Joana F. B.
Barata
,
Ana L.
Daniel-da-Silva
,
M. Graça P. M. S.
Neves
,
José A. S.
Cavaleiro
and
Tito
Trindade
*
Chemistry Department, CICECO and QOPNA, University of Aveiro, 3810-193, Aveiro, Portugal. E-mail: tito@ua.pt; Fax: +351 234 370 084; Tel: +351 234 370 726
First published on 24th October 2012
The present study describes the first example of hybrid particles composed of amorphous silica and corrole. The hybrid particles were obtained by covalent linking of the gallium(III)(pyridine) complex of 5,10,15-tris(pentafluorophenyl)corrole (GaPFC) at the surface of functionalized silica spheres. The functionalization step was achieved by a nucleophilic substitution reaction between corrole and 3-aminopropyltriethoxysilane previously grafted at the silica surfaces. The hybrids were morphologically and chemically characterized and the results have confirmed covalent linkages between corrole molecules and the silica particles. Preliminary studies on the capacity of corrole and hybrid particles to generate singlet oxygen was evaluated by a chemical method in which 1,3-diphenylisobenzofuran was used to trap singlet oxygen. The new corrole-silica hybrid particles have shown lower efficiency to generate singlet oxygen as compared to the pure corrole precursor. This effect was interpreted as a consequence of interparticle interactions mediated by the corrole molecules grafted at the silica surfaces that result in their clustering. Taken together, these findings demonstrate that despite lower efficiency in terms of singlet oxygen generation, the hybrid materials offer an alternative route to develop new platforms with potential for photodynamic therapy.
The association of PDT drugs to silica surfaces is very promising, namely because silica has been used to coat inorganic nanoparticles and the surfaces can be further functionalized by diverse chemical strategies, thus allowing the development of multifunctional nanomedicines.6,7 For example, Foscan® encapsulated on silica, has been tested in PDT procedures.7 Also, porphyrins and phthalocyanines have already been coupled to a variety of nanoparticles.8 Porphyrin derivatives have been widely investigated as drugs for cancer treatment essentially due to the high singlet oxygen generation yield and the selectivity to cancer cells.9 However most porphyrins and related compounds are hydrophobic and have therefore a limited solubility in water.
Corroles form a class of aromatic tetrapyrrolic macrocycles bearing a direct pyrrole–pyrrole linkage. These macrocycles are highly promising molecules in many applications, including the biomedical field.10 Owing to their unique photochemical properties, corroles are good candidates for PDT applications yet this is an area of medicinal research that has not been explored. In particular, and to the best of our knowledge, there are no reports on the use of corroles that could prompt new advances in PDT photosensitizers based on corrole chemistry. Here we report the first example of a hybrid system in which amorphous silica particles and corrole molecules have been chemically combined.
In order to minimize side reactions, a Ga(III) complex of pentafluorophenylcorrole was selected as a stable corrole derivative in the preparation of the hybrid particles. At this stage, we have favored this aspect in detriment of possible limitations that the use of the Ga(III) corrole complex might have in terms of single oxygen generation as compared to free corrole. Nevertheless, standard assays for singlet oxygen generation of the prepared hybrid Ga(III) corrole complex-silica nanoparticles have been carried out in order to compare their performance for PDT in relation to the use of pure metallocorrole samples.
During the irradiation period, the solutions/suspensions were stirred at room temperature. The percentage of the DPiBF absorption decay, that it is proportional to the production of singlet oxygen, was monitored by measuring the difference between the initial absorbance at 415 nm and the absorbance after a given time of irradiation. The DPiBF absorption decays were measured at irradiation intervals of 1 min up to 15 min.
Scheme 1 Synthetic route to silica-corrole nanoparticles. |
The grafting reaction was carried out in DMSO at 100 °C. After 24 h, thin layer chromatography (TLC) of the reacting mixture showed that most of the starting GaPFC was converted into a new green-colored material that remained in the baseline. The resulting solids were filtered and washed with adequate solvents in order to remove the residual unbound corrole.
Fig. 1 shows the ATR-FTIR spectra of corrole and of the SiO2 particles at the distinct surface modification stages. The spectrum of the corrole GaPFC shows the typical vibrational bands expected for this type of macrocycle with the characteristic stretching modes from the pyrrole (νC–H, νC–C, and νC–N) assigned to the absorption bands over the range of 700–1500 cm−1,17 and the bands between 2800 and 3000 cm−1 assigned to aromatic C–H stretching. Although less intense, these diagnosis bands appear in the spectra of the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 hybrid particles, with slight shifts, at 752, 963 and 2930 cm−1 thus confirming the presence of the corrole in the SiO2 particles. As expected, the spectra of the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 particles is dominated by the typical bands of amorphous SiO2 at 1035 cm−1 (νas(SiO–Si)), 947 cm−1 (ν(Si–OH)) and 790, 560 and 430 cm−1 (δ(Si–O–Si)).15 The ATR-FTIR spectra of the materials were recorded after washing thoroughly, which in principle removed GaPFC not chemically bound to the silica surface. Moreover, the band corresponding to the CH2 rocking from the Si–CH2R moieties at the silica surface is noticeable at 690 cm−1, which seems to support the presence of covalent linkages between the corrole and the silicon alkoxide linker grafted at the silica surface.18These results were further supported by XPS as will be discussed below.
Fig. 1 ATR-FTIR spectra: (a) GaPFC, (b) SiO2, (c) SiO2-APS and (d) GaPFC-APS-SiO2 NPs. |
In order to confirm that the corrole macrocycle is covalently linked to the APS functionalized SiO2 particles, a mixture of non-functionalized silica and the complex GaPFC was submitted to heat treatment using the same experimental conditions described for the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 particles synthesis – DMSO at 100 °C. The resulting powder collected after washing was colorless as observed for non-functionalized silica samples. Conversely, the powders resulting from the reaction of GaPFC with the amine functionalized NPs showed a green color, as described above. Accordingly, the UV-VIS spectrum of the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 sample (Fig. 2) shows the GaPFC characteristic Soret band at 450 nm, which is red shifted in relation to that of the pure complex (434 nm). The explanation for this band shift will be apparent later, but for the moment these experiments provided additional evidence for the covalent attachment of GaPFC at the SiO2 surfaces via APS linkers. The broadening of the Q band in the spectrum of the SiO2-grafted-corrole can be related to aggregation effects of the functionalized particles, due to their low solubility in ethanol.
Fig. 2 Absorption spectra of GaPFC (....) and GaPFC-APS-silica (——) in ethanol. |
In order to have a better description of the chemical composition of the hybrid, XPS analysis was performed for samples GaPFC-APS-SiO2, SiO2-APS and GaPFC. The binding energies of C 1s, N 1s, F 1s and Ga 2p3/2 are summarized in Table 1.
Sample | C 1s (eV) | N 1s (eV) | F 1s (eV) | Ga 2p3/2 (eV) |
---|---|---|---|---|
GaPFC | 285.0 C–C | 398.3 (iminic type) | 688.5 C–F | 1118.1 |
286.2 C–H | ||||
288.3 C–N aromatic | 400.5 (aminic type) | 690.7 C–F | ||
290.3 C–F | ||||
APS-SiO2 | 280.4 Si–C | 399.7 N–H | — | — |
281.8 C–C | ||||
285.2 C–N | ||||
GaPFC-APS-SiO2 | 284.9 | 398.1 | 687.4 | 1117.5 |
285.2 | 399.1 | 689.0 | ||
286.1 | 399.6 | 690.4 | ||
286.9 | 401.1 |
The high resolution C 1s signal for SiO2-APS (Fig. 3a) was fitted into three components at 280.4 (SiCH2C), 281.8 (CCH2C) and 285.2 (CH2NH2) eV (Table 1), attributed to the three different carbon atoms in the APS molecule.
Fig. 3 Characteristic C 1s core line signal of (a) APS-SiO2, (b) GaPFC and (c) GaPFC-APS-SiO2. |
For GaPFC (Fig. 3b) the C 1s peak shows four components centered at 285.0, 286.2, 288.3 and 290.3 eV due to the different sorts of C linkages: C–C, C–H, C–N and C–F. The signal at 290.3 eV corresponds to the C–F linkage of the pentafluorophenyl rings.19 Considering the high resolution C 1s of GaPFC-APS-SiO2 (Fig. 3c) the C linkages of APS and GAPFC contribute to the C 1s signal. Note that the C 1s peak corresponding to the C–N covalent bond between the corrole macrocycle and the silica nanoparticle is observed at 286.9 eV.20 In fact, all the C 1s peaks of GaPFC-APS-SiO2 have been shifted towards lower energy in relation to free GaPFC, which confirms that a new chemical environment has been established. These observations are consistent with electron-donating effects via the APS-SiO2 component.21,22
Concerning the high resolution of N 1s (Fig. SI3†), the signal was fitted into one component at 399.7 eV for SiO2-APS (free amine group from APS), two components centered at 400.5 eV (pyrrolic aminic type) and 398.3 eV (pyrrolic iminic type) for GaPFC.23,24
The high resolution N 1s signal of GaPFC-APS-SiO2 (Fig. SI 3c†) was fitted into four components centered at 398.1, 399.1, 399.6 and 401.1 eV. These components are due to the four different types of N for the respective chemical linkages present, i.e. the free amino group from APS, the aminic and iminic nitrogens of the corrole core and the new covalent linkage formed between corrole and the silica particles (–C–N–C).25
Fig. 4a and b shows the high resolution of F 1s signal for GaPFC and GaPFC-APS-SiO2, respectively. For GaPFC (Fig. 4a) the F 1s peak was fitted to two components centered at 688.5 and 690.7 eV.26 This assignment takes into account that the 10 pentafluorophenyl ring is distinct from the 5 and 15 rings based on symmetry arguments. The 5 and 15 pentafluorophenyl rings are equivalent in relation to the symmetry plane perpendicular to the corrole macrocycle and that contains the remaining 10 pentafluorophenyl ring, which is distinct.11 The shape of the F 1s signal peak (Fig. 4b) for the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 is similar to GaPFC, however with a more intense shoulder at 690.4 eV probably due to chemical modification on the periphery of the pentafluorophenyl rings, with the new formed linkages to the APS-SiO2 particles. Note that Scheme 1 shows an oversimplified view of the derivatized amorphous SiO2 particles because it does not show surface sites with distinct environments. Concerning the high resolution of Ga 2p3/2 for the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 its binding energy and shape is similar to the ones of corrole complex GaPFC (Table 1, Fig. SI4†).
Fig. 4 Characteristic F 1s core line signal of (a) GaPFC and (b) GaPFC-APS-SiO2. |
Also, the fluorescence emission spectra of GaPFC and GaPFC-APS-SiO2 particles show maxima at 605 nm and 660 nm, thus indicating that the corrole units in the silica act as emitting centers (Fig. 5).29
Fig. 5 Fluorescence emission spectra of GaPFC (- - - -) and of GaPFC-APS-SiO2 particles (——) in DMF. Excitation wavelength at 417 nm, OD 0.08. |
To evaluate the potential of GaPFC-APS-SiO2 hybrids as photosensitizers for PDT, its capacity to generate singlet oxygen was estimated using 1,3-diphenylisobenzofuran (DPiBF) as a 1O2 indicator. This is a standard indirect test in which yellow DPiBF is oxidized with 1O2via a Diels–Alder cycloaddition reaction to colorless o-dibenzoylbenzene. There were no attempts here to detail the photophysics of these systems, but instead to provide a preliminary assessment of the effect of the silica nanoparticles on the corrole capacity to generate 1O2. As such, the DPiBF absorption band at 415 nm was monitored to follow the ability of the PS to generate 1O2.23Fig. 6 summarizes data for the absorption decay observed at 415 nm for the analysed samples. It is clear from these results that GaPFC-APS-SiO2 hybrids are able to generate 1O2 that depends on the concentration employed but are also less efficient as compared to non-immobilized GaPFC complex.
Fig. 6 Reduction of DPiBF absorbance in the presence of GaPFC and of GaPFC-APS-SiO2 NPs at different concentrations after 15 min of irradiation with white light filtered through a cut-off filter for wavelengths <540 nm (25 W m−2). Concentrations indicated for the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 refer to the equivalent concentration of non-immobilized GaPFC. |
In a first attempt to explain the lower efficiency of the hybrids for 1O2 generation as compared to pure GaPFC, the role of the SiO2 particles was investigated by a control experiment in which a blend of the components was used.30 Thus GaPFC was mixed either with non-functionalized (SiO2) or functionalized (APS-SiO2) silica particles and the respective DPiBF absorption decays have been evaluated (Fig. SI6†). The results obtained in both cases after 15 min of light irradiation were similar.
A possible explanation relies on the distinct optical properties observed for the GaPFC and derived silica hybrids (Fig. 2 and 5). First we note that the UV-VIS spectrum of GaPFC-APS-SiO2 shows a slight batochromic shift (16 nm) of the Soret band in relation to the spectrum of the pure complex in solution (Fig. 2). This might be an indication that the GaPFC molecules grafted at the silica surfaces are interacting due to their proximity as a result of particle aggregation. This tendency would be expected to be more pronounced in the solid state and in fact, the visible reflectance spectrum of the corresponding GaPFC-APS-SiO2 powder (Fig. 7) shows a larger batochromic shift (37 nm).
Fig. 7 Visible reflectance spectra of GaPFC (- - - -) and GaPFC-APS-SiO2 (——). |
The morphological characteristics of the starting SiO2 particles and of the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 sample were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). As expected from previous reports, the as prepared SiO2 particles appear as discrete particles dispersed on the sample14 (Fig. 8a). Also DLS measurements performed on APS functionalized colloids gave an average particle diameter of 158 nm. Therefore, prior functionalization with the corrole derivative, the SiO2 colloid is mainly composed of discrete particles as the dispersible phase. On the other hand, GaPFC-APS-SiO2 particles deposited from suspensions of a variety of organic solvents, such as acetone, ethanol and DMF, originated blackberry-shaped clusters composed of spherical SiO2 particles (Fig. 8). Additionally, clustering was still observed for samples deposited from aqueous suspensions at pH 4 and pH 9 in variable extent (Fig. SI5†). Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) experiments performed on these suspensions suggest that this clustering effect had already occurred in solution and is not a result from SEM specimen preparation. In fact, the average diameter (and standard deviation) determined by DLS for the GaPFC-APS-SiO2 dispersed in water was 229.7 ± 3.5 nm and the suspensions at pH 4 and pH 9 result in particle average sizes of 497.0 ± 17.6 nm and 576.7 ± 29.7 nm, respectively. Therefore, these results indicate that this clustering effect is a consequence of the GaPFC attached at the silica particle surfaces and depends on the dispersing medium. In fact, for GaPFC-APS-SiO2 particles dispersed in DMF, i.e. the solvent used for 1O2 measurements, an average diameter of 463.0 ± 33 nm was obtained which is consistent with the dimensions observed for the particle clusters in the SEM images (Fig. 8).
Fig. 8 SEM images a) SiO2, b) GaPFC-APS-SiO2 deposited from acetone, c) GaPFC-APS-SiO2 deposited from ethanol and d) GaPFC-APS-SiO2 from DMF. |
The above discussion is consistent with a self-assembly process in which the clustering of the hybrid particles is mediated by the interactions occurring between adjacent corrole macrocycles. In fact, the establishment of π–π interactions between the corrole molecules at the SiO2 surface would account for the optical features shown in Fig. 7.31–33 Also, the role of the corrole complex as a molecular spacer for directional assembly can not be discarded, because each corrole complex has three available sites to react with each amine group at the SiO2 surface. However this effect has to be balanced with particle size constraints arising from the proximity of neighboring SiO2 particles.
Footnote |
† Electronic Supplementary Information (ESI) available: See DOI: 10.1039/c2ra22133k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2013 |