Open Access Article
Jian
Jiang‡
a,
Jianhui
Zhu‡
a,
Wei
Ai
a,
Zhanxi
Fan
b,
Xiaonan
Shen
a,
Chenji
Zou
a,
Jinping
Liu
d,
Hua
Zhang
b and
Ting
Yu
*ac
aDivision of Physics and Applied Physics, School of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University, 637371, Singapore. E-mail: YuTing@ntu.edu.sg; Fax: +65 6795 7981; Tel: +65 6316 2962
bSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, 639798, Singapore
cGraphene Research Centre, National University of Singapore, 117546, Singapore
dInstitute of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology, Department of Physics, Central China Normal University, Wuhan, 430079, Hubei, P. R. China
First published on 29th April 2014
Future development of mini consumer electronics or large electric vehicles/power grids requires Li-ion batteries (LIBs) with not only an outstanding energy-storage performance but also a minimum cost, and the foremost sustainability. Herein, we put forward a smart strategy to convert used disposable bamboo chopsticks into uniform carbon fibers for anodes of LIBs. Bamboo chopsticks waste is recycled and simply treated by a controllable hydrothermal process performed in alkaline solutions, wherein abundant natural cellulose fibers in bamboo in situ get separated and dispersed spontaneously. After carbonization, the evolved carbon fibers exhibit superior anodic performance to the bulky bamboo carbons counterpart, and competitive electrochemical behavior and cost with commercial graphite. The performance of carbon fibers can be further upgraded by growing nanostructured metal oxides (like MnO2) firmly on each fiber scaffold to form a synergetic core–shell electrode architecture. A high reversible capacity of ∼710 mA h g−1 is maintained without decay up to 300 cycles. Our strategy presents a scalable route to transform chopsticks waste into carbon fibers, offering a very promising way to make sustainable anodes for LIBs and economical multi-functional carbon-based hybrids available for other practical applications.
Broader contextLi-ion batteries (LIBs) nowadays play a dominant role on the progress of HEVs/EVs industry. However, despite the ceaseless development of electrode materials selection/manufacturing, current LIBs still show little promise in competing with the traditional gasoline in terms of price, energy, convenience and safety. Besides, the excepted huge exploitation on graphite driven by future demands will eventually one day lead to the depletion of natural graphitic resources. In a long-term perspective, LIBs therefore require to not only possess outstanding energy-storage capability but also be lower-cost and foremost sustainable. We herein propose a smart strategy to convert the used bamboo chopsticks into uniform carbon fibers for a sustainable anode of LIBs. Abundant natural fibers in chopsticks waste are readily separated and dispersed after a simple hydrothermal treatment. The derived carbon fibers exhibit superior anodic performance as compared to the bulky counterparts, and competitive electrochemical behavior and cost with commercial graphite. Moreover, their performance can be further upgraded by integrating nanostructured metal oxides onto each fiber. Our success in the evolution of carbon fibers from chopsticks waste may provide a cost-effective and sustainable platform for developing advanced carbon-based materials for practical use, not merely in LIBs but also in a wide spectrum of fields. |
The use of chopsticks brings about the mysterious verve of East Asia's catering culture but inevitably results in negative environmental impact and enormous waste of precious forest resources. Only in Japan, humans stupendously consume around a total of ∼24 billion pairs of disposable chopsticks per year (adding up to millions of cubic meters of timber or fully grown bamboo trees).6 This giant consumption gives rise to a great many issues, in which the overriding concern is how to appropriately deal with the vast of discarded chopsticks garbage. Current handling approaches are still the conventional ones realized by either direct combustion of these wastes or sanitary landfills for biodegradation. Even though treatments in such ways are rather simple and convenient, they are virtually “low-level” and not rational, causing extra air/dust pollution and, more importantly, making little use of these valuable and economic natural resources. How humans process the large amount of disposable chopsticks waste into commercially available products through general, high-efficiency and cost-effective approaches is quite desirable but still needs serious reconsidering.
We herein put forward a scalable and smart strategy to convert disposable bamboo chopsticks waste into uniform carbon fibers for LIBs application. The recycled bamboo chopsticks only undergo a simple and controllable hydrothermal (delignification) treatment conducted in alkaline solutions, in which plenty of cellulose fibers in bamboo are in situ separated and dispersed spontaneously. Both the reaction time and alkali concentration are verified as significant parameters to adjust the overall fiber-separation process. Extracted natural fibers are further evolved into graphitic carbon fibers after a carbonization treatment. When tested as anode for LIBs, the chopsticks-derived carbon fibers can exhibit competitive anodic performance with practical graphitic materials, and much better electrochemical behavior than unseparated bamboo carbon in terms of specific energy and rate capability. We also find the anodic performance of carbon fibers can be markedly upgraded by integrating nanostructured metal oxides (e.g., MnO2) onto each carbon fiber. Thanks to the three-dimensional (3D) functionalized core–shell constructions, the hybrid products of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers have been demonstrated as excellent anode materials for LIBs, with good cyclic performance (maintaining ∼710 mA h g−1 without decay up to 300 cycles) and outstanding rate capability. To our knowledge, their comprehensive anodic performance is among the best reported to date for the hybrid systems of MnO2@carbon matrix. Our success in the evolution of carbon fibers from chopsticks waste may not only open up the possibility of manufacturing sustainable high-performance anode materials for LIBs, but also set up an economical platform for preparing advanced hierarchical carbon-based hybrid materials that might be available in a large spectrum of practical applications.
:
10
:
10 and dispersed/homogenized in N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP) to form slurries. The homogenous slurry was then pasted onto a Cu foil (thickness: 10–15 μm) and dried at 100 °C for 10 h under vacuum. The mass loading of fiber products on each current collector was controlled to be 2.5–4.0 mg cm−2. Electrochemical measurements were all performed using CR-2032 coin-type cells within a potential range of 0.005–3 V. The cells were assembled in an Ar-filled glove box (MBraun, Unilab; H2O < 0.1 ppm, O2 < 0.1 ppm) using Li foil as the counter and reference electrode. 1 M LiPF6 dissolved in a 1
:
1 (v/v) mixture of ethylene carbonate (EC) and diethyl carbonate (DEC) was used as the electrolyte. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and cyclic voltammetry measurements were performed on an electrochemical workstation (CHI 760D, CH Instruments Inc., Shanghai) and galvanostatic charge–discharge tests were conducted using a specific battery tester (NEWARE, Shenzhen). Prior to battery testing, all cells were aged for 8 h.
O, C–F, C–Cl, etc.) are quite useful since they may contribute part of the capacities via lithiation/delithiation or pseudocapacitive reactions. The N2 adsorption–desorption isotherm with a hysteresis loop (inset in Fig. 2I) shows a typical “type I” characteristics (according to IUPAC recommendations) which is usually displayed by microporous solids especially for instances of carbon materials.15 The specific surface area for evolved carbon fibers is measured around ∼808.25 m2 g−1. Also, we have calculated the micropore size of fiber specimens based on the density functional theory (DFT) (Fig. 2I). The carbon fibers contain ∼47% microporosity below 2 nm, with small mesopores centered among a range of 2–10 nm. The existence of such surface defects and hydrophilic function groups as above is very helpful for the nucleation formation of other functionalized active materials on the carbon surface.16 This potentially enables the immobilization of high-capacity materials with robust mechanical adhesion to carbon fibers scaffold, eventually forming advanced core–shell synergetic hybrid electrode systems for LIBs. Moreover, we have measured the electrical performance of a single carbon fiber (Fig. S5†). Its electrical resistivity is evaluated around ∼10−1 Ω cm (very close to that of metals), which is quite favorable for LIBs performance especially for high-rate lithiation/delithiation.
Seeking to control the entire preparation of bamboo fibers, we thereby carry out systematic studies on the relationships between KOH concentration (CKOH) and other significant parameters like the hydrothermal reaction time and the weight losses of the chopsticks. Fig. 3A and B successively display their reaction time (t) and percentage loss in weight (wt%) as a function of CKOH at a constant hydrothermal temperature of 150°. When CKOH is as much as 1 M, t of 15 ± 2 h needs to be spent for the complete extraction of bamboo fibers. This treatment gives rise to a wt% up to ∼31.3%. Upon the increase of CKOH from 1 to 6 M, t has to be 9 ± 1.5 h (for 2 M), 6 ± 0.5 h (for 3 M), 5 ± 0.3 h (for 4 M), 4.75 ± 0.25 h (for 5 M) and 4.5 ± 0.2 h (for 6 M), corresponding to the wt% of ∼28.3%, ∼22.7%, ∼23.3%, ∼26.7%, ∼33%, respectively. As reflected by the experimental data and their fitting analysis, the fiber-extraction procedure is proven to be highly associated with t and CKOH parameters. Using a high molar-ratio alkali solution enables to shorten t by acceleration of the delignification process but in turn inevitably causes dissolution of the partial cellulose fibers (∼21% solubility percentage in concentrated alkaline) as well as the high wt%.17 Though prolonging the hydrothermal time indeed eliminates the use of concentrated KOH solution, the corresponding wt% is not the lowest since a long hydrothermal period would also result in a partial weight loss of the biomass. Considering the manufacturing cost and production efficiency of bamboo fibers, we eventually choose 3 M KOH as the hydrothermal solution, along with a moderate t (6 h) and the lowest wt% (∼22.7%). Moreover, we also pay close attention to other influence factors, like reaction conditions, as compared and summarized in Table 1. Underneath the 5 h soaking treatment in either alkaline/acid solutions or neutral water, we fail to attain any cellulose fibers; there are actually no changes on bamboo chopsticks after the soaking process except for the ones soaking in alkaline aqueous solutions (with a slight weight loss of ∼3–6% caused by dissolution of the biomass in bamboo). As for events under hydrothermal conditions, high-quality bamboo fibers (3–6 μm) are harvested merely in 3 M alkalis, instead of in 3 M acids or neutral water (see optical/SEM observations in Fig. S6†). Even though rough fibers with a mean diameter of ∼30 μm (marked by arrows in Fig. S6D†) are also yielded after a hydrothermal process conducted in acids, the as-formed products are substantially carbonized and become rather rigid/fragile, being simultaneously accompanied by remarkable morphological changes (e.g., structural collapse in some regions) and huge weight losses up to ∼63%. The resultant carbonization may be induced by complicated intermolecular dehydration, hydrolysis and condensation/polymerization of the organics (like oligosaccharides, hemicelluloses or other molecules in bamboo biomass) in neutral/acid atmosphere when the hydrothermal temperature is held at 150 °C.18
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Relationships between the KOH concentration (CKOH) and other significant parameters of (A) hydrothermal reaction time (t) and (B) weight loss (wt%) of the chopsticks shavings. | ||
| Treatment | Bamboo fibers extraction (yes/no) | Experimental results |
|---|---|---|
| Soaking in pure H2O at room temperature (RT) for 5 h | No | No changes |
| Hydrothermal treatment (150°) in pure H2O for 5 h | No | Bamboo carbonization (slight); both bamboo and solution turn brown |
| Soaking in 3 M acids (e.g., HCl, H2SO4, etc.) at RT for 5 h | No | No changes |
| Hydrothermal treatment (150°) in 3 M acids (e.g., HCl, H2SO4, etc.) for 5 h | Yes but rough & poor | Heavy carbonization (both bamboo and solution turn black); huge weight loss; fibers (diameter > 50 μm) are rigid and fragile |
| Soaking in 3 M alkalis (e.g., NaOH, KOH, etc.) at RT for 5 h | No | Slight weight loss (∼3–6%) of bamboo; the soaking solution turns yellow |
| Hydrothermal treatment (150°) in 3 M alkalis (e.g., NaOH, KOH, etc.) for 5 h | Yes | Soft bamboo microfibers (3–6 μm in diameter) are well extracted and uniformly dispersed in solution after a slight ultrasonic process |
Galvanostatic charge–discharge tests have been conducted at ∼0.37 C (1 C = 372 mA g−1) for 800 cycles (Fig. 4B) to estimate the long-term cyclic behavior of carbon fibers. For comparison, unseparated bulky bamboo carbons (see SEM observations in Fig. S7C and D†) with an average size of ∼100 μm are also tested. The electrode of carbon fibers exhibits initial discharge and charge capacities of ∼500 mA h g−1 and ∼283 mA h g−1, respectively. By contrast, the bulk bamboo carbons show a bit higher initial discharge capacity (up to ∼535 mA h g−1) but a much lower reversible charge capacity of ∼208 mA h g−1. This implies that carbon fibers possess better reversibility than their bulky counterpart, with an upper initial Coulombic efficiency of ∼56.6%. This value is definitely higher than that of bamboo carbons (∼38.8%), and even comparable to that of transitional metal oxides.20 For carbon fibers, the evident decrease in the irreversible capacity loss during the 1st cycle may be due to the individual fibrous geometric features; in the kinetics, Li+ may not tend to be trapped because carbon fibers, the active host materials have been perfectly isolated and dispersed for the ease of Li+ intercalation/deintercalation. Both electrodes show a trivial capacity reduction among the prime 30 cycles and later a capacity rise in subsequent steps. The specific capacity of carbon fibers rises from the bottom capacity of ∼256 mA h g−1 to ∼355 mA h g−1 with a growing rate of ∼0.25 mA h g−1 per cycle and then stabilizes at ∼360 mA h g−1, which is more than the practical capacity of commercial graphite (∼300–330 mA h g−1) and the capacity values of other carbon materials.2c,3c,5a,21a Note that similar activation results have been reported on carbon-/silicon-based materials.21 We believe that this capacity-rise phenomenon may result from two aspects as follows. Within prime tens of cycles, the capacity of carbon fibers begins to recover from the minimum value. The origin of this activation is mainly attributed to the delayed infiltration of an electrolyte into the carbon fibers.21c Around 100 cycles later, the repeated Li insertion/deinsertion process would gradually disrupt carbon fibers preferably at the structural defects. Fibers breaking may lead to more open-up places and accordingly provide more active sites available for Li storage. Besides, Li ions can go through such open-up regions and further diffuse a few nanometers deep into carbon fibers, which may lead to a continual capacity rise until the entire carbon fiber has been fully utilized. Despite bulky bamboo carbons also having excellent cycling stability and undergoing a similar capacity-increasing process, the delivered capacity is maintained at a level of ∼250 mA h g−1 (∼110 mA h g−1 less than that of carbon fibers and far below the practical standard), and the ramped rate is only ∼0.15 mA h g−1 per cycle. Galvanostatic charge–discharge tests at programmed C rates are further carried out to examine their rate capability (Fig. 4C). The electrode of carbon fibers is primarily subjected to continuous cycling under varied current densities, successively at 0.46 C (171 mA g−1), 0.92 C (342 mA g−1), 1.39 C (517 mA g−1), 2.77 C (1030 mA g−1), 5.54 C (2060 mA g−1) and 12.34 C (4590 mA g−1) followed by charge–discharge cycles with currents switching back to 0.46 C. The corresponding records on the relationship between the reversible capacity and the current density have been summarized in Fig. 4D. The capacity of a carbon fiber electrode can fully recover or even surpass its former values upon continuously switching the current rates, capable of delivering a maximum capacity up to 353 mA h g−1 (at 0.46 C), 319 mA h g−1 (at 0.92 C), 292 mA h g−1 (at 1.39 C), 254 mA h g−1 (at 2.77 C) and 211 mA h g−1 (at 5.54 C), respectively. All these values are higher than those of bamboo carbons. Note that when the current suddenly jumps to 12.34 C (4590 mA g−1; cells charged–discharged in less than 1 min), the electrode of carbon fibers still retains a capacity of ∼137 mA h g−1, which is definitely beyond the value of bamboo carbons (∼59 mA h g−1) and other hard carbon materials;2c more strikingly, this value is even a bit higher than that of highly conductive carbon nanotubes (CNTs) measured at 10 C (3720 mA g−1).3c The above results highlight both the excellent rate capability and capacity retention of derived carbon fibers, showing a great promise to function as an alternative anodic substitute for graphite in LIBs. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) recorded in the frequency range of 1 × 106 to 0.01 Hz under open-circuit conditions is shown in the inset of Fig. 4C. The data fitted from the semicircle in high frequency range reveal the electrode of carbon fibers has a low charge-transfer resistance (Rct) of ∼24 Ω (substantially lower than that of bulky bamboo carbons (∼61 Ω)), evidencing the individual carbon fibers possess better electrolyte infiltration and charge-transport capability than the bulk. In the low frequency range, a comparison toward the fitting line slope illustrates carbon fibers electrode exhibits less Warburg impedance (Zw), which represents a significant parameter associated with the diffusion of Li+ ions along the inter-space of graphitic carbons.22 The above impedance spectra suggest the electrode of carbon fibers undergoes a fast Faradaic process and has a lower activation energy for Li+ diffusion into graphitic lattices. Even after deep cycling, the Rct of carbon fibers does not change a lot (Fig. S8†). Apart from the electrochemical testing/analysis, we also compare the cost of anodic materials made from chopsticks-derived carbon fibers with the commercially used graphite (see Table S1†). The unit prices given out are all referenced in the recent literature5a and the global trade website http://Alibaba.com. Assuming each coin-type cell contains ∼100 mg active anode materials, the use of carbon fibers would bring about around $30–41 for manufacturing 10
000 cells in lab. The total amount is lower than that of graphite ($39–54), implying the cost advantage of evolved carbon fibers for LIBs industry.
Though carbon fibers are proven superior to bulky bamboo carbons and competent in sustainability, the battery performance and cost (raw materials are renewable and all recycled from wastes) with graphite (a type of limited fossil/mineral resource), their energy density is yet problematic to meet the ever-growing demand for modern energy-storage applications. Aimed to upgrade their energy density, we have tried various strategies to optimize carbon fibers, either by growth of functionalized metal oxides on each fiber scaffold or doping active elements (like B, N, F and P etc.) on/into the fibrous carbon host.23-25 One model example is the promotion of the anodic performance by constructing carbon-coated MnO2 nanowires (NWs) on the carbon fibers, forming a smart sandwich-like hybrid (denoted as C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers). The choice of MnO2 as an incorporated electrode material is mainly given by factors like manufacturing complexity, environment friendliness, cost and natural abundance. Another notable reason is that unlike other transition metal oxides with conversion reactions occurring above ∼1 V,14a,18c,24 MnO2 has a low lithiation plateau of ∼0.5 V vs. Li/Li+ (approaching the value of carbon species). This is definitely below the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of liquid organic electrolyte but still keeps higher than the Li-reduction potential, enabling generation of stable protective passivation layers on the anode surface to ensure cyclic durability and simultaneously avoiding a yield of detrimental Li dendrites for safety.4 An XRD measurement has clearly identified the formation of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers hybrid after a series of post-treatments (see Fig. S9A†). Fig. 5A–C show representative SEM images of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers hybrid products. The samples geometrically inherit the fibrous features and possess intriguing hierarchical structures consisting of a carbon fiber inner core and MnO2 NWs outer shells. According to the above XRD record and the HRTEM observation (Fig. S9B†), the produced oxide is identified as α-type MnO2 within a space group of I4/m. In addition to being immobilized as a robust shell (shell thickness: 3–5 μm) on each carbon fiber surface, a uniform carbon layer with few-nanometer thickness is intimately coated on MnO2 NWs, as confirmed a by high-resolution TEM observation (Fig. S9C,† see arrows) and Raman spectrum (inset in Fig. 5B; Raman peaks at 505, 572 and 630 cm−1 corresponds to distinct Mn–O stretching modes of MnO2 while the ones located at 1342 and 1576 cm−1 are fingerprints for the thin carbon layer). As a consequence, nanostructured MnO2 with a high theoretical capacity of ∼1230 mA h g−1 has been perfectly encapsulated into a carbon matrix (by referring to the thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) in Fig. S10B,† the mass ratio of MnO2 in C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers is determined to be ∼45.7%). Such designed electrode architecture is quite favorable for LIBs application, alleviating the problems led by self-aggregation and intrinsically low electronic conductivity of MnO2, as well as the lithiation-induced stresses. As a proof-of-concept demonstration of such hybrid products in LIBs, we have evaluated the hybrid of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers (CV and charge–discharge curves are successively present in Fig. S10C and D†). Also, we compare the cyclic behavior of MnO2/carbon fibers (without carbon coating) and pristine carbon fibers. Fig. 5D displays their cyclic performance at 0.2 A g−1 in a potential range of 0.005–3 V. C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers hybrid electrode delivers initial discharge–charge capacities of 1105 mA h g−1 and 706 mA h g−1, respectively. The capacity loss can be attributed to: (i) irreversible intercalation of Li+ into carbon fibers, (ii) irreversible conversion of MnO2 with Li+, and (iii) the formation of SEI film on electrode surfaces. The reversibe discharge capacity after 300 cycles is still kept at ∼710 mA h g−1 (nearly two times that of pristine carbon fibers and far higher than that of MnO2/carbon fibers electrode), showing 93.8% retention of the 2nd discharge capacity. Fig. 5E shows the programmed cyclic responses of the hybrid products at varied current densities. Along with the increase of current rates from 0.2 to 6 A g−1, the electrode of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers still exhibits stabilized cyclic behavior, with maximum discharge capacities of 706, 578, 532, 478, 398 and 241 mA h g−1 at 0.2, 0.4, 0.8, 1.6, 3.2 and 6.4 A g−1, respectively. Even when the current abruptly jumps back to 0.2 A g−1, the electrode is even able to deliver a higher reversible capacity of ∼715 mA h g−1. These results exclusively confirm the enhanced energy-storage and rate capabilities of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers hybrids over the pristine carbon fibers and the single-phased MnO2 anode.26 The high capacity retention and outstanding rate behavior are mainly ascribed to the synergy effects between MnO2 and the carbon matrix. On one hand, nanostructured MnO2 with a large surface to volume ratio ensures the delivery of a high specific capacity for the hybrid electrode of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers. On the other hand, the inner carbon fibers backbone functions as the robust scaffold and electric cables for electrons transfer, whereas the uniform carbon layers on the outer surface of MnO2 NWs are responsible for positive mechanical protections.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: SEM images of intermediate products during the fiber-extraction process; TEM image of a single carbon fiber; optical and SEM images of samples treated in different atmospheres; XRD pattern and TEM image of C/MnO2 NWs/carbon fibers. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ee00602j |
| ‡ Jiang Jian and Zhu Jianhui contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |