Yimeng
Wang
,
Adam
Giebink
and
Dana M.
Spence
*
Department of Chemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA. E-mail: dspence@chemistry.msu.edu
First published on 14th November 2013
The most recent American Association of Blood Banks survey found that 40
000 units of blood are required daily for general medicine, hematology/oncology, surgery, and for accident and trauma victims. While blood transfusions are an extremely important component of critical healthcare, complications associated with transfusion of blood components still exist. It is well-established that the red blood cell (RBC) undergoes many physical and chemical changes during storage. Increased oxidative stress, formation of advanced glycation endproducts, and microparticle formation are all known to occur during RBC storage. Furthermore, it is also known that patients who receive a transfusion have reduced levels of available nitric oxide (NO), a major determinant in blood flow. However, the origin of this reduced NO bioavailability is not completely understood. Here, we show that a simple modification to the glucose concentration in the solutions used to process whole blood for subsequent RBC storage results in a remarkable change in the ability of these cells to stimulate NO. In a controlled in vitro microflow system, we discovered that storage of RBCs in normoglycemic versions of standard storage solutions resulted in RBC-derived ATP release values 4 weeks into storage that were significantly greater than day 1 release values for those RBCs stored in conventional solutions. During the same storage duration, microfluidic technologies enabled measurements of endothelium-derived NO that were stimulated by the ATP release from the stored RBCs. In comparison to currently accepted processing solutions, the NO production increased by more than 25% in the presence of the RBCs stored in the normoglycemic storage solutions. Control experiments using inhibitors of ATP release from the RBCs, or ATP binding to the endothelium, strongly suggest that the increased NO production by the endothelium is directly related to the ability of the stored RBCs to release ATP. We anticipate these findings to represent a starting point in controlling glucose levels in solutions used for blood component storage, especially considering that current solutions contain glucose at levels that are nearly 20-fold greater than blood glucose levels of a healthy human, and even 10-fold greater than levels found in diabetic bloodstreams.
Insight, innovation, integrationThe work presented here provides biological insight by demonstrating that modification to the solutions used to process (collect and store) red blood cells (RBCs) for storage prior to transfusion leads to an improvement in these cells’ ability to release ATP and, subsequently, stimulate nitric oxide production in endothelial cells. Efficacy was confirmed with the technological innovation of using a microfluidic device and other microflow techniques to measure ATP release from the stored cells in a flow-based environment. This integration was necessary to prove that insufficient nitric oxide bioavailability (INOBA) after transfusion may be due to reduced cell-to cell-communication between RBCs and the endothelium and this reduction in communication is due to the hyperglycemic conditions of current storage protocols. |
In the United States alone, it is estimated by the American Association of Blood Banks that 40
000 units of blood are required daily for general medicine, hematology/oncology, surgery, and for accident and trauma victims. While the most recent National Blood Collection and Utilization Survey (NBCUS) suggests that a “shortage” of stored units of red blood cells (RBCs) was not necessarily an issue in the US during the period covered by the survey, the complications associated with receiving a transfusion remain one of the critical barriers to progress in the field.2 Thus, while blood transfusions are an extremely important component of critical healthcare, complications associated with transfusion of blood components still exist.3,4
Recently, it has been reported that people who receive a transfusion suffer from insufficient nitric oxide bioavailability (INOBA), which has a profound effect on blood flow.5 The concept of INOBA associated with the transfusion of stored RBCs is of particular interest to our group and others due to a wealth of literature describing the RBC as a determinant of blood flow.6–8 Specifically, the RBC has been shown to release nitric oxide (NO) through different mechanisms when exposed to hypoxia.9,10 In addition, the RBC is also capable of releasing adenosine-5′-triphosphate (ATP) when exposed to hypoxia,11,12 flow-induced deformation,13,14 and various molecular stimuli.15,16 Importantly, this RBC-derived ATP has been shown to stimulate NO production in various cell types such as the vascular endothelium,17 as well as platelets.18
However, the origin of the INOBA is not completely understood, and when stored RBCs are transfused, it is not clear if the INOBA is due to a reduction in RBC-derived NO, or RBC-stimulated NO. Differentiating these two sources using an in vivo model would be very difficult and complex, if not impossible. Unfortunately, even if an in vitro tool or device that mimics in vivo cellular properties and cell-to-cell communication could be developed, the origins of the RBC properties that may be leading to the INOBA would still not be completely understood.
Investigators in the field of transfusion medicine are well aware of various properties that may affect the stored RBC. Interestingly, many of these stored RBC properties (e.g., oxidative stress19 and advanced glycation endproducts (AGEs)20), collectively known as the red cell storage lesion,21 also occur in the RBCs obtained from people with diabetes.22 It would be premature to assume that the RBC storage lesion and diabetic complications have the same origin; however, an examination of the processing solutions used to prepare RBCs for storage reveals a very interesting environment into which collection and storage occur.
Consider 450 mL of whole blood collected from a donor;23 the number of RBCs in that collection volume can be estimated by assuming that ∼40% of the collected blood is comprised of RBCs and, at a volume of ∼87 fL per RBC, one could estimate that the number of RBCs is approximately 2 × 1012 in the whole blood collection. These RBCs are collected in ∼70 mL of citrate phosphate dextrose (CPD) solution, which contains about 1.6 g of glucose (or 9.0 × 10−3 moles); in other words, these RBCs are being exposed to a solution (the CPD) that has a glucose concentration of ∼129 mM prior to collection of the whole blood. Even after the collection of the ∼450 mL of whole blood, the glucose levels are still >20 mM. After collection into the CPD, the RBCs are separated and added to 100 mL of an additive solution (AS-1) that contains glucose at a concentration of ∼111 mM. After the addition of the RBCs, the final glucose concentration is ∼40 mM. To give this value some perspective, keep in mind that a normoglycemic, healthy individual has a bloodstream glucose level between 4 and 6 mM.24 In short, the glucose concentrations in the collection and storage solutions (nearly an order of magnitude higher than a healthy individual) may adversely affect the stored RBC.
Here, using a microfluidic device, we demonstrate that the solutions used for collection of whole blood, and for storage of purified RBCs, are having a significant impact on flow-induced ATP release from stored RBCs, which in turn is affecting endothelium-derived NO production. Importantly, we also provide evidence that collection and storage in normoglycemic versions of CPD and AS-1 (labeled as CPD-N and AS-1N, respectively), followed by periodic feeding of the stored cells to maintain glucose concentrations near normoglycemic levels, results in ATP release values 4 weeks into storage that are statistically higher than day 1 values for cells processed in typical CPD–AS-1 solutions. We also demonstrate that this RBC-derived ATP is having a significant impact on endothelium-derived NO.
Although the ATP release from the CPD-N–AS-1N cells on day 8 was statistically higher (p < 0.05) than the day 1 release from cells processed in CPD–AS-1, the results in Fig. 1b also show that the ATP release from the RBCs processed in CPD-N–AS-1N was also decreasing rapidly. Results from additional experiments evaluating lactate levels in the supernatant of the storage solutions, which were performed on the same day as the ATP release studies, suggested that the lactate levels in the supernatant of RBCs stored in CPD-N–AS-1N stopped accumulating around day 8 (see Fig. 1c). The decrease in lactate accumulation was verified by a quantitative determination of glucose concentration in the AS-1N supernatant, which was found to be exhausted by day 8 (data not shown). Collectively, the results shown in Fig. 1 suggest that while a normoglycemic collection and storage protocol may be beneficial for maintenance of ATP release from stored RBCs, it is not necessarily conducive for storage periods beyond 1 week.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 RBC-derived ATP is shown in (a) for cells processed using the CPD–AS-1 solutions (black bars) or the CPD-N–AS-1N solutions with glucose supplementation occurring weekly beginning at Day 5 of storage (gray bars). Not unlike the data shown in Fig. 1, the cells stored in AS-1N consistently release higher levels of ATP than their AS-1-stored counterparts. However, the weekly maintenance of glucose levels in the storage bags helped maintain increased release of ATP from the RBCs throughout the 29 day storage duration (*p < 0.05). In fact, the release from the AS-1N stored cells on Day 36 is statistically equivalent (p = 0.694) to those cells stored in AS-1 on Day 1. The weekly glucose supplementation resulted in lactate accumulation (b) during the entire storage period, while glucose measurements (not shown) verified that glucose concentrations in the AS-1N were maintained between 5–6 mM. Data represent mean ± s.e.m. (n = 4 for all). | ||
Two negative control experiments were performed to ensure that this NO release was stimulated by flowing RBC-derived ATP release. First, RBCs in CPD–AS-1 and CPD-N–AS-1N were incubated with glibenclamide (GLI), an inhibitor of ATP release from RBCs.27 The data in Fig. 3d show that inhibition of the RBCs stored in the AS-1N with GLI decreases the NO production to a level that is statistically equal (p = 0.742) to those cells stored in AS-1. This strongly suggests that the increased endothelium-derived NO is not due to stimulation by ATP due to RBC lysis; if ATP due to lysis was the stimulus for the enhanced NO production, GLI inhibition would have no effect on the results.
In addition to inhibition at the RBC level, a second control was performed at the endothelial level. Specifically, endothelial cells cultured on the microfluidic device were incubated with pyridoxalphosphate-6-azophenyl-2′,4′-disulfonic acid (PPADS), which is a recognized inhibitor of the P2Y purinergic receptor for ATP.28 As shown in Fig. 3e, NO production in the presence of CPD-N–AS-1N processed RBCs, which had been significantly higher than when exposed to RBCs processed in CPD–AS-1, were unable to stimulate such increases when the endothelium was inhibited with PPADS. The data in Fig. 3e provide further evidence that the increase in NO production from the endothelial cells is directly a result of ATP stimulation. The combined data in Fig. 3 suggests that endothelium-derived levels of NO are strongly related to the ability of the stored RBC to release ATP.
To be effective, the transfused RBC must be intact, have sufficient survival rates in vivo, and circulate.38 These three properties translate to a required reduction in RBC lysis, the ability of the transfused RBCs to avoid removal due to cell apoptotic or cell senescence mechanisms, and the ability of the transfused RBCs to traverse blood vessels. In combination, satisfying these three properties helps ensure that the RBC will be able to conduct its primary physiological objective of delivering heme-bound oxygen to demanding organs and tissues.
In addition to oxygen delivery, the RBC has also been reported to be a major determinant in the maintenance of vascular caliber.6,7 Multiple mechanisms that describe how the RBC fulfills its role in the control of blood flow have been proposed, although these mechanisms generally fall into one of two categories. One describes the RBC's ability to donate NO directly.6 Importantly, these mechanisms have been shown to play a role in stored RBCs and, in fact, recent work has shown that the ability to reload stored RBCs with components that could replenish NO levels have a beneficial impact on tissue oxygenation in transfused animal models.39
A second category portrays the RBC's ability to stimulate NO production in other cell types by its ability to release ATP (a known stimulus of endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS)).7,40 Similar to mechanisms involving direct release of NO from the RBC, RBC-derived ATP has been shown to be altered during storage. McMahon et al. reported that RBCs stored for longer than one week were incapable of releasing ATP in response to hypoxia, a well-recognized stimulus of ATP release from RBCs.41 This same work also demonstrated that the reduction in ATP release was correlated with an increase in RBC adherence to endothelial cells. It was also concluded that methods to enhance ATP release from the RBCs during storage would be beneficial to patients receiving a transfusion.
Importantly, a reduction in ATP release from RBCs exposed to various stimuli is not limited solely to stored RBCs. Reduced ATP release from RBCs purified from the whole blood of people with primary pulmonary hypertension30 and cystic fibrosis42 has been reported. Furthermore, our group and others have reported that ATP release from the RBCs of people with type 2 diabetes is also significantly lower in comparison to healthy, non-diabetic controls.18,43 These reports involving ATP release from the RBCs of diabetic individuals are potentially important when one considers a hallmark feature of diabetes, namely, the hyperglycemic conditions of the bloodstream, and the glucose levels in the solutions used during the processing of whole blood for RBC storage. The bloodstream glucose concentration of a person with diabetes is typically between 7 and 9 mM, or higher if poorly controlled. As mentioned previously, the concentration of glucose in the current solutions used to collect and store whole blood and RBCs, respectively, are both well above 100 mM, but it is not to be assumed that diabetes and the RBC storage lesion have the same root cause. However, a common feature of both diabetes and the RBC storage lesion is the hyperglycemic conditions to which the RBCs are exposed. Interestingly, the ATP release data for those cells processed in the CPD–AS-1 solutions overlap with those obtained in separate studies by our group and others when studying release from the RBCs of people with type 2 diabetes.18
The data in Fig. 1b provides evidence that the ability of the RBC to release ATP in response to mechanical deformation is compromised when processed using the standard CPD–AS-1 collection and storage solutions. When a separate aliquot of these RBCs were analyzed in normoglycemic versions of these solutions (CPD-N–AS-1N), the ATP release was significantly increased. In fact, our results show that the ATP release on day 16 in the CPD-N–AS-1N system was statistically equal (p = 0.735) to that of the CPD–AS-1 system on day 1. Such results are important considering that complications associated with transfusions generally increase when using RBCs that have been stored for more than 2 weeks.
Unfortunately, storing the RBCs in a normoglycemic solution (AS-1N) resulted in the complete exhaustion of glucose in the storage bag, as indicated by both lactate accumulation measurements (Fig. 1c) and direct determination of glucose. Therefore, a rudimentary feeding protocol was developed that allowed for normoglycemic levels of glucose to be maintained in miniaturized storage bags without affecting overall sample volume. When this protocol was implemented, the ATP release remained steady throughout storage; in fact, the data in Fig. 2b show that the level of ATP release on day 36 is statistically higher than the release on day 1 using standard CPD–AS-1 collection and storage solutions.
The ATP release from RBCs processed in normoglycemic solutions shown in Fig. 1 and 2 are increased in comparison to those processed with current protocols (CPD–AS-1). However, these data alone do not provide requisite evidence that INOBA in transfusion medicine is simply a result of decreased ATP release from RBCs due to high glucose levels in the solutions used to process whole blood. Therefore, a microfluidic device was employed to determine the origin of NO measured above an endothelium that was exposed to the RBCs processed in the different collection and storage solutions. The results from the microfluidic device experiments, shown in Fig. 3, suggest that the NO measured above the endothelium is a result of eNOS stimulation from RBC-derived ATP binding to the endothelium. These data are enhanced by the use of GLI (an inhibitor of ATP release) and PPADS (a puringergic receptor inhibitor that blocks the ATP binding site). NO levels were not statistically increased when these antagonists were employed. Both of these antagonists would affect endothelium-derived NO, but not necessarily RBC-derived NO; thus, the data presented here provides evidence that the NO being measured in Fig. 3c is not RBC-derived, but rather, RBC-stimulated by ATP. Not to be overlooked in this discussion of NO origin is the fact that the normoglycemic collection and storage solutions are keys to enabling the release of ATP from the stored RBCs.
The underlying biochemical reasoning for increased ATP release from the RBCs stored in normoglycemic solutions does not appear to be due to intracellular levels of ATP during storage. The data in Fig. 4 show that intracellular levels of ATP are actually slightly increased in those RBCs stored in the higher glucose-containing AS-1 solutions. This is not completely surprising as Sprague et al. have shown that people with primary pulmonary hypertension (PPH) release less ATP in response to stimulation, even though their RBCs contained levels of intracellular ATP statistically equal to those of non-PPH controls.30 Thus, even when cells have normal levels of intracellular ATP, it does not translate to normal release in response to various stimuli. Interestingly, Sprague et al. have shown that increased glycation of cellular molecules affects key components required for ATP release from the RBC.43,44 Therefore, it may be possible that the high glucose concentrations in CPD and AS-1 may be reducing ATP release by adversely affecting key molecular components in the ATP release pathway. In addition to the work by Sprague et al. showing decreased ATP release from RBCs with increased glycation, others have also shown increased advanced glycation endproducts (AGEs) in stored RBCs.45
The modified collection and storage solutions seem to have a beneficial effect on ATP release and subsequent NO production, which could be advantageous in vivo. However, another key component to successful blood transfusion is that the RBCs remain intact. In fact, regardless of how much NO is being stimulated or produced by the RBC, if RBC lysis is present, the bioavailability of NO will more than likely drop due to NO scavenging by free hemoglobin. While no measurements involving cell survival were performed in this study, the percentage of RBCs that underwent hemolysis did not significantly increase when stored in the normoglycemic versions of the collection and storage solutions, followed by maintenance of glucose levels. When these cells were not maintained with physiological levels of glucose by periodic feeding, the lysis did increase, as to be expected as glucose and ATP are both key components in maintaining proper cellular membrane structure and functionality. It is noteworthy that the hemolysis rates for the RBCs stored during this study would most likely improve, i.e., a reduction in the hemolysis rate, if the collected whole blood had been leukocyte reduced by buffy coat removal and filtration. It has been shown that mean hemolysis rates are significantly lowered when stored products are leukoreduced by filtration.46 This method was avoided here due to the small volume of samples that were collected from donors. However, future studies involving standard collection volumes would most certainly benefit from leukoreduction by filtration methods. Not only has leukoreduction been shown to affect hemolysis rates, but also lipid composition and microvesicles.47,48
All blood collection procedures from informed and consented donors were approved by the Biomedical and Health Institutional Review Board at Michigan State University. The collection process consisted of preparing 6 non-siliconized and untreated (i.e., no heparin or other anticoagulant) 10 mL glass Vacutainer tubes (BD, Franklin Lakes NJ); 3 of these tubes contained 1 mL of CPD, while the other 3 contained 1 mL of CPD-N. Next, approximately 7 mL of whole blood were collected into each tube, resulting in a total volume of 8 mL. The blood remained in the collection solutions for at least 30 min, but not more than 2 h at room temperature (∼20 °C), prior to processing. Whole blood processing consisted of centrifugation at 2000g for 10 min followed by removal of the plasma and buffy coat layers by aspiration. Importantly, an additional top 2 mm layer of the packed RBCs were also removed to minimize leukocyte presence during subsequent storage in the AS-1 or AS-1N solutions. The purified RBCs from the 3 tubes containing CPD were then combined into a single 15 mL tube, followed by the addition of AS-1 such that the ratio of packed RBC
:
AS-1 volume was 2
:
1. The same protocol was followed for RBCs collected in CPD-N and stored in AS-1N. Finally, 2 mL of the RBCs (stored in the AS-1 or AS-1N) were added to PVC bags and stored at 4 °C. Prior to use, PVC bags were sterilized under UV light overnight. The PVC bags were prepared in-house using rolled PVC and a heat sealer. The PVC did not contain any di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP), a common plasticizer used in clinical storage bags. All solutions used in collection and storage were autoclaved at 10 bar and 121 °C prior to use. All blood collection and storage processes were performed under sterile conditions.
The RBCs stored in the normoglycemic AS-1N solutions required periodic feeding. These cells were “fed” by opening the PVC storage bag and adding a 10 μL droplet of 200 mM glucose in saline to the RBCs and then re-sealing the bag. This helped to maintain the glucose concentrations in the stored cells at around 5 mM, while not changing the volume into which the cells were stored.
000g for 15 min. The resulting supernatant was then diluted 1/10 in Drabkin's solution. Similarly, Hbt samples were prepared by diluting RBC samples 1/1000 in Drabkin's solution so that the final cyanmethemoglobin (HbCN) concentration fell within the range of the calibration curve (0–0.8 g L−1 HbCN). After mixing, samples and standards were incubated at room temperature in the dark for 30 min. Absorbance was read at 550 nm in a commercial plate reader (Spectramax M4, Molecular Devices). The Hb concentration was then calculated from the linear equation of the calibration curve. The sample hematocrit was determined manually by collecting RBCs in microcapillary tubes, spinning in a microhematocrit centrifuge (CritSpin M960-22, Statspin) and visually quantifying the percentage of packed red cells using a microcapillary reader. Hemolysis was then calculated according to the formula:| % Hemolysis = (Supernatant Hb (g L−1) × [100 − hematocrit (%)])/Total Hb (g L−1) |
The measurement of flow-induced ATP release has been described previously.50 Briefly, to measure the ATP release, a 500 μL syringe (Hamilton, Fisher Scientific) was filled with the luciferin–luciferase mixture described above. A second syringe was filled with either ATP standards (during calibration) or a 7% RBC solution (for measuring ATP release from the cells). Both solutions were pumped through 30 cm sections of microbore tubing with an internal diameter of 50 μm (Polymicro Technologies, Phoenix, AZ) at a rate of 6.7 μL min−1 using a dual syringe pump (Harvard Apparatus, Boston, MA). The streams containing the luciferin–luciferase mixture and ATP standard or 7% RBCs combined at a mixing T-junction. The combined stream flowed through a segment (∼5 cm) of microbore tubing (i.d., 75 μm) that had its polyimide coating removed, allowing for the detection of resultant chemiluminescence emission from the reaction using a photomultiplier tube (PMT, Hamamatsu Corporation, Hamamatsu, Japan) placed in a light excluding box. The ATP release from RBCs was measured immediately after placement in the storage solutions (AS-1 or AS-1N) and weekly through day 36 of storage. In order to account for any ATP already present in the sample prior to flow, an aliquot of the cells were centrifuged and supernatant analyzed for ATP. This value was subtracted from that obtained during the flow experiments to obtain a true value of the ATP that was released from the cells, as opposed to any ATP that was already present in the extracellular matrix.
Microfluidic devices were prepared for cell culture by coating the polycarbonate membrane in each well in with 10 μL of a 50 μg mL−1 fibronectin solution, and subsequent air-blow drying and exposure to UV light for sterilization. Meanwhile, endothelial cells (from bovine pulmonary arterioles) were cultured in T-25 culture flasks with Dulbecco's modified eagle medium (DMEM) containing 5.5 mM glucose, 10% (v/v) fetal bovine serum, and penicillin/streptomyocin. Cells were subcultured when 80% confluent in the flasks. Cells were detached from the flask, harvested in a test tube by centrifuging at 1500g for 5 min and then resuspended in 600 μL of culture media; 10 μL of this solution were then added into each well. After 1 h, media was changed, and every hour thereafter. The device was prepared ∼12 h before experimentation.
To evaluate NO production in the endothelium, endothelial cells in each well of the device were rinsed with Hank's balanced salt solution (HBSS, to remove culture media) followed by the addition of 10 μL of a 5 μM DAF-FM (Molecular Probes, Carlsbad, CA) solution prepared in HBSS. Next, a solution of 7% RBCs was pumped through the channels of the microfludic device for 30 min at 1 μL min−1 and 37 °C. The ATP released from the flowing RBCs is able to diffuse through the pores of the membrane (the RBCs are too large to diffuse through these pores and continue to flow to a waste reservoir on the device), stimulating NO production through purinergic receptor signaling on the endothelial cells. NO that is produced interacts with the probe and an increase in fluorescence intensity is measured using an excitation wavelength of 488 nm and emission wavelength of 515 nm.
To ensure that NO production is from RBC-derived ATP stimulated endothelial cells, two control experiments were performed. First, the activity of cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) which plays an important role in ATP release mechanism of RBC can be inhibited by GLI. Specifically, 0.0247 g of GLI were weighed and dissolved into 10 mL of 0.05 M NaOH in a hot water bath (∼50 °C) to generate a 5 mM solution. 20 μL of this solution were added into 1 mL of 7% RBC sample to create a final concentration of 100 μM. Then, samples were incubated for 30 min at room temperature. Secondly, PPADS which is a non-selective P2 purinergic antagonist, was used to block the response of ATP stimulation from endothelial cells. Briefly, 50 μL of 100 mM PPADS stock solution (in DMSO) were diluted with 450 μL of HBSS to create a final solution of 10 mM just prior to use. After removing cell culture media and rinsing with HBSS, 10 μL of this PPADS solution were added into wells and the entire device was incubated at 37 °C for 30 min. Next, wells were rinsed several times (usually 3–4 times) with HBSS to remove excess PPADS solution, which has a dark orange color, before the addition of DAF-FM probe. Both of these two controls were performed as described above. Samples without these treatments were always run with the controls for comparison.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |