O.
Marconi
*a,
E.
Bravi
a,
G.
Perretti
a,
R.
Martini
b,
L.
Montanari
a and
P.
Fantozzi
a
aDepartment of Economic and Food Science, University of Perugia,
via S. Costanzo, 06126, Perugia, Italy. Fax: +39.075.585.7939; Tel: +39.075.585.7923
bColussi, Petrignano di Assisi, Perugia, Italy
First published on 5th October 2010
Among advanced hypotheses concerning acrylamide formation in cooked food, the Maillard browning reactions of sugars and amino acids have received much attention as the most likely pathway. Bakery products such as biscuits represent a class of food in which the effect of ingredients and processing promote acrylamide formation. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classified acrylamide as “potential carcinogen to humans”; therefore, there is an urgent requirement for the development and validation of sensitive, robust and inexpensive analytical methods to quantify acrylamide in different food matrices to the μg kg −1 levels. The aims of this research were the set up of an analytical method to determine acrylamide concentration in shortbread biscuits, and the study of the technological parameters influencing the acrylamide formation during shortbread processing. Five technological tests were conducted to produce five different experimental types of shortbread. The experimental shortbreads were obtained using different concentrations of baking agents (sodium bicarbonate and ammonium bicarbonate) and applying different cooking temperatures and different times. A HPLC-DAD reliable and sensitive method to determine acrylamide in shortbread was achieved. The chromatographic separation was achieved with isocratic analysis in a 15-min run. The coefficient of determination of the acrylamide standard calibration curve is 0.997; the limit of detection was 8 μg Kg−1, and the limit of quantification was 28 μg Kg−1. The recovery test was conducted adding three different concentrations of acrylamide standard solution to the blank sample. The acrylamide recovery ranged from 90.5 ± 0.3% to 99.1 ± 1.8%. The results showed that the ammonium bicarbonate concentration in shortbread, and the high temperature, influenced the acrylamide formation during the processing highlighting that the final acrylamide concentration is influenced by the processing parameters.
In general, thermal processes during the production of foodstuffs are complex, and the initial result on acrylamide level do not seem to indicate a common pattern, except that carbohydrate-rich foods seems to generate relatively more acrylamide.3 The low water content seems important for the reactions, and acrylamide is nearly not detected in boiled foods containing starch. Deep frying or roasting seems to be propitious to the formation of acrylamide.6 Recent studies suggested that the acrylamide in food is largely derived from heat-induced reaction between the amino group of free amino acid asparagine and the carbonyl group of reducing sugar such as glucose during baking and frying.7–9 Two main mechanisms of acrylamide formation in foods have been proposed. However, acrylamide is also generated by direct decarboxylation from Schiff bases prior to the Amadori rearrangement, as well as from carnosine, Strecker aldehydes or from pyrolysis of gluten.10–12 Finally, acrolein and ammonia have also been identified as precursors of acrylamide from thermal degradation of triglycerides in lipid-rich foods.13 Acrylamide chemistry, biochemistry, occurrence, metabolism and toxicology have been reviewed elsewhere.14
An urgent requirement is for the development and validation of sensitive, robust and inexpensive analytical methods to quantify acrylamide in different food matrices to the μg kg −1 levels.1 A number of chromatographic methods for determination and detection of acrylamide in heat-treated foods has been developed. Gas chromatographic (GC) and high-performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) techniques are used for both determination and detection of acrylamide in water, biological fluids and non cooked foods.3,5,15–17 The GC-MS methods require derivatization of the acrylamide before the analysis (e.g., bromination), LC-MS instead analyzes the compound directly. Moreover, many researchers believe that the liquid chromatography (LC) methods were not found to be appropriate for the analysis of acrylamide in processed food at low levels, and many authors believe that LC must be coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) for better identification of acrylamide processed foods. Although MS is a selective system for detection, the mass of acrylamide itself or its ions are not specific due to the presence of co-extractive compounds that yield the same magnitude of m/z with acrylamide in the sample matrix.1,15 The sample clean-up plays a fundamental role in acrylamide analysis. High-performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) techniques are easy and low cost with respect to MS techniques. As reported in the literature,15,18 the HPLC method coupled with Diode Array Detector (DAD) can be suitable for the analysis of acrylamide in potato chips, crisps and deep-fried flour based food so it could be applied to other processed foods such as biscuits. Gökmen et al.15 found that a conventional HPLC instrument coupled to DAD can also be used accurately and precisely as an alternative to tandem LC-MS methods for the determination of acrylamide in potato-based foods after extraction of acrylamide with methanol, purification with Carrez I and II solution, evaporation and solvent change to water. In different foods, acrylamide formation has been show to correlate with pre-processing levels of asparagine, fructose, glucose or the product of asparagine and reducing sugars. However, the observed wide variations in levels of acrylamide in different food categories as well as in different brands of the same food category appear to result not only from the amounts of the precursors present but also from variations in processing conditions (e.g., temperature, time, nature of food matrix).20 Bakery products such as biscuits represent a class of food in which the effect of ingredients and processing promote the acrylamide formation.21 The highest contents were often found in products prepared with the baking agent ammonium bicarbonate such as gingerbread products.22 Some studies about model experiments showed that the ammonium bicarbonate strongly promotes the acrylamide formation in sweet bakery.23,24 Shortbread represents a biscuits class containing acrylamide because of the ingredients and the thermal process. Shortbread ingredients that influence the acrylamide formation are the baking agents, reducing sugars and the asparagine which derived from cereals, milk or eggs.19 The cereals cultivars containing low concentrations of reducing sugar and asparagine represent an important way to reduce the acrylamide content of shortbread. Nevertheless it is shown that the breakdown of the stark grain during the milling causes the increase of acrylamide in the final product. The damaged grains are more susceptible to the enzymatic hydrolysis which led to the reducing sugars formation. The bran cereal displacement to obtain white flour represents another way to prevent the acrylamide formation in bakery products. In fact the bran contains a high concentration of acrylamide precursors as asparagine.25 Graft et al., 20067 conducted a study about influence of the baking agents at different concentrations on acrylamide formation during the production of a semi-finished biscuit on an industrial scale. Recently, Sadd et al., 200826 evaluated the effect of dough age, yeast, fermentation times, the addition of amino acids or metal ions and the use of sodium instead of ammonium raising agents for reducing acrylamide in pilot scale bakery products.
The aims of the present investigation were the set up of an analytical method to determine acrylamide concentration in the level of 30–650 μg kg−14 in shortbread biscuits and to study the technological parameters influencing the acrylamide formation during shortbread processing. The paper presents a reliable, sensitive, fast and low-cost analytical method for the determination of acrylamide in shortbread biscuits. The method utilized LC with UV detection that can be easily adopted by non-specialized analytical laboratories. The second purpose of this study was to check the influence of the cooking temperature, time, and the baking agents—like ammonium bicarbonate and sodium bicarbonate—on the acrylamide content of shortbread biscuits produced in a pilot plant.
Eight different shortbread samples. Samples 1, 2, 3A, 3B, and 3C, obtained with different technological trials, were prepared in a pilot plant. Samples 1CS, 2CS and 3CS were commercial shortbreads purchased in local market.
RECIPE | (NH4)HCO3 g | NaHCO3 g | COOKING PARAMETERS |
---|---|---|---|
1 | 3.0 | 3.0 | T = 240 °C t = 7′ |
2 | 4.5 | 4.5 | T = 240 °C t = 7′ |
3A | 11.9 | 11.9 | T = 240 °C t = 7′ |
3B | 11.9 | 11.9 | T = 300 °C t = 3′ |
3C | 11.9 | 11.9 | T = 180 °C t = 12′ |
Finally for the recipes 3B and 3C they had same ingredients of 3A but different baking parameters, 300 °C for 3 min and 180 °C for 12 min respectively.
The baking process was carried out in a static oven (TMP, C/2B Mod.).
Two grams of ground shortbread sample and 20 ml of methyl alcohol were mixed in a 50 ml Falcon tube. The obtained solution was homogenated with Ultraturrax at 10000 rpm for 2 min and centrifuged at 12000 rpm for 5 min. The supernatant was recovered, transferred in a Falcon tube and Carrez I (200 μl) and II (200 μl) were added. The mixture was centrifuge at 12000 rpm for 5 min. After centrifugation 5 ml of supernatant were collected, filtered and anhydrified with sodium sulfate anhydrous. The filtered sample was evaporated to dryness, dissolved in 2 ml of water in Eppendorf tubes and centrifuge at 14000 rpm for 2 min. The supernatant was then purified in SPE Oasis HLB cartridges. The cartridge was conditioned with 2 ml of methanol and equilibrated with 2 ml of water. Then the supernatant was loaded, the first 1.5 ml drops were discarded and the remaining solution injected into the HPLC-DAD system.
All procedures were carried out isocratically using a mixture of 0.01M sulfuric acid of water–methanol 97.5:
2.5. The flow rate was 0.7 mL min−1.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Sample preparation procedure. |
Concentration range | a | b | r2 | LODb | LOQb | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(μg ml−1) | a ± t0.05, 13 | b ± t0.05, 13 | (μg Kg−1) | (μg Kg−1) | ||
a p < 0.05 a = a± t0.05, 13 × sda, sda = standard error of slope, b = b ± t0.05, 13 × sdb, sdb = standard error of intercept, y = ax + b. b n = 10. | ||||||
Acrylamide | 0.05–1.00 | 915.23 ± 47.33 | 18.48 ± 15.19 | 0.997 | 8 | 28 |
Background level in shortbread (μg Kg−1) | Spike level (μg Kg−1) | Detected (μg Kg−1) | Recovery (%) |
---|---|---|---|
a n = 3. | |||
257 | 75 | 315 ± 5 | 94.8 ± 1.4 |
100 | 323 ± 1 | 90.5 ± 0.3 | |
250 | 502 ± 9 | 99.1 ± 1.8 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Chromatogram and UV spectrum of a 1 μg ml−1 standard solution of acrylamide. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (a) A typical elution profile of acrylamide in shortbread; (b) acrylamide spectra; (c) acrylamide peak purity test. |
Table 5 reports the acrylamide concentrations of the five experimental shortbreads. The samples 1, 2 and 3A were obtained using different amounts of baking agents (3.0, 4.5 and 11.9 g respectively) but were cooked at the standard parameters of 240 °C for 7 min. The acrylamide concentration of sample 1 was lower than sample 2 and 3A. The sample 1 recipe contained a lower amount of ammonium bicarbonate, and these data confirmed that ammonium bicarbonate had a positive correlation with the acrylamide formation. Literature data reported that the recipes without ammonium bicarbonate lead to gingerbread without acrylamide.22 The replacement with sodium bicarbonate as the only baking agent could be an approach to decrease the acrylamide formation in shortbread but the product had an alkaline taste. The samples 3A, 3B and 3C were obtained utilizing the same amount of ammonium bicarbonate (11.9 g) but with different cooking temperatures and times. The sample 3A, cooked at 240 °C for 7 min, showed a concentration of acrylamide higher than 3B and 3C. The sample 3B has the minor acrylamide concentration. It was cooked at 300 °C for 3 min and we hypothesize that the high temperatures promote the acrylamide degradation as suggested by literature.25,31 Sample 3C was obtained applying a cooking temperature of 180 °C for 12 min and it presented a lower acrylamide concentration than samples 3A. Gokmen et al.32 reported that after the initial lower rate period, acrylamide concentration of cookies reaches a plateau of about 250 μg kg −1 within a baking time of 15 min at 180 °C, using sucrose in the recipe. They obtained cookies with an acrylamide concentration less than 150 μg kg −1 by baking them at 160 °C for 25 min which will convert the surface to a fully brownish color. Sample 3C presented a concentration of acrylamide of 127 μg kg−1 and the typical surface color of shortbread. It is well known that the acrylamide formation is influenced by the ingredients and their composition. The obtained results also highlighted the role of the cooking time and temperature. In fact, the evolution of acrylamide concentration with respect to the thermal treatment time in model system follows a “bell course” (gaussian course). Moreover, the acrylamide concentration of a food system subject to an intense thermal treatment for a determined time should be the result of its formation and degradation.33 The acrylamide content of heating processed food first increases in the time at a constant cooking temperature. Then, after prolonged heating, a decrease in the acrylamide content was observed because degradation of acrylamide becomes predominant.34
The obtained results highlight the strong influence of ammonium bicarbonate in acrylamide formation. The acrylamide concentration in the finished product was influenced by the process parameters. The high cooking temperatures obtained a decrease of acrylamide concentration. The experimental shortbreads showed a lower acrylamide concentration in comparison with commercial shortbreads, and it should be the consequence of the simplified recipe. In fact, the acrylamide formation depends on the food matrix.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |