A.
Mudarra Rubio
,
M.
Montes-Bayón
,
E.
Blanco-González
* and
A.
Sanz-Medel
*
Department of Physical and Analytical Chemistry, University of Oviedo, C/Julián Clavería 8, 33006 Oviedo, Spain. E-mail: eblancog@uniovi.es; asm@uniovi.es
First published on 13th August 2010
A sample preparation strategy for the determination of the Fe-containing enzyme catalase (CAT) by Fe specific monitoring in human erythrocytes has been optimized. For this purpose, the combined use of elemental mass spectrometry (via inductively coupled plasma, ICP-MS), molecular mass spectrometry (via MALDI-TOF) and enzymatic activity measurements has been required. The procedure involved haemoglobin precipitation from cell lysate with a solution of ethanol–chloroform and preconcentration of the supernatant by using a Speed-Vac concentrator. Catalase recoveries of about 88 ± 15% could be measured by monitoring the protein enzymatic activity before and after precipitation. Further fractionation of Fe-containing proteins from the preconcentrated extract was achieved by size exclusion chromatography (Superdex 200) with a mobile phase of ammonium acetate (0.05 M, pH 7.4) coupled to ICP-MS (Fe monitoring) and UV/VIS detection (specific absorption of the heme-group at 408 nm). A second dimensional chromatography of the CAT-positive activity fraction was carried out by anion-exchange chromatography (Mono Q 5/50) using for elution a linear gradient of ammonium acetate (0–0.750 M in 15 min). This second step revealed a single Fe-containing species in the chromatogram and permitted the unambiguous characterization of the CAT in such fractions by MALDI-TOF. Column recoveries were evaluated and were quantitative, in terms of Fe bound to protein and CAT activity.
At present most of the studies have been focused on measuring the CAT activity changes under certain health disorders. In these cases the enzyme activity is generally determined using assays that are based on either the decrease in absorbance of hydrogen peroxide at λ = 240 nm or by measuring oxygen release with Clark-type electrodes.16,17 The activity measurements have some limitations, for instance, the inability to assay catalase at saturating substrate (H2O2) concentrations, as is conventionally done in standardized enzyme assays, which results in the absence of an official reference method and a wide variation in the reaction conditions. Thus, estimates of catalase activity for different tissues may vary widely, depending on the activity method, concentration of H2O2 and units of measurement. For instance, human plasma activity of catalase is reported to be 70 ± 29 U/L by using a peroxidatic method, 1 mM H2O2, and catalase standards, but approximately 200-fold or 700-fold higher in catalatic methods based on measurement of the decrease in absorbance of 10 and 54 mM H2O2, respectively. Therefore, the activity measurements are only useful for comparison purposes (relative measurement). However in order to gain insight into the pathophysiological relevance of CAT, direct quantitative data of its concentration level in biological samples is demanded. In this regard, very few strategies have been developed over the years for the direct quantification of CAT in red blood cells. A recent method has been developed for the determination of catalase by means of electrospray-MS using multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) strategies after tryptic digestion of the protein into the corresponding peptides. However, the authors reported a discrepancy between the protein concentrations as determined from two different peptides. They claim that most likely these differences arise from inadequacy in the sample preparation and handling procedures, in particular, incomplete tryptic digestion of the protein or sample losses due to unspecific adsorptions.18 Another approach for quantification of CAT levels in transfected cells is proposed by using competitive ELISA, with rabbit anti-human CAT antibody.19 Plates are read in an ELISA reader at 492 nm and the total catalase levels are determined by reference to a standard curve, constructed with serial dilutions of human catalase. However, this procedure involves several preparation steps that make it prone to errors due to protein losses obtaining final inaccurate results.
In this work we propose an integrated speciation approach based on the complementary use of elemental mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) for the sensitive Fe detection, UV/VIS absorption for selective monitoring of the heme-group (408 nm) and the CAT activity measurements. The use of ICP-MS also allows the accurate quantification of heteroelements in biomolecules by isotope dilution analysis (IDA).20 The quantitative determination of such metals and/or metalloids in combination with the knowledge of the heteroelement-protein stoichiometry provides an elegant methodology to obtain absolute protein concentrations.21,22 However, since the quantification of heteroatom-containing biomolecules via HPLC-ICP-MS is only based on the detection of the corresponding heteroelement, extreme care must be taken to preserve the native compositional and coordinative structure of the metallo- or heteoatom-containing protein during the whole analytical procedure. Moreover, protein column recovery for the biomolecule must be always taken into account since quantification errors will still occur if the metal containing protein does not elute completely from the column.21
Thus, in this study we propose the use of complementary techniques to asses the recovery of every step necessary for the determination of CAT in real samples, by using post-column IDA-HPLC-ICP-MS strategies. The different steps during the required sample preparation and species isolation will be quantitatively controlled aiming at developing a reliable alternative analytical procedure for the determination of CAT via elemental detection of the iron present in the hemo groups of the protein.
Intact protein analysis by MALDI-TOF-MS was conducted using a Voyager-DETM STR BiospectrometryTM Workstation (Applied Biosytems, Langen, Germany) instrument equipped with nitrogen pulsed laser (337 nm). All spectra were recorded in linear, positive ion mode. Spectra were collected as a sum of 100 shots across a spot. External calibration was performed for molecular assignments using a standard of albumin from bovine serum. Sample preparation was performed on a stainless steel hydrophobic target (Voyager 96 × 2 Sample Plate P/N V700813) using the dried-droplet technique. For that, an aliquot (0.5 μL) of the sample solution and an equal aliquot of the matrix solution were mixed on the target in the given order and dried at room temperature. The matrix solution was prepared with sinapinic acid (5 mg mL−1) in 70% (v/v) water, 29.9% (v/v) acetic acid and 0.1% (v/v) TFA. Operational conditions and data acquisition parameters are summarized in Table 1.
ICP-(ORS)-MS | |
Instrument | Agilent 7500 CE (ORS) |
RF power | 1500 W |
External flow | 15 L min−1 |
Nebuliser gas flow rate | 1.1 L min−1 |
m/z monitored | 54Fe, 56Fe, 57Fe |
Integration time per isotope | 0.1 s |
Collision/reaction gas | He |
Flow rate | 4 mL min−1 |
Octapole-bias | −18 V |
QP-bias | −14 V |
MALDI-TOF | |
Instrument | Voyager-DETM STR BiospectrometryTM |
Scan type | Positive |
Instrument mode | Linear |
External calibration | Albumin of bovine serum |
Matrix | 5 mg mL−1 Sinapinic acid, 70% H2O, 29.9% acetic acid, 0.1% TFA |
Laser | 2600 V |
Spectrum acquisition | |
Shoots | 150 |
Scan range | 6000–35000 |
For this purpose, ammonium acetate was chosen as eluent providing adequate compatibility with ICP-MS detection and the separation was carried out at the physiological pH of 7.4. A group of iron containing protein standards including cytochrome c (13 kDa), haemoglobin (63 kDa), ferritin (450 kDa) together with CAT from bovine liver (240 kDa) were used for calibration (data not shown). The chromatogram obtained with UV/VIS detection (280 and 408 nm) (Fig. 1A) and ICP-MS detection of Fe (Fig. 1B) for a bovine CAT standard revealed the presence of an important number of unexpected peaks. The UV trace at 280 nm shows that the protein standard is not pure and different species absorb at this wavelength at different retention times. However, only the species eluting at about 21 min showed absorbances at 280 nm and 408 nm, which corresponds to the main Fe-signal (see Fig. 1B). Therefore, such fractions can be ascribed to CAT. The Fe trace (Fig. 1B) shows also another species at about 18 min that corresponds, according to the different injected Fe-protein standards, to the retention time of ferritin that could be present as impurity. In order to rule out that this Fe-signal is due to possible CAT agglomerates, the peak associated to CAT at 21 min was collected and re-injected in the same column. The inset of Fig. 1B reveals a pure peak at 21 min, confirming the previously observed results of ferritin impurities present in the commercial CAT standard.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 SEC chromatogram of the CAT standard from bovine liver obtained by: (A) UV/VIS detection at 280 nm and 408 nm; and (B) ICP-(ORS)-MS detection of Fe. The shadowed fraction of Fig. 1A was collected and re-injected and the corresponding chromatogram is shown in the inset. Experimental conditions in the text. A.u. (absorbance arbitrary units). |
Fig. 2 shows the separation obtained for a human blood sample processed as described in the experimental section. As can be seen in the chromatogram of Fig. 2A, several Fe-containing species are still present after haemoglobin precipitation. The main Fe and heme containing peak corresponds to the retention time of the haemoglobin standard (≈ 27 min) which reveals that, as anticipated, a small percentage of this protein is still present in solution after precipitation. Additionally, both the UV/VIS and the ICP-MS signals (see Fig. 2A) reveal the presence of two peaks in the fraction corresponding with the elution of the standard of CAT (20–25 min, see Fig. 1). In order to evaluate if the sought protein was present in any of the two observed peaks (around 21 min and 24 min) different fractions of the eluate from the SEC column were collected every 30 s (0.3 ml fractions) and the enzymatic activity of CAT was measured in each fraction as described in the procedures section. The chromatographic profile obtained is shown in Fig. 2B superimposed to the 56Fe iron chromatographic profile. As can be observed, the fraction presenting, almost exclusively, CAT activity, Fe-signal and absorbance at 408 nm occurs at 20–22 min. This finding confirms the presence of CAT in the Fe containing sought fraction although it does not provide any information about species purity. The peak at about 31 min (Fig. 2B) could be due to the presence of other peroxidases, primarily glutathione peroxidase that could be present in the extract and could cause overestimation of catalase activity if these species are not chromatographically resolved, as reported by other authors.15
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 SEC chromatogram of a sample of human erythrocytes after sample treatment obtained by: (A) UV/VIS detection at 408 nm (red trace) and ICP-(ORS)-MS on the 56Fe (black trace); and (B) same Fe signal that in Fig. 2A but superimposed to the enzymatic activity profile (green trace). Experimental conditions in the text. A.u. (absorbance arbitrary units). |
In order to evaluate species purity, the fraction 1 eluting from the SEC column between 20–22 min and containing CAT (see shadowed area of Fig. 2A) was collected, desalted and preconcentrated (using a 100 kDa cut-off filter) and then analyzed by anion exchange chromatography. For this purpose, different ammonium acetate gradients buffered at pH 7.4 were tested for elution of the CAT standard in this column and a linear gradient of acetate (0–0.750 M in 15 min) was chosen. As can be seen in Fig. 3, the chromatogram obtained by anion exchange of the fraction 1 from Fig. 2A shows a single species at a retention time of about 7 min using both ICP-MS (56Fe) and UV/VIS (408 nm) detection. This retention time matches the CAT standard retention time (data not shown) and confirms the presence of the sought protein in fraction 1 (additionally, the small ICP-MS peak observed at 10 min appeared, with the same intensity, in the gradient blank). Therefore, adequate species purity seems to be achieved for separation of CAT from human erythrocytes by sequential fractionation by size exclusion (Superdex 200) followed by anion-exchange chromatography (Mono Q 5/50).
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Anion-exchange chromatogram of the fraction collected from 20 to 22 min in the chromatogram of Fig. 2A, obtained by UV/VIS detection at 408 nm (red trace) and with ICP-(ORS)-MS for detection of Fe. Experimental conditions in the text. |
For complete confirmation of the above described results, the fraction eluting at 7 min in the chromatogram of Fig. 3 was collected, cleaned-up and analysed by MALDI-TOF-MS using sinapinic acid as matrix and the conditions described in the experimental section. The mass spectrum obtained is depicted in Fig. 4. The most intense signal observed at m/z 59616.39 Da could correspond to the singly charged ion of the apo-subunit of CAT (one catalase chain without the heme group) which has a theoretical molecular mass of 59585 Da (Δm = 0.05%). This result confirms the presence of CAT in the fraction analyzed, since it is well known from the literature that analysis of quaternary structure of proteins by MALDI-TOF using typical acidic matrix solutions such as sinapinic acid/trifluoroacetic acid yields spectra of monomeric protein subunits rather than the intact protein.23 This is due to the fact that the acid conditions for MALDI leads to dissociation of the non-covalent subunits assemblies and, in the case of metaloproteins, often to the lost of the metal bound to the protein (unless special MALDI matrices are used).20,24 In fact, only a very limited number of publications reported the observation of the intact holohomotetramer of beef liver catalase (assembly composed of four catalase chains and four heme groups) by MALDI-MS using less acid matrix substances, such as hidroxyacetophenones derivatives in organic solvents with and without the addition of MALDI-compatible buffer salts.23,24
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 MALDI-TOF-MS spectrum of the fraction collected from 6 to 8 min in the chromatogram of Fig. 3. Experimental conditions in the text. |
Finally, in order to prove the suitability of the developed multidimensional chromatographic method for future quantification studies, it was necessary to ensure that the recovery of both Fe and CAT along the separation procedure is quantitative. To evaluate this recovery, the eluate from the entire chromatographic run (50 min for SEC-HPLC, 30 min for anion-exchange-HPLC) was collected (n = 3) and Fe was quantified (5 replicates) by ICP–MS with direct calibration using Ga as internal standard. The amount of Fe found was compared with that measured in the sample before injection. The results of this mass-balance for Fe were quantitative from both columns, SEC (79 ± 12%) and anion-exchange (87 ± 10%). Moreover, the integrity of CAT during the multidimensional chromatographic separation procedure was also evaluated by measuring its enzymatic activity in the sample and in the eluate collected from the column after sample separation. The recovery for activity obtained was again quantitative (90 ± 20%). Since the heme group is essential for the enzyme activity, this result indicates no loss of the enzyme-bound heme during chromatographic separation.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Chromatographic profile of Fe obtained by SEC-ICP-(ORS)-MS after the sample treatment in human erythrocytes using a relation cell lysate volume /ethanol volume /chloroform volume of 8/1/1 (black trace) and 8/4/2 (red trace). |
Finally the recovery of the whole sample treatment procedure described (haemoglobin precipitation and preconcentration using a Speed-Vac concentrator) was evaluated by measuring the specific activity of CAT in the erythrocyte lysate before and after treatment. Recoveries of about 88 ± 15% (mean±SD, n = 3) of the enzymatic activity of the CAT remained after sample treatment. Since the CAT enzymatic activity depends on the presence of the heme group in the molecule, quantitative recoveries calculated through activity measurements imply species stability throughout the precipitation step. As consequence, Fe (target element for further ICP-MS quantification of CAT) remains present within the molecule and can be directly quantified after separation of the remaining Fe-proteins by SEC (which provides also quantitative recoveries). Such results should permit the direct correlation between the enzymatic activity with the metal measurements in the ICP-MS (Fe in this case), previously demonstrated for Cu, Zn-SOD.20 This would be an elegant way to obtain, via elemental mass spectrometry simultaneous data about CAT concentration and activity and has to be now proved in several samples.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |