: 2-aminobutyric acid (8), 2-aminopentyric acid (9), tert-butylalanine (10), cyclohexylglycine (11) and tert-leucine (12)] were synthesized, and their structures were analyzed with X-ray diffraction and CD spectral measurements. Variable temperature 1H NMR measurements were performed to determine their equilibrium constants and their thermodynamic parameters. The use of two reference peptides made these quantitative studies possible. T3ASC, which contains three thiazole rings as a result of replacing oxazoline2 with thiazole, and dASC, in which the two oxazoline rings were deleted, were respectively used as square and folded reference peptides. The estimated parameters enabled more detailed discussion of the relationship between the bulkiness of substituents and the conformational free energies (ΔG°) of the peptides as well as the relationship between structure and cytotoxicity. The ΔG° values for peptides 1, 2, 3, 8, 9 and 11 decreased with decreases in the bulkiness of their substituents. We suggest that spontaneous folding is promoted as the bulkiness of substituents decreases. Peptides 7 and 12, which have large positive ΔG° values independently of temperature, did not exhibit spontaneous folding at any temperature; that is, their conformations were very stable in the square form. Peptides 4, 5, 6 and 10 had negative ΔG° values, despite their bulky substituents. Peptides with a positive ΔG° value showed cytotoxicity, and peptides with a negative ΔG° value showed reduced or no cytotoxicity. However, peptides 5 and 6 showed cytotoxicity equal to or stronger than 1. Those ten peptides except for 5 and 6 showed a clear structure–cytotoxicity relationship based on ΔG° values.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Chemical structures of 1 and the side chains (R) of the Xxx1 residues in the asymmetric analogues (2–12). Peptides 1–7 are the previously synthesized.2–9 Peptides 8–12 are new asymmetric analogues. |
In 1955, the A values of substituent as the free energy difference between the axial and equatorial isomers of monosubstituted cyclohexanes were defined by Winstein and Holness.11 The equatorial isomer becomes predominant as the corresponding size of substituent grows, and the A values increase concomitantly. This parameter is a very useful resource to assess the steric size of variety of substituents. Many other conformational analyses using cyclohexane and its analogues have been carried out in an effort to understand steric repulsion within a molecule.12–17 We were interested in assessing the conformational equilibrium quantitatively to better understand the conformational behavior of ascidiacyclamides. In order to determine the equilibrium constants experimentally, it is necessary to observe an independent signal from each conformer. However, the signals from a small peptide like ascidiacyclamides equilibrate rapidly between the two conformers on the NMR time scale. It is often possible to slow down the equilibration of the signals by measuring at low temperatures, but in the case of ascidiacyclamides, the signals corresponding to the two conformers were still not separated when the temperature was lowered to −60 °C in acetonitrile-d3 solution. To overcome this limitation with small peptides, NMR-based quantitative studies of β-sheet populations have been carried out using reference peptides for the folded and unfolded states.18,19 For instance, to determine the β-sheet populations of flexible linear peptides, disulfide-linked cyclic peptides (or backbone cyclization) and residue truncated peptides were used as controls to provide reference chemical shifts for the fully folded and random coil states, respectively. We therefore searched for square and folded reference peptides to apply this strategy to ascidiacyclamides. The results showed that the T3ASC and dASC analogues were potential models for the fully square and folded states, respectively (Fig. 3). T3ASC, cyclo(-Ile1-Thz2-D-Val3-Thz4-Ile5-Oxz6-D-Val7-Thz8-) contains three Thz rings, as the Oxz2 ring was replaced with a Thz2 ring. The crystal structure of T3ASC exhibited a square form very similar to that of 1 (The RMS deviation = 0.351 Å) (Fig. S43†), and most T3ASC molecules reportedly retain the square form even in solution.20 On the other hand, dASC, cyclo(-Ile-alloThr-D-Val-Thz-)2, which lacks the Oxz rings of 1, assumes a folded form in both solid and solution states (Fig. S44†).21 Asymmetric modifications were also made in dASC, but unlike 1, all dASC analogues were folded, regardless of the bulkiness of the side chain of the replaced amino acid. The folded conformation of dASC was stabilized by four intramolecular hydrogen bonds, making it unable to transform to the square form from the folded form, and it exhibited no cytotoxicity.21,22
In the present study, five new asymmetric acidiacyclamide analogues [Xxx1: 2-aminobutyric acid (Abu) (8), 2-aminopentyric acid (Nva) (9), tert-butylalanine (Tbu) (10), cyclohexylglycine (Chg) (11) and tert-leucine (Tle) (12)] were synthesized (Fig. 1). We first describe their structural characterization using X-ray diffraction and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, and then discuss the NMR-based quantification of the conformational equilibrium for 1 and eleven asymmetric analogues (the aforementioned six analogues, 2–7, and five new analogues, 8–12).
Peptide | Donor | Acceptor | Distance (Å) | Angle (°) |
---|---|---|---|---|
D–H | A | D⋯A | D–H⋯A | |
a A letter of W represents the oxygen atom of water. | ||||
10 | N(Tbu1)–H | O(DMF9) | 3.104(2) | 163.2 |
N(Ile5)–H | O(DMF10) | 2.928(2) | 163.7 | |
11 | N(Chg1)–H | W | 3.262(7) | 137.3 |
N(D-Val3)–H | O(DMA9) | 2.904(6) | 169.2 | |
N(Ile5)–H | W | 3.247(7) | 137.5 | |
N(D-Val7)–H | O(DMA10) | 2.916(6) | 168.3 | |
W–H | N(Oxz2) | 2.835(7) | 165.5 | |
W–H | N(Oxz6) | 2.831(7) | 137.9 | |
12 | N(Tle1)–H | O(DMF9) | 3.161(6) | 167.4 |
N(Ile5)–H | O(DMF10) | 3.161(6) | 167.4 |
We have been using the diagonal distance between the nitrogen atoms of the two Oxz and Thz rings (N(Oxz2)⋯N(Oxz6) and N(Thz4)⋯N(Thz8)) as an index to characterize the square form in crystal.2,7–9 These distances in the crystals of 10, 11 and 12 are listed together with the previously collected data for 1 in Table 2. Whereas the diagonal distances in 10 and 12 are similar to that in 1, the N(Oxz2)⋯N(Oxz6) distance is shorter and the N(Thz4)⋯N(Thz8) distance is longer in 11 than in 1. Thus, 10 and 12 were classified as being in the original square form, while 11 exhibited different diagonal distances but was open. In previous X-ray analyses, the crystal structures of 2 and 5 were classified as being in the folded form,6,7 and the crystal structures of 1, 3, 4, 6 and 7 were classified as being in the square form.2,7–9
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 CD spectral changes elicited by titration of TFE for peptides 1 and 8–12. The CD spectra for 1 were taken from a previous report.7 The spectra were measured in CH3CN solution while changing the TFE concentration (10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50% and 100%). The spectra in 100% CH3CN and 100% TFE solution are drawn in bold and dashed lines, respectively. |
The spectral changes observed with 11 showed the same features as 1 in this solvent system. The conformation of 11 in CH3CN solution was the square form, which was converted to the folded form through TFE titration. The spectra for 3 had similar features.7 The spectrum of 12 in CH3CN solution had the same shape as that of 1, but the spectral changes elicited by TFE titration were very small and were very similar to those of 7.9 The spectrum of 10 exhibited the features of the folded form, even in CH3CN solution, and TFE titration elicited little change. The spectra of 2, 4, 5 and 6 have also been exhibited folded form.7,8 In crystal, however, 2 and 5 were in the folded form, while 4, 6 and 10 assumed the square form. The spectral features of 8 and 9 were very similar to each other. They did not exhibit a clear negative band around 245 nm in CH3CN solution, as 1 did, but a single isodichroic point at around 230 nm was observed. Previously recorded CD spectra for 2–7 are shown in Fig. S41.†
We also evaluated the temperature dependencies of the CD spectra of ascidiacyclamides in CH3CN solution at 273, 293, 313 and 333 K. The temperature dependencies of 1, T3ASC, dASC and 8–12 are shown in Fig. 6; those of peptides 2–7 are shown in Fig. S42.† The [θ]245 values decreased as temperature increased in all ascidiacyclamides spectra, except those of T3ASC, 7 and 12. Peptides 1, 3 and 11, which exhibited a negative band at 245 nm at low temperature, showed a slight decrease in [θ]245 with increasing temperature. By contrast, peptides 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9 and 10 all showed strong temperature dependencies, with a positive band in the range of 230–260 at low temperature. In particular, a clear negative band at 245 nm appeared for 8 and 9 as the temperature increased. The spectrum of dASC also showed a positive band in the range of 230–260 nm at low temperature. However, the decrease in [θ]245 with increasing temperature of dASC was slight compared with these peptides. The spectra of T3ASC, 7 and 12 were little affected by increasing temperature. These observations suggest the following:
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Temperature dependence of the CD spectra of peptides 1, 8–12, T3ASC and dASC. The CD spectra for 1 are taken from a previous report.29 The spectra were measured every 20 K in CH3CN solution at 273–333 K. The CD spectra at 273 and 333 K are drawn in bold and dashed lines, respectively. |
(1) The conformation of ascidiacyclamide changes from the folded form to the square form with increasing temperature.
(2) T3ASC, 7 and 12 in CH3CN solution form the most stable square form against temperature increases.
(3) dASC in CH3CN solution forms the most stable folded form against temperature increases.
Peptide | Xxx1NH | D-Val3NH | Ile5NH | D-Val7NH | ThzHa | ThzHa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a The chemical shifts of Thz4H and Thz8H were indistinguishable.b The temperature coefficients of these peptides have already been reported.7 However, they were measured again because different NMR equipment was used in this study.c dASC also includes allo-Thr2NH and allo-Thr6NH. The temperature coefficient for both was −2.3 ppb K−1.d The correlation coefficients were less than 0.9.e The chemical shifts of D-Val3NH and D-Val7NH were indistinguishable. | ||||||
1b | 2.0 | 0.0 | 2.0 | 0.0 | 1.9 | 1.9 |
2b | 2.0 | 1.6 | 2.2 | 1.0 | 3.9 | 3.9 |
3b | 2.3 | 0.6 | 2.9 | 0.9 | 2.9 | 3.1 |
4b | 1.9 | 0.7 | 2.4 | 1.5 | 3.3 | 3.3 |
5b | 1.1 | 0.7 | 2.1 | 1.0 | 3.5 | 3.2 |
6 | 2.0 | 0.9 | 2.5 | 1.5 | 3.5 | 3.5 |
7 | —d | −2.2 | −0.7 | −1.4 | 0.0 | —d |
8 | 2.2 | —d | 2.7 | 1.0 | 3.3 | 3.3 |
9 | 2.0 | —d,e | 2.5 | 0.9e | 3.0 | 3.2 |
10 | —d | 0.6 | 2.0 | 1.4 | 2.5 | 2.7 |
11 | 2.5 | —d,e | 2.1 | 0.5e | 2.0 | 2.0 |
12 | 0.0 | —d | 0.0 | —d | 0.0 | 0.0 |
T3ASC | 0.0 | —d | 0.0 | —d | 0.0 | 0.0 |
dASCc | −1.1 | −1.3 | −1.1 | −1.3 | 1.3 | 1.3 |
K = (δS − δobs)/(δobs − δF) | (1) |
For 1–12, values of K and the Gibbs free energy (ΔG°) were measured every 10 K from 237 K to 333 K (Tables S30, S32, S34, S36, S38, S40, S42, S44, S46, S48, S50 and S51†). In addition, ΔG° at 298 K was estimated from the thermodynamic parameters of ascidiacyclamide and the asymmetric analogues. The enthalpy (ΔH°) and entropy (ΔS°) were determined through a linear van't Hoff plot (lnK versus 1/T), and then ΔG° at 298 K was calculated from eqn (2). For 7 and 12, we could not obtain their values of ΔH° and ΔS° by a van't Hoff plot because their K values showed no temperature dependencies.
ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS° = −RT![]() ![]() | (2) |
These values are listed in Table 4. Folding of ascidiacyclamides was enthalpically favorable and entropically unfavorable. This thermodynamic profile is considered reasonable because four hydrogen bonds are formed by folding: N(Xxx1)H⋯Oγ(Oxz6), N(D-Val3)H⋯O(Thz8), N(Ile5)H⋯Oγ(Oxz2) and N(D-Val7)H⋯O(Thz4). The average values of ΔH° and ΔS° were respectively determined to be −13.55 (2.06) kJ mol−1 and −43.72 (4.71) J K−1 mol−1, and there were no significant differences in these values among ascidiacyclamides. The ΔG° values for both 7 and 12 were positive and very large, which means that the conformational equilibrium positions of 7 and 12 are significantly shifted in the opposite direction. As shown in Fig. 7, within the measured temperature range, the ΔG° values for 1 and 11 are positive at every temperature, suggesting that there is no spontaneous folding. The ΔG° values for 3 are positive at higher temperatures but negative below 278 K. Peptides 8 and 9 will fold spontaneously at temperatures below 303 K. Peptides 4, 5 and 6 will fold spontaneously at temperatures below 333 K, and the ΔG° values are near zero at around 333 K. Peptide 10 appears to spontaneously fold at any temperature.
Peptide | ΔH° (kJ mol−1) | ΔS° (J K−1 mol−1) | |
---|---|---|---|
a ΔH° and ΔS° values were determined from the linear fitting to the van't Hoff equation.b Since the chemical shifts of Thz4H and Thz8H were observed separately, these parameters were determined in duplicate. The values with the larger correlation coefficient are given here.c The temperature dependence of the equilibrium constant (K) is not shown. The ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|||
1a | −9.55 | −39.40 | 2.19 |
2a | −16.76 | −52.29 | −1.03 |
3a,b | −13.60 | −49.00 | 1.00 |
4a | −14.83 | −44.67 | −1.52 |
5a,b | −15.80 | −47.50 | −1.64 |
6a | −15.80 | −47.60 | −1.62 |
7c | — | — | 4.32 |
8a | −13.83 | −45.23 | −0.35 |
9a,b | −13.23 | −44.18 | −0.06 |
10a,b | −14.14 | −38.59 | −2.64 |
11a | −9.85 | −39.55 | 1.93 |
12c | — | — | 4.91 |
The ΔG° values at 298 K for all ascidiacyclamides are arranged in descending order in Fig. 8. These results allow for a logical discussion that takes into account the counterpoise between the bulkiness of substituents in the Xxx1 and Ile5 residues. Symmetric peptide (1) showed a preference for the square form in CH3CN-d3 solution at 298 K, with a ΔG° value of 2.19 kJ mol−1, while 11, which contains a cyclohexyl group, had nearly the same ΔG° value as 1. Comparison among peptides 1, 2, 3, 8 and 9 revealed that the ΔG° value decreased with a decrease in the carbon number of the substituent. In addition, although peptides 3 and 9 have the same number of carbon atoms in their side chains, the ΔG° value was smaller for 9, which has a linear alkyl group, than for 3, which has a branched alkyl group (sec-butyl (1) > isopropyl (3) > n-propyl (9) > ethyl (8) > methyl (2)). The ΔG° value for 9 was nearly zero, and those of 2 and 8 were negative, indicating a preference for the folded form. In the square form, the side chain of the Xxx1 residue is close to the sec-butyl group of the Ile5 residue, and we suggest that the attractive force between these two functional groups is greater than the repulsive force. Consequently, with a decrease in the bulkiness of the substituent in the Xxx1 residue, the attractive force will be weakened, and the peptide will be easier to fold. Peptides 4, 5, 6 and 10 had even greater preferences for the folded form. The ΔG° value for 10 was −2.64 kJ mol−1, which was the minimum value, but those of 4, 5 and 6 were nearly the same. The common feature for the substituents of 4, 5, 6 and 10 is a β-methylene. This spacer may reduce contacts between the Xxx1 and Ile5 residues within these peptides. By contrast, peptides 7 and 12 had strong preferences for the square form. Although the tert-butyl group (12) and sec-butyl group (1) are both four carbon alkyl groups, the former is branched and therefore may exert a greater dispersion force. While it is apparent that the van der Waals space occupied by a cyclohexyl group (11) is larger than that occupied by a planarity phenyl group (7), the ΔG° for 7 was nevertheless significantly greater than that for 11. A dispersion force like the CH–π interaction may be acting between the phenyl group of the Phg1 residue and sec-butyl group of the Ile5 residue. The additional attractive force may increase the stability of the square form, though that could not be verified here. Still, the very high stabilities of square forms of 7 and 12 are noteworthy.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Plots of the free energies for peptides 1–12 at 298 K in descending order. The chemical structures in the figure are the side chains of the Xxx1 residues. |
Peptide | ED50 (μg mL−1) | Structure in solid | Structure in solution |
---|---|---|---|
a These are taken from a previous report.7b This datum is taken from a previous report.2c This datum is taken from a previous report.6d These data are taken from a previous report.8e These data are taken from a previous report.9f These crystal structures have not obtained yet.g These data are taken from a previous report.20h This datum is taken from a previous report.22i This datum is taken from a previous report.21 | |||
1 | 10.5a | Squareb | ![]() |
2 | 49.0a | Foldeda | ![]() |
3 | 7.4a | Squarea | ![]() |
4 | 29.5a | Squarec | ![]() |
5 | 11.8a | Foldeda | ![]() |
6 | 5.6d | Squared | ![]() |
7 | 12.4e | Squaree | ![]() |
8 | >100 | —f | ![]() |
9 | 18.7 | —f | ![]() |
10 | >100 | Square | ![]() |
11 | 3.4 | Square | ![]() |
12 | 5.5 | Square | ![]() |
T3ASC | 0.93g | Squareg | — |
dASC | >100h | Foldedi | — |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2007056–2007058. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/d0ra07396b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |