Xin Yu Ming Donga,
Yan Yan Lia,
Feng Weia,
Yu Zhoua,
Shi Lu Zhoub and
Jian Hua Zhu*a
aKey Laboratory of Mesoscopic Chemistry of MOE, College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing University, 22 Hankou Road, Nanjing 210093, China. E-mail: jhzhu@netra.nju.edu.cn; Fax: +86-25-83317761; Tel: +86-25-83595848
bChina Tobacco Shandong Industrial Co. Ltd., Tsinan 250000, China
First published on 15th December 2014
A novel menthol releaser is reported for the first time by utilizing the as-synthesized mesoporous silica MCM-41, MCM-48, and SBA-15, which not only saves the energy and time for the removal of the template, but also opens new applications for micelles. The micelles of CTAB (cetyltrimethylammonium bromide) in the as-synthesized MCM-41 had a flexibility dependent on temperature, that is, they were flexible at around 373 K so that menthol could enter the channel, but rigid at ambient temperature so the adsorbed menthol was sealed through physical interception, and they would release the spice at 333 K. The influence of temperature, nature and distribution of micelles on the adsorption and release of menthol was carefully assessed, and among three as-synthesized mesoporous vessels, the as-synthesized MCM-41 exhibited the highest capability in thermal release of menthol at 333 K after open stored in ambient for 30 days or longer. Furthermore, this new menthol releaser was preliminarily used in the filter of cigarette.
Menthol(5-methyl-2-isopropyl-cyclohexanol) is a natural compound that can provide the typical minty smell and flavour.11 Apart from pharmaceutical applications like anti-inflammatory, analgesic and anti-fungal, it is often used as the flavoring agent such as tobacco flavor, toothpaste, perfume, beverage and sweets. For instance, addition of menthol into cigarettes can produce the cool and refreshing taste, stimulating the central nervous system and making the respiration unobstructed.12 Practically, the addition of menthol in cigarette is often performed by spraying the menthol solution or putting the menthol-containing additive in tobacco, filters and packaging materials. However, menthol volatilizes easily so that its function is significantly reduced.13,14 To conquer this problem, the as-synthesized mesoporous silica is selected to adsorb and store as well as release menthol based on the variable flexibility of the micelles inside the channel. The gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) combined with headspace technique are employed to explore the influence of channel structure of mesoporous silica and the nature of micelles, temperature of menthol adsorption and storage conditions on the release of menthol. Besides, the vessels pre-adsorbed menthol will be used in the filter of cigarette to assess their actual function in storage and release menthol. It is expected to expand the value of template micelles in mesoporous silica through endowing them the new function of menthol-releaser.
To evaluate the release of menthol from these vessels, a given weight of the menthol-loaded vessel was put into an Agilent 5182-0837 Headspace vial (flat bottom, 20 mL), firstly balanced at a given temperature for a period of time, and then packed in the Agilent G1888 Network Headspace Sampler connected with gas-chromatograph for the second balance prior to sampling. The released menthol was forced into the sample loop and detected with the GC-MS equipped with a 60 m VOCOL capillary column and PerkinElmer Clarus 600T Mass Spectrometer. The detection conditions and parameters were listed in ESI.† In the experiment of cycled detection the vessel was taken out and put into another Headspace vial keeping at the temperature for balancing again once the first GC-MS analysis was finished, and the released menthol in the 2nd cycle was then sampled and detected again in the same procedures.
To assess the temperature controllable release of menthol, a give amount of as-M41 vessel pre-adsorbed at 373 K was put into the filter of cigarette and stored for a period prior to smoking. For these sample cigarettes, part of them was sucked for dozens of times without igniting, and then the vessel was taken out to test the release of residual menthol with the GC-MS method aforementioned. Part of them was smoked by the technicians to evaluate the taste of menthol released in smoke.
X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of samples were recorded on a D8 ADVANCE diffractometer (40 kV, 40 mA) using Cu-Kα radiation in the 2-theta range from 0.5° to 10°. Fourier Translation-Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR) spectra were recorded on a spectrophotometer of NICOLET iS10 with a resolution of 2 cm−1 using compressed KBr pellets containing 5 wt% of sample.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) Low-angle XRD patterns of as-synthesized mesoporous silica and (b) menthol adsorbed on as-M41 sample. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) GC spectrum and (b) MS spectrum of the menthol released from as-M41 vessel adsorbed at 373 K. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 The MS spectrum of the menthol released from as-M41 vessel adsorbed at 373 K was fitting with the standard spectrum of the menthol. |
Fig. 4a illustrates the influence of adsorption temperature on the release of menthol from 40 mg as-M41 vessel, in which all of the vessels pre-adsorbed menthol in the range of 353 K to 413 K and then were stored at ambient temperature for 30 days prior to the release at 333 K. According to the results shown in Fig. 4a, all vessels released the menthol indeed even after the long time open storage of 30 days. Among these composites the one adsorbed menthol at 373 K released the largest amount of the spice; rather, it was still the champion among these four composites in the 2nd cycle test (Fig. 4a). The temperature lower than 373 K seems not beneficial for the as-M41 to adsorb menthol since the vessel adsorbed at 353 K only released the spice equalling to 14% of that from the 373 K adsorbed vessel. Nonetheless, the elevated temperature was also unprofitable for the release of menthol on as-M41 because both the vessels adsorbed at 393 K and 413 K released less menthol than that at 373 K, although they could adsorb more the spice (about 16.6% and 20%, respectively) than that at 373 K (11%). Same trend was also observed on the 2nd cycle release at 333 K (Fig. 4a), verifying the effect of adsorption temperature on the menthol release from as-M41 vessel.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 The release of menthol at 333 K from (a) the as-M41 composites adsorbed menthol at different temperatures and (b) the as-M48 vessel adsorbed at 413 K in different cycles. |
Table 1 demonstrates the effect of 1st and 2nd balances temperatures on the release of menthol from as-M41 vessel. For these double balanced vessels, the higher the temperatures of balance, the more menthol to be released, and the sample to be 1st balanced at 293 K released about three times more menthol at 333 K than that from the sample to be 1st balanced at 278 K but released at 313 K. However, it was unclear which temperature of balance, 1st or 2nd, played the major role hence the vessel was tested without 1st balance (Table 1). As a consequence, the vessel released 100% more menthol at 333 K than that at 313 K. It is distinct that the high temperature impels the menthol stored to be released from the vessel more quickly.
1st balanced temperature (K) | 1st balanced time (min) | 2nd balanced temperature (K) | 2nd balanced time (min) | Released amount (a.u.) |
---|---|---|---|---|
278 | 60 | 313 | 1 | 53.4 |
293 | 60 | 333 | 1 | 204.8 |
313 | 1 | 313 | 60 | 298.5 |
333 | 1 | 333 | 60 | 677.2 |
With the same CTAB template micelles occluded in channel, the composite as-M48 could also efficiently adsorb and temperature-controllable release menthol, even though they were open stored for 45 days. Table 2 displays the release of menthol from the as-M48 adsorbed at different temperatures, and it is clear that the 1st balance at 333 K is more beneficial than at 293 K for menthol release excepted the vessels adsorbed at 353 K (Table 2) on which reverse situation was observed. Also, the higher adsorption temperature in the range of 353 K to 413 K was also beneficial for the menthol release in as-M48 composite. The vessel adsorbed menthol at 413 K could release 8 times more the spice than that adsorbed at 393 K when they were 1st balanced and released at 333 K. There are two differences between as-M41 and as-M48 vessels. The first, 373 K was the best temperature for as-M41 to release menthol while 413 K was the best one for as-M48. The second, as-M41 seemed to adsorb and release more menthol than as-M48 did. It is known that the micelle in the channel of these vessels will be little bit softer at relatively higher temperature hence the guest molecules can thus enter,4 however MCM-48 has the double helix Ia3d structure so that its surfactant micelles were arranged closer.20 As a consequence, it is not easy for menthol molecule to enter the occluded channel and diffuses inside due to its relatively large molecular size, resulting in an inferior menthol adsorption performance of as-M48. Nonetheless, without the template micelles inside channels to seal menthol, the common MCM-48 sample failed to hold the volatile spice during the open storage and thus no menthol was detected in the release at 333 K (Table 2). Similar situation was observed on the sample of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) tube without pore structure, which excludes the suspicions whether the mesoporous skeleton structure or the surface adhesion cause the storage of menthol. In contrast, a considerably amount of menthol was released from the as-M48 adsorbed at 413 K, even though in the 5th cycle (Fig. 4b). Of course, the amount of detectable menthol declined as the cycle time increased, say, about half in the 5th cycle, which was comprehensible. To explore the stability of menthol sealed inside the channel of as-synthesized mesoporous silica, the as-M48 vessel that adsorbed menthol at 373 K was divided to two parts. One part was open stored at ambient temperature for 45 days, and another was open stored for 30 day similarly but followed by the purge of nitrogen flow with 30 mL min−1 for 15 days. However, two vessels released the similar amount of menthol (0.10 and 0.12 a.u., respectively) at 333 K, which indicates the high stability of menthol sealed in as-M48 vessel during the storage at ambient temperature.
Sample | Adsorbed at (K) | 1st balanced at (K) | 1st balanced time (min) | 2nd balanced at (K) | 2nd balanced time (min) | Released amount (a.u.) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
as-M48 | 353 | 293 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.21 |
333 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.15 | ||
373 | 293 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.02 | |
333 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.10 | ||
393 | 293 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.01 | |
333 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.13 | ||
413 | 293 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.09 | |
333 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 1.18 | ||
MCM-48 | 373 | 293 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0 |
333 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0 | ||
as-S15 | 373 | 333 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0.50 |
Teflon | 373 | 293 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0 |
333 | 60 | 333 | 60 | 0 |
With different template in synthesis, as-S15 contained its micelles of P123 inside channels. However, these non-ionic surfactant micelles could still seal the adsorbed volatile spice and there was a considerably amount of menthol released from the as-S15 vessel that adsorbed menthol at 373 K and open stored for 45 days. Judged from these results, it is clear that the inherent temperature-controllable rigidity of template micelles, rather than their chemical composition, enables them to be novel releaser of menthol within the mesoporous channels.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Temperature-controlled adsorption and storage as well as release of menthol in the as-synthesized mesoporous silica vessels. |
The nature of micelles affects their function of storing menthol, since as-S15 vessel released much less menthol than as-M41 did (Tables 1 and 2) due to the nonionic template Pluronic P123 micelles. Such difference was reported in NO release4 in which as-S15 failed to store NO even at room temperature. Also, the channel structure of mesoporous silica impacts the storage of menthol, for instance the as-M41 composite could release hundred times more menthol than as-M48 did, although they contained the same CTAB micelles. The former had the one-dimensional channels in the hexagonal P6mm structures while the latter was the cubic Ia3d mesoporous material with three-dimensional pore systems. Although the structure of common MCM-48 has much more advantages in diffusion and mass transport in comparison with that of MCM-41,22 it is difficult for menthol to diffuse inside the sinuate channel occluded with micelles because of the micelles oriented with ever-changing directions in the helix structure. As a consequence, as-M48 vessel adsorbed and thus released less menthol. Nonetheless, the adsorbed menthol was tightly held to resist the purge of nitrogen flow. In contrast, the funnel-like channels of MCM-41 enabled the occluded CTAB micelles to be arranged orderly so that the menthol entered and diffused into the channel of as-M41 relatively easier. As the result, relatively large amount of menthol could be adsorbed and stored in the vessel of as-M41, ensuring this composite to thermal release menthol in cigarette smoke.
Apart from the potential economic benefit in application, the success of new menthol releaser derived from the micelles occluded mesoporous silica provides a new concept on the as-synthesized mesoporous composites. Strictly speaking, these composites are the core–shell composite where the micelles core supports the silica shell. Usually the attention is paid on the silica shell on which a lot of study is focused on introducing other metal species or converting the amorphous silica to zeolite,23 meanwhile the micelles core is removed or simply used as the tentatively supports. However, if we change our thinking, this composite is actually a special one where the inorganic shell forms the ordered and limited space and more importantly, the organic core also forms a magical delicate configuration, dividing further the limited space to numerous sub-nanometer gaps such as the superfine pores with the size less than 0.4 nm.5 That is, the common surfactant micelles actually form an unusual precise sub-nanometer structure within the special chemical environment and the limited space isolated by the silica shell. Such elaborate structure is expected to provide a perfect configuration for efficiently containing guest species to fabricate various novel hybrid functional materials, and menthol releaser is only one among them. This new menthol releaser may afford a candidate for tobacco industry to conquer the problem caused by the volatile of the spice. Furthermore, it gives a clue to elevate the value of template micelles oriented in mesoporous silica.
(1) The micelles in as-synthesized mesoporous materials such as MCM-41 exhibited a temperature on-off effect, namely, they showed an adjustable flexibility at different temperature and then switched the sub-nanometer space in the mesoporous channel, allowing and prohibiting guest molecules in and out to realize the temperature controllable storage and release.
(2) Menthol could be adsorbed in the vessel at 373 K and open stored in ambient for 30 days or longer, and finally released at 333 K.
(3) Among the sample of as-synthesized mesoporous silica, as-M41 exhibited a higher capability than as-M48 or as-S15 did in thermal release of menthol at 333 K.
(4) 373 K was the optimal temperature for the adsorption of menthol in the as-synthesized MCM-41, while 413 K was the best one for as-synthesized MCM-48.
(5) The as-M41 vessel adsorbed menthol at 373 K and open stored for 30 days could release the spice in filter when the cigarette was smoked.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: The instrument and condition used for the detection of menthol released from mesoporous silica vessels, FT-IR spectra of menthol–mesoporous silica composites and GC-MS spectrum of the released menthol from as-M48. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra13364a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |