Open Access Article
Mikhail
Khrizanforov
,
Sofia
Strekalova
,
Kirill
Kholin
,
Vera
Khrizanforova
,
Valeriya
Grinenko
,
Tatyana
Gryaznova
and
Yulia
Budnikova
*
A.E. Arbuzov Institute of Organic and Physical Chemistry, Kazan Scientific Center of Russian Academy of Sciences, 8, Arbuzov str., 420088 Kazan, Russian Federation. E-mail: khrizanforov@gmail.com; Fax: +7 843 2732253; Tel: +7 843 2795335
First published on 25th April 2016
A new approach is proposed for ferrocene phosphorylation using α-hydroxylalkylphosphonate as a “masked” phosphorylating agent, by electrochemical reduction of a ferrocene and (Me)2C(OH)P(O)(OC2H5)2 mixture at −50 °C. The method makes it possible to obtain the product of diethyl ferrocenyl phosphonate with a high yield (87–89%) and 100% conversion of the initial phosphonate in one stage. It is evidenced with experiments that ferrocene reduction is carried out with preservation of the iron charge in the ferrocene fragment and with the formation of a cyclopentadienyl ligand radical anion at −3.3 V ref. Ag/AgCl (at −50 °C).
Ferrocene-bearing ligands proved to be prospective precursors in the design of various complexes and coordination polymers, which possess interesting and practically applicable physical features. The electrochemical, magnetic, luminescent and nonlinear optical features of coordination polymers with ferrocene fragments are of particular significance.3,7,16–20 This is due to the specific geometries that the ferrocenyl moiety can determine as well as to its electronic (redox) properties. Ferrocene can be regarded as a universal modifier for organic compounds and biomolecules. Due to stable sandwich structure and reversibility of oxidation under physiological pH, ferrocene can be used as a redox-active but nonradioactive label.21–24 Moreover, with its high lipophilicity, ferrocene easily penetrates cell and nuclear membranes and overcomes the blood brain barrier. Ferrocene as a carrier (or, in modern terms, a vector) can be used for the delivery of other molecules through membranes. It is important that the toxicity of organic compounds decreases upon Fc modification.24,25 Ferrocenyl organophosphorus ligands are usually stable, easy to handle and often isolable as optical stereoisomers. Ferrocenyl phosphine ligands are able to form complexes with transition metals in a variety of coordinative geometries and oxidation states, thus producing efficient catalyst precursors for many chemical transformations.1,16
The first attempts to introduce a phosphorous substituent to a ferrocene by means of (EtO)2P(O)H free-radical phosphorylation occurred as early as 1962;26 however, they were unsuccessful. It was shown that mixing a ferrocene suspension in phosphorous trichloride PCl3 with aluminum chloride AlCl3 and a subsequent hydrolysis of the reaction mixture would lead to the formation of ferrocenyl(H-phosphinic)acid and 1,1′-ferrocenyl-bis(H-phosphinic)acid with a low yield of 3–5%.27 The use of (dimethylamine)dichlorophosphine Me2NPCl2 as the phosphorylating reagent somehow made it possible to increase the yield of the acid to 9%.28 Ferrocenyl(phenyl)phosphonic acid was obtained with a high yield of 92% in the course of the reaction of ethyl ether of ferrocenyl(phenyl)phosphonic acid Fc(Ph)P(O)OEt with Me3SiBr and subsequent hydrolysis.29 However, Fc(Ph)P(O)OEt obtaining is based on the use of a hazardous gas Cl2, which makes this method much less attractive.
The most frequent method of synthesis of ferrocene derivatives with phosphorus-containing substituents is based on the metallation of ferrocene (for instance, with butyllithium) or its derivatives with a subsequent addition of chlorophosphine electrophile.16,18,29–33 Diethyl ferrocenyl phosphonate FcP(O)(OEt)2 was obtained with the yield of 33% using a reaction of ferrocene monolithium with diethylchlorophosphate (EtO)2P(O)Cl at 0 °C.27 The addition of a base tBuOK facilitated an increase in yield to 79% (at −78 °C in THF, Scheme 1).32
This approach is multi-stage, as it includes the use of t-BuLi (after adding tert-butoxide to ferrocene) at a very low temperature −78 °C at the first stage, and the use of a chlorinated derivative, i.e., diethyl chlorophosphate, which is toxic, unstable and results in chlorine-containing byproducts, at the second stage.32 It is also disadvantageous to use the explosive solvent THF. For that reason, such a method is expensive and environmentally unacceptable.
The latest achievements in the field of direct phosphorylation of the C(sp2)–H bons in a variety of aromatic substrates, including electrochemical functionalization, do not concern the phosphorylation of ferrocenes.34–37
Taking into account the importance of ferrocene derivatives with phosphor-containing substituents, search of new, more convenient, one-stage and selective approaches to their synthesis remains a relevant objective. The purpose of this work is to develop a method for the direct phosphorylation of ferrocene with α-hydroxylethylphosphonate under electrochemical reduction conditions and to identify the intermediate of this reaction.
| No | Reagents and ratios | Base additive | Electrode/reaction potential | Producta yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|
a
– 1-diethyl ferrocenyl phosphonate; 2-1,1′-ferrocenylbis-(diethylphosphonate); 3-ferrocenylphosphonic acid.
|
||||
| 1 | Fc : (CH3)2C(OH)P(O)(OEt)2 [1 : 1] |
Et4NOH | Pt/−3.3 V | 1, 88% |
| 2, 2% | ||||
| 2 | Fc : (CH3)2C(OH)P(O)(OEt)2 [1 : 2] |
Et4NOH | Pt/−3.3 V | 1, 60% |
| 2, 12% | ||||
| 3 | Fc : (CH3)2C(OH)P(O)(OEt)2 [1 : 1] |
NaOH + Et4NBF4 | Pt/−2.9 V | 1, 61% |
| 2, 6% | ||||
| 4 | Fc : HP(O)(OEt)2 [1 : 1] |
Et4NBF4 | Pb/−3.2 V | 1, 35% |
| 5 | Fc : H3PO3 [1 : 1] |
Et4NBF4 | Pb/−3.3 V | 3, 36% |
The use of Et4NOH provides higher yield compared to NaOH, probably because, in the latter case, due to side reactions of sodium reduction and the formation of sparingly soluble sodium salts of phosphorous acids. Alkaline conditions are necessary for a slow transformation of the “masked” phosphorylating agent into H-phosphonate by a known reaction,38–41 which we assumed would be quickly captured by the reduced form of ferrocene. In the absence of Et4NOH (or NaOH), phosphorylation with (CH3)2C(OH)P(O)(OEt2) does not occur.
Interestingly, in the proposed low-temperature conditions, phosphorous acid H3PO3 can also serve as a phosphorylating reagent using a lead cathode because it is not reduced in the available range of potentials on Pb at −50 °C (Table 1, line 5, product 3). An alkali activator is not required in this case. It should be noted that the lead cathode at low temperatures and high cathode potentials is gradually degraded, hence its use is limited to (by) only several cycles of synthesis. In this regard, preference was given to a platinum electrode and correspondingly suitable for it phosphorylated substrate, (Me)2C(OH)P(O)(OC2H5)2. After passing of 1F of electricity (not 2F, as shown in Table 1), the yield reduced by ca. 10–12%. Further increase (>2F) of the passed current led to a decrease in yield and an unidentified byproducts formation. Ferrocene phosphorylation reaction with the use of dialkyl-H-phosphonate at the lead cathode occurs non-selectively, the yield of target product, determined by 31P NMR spectra, was 35% (Table 1, line 4). Unidentified phosphorus-containing products were formed and the electrode was partially destroyed.
A high-purity solvent and electrochemical measurements at temperatures ranging from −45 °C to −30 °C have made it possible to observe a reversible one-electron reduction of ferrocene on mercury, platinum and glassy-carbon electrodes in DMF and dimethoxyethane.45–47 However, the voltammograms are poorly reproducible, the approximate half-wave potential is −2.9 V (ref. electrode was not specified) at −37 °C (ref. 43) or −3.0 V at −90 °C in THF (ref. SCE).45 It was assumed that, as a result of the reduction, a relatively unstable Cp2Fe− anion would be formed.48 An increase in temperature leads to a two-electron reduction of the ferrocene and its decomposition, thereby forming metal iron on the mercury cathode.46 Attempts were made to reduce the ferrocene in the CO atmosphere, and the formation of [CpFe(CO)2]2 was observed.49
We have assumed the reversibility of the ferrocene reduction at low temperatures and, accordingly, the relative stability of the reduced form (at least, in the time scale of the voltammetry) could be used to perform the functionalization-phosphorylation with its participation. The choice of partner for the coupling the ferrocene is limited by its reduction potential; that is, its Ep should be more negative than that of the ferrocene, or it should be electrochemically inactive in the accessible cathode range of the potentials. The voltammograms of investigated phosphorylating agents reduction on electrodes with low and high hydrogen overvoltage (Pt and Pd, correspondingly) at 25 °C and −50 °C, respectively, are shown in Fig. 1. Earlier it was known that dialkyl phosphites were reduced on electrodes with low hydrogen overvoltage at room temperature on platinum or glassy-carbon type electrodes in aprotic solvent in the presence of ammonium salts as supporting electrolyte,50,51 although in the range of high potentials, but still comparable with that for ferrocene. We can clearly see that voltammograms of phosphorus compounds with P–H bonds ((EtO)2PHO, H3PO3) have no pronounced reduction peaks on platinum, as noted previously,51 but their electrochemical activity is reflected in the sharp decrease of the limiting potential at which current increases, apparently due to the discharge of phosphoric acids and background electrolyte. The evolution of hydrogen, which can be observed visually, leads to oscillations in the voltammograms. The use of a lead electrode with high hydrogen overvoltage allows to extend the available range of potentials, because no electrode reaction up to −3.4 V is observed (Fig. 1).
Consequently, α-hydroxyethylphosphonate, so-called “masked” phosphorylating agent,38–41 is a more appropriate phosphorylating agent in our case (Table 1, lines 1–3). It is not reduced in the investigated accessible potential window in DMF on platinum cathode (Fig. 1) but is capable of slowly generating diethylphosphonate in the reaction mixture in the presence of a base.38–41
Cyclic voltammetry of ferrocene at the temperature of −50 °C is presented in Fig. 2 and Table 2. Accessible potential range increases at low temperatures. In the research conditions, two quasi-reversible peaks of oxidation and reduction of the ferrocene are observed, respectively. The quasi-reversible reduction at the potential of E1/2 = −3.10 V is well matched to the results of the ESR experiments, evidencing the formation of stable radical anions at this potential. The addition of a single electron to a neutral (uncharged) molecule generates chemical species called the radical anion (in our case, ferrocene radical-anion),52 which simultaneously has a unit of negative charge and an unpaired electron, as is known.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Cyclic voltammogram of ferrocene. Conditions: T = −50 °C, glassy carbon working electrode, Ag/AgCl ref. electrode, 0.5 mM concentration, Bu4NBF4, DMF, 100 mV s−1. | ||
| Oxidation, Fc0/Fc+ | Reduction, Fc0/Fc˙− | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E ap/Ecp, V | ΔEa–cp, V | E 1/2, V | E cp/Eap, V | ΔEc–ap, V | E 1/2, V |
| 0.62/0.53 | 0.09 | 0.57 | −3.19/−3.01 | 0.18 | −3.10 |
There is no distinct reduction peak on the CV of the obtained diethylphosphonate at room temperature and at −50 °C in the available range of potentials. Selectivity of ferrocene phosphorylation, high yield of monophosphorylation product and trace amounts of by-products in the optimal synthesis conditions indicate that the products are stable in electrolysis conditions and do not undergo further redox or chemical reactions (Table 1). We investigated the electrochemical behavior of diethyl ferrocenyl phosphonate in the electrolysis conditions (Fig. 3, Table 3). It has been found that the CV of this product differs strongly from CV of an unsubstituted ferrocene. So, diethyl ferrocenyl phosphonate is characterized by quasi-reversible oxidation peak at more positive potentials compared to that for ferrocene, ΔEa–cp = 0.44 V (Table 3). Importantly, the phosphorylated ferrocene cathodic peak is not observed in the available potential range (Fig. 3). Apparently, heterogeneous rate constants of oxidation and reduction of the phosphorylated ferrocene is much less than those for ferrocene under similar conditions. The observed redox properties explain the success of the ferrocene phosphorylation.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Cyclic voltammetry of diethyl ferrocenyl phosphonate. Conditions: T = −50 °C, glassy carbon working electrode, Ag/AgCl ref. electrode, 0.5 mM [Fe], Bu4NBF4 background salt, DMF, 100 mV s−1. | ||
| Oxidation, R-Fc0/R-Fc+ | Reduction, R-Fc0/R-Fc˙− | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E ap/Ecp, V | ΔEa–cp, V | E 1/2, V | E cp/Eap, V | ΔEc–ap, V | E 1/2, V |
| 0.94/0.50 | 0.44 | 0.72 | —/−2.95 | — | — |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 ESR signal of reduced ferrocene (at −3.3 V) in a DMF solution, −50 °C. g = 2.000, ΔHpeak–peak = 11 Gs. | ||
At further increasing negative potential of the electrode, the ESR spectra become more complicated (Fig. 5). It is most likely that they correspond to paramagnetic products of ferrocene molecule decomposition. The simulated signal sim1 with a splitting from two protons refers to a derivative of the free ligand without the ferrocene structure. The simulated signal sim2 most likely refers to a fragment with Fe. ESR signals exist for a long time after the potential has been disconnected, but their intensity did not reduce for at least half an hour at the temperature of −50 °C.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 ESR signals of reduced ferrocene at −3.9 V in a DMF solution at the temperature of −50 °C. sim1: g = 2.0063, 2: aH = 7 Gs ΔH = 0.7 Gs; sim2: g = 2.002, ΔHpeak–peak = 11 Gs. | ||
In fact, in the reaction conditions we simultaneously generated dialkyl H-phosphonate from (Me)2C(OH)P(O)(OC2H5)2 by a known reaction, as well as ferrocene radical anions, which react with each other, ultimately producing a phosphorylated ferrocene with good yield in a single stage. The proposed scheme is the best possible, but it does not preclude any other separate stage that might lead to the same final product.
A platinum wire was used as an auxiliary electrode. The curve recording was performed at the potential linear sweep rate of 100 mV s−1. The measurements were performed in a temperature-controlled electrochemical cell (volume from 1 ml to 5 ml) in an inert gas atmosphere (N2). The cooling of the researched solutions was performed with frozen carbon dioxide.
Between measurements or prior to the registration of a voltammetry wave, the solution was actively stirred with a magnetic stirrer in the atmosphere of constant inflow of an inert gas that was run through a dehydrating system, and then through a BI-GAScleaner (manufactured by OOO Modern Laboratory Equipment, Novosibirsk) nickel-based purification system to remove any trace quantity of oxygen.
NMR spectra were recorded with a Bruker AVANCE-400 multi-nuclear spectrometer (400.1 MHz (1H), 100.6 MHz (13C) and 162.0 MHz (31P)). Chemical shifts are given in parts per million relative to SiMe4 (1H, internal solvent) and 85% H3PO4 (31P, external).
Et4NBF4 was obtained by mixing 30–35% water solution of tetraethylammonium hydroxide, Et4NOH and HBF4 acid to a neutral indicator reaction. In the course of the reaction, a white crystal precipitation is deposited, which is filtered and dehydrated. The obtained powder salts were recrystallized from ethyl ester and were dried for 2 to 3 days in a vacuum at 55 °C.
Ferrocene (98%) and H3PO3 (extra pure, 98%, Acrosorganics) were used without preliminary purification.
Et4NOH (20% aqueous solution, Acrosorganics) was subjected to a complete dehydration to a white solid on Schlenk's system prior to the beginning of the experiment.
O), 1052 (P–O). EIMS, m/z: 322.15 [M]+; anal. calc.: C, 52.20; H, 5.95; Fe, 17.34; O, 14.90; P, 9.62; for C14H19FePO3; found: C, 52.14; H, 5.91; P, 9.58, Fe, 17.24. The spectroscopic data for diethyl ferrocenyl phosphonate matched that reported in the literature.28
O), 1055 (P–O). EIMS, m/z: 458.57 [M]+; anal. calc.: C, 47.18; H, 6.16; Fe, 12.19; O, 20.95; P, 13.52 for C18H28FeO6P2; found: C, 47.16; H, 6.09, P, 13.45, Fe, 12.13. The spectroscopic data for 1,1′-ferrocenylbis(diethylphosphonate) matched that reported in the literature.28
O), 1030 (P–O). EIMS, m/z: 266.70 [M]+; anal. calc.: C, 45.11; H, 4.13; P, 11.65, Fe, 20.97. for C10H11FePO3 found: C, 45.16; H, 4.10; P, 11.69, Fe, 20.60. The spectroscopic data for ferrocenylphosphonic acid matched that reported in the literature.28
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |