Open Access Article
Yulou Ouyanga,
Zhongwei Zhanga,
Qing Xia,
Pengfei Jianga,
Weijun Rena,
Nianbei Lib,
Jun Zhoua and
Jie Chen
*a
aCenter for Phononics and Thermal Energy Science, China–EU Joint Lab for Nanophononics, School of Physics Science and Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, People's Republic of China. E-mail: jie@tongji.edu.cn
bInstitute of Systems Science and Department of Physics, College of Information Science and Engineering, Huaqiao University, Xiamen 361021, People's Republic of China
First published on 18th October 2019
Thermal transport properties of amorphous polymers depend significantly on the chain morphology, and boundary chain folding is a common phenomenon in bulk or lamellar polymer materials. In this work, by using molecular dynamics simulations, we study thermal conductivity of lamellar amorphous polyethylene (LAPE) with varying chain length (L0). For a short L0 without boundary chain folding, thermal conductivity of LAPE is homogeneous along the chain length direction. In contrast, boundary chain folding takes place for large L0, and the local thermal conductivity at the boundary is notably lower than that of the central region, indicating inhomogeneous thermal transport in LAPE. By analysing the chain morphology, we reveal that the boundary chain folding causes the reduction of both the orientation order parameter along the heat flow direction and the radius of gyration, leading to the reduced local thermal conductivity at the boundary. Further vibrational spectrum analysis reveals that the boundary chain folding shifts the vibrational spectrum to the lower frequency, and suppresses the transmission coefficient for both C–C vibration and C–H vibration. Our study suggests that the boundary chain folding is an important factor for polymers to achieve desirable thermal conductivity for plastic heat exchangers and electronic packaging applications.
The bulk amorphous polymers typically have a low thermal conductivity around 0.1–1.0 W m−1 K−1 at room temperature,15,16 which is two to three orders of magnitude lower than that of crystals.17,18 The random orientation of the polymer chains and the weak inter-chain couplings are the two main mechanisms responsible for the low thermal conductivity.19 Proper alignment of polymer chains is found to be an effective method to enhance the polymer's thermal conductivity, which can achieve more than two orders of magnitude enhancement for amorphous polyethylene (PE).17,20 Using molecular dynamics simulations, Henry et al.21,22 found that thermal conductivity of a single PE chain can reach up to 300 W m−1 K−1, which is almost as high as that of some inorganic semiconductors and metals.
The morphology of polymer chains also plays an important role on the thermal conductivity of polymer. Zhang et al.23 used PE as a model system to systematically investigate the fundamental relationship between the molecular morphology and thermal conductivity in bulk amorphous polymers. They found that thermal transport through covalent bonds dominates the effective thermal conductivity in polymers, and the thermal conductivity of rigid rod-like polymer can be increased by more than one order of magnitude, compared to that of polymers with very soft backbone. For lamellar amorphous polyethylene (LAPE), Ma et al.24 found that stronger confinement and less entanglement lead to a smaller thermal conductivity. However, the impact of boundary chain-folding on thermal transport in lamellar polymer has not been understood yet. This is particularly relevant for lamellar polymer because the surface-to-volume-ratio is rather large7 due to the limited film thickness, and the influence of chain folding cannot be neglected.
In this work, we study the thermal conductivity of LAPE by using molecular dynamic simulation to elucidate the effect of chain folding on thermal transport. Our results show that the chain folding results in the non-uniform local temperature gradient in LAPE. To describe the thermal transport property of the whole system in the presence of non-uniform temperature gradient, the validity of using effective thermal conductivity is discussed. The physical origin for the non-uniform local thermal conductivity is revealed by comparing various factors in different regions, including chain morphology, orientation, and vibrational spectrum. Our study provides a solid understanding for the influence of chain configuration on the thermal transport in LAPE, which will be beneficial for the design of polymer based materials for thermal management applications.
where L0 is the average length, and σ is the standard deviation. Table 1 summarizes the detailed configurations for various PE chains with different lengths with a given standard deviation of σ = 1 nm. As the total number of atoms in our study is fixed (about 27
000), the number of chains will decrease with the increase of L0. We then use the PACKMOL software25,26 to randomly place the PE chains into a sufficiently large box (50 nm × 10 nm × 10 nm), which allows for the construction of the initial lamellar structure (see Fig. S1(b) in ESI†).
| Average chain length (L0) | 5 nm | 10 nm | 15 nm | 20 nm | 25 nm | 30 nm |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of chains (N) | 225 | 112 | 75 | 56 | 45 | 37 |
| Total number of atoms | 27 000 |
26 880 |
27 000 |
26 940 |
27 000 |
26 640 |
| Final density after NPT relaxation (g cm−3) | 0.69 | 0.71 | 0.70 | 0.68 | 0.68 | 0.72 |
| Simulation box size after NPT relaxation: X (nm)/Y (nm)/Z (nm) | 19.8/4.0/4.0 | 20.1/3.9/4.0 | 20.0/4.0/4.0 | 20.9/3.9/3.9 | 19.5/4.1/4.1 | 19.6/4.0/4.0 |
After preparing the initial structure, molecular dynamics simulations are performed to study the dynamics of the system by using the large-scale atomic/molecular massively parallel simulator (LAMMPS) software.27 The adaptive inter-molecular reactive empirical bond order (AIREBO) potential28 is used to describe inter- and intra-molecular interactions between carbon and hydrogen atoms, which has been widely used to study the polymer systems in literature.21,22 The time step is 0.2 fs, and the force cutoff distance is set as 10 Å. Periodic boundary conditions are adopted in all directions.
The initial structure is relaxed by performing equilibrium molecular dynamics (EMD) simulation with the isothermal-isobaric (NPT) ensemble at 1 atm and 300 K for 2 ns, after which the thermal equilibrium and structure relaxation have been achieved (see Fig. S2 in ESI†). More details about the structure generation are included in the ESI.† EMD simulations with canonical (NVT) ensemble at 300 K are then performed for another 1 ns. A typical relaxed atomic structure of LAPE is shown in Fig. 1.
After structure relaxation, we then carry out the non-equilibrium molecular dynamics (NEMD) simulations to compute the thermal conductivity of LAPE. As shown in Fig. 1, two Nosé-Hoover thermostats at 310 K and 290 K are applied to the center and two ends of the simulation domain, respectively, in order to establish the temperature gradient along the LAPE. The lattice thermal conductivity κ of the amorphous PE is then calculated as:
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
Fig. 2 shows the typical temperature profile along the length direction for LAPE with different average length (L0) and constant standard deviation (σ = 1 nm). For short PE chains (L0 = 15 nm), a linear temperature profile (square in Fig. 2) is established in the whole region between the heat source and heat sink. In contrast, the temperature profile for long PE chains (L0 = 30 nm) is no longer linear across the whole region, but becomes piecewise linear, exhibiting a two-segment kinked characteristic (circle in Fig. 2). Besides, the temperature gradient in the boundary region (X < 20 Å) is greater than that in the internal region (X > 20 Å). Furthermore, we repeat the simulations for L0 = 30 nm with Langevin heat bath, and the same non-uniform characteristics in temperature profile are also observed (see Fig. S4 in ESI†).
According to the Gaussian distribution, the length of various chains mainly falls into the range from L0 − 3σ to L0 + 3σ. When the upper bound of the chain length (L0 + 3σ), for instance L0 = 15 nm, is smaller than the length of the simulation domain (L = 20 nm), each PE chain can be placed into the simulation box so that no boundary chain folding occurs. On the other hand, when the length of PE chains is longer than the simulation domain, they have to be folded at the boundary in order to fit into the simulation box. The two-segment kinked temperature profile obviously suggests that the boundary chain folding has a remarkable impact on the thermal transport in LAPE.
In order to quantify the effect of boundary chain folding, we calculate the thermal conductivity of LAPE with varying average length L0. When a uniform linear temperature gradient (square in Fig. 2) is established, thermal conductivity can be directly calculated according to eqn (1) for the whole region. In the presence of boundary chain folding, however, the two-segment piecewise linear temperature gradient (circle in Fig. 2) occurs, and thus only local thermal conductivity in each linear segment can be calculated by eqn (1) instead. As shown in Fig. 2, κ1 and κ2 represents the local thermal conductivity for the boundary and internal region, respectively.
Here, a natural question to be asked is how to define the effective thermal conductivity for the whole system in the presence of non-uniform temperature gradient? This problem has been seldomly emphasized in literatures as most materials are homogeneous along the temperature gradient direction. For instance, one widely used experimental technique to measure thermal conductivity is the thermal bridge method,34,39,40 which directly relates thermal conductivity of sample to the temperature change in the heater and sensor assuming a linear temperature gradient across the sample. Since the non-uniform temperature gradient is not considered in the experimental model, the second question is the validity of such calculation (κ0 in the inset of Fig. 2) and underlying assumption.
To address these questions, let us start with the relationship between the thermal resistance (R) and thermal conductivity (κ) κ = L/(SR), where L and S denotes the length and cross sectional area for the system of interest, respectively. Then, one can define the local thermal resistance as:
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
Based on eqn (4), one immediate derivation is that κeff ≈ κ2 in the limit when L1 ≪ L2. In other words, when the length of the boundary segment is much smaller than that of the internal segment, the assumption of a uniform linear temperature gradient is well justified as the temperature gradient for the internal segment is equivalent to the temperature gradient across the whole system in this limit case. This condition can be satisfied in most experimental measurements when the contact (boundary) region is much smaller than the internal suspended region.
Interestingly, we further prove rigorously in ESI† that κeff given by eqn (4) is actually identical to κ0 in which one fictitious temperature gradient is used in the calculation (inset in Fig. 2), regardless of the emergence of the non-uniform temperature gradient. That is to say, even in the presence of non-uniform temperature gradient among different segments, if one assumes serial connection between each heat dissipation segment, it is essentially equivalent to define an effective uniform temperature gradient established across the whole system. Similarly, for thermal conductance, we can also define an effective thermal conductance analogue to the effective thermal conductivity (see ESI† for more detail).
To verify such equivalence numerically, we compute two types of effective thermal conductivity κeff (eqn (4) with two linear fittings) and κ0 (eqn (1) with one linear fitting) for different LAPE samples with varying length (Fig. 3). For short length samples (L0 < 20 nm), only κ0 can be defined as there is only one uniform temperature gradient. Besides, thermal conductivity exhibits an increasing trend with the average chain length, which is consistent with the previous theoretical study on amorphous polymer at short length scale.41 For longer samples (L0 ≥ 20 nm) where boundary chain folding takes place, κeff and κ0 overlap with each other within the statistical error, and both of them show no obvious length dependence. Moreover, the local thermal conductivity for the internal region (κ2) is consistently higher than that for the boundary region (κ1) for the same L0. Obviously, the emergence of non-uniform local thermal conductivity hinders the continuous growth of effective thermal conductivity with length in LAPE. These results suggest that the boundary chain folding has a remarkable impact on thermal conductivity of LAPE.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Room temperature thermal conductivity of LAPE as a function of the average chain length (L0) with fixed σ = 1 nm. κ0 (empty triangle), κ1 (solid circle), and κ2(solid square) are computed by eqn (1), while κeff (solid triangle) is computed by eqn (4). The dashed lines are drawn to guide the eye. | ||
The variation of thermal conductivity with σ can be understood by analyzing the distribution function of PE chain length. As shown in Fig. 4(b), the upper bound for chain distribution for the sample with L0 = 10 nm (solid symbols) does not exceed the length of simulation domain (L = 20 nm) for all σ values, which means that each chain has enough space to extend. As we fix the average length L0, with the variation of σ value, the chain length of some PE chains decreases while that of others increases, so that the thermal conductivity for the whole system is size independent. This is also the case for the sample with L0 = 10 nm and σ < 3 nm. However, for the sample with L0 = 15 nm and σ = 3 nm, there is a notable portion of PE chains whose chain length is longer than the length of simulation domain. Consequently, these long PE chains have to be folded at the boundary in order to fit into the simulation box, which gives rise to the non-uniform local thermal conductivity.
In order to quantify the morphology change, we compute the radius of gyration (Rg) of PE chains, which is one of the most important parameters to characterize the conformation of amorphous PE. The radius of gyration for an individual PE chain is defined as:24,42
![]() | (5) |
![]() | (6) |
![]() | (7) |
Since the morphology of a PE chain is mainly determined by carbon atoms on the backbone,43,44 we only include the carbon backbone in order to simplify the calculation of Rgl. In order to record the structure variation, we run EMD simulation for another 1 ns after the structure relaxation process. Fig. 5(b) shows the variation of Rgl versus time for the sample with L0 = 30 nm and σ = 1 nm in different regions. For each region, Rgl is almost time-independent, confirming that the polymer structure has been fully relaxed. Besides, Rgl in region A is consistently lower than that in region B. This difference means PE chains near the boundary are more entangled as a result of the chain folding, which is consistent with the result that the local thermal conductivity for the boundary region is lower than that for the internal region (Fig. 3). Such relation suggests that the entangled PE chains suppress the thermal transport in LAPE. Previous studies also have shown that more extended chain morphology with larger radius of gyration is favorable for more efficient thermal transport in amorphous polymers.45
Although the radius of gyration can measure the degree of entanglement for polymer chains, it contains no information about the chain alignment direction, which is an important factor that can affect the polymer's thermal conductivity.46 To this end, we introduce here the orientational order parameter P2 that can be used to characterize the segment alignment along different directions defined as:47–49
| P2 = 1.5 < (ei⋅ex)2 > −0.5, | (8) |
![]() | (9) |
A value of P2 = −0.5 means that the orientation is perpendicular to the selected direction, and P2 = 1 means that the orientation is parallel to the selected direction. Similar to the calculation of Rgl, we compute the local orientational order parameter P2l, including only those atoms in a specific region.
As shown in Fig. 5(c), P2l in region B exhibits the largest value along the X-axis (temperature bias direction), but P2l in region A has a peak value along the Y-axis. In particular, along the X-axis, P2l in region B is larger than that in region A. These results indicate that PE chains in the internal region are mostly aligned along the length (temperature bias) direction, while the alignment of PE chains in the boundary region deviates substantially from the thermal transport direction due to the chain folding process. As the heat conduction in polymer is mainly through the covalently bonded backbone,37 the conformable alignment of polymer chains along the temperature bias direction will greatly promote the thermal transport in polymer systems. This explains the origin for the non-uniform local thermal conductivity in the presence of chain folding, and the lower thermal conductivity in the boundary region. Our results are consistent with the previous study which reported the improvement on the chain alignment, achieved by the mechanical stretching, can increase the polymer's thermal conductivity.46 Therefore, in addition to the morphology change, the chain alignment is another factor responsible for the higher thermal conductivity in the internal region.
![]() | (10) |
Fig. 6(a) shows the VDOS in different regions (as shown in Fig. 5(a)) for the sample with L0 = 30 nm and σ = 1 nm. For the extended PE chains in region B, VDOS exhibits the high frequency peak around 90 THz, which is a characteristic for CH2 stretching vibration.59 Moreover, the VDOS peak at ∼50 THz is the characteristic G-peak of carbon material,60 and the low-frequency peaks (<30 THz) originates from the flexibility (angular bending and dihedral rotations) of the carbon–carbon bonds.56 Compared to the carbon–carbon bond, carbon–hydrogen bonds are associated with higher vibrational frequencies due to the lighter weight of hydrogen atoms.56
As a result of the chain folding in region A, the high frequency spectrum (∼50 THz) shifts to the lower frequency, and the ultrahigh frequency vibrations (∼90 THz) are significantly suppressed in the PE chains. Such frequency shift is qualitatively consistent with the previous molecular dynamics study by Brayton et al.,61 in which they found that the vibration spectrum shifted to the lower frequency when the structure of PE changed from crystal to semi-crystal to amorphous structure. In our study, the PE chains in region A are less extended and more confined compared to those chains in region B. The chain folding restricts the vibration of the covalent C–C bond and reduces the order of chain alignment.
In order to further understand the effect of chain folding on thermal transport properties of LAPE, we calculate the frequency spectrum of transmission coefficient Γ(ω) defined as62,63
![]() | (11) |
![]() | (12) |
Fig. 6(b) shows the calculation results of Γ(ω) from NEMD simulation. Compared to the transmission spectrum for region B (solid line), the original characteristic peaks ∼30 THz and 50 THz have been greatly suppressed in region A (dashed line). In particular, the transmission of C–H vibration at very high frequency (∼90 THz) is also forbidden in region A. Therefore, the boundary chain folding induces substantial suppression of the transmission for both C–C vibration and C–H vibration, which leads to the reduced local thermal conductivity in the boundary region.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9ra07563a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |