Rui
Wang
a,
Hong
He
*a,
Li-Cheng
Liu
a,
Hong-Xing
Dai
a and
Zhen
Zhao
b
aCollege of Environmental and Energy Engineering, Beijing University of Technology, Beijing 100124, People's Republic of China. E-mail: hehong@bjut.edu.cn; Fax: +86 010 67391983; Tel: +86 010 67396588
bState Key Laboratory of Heavy Oil Processing, China University of Petroleum, Beijing 102249, People's Republic of China. E-mail: zhenzhao@cup.edu.cn; Fax: +86 010 69724721; Tel: +86 010 69724721
First published on 23rd November 2011
It is of great interest to study the shape effect on the catalytic activity of metal nanocrystals, which exposed different crystallographic facets upon adopting various shapes. The investigations on shape-dependent catalysis of supported metal nanocrystals need to be conducted over nanocrystals with well-defined shapes and cleaned surface. The palladium nanocrystals with cubic, octahedral, and spherical morphologies were synthesized and well dispersed onto the inert silica support after removing the capping agents, which were used as the heterogeneous catalysts for carbon monoxide (CO) oxidation. It was found that the crystal facets of Pd nanoparticles played an essential role in determining the catalytic oxidation properties. As a result, the octahedral and spherical nanoparticles that predominantly exposed the Pd {111} crystal facets exhibited significantly better catalytic activity than the palladium nanocubes that possessed the Pd {100} crystal facets as the basal plane for the CO catalytic oxidation. It was inferred that the appropriate adsorption strength of CO molecules on Pd {111} planes was beneficial to the enhancement of the catalytic activity.
In recent years, many investigations on the shape-independent effect of metal nanocrystals were focused on the Pt-based catalysts, which were performed on the facets of Pt polyhedral nanocrystals. For instance, El-Sayed and coworkers4 investigated the influence of the particle shape on the catalytic activity and stability of Pt nanocrystals for the Suzuki cross-coupling reaction between phenylboronic acid and iodobenzene. They discovered that the average rate constant of the reaction increased exponentially as the percentage of surface atoms at the corners and edges increased. Meanwhile, Somorjai and coworkers5a conducted the research on the catalytic activity of Pt nanocrystals for hydrogenation reactions. They found that, similar to single crystals, only cyclohexane could be obtained over the Pt nanocubes enclosed by {100} planes, whereas both cyclohexane and cyclohexene were produced over the cuboctahedrons enclosed by both {111} and {100} planes. They also found that Pt nanocubes enhanced the ring-opening ability and showed a higher selectivity to n-butylamine as compared to nanopolyhedra for pyrrole hydrogenation.5b Besides, Zaera's work6 had shown that the cis–trans isomerization selectivity of 2-butene was quite different on the Pt tetrahedron enclosed with {111} planes as compared to Pt cubes enclosed with {100} planes. Moreover, Mostafa and coworkers7 observed a correlation between the number of uncoordinated atoms at the Pt nanoparticle surface and the light-off temperature for 2-propanol oxidation. There are also a few reports on the shape-dependent catalysis of other precious metal nanocrystals8–10 (like Au,8 Ag9 and Rh10), all of which presented some close relationship between shapes and the catalytic properties of metal nanocrystals. It has been shown that by tuning the crystalline shapes and altering the exposed facets on the surface of metal nanocrystals, the catalytic properties of metal nanocrystals could be greatly regulated.
As a kind of widely used metal catalyst, Pd has been proved to be effective for low-temperature elimination of automobile pollutants, hydrogenation reaction and carbon–carbon bond reforming reactions, such as Suzuki coupling,11 with much lower price than platinum. In the last few years, several studies were reported on the progress of the “Pd shape-electrocatalysis” correlation.12 However, the related research on the shape-dependent effect of Pd nanocrystals is still much less reported as compared to Pt nanocrystals, and the “Pd shape-catalysis” correlation still needs more comprehensive understanding especially in the heterogeneous catalysis field. In recent years, based on the groundwork of Xia and Niu et al.,13–17 the shape-controlled synthesis of Pd nanocrystals has gained much progress. Multiple shapes (such as cube,13,14 octahedron,14,15 decahedron,15 icosahedron,15 hexagonal/triangular plate,16 bar/rod17 and sphere,18etc.) of Pd nanocrystals have been obtained in an aqueous or polyol system. Some of the synthesis strategies are eco-friendly and highly reproducible, which are quite appropriate for the manufacture of heterogeneous catalysts loaded with well-shaped Pd nanocrystals.13,18
In this study, the Pd nanocrystals with cubic and octahedral morphologies, which are typically enclosed by equivalent {100} and {111} facets, respectively, were synthesized and supported on SiO2 as the model catalysts. The spherical Pd nanoparticles were also prepared as a reference shape considering that Pd nanospheres are now widely utilized in the practical catalysis industry. To obtain the clean surface of the Pd nanocrystals with the reservation of the typical shapes, the “deposition–redispersion” strategy was adopted instead of the calcination treatment (see the Experimental section). The CO oxidation experiments showed that the shape of Pd nanocrystals had a significant influence on the catalytic activities of the supported Pd catalysts. The CO adsorption and desorption behavior were also found to be quite different over the three Pd nanocrystals.
Fig. 1 shows the TEM and HRTEM images of the as-synthesized Pd nanocrystals with three different shapes. The insets in Fig. 1a and c are the representative sketches of the typical cubic and octahedral shapes. It was obvious that the three Pd nanocrystals possessed cubic (Fig. 1a), octahedral (Fig. 1c), and spherical (Fig. 1e) morphologies, respectively. Meanwhile, the HRTEM images of a single Pd nanocube (Fig. 1b) and octahedron (Fig. 1d) presented their typical shape features. Fig. 1f exhibited clearly the lattice fringes of Pd nanospheres with a spacing of 0.228 nm, which was quite consistent with that of the Pd {111} planes. Meanwhile, the corresponding SAED patterns (Fig. S2 in ESI†) of the cubic and octahedral Pd nanocrystals also revealed the exposed {100} and {111} planes. The average sizes of the cubic, octahedral and spherical Pd nanoparticles were 20.5 ± 2.3 nm (diagonal), 22.4 ± 1.6 nm (vertex to vertex), and 3.9 ± 0.5 nm (diameter), respectively, and the detailed size distributions are presented in Fig. S1 in ESI.† The percentage of Pd cubes was 90% (6% irregular shapes, 4% bars), whereas the proportion of Pd octahedra was 78% (14% irregular shapes, 8% triangles). A better overall view of the shape of the cubic and octahedral Pd nanocrystals could also be seen in the SEM images (Fig. S3 in ESI†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 TEM and HRTEM images of Pd nanocrystals with the shape of cube (a, b), octahedron (c, d), and sphere (e, f). The insets show the corresponding representative sketches of the typical shapes. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 TEM images of as-prepared (a) Pd (cube)/SiO2, (b) Pd (octahedron)/SiO2, and (c) Pd (sphere)/SiO2 catalysts. |
The silica support (fumed silica) here was a kind of amorphous SiO2 with no porous structures and the Pd nanocrystals were largely deposited on the outer surface of silica. Meanwhile, the elemental analysis results showed that the actual Pd loading was ca. 2.9 wt% for all supported catalysts (the theoretical Pd loading is 3.0 wt%) as listed in Table S1 in ESI†, which indicated the successful supporting process to minimize the metal loss. The Pd dispersion was also measured by CO chemisorption and the results (>60%) showed that the Pd nanoparticles were well-dispersed on the surface of the silica support (Table S1 in ESI†).
The XRD patterns of the three as-obtained palladium nanocrystals are shown in Fig. 3. All of the peaks can be indexed to the face-centered cubic (fcc) palladium metal phase (JCPDS card No. 89-4897). The three peaks detected for the Pd nanoparticles could be assigned to diffraction from the {111}, {200} and {220} planes of metallic palladium, respectively. The XRD pattern of Pd nanocubes showed an abnormally intense {200} peak (Fig. 3a), suggesting that a relatively large proportion of the palladium nanocubes were oriented with the {100} facets parallel to the substrate. For the Pd octahedra, an overwhelmingly intensive peak located at 2θ = 40° corresponding to the diffraction of the {111} lattice plane of the fcc structure was detected (Fig. 3b), whereas the peaks arising from other planes were quite weak, indicating that the (111) planes of Pd octahedra were also highly oriented. Meanwhile, the widening of the diffraction peaks for the Pd nanospheres (Fig. 3c) could be observed, which was consistent with the much smaller particle size of the spherical Pd particles (∼4 nm).
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 XRD patterns of (a) Pd (cube)/SiO2, (b) Pd (octahedron)/SiO2, and (c) Pd (sphere)/SiO2 catalysts. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 CO oxidation activity over (a) Pd (cube)/SiO2, (b) Pd (octahedron)/SiO2, and (c) Pd (sphere)/SiO2 catalysts with 1.0% CO and 1.0% O2 in N2 at a space velocity of 32.4 mL s−1 g−1. |
In order to further study the intrinsic catalytic properties, the apparent activation energies of the CO oxidation reaction of the three Pd/SiO2 catalysts were calculated and shown in Fig. S5 and Table S1 in ESI†, which were 76.5, 52.9 and 42.6 kJ mol−1 for cubic, octahedral, and spherical Pd supported catalysts, respectively. The results indicated that the Pd (sphere)/SiO2 catalyst with the lowest activation energy showed the best catalytic performance, while the Pd (cube)/SiO2 with the highest activation energy showed relatively poor catalytic activity, which was quite consistent with the experimental results above. Besides, the specific TOF values based on Pd dispersion and related data are also given in Table S1 in ESI†, showing quite different reaction rates on the surface of Pd particles with different shapes.
It is worth noting that the particle size of the Pd spheres (∼4 nm) was much smaller than the other two Pd nanocrystals (∼20 nm). According to related reports, the metal nanoparticle size could have a noticeable influence on the CO oxidation activity, which was conducted over the two-dimensional nanoparticles array system.1b,c To examine the size effect in our evaluation system, a controlled experiment was conducted over Pd (sphere)/SiO2 with different sizes, which were synthesized based on Piao's work.18 Both the TEM images (Fig. S6 in ESI†) and size distributions (Fig. S7 in ESI†) of related samples proved the successful synthesis of three Pd spheres with average sizes of 3.9 nm, 7.5 nm and 9.6 nm, respectively. These Pd nanospheres with different sizes were then evaluated for CO oxidation activity in the same system as mentioned above. Interestingly, the size effect in our system was not quite remarkable. The CO oxidation activities were nearly the same for Pd (sphere)/SiO2 with different sizes (see Fig. S8 in ESI†). Therefore, it could be deduced that the size effect of Pd nanocrystals on the CO oxidation activity is limited under our experimental conditions.
Up to now, many researchers have reported that the catalytic properties of metal nanocrystals could be influenced by tuning the exposed crystal planes of the nanocrystals. Markovic et al.19 found that Pt {111} planes presented better catalytic activity than Pt {100} planes in the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), while Kondo et al.20 and Xia et al.12a demonstrated that Pd crystal planes exhibited an opposite trend with a much better activity on Pd {100} than Pd {111} planes. Herein, based on the previous studies mentioned above, the CO-TPD experiments were conducted to study the CO adsorption and desorption on the different Pd/SiO2 catalyst surfaces for further exploration of the correlation between the CO oxidation activity and the Pd nanocrystals’ morphology.
The CO-TPD profiles of related samples are shown in Fig. 5. As comparison to the supported Pd catalysts, a controlled experiment was conducted on bare SiO2 and only a single TPD peak at ca. 70 °C was observed (Fig. 5a), which corresponded to CO desorption from the SiO2 support surface. For the Pd loaded samples (Fig. 5b–d), the CO desorption peaks at a similar low temperature range (52/53 °C) were observed, which could also be assigned to CO desorption from the SiO2 support. For Pd (octahedron)/SiO2 (Fig. 5c) and Pd (sphere)/SiO2 catalysts (Fig. 5d), an extra CO desorption peak with strong intensity was found at higher temperatures of 394 and 324 °C, respectively, which should be assigned to the desorption of CO adsorbed on Pd nanocrystals.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 CO-TPD spectra of the (a) SiO2, (b) Pd (cube)/SiO2, (c) Pd (octahedron)/SiO2, and (d) Pd (sphere)/SiO2 catalysts. The inset shows the corresponding CO2 desorption profiles on the surface of three different catalysts and SiO2. |
However, in the case of Pd (cube)/SiO2, the CO desorption at high temperature exhibited a very weak and broad feature in the range of 250–500 °C. To further determine the interaction between CO molecules and Pd (cube)/SiO2, a temperature dependent DRIFT experiment was employed (Fig. S9 in ESI†). The IR band at ca. 1940 cm−1 could be assigned to the bridged CO species. It was also found that the adsorption peak position changed with a red-shift from 1940 cm−1 to 1878 cm−1 with a decrease in the peak intensity as the temperature ramped. The phenomena above indicated that the CO species were bridged adsorbed on Pd {100} facets over Pd (cube)/SiO2, and when the temperature reached ca. 250 °C, the CO began to desorb from the Pd cube surface. This observation confirmed that the peak between 250–500 °C was attributed to the CO desorption from the {100} facets of Pd cubes.
Considering the morphology of three Pd/SiO2 catalysts, the remarkable difference in thermal desorption temperature of CO molecules from Pd nanoparticles could be ascribed to the different exposed facets on the Pd polyhedra. For Pd (octahedron)/SiO2 and Pd (sphere)/SiO2 catalysts, the high intensity and desorption temperature (394 °C and 324 °C) originated from the strong interaction between CO and {111} facets of Pd octahedra and spheres, while the small adsorption capacity of the broad peak at 250–500 °C over Pd (cube)/SiO2 suggested the weak interaction between CO and Pd {100} facet of nanocubes, which was not sufficient to activate the adsorbed CO molecules and resulted in the poorest CO oxidation activity among the three catalysts.
Meanwhile, it was noteworthy that Pd (octahedron)/SiO2 presented a higher CO desorption temperature (394 °C) than Pd (sphere)/SiO2 (324 °C), indicating that the CO chemisorption on the Pd octahedron was more stable than on the Pd spheres. This phenomenon could be originated from the difference in particle sizes of the two Pd nanoparticles, which had no obvious influence on the CO oxidation activity as discussed earlier.
The adsorption of CO on Pd {100} and Pd {111} facets on a single crystal had been extensively studied under ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) conditions in the past decades.21 Bradshaw et al.21a found that thermal desorption temperature of CO on Pd {100} was mainly at 400–600 K. Goodman21c and Yates21eet al. also reported that the CO desorbed on Pd {100} and Pd {111} in a similar temperature region. The results of CO-TPD experiments on Pd nanocrystals in our group showed that CO desorption temperature was slightly higher than that reported by the references mentioned above, suggesting stronger and more stable CO adsorption on Pd nanocrystal facets. Meanwhile, Goodman and Szanyi21b found that the apparent activation energy for CO oxidation is 122.3 kJ mol−1 on the Pd {100} surface of a single crystal, which was higher than that (76.5 kJ mol−1) obtained on Pd cubic nanocrystals in our experiments. The lower apparent activation energy and higher CO desorption temperature over the Pd nanocrystals than over Pd single crystals could be attributed to an increase in the number of Pd atoms at the corners and edges of the Pd nanocrystals.
Based on the investigations, one can conclude that Pd octahedra and spheres that exposed mainly Pd {111} planes were more active towards CO oxidation than Pd cubes enclosed by Pd {100} planes, demonstrating that the exposed facets of Pd nanocrystals with different shapes have a significant effect on the adsorption and desorption properties of CO molecules, and consequently influence the CO catalytic oxidation activity.
Additionally, the CO2 desorption profiles (inset in Fig. 5) exhibited a quite similar trend with that of CO species. The CO2 molecules originated from the CO disproportionation reaction: 2CO (g) → CO2 (g) + C (s), which was favored on metallic Pd surfaces according to the previous studies.22,23
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c2cy00417h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |