Alessandro
Contini
* and
Emanuela
Erba
Dipartimento di Scienze Farmaceutiche – Sezione di Chimica Generale e Organica “Alessandro Marchesini”, Università degli Studi di Milano, Centro Interuniversitario di Ricerca sulle Reazioni Pericicliche e Sintesi di Sistemi Etero e Carbociclici, Via Venezian, 21 20133 Milano, Italy. E-mail: alessandro.contini@unimi.it; emanuela.erba@unimi.it; Fax: +39.02.503.14476; Tel: +39.02.503.14475
First published on 11th September 2012
The cycloaddition reaction of the morpholino enamines of N-methylpiperidone and N-methyl tropinone with sulfonylazides was exploited, leading to a click-chemistry approach to uncommon azacycloalkene monosulfonyl diamines in good yields. A computational model for the key step decomposition of the triazoline intermediate was then realized by DFT calculations. The model explains the observed reaction outcome and leads to a new interpretation of the decomposition mechanism for 5-amino-1,2,3-triazolines.
For those reasons, in this paper we describe a facile and versatile synthetic method to obtain azacycloalkene-monosulfonyl-diamines from accessible starting materials.
Our group studied for a long time cycloaddition reactions and the subsequent rearrangement of the cycloadducts of aryl and sulfonyl azides with enamines of various aldehydes and linear or cyclic ketones.4 In particular, when sulfonyl azides were used, the primary unstable dihydrotriazole cycloadduct underwent a spontaneous transformation and two main products were obtained: 2-alkyl-sulfonylamidine 1 by nitrogen loss and C-5 substituent transposition and the sulfonylformamidine 2 by alkyl diazomethane loss (Scheme 1).
Scheme 1 General reaction scheme for the cycloaddition of enamines with sulfonyl azides. |
The obtained amidines were extensively used as syntones in heterocycle synthesis.5 Aiming to obtain new synthetically useful starting materials, a number of carbonylic compounds have been used. It is known that the nature of the starting carbonyl reactant appears to rule the outcome of the reaction, and cyclic ketones containing a nitrogen atom showed an unexpected behaviour.6 Consequently, one aim of this work was to thoroughly investigate the behaviour of alkylpiperidones and tropinones as the carbonylic reactant. Moreover, due to the peculiar regiochemical results herein obtained, an in-depth computational study of the reaction mechanism was performed. The results were in perfect agreement with the experiments and provided the evidence for a new interpretation of the mechanism of 5-amino-1,2,3-triazoline decomposition and rearrangement.
Encouraged by those interesting results, we drove to extend this scheme to other starting materials to verify the reaction trend and the repeatability of the results. The selected enamines were the morpholino enamines of 4-methylpiperidone 3 and of tropinone 6, while the chosen sulfonylazides were tosylazide 4a, p-nitrosofolylazide 4b, styrylsulfonylazide 4c, o-nitrosulfonylazide 4d and phenylmethanesulfonylazide 4e (Scheme 2).
Scheme 2 Reaction scheme for azacycloalkene-monosulfonyl-diamines 5 and 7. Reagents and contitions: (i) Et2O (iPr2O for 5b), 20 °C, 15 min. |
In all cases the products were obtained in good yields in accordance with the proposed scheme. An in-depth study of NMR HSQC, COSY and NOESY spectra of 7d allowed us to unequivocally confirm the proposed structure. All signals were separable and identified in 1H and 13C NMR at 500 and 125 MHz, respectively. So the nOe effect between NCH-1 at 3.49 δ and morpholino CH2N at 2.55 δ confirmed the C2 position of morpholine. Another observation was useful to explain the reaction steps. When the 13C spectra of a concentrated solution of 7d (50 mg of 7d in 1 mL of CDCl3) was recorded, the first 50 scans only showed signals associated with the imino form C (see Scheme 3). Instead the 13C spectra recorded after 10 h of sample preparation only showed signals associated with the enamino form 7. This fact suggested the imino form C as the initial reaction product, which subsequently tautomerizes (Scheme 3).
Scheme 3 Tautomeric forms of products 5, 7. |
Although the reported mechanism concerned bicyclic triazolines bearing an alkyl group at the 7a position, its generalization to the 7-morpholino substituted triazolines herein described, as depicted in Scheme 4, appears to be legitimate.
Scheme 4 Stepwise mechanistic hypothesis for bicyclic 1,2,3 triazolines. |
Indeed, the triazolines A, through an initial ring opening, could provide a zwitterion intermediate B which could evolve by either ring contraction (path a) or [1,2] shift of the morpholino group (path b) and consequent nitrogen loss. The zwitterion intermediate could exist in two different conformations, B1 and B2: while conformer B1 leads to 1–2 bond migration onto the leaving diazonium group in an antiperiplanar fashion, migration of the morpholino group in B2 onto the axial diazonium species results in formation of imine C which could tautomerize to 5 and D (see Scheme 3).
Previously reported decompositions of triazolines obtained by the reaction of tosylazide with 4-cyclohexenylmorpholine (X = CH2),4a only provided the ring contraction product 1 (path a). On the other hand, the herein reported reactions (X = NCH3) only provided diamino products 5, 7 (or the corresponding C and D tautomers) deriving from the migration of the morpholino group (path b).
Starting from the results herein reported and considering our interest in modeling reaction mechanisms,9 we decided to perform a computational mechanistic study by means of Density Functional Theory (DFT). The mPW1B95 functional,10 coupled with the 6-31+G(d,p) basis set, was chosen for all calculations as in precedent works of our group it proved to be highly reliable when compared with other common functionals.9d,e All calculations have been performed in the gas phase and in solution, where the solvent effect was considered for both geometry optimizations and Intrinsic Reaction Coordinates (IRCs) analyses by means of the conductor-like polarizable continuum model (CPCM) for diethyl ether.11 Unless differently specified, the following discussion is referred to solution phase results.
The decomposition of triazolines AN (from 1-methylpiperidin-4-one, hereafter referred as the “aza” model) and AC (from cyclohexanone, hereafter referred as the “carbo” model), where Ar = Ph, were chosen as representative reaction models. The following discussion, unless differently specified, refers to both the “aza” and “carbo” models.
Starting from the mechanistic hypothesis of Scheme 4, we initially evaluated the difference in stability between zwitterion conformations B1 and B2 as their energy difference might be responsible for the observed outcome. However, for both the “aza” and “carbo” models, the B1 conformer was the most favored, being 2.3 and 3.1 kcal mol−1 more stable, respectively.
This result suggests that the reaction outcome might be controlled at the transition state level, then the relative stability between transition states for paths a and b could rule the reaction outcome. For this reason, structures corresponding to triazolines A, zwitterions B and products 1 and C, were fully optimized. Starting from the most stable conformation of triazolines A, the location of the transition states (TSs) leading to zwitterions B was attempted by slightly lengthening the N1–N2 bond distances.
In both the “aza” and “carbo” models, the corresponding TS-AN1 and TS-AC1 presented N1–N2 and C3a–N3 (d1 and d2, accordingly to Fig. 1), bond distances both increased with respect to the corresponding distances in triazolines A (Δd1 = 1.066 Å, Δd2 = 0.400 Å and Δd1 = 1.043 Å, Δd2 = 0.382 Å for the “aza” and “carbo” models, respectively), thus suggesting that the nitrogen molecule might be eliminated in a concerted manner.
Fig. 1 Geometries for the “aza” and “carbo” model TSs. Selected distances are reported in Å, Wiberg bond indices calculated from NBO analysis are reported in parenthesis. |
To confirm or refuse this hypothesis, an IRC analysis,12 which locates the lowest energy path connecting reactants to TSs and TSs to products, was performed starting from TS-AN1 and TS-AC1. In both cases the IRC analyses confirmed the direct transformation of triazolines A into the final products 1 without the obtainment of any zwitterionic structure that could be considered a stationary point along the potential energy surface (PES) (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2 IRC analysis for the decomposition of triazoline AC (“carbo” model) following path a. Geometries for selected points along the reaction energy path are also reported. Energies are calculated relatively to the most stable conformation of triazoline AC. |
This result gives weight to the hypothesis that triazolines might decompose through a pericyclic mechanism, involving a sigmatropic [1,2] shift of the alkyl (path a) or morpholino (path b) groups accompanied by nitrogen loss. The two different paths a and b would then originate from the conformations A1 or A2 of the corresponding triazoline, accordingly to Scheme 5.
Scheme 5 Proposed concerted reaction mechanism. |
It should be noted that, analogously to what is observed for the hypothesized zwitterion intermediates, conformation A1 is always preferred for triazolines also (ΔGA2−A1 = 3.2 and 1.1 kcal mol−1 for “aza” and “carbo” models, respectively) and so the preference toward paths a or b should be exclusively determined at the transition state level. This hypothesis could be confirmed by locating the TSs involved in path b for both the “aza” and “carbo” models (TS-AN2 and TS-AC2, respectively). Activation energies should then favor path b in the former and path a in the latter model.
Both TS-AN2 and TS-AC2 were obtained from the corresponding triazolines A2 by lengthening the N1–N2 bond distance and the evaluation of the corresponding activation free energies (ΔΔG‡b−a = −1.1 and 2.2 kcal mol−1 for the “aza” and “carbo” models, respectively, accordingly to Table 1) supported our thesis. As expected, a successive IRC analysis (Fig. 3 and Fig. S2, ESI‡) confirmed that the located TSs directly connect the triazoline reactants with the imino product C, providing further evidence of a concerted decomposition.
Fig. 3 Intrinsic Reaction Coordinate analysis for the decomposition of triazolines obtained from the enamines of 4-piperidone (“aza” model) or cyclohexanone (“carbo” model). |
To provide a complete description of the reaction, the formation of triazolines AN and AC through the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of azide 3 with enamines 4N and 4C (for “aza” and “carbo” models, respectively) was initially modelled (see Fig. S3, ESI‡) and the complete reaction profiles are reported in Scheme 6.
Scheme 6 Complete reaction profiles for “carbo” (black) path a and “aza” (blue) path b. Free energy differences are calculated in solution (Et2O) and reported in kcal mol−1. Free energy differences for the unfavored “carbo” path b and “aza” path a are reported in parenthesis. Thermochemical corrections were obtained from vibrational analyses performed at 298.15 K, 1 atm. |
For both the “aza” and “carbo” models, the reaction between enamines 3 and azide 4 occurs with rather low activation free energy barriers, with the reaction of 1-methyl-4-piperidone 3 being less favoured with respect to the carbocyclic analogue (9.1 and 7.3 kcal mol−1, respectively) and leads to the corresponding triazolines with a free energy difference, with respect to isolated reagents, of −21.0 and −20.2 kcal mol−1 for the “aza” and “carbo” models, respectively, this path being slightly advantagous over the reverse reaction in both cases. The reaction then proceeds through the triazoline decomposition, taking different routes for “carbo” and “aza” models, as described above. In both cases, quite large activation free energies are computed, suggesting that the triazoline might not immediately decompose. In the case of the herein reported compounds 5a–d and 7a–c,e, this is supported by the experimental observation that nitrogen starts to be released after about 2 min from the addition of the azide, while the reaction reaches completion in about 10 min. In both cases the triazoline decomposition is predicted to be quite exothermic, with free energy differences of −63.5 and −57.0 kcal mol−1 for the “carbo” and “aza” models. For this latter reaction path, the imino form C, directly obtained from TS-AN2, tautomerizes to the most stable enamino forms 5 (ΔG5−C = −1.6 kcal mol−1) and D (ΔGD−C = −1.2 kcal mol−1, see Scheme 6). While in Et2O the enamino tautomer 5 prevails over D (ΔG5−D = −0.4 kcal mol−1), and exactly the opposite is predicted by performing the calculation in chloroform (ΔGD−5 = −0.4 kcal mol−1). These results suggest that both 5 and D enamino forms coexist and their equilibrium can be shifted to one or to the other depending on conditions.
The lower reaction free energy differences obtained for both the path a products (Scheme 6) are not surprising, as the triazoline decomposition is not reversible and a thermodynamic equilibrium between products is not possible. The outcome might then only be ruled by the energy differences between transition states, making the reaction proceed under exclusive kinetic control.
A further remark should be given on the comparison of activation and reaction free energies for paths a and b. While the energy difference between TS-AC1 (“carbo” path a) and TS-AC2 (“carbo” path b; ΔGb−a = 2.2 kcal mol−1) fully supports the isolation of 1 as the only product, the difference between TS-AN2 (“aza” path b) and TS-AN1 (“aza” path a; ΔGb−a = 1.1 kcal mol−1) appears to be too low to suggest the isolation of 5 as the only product. Indeed, according to the Arrhenius equation, the ratio between products 1N and CN, predicted from computed activation free energies as [1N]/[CN] = e(ΔG‡C−ΔG‡1)/RT, is 16:84. Although we did not expect to exactly reproduce the complex experimental results by a computational method (the mean average errors of some among the most accurate theoretical methods in predicting activation energies for 1,3-dipolar cycloadditions spanned from 1.2 to 3.5 kcal mol−113), it is true that 16% of compound 1N should have been detected by NMR. However, it is also true that for all the reported reactions the principal product precipitated in the reaction mixture and was isolated in about 80% yield, while byproducts in the mother liquors were not isolable.
Finally, providing a rationale of the computed activation barriers for “aza” and “carbo” species has not been trivial. Our investigation started from two hypotheses on the role of N5, that is the stabilization of TS-AN2 or the destabilization of TS-AN1. Nevertheless, the visual inspection of TS geometries for paths a and b of both models evidenced only minor differences, suggesting that the observed outcome should not be ruled by one main reason (such as an evident difference in steric hindrance or the presence of hydrogen bonds at the TS level), but by the combination of different minor effects. For instance, Wiberg bond indices (BIs)14 were calculated via NBO15 analysis (see Fig. 1) for TS-AC,N1,2. Indeed, the difference between BIs (ΔBI) at the TS level can be taken as a measure of the synchronicity degree, the lower is ΔBI, the higher is the synchronicity.9e Such analysis showed that path b TSs were less synchronous than path a TSs, but a higher variation in synchronicity was observed when switching from TS-AN1 (ΔBI = 0.32) to TS-AN2 (ΔBI = 0.53) than from TS-AC1 (ΔBI = 0.33) to TS-AC2 (ΔBI = 0.45). This observation was also supported by the analysis of NBO charges on the leaving N2 group (see Fig. S4, ESI‡), showing a higher cationic character in TS-AN2 and TS-AC2 (N2 charge = 0.219 and 0.176, respectively), than in TS-AN1 and TS-AC1 (N2 charge = 0.140 and 0.146, respectively).
The above data help in defining the chemical-physical variations induced by the replacement of the C5 with a nitrogen, but a further indication came from an Atom In Molecules (AIM)16 wavefunction analysis of TS-AN1, -AN2, -AC1 and -AC2, which by locating bond critical points (BCP) and corresponding bond paths (BP) allows a rigorous identification of those weak interactions that are otherwise difficult to evidence (Fig. 4). Indeed, in recently published studies AIM analysis has been found useful in characterizing TSs leading to competing reaction paths.17
Fig. 4 AIM analyses, molecular graphs and bond critical points (BCP) for TSs of path a (TS-AN1 and TS-AC1) and path b (TS-AN2 and TS-AC2). Bond paths are denoted by solid lines, BCPs are denoted by small red balls on the bond path. Weak interactions which differentiate “aza” and “carbo” models are evidenced by a black arrow. The values of ρb for selected BCP are reported in a.u.: BCP1, 0.0080; BCP2, 0.0076; BCP3, 0.0129; BCP4, 0.0109. |
As reported in Fig. 4, our analyses show that the replacement of C5 with N5 induces both a destabilization of TS-AN1 with respect to TS-AC1, where BCP1 defines an additional weak attractive interaction between the SO2 oxygen and the axial C6 hydrogen in the cyclohexane ring, as well as a stabilization of TS-AN2, where BCP3 defines an additional weak attractive interaction between the SO2 oxygen and the axial C7 hydrogen. Other differences can be observed between TS-AN2 and TS-AC2, that are the presence of a BCP between SO2 and the CH next to the morpholine oxygen in TS-AN2 (BCP2), not present in TS-AC2, which is however characterized by an additional BCP between SO2 and the equatorial C7 hydrogen in the cyclohexane ring. The values of ρb (Fig. 4), which are proportional to the strength of the interaction,18 at the selected BCPs are in line with values reported in previous work for an analogous weak interaction,17 and confirm a clear stabilization effect in TS-AN2. As mentioned above, this analysis is intended to provide a rationale of the observed experimental outcome, but we cannot exclude that other reasons could concur in determining the computed activation barriers.
Seeking for an ultimate proof on the reliability of our theoretical findings, several attempts for locating transition states for a stepwise mechanism were also made by evaluating different levels of theory. However, in every case, TSs from zwitterions B1 and B2 to products 1 and C were actually located (TS-BN,C1 and TS-BN,C2, respectively, see ESI‡) but no TSs connecting triazoline A to zwitterion B were found.
In should be finally considered that the proposed mechanism is only possible if, at the reaction conditions, an equilibrium between conformations A1 and A2 might be established. Moreover, the required energy for the conversion between triazolines A1 and A2 should be lower than the reaction activation energy. In order to prove this, we realized a simple computational model based on the main scaffold of triazoline A, accordingly to Scheme 7. The activation energy for the conformational change between the most stable chair conformation and the boat intermediate was then calculated by locating the corresponding TSs (ΔG‡ = 6.6 and 6.9 kcal mol−1 for the chair 1 to boat transition and 7.5 and 5.0 kcal mol−1 for the boat to chair 2 transition in the “aza” and “carbo” models, respectively), and was far below the activation energy required for the reaction to proceed via either path a or b (ΔG‡ = 28.9 and 27.8 kcal mol−1, respectively, for the “aza” model), confirming that an equilibrium between the two triazoline conformations is possible in the reaction conditions.
Scheme 7 Chair–twisted boat–reversed chair equilibrium. Activation and reaction free energy differences are calculated in solution and reported in kcal mol−1. |
The key reaction step, consisting of the decomposition and rearrangement of the 1,2,3-triazoline intermediate, has been modeled and compared to the parent carbocyclic derivative, which only leads to the amidine product through the ring contraction mechanism. Contrarily to what is expected, the triazoline decomposition occurs in both cases in a concerted manner, directly leading to the final products. The reaction is predicted to be under kinetic control and the selectivity toward the diamino derivatives can be due to stabilising weak interactions at the TS level, as evidenced by AIM analyses.
The synthesis of enamine 3a22 and 623 was previously described.
Footnotes |
† This work is dedicated to our mentor and friend, Prof. D. Pocar, for his 50 year long exploration of triazoline chemistry. |
‡ Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Further computational details, Cartesian coordinates, energies and thermochemical corrections for all the stationary points, NMR spectra of compounds 5a–d and 7a–d. See DOI: 10.1039/c2ra21592f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |