Xiong Yanga,
Jing Zhoua,
Xiaoling Xinga,
Yafeng Huanga,
Zhengfeng Yana,
Qi Xuea,
Xiaofeng Wang*a and
Bozhou Wang*ab
aXi'an Modern Chemistry Research Institute, Xi'an, 710065, China. E-mail: wbz600@163.com; wangxf_204@163.com
bState Key Laboratory of Fluorine & Nitrogen Chemical, Xi'an, 710065, China
First published on 14th July 2020
3,3′-Bi(1,2,4-oxadiazole)-5,5′-diylbis(methylene)dinitrate (BOM) is a liquid phase carrier for melt cast explosives that is expected to replace TNT. The combination of a conjugated 1,2,4-oxadiazole backbone and nitrate ester groups endows BOM with both good energetic performance and impressive insensitivity. In this paper, the thermal behaviors of BOM were investigated using a TG–DSC synchronous thermal analyzer, proving that BOM is basically non-volatile under heating and melting processes. The apparent activation energy of BOM calculated by the Kissinger method was 158.2 kJ mol−1 at atmospheric pressure, which is higher than that of DNTF at atmospheric pressure and TNT at 2 MPa, indicating good thermal stability at low temperatures. The thermal decomposition mechanism of BOM was studied through both DSC-MS and in situ FTIR technologies. The low eutectic characteristics of BOM and DNTF were also investigated carefully and the best ratio of BOM/DNTF was 40/60 with a melting point at 75.5 °C. Finally, the detonation performances of TNT/HMX, BOM/HMX and BOM/DNTF(40/60)/HMX explosive formulations were calculated, showing that the detonation performances of the latter two formulations were significantly higher than that of TNT/HMX.
Exp | MP, °C | ρ, g cm−3 | D, km s−1 | P, GPa | Si, H50, cm | Sf |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BOM | 85.8 | 1.823 | 8.18 | 28.1 | 8.6 J | 282 N |
TNT | 80.8 | 1.64 | 6.94 | 21 | H50 = 79 | 4–6% |
DNAN | 94.5 | 1.34 | 5.60 | 7.02 | H50 = 220 | 170 N |
TNAZ | 101 | 1.84 | 8.73 | 37.2 | H50 = 21 | 353 N |
DNTF | 110 | 1.937 | 9.25 | 41.1 | H50 = 20 | 84% |
MTNI | 82 | 1.78 | 8.80 | 35.5 | H50 = 100 | 252 N |
DNP | 86 | 1.81 | 8.24 | 28.8 | — | — |
MDNT | 98 | 1.676 | 7.66 | — | H50 = 100 | 252 N |
MTNP | 91 | 1.83 | 8.96 | 33.5 | — | — |
DNBF | 85 | 1.85 | 8.80 | 35.6 | H50 = 12 | — |
ADN | 92 | 1.82 | — | — | H50 = 24 | 72% |
DINA | 51.3 | 1.488 | 7.58 | 28.6 | — | — |
NG-N1 | 66 | 1.799 | 8.84 | 32.6 | 14 J | 96 N |
TNE | 86 | 1.92 | 9.1 | 40 | 2.7 J | 75 N |
TTA | 94 | 1.54 | 5.68 | — | — | — |
BOM is a newly discovered liquid carrier for melt cast explosives. As shown in Fig. 1, the structure of BOM successfully combines a conjugated isofurazan backbone with oxidative nitrate ester groups, achieving both good energetic performance and impressive insensitivity. A preliminary study showed that the melting point of BOM is only 85.8 °C, while the thermal decomposition temperature reaches 200 °C, showing attractive application prospects as a carrier for melt cast explosives. The energy level of BOM is about 1.5 times the TNT equivalent with a density of 1.823 g cm−3 and a detonation velocity of 8180 m s−1. With an impact sensitivity of 8.6 J and a friction sensitivity of 282 N, the safety performance of BOM is even better than that of RDX. Moreover, BOM has also been proved as an environmentally-friendly explosive molecule.9 All of these make BOM an ideal alternative to TNT.
As a potential carrier for melt cast explosives, systematic studies on the thermal behaviors and decompositions of BOM are important for its future applications. Herein, we report studies on the thermal behavior, thermal decomposition kinetic parameters and thermal decomposition mechanism of BOM. In terms of application, the development of eutectics is an effective means to improve the performance of melt cast explosive carriers. In order to increase the energy level of BOM, the eutectic characteristics of BOM and DNTF were also studied, and the phase diagram was drawn to determine the optimal ratio of the two. In addition, the detonation performance parameters of BOM/HMX and BOM/DNTF(40/60)eutectic/HMX were estimated, and the effect of BOM instead of TNT was evaluated from the perspective of detonation performance.
(2) To test the low eutectic properties, 0.1 g BOM/DNTF mixtures with different proportions (100/0, 90/10, 80/20, 70/30, 60/40, 50/50, 40/60, 30/70, 20/80, 10/90, 0/100) were prepared, added to 10 mL of acetone for dissolution, and left still until the solvent volatilized completely to obtain a crystal mixture of BOM and DNTF. The crystal mixture (1.0 mg) was heated to 115 °C in a DSC instrument, cooled immediately after the crystal mixture was completely melted, and then heated to 120 °C. The DSC curves were obtained, and the binary phase diagram of BOM/DNTF was drawn according to the DSC curves.
In situ FTIR spectroscopy was carried out on a Nexus 870 FTIR spectrometer. Operation conditions: sample mass, 1.08 mg; heating rate, 10 °C min−1; resolution, 4 cm−1; spectral acquisition rate, 7.5 file min−1, 8 scans·file−1; temperature range, 25–465 °C.
The mass spectra (MS) were obtained with a QMS403 Four Bar Mass Spectrometer. Test quality range, 1–300 amu; resolution < 0.5 amu; detection limit > 1 ppm.
It can be seen from Fig. 3 that there is an endothermic peak and an exothermic peak in the heating process of BOM. The endothermic peak is the melting endothermic peak of BOM, which is at the temperature of 85.8 °C, and the exothermic peak is the decomposition exothermic peak of BOM at 203.4 °C. For most liquid-phase carriers of melt cast explosives, their melting points are at between 70 and 120 °C. An ideal melting point is below 100 °C, since the molding and processing process of energetic materials can be completed by using the temperature condition of steam. The melting endothermic peak of BOM is at 85.8 °C. This shows that BOM is very suitable to be used as an explosives carrier.
In the TG curve, the weight of BOM decreased rapidly at 201.3 °C, and the weight loss was close to 70%, which was the main stage of thermal decomposition.
The decomposition peak in the DSC curve of BOM is almost the same as that corresponding to the peak of DTG, indicating that BOM was hard to volatilize before the thermal decomposition. Unlike other volatile melt cast explosive carriers, especially TNT, non-volatility is another good characteristic of BOM. It is not harmful to the human respiratory system or eyes during the operation process.
The Kissinger model12 was used to calculate the kinetic parameters (apparent activation energy (Ek) and pre-exponential constant (Ak)) of the decomposition reaction of BOM. The Kissinger model can be expressed as follows:
![]() | (1) |
The kinetic parameters for BOM obtained by the Kissinger model are given in Table 2.
βi, K min−1 | Ti, K | Ek, kJ mol−1 | r | lg![]() |
---|---|---|---|---|
2.5 | 471.0 | 158.2 | 0.9848 | 19.55 |
5 | 477.1 | |||
10 | 486.1 | |||
20 | 495.3 |
In order to further investigate the thermal stability of BOM, the kinetic parameters of BOM, DNTF13 at atmospheric pressure and TNT14 at 2 MPa pressure obtained based on the Kissinger method are shown in Table 3. The reaction rate constants are calculated and compared.
Exp | T, °C | T, K | 1000, T | Ek, kJ mol−1 | Ek/RT | lg![]() |
K, s−1 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BOM 0.1 MPa | 50 | 323.2 | 3.0941 | 158.2 | 58.8560 | 19.55 | 10−6.01 |
80 | 353.2 | 2.8313 | 158.2 | 53.8583 | 19.55 | 10−3.84 | |
130 | 403.2 | 2.4802 | 158.2 | 47.1811 | 19.55 | 10−0.94 | |
180 | 453.2 | 2.2065 | 158.2 | 41.9769 | 19.55 | 101.32 | |
230 | 503.2 | 1.9873 | 158.2 | 37.8068 | 19.55 | 103.13 | |
260 | 533.2 | 1.8755 | 158.2 | 35.6800 | 19.55 | 104.05 | |
300 | 573.2 | 1.7446 | 158.2 | 33.1906 | 19.55 | 105.13 | |
350 | 623.2 | 1.6046 | 158.2 | 30.5281 | 19.55 | 106.29 | |
DNTF 0.1 MPa | 50 | 323.2 | 3.0941 | 58.8 | 21.8825 | 7.76 | 10−1.74 |
80 | 353.2 | 2.8313 | 58.8 | 20.0238 | 7.76 | 10−0.93 | |
130 | 403.2 | 2.4802 | 58.8 | 17.5407 | 7.76 | 100.15 | |
180 | 453.2 | 2.2065 | 58.8 | 15.6055 | 7.76 | 100.99 | |
230 | 503.2 | 1.9873 | 58.8 | 14.0549 | 7.76 | 101.66 | |
260 | 533.2 | 1.8755 | 58.8 | 13.2641 | 7.76 | 102.00 | |
300 | 573.2 | 1.7446 | 58.8 | 12.3385 | 7.76 | 102.41 | |
350 | 623.2 | 1.6046 | 58.8 | 11.3485 | 7.76 | 102.84 | |
TNT 2 MPa | 50 | 323.2 | 3.0941 | 110.9 | 41.2587 | 7.60 | 10−10.3 |
80 | 353.2 | 2.8313 | 110.9 | 37.7553 | 7.60 | 10−8.79 | |
130 | 403.2 | 2.4802 | 110.9 | 33.0745 | 7.60 | 10−6.76 | |
180 | 453.2 | 2.2065 | 110.9 | 29.4263 | 7.60 | 10−5.18 | |
230 | 503.2 | 1.9873 | 110.9 | 26.5029 | 7.60 | 10−3.91 | |
260 | 533.2 | 1.8755 | 110.9 | 25.0121 | 7.60 | 10−3.26 | |
300 | 573.2 | 1.7446 | 110.9 | 23.2669 | 7.60 | 10−2.50 | |
350 | 623.2 | 1.6046 | 110.9 | 21.4005 | 7.60 | 10−1.69 |
The decomposition peak temperatures of BOM at different heating rates are 198.2 °C, 204.1 °C, 212.7 °C and 222.4 °C, respectively. The apparent activation energy is 158.2 kJ mol−1, which is much higher than that of DNTF (58.8 kJ mol−1) at atmospheric pressure, and that of TNT (110.93 kJ mol−1) at 2 MPa. This indicates that BOM has good thermal stability at low temperature. The reaction rate constant of BOM is greater than that of TNT at 2 MPa, but much less than that of DNTF at atmospheric pressure.
MS can detect the thermal decomposition ion fragments of BOM in real time, and the relation curves between the detected main ion fragment currents and temperature are shown in Fig. 5.
It can be seen from the mass spectrogram that a NO (m/z = 30) fragment was detected at 100 °C, which indicates that a small amount of nitro and nitroso were transformed into each other in the process of denitrification of BOM, and a small amount of NO was first decomposed and released.15 When the temperature reached 140 °C, small amounts of 1,2,4-oxadiazole ring (m/z = 68) and ·CH2–O–O· (m/z = 46) were formed. When the temperature was increased to 170 °C, a large number of ion fragments with m/z = 30, 46 and 68 were formed rapidly, especially those with m/z = 30. It is speculated that the separation of –NO2 groups (m/z = 46) should start at this time, with the separation of ·CH2–O·(m/z = 30) and the 1,2,4-oxadiazole ring (m/z = 68) from the BOM structure at the same time. When the temperature is higher than 170 °C, NO2 will decompose immediately to NO (m/z = 30). The ion fragment with m/z = 30 contains ·CH2–O· and NO, so the amount of formation is very large. When the temperature reached 180 °C, ion fragments with m/z = 12, 18, 26 and 44 were detected, which were considered as the final product fragments of the plasma fragments of ·CH2–O· and the 1,2,4-oxadiazole ring, respectively, C, H2O, ·CN and CO2. Therefore, this suggested that the BOM thermal decomposition process is as shown in Fig. 6.16
In situ FTIR technology can detect the infrared spectrum of the remaining condensed matter in BOM from the beginning of heating to the end of decomposition. The infrared spectra at 40 °C, 100 °C, 170 °C, 200 °C and 220 °C during heating are shown in Fig. 7.
At 40 °C, the peaks at 3000 cm−1, 2952 cm−1 and 2924 cm−1 are the characteristic peaks of methylene (–CH2–), and those at 1660 cm−1, 1288 cm−1 and 848 cm−1 are the antisymmetric stretching vibration peak, symmetric stretching vibration peak and N–O stretching vibration peak of the oxidative nitrate ester group (–ONO2), respectively.17 In addition, the peaks at 1576 cm−1, 1418 cm−1, 1352 cm−1, 1061 cm−1 and 903 cm−1 are the characteristic peaks of 1,2,4-oxadiazole.18
With an increase in temperature, BOM melted completely at 100 °C (from DSC, the melting temperature of BOM is 85.8 °C). At this time, the infrared characteristic peak of liquid BOM has different degrees of deviation compared with that of solid BOM: 1660→1664 cm−1, 1576→1582 cm−1, 1352→1357 cm−1, 1288→1281 cm−1, 1061→1053 cm−1, 903→909 cm−1, 848→838 cm−1, etc. This shows that the change of BOM state has some influence on the position of its infrared characteristic peaks. At 100 °C, a peak at 1232 cm−1 appeared which is the characteristic peak of nitrite. It is speculated that NO and H2O in the air react with KBr tablets in the in situ cell to generate KNO2, which also proves that a small amount of nitro and nitroso transform into each other first in mass spectrometry at 100 °C, and a small amount of NO is released first.
When the temperature rises to about 170 °C, new peaks at 1385 cm−1 and 1725 cm−1 appear in the infrared spectrum, which are the characteristic peaks of nitrate and carbonyl. The peak at 1725 cm−1 is very weak, but that at 1385 cm−1 becomes stronger and stronger with the increase of temperature. This shows that when the temperature is about 170 °C, the nitrate group of BOM begins to denitrify and catalyzes the loss of a H from a small amount of methylene,19 forming a carbonyl. NO2 and H2O in the air react with KBr tablets in the in situ cell to form KNO3. When heated to about 200 °C, denitration is completed and the characteristic peaks of the nitrate ester group disappear completely. Only the characteristic peaks of carbonyl, 1,2,4-oxadiazole ring, KNO2 and KNO3 are left in the spectrum.
When the temperature increases to about 220 °C, the 1,2,4-oxadiazole ring in the pool is completely cracked, and the characteristic peaks disappeared. Finally, only the characteristic peaks of KNO2 (1232 cm−1) and KNO3 (1385 cm−1) are left.
Similar to the deep eutectic solvents, researchers often melt and mix two kinds of melt cast explosive carriers to obtain a low melting point liquid phase carrier in the field of melt cast explosives, which is called a low eutectic. The preparation of a low eutectic is an effective way to improve the performance of fused cast explosive carriers. DNTF22 has the advantages of high energy, high detonation velocity and high density, but its sensitivity is high, and its melting point is 108 °C, which is not conducive to steam forming. The advantages of BOM are high density, low melting point and low sensitivity, but the detonation performance of BOM is lower than that of DNTF. If DNTF and BOM can form a low melting point eutectic, the safety and high melting point of DNTF will be improved significantly, and the detonation performance of BOM will be improved at the same time.23 Therefore, in this chapter, the melting points of BOM/DNTF at different proportions (100/0, 90/10, 80/20, 70/30, 60/40, 50/50, 40/60, 30/70, 20/80, 10/90, 0/100) are tested by DSC (Fig. 8), and the low eutectic characteristics of BOM and DNTF are studied. Table 4 shows the melting points of BOM/DNTF at different proportions, T1 is the first endothermic peak temperature, and T2 is the second endothermic peak temperature.
BOM/DNTF | T1, °C | T2, °C |
---|---|---|
100/0 | — | 86.4 |
90/10 | 72.5 | 83.2 |
80/20 | 74.6 | 82.3 |
70/30 | 74.9 | 79.8 |
60/40 | 75.5 | — |
50/50 | 75.9 | — |
40/60 | 75.5 | — |
30/70 | 74.7 | 97.3 |
20/80 | 74.8 | 102.0 |
10/90 | 72.8 | 106.2 |
0/100 | — | 111.5 |
The binary phase diagram of BOM/DNTF is obtained by the T–Z (temperature–composition) method from the data in Table 4 (Fig. 9). It can be seen from the phase diagram that when the ratio of BOM/DNTF is 60/40, 50/50 and 40/60, they formed a complete eutectic with melting points of 75.5 °C, 75.9 °C and 75.5 °C, respectively.
The ideal melting temperature of a melt cast explosive carrier should be between 70 and 120 °C. If the melting point is lower than 100 °C, it is more conducive to steam melt processing. The melting points of the BOM/DNTF low eutectics with the proportions of 60/40, 50/50 and 40/60 are very ideal, and suitable for use as the carrier of melt cast explosives. Considering that the detonation performance of DNTF is better than that of BOM, it is considered that the 40/60 BOM/DNTF low eutectic has the best detonation performance, and 40% BOM will greatly reduce the sensitivity of the system. Table 5 shows the results of impact, friction and ESD sensitivity tests. The impact sensitivity was investigated using the drop height of 50% explosion probability (H50) with the drop weight of 5 kg. The friction sensitivity was tested by the method of explosion probability (conditions: the mass of the pendulum was 1.5 kg and the swing angle was 90°). The ESD test was carried out by charging a capacitor of 10000 pF to 10 kV, and testing the samples 30 times under four conditions (0.12 mm/0 Ω, 0.25 mm/0 Ω, 0.18 mm/100 kΩ and 0.50 mm/100 kΩ) to observe the reaction of the explosives.
Exp | Impact, H50, cm | Friction, % | ESD |
---|---|---|---|
DNTF | 20.0 | 84 | No initiation |
BOM | 115.3 | 22 | No initiation |
BOM/DNTF(40/60) | 106.8 | 24 | No initiation |
From the test results, 40% BOM can effectively reduce the impact sensitivity and friction sensitivity of DNTF. DNTF, BOM and BOM/DNTF (40/60) are insensitive to electric sparks because they are not initiated under ESD test conditions.
The vapor pressure of a melt cast explosive liquid carrier is a performance metric that we are very concerned about. Therefore, we tested the vapor pressures of DNTF and the BOM/DNTF(40/60) low eutectic with increasing temperatures, and compared their volatility at their use temperatures. The results are shown in Fig. 10.
It can be seen from Fig. 10 that the BOM/DNTF(40/60) low eutectic has lower vapor pressure values at its actual use temperature (melting point to 20 °C above the melting point), lower than that of DNTF. The vapor pressure value of the low eutectic increases slowly with the increase of temperature, and the rate is lower than that of DNTF. Linear fitting of the measured data shows that the vapor pressure curves of the two carriers have a cross point at 120 °C.
To evaluate the detonation performance of the low eutectic, the detonation properties of TNT, BOM and the BOM/DNTF (40/60) low eutectic were calculated by EXPLO5 software.24 The results are shown in Table 6.
Sample | Density, g cm−3 | OB, % | Detonation heat, J g−1 | Detonation velocity, m s−1 | Detonation pressure, GPa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
TNT | 1.654 | −73.96 | 4380.45 | 6809.01 | 18.70 |
BOM | 1.823 | −33.32 | 4857.29 | 8092.01 | 28.11 |
BOM/DNTF(40/60) | 1.931 | −18.90 | 6008.45 | 9079.33 | 37.87 |
BOM/DNTF(50/50) | 1.917 | −21.31 | 5815.85 | 8919.67 | 36.18 |
BOM/DNTF(60/40) | 1.899 | −23.71 | 5620.03 | 8749.84 | 34.32 |
It can be seen from Table 6 that the detonation performance of BOM is better than that of TNT in all aspects. BOM and DNTF are prepared into a low eutectic with a percentage of 40/60. The detonation performance is greatly improved compared with BOM, with a density of 1.931 g cm−3, detonation heat of 6008.45 J g−1, detonation velocity of 9079.33 m s−1 and detonation pressure of 37.87 GPa.
According to the charge characteristics of melt cast explosives, the carrier content of the liquid phase is generally set at 40%, and the solid component content of high energy is set at 60%. In order to investigate the detonation properties of the melt cast explosives with BOM or BOM/DNTF as liquid phase carriers and HMX as a high-energy solid-phase explosive component, the detonation parameters of TNT/HMX, BOM/HMX and BOM/DNTF (40/60)/HMX were calculated by EXPLO5 software (Table 7). Fig. 11 is obtained by drawing the data in Table 5.
Sample | Density, g cm−3 | OB, % | Detonation heat, J g−1 | Detonation velocity, m s−1 | Detonation pressure, GPa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
TNT/HMX | 1.796 | −42.55 | 5174.33 | 8194.57 | 28.72 |
BOM/HMX | 1.871 | −26.29 | 5347.88 | 8712.74 | 33.78 |
BOM/DNTF(40/60)/HMX | 1.915 | −20.53 | 5797.43 | 9041.98 | 37.11 |
BOM/DNTF(50/50)/HMX | 1.887 | −21.49 | 5777.20 | 8996.10 | 36.93 |
BOM/DNTF(60/40)/HMX | 1.879 | −22.45 | 5700.71 | 8934.18 | 36.28 |
The results show that the detonation parameters of the melt cast explosives with BOM and BOM/DNTF (40/60) as liquid carriers are significantly higher than that of TNT. The explosion heat, detonation velocity and detonation pressure of BOM/HMX are 5347.88 J g−1, 8712.74 m s−1 and 33.78 GPa, respectively, and are 3.4%, 6.3% and 17.6% higher than those of TNT/HMX. The detonation heat, detonation velocity and detonation pressure of BOM/DNTF(40/60)/HMX are 5797.43 J g−1, 9041.98 m s−1 and 37.11 GPa, respectively, 8.4%, 3.8% and 11.8% higher than those of BOM/HMX, and 12.0%, 10.4% and 29.2% higher than those of TNT/HMX.
Therefore, from the perspective of detonation performance, BOM and BOM/DNTF (40/60) can replace TNT as the liquid phase carrier of high-energy melt cast explosives.
(1) From the TG–DSC, when the heating rate is 5 °C min−1, the melting peak of BOM is 85.8 °C, and the decomposition peak is 203.4 °C, so it is basically non-volatile before decomposition.
(2) The apparent activation energy of BOM obtained by the Kissinger method is 158.2 kJ mol−1, which is much higher than that of DNTF at atmospheric pressure (58.8 kJ mol−1), and that of TNT at 2 MPa (110.93 kJ mol−1). This shows that BOM has good thermal stability at low temperature.
(3) In the decomposition process of BOM, a small amount of nitro and nitroso are transformed into each other first, then nitro is separated, the 1,2,4-oxadiazole ring and branch chain are separated, and finally the 1,2,4-oxadiazole ring is completely decomposed.
(4) BOM/DNTF with the proportions of 60/40, 50/50 and 40/60 can form a complete low eutectic. The analysis shows that the comprehensive performance of BOM/DNTF with the proportion of 40/60 is the best.
(5) When the composition of liquid-phase carrier and solid-phase high-energy explosive (HMX) is 40%/60%, the detonation performance is calculated by EXPLO5 as follows: the detonation heat, detonation velocity and detonation pressure of BOM/HMX are 5347.88 J g−1, 8712.74 m s−1 and 33.78 GPa, respectively, 3.4%, 6.3% and 17.6% higher than those of TNT/HMX. The detonation heat, detonation velocity and detonation pressure of BOM/DNTF(40/60)/HMX are 5797.43 J g−1, 9041.98 m s−1 and 37.11 GPa, respectively, 8.4%, 3.8% and 11.8% higher than those of BOM/HMX, and 12.0%, 10.4% and 29.2% higher than those of TNT/HMX.
Based on the above research content and results, it is considered that BOM has low sensitivity, is nontoxic, and has excellent detonation performance, and is therefore very suitable as a liquid-phase carrier of melt cast explosives. It has huge application prospects, and is expected to replace TNT in an all-round way after its mass production.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |