Marta
Quintanilla
*a,
Nuria O.
Núñez
b,
Eugenio
Cantelar
a,
Manuel
Ocaña
b and
Fernando
Cussó
a
aDepartamento de Física de Materiales (Módulo 04), Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, C/Francisco Tomás y Valiente, 7, 28049, Madrid, Spain. E-mail: marta.quintanilla@uam.es; Fax: +34 91 497 85 79; Tel: +34 91 497 24 50
bInstituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Sevilla, CSIC-US, Américo Vespucio 49, Isla de la Cartuja, 41092, Sevilla, Spain. E-mail: mjurado@icmse.csic.es; Fax: +34 95 446 06 65; Tel: +34 95 448 95 33
First published on 13th December 2010
Monodisperse YF3:Tm3+/Yb3+ nanocrystals have been synthesized to explore the visible up-converting properties under near infrared (975 nm) excitation. It has been found that the nanoparticles exhibit intense red up-converted emissions, in addition to the characteristic UV and blue Tm3+-bands. It is demonstrated that, by carefully selecting Tm3+ and Yb3+ contents, the relative intensity of the different emissions can be changed producing an overall emission colour that can be tuned from blue to magenta.
Rare-earth (RE) based up-conversion nanophosphors are based on the combination of ion pairs acting as sensitizers–activators that allow a variety of excitation–emission choices.
Among all the studied lanthanide doped materials, the fluorides family (NaYF4, LaF3, YF3, …) are the materials considered as the best hosts for efficient up-conversion,12 favoured by the low phonon energy of these materials, which enhance the luminescence efficiency of RE dopants.13 Therefore, a great research effort has been done to develop synthesis routes to obtain uniform nanoparticles of those materials,14–18 and to study the relationship between shape, size and dopant concentration with the optical properties.19,20
In particular, Yb-activated materials are extensively used because of its convenient near IR absorption band, accessible by commercially available diode-lasers, and its efficient sensitization of several emitting rare earths (Er3+, Tm3+, …). Depending on the particular ion used as activator different emissions can be obtained: Er3+ ions are selected as a standard green and red emitters, while Tm3+ ions are chosen as blue emitters.
Along this line, there are a number of recent studies devoted to Yb3+/Tm3+ co-doped fluoride hosts,16,21,22 including YF3:Yb3+/Tm3+nanoparticles.17,23–29 Nevertheless, in this material the emissions seem to be restricted to the high energy side of the spectrum. Enhanced UV and blue up-converted emissions have been reported23–26 but they exhibit negligible emissions in the lower energy spectral range. At variance, it has been recently reported19 for monodisperse β-NaYF4:Yb3+/Tm3+ the appearance of sizeable red emissions, which have not been observed before in YF3. It is also noteworthy that the YF3:Yb3+/Tm3+ synthesis procedures reported in previous works led, in most cases, to particles with irregular shape and heterogeneous size, both in the nanometre or micrometre size range. In fact, to our knowledge, only the procedure developed by Wang et al.27 (based in the use of microemulsions), led to truly uniform Tm3+-based nanophosphors with octahedral shape and a mean size of about 100 nm.
In the present work we have synthesised YF3:Yb3+/Tm3+ uniform nanophosphors with rhombic shape and reported, for the first time, that they present efficient red up-converted emission, in addition to the well known UV-blue emissions. Furthermore the overall emission characteristics can be controlled and tuned by changing the relative concentration of the RE-dopants. The bright up-conversion emissions, both in the UV-blue and the red spectral region, make them suitable for biological applications.
For the synthesis of the uniform YF3:Tm3+/Yb3+ nanocrystals with rhombic shape and different doping levels, we have used a simple and environmentally friendly procedure, previously developed by us to produce YF3 down-conversion (Eu3+ or Tb3+ doped) phosphors,15 which has been properly modified for the preparation of Yb3+/Tm3+ co-doped YF3.
After ageing, the resulting dispersions were cooled down to room temperature, centrifuged to remove the supernatants and washed, twice with ethanol and once with double distilled water. The powders were then dried at 50 °C and annealed for 20 min at 400 °C. In the case of YF3:Er3+/Yb3+ nanoparticles prepared by a similar procedure, this treatment has been proven to be adequate to eliminate residual OH−groups, resulting in enhanced fluorescence properties, while preserving the size and shape of the nanocrystals.30
The composition of the precipitated particles was assessed by energy dispersive X-ray analysis (EDX, Philips DX4) coupled to the TEM microscope. In order to obtain structural information on the prepared nanoparticles, we used X-ray diffraction (XRD, Siemens D501). Unit cell parameters were measured by Rietveld refinement of the XRD data using the X'Pert HighScore Plus software.
The optical measurements for powdered pressed samples were performed using a JENOPTIK laser diode source at 980 nm to excite the Yb3+ ions with different excitation powers. The visible Tm3+ luminescence was dispersed by using an ARC Spectrapro 500-I monochromator and then detected with an ultraviolet enhanced photomultiplier tube (Thorn Emi QB9558).
In order to achieve reproducible and comparative luminescence spectra, all the data have been taken using a standard experimental arrangement, including specially design sample holders. They were constructed using a 1 mm thick PMMA spacer with a 2 mm diameter circular opening, enclosed by two microscope slide covers. The nanopowders were introduced filling the cavity, which was placed in a fixed mounting on the top of a micrometre stage, in order to optimize the luminescence signal.
The diode laser beam was limited by a diaphragm assuring that the excitation area was smaller than the exposed sample area. The sample holder can be removed and replaced into this arrangement without altering the geometry.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 TEM image of the YF3:Yb3+ (10%)/Tm3+ (2%) sample showing the homogeneity and size of the particles. |
Fig. 2 shows the EDX spectra measured for a sample with composition YF3:Yb3+ (10%)/Tm3+ (2%) chosen as a representative example. As observed, the main peaks corresponding to F, Y, Yb and Tm were detected confirming the incorporation of the doping cations to the YF3 nanoparticles. It should be also noted that the EDX spectra recorded for several single particles were almost identical, pointing towards a high degree of chemical homogeneity in the sample, at least at the particle level.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 EDX spectrum for the YF3:Yb3+ (10%)/Tm3+ (2%) sample. The most intense peak for each element has been labelled. |
The XRD pattern of the samples indicated that the nanoparticles were well crystallized and consisted of orthorhombic YF3 (JCPDS file no. 32-1431), as illustrated in Fig. 3 for the sample shown in Fig. 1. Finally, the comparison of the unit cell parameters measured for a nanophosphor sample having a high Tm3+ content (for a better observation of the changes) with those of an undoped sample (Table 1) clearly manifests the formation of a solid solution between the doping cations and the YF3 host. Thus, a contraction of the YF3 unit cell was detected for the phosphor nanoparticles which is in agreement with the smaller size of Tm3+ (0.87 Å) and Yb3+ cations (0.858 Å) when compared with that of Y3+ (0.893 Å).31
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 X-Ray diffraction pattern for the YF3:Yb3+ (10%)/Tm3+ (2%) sample. The reference pattern for orthorhombic YF3 (JCPDS 32-1431) is also included. |
a/Å | b/Å | c/Å | V/Å3 | |
---|---|---|---|---|
YF3 | 6.347(1) | 6.871(1) | 4.432(1) | 193.31 |
YF3:Yb3+ (10%)/Tm3+ (5%) | 6.310(1) | 6.853(1) | 4.445(1) | 192.23 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Energy level scheme showing the different energy transfer processes responsible for the generation of UV and visible light emission in Tm3+/Yb3+ systems after excitation at Yb3+ ions. |
It is possible a further step to populate an even higher energy level of thulium, 1D2, although in this case the exact mechanism is not yet fully elucidated. Different processes have been proposed to explain the way this level can be excited: on one hand, it has been proposed a fourth energy transfer involving Yb3+ ions as sensitizers and, alternatively, several Tm3+ → Tm3+ internal cross-relaxation processes have been invoked.21,23,35,36
The proposed fourth energy transfer, 2F5/2 → 2F7/2 (Yb3+):1G4 → 1D2 (Tm3+), is highly non-resonant, involving a large energy mismatch between the different transitions: ΔE ≈ 3300 cm−1, so that it seems to be an unlikely process in a host with low phonon such as YF3 (Eph ≈ 514 cm−1).13 Therefore, Tm3+ → Tm3+ resonant energy transfer processes (1G4 → 3H6:3F4 → 1D2; 3F2,3 → 3H6:3H4 → 1D2 and 3H4 → 3H6:3F2,3 → 1D2) seem to be more plausible mechanisms to populate 1D2 energy level21,23. These processes have been depicted in Fig. 4b.
Then, after Yb3+ excitation, different Tm3+ multiplets are populated and it is possible to observe several emissions from the near ultraviolet to near IR spectral range. The emission spectrum, obtained after excitation at 975 nm (coincident with the maximum absorption cross-section wavelength of ytterbium ions in YF3), is presented in Fig. 5. This particular example corresponds to nanoparticles with dopants concentration: [Tm3+] = 2 mol%; [Yb3+] = 20 mol% and it has been recorded in the spectral region between 300 nm and 900 nm. As it can be observed, there appear different bands in the ultraviolet, blue, red and near IR regions, which originate from the Tm3+ excited states: 3H4, 3F2,3, 1G4 and 1D2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Emission spectrum of a YF3:Tm3+/Yb3+ ([Tm3+] = 2 mol%, [Yb3+] = 20 mol%) sample under excitation at ytterbium ions. |
All the transitions have been labelled in the figure according to the general assignment of thulium emissions, and, for the sake of clearness, they are also depicted in Fig. 4 as double arrows. As it can be seen, the near IR emission, centred at ∼800 nm originates from the 3H4 → 3H6 transition, the emissions centred at ∼650 nm and ∼476 nm are both due to emissions from 1G4 level (1G4 → 3F4 and 1G4 → 3H6 transitions, respectively) and the emissions centred at ∼450 nm and ∼363 nm arise from 1D2 level (1D2 → 3F4 and 1D2 → 3H6 transitions, respectively). This spectrum is similar to that reported for different authors16,21,24,26 although in this case a non-negligible red emission, at around 700 nm, ascribed to the 3F2,3 → 3H6 transition, is also clearly visible. This emission has been rarely observed in YF3:Yb3+/Tm3+nanoparticles but its significance has been recently pointed out in NaYF4:Yb3+/Tm3+nanoparticles.19
Information about the processes involved in the UC emissions can be achieved from the dependence of the intensity of the different emission bands as a function of the IR excitation power. This dependence brings information on the up-conversion mechanisms, as it is related to the number of photons needed for the successive up-conversion processes.37
In the simplest situation, the power dependence would indicate the number, n, of photons (UC-steps) involved in the process. Nevertheless, it is often found a saturation effect which reduces the experimental power dependence. In these cases the slope values provided by the emission intensity versus excitation power graph represent just a lower limit of the number of photons involved in the population process.37
The experimental power dependences of the up-converted Tm3+ emissions are presented in Fig. 6. As it can be observed in the figure, the power dependency deviates from linearity, indicating that some of the excited states involved are saturated. Anyway, in the low pump power regime, the intensity of the up-converted emissions exhibits a power dependence with slopes of 1.5 for 3H4 → 3H6 transition, 2.0 for 1G4 → 3H6 and 3.0 for 1D2 → 3H6, represented by the continuous coloured lines in the figure. The red emission (700 nm) associated to the 3F2,3 → 3H6 transition follows a linear dependence with a slope 1.7 through all the power range used in this work.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Power dependency of the emission intensity of Tm3+ transitions that take place from different levels to the ground state, 3H6. The full lines represent the fits made to obtain the slopes. The dotted lines are polynomial fits drown to guide the eye. |
As it has been indicated above, considering the evidence of saturation these power dependences represent the lower limit of the number of photons involved in the up-conversion mechanisms. Therefore, the experimental results are consistent with the mechanisms shown in Fig. 4, that suggest a two-photon process for 3F2,3 and 3H4 population, a three-photon process for 1G4 emissions and, at least, a four-photon process for populating the 1D2 multiplet.
In relation to the origin of the observed saturation power dependence, it should be considered that this effect is usually related to up-conversion processes depopulating one, or several, intermediate excited states in such a way that the up-conversion path becomes comparable or more probable than the relaxation paths to lower energy states. This produces a decrease in the slope obtained for those intermediate levels and, in consequence, in the slope of the levels populated from them.37 Although transfer probabilities of Yb3+-to-Tm3+ in YF3 nanoparticles have not been reported yet, they have been obtained for YF3 polycrystalline phosphors,38 and show that the first energy transfer, that populates 3H5 and 3F4 levels of thulium, presents a lower probability than the next two consecutive transfer mechanisms, so that saturation effects seem to be highly probable.32
According to Fig. 6, since the different emission bands hold different power dependencies, the relationship between the bands and the colour of the emission can be modified by changing the excitation power. In that sense, higher powers produce an increase of blue and ultraviolet emissions in comparison to red emissions, and vice versa. Anyway, this is a slight modification compared to the changes that could be seen related to Tm3+ and Yb3+ contents, as it will be shown next.
Fig. 7 presents the emission spectra, after 975 nm excitation, of three samples with different Tm3+ content but the same Yb3+ concentration ([Yb3+] = 10 mol%). With the aim of clearly comparing the obtained results, those spectra have been normalized dividing each one by the whole area of emission in the measured range. The emission spectra are strongly dependent on lanthanide ions concentration, as it can be deduced from the changes in the blue-to-red ratio of the emissions with thulium concentration. The figure includes also three pictures of those samples illustrating the change in colour that can be easily discerned by the naked eye. The photograph has been taken using a LUMIX digital camera with 1 s exposure at ISO 400. As it can be observed, the sample glows in a rather magenta hue, which oscillates from a reddish tone for the samples with higher thulium content and turns to a bluer tone when thulium content is diminished.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Pictures of the emission of three samples with different doping content under the same excitation (up). The spectra obtained are shown in the graph. For comparison purposes they have been normalized to the whole emission area (down). |
To follow in detail the dependency between those colour changes and doping concentrations, two different series of samples have been synthesized. One of them keeps ytterbium concentration constant at [Yb3+] = 10 mol%, while varies [Tm3+] concentration from 0.1 mol% up to 5 mol%. In the other one, on the contrary, thulium concentration has been kept constant at [Tm3+] = 0.5 mol% while ytterbium content is changed from 1 mol% up to 30 mol%.
The luminescence spectra of these samples have been measured after 975 nm excitation keeping constant the excitation power (500 mW). The obtained results are similar to those presented in Fig. 7, except for the variation in the emission intensities of the different up-converted emissions. To quantify the results, the maximum peak emission of each band has been plotted versus doping concentration. The graphs can be seen in Fig. 8 for both concentration series (ytterbium constant Fig. 8a and thulium constant Fig. 8b). Each sample has been measured up to five times, removing it from the positioning platform and placing it back again on it to be sure that the measured changes in the bands are not caused by experimental artefacts. The error bars included in the figure correspond to an experimental uncertainty of around 20%, calculated from the average value of the different measurements. In addition, different groups of particles fabricated at the same time have been measured to guarantee the homogeneity of the samples. No observable changes have been obtained with that procedure.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Dependency of the intensity of the observed emission bands and doping concentrations keeping ytterbium (a) or thulium (b) content constant. The lines have been drawn to guide the eye. |
As a first, general conclusion, it can be observed from Fig. 8 that luminescence intensities are strongly affected by the lanthanide ions content in the nanoparticles (note that the intensities are represented in a logarithmic scale, so that the variations cover several orders of magnitude). It appears also to be clear from the data that all the intensities are stronger at high ytterbium concentration (Fig. 8b), while they diminish with the increase of thulium content (Fig. 8a). In fact luminescence quenching by Tm3+ concentration is so strong that the emission becomes undetectable for the samples with higher thulium content ([Tm3+] = 5 mol%).
The figure includes emissions at different wavelengths but originating from the same Tm3+ multiplet (363 nm and 451 nm, originating from the 1D2 level, for instance) which, as expected, follow the same behaviour with doping concentration. This parallelism supports the reliability of the data.
Considering that the overall emission intensity is changing with dopant concentration, an alternative representation of the spectral changes in relation to the measured emission intensity is obtained normalizing the emissions to the intensity of the near infrared 3H4 → 3H6 transition. That representation can be seen in Fig. 9, where the lines have been added to guide the eye.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 Normalized intensities related to 1D2 → 3H6 (purple dots), 1G4 → 3H6 (blue dots) and 3F2,3 → 3H6 (red dots). The lines have been added to guide the eye. |
As it can be seen, under that normalization, the intensity of the red emission, associated to 3F2,3 → 3H6 transition, holds a nearly constant value. This can be easily understood, considering that the 3H4 energy level is populated from the decay of the 3F2,3 upper-level and therefore their emissions are proportional to each other. The slight increase found, in the samples with constant thulium content ([Tm3+] = 0.5 mol%), at the highest ytterbium concentrations, could be related to the effective UV-blue up-conversion processes that partially depopulate the 3H4 level while keeps the 3F2,3 population unaltered.
Regarding the UV and blue emissions, in samples with constant ytterbium concentration ([Yb3+] = 10 mol%), it can be seen in Fig. 9a that their intensities, generated by the radiative decay from levels 1D2 and 1G4, decrease when Tm3+ concentration increases. On the other hand, in samples with constant thulium content ([Tm3+] = 0.5 mol%), UV and blue emission bands show an initial increase with Yb3+ concentration, and their intensities remain dominant over the red emissions through the entire range of Yb3+ concentrations used in this work.
It can be quantified by considering a blue to red ratio (BRR) calculated in terms of the area under the blue bands (1D2 → 3F4 and 1G4 → 3H6) and the area related to the red bands (1G4 → 3H6 and 3F2,3 → 3H6) from emission spectra corrected for the response of the experimental set-up (monochromator and detector). These ratios change from a lowest value BRR ≈ 0.3 (reddish colour) to a highest value BRR ≈ 2 (bluish) for nanoparticles with concentrations changing from [Yb3+] = 10 mol%/[Tm3+] = 2 mol%, to [Yb3+] = 30 mol%/[Tm3+] = 0.5 mol%, respectively.
These emission changes associated to Yb3+ and Tm3+ concentrations can be understood, at least qualitatively, considering the UC-excitation mechanisms and the possible reverse processes (down-converting cross-relaxation processes or back-transfer mechanisms) that can take place in Yb3+/Tm3+ doped materials. First, considering the multiphoton intrinsic nature of the up-conversion mechanisms, it is clear that increasing Yb3+ concentration (and Yb3+/Tm3+ ratio) would facilitate the excitation of the upper Tm3+ multiplets. Also, it should be considered that several of the excited states of thulium may experience down-converting processes that will effectively quench Tm3+ emissions. In particular, it is well known that Tm3+ ions exhibit a highly effective infrared cross-relaxation process that depopulates the 3H4 level, following the scheme 2H4 → 3F4 (Tm3+):3H6 → 3F4 (Tm3+).39–43 This process not only disrupts the sequence of up-conversion paths to populate the blue-emitting upper Tm3+ levels (1G4 and 1D2) but it also simultaneously increases the population of the 3F4 level, which feeds (by energy transfer from Yb3+) the red emitting 3F2,3 level (see Fig. 4). Therefore, this internal cross-relaxation process, which is enhanced by Tm3+ concentration, may contribute to the observed concentration dependencies.
Finally, in order to represent colour modifications in a quantitative way, the response of the standard human eye should be considered. For that reason, the CIE colour coordinates have been calculated, after correcting the spectra from the experimental response, and are shown in Fig. 10. In the figure, the arrows point towards the direction where doping concentration increases.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 CIE colour coordinates of three different samples of each concentration series, [Yb3+] constant (left) and [Tm3+] constant (right). |
As it can be observed, the changes in the spectra produce different emission colours that go from a reddish hue ([Yb3+] = 10 mol%; [Tm3+] = 2 mol%) to a deep blue emission ([Yb3+] = 30 mol%; [Tm3+] = 0.5 mol%), covering several magenta hues in between.
Finally, it is also remarkable in Fig. 10 the opposite direction of the evolution of the hue with increasing concentrations of Tm3+ or Yb3+. While higher thulium contents are related to reddish emissions, higher Yb3+ concentrations are connected to the bluest hues. Therefore, it can be said that the higher the Yb3+/Tm3+ rate is, the highest population density will be found at thulium 1G4 and 1D2 energy levels and the bluest the emission will be.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 |