Johannes
Kiefer
*a,
Nina
Ebel
b,
Eberhard
Schlücker
b and
Alfred
Leipertz
a
aLehrstuhl für Technische Thermodynamik (LTT) and Erlangen Graduate School in Advanced Optical Technologies (SAOT), Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Am Weichselgarten 8, 91058, Erlangen, Germany. E-mail: jk@ltt.uni-erlangen.de; Fax: 0049 9131 8529901; Tel: 0049 9131 8529766
bLehrstuhl für Prozessmaschinen und Anlagentechnik (iPAT), Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Cauerstraße 4, 91058, Erlangen, Germany
First published on 26th November 2009
In this paper we demonstrate that conventional absorption spectroscopy in the ultraviolet, visible and near-infrared spectral range facilitates characterization of Escherichia coli (E. coli) suspensions. Two kinds of samples have been studied: (1) Untreated E. coli suspensions with systematically varied cell concentration and (2) E. coli treated by different inactivation procedures. For the purpose of inactivation the bacteria have been treated by either heat at elevated temperature as an established method or by hydrostatic or dynamic high pressure. The results show that at cell concentrations above a certain threshold extinction measurements in the ultraviolet region can yield a quantitative measure of the cell number density with optimal sensitivity and precision. Furthermore, examining suitable spectral regions the absorption spectra reveal characteristic features hence allowing identification of the treatment procedure later on. In conclusion, this study establishes a simple and cost-efficient approach for online and in-situ monitoring of processes for the inactivation of microbiological organisms. Moreover, the method provides a tool for the investigation of the inactivation mechanisms.
In the past numerous approaches to inactivate microbiological organisms have been demonstrated and applied. As this work focuses on Escherichia coli as an example bacterium a short overview over selected, recent activities is given considering E. coli only. A common method to achieve inactivation is the direct exposure of the contaminated sample to certain additives. For instance, gaseous ozone and hot water or steam may be employed in this context. Dorsa et al.1 investigated the dependence of the decontamination efficiency on temperature applying steam, hot water spray washes and a steam-vacuum sanitizer to sheep and beef carcasses aiming at a reduction of fecal bacteria like E. coli. Selma and co-workers2 investigated the potential of hot water and gaseous ozone employed to cantaloupe melons. They reported that both methods allow efficient reduction of the total microbial population, however the combination of both was found to be most successful. Moreover, the sensory quality of the samples was not affected by the treatment. Another promising approach is the use of dense phase or supercritical carbon dioxide. For instance, Liao et al.3 investigated the inactivation kinetics of E. coli at different pressure and temperature revealing a change of the mechanism with exposure time. In a follow-up study4 they compared the experimental results with model calculations and obtained good agreement. Furthermore, photocatalytic inactivation of E. coli can be achieved using ultraviolet radiation in combination with suited catalysts like titania, TiO2,5 or silver ions.6
However, all methods mentioned above are based on the exposure of the samples to additional substances; hence they either require a further removal step or they may exert a long-lasting influence on the food. Both may be not wanted. For this reason more or less non-invasive methods have been developed employing heat at elevated temperature, electric fields or pressure for instance. Sterilization employing heat is by far the oldest, most common and effective way to inactivate microbial matter, but it may also cause destruction of valuable nutrients. A more gentle procedure in this respect is the application of electric fields. A short overview over past activities along with a description of inactivation mechanisms using pulsed electric fields to E. coli has recently been given by El Zakhem et al.7 Other processes of increasing interest employ high hydrostatic pressure (HHP) in single- or multiple-cycle applications, see e.g.8–10 The physiological aspects of HHP on eukaryotic cells have recently been discussed by Frey et al.11 However, although these methods do not require the exposure of the food samples to additional substances the characterization of the samples after the treatment is usually complicated.
The most common approach to enumerate viable cells after inactivation treatment is the total plate count (TPC) method. Small parts of the sample, before and after treatment, are diluted with sterile 0.9% sodium chloride solution and subsequently incubated on plates, e.g., at 37 °C for 24 h. Eventually, the colonies are counted. In general, this procedure is time consuming and complicated.
In contrast, optical spectroscopic methods in principle allow online and in-situ measurements. Techniques based on light scattering phenomena like Raman spectroscopy are actually well suited in this respect, see for instance Ref. 12, however in complex systems such as suspensions containing microorganisms and biochemical substances the interpretation of the spectra can be rather complicated as almost all molecules contribute to the signal. For this reason, more specific methods especially absorption based techniques have gained major impact in numerous fields in engineering applications and fundamental science, see e.g.13–15, as they provide both qualitative and quantitative information of selected species. During the last decade such methods have also entered the area of microbiology and food technology, where most studies investigated the near-infrared spectral range around 1000 nm. For instance, Sasic and Ozaki16 quantitatively analyzed fat, proteins and lactose in milk in the 800–1100 nm spectral region. Büning-Pfaue17 investigated the state of water in different food samples using NIR spectroscopy between 730 and 2300 nm. Wu et al.18 measured the fat, protein and carbohydrate content in milk powder samples using absorption spectroscopy in the 800–1050 nm spectral range. Spectroscopy in the ultraviolet and visible spectral range has also been used to study bacterial cells and their suspensions.19 For instance, Alupoaei et al. employed UV/Vis absorption spectroscopy to obtain quantitative information from E. coli suspensions in order to study the growth behavior of the bacteria.20,21 For analyzing the spectra they developed an interpretation method based on the theory of light scattering, an approximation of the constituents' optical properties and spectral deconvolution approaches.22
In this paper we show the application of absorption spectroscopy in the ultraviolet, visible and near-infrared spectral ranges for the characterization of Escherichia coli samples. E. coli has been selected as an example microorganism because it is well known and therefore often employed for this purpose. E. coli is a gram-negative bacterium with a size of approximately one micron and contains a large number of different proteins, RNAs and ribosomes. The spectroscopy is applied before and after different inactivation procedures employing heat and high-pressure or combinations of both. The results are discussed and compared to the conventional total plate count method.
For the inactivation experiments the main culture was diluted with St1 to obtain a 106 cells/mL suspension. Samples of approximately 2 mL were transferred aseptically to 1.8 mL Cryo.S reaction vials (Greiner bio-one GmbH, Frickenhausen, Germany), which were additionally sealed tightly with Parafilm (Brand GmbH & Co. KG, Wertheim, Germany). The vials had to be filled completely with the liquid in order to avoid air bubbles. The samples were then placed on ice until further handling. For control purposes cell death was induced by heating for 20 min at 65 °C.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Absorption spectra of suspensions with different cell content (cell concentrations: 0 (medium), 5*102 (e2), 6*104 (e4), 7*106 (e6), 7*107 (e7) and 7*108 (e8) cells/mL). In this diagram the curves of the medium and the samples e2 and e4 overlap with each other and can not be distinguished. |
In principle, the spectra at cell concentrations below 105 cells/mL do not differ from each other at all. This defines the lower limit of the sensitivity of the method. In this concentration range the medium is dominating. Going to higher cell number densities the absorption increases in the full spectral range under investigation, hence it can in principle be utilized for cell number determination. In order to select an appropriate or rather the optimal wavelength a computational procedure has been used for the analysis of the spectra. This method has been developed in a previous study for the evaluation of infrared spectra24 and can be described in a nutshell as follows.
The quantification of data obtained from absorption-based techniques is usually based on the Beer–Lambert relation as given in Equation (1)
E = −log10(1 − A) = ε(λ)cd | (1) |
E = m·c + b | (2) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Extinction as a function of cell concentration at 420 nm absorption wavelength: (a) entire cell concentration range investigated, (b) selected range on a log-scale. The diamonds represent experimental data, the solid lines show the best-fit linear functions. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Absorption spectra of selected samples in the spectral range 300–1100 nm (untreated: 106 cells/mL, heat, pressure, combination: completely inactivated (6 log reduction)). Except for the water spectrum all spectra are in close vicinity to each other and can not be distinguished in this diagram. Differences are visible in the enlarged spectra shown in Figs. 5, 6 and 7. |
Fig. 5 illustrates the enlarged spectra in the range between 350 and 400 nm. Obviously, two branches can be distinguished in this spectral range. While the spectra of the untreated sample and that one after high-pressure treatment strictly follow the absorption of the pure medium, the spectra after application of heat (also in combination with high-pressure) show higher absorption. Interestingly, all spectra in the respective branches overlap perfectly. The total plate count method revealed that no microorganisms survived the inactivation treatment (neither high-pressure nor heat or combined). As commonly known the heat treatment destroys the cell membrane and hence the released substances in particular the nucleic acids result in stronger absorption in the spectrum displayed in Fig. 5.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Enlarged absorption spectra in the range 350–400 nm (untreated: 106 cells/mL, heat, pressure, combination: completely inactivated (6 log reduction)). The spectra after pressure and heat, and after only heat treatment form one branch (upper) and all other spectra form another branch (lower) where the individual spectra perfectly overlap with each other. |
In Fig. 6 the enlarged spectra from 800 to 900 nm are displayed. There they split up into three branches, where pure water shows the weakest absorption. The strongest absorption occurs in the spectrum of the sample which was treated with pressure and heat. However, in contrast to the spectral range 350–400 nm the absorption of the sample inactivated by heat only does not follow here. From this result we assume that the pure high-pressure treatment does not affect the cell membrane but causes major damage inside the E. coli bacteria and finally leads to inactivation. Several groups have reported strong influences of high-pressure to the structure of proteins and other biomolecules, see for instance 29–31. This supports our theory. In the spectral range between 800 and 900 nm the damaged cell constituents which are released after heat treatment lead to a stronger absorption, while the undamaged cell contents (also released after heat treatment only) do not show this behavior. As mentioned above the high-pressure treatment influences the structure of, e.g., proteins which in turn can change their optical properties. In the spectrum shown in Fig. 6 it is likely that a modified behavior of some overtone or combination bands of the NH and OH groups lead to a slightly enhanced absorption.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Enlarged absorption spectra in the range 800–900 nm (untreated: 106 cells/mL, heat, pressure, combination: completely inactivated (6 log reduction)). The spectra form three different branches: the upper one is the spectrum after heat and pressure treatment, the lower one is the spectrum of pure water; in between all other spectra form one branch and overlap with each other. |
Fig. 7 shows the spectra between 900 and 1000 nm, i.e. the range where the water absorption occurs. There the water and the pure medium spectra form one branch, while all E. coli containing samples show weaker absorption. At first glance this might be attributed to the fact that the pH value changes in the presence of E. coli compared to water and medium and thus might influence the water vibrational structure. However, we recorded spectra of a number of diluted hydrochloric acid samples in a corresponding pH range and did not see a similar behavior. Therefore, this can not be the true explanation. A more likely reason may be that the water molecules coat the cells in a defined way and as a result the vibration of the water combination band is influenced. However, this requires further investigation in future works as it is beyond the scope of the present paper.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Enlarged absorption spectra in the range 900–1000 nm (untreated: 106 cells/mL, heat, pressure, combination: completely inactivated (6 log reduction)). The spectra of pure water and the pure medium form the upper branch and all other spectra overlap with each other forming the lower branch. |
The differences in the spectra of untreated samples and samples after heat and high-pressure treatments are probably due to different inactivation mechanisms. Obviously, heat treatment causes significant damage of the cell membrane while the applied pure high-pressure procedures cause intracellular damage only. When the cell membrane is damaged the cell contents, i.e., mainly nucleic acids, are released and lead to an enhanced absorption in the ultraviolet. The high-pressure treatment affects the structure of proteins and other biomolecules. However, this manifests in a change in the NIR spectral range, but only when the substances are released into the suspension by a subsequent heat treatment for example. For the sake of completeness it should be mentioned that our experiments have been repeated several times at different days showing similar results, hence indicating the reproducibility of the technique.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |