Deirdre M.
Murphy
,
Ronan J.
Cullen
,
Dilushan R.
Jayasundara
,
Eoin M.
Scanlan
and
Paula E.
Colavita
*
School of Chemistry, University of Dublin Trinity College, College Green, Dublin 2, Ireland. E-mail: colavitp@tcd.ie
First published on 11th May 2012
Diazonium salts of two nitro-substituted polycyclic aromatic compounds were synthesized and their spontaneous covalent attachment onto amorphous carbon surfaces was studied via electrochemical and spectroscopic techniques. In situ spectroscopic monitoring of the grafting of these compounds at amorphous carbon surfaces via attenuated total internal reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR) highlighted a marked difference in adsorption rates, which was also evident via ex situ electrochemical analysis. We show that adsorption rate differences cannot be explained based on differences in the solvolysis rates of these two molecules. It was found instead that the relative position of the –N2+ groups with respect to the –NO2 groups affected the reduction potential of the diazonium cations and in turn their adsorption rate at amorphous carbon surfaces. We conclude that differences in the electron density at the carbon atom bound to the diazonium group are responsible for the differences observed in the spontaneous attachment at carbon.
The spontaneous reaction of aryldiazonium salts on surfaces is mechanistically less well understood than electrografting. The specific substituents on the aryldiazonium, the type of substrate and the solvent used for the deposition have all been found to affect reaction yields and rates.12,18 General trends have been identified showing that electron withdrawing substituents and easily oxidizable metals tend to display faster grafting reactions. Based on these results a mechanism involving the spontaneous electron transfer from metal substrates to aryldiazonium with the loss of dinitrogen has been proposed, in analogy with the electrografting process. The grafting yield on carbon appears to depend, as for metals, on the relative position of the donor and the acceptor levels at the carbon and aryldiazonium cation, respectively, thus suggesting that the surface acts as a mild reductant.19 However, it has been hypothesized that multiple routes could lead to the spontaneous formation of aryldiazonium layers and multilayers.20–23 In particular, it has been proposed that the thermal decomposition of aryldiazonium salts via either homolytic or heterolytic cleavage of C–N2+ bonds gives rise to alternative pathways of the covalent aryldiazonium attachment at surfaces, as illustrated in Scheme I.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Heterolytic (A) and homolytic (B) pathways of the covalent aryldiazonium attachment at surfaces. |
The spontaneous grafting process has been mainly studied using p-substituted benzenediazonium salts on metals and carbon. The most popular reagent choice is 4-nitrobenzenediazonium tetrafluoroborate (4NBD) due to the fact that it is relatively stable, it is commercially available and it possesses a nitrophenyl group that can be used to electrochemically monitor the surface coverage via its electroreduction to phenylamine. Few reports however exist on the spontaneous grafting of diazonium salts with polynuclear aromatic backbones. Polynuclear aromatic molecules, such as biphenyls, azobenzenes, stilbenes, oligo(phenylenes), or anthracene, have been the subject of intense investigation due to their extended conjugated systems. Diazonium derivatives of these molecules have been used for fundamental studies of charge transfer through thin organic films and molecular aggregates,9,24–30 as well as for sensing applications31 in which the extended π-system and backbone rigidity are leveraged to allow fast electron transfer. With few exceptions, previous work on surface modifications using polynuclear aromatic diazonium derivatives has been almost exclusively carried out using an electrochemical approach. The spontaneous grafting of diazonium derivatives of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH–N2+), on the other hand, has not yet been investigated. This is surprising, since spontaneous grafting of aryldiazonium salts has been shown to lead to greater control over surface coverage and layer ordering,12 two properties that are of great importance for electronic and sensing applications.
In this work we report studies on the spontaneous grafting of diazonium derivatives of PAH compounds at carbon surfaces. We synthesized two diazonium salts that share a 1-nitronaphthalene backbone: 4-nitronaphthalenediazonium tetrafluoroborate (4NND) and 5-nitronaphthalenediazonium tetrafluoroborate (5NND); the structure of these two compounds is shown in Scheme II. We have used a combination of techniques in order to investigate their covalent attachment to carbon and compare it to that of their monocyclic analog 4NBD. The nitro group allowed us to monitor the grafting process and coverage in situ via infrared spectroscopy at the solid–liquid interface and ex situ via electrochemical methods. Thermal or solvolytic decomposition of aryldiazonium salts has been shown to play a role in the covalent grafting of aryldiazonium salts.32 Therefore, we studied the thermal stability and rate of solvolysis of 4NND and 5NND in order to understand whether these can affect their spontaneous attachment to carbon. We have found marked differences in the attachment rate of these two molecules and we discuss them in terms of their structural differences.
![]() | ||
Scheme 2 Structures of 4-nitrobenzenediazonium tetrafluoroborate (4NBD), 4-nitronaphthalenediazonium tetrafluoroborate (4NND) and 5-nitronaphthalenediazonium tetrafluoroborate (5NND). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) IRRAS spectra of a-C substrates following immersion in 1 × 10−3 M 4NND and 5NND solutions for 1 h. (b) Cyclic voltammograms of 4NND and 5NND-modified a-C electrodes obtained in 0.1 M H2SO4 at 0.2 V s−1; the substrates were modified via immersion in 1 × 10−4 M aqueous solutions of 4NND and 5NND for 10 min. |
The grafting of nitronaphthalene diazonium salts on carbon was also investigated via electrochemistry using amorphous carbon electrodes. Fig. 1b shows the cyclic voltammetric response of 4NND and 5NND modified a-C electrodes in 0.1 M H2SO4 aqueous solutions. The modified a-C electrodes in Fig. 1b were prepared via spontaneous modification in 1 × 10−4 M aqueous solutions of the diazonium salts for 10 min. The cyclic voltammograms (CVs) show an irreversible cathodic peak at −0.87 V and −0.59 V (vs. Ag/AgCl) for 4NND and 5NND, respectively, that we attribute to the electroreduction of the nitroaryl groups.37 Subsequent potential sweeps do not display these peaks, which is consistent with a near complete reduction of the surface-bound ArNO2 groups. The difference of ∼0.28 V in the cathodic peak position for 4NND and 5NND suggests that the organic layers resulting from the spontaneous grafting of these two molecules over 10 min are different in structure and/or thickness. The cathodic peak for 4NND has a larger integrated area than that observed for 5NND. This result also suggests that a higher surface density of reducible nitroaryl groups is present at the carbon surface in the case of 4NND, which would be consistent with a thicker organic film. Both IRRAS and electrochemical results, however, indicate that both nitronaphthalene diazonium salts can be spontaneously grafted from solution onto amorphous carbon films.
The in situ monitoring of the spontaneous grafting of 4NND and 5NND onto a-C substrates was carried out via attenuated total internal reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR) techniques as previously reported.35 Carbon coated trapezoids were used as ATR optical elements in a liquid cell containing water; at time zero, a 1 × 10−4 M aqueous solution of the diazonium salt was introduced into the cells and left to react at the carbon surface. Fig. 2a shows an example of ATR-FTIR spectra in the ν(NO2) spectral region measured at different times after the injection of the 4NND solutions into the liquid cell. Surface adsorption was monitored by plotting the net absorbance at the ∼1340 cm−1 peak maximum associated with the νs(NO2) mode; this peak was chosen over the asymmetric stretching mode because it was least affected by water vapour peaks across all of the ATR-FTIR datasets. The νs(NO2) net absorbance was corrected for any differences in pathlength by normalizing spectra against the same peak obtained from a standard KNO3 solution, thus obtaining curves of corrected net absorbance as a function of time. Fig. 2b shows adsorption curves obtained via this methodology for 4NND and 5NND; curves obtained for the monocyclic aromatic analog, 4NBD, previously investigated in our group35 are also reported for comparison purposes. In order to obtain curves that reflect the density of adsorbed molecules at the carbon surface as a function of time, we further normalized the curves in Fig. 2b by the relative absorption cross sections of the νs(NO2) mode for the three different molecules (see the ESI†). Fig. 2c shows the results of normalization by both pathlength and absorption cross sections; these curves display the changes in the surface density of the nitroaryl groups as a function of the deposition time obtained during the adsorption of 4NBD, 4NND and 5NND at the same carbon surface.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) ATR-FTIR spectra collected as a function of time after injection of a 1 × 10−4 M 4NND aqueous solution into the liquid cell; spectra are offset for the sake of clarity. (b) Plot of the pathlength-corrected net absorbance of νs(NO2) as a function of deposition time obtained for 4NBD, 4NND and 5NND. (c) Plot of the νs(NO2) net absorbance normalized by pathlength and absorption cross-section (normalized net absorbance), as a function of deposition time. The normalized net absorbance is proportional to the surface density of the arylnitro groups at the carbon–solution interface. |
The deposition curves shown in Fig. 2c indicate that the rate of adsorption of the nitroaryl groups follows the order 4NBD > 4NND > 5NND. In all three cases two adsorption regimes can be observed: a fast first adsorption process takes place within the first 20 min followed by a slower adsorption process at longer times, in agreement with previous reports on 4NBD by Lehr et al.23 A first notable difference that emerges from Fig. 2c is that between the adsorption rate of 4NBD and 4NND. These two molecules share a p-nitrosubstituted benzenediazonium backbone, but differ in size due to the presence of an additional fused aromatic ring in 4NND. After the first 20 min of deposition, the average surface density of the arylnitro groups at the 4NBD modified carbon surfaces is equal to 3.4 times the density observed via modification with 4NND. This value is in excellent agreement with the previously observed surface density ratios of 2.7 obtained by Allongue et al. from electrografting experiments on the same diazonium salts, which were attributed to differences in the diazonium cation size.38 The similar surface density ratios obtained via electrografting and spontaneous adsorption suggest that differences in the adsorption rate between 4NBD and 4NND in Fig. 2c arise predominantly from differences in the molecular cross section.
A second significant difference is that observed between the two positional isomers, 4NND and 5NND. After the first 20 min of deposition, the average surface density of the nitroaryl groups at the 4NND modified carbon surfaces is equal to 3.1 times the density observed via modification with 5NND indicating that 4NND accumulates in significantly higher yields at a-C surfaces. 4NND and 5NND do not differ by their geometric molecular cross sections; therefore, the difference in the surface density shown in Fig. 2c must arise from the difference in the position of the –N2+ relative to the –NO2 group.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Surface coverage of nitroaryl groups (Γ) on a-C substrates as a function of deposition time in 1 × 10−4 M 4NND (○) and 5NND (■) solutions. |
The differences in the adsorption of the two positional isomers observed in situ, ultimately lead to different surface coverage in the chemisorbed organic layer, as shown by ex situ techniques. Since the geometric molecular cross section of 4NND and 5NND is similar, differences observed in adsorption rates must be attributed to differences in the position of the –N2+ relative to the –NO2 group. A change in the substitution position can have two important effects on these molecules: substitution position at C4 compared to C5 should lead to (a) higher diazonium salt stability towards dediazoniation and/or (b) changes in electron density, in particular at the diazo-substituted carbon. In order to understand whether one or both of these effects plays a role in determining the adsorption rate at the carbon–solution interface we carried out an investigation on the stability of 4NND and 5NND towards dediazoniation.
The stability towards thermal decomposition of 4NND and 5NND was first investigated in the solid state using TGA (thermogravimetric analysis) and DSC (differential scanning calorimetry). The weight percentage loss of both 4NND and 5NND upon heating under an inert atmosphere was measured for both compounds as illustrated in Fig. 4. The TGA results display an initial sharp weight loss between 120 °C and 160 °C for both compounds and then a gradual decline in weight as the temperature increased to 900 °C. The extrapolated onset temperatures of thermal decomposition were found to be 145 ± 2 °C and 126 ± 1 °C (90% confidence interval (C.I.)) for 4NND and 5NND, respectively. DSC data were used to calculate reaction enthalpys ΔRH associated with this decomposition process of −132.1 kJ mol−1 and −133.3 kJ mol−1 for 4NND and 5NND, respectively. Bräse et al.39 have proposed that the first step in the thermal decomposition of aryldiazonium tetrafluoroborate salts in the solid phase involves dediazoniation, in a process similar to a Schiemann reaction.40 Therefore, our results indicate that 5NND is more thermally labile than 4NND, as would be expected based on the stabilizing effect of the nitro group being closer to the diazo group in the case of 4NND.41
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 The thermogravimetric analysis of 4NND and 5NND under N2 in the range 0–900 °C at 10 °C min−1. |
In order to determine if any significant differences in dediazoniation rates were observed in solution, we carried out hydrolysis experiments using 4NND and 5NND. Aryldiazonium compounds hydrolyse via dediazoniation followed by formation of phenolic derivatives;1,42,43 this process can be followed via UV-vis by monitoring the disappearance of the absorption peak at ∼250 nm associated with the aryldiazonium groups, as previously reported.41,42,44Fig. 5a and 5b show the evolution of the absorption spectra of 1 × 10−4 M 4NND and 5NND solutions, respectively, as a function of time at 37 °C over 7 h: as hydrolysis of the aryldiazonium cation progresses, the absorption peaks at 259 nm (Fig. 5a) and 232 nm (Fig. 5b) decrease. Observed first-order hydrolysis rate constants were obtained by fitting the absorbance vs. time according to eqn (1) (shown in the insets in Fig. 5):41,45,46
![]() | (1) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 UV-Vis spectra of 1 × 10−4 M solutions of 4NND (a) and 5NND (b) during hydrolysis at 37 °C over a period of 7 h. The insets show the corresponding first-order kinetic plots obtained from the UV-vis data (see eqn (1)). |
Our results indicate that, despite showing differences in thermal stability in the solid phase, 4NND and 5NND are equally stable towards dediazoniation under typical conditions used for spontaneous adsorption at surfaces. The remarkable difference in the adsorption rate observed in Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 therefore cannot be attributed to dediazoniation reactions that take place in solution but must arise from differences in the interaction of 4NND and 5NND at the carbon surface due to the differences in electron density between the two positional isomers.
Therefore, electrochemical measurements were carried out to find the reduction potential of the aryldiazonium functional group. The peak potential at which the reduction peak is observed shifts with the position of acceptor levels in solution. A cathodic sweep in the 7 × 10−4 M solutions of 4NND and 5NND in anhydrous acetonitrile shows an irreversible cathodic wave with Ep at 0.05 ± 0.01 V and −0.20 ± 0.02 V (vs. Saturated Calomel Electrode C.I. = 90%) for 4NND and 5NND, respectively (see ESI†). The more negative potential obtained for 5NND indicates that its reduction is more difficult to achieve than that of its positional isomer 4NND.
The solvolysis of 4NND and 5NND was found to occur over similar timescales under the experimental conditions used for the spontaneous attachment of these two aryldiazonium salts, therefore, the differences in the coverage cannot be ascribed to the faster degradation in solution of one of the positional isomers. Adsorption rates, on the other hand, appear to correlate very well with the reduction potential of the aryldiazonium cation, which was found to be more positive for 4NND compared to 5NND. These results are in agreement with reactivity trends observed for monocyclic aryldiazonium salts, which suggest that cations with lower lying electron-acceptor levels are more easily grafted than electron rich cations.
This work shows, for the first time, the spontaneous grafting of diazonium derivatives of n-PAHs onto amorphous carbon substrates. Our results indicate that the spontaneous grafting of diazonium derivatives of n-PAHs can lead to different layers at carbon surfaces, depending on the position of the –N2+ functional group with respect to the other substituents in the condensed ring system. This work presents a clear example of positional isomers displaying very different grafting behaviours and highlights the importance of substituent position which may be useful when choosing compounds for sensing and electronic applications.
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed on a Pyris 1 TGA (Perkin Elmer). Measurements were recorded under N2 atmosphere in the range 0–900 °C at 10 °C min−1. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was carried out on a Diamond DSC (Perkin Elmer). These measurements were collected in the range 0–200 °C at 5 °C min−1 and in the range 90–180 °C at 0.5 °C min−1. UV-Vis was carried out on a Lambda35 (Perkin Elmer) spectrometer equipped with a thermostated cell; spectra were collected at 1 nm resolution in the range 220–470 nm at 37 °C, at regular time intervals.
Aryldiazonium grafting on a-C substrates was carried out by immersing the samples in aqueous solutions of 4NND and 5NND for varying lengths of time. After grafting, the substrates were washed and sonicated in water and dried under argon prior to electrochemical analysis. Cyclic voltammetry was carried out on a CHI660C potentiostat using Pt wire and Ag/AgCl (IJ Cambria) as counter and reference electrodes, respectively. Experiments were carried out in a previously described Teflon cell52 with an electrode area of 0.067 cm2. Electrochemical analysis was performed at room temperature in argon purged 0.1 M H2SO4 solutions. Electrochemistry of aryldiazonium salts in non-aqueous solutions was carried out in anhydrous acetonitrile using 0.1 M tetrabutylammonium perchlorate (NBu4ClO4) as supporting electrolyte;6 potentials were measured against a Pt pseudo-reference electrode and corrected using ferrocene as a standard.
Footnote |
† Electronic Supplementary Information (ESI) available: details of the normalisation procedure for the infrared absorption cross sections for the three compounds used in our experiments, cyclic voltammetry of 4NND and 5NND in acetonitrile and additional infrared spectra of the organic films. See DOI:10.1039/c2ra20292a/ |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |