Xiying Feng,
Lihua Zeng,
Dianting Zou,
Zizhe Zhang,
Guihao Zhong,
Shuyin Peng,
Liping Liu,
Liuping Chen and
Jianyong Zhang*
Sun Yat-Sen University, Lehn Institute of Functional Materials, MOE Laboratory of Bioinorganic and Synthetic Chemistry, Guangzhou 510275, China. E-mail: zhjyong@mail.sysu.edu.cn
First published on 27th July 2017
A novel approach has been proposed to fabricate MOF-based luminescent gel materials with trace amounts of doping in order to study the role of trace defects in metal–organic gel materials. UiO-66-based ZrBDC (BDC = 1,4-benzene dicarboxylate) gels were first prepared from Zr4+ and H2BDC under mild conditions, and subsequently trace doping (as low as 0.01 mol%) of the ZrBDC gel materials with H4TCPE (tetrakis(4-carboxyphenyl)ethylene) was achieved successfully. The resulting ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% gel material features mild synthetic conditions and retains the high porosity of parent UiO-66 gel materials. Moreover, trace doping causes a remarkable change to the luminescence properties and the gel emits blue luminescence with high quantum yield (59%). ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% shows responses with high sensitivity and selectivity for nitroaromatics (picric acid) in the aqueous phase and detects picric acid as low as parts per billion (24 ppb). The present luminescent gel materials provide new insights into developing functional metal–organic materials through trace defects, which may remarkably alter the properties of metal–organic materials.
In the present work we propose a novel approach for fabricating MOF-based gel materials with trace-doped-enhancement luminescence. MOF-based gel materials are assembled from MOF nanoparticles, combining the advantages of MOFs and of gels.18–22 UiO-66-based ZrBDC (BDC = 1,4-benzene dicarboxylate) gel materials have been developed as new members of these materials. Subsequent trace doping (as low as 0.01 mol%) of the gel materials with tetraphenylethylene (TPE) lumiphore has been achieved (Fig. 1). The resulting materials have three features. (1) MOFs offer a platform with high surface areas, tuneable framework composition. Among them, UiO-66-type MOFs have Zr6-based robust and porous networks with high connectivity with each [Zr6(μ3-O)4(μ3-OH)4]12+ node linked to 12 carboxylates of 1,4-benzene dicarboxylate ligands,23–25 showing high thermal and chemical stability.26–29 (2) Gelation is a powerful method to prepare micro-meso-macroporous hierarchical metal–organic materials with surface and inherent defects under mild conditions.30–34 It may scale down MOF crystallites to the nanosize regime and implement hierarchical porosity to overcome diffusion limitations.18–22 (3) Materials with trace doping may be interesting because it may save expensive luminescent materials and avoid some problems caused by high doping concentration such as unstable luminescence and device aging. Additionally trace-doped materials are generally isostructural to the parent ones, thus it is easy to predict the outcome structure and the synthesis of functionalized materials becomes versatile and applicable.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) SEM and (b) TEM images of ZrBDC-1:1-0.15, and (c) SEM and (d) TEM images of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%. Scale bars represent 500 nm for SEM images. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 PXRD patterns of (from bottom to top) simulated UiO-66, ZrBDC-1:1-0.15, ZrBDC–TCPEx (x = 0.01, 0.1, 1, 10%) wet gels. The patterns are vertically offset for clarity. |
To create luminescent gels, tetraphenylethylene (TPE) lumiphore is subsequently introduced into the ZrBDC-1:1-0.15 gel via trace doping of tetrakis(4-carboxyphenyl)ethylene (H4TCPE). In this strategy TCPE is an inherent component as the organic struts for the construction of the gel matrix via coassembly of two ligands into gels. TCPE groups replace part of the 1,4-benzenedicarboxylate linkers in the gel material, creating luminescent gel materials. Additionally TPE features aggregation-induced emission (AIE) characteristics showing highly enhanced emission in the aggregate state.36 Immobilization of H4TCPE into a rigid framework may inhibit the rotation and torsion of phenyl rings, leading to increased quantum yield.37–41 ZrBDC-1:1-0.15 gel with trace doping (0.01%) of TCPE was prepared, synthetically 0.01% equivalent of H4TCPE with respect of H2BDC was used to prepare metal–organic gels, and the sample is denoted as ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% (Fig. 1). For comparison ZrBDC–TCPEx (x = 0.1, 1, 10%) gels were also prepared (Fig. S1†). In order to characterize the porosity, the solvent in the wet gels was removed by centrifugation and exchanged with ethanol, and the resulting materials were dried by subcritical CO2(l) to obtain dried materials as crushed solid.
SEM and TEM reveal that the introducing of TCPE does not affect the morphology significantly, showing similar porous structures with cross-linked nanoparticles (Fig. 2c, d and S2–S4†). In comparison ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% consists of smaller nanoparticles with ca. 20–50 nm size. The gels give well-resolved PXRD patterns with salient peaks that precisely match the simulated patterns of single-crystal UiO-66, indicating that the crystallinity of UiO-66 is maintained (Fig. 3). The crystallite size of is ca. 41 nm for ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%, as simulated by the Scherer equation. The smaller nanoparticles may be attributed to the presence of increasing surface and inherent defects in the trace-doped materials.
ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% gel was also characterized by other analytical techniques including FT-IR, EDX and XPS (Fig. S5–S11†), but no difference could be identified as expected due to the trace presence of TCPE. FT-IR spectra account for the presence of carboxylate in the metal coordination sphere, as evidenced by the CO asymmetric stretching at around 1580 cm−1. Elemental composition analysis by energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) reveals that trace of Cl was present as well in the gels which originate from the precursors. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis shows that the Zr 3d3/2 and 3d5/2 binding energies are 185.2 and 182.8 eV, respectively, confirming the presence of highly oxidized tetravalent zirconium.
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) profiles of ZrBDC-1:1-0.15 and ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% exhibit continuous weight loss of 56%, related to the removal of moisture, free solvent and ligand and they may remain thermally stable up to ca. 550 °C (Fig. S12†). In the TGA profile of ZrBDC-1:1-0.15, a weight loss from 68 wt% to 44 wt% between 500 and 600 °C means that the as-synthesized material is defective, exhibiting about 8 BDC ligands per Zr6O4(OH)4 cluster. In the TGA profile of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%, the weight loss from 71 wt% to 46 wt% between 500 and 600 °C is consistent with a BDC:
Zr6 ratio of 8, in line with similar linker deficiency.42 Such defective UiO-66 materials43–46 may be produced because the present synthesis temperature was low.47
To evaluate the porosity, N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms were collected for the dried materials (Fig. 4 and Table S2†). For ZrBDC-1:1-0.15, the BET surface area is 1140–1236 m2 g−1 and the total pore volume is 0.929–1.107 cm3 g−1 (two parallel measurements). Its microporosity nature was indicated by rapid gas sorption at low relative pressure (P/P0 < 0.05). Pore size distributions obtained by nonlocal density functional theory (NLDFT) show main pore size centred at ca. 1.11 and 1.27 nm, interpreted as octahedral cages in the pristine UiO-66 structure as well as defect-related regions.48 The trace doping with TCPE (0.01%, 0.1%) does not show much effect on the porosity of gel materials. For ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%, the BET surface area is 1145–1280 m2 g−1 and the total pore volume is 0.598–0.832 cm3 g−1 (two parallel measurements). Additionally the pore size does not change greatly with main pore size centred at ca. 1.11 and 1.27 nm. This is consistent with the reported data with only 8 linkers per node44 and the above TG data. However, the BET surface areas (1044–901 m2 g−1) and pore volumes (0.613–0.682 cm3 g−1) decrease with high doping concentration of TCPE (1%, 10%).
The photoluminescence property of ZrBDC–TCPEx gel materials synthesized with various doping concentration (0.01–10% of TCPE with respect to BDC) was examined (Fig. 5a, S13 and Table S3†). ZrBDC-1:1-0.15 gel is nearly weakly emissive with an emission band at about 498 nm and a fluorescence quantum yield of 14% in gel state. The fluorescence spectra of ZrBDC–TCPEx gels display an obvious blue shift and the corresponding emission efficiency increases remarkably. In contrast to ZrBDC-1:1-0.15 gel, ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% is highly emissive. The fluorescence is blue-shifted with an emission maximum at 461 nm, which originate from the ligand-based π–π* transition. The fluorescence efficiency of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% is as high as 59%, much higher than that of the parent gel. The time-resolved emission-decay behaviours show that the weighted mean lifetime is 3.32 ns for ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%.
The emission peak wavelengths for the ZrBDC–TCPEx gels dispersed in water range from 461 nm (x = 0.01%) to 521 nm (x = 10%). With increasing content of TCPE, the emission wavelengths presented a red-shift. The emission of the ZrBDC–TCPEx gels with higher content of TCPE move closer to that of the ZrTCPE gel (λem = 540 nm). Thus the emission of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% mainly ascribe to the homogeneous distribution of TCPE in the framework. The porous network of ZrBDC UiO-66 nanoparticles sterically inhibits the TPE fluorophores from approaching each other and prevents the aggregation of TCPE molecules. This leads to the blue-shifted emission of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% in comparison with ZrTCPE. The blue shift in the emission is obvious when the doping concentration is low.
The unique porosity and the fluorescence of ZrBDC–TCPEx gels prompted us to explore their potential application as fluorescent sensors for nitroexplosives. The open framework structure of ZrBDC–TCPEx gels with high surface area and large pore windows may facilitate guest diffusion across the frameworks and easily interact with active lumiphore sites. Herein picric acid (PA) was used as a model nitroexplosive (Scheme S1†). Fluorescence quenching titrations with various PA concentrations were conducted at room temperature in aqueous solution because aqueous-phase detection is preferred for probing of nitro explosives in soil or groundwater.49 The gels were readily dispersed in water with a concentration of 10 g L−1 for detection. The fluorescent intensity gradually decreases with the addition of PA into ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% (Fig. 5b, c and S14†). The Stern–Volmer (SV) equation of the relative fluorescence intensity vs. PA concentration in aqueous solution is I0/I = KSV[A] + 1, where I0 and I are the photoluminescence intensities before and after addition of the analyte, respectively, and [A] is the molar concentration of the analyte. KSV is the quenching constant (L mol−1). The relative fluorescence intensity is linear with the concentration suggesting the quenching is mainly diffusion-limited. The quenching constant for PA is 2.91 × 105 L mol−1 in the low concentration range (0–0.53 mol L−1) (R2 = 0.9962), which is remarkably higher than that of a closely related TPE-modified Zr-MOF (2.8 × 104 L mol−1),50 lying amongst the highest of the known luminescent MOF-based sensors.51–53 The limit of detection (LOD) is calculated by the fluorescence quenching data using the 3σ/slope criteria using the equation LOD = 3σ/m, where σ is the standard deviation of blank measurements, and m is the slope between the fluorescence intensity and analyte concentration. The LOD is 1.05 × 10−7 mol L−1 (24 ppb) for ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%. Interestingly, both the quenching constant and the LOD decrease when the doping concentration of TCPE is higher for the ZrBDC–TCPEx gels (Fig. S15 and S16†). The quenching constant is 1.82 × 105 and 5.64 × 104 L mol−1 and the LOD is 1.98 × 10−7 (45 ppb) and 5.25 × 10−7 (120 ppb) for ZrBDC–TCPE0.1% and ZrBDC–TCPE1%, respectively. Therefore, the present gel material with trace doping of TCPE greatly enhances fluorescence response efficiency and demonstrates the potential as a novel type of highly sensitive sensors for PA in aqueous phase.
Fluorescence quenching titrations were also performed with nitroaromatic compounds with similar chemical structures such as 2,6-dinitrophenol (2,6-DNP), 1,3-dinitrobenzene (1,3-DNB), 4-nitrophenol (4-NP), 2-nitrophenol (2-NP) and nitrobenzene (NB), and nitro-aliphatic compounds such as 2,3-dimethyl-2,3-dinitrobutane (DMDNB), 1-nitropropane (NProp) and nitromethane (NM) (Scheme S1†). In a typically designed experimental protocol, the fluorescence spectrum for ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% dispersed in water was monitored upon the incremental addition of an aqueous solution of nitroaromatic compounds. Different extents of fluorescence quenching take place upon the addition of the same amount of various analytes (400 μL of 0.1 mM) (Fig. 5d and S17–S25†). The fluorescence quenching efficiencies of various analytes are calculated using the equation (I0 − I)/I0 × 100%, where I0 and I are the fluorescence intensities of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% before and after the addition of the analytes. The fluorescence quenching efficiencies are in the order, PA (83.1%) ≫ 4-NP (51.8%) > 2,6-DNT (41.2%) > 2-NP (30.0%) > 1,3-DNB (15.6%) > DMDNB (12.3%) > NB (10.0%) > NM (8.6%) > 1-NProp (6.6%). It suggests that PA shows significant and sensitive fluorescence quenching, while other nitroaromatic compounds with similar chemical structures have much lower fluorescence quenching efficiencies.
The quenching mechanism may be proposed as follow. The tested analytes have suitable sizes (e.g., PA 5.0 × 6.2 × 7.1 Å) to enter the pores of gel nanoparticles.54 The selective fluorescence quenching for PA may be attributed to energy transfer of the excited-state electron of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01% to the electron-deficient PA molecule with its electron-withdrawing –NO2 group. The absorption bands of the analyte PA display considerable overlap with the emission spectra of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%, while nearly absent overlap in the cases of other nitro compounds (Fig. S26†). Resonance energy transfer can effectively occur from the fluorophore to non-emitting analytes. In addition, the fluorescence emission decays instantly upon the addition of PA solution into ZrBDC–TCPE1% and maintain an equilibration afterwards (Fig. S26†). The decay time is short to fall in the data collection time of the fluorometer (<1 min). It suggests facile diffusion (mass transfer) of PA across the porous gel network of ZrBDC–TCPE0.01%.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details, photos, SEM and TEM images, EDX, IR, XPS spectra, TGA and luminescence data. See DOI: 10.1039/c7ra05783k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |