Congmei Lin,
Jiahui Liu,
Feiyan Gong,
Guiyu Zeng,
Zhong Huang,
Liping Pan,
Jianhu Zhang and
Shijun Liu*
Institute of Chemical Materials, CAEP, Mianyang 621900, China. E-mail: lsj99@sohu.com; Fax: +86-816-2495856; Tel: +86-816-2489302
First published on 18th February 2015
In order to investigate the effects of multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) content and loading stress on the high-temperature creep properties of 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-trinitrobenzene (TATB)-based polymer bonded explosives (PBXs), three-point bending creep behavior was studied by dynamic mechanical analyzer at 60 °C. The experimental results showed that under low stress (4 MPa), the constant creep strain rates of the MWCNTs modified formulation reduced with MWCNT concentration. However, due to the agglomeration of MWCNTs, the existence of intertube sliding or stick-slip resulted in an increase in creep strain. Under higher stress (6 MPa and 7 MPa), with only 0.25 mass% of MWCNTs, the creep resistance of TATB-based PBX could be significantly improved with reduced constant creep strain rate. Additionally, compared with TATB-based PBX without MWCNTs, the creep lifetime of the nanocomposites with a content of 0.25 mass% MWCNTs had been considerably extended by over 33.3% and 750% under 6 MPa and 7 MPa, respectively. The nanocomposites with a content of 0.5 mass% MWCNTs displayed a lower creep resistance compared to that of the TATB-based PBX without MWCNTs. The creep resistance of the TATB-based PBXs depends significantly on loading stress. A six-element model could be used to simulate the high-temperature creep behaviors of the TATB-based PBXs with and without MWCNTs. The constitutive equations of the creep curves under different stresses at 60 °C were obtained. Among the fitting parameters, the elastic modulus of high elastic deformation E3 and the viscosity of Voigt units η3 were sensitive and promising for the evaluation of the creep strain of the TATB-based PBXs.
Due to the moderately energy output and excellent thermally stability, tri-amino-tri-nitro-benzene (TATB) has been comprehensively applied in military field as insensitive high explosive (IHE).23–27 TATB-based polymer bonded explosive (PBX) is a kind of particle highly-filled polymer composite. The structure and properties of TATB-based PBX, such as pore structure and size distribution,28,29 microstructural differences between virgin and recycled lots,30 mechanical behavior,31–33 shock initiation,34,35 thermal expansion,36,37 sensitivity,38 moisture outgassing,39 have been widely studied in the past years. However, there are only few literatures concerning creep performance of TATB-based PBX. Gagliardi et al.40 have carried out high fidelity measurements of time-dependent creep strain in the plastic-bonded explosives LX-17-1 and PBX-9502 and pointed out that the creep and recovery behavior of PBX was dependent on the type of explosive, the percentage and type of binder, the stress level and test temperature.
Less attention is paid to the effects of nanoparticles on the creep resistance of TATB-based PBX. In present study, the creep behaviors of TATB-based PBX prepared with water suspension methods, have been studied by three-point bending creep experiments. An attempt has been made to correlate the observed creep properties of TATB-based PBX with MWCNTs concentration and loading stress.
:
50) as solvent was added dropwise, and the system was heated to 70 °C in a vacuum. After removing the organic solvent, the precipitate was filtered, washed, and dried in a vacuum drying oven to give the molding powder of TATB-based PBXs. Afterwards, the molding powder product was pressed in a mould at 120 °C under 380 MPa and transformed into explosive sheet with a length of 30 mm, a breadth of 10 mm and a height of 1–2 mm. The pellet density is about 95% of the theoretical density after compression. Morphological characterization was carried out with a field emission scanning electron microscope (FESEM, CamScan Apollo 300, England). The samples were coated with a thin layer of gold in a vacuum chamber for conductivity. The accelerating voltage was 2.0 kV.
The schematic of the three-point bending creep experiment was presented in Fig. 1. The sample was coinstantaneously affected by tensile load and compressive load. The upper surface sufferred from compressive load and the lower surface sufferred from tensile load. At a certain center layer, i.e. neutral layer, no tensile stress or compressive stress was loaded on the sample. The bending normal stress presented a linear distribution perpendicular to the neutral layer. The bending normal stress reached maximum on the surface. The maximum bending normal stress σmax was calculated using the following equation:
![]() | (1) |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 SEM micrographs of MWCNTs modified composites with filler content of (a) 0.25 mass%; (b) 0.5 mass%. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Three-point bending creep strain curves of TATB-based PBXs at 60 °C under different maximum bending normal stresses. | ||
| Sample | Maximum bending normal stress/MPa | Constant creep strain rate/% min−1 | Creep failure strain/% | Creep failure time/min |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PBX-1 | 4 | 7.51 × 10−5 | >0.03526 | >90 |
| 6 | 2.65 × 10−4 | 0.06931 | 67.5 | |
| 7 | 4.38 × 10−3 | 0.06052 | 5.0 | |
| PBX-2 | 4 | 6.43 × 10−5 | >0.04002 | >90 |
| 6 | 1.21 × 10−4 | >0.06887 | >90 | |
| 7 | 5.89 × 10−4 | 0.07889 | 42.5 | |
| PBX-3 | 4 | 4.96 × 10−5 | >0.05872 | >90 |
| 6 | 5.33 × 10−4 | 0.05332 | 35.5 | |
| 7 | — | 0.02854 | 0.4 |
As can be seen in Fig. 3 and Table 1, in the experimental set time, no creep rupture is found in the three-point bending creep process of TATB-based PBXs at 60 °C/4 MPa. Due to the low loading stress, the sample displays a long-term creep process and no creep rupture time could be obtained. Only decelerated creep stage and steady creep stage could be observed from the creep strain curves. The relationship of the creep time on the creep strain in the steady creep stage of PBX-1 at 60 °C/4 MPa is plotted in Fig. 4. It is obvious that the creep strain varies linearly with the creep time in the steady creep stage. The constant creep strain rate is the coefficient of creep strain to creep time which are acquired from the slope of the fitting lines in Fig. 4. At 60 °C/4 MPa, the constant creep strain rate of PBX-1 is 7.51 × 10−5% min−1. The constant creep strain rates of TATB-based PBXs are listed in Table 1. As revealed shown in Table 1, at 60 °C/4 MPa, the constant creep strain rates of the MWCNTs modified formulations PBX-2 and PBX-3 are lower than that of the PBX-1. This result could be also explained by the fact that the motion of chain segment of fluoropolymer is restricted by the presence of MWCNTs. However, an increase of the three-point bending creep strain of MWCNTs modified formulations is observed with increasing MWCNTs content. In fact, due to the fact that MWCNTs are not ideally dispersed in polymer matrix, poor load transfer between nanotubes (in some bundles or entanglements) and between nanotubes and surrounding polymer chains may give rise to interfacial slippage and an increase in the creep strain under low stress.41,42
| Test condition | Sample | E1/MPa | E2/MPa | τ2/s | η2/MPa s | E3/MPa | τ3/s | η3/MPa s | η4/MPa s | R2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 60 °C/4 MPa | PBX-1 | 8.130 × 105 | 3.198 × 104 | 616.17 | 1.971 × 107 | 2.445 × 104 | 21.62 | 5.286 × 105 | 3.493 × 108 | 0.99865 |
| PBX-2 | 5.291 × 106 | 2.863 × 104 | 603.53 | 1.728 × 107 | 1.902 × 104 | 21.48 | 4.085 × 105 | 4.106 × 108 | 0.99869 | |
| PBX-3 | 5.721 × 107 | 4.134 × 104 | 623.76 | 2.579 × 107 | 8.856 × 103 | 12.25 | 1.085 × 105 | 5.373 × 108 | 0.99931 | |
| 60 °C/6 MPa | PBX-2 | 8.464 × 106 | 3.022 × 104 | 603.96 | 1.825 × 107 | 1.521 × 104 | 17.90 | 2.723 × 105 | 3.270 × 108 | 0.99894 |
Under higher stress (6 MPa and 7 MPa) at 60 °C, as represented in Fig. 3b and c, compared with PBX-1 without MWCNTs, with only 0.25 mass% of the reinforcing agent MWCNTs, the creep resistance of PBX-2 is improved with reduced constant creep strain rate and prolonged creep rupture time. For example, at 60 °C/7 MPa, with regard to PBX-1 without MWCNTs, the creep strain increases rapidly with creep time, afterwards, creep failure of the sample is occurred at 5.0 min with a constant creep strain rate of 4.38 × 10−3% min−1. The creep rupture time of nanocomposite PBX-2 is considerably extended by 750% compared with that of PBX-1, and the constant creep strain rate distinctly reduces by 86.6%. As a kind of particle highly-filled composite, when the particle phase is rigid, although the polymer content is low, the creep of polymer matrix still is the main source of the creep of composite. Consequently, the creep behavior of TATB-based PBXs depends on the creep properties of polymer binder. Three possible mechanisms of load transfer that could contribute to the observed enhancement of creep resistance are proposed by Yang et al.,9 which are (i) fairly good interfacial strength between MWCNTs and polymer matrix, (ii) increasing immobility of amorphous region due to the appearance of nanotubes acting as blocking sites, and (iii) high aspect ratio of MWCNTs. For MWCNTs/fluoropolymer nanocomposites, the large deformation of fluoropolymer transfers the external load to MWCNTs through the good interfacial bonding. Under the external load, the crack initiates and propagates in the fluoropolymer matrix far from MWCNTs due to the low bulk strength. When propagated to MWCNTs with skin-core structure, the crack branches and deflects, inducing an increase of crack propagation resistance. Furthermore, MWCNTs are randomly distributed in the fluoropolymer matrix and lapped with each other. On account of the high aspect ratio of MWCNTs, skeleton structure is formed to block the motion of surrounding molecular chain. Accordingly, a prominent increase of the creep resistance of MWCNTs/fluoropolymer nanocomposites is achieved, resulting in the enhancement of the creep resistance of TATB-based PBXs.
In addition, it should be noted that with 0.5 mass% of MWCNTs, the creep resistance of PBX-3 reduces with increased constant creep strain rate and shortened creep rupture time, compared with PBX-1 without MWCNTs. For example, at 60 °C/6 MPa, the creep failure of PBX-1 without MWCNTs is occurred at 67.5 min, while the creep failure time of PBX-3 is shortened to 35.5 min. Shen et al.16 and Beake et al.17 have studied the nanoindentation behavior of nylon 66/clay nanocomposites and poly(ethylene oxide)/clay nanocomposites, respectively, and also revealed that the addition of small amount of clay had an adverse effect on the creep behavior of the nanocomposites, in accordance with the results of PBX-3 with 0.5 mass% of MWCNTs. Generally, as a result of the addition of nanoparticles, such as clay and carbon nanotubes into the polymer matrix, two adverse effects are functioning simultaneously on the nanocomposites:16 (i) significant enhancement effect from the well-dispersed, stiff, high aspect ratio nanoparticles, usually and particularly having remarkable influence on hardness and modulus of the material, as observed in PBX-2 with 0.25 mass% of MWCNTs; (ii) substantial changes of micro and/or nano-structures of the matrix due to confinement or other effects, for instance, the changes of crystalline morphology for semicrystalline thermoplastics owing to heterogeneous nucleation of nanoparticles, which usually lower or destroy the crystal perfection or crystallinity of the polymer matrix, as observed in PBX-3 with 0.5 mass% of MWCNTs. Two competing or combined effects coexist in the TATB-based PBXs. For PBX-3, MWCNTs trends to agglomerate in the polymer matrix. On the other hand, MWCNTs act as heterogeneous nucleating agent in fluoropolymer and thus possibly reduce the crystal size or the degree of crystallinity. The morphological change plays a dominant role in the creep behavior, giving rise to the poor creep resistance of PBX-3.
Creep is a typical viscoelastic phenomenon of PBX, which is intimately correlated to loading stress. As depicted in Fig. 3 and Table 1, the creep resistance depends significantly on the maximum bending normal stress σmax. It is clear that with σmax increased from 4 MPa to 7 MPa at 60 °C, the creep rupture time of PBX-1 minishes from more than 90 min to 5 min, the creep strain and constant creep strain rate enlarges, suggesting that the creep resistance decreases obviously. The creep resistance of PBX-2 and PBX-3 presents a similar trend with loading stress. The results indicate that the dimensional stability and long-term load capacity reduces with increasing loading stress. The result is attributed to an enhancement in molecular thermodynamic movement. According to free volume theory,43 the viscosity which reflects time-dependence of material is correlated with free volume fraction. An increase in intermolecular free volume fraction is caused by the increase of stress, resulting in a decrease of material viscosity and the aggravation of molecular thermodynamic movement. Consequently, the creep resistance of TATB-based PBXs reduced with increasing stress.
The six-element mechanical model can be regarded as a series connection structure of a Maxwell model and two Voigt models. During the creep process, σ = σ0, consequently, the total strain of polymer composite material PBX could be determined by:
![]() | (2) |
Eqn (2) divides by σ0:
![]() | (3) |
During the creep process, the loading stress is regarded as a constant value, and therefore, the creep process can be also characterized with the creep compliance D. The creep compliance can be calculated as:
![]() | (4) |
Eqn (3) is transferred to creep compliance equation:
![]() | (5) |
Eqn (5) is the constitutive equation of creep compliance curve.
As an example, Fig. 6 gives the model prediction of the experimental data with the method of non-linear fitting for PBX-1 at 60 °C/4 MPa using Origin data analysis software. As can be seen in Fig. 6, the experimental data can well fit into the six-element mechanical model. The non-linear fitting parameters of six-element model, including the elastic modulus E1, E2, E3, the relaxation time τ2, τ3, the viscosity of Voigt units η2, η3, and the bulk viscosity η4 of TATB-based PBXs are listed in Table 2. Square values of fitting correlation coefficient R2 are all above 0.99865, suggesting that the six-element mechanical model can effectively describe the three-point bending creep behaviors of TATB-based PBXs with high precision.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Three-point bending creep compliance curve and non-linear fitting curve of PBX-1 at 60 °C/4 MPa. | ||
As can be seen from the fitting parameters in Table 2, the bulk viscosity η4, which reflects that the irrecoverable creep strain is much higher than the viscosity of Voigt units η2 and η3. The bulk viscosity η4 manifests a distinct depend on MWCNTs content. η4 increases with increasing MWCNTs concentration, indicating that lower flow is occurred and the permanent deformation reduces. The fact is resulted from the capability of MWCNTs to restrict the relative slide of molecular chain. η4 is also sensitive to the loading stress. η4 decreases as the loading stress increases. As mentioned above, the results could be attributed to an increase in intermolecular free volume fraction and an aggravation of molecular thermodynamic movement with increasing loading stress. Among the fitting parameters, E3 decreases with MWCNTs concentration under 4 MPa. The results are in good accordance with the change trend of creep strain. The higher value of E3 implies a smaller creep strain. It is also observed that E3 decreases with the loading stress, indicating a poor creep resistance. η3 also displays a similar decrease trend with MWCNTs concentration and loading stress. In view of the results, it seems reasonable to believe that E3 and η3 could be promising for the evaluation of the creep strain of TATB-based PBXs.
1. The creep behavior of MWCNTs modified TATB-based PBXs presented a different relationship with the MWCNTs content under low stress and high stress. It was found that under low stress (4 MPa), compared with TATB-based PBX without MWCNTs, the constant creep strain rates of the MWCNTs modified formulations reduced, while creep strain increased. Under higher stress (6 MPa and 7 MPa), with regard to the MWCNTs modified formulation with only 0.25 mass% of MWCNTs, the creep resistance could be significantly improved with reduced constant creep strain rate and prolonged creep lifetime. However, the nanocomposites with content of 0.5 mass% MWCNTs displayed a lower creep resistance compared to that of TATB-based PBX without MWCNTs.
2. Owing to an increase in intermolecular free volume fraction and an aggravation of molecular thermodynamic movement, TATB-based PBXs with or without MWCNTs displayed a very pronounced decrease in the creep resistance with increasing loading stress.
3. Six-element model was utilized to simulate the relaxation process of creep process of TATB-based PBXs. The experimental results indicated that the bulk viscosity η4 manifests a distinct depend on the content of MWCNTs, due to the capability of MWCNTs to diminish the relative slip of polymer chains. Elastic modulus of high elastic deformation E3 and the viscosity of Voigt units η3 were sensitive and promising for the evaluation of the creep strain of TATB-based PBXs.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |