Yafei Lianab,
Guangwei Yuab,
Fafu Liuab,
Lisong Zhangab,
Mingxia Xuab,
Hailiang Zhouc,
Xun Sun*ab and
Qingtian Gu*ab
aState Key Laboratory of Crystal Materials, Shandong University, Jinan 250100, PR China. E-mail: sunxun@sdu.edu.cn; qtgu@sdu.edu.cn
bKey Laboratory of Functional Crystal Materials and Device, Shandong University, Ministry of Education, Jinan 250100, PR China
cSchool of Information Science and Engineering, Shandong Agricultural University, Taian 271018, PR China
First published on 15th November 2017
Herein, ammonium dihydrogen phosphate (NH4H2PO4, ADP) crystals were grown in a defined crystallographic direction (θ = 90°, Φ = 45°) in an aqueous solution using the point seed rapid growth method. Ex situ atomic microscopy (AFM) measurements were implemented to observe the prismatic growth micro-morphology of ADP and Cr3+-doped ADP in the defined crystallographic direction. It was found that with the increasing supersaturation, the growth morphology changed in turn to elementary steps, macro steps, and 2D nuclei. Moreover, the differences between ADP and Cr3+-doped ADP grown in the defined crystallographic direction have been discussed. The influence of Cr3+ on the growth of ADP crystals has been explored.
Currently, the application of DKDP/KDP crystals is deterred by the bottleneck of their low laser damage threshold (LDT);21 moreover, the LDT of ADP crystals is higher than that of the KDP/DKDP crystals.15 Furthermore, non-critical phase matching (NCPM) performed on type-I crystals (θ = 90°, Φ = 45°), namely type-I (ooe) noncritical phase matching in the direction 90° to the crystal Z axis (θ = 90°) and 45° to the crystal X axis (Φ = 45°), has greater angular acceptance and avoids phase mismatch caused by dispersion in the crystal to achieve more efficient and more stable output power.22,23 In addition, the sizes in the [100] and [001] directions of crystals grown in Z-seed slices are smaller; moreover, because of the distribution of chemical bonds in the ADP crystal,24 the aspect ratio [Z/X] of ADP is very small; this leads to low utilization of the ADP crystal. Therefore, ADP crystals have been grown in a defined crystallographic direction (θ = 90°, Φ = 45°) by our research group. This method can improve the morphology of the ADP crystal by ensuring the growth in the direction of fourth harmonic generation to the greatest extent, by which we can obtain crystals of ample size and enhance their utilization rate; additionally, this method may improve the growth sections and homogeneity of the ADP crystals.
In this study, ADP crystals were grown in a defined crystallographic direction (θ = 90°, Φ = 45°, which is the direction of NCPM) in an aqueous solution using the point seed rapid growth method.25,26 Ex situ atomic microscopy (AFM) measurements were implemented to observe the prismatic growth micro-morphology of ADP. Moreover, Cr3+ was added to the growth solution to study the effects of Cr3+ on this growth direction as Cr3+ is a common impurity ion. Furthermore, prismatic morphology of the chromium-doped ADP crystals grown in the defined crystallographic direction was obtained. The differences between ADP and Cr3+-doped ADP in the defined crystallographic direction have also been discussed.
σ = (C0 − Ce)/Ce | (1) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Crystals suitable for surface microtopography (the yellow numbers represent the different σ values and the scale plate). |
Fig. 3(a) shows the surface microtopography at a supersaturation of 0.6%; the average step height of the steps was measured to be about 0.366 nm, equal to half of the length of unit cell a or b (7.502 Å (ref. 6)). This can be named as the elementary step. Thus, it can be seen that only the spiral growth mechanism is observed, and the direction of the step bending points to the dislocation source. Additionally, the steps are equidistant and regular, showing a steady initial growth stage of the ADP crystal, and correspond well with the growth theory.29 It is illustrated in Fig. 3(b) that at a supersaturation of 0.8%, the height of the elementary step is about 0.490 nm, which is approximately equal to half of the length of the unit cell. At the edges of the elementary steps, some ridges and dents emerge; this occurs because the growth units prefer to be absorbed into the edges of the steps, forming ridges, or because the fluctuations impede the absorption of the growth units, forming dents with small fluctuations of the growth conditions. In Fig. 3(c), at a supersaturation of 1.0%, the average height of the step is 4.61 nm, which is equivalent to six times the length of a. This shows that the crystal surface is covered by macro steps, which are the result of a process called step bunching; the macro steps increase in height and terrace width with distance from the top of the hillock and integrate multiple micro steps. The shape of the macro steps is approximately regular; this indicates that the macro steps develop and step forward as a whole, rather than by respective growth of elementary steps. When the supersaturation increases to 1.2%, the process of step bunching continues, and the macro steps become larger, as shown in Fig. 3(d). In addition, the average height of the steps is about 12.3 nm, which is equal to 17 times the length of a. A partial magnified image of Fig. 3(d) is shown in Fig. 3(d-1); this image clearly illustrates the topography of the macro steps and the process of step bunching. The macro steps are neither straight nor strictly parallel, but have more complicated shapes; this indicates that the crystal surface may be influenced not only by supersaturation but also by other factors. At a supersaturation of 1.4%, as shown in Fig. 3(e), the process of step bunching still occurs; the average height of the macro steps is about 20.8 nm, equal to 28 times the length of the unit cell. However, some islands without any signs of dislocation outcrop appear on the terraces between two steps, and their average radius is about 230 nm, much greater than the radius of the critical nucleus at this supersaturation. These islands are called 2D nuclei and are much more visible in Fig. 3(e-1), particularly in the magnified image shown in Fig. 3(e). When the supersaturation is increased to 1.8%, the radius of the 2D nuclei increases to about 1.107 μm, and the height of the macro steps is about 23.1 nm, as clearly shown in Fig. 3(f) and (f-1); moreover, the quantity of 2D nuclei obviously increases. The 2D nucleation mechanism is dominant in the crystal growth process.
Fig. 3(g) illustrates the (100) face growth micro-morphology at σ = 2.2%; it can be seen that the radius of the 2D nuclei increases to about 4.21 μm; this indicates that the 2D nuclei grow and step forward via step growth. The growth velocity of the 2D nuclei is anisotropic, as shown in Fig. 3(g). The velocity in the [001] direction is obviously smaller than that in the [010] direction, and this phenomenon is in good accordance with the chemical bond distribution shown in ref. 15. The chemical bond strengths of the α and β bond chains are stronger than that of the γ bond chain;15 this leads to a low aspect ratio of the ADP crystals.
The relationship between the supersaturation and the step heights of the ADP crystals in the defined crystallographic direction is shown in Fig. 6. Thus, we can know that (1) the height of the elementary step is about half the height of the unit cell; (2) the growth steps are all elementary steps when σ ≤ 0.8%, and this indicates that the process of crystal growth is stable, with few fluctuations influencing the crystal growth; (3) under the condition of σ ≤ 1.2%, only the spiral step growth mechanism exists in the aqueous solution. Moreover, the elementary steps develop into macro steps, which integrate multiple micro steps via step bunching with the increasing supersaturation; (4) islands, namely 2D nuclei, without any signs of dislocation outcrop appear on the terraces between two steps when σ > 1.2%; thus, the spiral step growth mechanism and 2D nucleation mechanism coexist during the process of crystal growth. When the supersaturation is increased by decreasing the temperature, the 2D nucleation mechanism, whose velocity is anisotropic, will be dominant until the crystal growth is complete.
By comparing our results with those reported in ref. 15, in which (100) face growth morphologies have been obtained for ADP crystals grown in the Z direction at different supersaturations, we can determine the differences and similarities between the prismatic growth morphologies of the ADP crystals in the Z direction and the defined direction.
Similarities: (1) the variation trends of both growth mechanisms are the same, namely changing from the spiral step growth mechanism to the coexistence of spiral step growth and 2D nucleation mechanisms and then to a dominant 2D nucleation mechanism. (2) The exposed faces of the crystals during the growth processes are the same; in both cases, the faces are (100) and (101).
Differences: (1) when σ = 0.6%, 2D nuclei appear on the surface of ADP grown in the Z direction, whereas, this occurs for ADP grown in the defined direction at σ = 1.4%. This phenomenon indicates that the growth rate of the prismatic face of ADP in the defined direction is smaller than that in the Z direction. Therefore, the aspect ratio of ADP in the defined direction is larger. (2) The growth rates of the (100) and (101) faces are different in the two directions.
The (100) face growth morphology of the ADP crystal at a supersaturation of 0.4% is shown in Fig. 4(a); the height of the elementary step is about 0.347 nm, which is half the height of the unit cell. These steps are formed during the initial growth process of ADP and are regular and approximately parallel to each other; they originate from the spiral core produced by screw dislocations. And in the spiral growth mechanism, the equidistant elementary-height steps propagate from the outcrop of the dislocation source of maximum activity.11 In Fig. 4(b), there is a visible hollow core (the core is covered by residual solution after emerging from the growth solution, and the residual solution recrystallizes into small grains). The hollow core is located in the direction of the step propagation and may play a pinning role. As the step free energy exceeds the critical value of the pinning energy, the steps will break through the fence of stoppers and continue to spread out with equidistant heights. The average height of the steps, as shown in Fig. 4(b), is 0.713 nm, equal to the height of the unit cell. Therefore, the impurity, namely Cr3+, in our experiments may play a role in pinning.
In Fig. 4(c), step bunching appears, and the macro steps integrate multiple elementary steps to 1.88 nm. Some circular points among the steps can be seen in the partial enlarged view of Fig. 4(c); these are believed to be defect points caused by the doped impurities. It is believed that this is why inclusions readily appear in the Cr3+-doped ADP, as shown in Fig. 5. As the σ increases to 1.0%, as shown in Fig. 4(d), step bunching continues with a height of 2.37 nm, far less than the height of the steps of the ADP crystals. As the supersaturation increases to 1.2%, as shown in Fig. 4(e), the step bunching continues; the average height of the macro steps is about 3.5 nm. In Fig. 4(f), at a supersaturation of 1.4%, a hollow core is observed; this proves that the impurity ion Cr3+ plays an important role in the formation of defects. When σ increases to 1.6%, as shown in Fig. 4(g), some 2D islands without any signs of dislocation outcrop appear on the terraces between two steps; their average radius is about 700 nm, much greater than the radius of the critical nucleus at this supersaturation.6 The quantity and radii of the 2D islands increase rapidly, and the islands are distributed regularly and in good proportion, as shown in Fig. 4(h); this indicates that the 2D nucleation mechanism is dominant. In Fig. 4(i), it can be seen that the two-dimensional islands continue to increase with an anisotropic growth velocity. The velocity in the [001] direction is obviously smaller than that in the [010] direction, same as the case with non-Cr3+-doped ADP.
The overall relationship between the supersaturation and the step height of Cr3+-doped ADP crystals in the defined crystallographic direction is shown in Fig. 6. Therefore, as σ ≤ 1.4%, the spiral step growth mechanism controls the crystal growth. In the initial process, elementary steps originate from the outcrop of the dislocation source of maximum activity; moreover, the steps are bending and moving towards one another at the front edge. The impurities are pinned on the steps of the (100) face and form hollow cores, which may lead to the appearance of defects or inclusions. Then, macro steps occur via coalescence of multiple micro steps. When σ > 0.014, two-dimensional islands appear with an anisotropic growth velocity, i.e. the velocity in the [001] direction is obviously smaller than that in the [010] direction. Moreover, as σ increases, 2D nuclei form and the 2D nucleation mechanism becomes dominant.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Relationships between supersaturation and the step heights of ADP and Cr3+-doped ADP crystals. |
R = PV | (2) |
V = bβσ | (3) |
The steepness P of a hillock from an isotropic spiral is determined by the structure of the dislocation. Moreover, the steepness is given by:6,30,31
![]() | (4) |
rc = Ωγ/kTσ | (5) |
Therefore, the radius of a critical nucleus rc of ADP in the defined crystallographic direction at different supersaturations can be calculated as shown in Table 2.
Σ (%) | 0.4 | 0.6 | 0.8 | 1.0 | 1.2 | 1.4 | 1.6 | 1.8 |
rc (nm) | 7.01 | 4.68 | 3.51 | 2.81 | 2.34 | 2.0 | 1.75 | 1.56 |
The actual experimental curves of the steepness P of the prismatic faces of the ADP crystals are shown in Fig. 7. Speculating that m in the formula (4) equals 1–3 and according to (4) and (5), the 2L values of the ADP and Cr3+-doped ADP crystals can be calculated, as shown in Table 2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 The steepness P of the prismatic faces of the ADP crystals (the black curve represents ADP and the blue curve indicates Cr3+-doped ADP). |
As shown in Table 3, for the ADP and Cr3+-doped ADP crystals, the maximum value of σ, which meets the condition 2L ≥ 0, increases as m increases. This indicates that as σ increases, the number of layers of the dislocation source will increase. Moreover, as m is constant, 2L1 increases initially and then decreases; however, 2L2 shows a decreasing trend with the increasing σ. Furthermore, 2L1 is larger than 2L2 at the same value of m at low supersaturation (σ ≤ 0.8%) when the step heights are very low; as the macro steps propagate after σ = 1.0%, Cr3+ obviously decreases the overlay layers of the elementary steps and decreases the growth velocity of the (100) face. Therefore, it appears that Cr3+ can impede the length of the perimeter of dislocations and the size of the dislocation cores. This leads to a smaller height of the steps for Cr3+-doped ADP; thus, the growth velocity R decreases at the same supersaturation and temperature. At the same supersaturation in both Cr3+-doped ADP and undoped ADP crystals, the steps of spiral dislocation or 2D nuclei can expand in height and terrace width with time. Moreover, according to the formulas (2)–(4) and fitting of the two curves in Fig. 7, σ increases dynamically with step growth and consumption of the solute; this leads to an increase in the growth velocity R in both Cr3+-doped ADP and undoped ADP crystals.
Σ (%) | 0.4 | 0.6 | 0.8 | 1.0 | 1.2 | 1.4 | 1.6 | 1.8 |
2L1 (m = 1) (nm) | — | 475.9 | 496.4 | 28.3 | −19.5 | −23.4 | — | −21.7 |
2L1 (m = 2) (nm) | — | 1040.7 | 1059.5 | 110.0 | 5.4 | −8.8 | — | −13.8 |
2L1 (m = 3) (nm) | — | 1605.5 | 1622.5 | 191.7 | 30.3 | 5.8 | — | 0.9 |
2L2 (m = 1) (nm) | 413.1 | 426.6 | 97.4 | 98.2 | 49.6 | 20.6 | −0.98 | — |
2L2 (m = 2) (nm) | 959.3 | 942.1 | 261.6 | 222.8 | 143.7 | 79.1 | 27.7 | — |
2L2 (m = 3) (nm) | 1505.6 | 1457.6 | 425.7 | 360.9 | 237.8 | 137.7 | 52.7 | — |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |