Elena
Kudrenko
*ab,
Vladimir
Roddatis
b,
Andrey
Zhokhov
a,
Irina
Zverkova
a,
Igor
Khodos
c and
Gennady
Emelchenko
a
aInstitute of Solid State Physics RAS, 142432 Chernogolovka, Russia. E-mail: lenak@issp.ac.ru; Fax: +7-496-522-81-60; Tel: +7-496-522-82-74
bNational Research Centre Kurchatov Institute, 123182 Moscow, Russia
cInstitute of Microelectronics Technology and High Purity Materials RAS, 142432 Chernogolovka, Russia
First published on 27th April 2012
SiC nanowires (NWs) with diameters of 20–200 nm and lengths from tens to hundreds of micrometers have been synthesized by the carbothermal reduction of colloidal silica. The morphology and microstructure of NWs have been studied in detail by electron microscopy techniques. SiC NWs have been found to be hexagonal prisms, “bamboo-like” nanorods and nanobelts. The NWs with a [111] growth axis are hexagonal prism nanorods, while the nanobelts have growth directions varying from [110] to [113]. It has been found that NW growth proceeds in two stages. Initially, SiC crystallites grow on the carbon fiber surface. These crystallites serve as seeds, on which the SiC NWs nucleate and grow. The crystallites containing microtwins and stacking faults (SFs) with a preferential [111] growth direction give rise to the growth of nanorods, while the nanobelts start growing on the (111) facets of relatively perfect crystallites. Wires with core (SiC)–shell (SiO2) structure have been obtained under special temperature treatment in air. The core–shell structure has been confirmed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) mapping techniques.
The morphology of SiC nanocrystals is determined by the synthesis methods. The successful formation of periodically twinned NWs,17 helical NWs,18 wires with periodical bulbs of SiO2 coatings,19 nanotubes,20 three-dimensional nanonets,21 S- and Y-shaped bicrystals22–25 and bicrystalline nanobelts25 has been reported. It should be noted that the [111] growth direction is typical of most NWs including NWs obtained by the carbothermal reduction of silica.2,5–7,17,23,24,26–28 In the case of bicrystalline NWs growth has been observed along [110], [112] or [113] crystallographic axes.22–25
Despite the numerous studies on the synthesis methods, the structure and properties of SiC NWs, little attention is paid in the literature to the mechanisms of NW growth and the structural transformation during the growth process.
We report the results of the investigation of silicon carbide NWs obtained by the carbothermal reduction of SiO2. A combination of analytical electron microscopy techniques such as field-emission electron microscopy (FESEM), high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM), energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) and X-ray powder diffraction (XRD) have been used to study the morphology types and growth stages of SiC NWs in detail.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 The XRD spectrum of the SiC NWs on the carbon felt substrate: indexed peaks, SiC-3C phase, X-peaks due to high density SFs, C, carbon with low crystalline graphite content. |
Fig. 2a shows the FESEM image of the general view of the synthesis product. It is seen that the product consists of wires from 20 to 200 nm in diameter and up to several tens of microns in length. FESEM images in Fig. 2b–e show that the NWs have different types of morphology. From the TEM images in Fig. 2f–i it follows that the wires have a pronounced striped structure which points to the presence of SFs and twins. By and large, three types of NW morphology can be distinguished: nanorods with hexagonal prismatic morphology (Fig. 2b and g); “bamboo-like” nanorods (Fig. 2c and f) and nanobelts (Fig. 2d, e and h) with a rectangle-like cross-section (Fig. 2d and e) and typical aspect ratio 10 (Fig. 2e). In rare cases, Y-shaped bicrystalline wires31 are observed as shown in Fig. 2i. The bicrystal “trunk” is composed of two wires connected along the (111)-3C twinning plane which then branch at 70° corresponding to the angle between the (111)-type planes in the cubic system. A more detailed description of the NW-type structures is given below.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The general view FESEM image of the NWs (a); (b) and (c) FESEM images of single hexagonal prism-shaped and “bamboo-like” nanorods, respectively; (d) and (e) FESEM images of nanobelts; (f)–(i) TEM bright-field images of the NW types. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Nucleation of SiC NWs on a carbon fiber surface: (a) FESEM view of single carbon fiber; (b) and (c) EDX mapping of the carbon fiber according to the emission line; (d), (e) and (f) FESEM images of SiC NWs on the carbon fiber surface. |
Fig. 3e and f present FESEM images of the NWs grown from SiC crystallites. From Fig. 3e it is seen that the crystallites show a high density of SFs and become gradually narrower in the direction perpendicular to the SFs and, hence, the close-packed {111} layers. Further growth proceeds as a thin nanorod along the [111]-3C crystallographic direction. It is seen that the original crystallites have a preferred growth direction perpendicular to the {111} layers. It can be assumed that the growth of nanorods starts when the size of a (111) plane reaches some minimum value. Another example (Fig. 3f) shows nanobelt growth. In this case, the nanobelt starts to grow on one of the {111} facets of relatively perfect 3C-SiC crystallites without any preferred orientation. Compared to the previous example, the close-packed planes are inclined at an angle to the direction of growth and, as a result, the axis of belt-like wire growth differs from the [111]-3C crystallographic direction.
The carbon felt substrate used for the deposition of silicon carbide nanowires consists of large carbon fibers 5–8 microns in diameter (Fig. 4a). Fig. 4b shows a magnified FESEM image of the initial carbon fiber before the synthesis of SiC NWs. It is seen that the fiber surface is not smooth, rather it is covered with sphere-shaped hillocks ∼20–50 nm in size. The hillocks are randomly distributed over the surface of the carbon fiber. It can be assumed that the hillocks can serve as templates for nucleation of future SiC NWs.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Carbon fibers: (a) FESEM image of the carbon fiber before synthesis; (b) magnified view of the carbon fiber surface. |
Such nucleation and growth behavior of SiC NWs is explained by their growth mechanism. For instance, the first stage of the carbothermal reduction of silicon dioxide generates gaseous silicon monoxide by reaction (1):
SiO2(solid) + C(solid) → SiO(vapor) + CO(vapor) | (1) |
Silicon monoxide vapors are carried to the crucible cover (felt) and react with the carbon on the carbon fiber surface to form SiC crystallites by reaction (2):
SiO(vapor) + 2C(hillock) → SiC(nanoparticles) + CO(vapor) | (2) |
In accordance with ref. 32, it can be assumed that it is the hillocks (Fig. 3b) on the carbon fibers that act as reducing agents and templates in the formation of SiC nanoparticles by reaction (2). However, reaction (2) does not ensure the growth of SiC nanowires. SiC crystallites formed by reaction (2) serve as nuclei and control the diameter of SiC NWs. Nanowires grow by reaction (3) under the conditions of CO vapor saturation:
SiO(vapor) + 3CO(vapor) → SiC(solid) + 2CO2(vapor) | (3) |
The condition of oversaturation of CO vapors in reaction (3) is critical since under equilibrium thermodynamic conditions this reaction cannot occur at 1400 °C.6
The gaseous CO2 phase formed by reaction (3) changes to a gaseous CO phase by reaction (4):
CO2(vapor) + C(solid) → 2CO(vapor) | (4) |
It has been shown32 that reactions (3) and (4) are related by positive feedback which finally leads to local oversaturation of the CO vapors. As it is known,33,34 in the oversaturation conditions growth occurs in the kinetic mode to form crystals and dendrites. In those conditions the (111) SiC face has the lowest surface energy. In the course of reaction (3) the silicon and carbon atoms are deposited on the SiC crystallite surface and most of them move to the face with the lowest (111) surface energy.6 In our case the existing mechanisms of formation and growth of nanowires from one-dimensional carbon nanotubes35 or metal catalysts36 with the use of templates turned out to be ineffective.
Yet, the mechanism of growth of nanowires along the [111] direction by the SiO and CO vapor reaction in the oversaturation conditions allows the explaination of most of their morphological and structural features, such as NW curvature, the presence of stacking faults and the phenomenon of NW branching.32
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 TEM images of a “bamboo-like” nanorod: (a) [−110] axis zone SAED pattern; (b) dark field TEM image in the (002) beam; (c) dark field TEM image in the (11−1) twin beam. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 The “bamboo-like” nanorod microstructure: (a) TEM image of the twin domain part of the “bamboo-like” rod; (b) HRTEM image of the twin domain of the wire circled in (a) with the corresponding FFT pattern inserted in the right bottom corner; (c) HRTEM image of both defect-free (1) and defect-containing (2) regions of the SiC nanorod with the corresponding FFT patterns. |
The HRTEM image of the twin domain part shows that they have a perfect 3C-structure (Fig. 6 b).
The inset presents the FFT (fast Fourier transform) pattern containing only diffraction spots for the [−110]-zone axis which confirms the absence of defects in this rod section. The crystallographic directions of the side boundaries correspond to the [112] and [110] directions, but due to the twinned structure of the “bamboo-like” nanorods, the average growth axis coincides with the [111] direction. Along with the perfect 3C domains there are segments with a high density of SFs in the “bamboo-like” nanorods. Below Fig. 6c shows the HRTEM image of the region with both defect-free (1) and defect-containing (2) segments, the white lines indicate the {111} planes. The inset in the lower left corner shows the FFT pattern of segment (1) which is identical to that presented in Fig. 6b and reflects the absence of defects in the 3C-structure of the segment. The FFT pattern of the defect-containing segment (2) is shown in the upper left corner. It contains both diffraction spots and streaks which correspond to high density of SFs. The streaks in the FFT pattern are perpendicular to the {111} atomic planes of part (2) and, hence, the growth direction of the narrow defect segments coincides with the [111]-direction.
Thus, the wide segments of the “bamboo-like” nanorods are the twin domains of the 3C-structure connected by narrow segments with a high density of SFs. The average growth axis of the “bamboo-like” nanorod coincides with the crystallographic direction of the [111]-3C-structure.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 The hexagonal prism SiC nanorod: (a) low magnification HRTEM image of a “smooth” SiC rod with a [111] growth direction; (b) HRTEM image of a wire showing high density or SFs; (d) magnification of the framed area shown in (b); (c) an example of a perfect 3C sequence. |
Fig. 8 presents a HRTEM image of the nanobelts (white lines denote {111} planes) containing a defect-free region. The corresponding FFT pattern contains the diffraction pattern typical of the 3C twins, [−110] zone axis. Considering the above “bamboo-like” wires, it has been shown (see Fig. 6b) that the side boundaries of the defect-free 3C twin domains are directed along [110] and [112], respectively. Analysis of the HRTEM image shows that the side boundary of the bottom twin domain has a [110] direction and that of the upper domain a [112] direction, respectively, but the average growth axis of the nanobelt coincides with the [112] direction which indicates that domains with the [112] side boundary direction are dominant. Thus, the SiC nanobelts exhibit a relatively low density of SFs due to the presence of the defect-free 3C twin domains that determine the orientation of the close-packed planes and, as a result, the average belt axis coincides with the [110] or [112] directions of the 3C-structure.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Nanobelts with a low density of SFs: HRTEM image of a defect-free nanobelt segment and the corresponding FFT pattern is inserted in the top left corner. |
Fig. 9 shows TEM images of another type of SiC nanobelt. Fig. 9a and b present the dark-field TEM image of the nanobelt from the (002) diffraction beam and the corresponding SAED pattern. From the SAED pattern it is seen that the growth direction of the nanobelt coincides with the [331] crystallographic direction for the 3C-structure. The presence of streaks along the [111] direction in the electron diffraction pattern points to a high density of SFs which is also confirmed by the pronounced striped structure of the nanobelt (Fig. 9a). Fig. 9c and d present the TEM image of the nanobelt and the corresponding SAED pattern indicating the [113] growth direction for this nanobelt and the presence of a high density of SFs. Common to these two cases are the extra diffraction spots (indicated by the arrows) in the SAED patterns (Fig. 9b and d) related to the hexagonal polytypes. The extra reflection intensity exceeds the intensity of the 3C-reflections, which suggests a prevalent hexagonal polytype content in these nanobelts.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 Nanobelts with a high density of SFs: (a) dark-field image of a NW with a [331] growth axis obtained in a (002) beam and the corresponding SAED pattern with a [−110] zone axis (b); (c) a dark field image of a NW with a [113] growth axis obtained in (002) beam and the corresponding SAED pattern with a [−110] zone axis (d) (arrows in the electron diffraction pattern denote the reflections of the hexagonal polytypes); (e) HRTEM image of a SiC nanobelt segment with the corresponding FFT pattern inserted in the top left corner; (f) a magnified HRTEM image of the framed area shown in (e) (the inset marked by the dashed line is a model of 2H-structure). |
Fig. 9e shows the HRTEM image of the nanobelt with the [331] growth direction axis. In the upper left corner the corresponding FFT pattern contains diffraction spots related to the hexagonal structure. Fig. 9f presents the magnified HRTEM image of the region framed in Fig. 9e. Analysis of the sequence of the close-packed layers revealed that the sequence can be attributed to the 2H-structure with SFs. For comparison, the model of the 2H-structure is shown in the frame marked by the dashed line. It is seen that the experimental and model patterns are in full agreement with one another.
Therefore, nanobelts with a high density of SFs grow along the [113] and [331] crystallographic directions of the cubic system. It should be noted that these nanobelts contain 3C as well as 2H polytypes with a dominant content of the latter. Fig. 10a–c show the bright- and dark-field TEM images and the SAED pattern for the NW exhibiting the change in growth direction from [111] to [331]. The NW segment with the [111] growth direction has hexagonal prism morphology, an example of the cross-section of such a NW type is shown in Fig. 2b. The extensionality of the segment is indicated by the thickness contour covering the middle of the wire and is seen as a dark line on the bright-field image (Fig. 10a). The segment with the [331] growth direction has nanobelt morphology. It has been shown that the nanobelt is a rectangle with a side ratio of about 10 (Fig. 2e). The small thickness of the nanobelts can be explained by the fact that the formation of high-index side facets leads to a significant increase of plane surface energy which, as it is known,37 is minimal for {111}-type facets. The increase of specific surface energy is compensated by the reduction of the side facets surface area. It can be assumed that upon transformation from the hexagonal prism to the thin plate the cross-section area of the nanowire does not change much.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 SiC wire with a change of growth direction: (a) and (b) bright and dark field images of the NW with a changed growth axis and the corresponding SAED pattern with [−110] zone axis (c). |
The most common morphological type of SiC NW is a hexagonal prism with the [111] growth axis. The density of SFs and twins throughout the NW length depends on the kinetic growth conditions. As was mentioned above, the hexagonal prisms nucleate and grow on the SiC crystallites with the [111] preferential growth direction and a high density of SFs and microtwins. The cross section of the crystallites gradually reduces and at some critical size the SiC nanowire starts to grow further. Generally such a kind of growth behavior of the nanowires is described by a screw dislocation growth mechanism.41
The hexagonal prism can be occasionally observed to transform to a rectangular nanobelt with a changed in the growth direction. In the case where SiC nanobelts exhibit a relatively low SF density, which is due to the presence of a certain type of defect-free 3C-structure twin domain, the mean direction of the wire axis coincides with either the [110] or [112] direction of the 3C-structure. Nanobelts with a high SF density grow in directions coinciding with the [113] and [331] directions of the cubic system. Such nanobelts contain both 3C and 2H polytypes, the latter predominating. The transformation of the wire morphology is related to the change of the growth kinetics, its reasons, however, are not completely understood. Since the formation of such high index side facets as {112}, {113} and {331} involves a considerable increase in the surface energy of the growth plane, it can be assumed that the change of the NW geometry into a high aspect ratio rectangular belt low-indexed [110] wide facet and narrow high-indexed facets takes place to avoid the increase in the surface energy.
The “bamboo-like” nanorods demonstrate randomly alternating wide and narrow regions. HRTEM analysis of this structure revealed that wide regions have a defect-free 3C-SiC lattice. The narrow regions are filled with SFs. The irregularity of the region alternation points to the intermittent nature of the growth conditions. This holds for supersaturation as the temperature throughout the whole process remained constant. As the NWs grow in the supersaturated conditions in reaction (3), it would be logical to assume that the growth of the wide regions resulted from moderate supersaturation while the growth of the narrow regions occurred upon high supersaturation. The latter brought about a considerable structure imperfection.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 (a) Bright-field TEM image of the annealed wire with core (SiC)–shell (SiO2) structure; (b) EDX mapping of the annealed SiC wire according to the emission line and (c) EDX mapping of the initial “bare” SiC wire according to the emission line. |
The annealing of NWs at 850 °C for 4 h in air leads to the formation of a core (SiC)–shell (SiO2) structure. The diversity of SiC NW morphology opens up a lot of opportunities for the investigation of the influence of the nanowire structure on the electrophysical, catalytic and sensory properties of nanowires.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |