Zhongfu Zhao*a,
Peiying Liu
a,
Chunqing Zhang*a,
Wei Liua,
Yifu Ding
b,
Yandong Zhanga,
Fanzhi Menga and
Tao Tangc
aState Key Laboratory of Fine Chemicals, School of Chemical Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, No. 2 Linggong Road, Dalian 116024, China. E-mail: zfzhao@dlut.edu.cn; zhangchq@dlut.edu.cn; Tel: +86-0411-8498-6102
bDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, CO 80309-0427, USA
cState Key Laboratory of Polymer Physics and Chemistry, Changchun Institute of Applied Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Changchun 130022, China
First published on 12th September 2017
A “graft onto” method was combined with an epoxidation reaction and living anionic polymerization to successfully synthesize a series of SIS-g-PB copolymers with defined branch numbers and branch lengths. These copolymers were utilized to formulate various hot-melt pressure-sensitive adhesives (HMPSAs). Their molecular structure and bulk properties were characterized by 1H-nuclear magnetic resonance (1H-NMR), gel permeation chromatography (GPC), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and rheometry. The adhesion performances were characterized in terms of holding power and 180° peel strength. The epoxidation reaction alone would negatively influence the rheological properties of the parent SIS copolymers, particularly for low-temperature applications. Controlled addition of the low-Tg PB blocks can significantly improve the low-temperature properties of the SIS copolymers. Both η* and G′ increased in the lower shear frequency regime (<101 rad s−1) but decreased in the higher shear frequency regime (>101 rad s−1) with branch number and branch length, in which branch length had a greater effect than the branch number. As a result, the 180° peel strength of the SIS-g-PB based HMPSAs displayed reached 0.23 kN m−1, which is more than twice the value for SIS-based HMPSAs.
SIS-based HMPSAs are mainly formulated with SIS copolymers, tackifier resins and antioxidants.10–14 Their nonpolar feature greatly limits their applications due to their poor adhesion with polar materials or weak compatibility with hydrophilic components.15–18 To improve their polarity, addition of polar tackifiers such as rosin and its derivatives were examined. However, the partial compatibility between the additives and the styrene end-block might compromise the integrity of the HMPSAs.3,13,19 Other hydrophilic components were also introduced into the formulation of the SIS-based HMPSAs for transdermal delivery of hydrophilic drugs.20,21 Similarly, this method sacrificed the adhesive performance of the SIS-based HMPSAs due to the weak interface interaction.
Another strategy to improve the polarity of the SIS-based HMPSAs is to functionalize the SIS copolymers.22 One of such approach is to epoxidize SIS (ESIS).23 Indeed, the ESIS markedly improved the polarity of the HMPSAs. However, the compatibility between ESIS and tackifier resins is reduced, which results in a decrease of the adhesive performance of HMPSAs. To overcome this shortcoming, parent SIS resins and ESIS resins were combined in the formulation HMPSAs.24 This method could greatly improve the adhesive performance of the adhesive matrix, but again lowered the polarity of the adhesives.
In this article, we explore a new synthetic approach to improve both the polarity of SIS copolymers and the compatibility with components in the HMPSAs formulations. The main idea is to controllably graft PB blocks onto ESIS, as PB is known to have excellent compatibility with tackifier resins in HMPSAs.25 The influence of the degree of epoxidation, degree of PB grafting on the properties of the SIS-PB copolymers as well as the performance of the corresponding HMPSAs were examined systematically.
![]() | (1) |
For all samples, 10.0 ± 0.1 mg was used in differential scanning calorimetry (DSC, NETZSCH DSC 204 instrument, Germany) measurements. They were first scanned from room temperature to 150 °C, kept for 5 min. Then, they were cooled to −120 °C with a cooling rate of 10 °C min−1 in N2 stream and kept for 5 min. Finally, they were reheated to 150 °C with a heating rate of 10 °C min−1.
A rotational rheometer (AR2000ex, TA Instrument, U.S.) was used to measure the rheological property of SIS-g-PB copolymers. SIS-g-PB copolymers (∼0.5 g) were compressed by a thermal press into discs with a diameter of ∼25 mm and a thickness of ∼1 mm at 170 °C. The rheological measurements were conducted under 170 °C and nitrogen atmosphere, with a frequency range of 0.01 Hz–100 Hz and a strain level of 1%, to ensure that all samples were measured within the linear viscoelastic response region.
These ESISx and parent SIS copolymers were used to fabricate HMPSAs, referred to as H-ESISx and HSIS in the following discussions, respectively. The adhesion performances of all the HMPSAs are summarized in Table 1. Although the holding power remained rather constant within the range of experimental uncertainty, the 180° peel strength showed strong dependency on the epoxidation degree. As the ED exceeds 10%, the corresponding HMPSAs displayed very poor adhesion performance because the compatibility between ESIS and tackifier resins reduced significantly by the excess epoxide groups.23 Since ESIS15 copolymers had sufficient amounts of epoxide groups and correspondingly H-ESIS15 showed only slightly lower adhesion performance compared with SIS-based HMPSA, they were chosen as the main precursors to synthesize graft copolymers. These synthesized branch copolymers were then used to investigate the effect of the branch structures on the adhesion performance of the corresponding HMPSAs in the following paragraphs.
Adhesion performance | H-SIS | H-ESIS5 | H-ESIS11 | H-ESIS15 | H-ESIS20 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Holding power (day) | >7 | >7 | >7 | >7 | >7 |
180° peel strength (kN m−1) | 0.09 ± 0.01 | 0.11 ± 0.02 | 0.09 ± 0.01 | 0.07 ± 0.02 | 0.02 ± 0.03 |
These PB chains were grafted onto ESIS15 to synthesize a range of SISx-yg-PBz copolymers, where x, y and z represent their ED, branch number and branch length, respectively. SIS15-10g-PB3.1 is taken for example to demonstrate the evolution of their molecular structures, measured by GPC (Fig. 4) and 1H-NMR (Fig. 5). Prior to the purification, the as-synthesized products were a mixture of free PB3.1 and SIS15-10g-PB3.1, evidenced by the two elution peaks in the GPC curve (curve b in Fig. 4). After the purification process, the elution peak corresponding to the free PB3.1 disappeared (curve c in Fig. 4). Thus, SIS15-10g-PB3.1 is successfully synthesized without linear PB3.1 chains. In the 1H-NMR spectrum (curve 3 in Fig. 5), there appear typical peaks of PB and SIS, which confirms the successful synthesis of SIS15-10g-PB3.1. Moreover, the peak of epoxide groups at 2.69 ppm is still very strong, showing that most functional groups were remained in the SIS15-10g-PB3.1.
Similarly, other SISx-yg-PBz copolymers with well-defined branch lengths and branch numbers were synthesized with various living PB lithium macroanions under designed molar ratios of PB lithium macroanions to epoxide groups. Table 3 lists their molecular structures based on the GPC results of SISx-yg-PBz, SIS, ESIS and PB branches. Among these copolymers, two series of SIS-g-PB copolymers were chosen to investigate the effects of their branch number (SIS15-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9) and branch length (SIS15-10g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and SIS15-11g-PB4.2) on their thermodynamic properties and corresponding HMPSAs performances.
Sample | Mn (kg mol−1) | St (wt%) | Bd (wt%) | Nb | PDI | [η] (dl g−1) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SIS | 90 | 29 | 0.0 | 0 | 1.06 | 1.170 |
SIS15 | 92 | 31.5 | 1.190 | |||
SIS15-14g-PB1.9 | 116 | 22.5 | 22.4 | 14 | 1.07 | 1.424 |
SIS15-10g-PB1.9 | 109 | 23.9 | 21.1 | 10 | 1.08 | 1.411 |
SIS15-8g-PB1.9 | 103 | 25.3 | 12.6 | 7 | 1.08 | 1.410 |
SIS15-19g-PB3.1 | 150 | 17.4 | 40.0 | 19 | 1.07 | 1.511 |
SIS15-12g-PB3.1 | 127 | 20.6 | 29.1 | 12 | 1.06 | 1.449 |
SIS15-10g-PB3.1 | 121 | 21.6 | 25.6 | 10 | 1.07 | 1.425 |
SIS15-11g-PB4.2 | 136 | 19.2 | 33.8 | 11 | 1.06 | 1.525 |
SIS15-8g-PB4.2 | 125 | 20.9 | 28.0 | 8 | 1.07 | 1.510 |
SIS15-5g-PB4.2 | 113 | 23.1 | 25.6 | 5 | 1.09 | 1.503 |
On the other hand, once grafted onto the ESIS chains, PB blocks, which has a lower Tg than the PI blocks, could restore or even improve the low temperature property of ESIS-based HMPSAs. Fig. 7 displays the DSC curves of PB branches (PB1.9, PB3.1 and PB4.2), showing that the Tg value increases with the molecular weight from −103.4 °C for PB1.9 to −99.0 °C for PB4.2. These PB chains all have much lower Tg values than the SIS copolymers (−56 °C) and ESIS15 (−47.2 °C).
Fig. 8 displays the DSC curves of a series of SIS15-yg-PB1.9 copolymers, showing that there is no distinctive glass transition of PB blocks. Instead, all three branched copolymers showed a single glass transition, with Tg values lower than the ESIS15. As the branch numbers increases from 8 to 14, the Tg value drops monotonically from −53.4 °C for SI5-8g-PB1.9 to −60.3 °C for SIS15-14g-PB1.9, which is even lower than that (−56 °C) of the parent SIS copolymers. Fig. 9 shows the DSC measurements of the copolymer series with constant branch number, but varying branch length. In this case, as the branch length increased from 1.9, 3.1 to 4.2 kg mol−1, the Tg value decreases from −55.0 for SIS15-10g-PB1.9, −70.7 for SIS15-10g-PB3.1 to −71.7 °C for SIS15-11g-PB4.2, which is significantly lower than that (−56 °C) of the parent SIS copolymers. Above experiments suggest that PB blocks are compatible with the PI blocks in the grafted copolymers. As a result, the mixing of PB blocks with the PI blocks effectively reduces the overall Tg values of the copolymers. With increasing number and lengths of the PB branches, the effective concentration of the PB increases, which leads to more reduction in Tg values. Such a property can be utilized to modify the low temperature property of graft copolymers and their corresponding HMPSA.
We further investigated the influences of branch numbers and branch lengths on the rheological properties of the copolymers. Fig. 10 and 11 show the complex viscosity (η*), defined in eqn (2) and storage modulus (G′) versus angular frequency (ω) at 170 °C for SIS, ESIS and various SIS-g-PB copolymers.
![]() | (2) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 (a) η* vs. ω and (b) G′ vs. ω for SIS, ESIS15, SIS5-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9 at 170 °C. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 (a) η* vs. ω and (b) G′ vs. ω for SIS, ESIS15, SIS15-10g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and SIS15-11g-PB4.2 at 170 °C. |
Even though ESIS15 copolymer has similar molecular structures as the SIS copolymer, they display significantly different rheological behavior. In comparison, the former has much lower η* and G′ than the latter throughout the experimental shear frequency range. In the low terminal shear frequency regime, ESIS15 copolymers have a platform region of η* independent of the shear frequency and accompanying even lower G′. As PB branches are grafted onto ESIS backbones, the platform region of η* still exists for SI5-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9. Besides, their η* and G′ increase in the lower shear frequency regime (<101 rad s−1) but decrease in the higher shear frequency regime (>101 rad s−1) with the branches numbers of PB for SI5-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9. But, they are still lower than those of parent SIS copolymers throughout the experimental frequency range.
Fig. 11 illustrates the influence of the branches length on the η* and G′ of SIS-g-PB copolymers. For SIS15-10g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and SIS15-11g-PB4.2, they also have lower η* and G′ than the parent SIS copolymers throughout the experimental shear frequency range. A similar trend takes place. Their η* and G′ increase with the branches length in a low shear frequency regime (<101 rad s−1) but decrease with the branches length in the high shear frequency regime (>101 rad s−1). Their outstanding difference from SIS15-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9 lies in the low terminal shear frequency regime. Clearly, the platform region in the low terminal shear frequency regime disappears for SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and SIS15-11g-PB4.2. Both their η* and G′ have a definite improvement, close to those of parent SIS copolymers. Their complex viscosity curves become higher leading to more prominent shear-thinning phenomenon. Considering the fact that their physical crosslinking sites of PS phase disappear at 170 °C, their rheological behavior could be interpreted as the typical character of polymers with long chain branching.27 For SIS15-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9, their branches length is very close to the critical molecular weight for entanglements of PB chains so that they have no the typical character of polymers with long chain branching. The results also show that the branches length has greater effects on the rheology of SIS-g-PB copolymers than the branches number in the experimental range.
In Fig. 12, these SIS-g-PB copolymers are analyzed by their van Gurp–Palmen (vGP) plots, in which the loss angle, δ (tanδ = G′′/G′), is plotted as a function of the absolute value of complex modulus (|G*|). The vGP plot is a useful tool for getting insight into the molecular structure of long chain branched polymers.27 It has been pointed out that materials are almost completely viscous when the δ terminal value is close to 90° and almost completely elastic when the δ terminal value is close to 0°. The δ terminal value of parent SIS copolymers is very low (<30°). By comparison, ESIS15 copolymers have much higher δ terminal value (close to 60°), demonstrating that the elasticity of parent SIS copolymers is significantly reduced due to the introduction of epoxide groups. SIS15-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9 have similar δ terminal value with ESIS15, demonstrating that PB1.9 is not long enough to dramatically influence the rheological properties and the effect of branch number can be ignored in these copolymers. As their branch length increases in SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and SIS15-11g-PB4.2, their similar δ terminal value dramatically decreases, approaching that of SIS copolymers. Obviously, the elasticity of SIS-g-PB copolymers can be restored only if the branch length is longer enough than the critical molecular weight for entanglements of PB chains.
Two series of SIS-g-PB copolymers were chosen to fabricate various HMPSAs in order to investigate the effects of the branch number (SIS15-8g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and SIS15-14g-PB1.9) and branch length (SIS15-10g-PB1.9, SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and SIS15-11g-PB4.2) on the HMPSAs performances. These HMPSAs are named as H-SISx-yg-PBz, where SISx-yg-PBz represents the corresponding SIS-g-PB copolymers. The adhesion performances were summarized in Table 4, mainly including holding power and 180° peel strength measurement results. The holding power of the grafted copolymers was similar with that of H-SIS and H-ESIS15, and showed no obvious change with the topological structures of SIS-g-PB copolymers in the experimental range (7 days). However, their 180° peel strength is prominently influenced by the branch number and branch length of SIS-g-PB copolymers.
Adhesion performance | H-SIS15-8g-PB1.9 | H-SIS15-10g-PB1.9 | H-SIS15-14g-PB1.9 | H-SIS15-10g-PB3.1 | H-SIS15-11g-PB4.2 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Holding power (day) | >7 | >7 | >7 | >7 | >7 |
180° peel strength (kN m−1) | 0.15 ± 0.02 | 0.21 ± 0.01 | 0.23 ± 0.02 | 0.20 ± 0.01 | 0.18 ± 0.03 |
In comparison, their 180° peel strength is much higher than the SIS-based HMPSAs in practical applications (Table 1). To elaborate the mechanism underlying the enhanced adhesion performance, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 is taken as an example for analysis. From DSC measurements (Fig. 13), C5 resin is completely compatible with the PI blocks of SIS copolymers so that the glass transition of PI markedly shifts to higher temperature. In the case of ESIS15/C5 blends, the Tg of PI slightly shifts to higher temperature. It is clear that the compatibility between SIS and C5 resin is negatively impacted by the introduction of epoxide groups, which results in the lower 180° peel strength of H-SIS15. As discussed in Fig. 8, SIS15-10g-PB1.9 has a low Tg value, due to the PB branches, which notably shifts to much higher temperature in the blend of SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and C5 resin. To some degree, the long PB branches restore the compatibility between the rubber phase of copolymers and the C5 resin. As a result, H-SIS15-10g-PB1.9 displayed higher 180° peel strength than H-SIS.
In Table 4, the 180° peel strength increases with the branch number of copolymers for H-SIS15-8g-PB1.9, H-SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and H-SIS15-14g-PB1.9, but slightly changes with the branch length of copolymers for H-SIS15-10g-PB1.9, H-SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and H-SIS15-11g-PB4.2. These copolymers all have excellent compatibility with C5 resin just like the blend of SIS15-10g-PB1.9 and C5 resin (see ESI Fig. S1 and 2†). Thus, the SIS-g-PB/C5 compatibility cannot be directly used to explain the different adhesive performance of these HMPSAs, different from H-SIS and H-ESIS15. It is well-known that the branch chains usually enhance the bulk properties of branched copolymers by increasing the entanglement of the chains. This does not agree with the trend of 180° peel strength for H-SIS15-10g-PB1.9, H-SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and H-SIS15-11g-PB4.2. As described in the experimental section, these HMPSAs contain about 70 wt% of a tackifier and a plasticizer. These SIS-g-PB copolymers can “dissolve” into the “solid solution” of the tackifier and the plasticizer through the excellent compatibility between the rubber phases and C5 resins, in which the entanglement of PB branches can be ignored even at the longer branch length. These SIS-g-PB copolymers still work as skeletons in their HMPSAs through the entanglement of polystyrene blocks. As a result, their adhesive performances increase with the branch number because the epoxide groups can be covered by the corresponding branches. As the increase of their branch length has no effect on the epoxide groups, the 180° peel strength has nearly no change for H-SIS15-10g-PB1.9, H-SIS15-10g-PB3.1 and H-SIS15-11g-PB4.2.
The results demonstrated that SIS-g-PB copolymer based HMPSAs displayed much higher adhesive performances than SIS and ESIS based HMPSAs. The enhancement was attributed to the improved combability between the ESIS and the matrix resin of the HMPSAs. Furthermore, for SIS-g-PB copolymers with constant PB concentration, the branch numbers appeared to have a greater impact than the branch lengths on the performance of the HMPSAs. The method reported here offers a new approach to improve both the polarity and adhesive performance of the SIS-based HMPSAs.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c7ra08180d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |