Open Access Article
Kai
Schwedtmann
a,
Jan
Haberstroh‡
a,
Sven
Roediger‡
a,
Antonio
Bauzá
b,
Antonio
Frontera
b,
Felix
Hennersdorf
a and
Jan J.
Weigand
*a
aFaculty of Chemistry and Food Chemistry, TU Dresden, Chair of Inorganic Molecular Chemistry, 01062 Dresden, Germany. E-mail: jan.weigand@tu-dresden.de
bDepartment of Chemistry, Universitat de Illes Balears, 07122 Palma de Mallorca, Spain
First published on 30th May 2019
Tetracationic cyclo-tetraphosphane [(LC)4P4]4+ as triflate salt (3[OTf]4) (LC = 4,5-dimethyl-1,3-diisopropyl-imidazol-2-yl) is obtained in high yield from the reduction of [LCPCl2]+ (4[OTf]) with 1,4-bis(trimethylsilyl)-1,4-dihydropyrazine (6) and represents the first salt of the cationic cyclo-phosphane series with the general formula [LnPn]n+. Theoretical calculations reveal the electrophilic nature of the P atoms within the P4-ring due to the influence of the imidazoliumyl-substituents. Further reduction of 3[OTf]4 with 6 affords the unexpected formation of the notricyclane P7-type cation [(LC)3P7]3+ (9[OTf]3). Selective transition metal mediated [2 + 2]-fragmentation of 34+ is achieved when 3[OTf]4 is reacted with Fe2(CO)9, Pd(PPh3)4 and Pt(PPh3)4 leading to the formation of the dicationic diphosphene complexes [(η2-LCP
PLC)Fe(CO)4]2+ (12[OTf]2) and [(η2-LCP
PLC)M(PPh3)2]2+ (13[OTf]2 for M = Pd; 14[OTf]2 for M = Pt). In contrast, the reaction of 3[OTf]4 with an excess of AuCl(tht) gives rise to the formation of the five-membered ring complex [((LC)4P4)AuCl2]3+ (15[OTf]3), where the Au(I) atom reductively inserts into a P–P bond of 34+.
P–Mes*.10 Generally, mixed-substituted or cationic cyclo-phosphanes are very scarce and the only examples of dicationic cyclo-phosphanes of type [R2(LC)2P4]2+ (2a,b2+) (LC = 1,3-bis(2,6-diisopropylphenyl)-imidazol-2-yl, 1a: R = Ph, 1b: R = NMe2; Scheme 1) were recently introduced by Grützmacher and co-workers as a result of a GaCl3-induced dimerization reaction of 1a,b.11 Mechanistically, it has been shown that cyclo-phosphanes 2a,b2+ are formed via a [2 + 2]-cycloaddition of the generated diphosphene intermediates. We targeted the replacement of all substituents R in cyclo-PnRn by an imidazoliumyl-substituent LC, resulting in the new group of cationic cyclo-phosphanes of type [(LC)nPn]n+ (Scheme 1). These cationic substituents LC are frequently employed in phosphorus chemistry as they are known to have a significant influence on the reactivity of the directly bonded P atom.12–15 In this contribution we present the formation of a tetracationic cyclo-tetraphosphane [(LC)4P4]4+ as triflate salt (3[OTf]4) via the reduction of [LCPCl2]+ (4[OTf])12 and elucidate the mechanism for its formation. Furthermore, the reductive build-up reaction to a larger cationic phosphorus framework and selective transition metal mediated [2 + 2]-fragmentation and ring opening reactions were investigated.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Cationic cyclo-phosphanes of type [R2(LC)2P4]2+ (2a,b2+) and [(LC)4P4]4+ (34+) and subsequent transition metal mediated fragmentation and insertion reactions. | ||
Mechanistically, we propose that 2 equivalents of 4+ react with one equivalent of 6 to give intermediate 72+ which subsequently reacts with another equivalent of 6 ultimately leading to tetracation 34+. The first reduction step might also lead to the formation of an [LCP]+-synthon which is supported by the formation of [(LC)3P3]+ (83+) in this reaction (Scheme 3). A few crystals of 8[OTf]3 could be isolated by overlaying the filtrate of the aforementioned reaction with n-hexane at −35 °C. The molecular structure is depicted in Fig. 1. The bonding parameters of trication 83+ are well in the expected range. Accordingly, one imidazoliumyl-substituent at the planar P3 ring is trans-arranged to the other two imidazoliumyl-substituents which results in the characteristic pattern in the 31P NMR spectrum.3,6 The 31P NMR spectrum of 83+ shows the AB2 spin system (δ(PA) = −142.5 ppm, δ(PB) = −130.8 ppm; 1J(PP) = −162 Hz) in the typical region for cyclo-triphosphanes.19 To our surprise, time dependent 31P NMR spectra reveal the rearrangement of 83+ into cyclo-tetraphosphane 34+ in a CD3CN solution in the course of 24 h (Fig. 2), suggesting that 83+ is the kinetic product of this reaction, while 34+ is thermodynamically favorable. Although such ring expansions are known for neutral cyclo-phosphanes, it seems, due to electrostatic repulsive effects, thermodynamically contradicting that a trication (83+) transforms into the corresponding tetracation (34+),24 rather than its fragmentation into charge separated species.24,25 We calculated the HOMO and the LUMO and optimized the structure by DFT methods using the PBE0/def2-TZVP level of theory (Fig. 3).16 The HOMO of cation 34+ is basically located at the imidazoliumyl-substituents, whereas the LUMO is mostly located at the P4 ring, suggesting an electrophilic nature of the P atoms within the P4 ring. The small degree of delocalization of the LUMO onto the imidazoliumyl-substituents also contributes to the stability of the tetracation 34+. We further reduced cyclo-tetraphosphane 3[OTf]4 again using the metal free reducing agent 6 (Scheme 4). Upon reaction of 3[OTf]4 with 6 in CH3CN, the reaction mixture turned from colorless to orange. The 31P NMR spectrum of this mixture showed after 8 hours a broad singlet resonance at δ(P) = −124.6 ppm and a dynamic AA′A′′BXX′X′′ spin system with resonances at δ(PA) = −178.5 ppm, δ(PB) = −164.9 ppm and δ(PX) = 13.2 ppm (see Fig. S5†).16 The singlet resonance is assigned to cation 10+ which was first reported by Macdonald and co-workers26 whereas the spin system of higher order is attributed to the P7 trication [(LC)3P7]3+ (93+). Imidazolium cation 11+ has been identified by its characteristic chemical shift in the 29Si NMR spectrum.129[OTf]3 can be isolated by washing the obtained crude oil with THF and CH2Cl2. After removal of all volatiles in vacuo, salt 9[OTf]3 is obtained as colorless solid in an overall yield of 61%. Fig. 3 shows the 31P{H} NMR spectrum of 93+ at 260 K which is iteratively fitted to an AA′A′′BXX′X′′ spin system and indicates the formation of a C3-symmetric stereoisomer (Fig. 4).27 The A part at δ(PA) = −178.5 ppm is assigned to the P atoms of the basal P3-ring, the B part at δ(PB) = −164.9 ppm to the apical P atom and the X part at δ(PX) = 13.2 ppm to the bridging P atoms carrying the imidazoliumyl-substituents. Details on coupling constants are included in the ESI in Table S1.† Single crystals suitable for X-ray analysis are obtained by slow diffusion of CH2Cl2 into a saturated CH3CN solution of 9[OTf]3 at −35 °C. The molecular structure confirms the C3-symmetric, heptaphosphanortricyclane cage with three imidazoliumyl-substituents at the bridging phosphorus atoms P2, P3 and P4 (Fig. 4). The P–C bond lengths (av. 1.834 Å) are comparable to those of tetracation 34+ (av. 1.822 Å) and other imidazoliumyl-substituted phosphorus derivatives.15 The bonding parameters within the P7-cage are comparable to those of our previously reported triarsonium-substituted P7 cage compound,27ai.e. the P–P bond lengths of the basal P atoms and the bridging P atoms (P2–P5, P3–P6 and P4–P7: av. 2.2238 Å) are slightly longer compared to those in the basal P3-ring (av. 2.2166 Å) and to those between the apical and the bridging P atoms (P1–P2, P1–P3 and P1–P4: av. 2.1882 Å).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 3 Formation of 3[OTf]4 and 8[OTf]3 from the proposed [LC–P]+-synthon by reduction of 4[OTf]. Compound 8[OTf]3 readily rearranges in a CH3CN solution at room temperature within 24 h to 3[OTf]4. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 HOMO (a) and LUMO (b) from the DFT optimized structure of 34+ using the PBE0/def2-TZVP functional. | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 4 Reaction of 3[OTf]4 with 6 to 9[OTf]3, 10[OTf] and 11[OTf]; (i) +2 6, CH3CN, 8 h, −2 pyrazine, –Me3SiOTf, 61%. | ||
As the DFT calculations suggest rather electrophilic P atoms in 34+, we investigated its reactivity towards a series of low valent transition metal compounds in order to evaluate the ligand properties of 34+. 3[OTf]4 readily reacts with two equivalents of Fe2(CO)9 in a 1
:
1 mixture of THF/CH3CN under the immediate formation of a brown-colored reaction mixture. The addition of Et2O gives a yellow-colored precipitate in a 98% yield which was identified as complex 12[OTf]2.16 In this complex, a Fe(CO)4 moiety is η2-coordinated by the disphosphene ligand [LCP
PLC]2+, which is formed via the metal induced [2 + 2]-fragmentation (Scheme 5). Single crystals suitable for X-ray analysis are obtained by slow diffusion of n-hexane into a saturated CH2Cl2 solution of 12[OTf]2. The complex reveals a trigonal core including the P atoms of the [LCP
PLC]2+ ligand and the Fe atom of the Fe(CO)4 moiety. The imidazoliumyl-substituents of the [LCP
PLC]2+ ligand are arranged in an E-configuration (C1–P1–P2–C12 149.205(1)°) and the P1–Fe–P2 angle is relatively acute with a value of 54.490(19)°. The shortest distance between the diphosphene unit and the Fe atom is 2.105 Å as a result of the rather long Fe–P contacts (Fe–P1 2.3774(6) Å and Fe–P2 2.3590(6) Å). In contrast, typically Fe–P distances in η1-coordination complexes are usually in the region of 2.2 Å.28 The P–P bond length with a value of 2.1684(7) Å is significantly longer compared to those in a typical diphosphene such as Mes*–P
P–Mes*: (2.034(2) Å),10 but slightly shorter compared to a typical P–P single bond (compare 34+: av. 2.235 Å). This also supports the η2-coordination of the P2 ligand. The IR stretching frequencies of the CO ligands are found at 2048 cm−1, 2074 cm−1 and 2116 cm−1 and are significantly shifted to higher wave numbers compared to related reported phosphorus Fe(CO)4 complexes (e.g. [(L2–P–L2)Fe(CO)4][BPh4]: 2029 cm−1, 1947 cm−1, 1907 cm−1).29 According to Tolman analysis,30 this suggests that the [LCP
PLC]2+ ligand is a very strong π-acceptor which even surpasses PF3 ([(PF3)Fe(CO)4]: 2101 cm−1, 2022 cm−1, 2018 cm−1, 1999 cm−1)31 due to the electron withdrawing effect of the imidazoliumyl-substituents.16,32 We therefore computed the π-accepting properties of the [LCP
PLC]2+ ligand which is related to the LUMO energy and shape of the ligand (see Fig. S12†).16 Our calculations show that the LUMO is the π*(P
P) bond which is perfectly pre-organized to interact with the d-orbitals of the Fe atom. Furthermore, the calculations indicated that, due to the dicationic charge, the LUMO is very low in energy (−9.313 eV; compare [LC–P
P–Dipp]+: −5.900 eV;16,33 LC = 4,5-dichloro-1,3-bis(Dipp)-imidazol-2-yl; Dipp = 2,6-diisopropylphenyl; see Fig. S12†) which is beneficial for π-bonding with the corresponding transition metal. In addition, the second order perturbation analysis of 12+ reveals a strong back-bonding from the d-orbitals of the Fe atom into the σ*(P–C)-orbital (E(2) = 35.77 kcal mol−1) indicating the stability of this complex.16 Similar findings have been recently reported by Macdonald and co-workers for a related diphosphene nickel complex featuring two phosphoniumyl-substituents.34
Similar [2 + 2]-fragmentation reactions are observed when 3[OTf]4 is reacted with 2 equivalents of M(PPh3)4 (M = Pd, Pt) in a 1
:
1 mixture of THF/CH3CN which leads to the formation of diphosphene complexes 13[OTf]2 (Pd(PPh3)4) and 14[OTf]2 (Pt(PPh3)4), respectively, under concomitant release of 4 equivalents PPh3 (Scheme 5). After workup, complexes 13[OTf]2 and 14[OTf]2 are obtained as analytically pure red-colored (13[OTf]2, 93%) or yellow-colored (14[OTf]2, 88%) crystalline powders. The 31P NMR spectrum of 13[OTf]2 at 300 K shows a broad singlet resonance at δ(P) = 10.2 ppm for the phosphorus atoms of the diphosphene moiety which upon cooling to 270 K appears as pseudo triplet with a 2J(PP) coupling constant of 31 Hz. The two PPh3 ligands give rise to a pseudo-triplet resonance at δ(P) = 23.4 ppm (2J(PP) = 31 Hz). The chemical shift is comparable to the related diphosphene complex [(η2-F3C–P
P–CF3)Pd(PPh3)2].35 In contrast to the trans-2J(PP) coupling, the magnitude of the cis2J(PP) coupling is not resolved, resulting in the observed pseudo-triplet splitting of this resonance. The 31P NMR spectrum of 14[OTf]2 shows dynamic behavior at 300 K which upon cooling resolves to an AA′BB′X spin system. The high field shifted A part at δ(PA) = – 42.9 ppm is assigned to the diphosphene moiety and shows a 2J(PP) coupling constant of 29 Hz similar to that of 13[OTf]2. The 1J(PPt) coupling with a value of 235 Hz is significantly smaller compared to typical 1J(PPt) coupling constants,35 indicating the η2-coordination of the disphosphene ligand and the Pt atom.35,36 The B part at δ(PB) = 25.1 ppm (2J(PP) = 29 Hz) is assigned to the PPh3 ligands and reveals a typical 1J(PPt) coupling constant of 3279 Hz. The 195Pt NMR spectrum shows a triplet of triplet resonance at δ(Pt) = −5015.7 ppm (1J(PtP) = 3279 Hz; 1J(PtP) = 235 Hz; see Fig. S8†). For both complexes a set of resonances with low intensities indicates the presence of rotational isomers in the NMR spectra which, however, only appears at temperatures below 270 K (see Fig. S6 and S7†). Single crystals suitable for X-ray analysis are obtained for both complexes by slow diffusion of Et2O into a saturated CH3CN solutions (Fig. 5). Similar to complex 12[OTf]2, the η2-coordination of the corresponding metal by the diphosphene ligand is observed with the metal atoms being in a distorted square planar bonding environment. The averaged distance between the diphosphene unit and metals are in the same range (132+: Pd⋯P–P 2.124 Å, Pd–P1 2.3543(6) Å, Pd–P2 2.4003(8) Å; 142+: Pt⋯P–P 2.114 Å, Pt–P1 2.3530(7) Å, Pt–P2 2.3930(6) Å). The P–P bond lengths are only marginally shorter (132+ 2.1340(12) Å and 142+ 2.1562(9) Å) compared to that of complex 122+ (2.1684(7) Å). Similar to the Fe complex the [LCP
PLC]2+ ligand is in both cases also in the E-configuration (132+: C1–P1–P2–C12 148.393°; 142+: C1–P1–P2–C12 147.088°).
Notably, the known diphosphene complexes [(η2-F3C–P
P–CF3)M(PPh3)2] (M = Pd, Pt)35,37 are also synthesized from the reaction of the tetraphosphetane (CF3)4P4 and the corresponding transition metal precursor M(PPh3)4 (M = Pd, Pt) suggesting the necessity of electron withdrawing substituents at the P atoms for the observed [2 + 2]-fragmentation. However, the formation of the dicationic diphosphene complexes (122+, 132+ and 142+), featuring imidazoliumyl-substituents at the P atom, illustrate the potential use of cyclo-tetraphosphane 34+ to synthesize a variety of novel cationic transition metal complexes. When 3[OTf]4 is reacted with one equivalent AuCl(tht) in THF/CH3CN (1
:
1) the formation of a small set of two coupled broad resonances at δ(P) = −49.9 ppm and δ(P) = −24.7 ppm along with a singlet resonance for 1[OTf] (δ(P) = 107.8 ppm) can be observed in the 31P NMR spectrum of the reaction mixture (see Fig. S9†). A complete consumption of 3[OTf]4 is achieved with 4 equivalents of AuCl(tht) (see Fig. S10†). Filtration of the reaction mixture after 12 h and recrystallization from THF, complex 15[OTf]3 can be isolated as a yellow powder. The yield can be increased by further recrystallization steps up to 57%. The 31P NMR spectrum of 15[OTf]3 dissolved in CD2Cl2 shows at 300 K two broad resonances which resolve to an AA′BB′ spin system at 260 K (Fig. 6). The A part at δ(P) = −49.9 ppm can be assigned to the backbone P atoms and the B part at δ(P) = −24.7 ppm to the Au-coordinating P atoms. Details on coupling constants are included in the ESI in Table S2.† Single crystals suitable for X-ray analysis are obtained by overlaying a saturated CH2Cl2 solution of 15[OTf]3 with pentane at −35 °C (Fig. 7). The Au atom is coordinated by two P atoms resulting in a five-membered P4Au-core structure which reveals an envelope conformation. Hey-Hawkins and co-workers reported on a similar structural motif where a catena-tetraphophosphane-1,4-diide coordinates Ni(0) and Pd(0), respectively.38 The gold atom in 153+ reveals a square-planar geometry where the P4-chain chelates the gold atom via P1 and P4. The phosphorus gold bond lengths (P1–Au 2.3053(11) Å and P4–Au 2.3103(10) Å) are well in the range for related P–AuIII bonds (av. 2.314).39 The four P atoms exhibit a pyramidal bonding environment with P–P bond lengths (av. 2.237 Å) being in the range of typical P–P single bonds (2.22 Å).20 As expected, the bond angles around the phosphorus atoms P1 and P4 (Au–P1–P2 107.79(5) ° and P3–P4–Au 107.90(5) Å) are wider compared to the other angles within the P4Au-core structure (P1–Au–P4 92.63(4) Å, P1–P2–P3 93.22(5) Å, P2–P3–P4 90.66(5) Å). Different from the above mentioned reactions, the reaction of 3[OTf]4 with an excess of AuCl leads to a reductive insertion of the gold atom into the P4-ring of 3[OTf]4 leading to the formation of a five-membered P4Au-core structure (Scheme 6).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 6 Formation of the 5-membered P4Au-complex 15[OTf]3; (i) +4 AuCl(tht), THF/CH3CN, 8 h 57%; (ii) +AuCl(tht), +nBu4N[Cl], THF/CH3CN, −nBu4N[OTf], 76% determined by 31P NMR spectroscopy. | ||
In this reaction, the Au(I) atom reductively inserts into a P–P bond of 34+ and is oxidized to Au(III). The free coordination site at the Au atom is saturated by a further chloride anion, leading to the square planar coordination environment at the Au(III) atom. Thus, it appears that the excess of the AuCl(tht) merely serves as chloride source in this reaction. We found that the reaction can be carried out with one equivalent AuCl(tht) and one equivalent nBu4N[Cl] as chloride source which leads to the consumption of 3[OTf]4 up to 90% and to the formation of the P4Au-complex 15[OTf]3 in 70% yield as judged by 31P NMR spectroscopy (see Fig. S11†).
P bond) rendering this ligand optimal for the complexation of a π-basic metal center. In contrast, the reaction of 3[OTf]4 with an excess of AuCl(tht) gives rise to the formation of complex 15[OTf]3 featuring a five-membered P4Au-core structure. In this reaction, the Au(I) atom reductively inserts into a P–P bond of 34+ and is oxidized to Au(III). As the DFT calculations of the optimized structure of 34+ reveal rather Lewis acidic P atoms, the reactivity towards nucleophiles promises a variety of novel phosphorus compounds featuring interesting bonding motifs and properties.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 1884156–1884162 and 1904570. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c9sc01701a |
| ‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |