Antonietta
Pepe
,
Maria Rosaria
Armenante
,
Brigida
Bochicchio
and
Antonio Mario
Tamburro
*
Department of Chemistry, University of Basilicata, Via N. Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy. E-mail: antonio.tamburro@unibas.it; Fax: +39 0971 202223; Tel: +39 0971 202258
First published on 14th October 2008
Elastin and elastin-related peptides have great potential in the biomaterial field, because of their peculiar mechanical properties and spontaneous self-assembling behavior. Depending on their sequences and under appropriate experimental conditions, they are able to self-assemble in different fiber morphologies, including amyloid-like fibers. Temperature-triggered self-assembly of a small elastin peptide shows a novel complex aggregation mechanism as revealed by different microscopy techniques. The conformations of the peptide have been investigated in solution and in the aggregated state by different spectroscopic techniques (CD, NMR, FT-IR) and revealed that the conformations adopted by the peptides in water in the prefibrillar state correspond to those populated by other elastin peptides, mainly polyproline II helix (PPII) and random coil. Conversely, the aggregated state shows evidence for antiparallel cross-β structures. Our molecular studies highlight the important role of PPII conformation on the prefibrillar state, putting forward the hypothesis that aggregation takes place through addition of the monomer in the PPII conformation with preformed β-sheet aggregates and/or through direct interaction of PPII helices.
Extracellular matrix proteins such as elastin and collagen are involved in different self-assembling processes, both producing well defined fibrils and fibers with specific mechanical and supramolecular properties.2 Another class of protein-based fibers are the amyloid fibers, formed by different proteins undergoing misfolding and/or misassembling.3 These aggregation patterns are often associated with pathological states of human diseases [Alzheimer’s disease (AD), diabetes], even though recently different studies point to a functional role of amyloid fibers in nature.4
However, because of the mechanical properties of these fibrillar structures, they have considerable potential as novel biomaterials with applications for nanotechnology.5 Among the proteins able to self-assemble, elastin and elastin-related polypeptides6,7 represent a special group from different points of view: (i) the sequences responsible for their self-assembling as well as for the elastic properties are of reduced size and complexity,8 (ii) important mechanical properties can be tuned by the choice of the sequence building block;9 (iii) several sequences are able to self-assemble into two different aggregation patterns, the classical elastin-like6,10 and the amyloid-type.11 These peculiar features of elastin-related polypeptides render them a special subject of interest, as bionanomaterials with “smart” behavior.12
From a molecular point of view, amyloid fibers are composed of β-strands stacked in an orthogonal way with respect to the fiber axis. The resulting cross-β structures are stabilized by hydrogen bonds, although also other types of interactions, electrostatic and/or hydrophobic, are important. The cross-β structure of the fibers is common to almost all the amyloid fibers, even though the monomeric species are unrelated in terms of sequence, size, hydrophobicity, and secondary structures.
In many cases partial denaturation or misfolding is responsible for the aggregation.13 For example, the proteolysis of APP (Alzheimer precursor protein), determines a transition from the native state to a β-sheet structure in the Aβ peptides, responsible for the amyloid aggregation in Alzheimer’s disease (AD). Experimentally, denaturation and consequently protein aggregation is induced through the addition of chaotropic agents, organic solvents (TFE, HFIP), ionic strength of the solution, or under extreme physical perturbations such as high temperature or pressure values. In several other cases, under appropriate experimental conditions, peptides and proteins—the socalled intrinsically unordered proteins (IUP)—devoid of stable secondary structures, evolve to amyloid fibers. For these samples the aggregation proceeds mainly through a PPII to β-structure transition.14 This is not surprising if we consider that both conformations populate the same upper left Ramachandran map region, thus requiring very small dihedral angle variations for the transition to occur. In addition, possible amyloid fibers directly originating from PPII structured polypeptides, have been suggested.15
With the aim of exploring the possible use of elastin self-assembling peptides for biotechnological applications, we searched for the minimal sequence of elastin responsible for the amyloid-like self-assembly. We have previously reported that the exon30-coded domain of human tropoelastin (EX30 30, GLVGAAGLGGLGVGGLGVPGVGGLG) is able to form amyloid fibers, whose diameter and helical pitch is time-dependent.16,17 The syntheses and self-assembling analysis of different fragments allowed us to identify the smallest amyloidogenic peptide, whose sequence corresponds to the first 17 N-terminal residues of EX30N (EX30N, GLVGAAGLGGLGVGGLG). This peptide contains twice the XGGZG sequence (X, Z = V, L), previously suggested to be responsible for amyloid-formation in elastin-related polypeptides.18 In this report, we will show that this 17 residue fragment of human tropoelastin forms a peculiar aggregation pattern, possessing characteristics of the amyloid fibers, with a great tendency to form nano-films. We determined the conformation of the monomeric species, by CD and NMR spectroscopy, and of the aggregate state, by FT-IR spectroscopy. According to our results also for this peptide a PPII to β-structure transition should be suggested as responsible for amyloid aggregation.
Sequential resonance assignments were made by the approach described by Wüthrich.24
The CD spectrum of EX30N recorded in water at 0 °C shows typical features of PPII, a positive band at ca. 217 nm and a large negative band at 197 nm (Fig. 1a). Although many textbooks still state that the positive (217 nm)–negative (197 nm), non-conservative CD couplet is diagnostic of the random coil, an enormous amount of theoretical and experimental findings argue in favour of the PPII structure.26 Parenthetically, those recent demonstrations have finally done justice to the early suggestions of Tiffany and Krimm.27 Increasing the temperature reduces the contribution of the PPII conformation to the CD spectrum, as evidenced by a progressive disappearance of the band at 217 nm, and a related reduction as well as red shift of the band at 197 nm. Furthermore, the presence of an isoelliptic point at 203 nm clearly indicates a two state equilibrium. CD difference spectra were performed in order to highlight the nature of this transition, revealing the presence of a type I β turn favoured by higher temperature. CD spectra in TFE recorded at different temperatures show a common spectral profile, two negative bands at 202 nm and 220 nm (Fig. 1b). These data suggest the presence of predominant unorder together with β-turn(s).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 CD spectra of EX30N in (a) water and (b) TFE at different temperatures: 0 °C (■), 25 °C (▲) and 60 °C (●). The difference spectrum (60–0 °C) is also shown (inset in a). |
Even though a high number of glycine residues (9 out of 17 residues) are present, a complete resonance assignment was achieved for all the peptide protons (Table SI and SII, ESI†). The NMR data of the sample recorded in H2O–D2O (90 : 10, v/v) exclude the presence of any folded structure. As a matter of fact, the chemical shifts of the Hα proton resonances are all in the range usually assigned to unordered conformations.28 No significant downfield shift is revealed, excluding the presence of a relevant amount of β-strand at 25 °C. The 3JNH-Hα coupling constants of non-glycine residues are in the range 5.8–7.6 Hz, usually assigned to unordered conformations, even though they are compatible also with PPII conformations. Only the valine residues show higher values, approximately 7.9Hz, suggesting a more extended conformation for these residues. While suggestive of the PPII conformation, as shown above by CD spectra, these NMR data alone are not able to define the presence of PPII. For this to occur, it is necessary to perform a careful NOE volume ratio analysis, between sequential dαN and dNN cross-peak volumes. As found by Fiebig et al.29 by statistical analysis, the random coil conformation should have an NOE ratio [αN(i,i + 1)/NN(i,i + 1] of 1.4 for the sequential backbone cross-peaks, while for the extended conformations the higher distance of sequential amide protons increases the ratio to a value of 55.30Fig. 2a shows the fingerprint (Hα-HN) and the amide (NH-NH) region of the ROESY spectrum of EX30N recorded in H2O–D2O (90 : 10) at 25 °C. The regions are displayed with the same threshold in order to highlight the difference in intensity of the cross-peaks. From the analysis of NOE volume, we were able to define the NOE ratio for some of not overlapping peaks (Table SIII, ESI†). The tabulated values show ratio values ranging from 0.97–11. In particular for the central region of the peptide, increased values are recorded (G7 = 11; L8 = 3.2; L11 = 3.6), suggesting that the time spent in the PPII conformation by the single residues at 25 °C is significant.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The fingerprint region and the amide region of the ROESY spectra of EX30Npeptide recorded in H2O–D2O (90 : 10) at 298 K. The regions were displayed with the same threshold, in order to highlight the difference in intensity of the cross-peaks (A). Summary of sequential and medium range NOEs. The NOE intensities are reflected by the thickness of the line. * refers to overlapped peaks (B). |
The analysis of the EX30Npeptide in TFE-d3–H2O (80 : 20) by NMR spectroscopy provides evidence for the presence of several β-turns, most probably rapidly interconverting. As a matter of fact, reduced temperature coefficients for some residues were found; these findings indicate a reduced exposition to the solvent, usually ascribed to hydrogen bonding.31 In detail, G7, G10, L11, V13, G15,and L16 show temperature coefficients in the range of 4.0–4.5 ppb K−1, values usually attributed to very weak H-bonds or to an equilibrium between turn and other conformations devoid of H-bonds. In the case of β-turns, the lowered temperature coefficient is due to the presence of a hydrogen bond between the amide proton of the fourth residue and the carbonyl group of the first residue of the turn. Further evidence of turn structures are some intense sequential dNN(i,i + 1) values and typical medium range NOE [dαN(i,i + 2)] identified for residue L8-G10 and L11-V13 (Fig. 3). It was not possible to identify the typical medium range NOE [dαN(i,i + 2)] for all suggested turn structures, because of high overlap in the glycine residue region. In other cases, where overlap was not present, we could only suggest the presence of rapidly interconverting (sliding) β-turns, whose time spent in β-turn is reduced and consequently not revealed by the slow NMR time scale. The overall picture highlights a dynamic structural ensemble and reveals a good agreement with the CD results.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 The fingerprint region and the amide region of the NOESY spectra of EX30Npeptide recorded in TFE-d3–H2O (80 : 20) 289 K. (A). Summary of the NMR sequential and medium range NOEs. The NOE intensities are reflected by the thickness of the line. * refers to overlapped peaks (B). |
The presence of sliding β-turns in the general elastin repeat sequence XGGZG (with X, Z = V, L) is not surprising as they were previously ascertained for (LGGVG)n,32 and many other elastin-related polypeptides.33
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Decomposed FT-IR spectra of EX30N fibers in KBr pellets. (a) Amide I and II region. (b) Amide A region. After dehydration (c) amide I and II regions show only slight variations, while (d) amide A region shows the absence of water-related OH stretchings. |
It should be noted that the studies in aqueous solution exclude the presence of β-strands or β-sheets in significant amounts. Only FT-IR spectra of the aggregated sample revealed the presence of antiparallel β-sheets and cross-β structures. This observation prompted us to suggest a model for aggregation involving the PPII as the prefibrillar conformation.
The dihedral angles characterizing the PPII structure (ϕ = − 78; ψ = +150) are in a region of the Ramachandran map very close to that typical of β-sheet structures, and, consequently, only small variations are necessary for the transition to take place.
Accordingly, an “induced fit” model could be proposed (Fig. 5). The highly flexible monomers, populating significantly PPII conformations, would be expected to readily interact with each other or with preformed β-sheet seeds, by adapting slightly their dihedral angles. PPII has been proposed as the prefibrillar conformation in other amyloid-forming proteins,14,15,36 reinforced by recent demonstrations of significant amounts of PPII in the Alzheimer amyloid peptides, Aβ(1–28)37 and Aβ(12–28).38
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Simplified model of aggregation of elastin peptideEX30N. (i) PPII monomer interacts with preformed antiparallel β-sheet seeds, and adopts the β-sheet structure. (ii) PPII monomer aggregates with PPII antiparallel helices interacting through H- bonds. |
Alternatively, on the basis of our results, an aggregation model directly implying PPII conformations could not be completely ruled out. An example of this kind of aggregation pattern has been previously reported for (APG)n39 and (PGG)n.40 In these models PPII helices aggregated to form zigzag sheets, with neighboring antiparallel chains joined by interchain hydrogen bonding.41 The absence of proline residues in the EX30Npeptide could argue against this structure, nevertheless recent work of Ohnishi et al. revealed the presence of polyglycine II (PGII) structures (with dihedral angles, ϕ = −80; ψ = 150, identical to PPII) in the aggregated state of glycine-rich peptides. According to their NMR and small-angle X-ray scattering data the monomeric state shows direct evidence of PGII elongated structures, retained in the solid state of the aggregated samples. PGII favours the intermolecular association through backbone hydrogen bonding, thus prompting aggregation.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Turbidimetry experiment on the EX30Npeptide, 4.0 mM in water. The turbidimetry on apparent absorbance (TAA) was recorded at λ = 440 nm as a function of time at room temperature (■) and at 50 °C (▲). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Birefringence of Congo red stained EX30Npeptide fibers viewed by cross-polarization microscopy. (a) Bright field. (b) Cross-polarized light. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Room temperature self-assembly of EX30Npeptides in aqueous solution as amyloid-like filaments examined by TEM. (a) Amorphous aggregates with long fibrils; (b) short flexible protofilaments; (c) long fibrils; (d) after 2 months of incubation mature fibers with ribbon-like aspect are observed; samples were negatively stained by 1% uranyl acetate solution. |
In order to analyze the sample, we sonicated for 30 s the 1 h incubated solution prior to sample preparation. Sonication was able to break some of the unspecific bonds (weak surface interactions), thus allowing detailed analysis of the aggregates (Fig. 9). A fine network structure is revealed, composed of long unbranched rods, in some regions aligned in a parallel manner, in others irregularly spreading. While the diameter of the fibers did not change during incubation, an increase in intermolecular and inter-fiber interactions of a hydrophobic nature is suggested. As a matter of fact, the sequence of EX30N is formed exclusively by glycines and hydrophobic residues (A, L, V), prompting us to suggest that the only energetically favourable side-chain interactions able to stabilize the basic β-conformation of the amyloid fiber should be of hydrophobic nature. Increasing the temperature, analogously to coacervation of elastin,16,45 could induce the expulsion of water and trigger self-assemblyvia hydrophobic collapse.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 TEM image of EX30N sample sonicated after 1 h of incubation at 50 °C. A film of irregularly spread fibrils is revealed. The sample was negatively stained by 1% uranyl acetate solution. |
ESEM offers the opportunity to work on biological samples without complex and artifact-generating manipulations. Nevertheless, ESEM has been assigned a reduced importance in amyloid ultra-structural analysis, mainly carried out by TEM and AFM (atomic force microscopy). Only a few studies on amyloid-forming proteins and peptides have conducted by ESEM, showing reticular,46 fibrillar,47 and spherical48 higher-order supramolecular structures.
The sample was analyzed by ESEM immediately after withdrawal from the solution. The initial images of EX30N show the presence of globules of uniform size (diameter, approximately 0.5–0.7 µm) (Fig. 10). These almost spherical particles are closely packed and evolve after 20 min incubation at 50 °C to highly flexible protofibrils, prone to forming a thin film. After 40 min of incubation a complex reticular network is formed. The connections between the fibrils increase and a developing film covering the network was observable in several sites.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 ESEM micrographs of EXN30peptide incubated at 50 °C at different incubation times. (a) Time = 0, closely packed globules of ca. 0.5–0.7 µm diameter; (b) t = 20 min, flexible protofibrils; (c) t = 40 min, a complex reticular network; (d) t = 70 min, a dense viscoelastic film with starting globules in the background. (e) t = 19 h and (f) t = 6 d, a compact film. |
After 70 min, in many points of the specimen a dense viscoelastic film has formed. In the background the starting globules are still evident. After 19 h the formation of a compact film is witnessed by the presence of large bubbles coming out from the peptide film. In some points holes are visible where the water bubbles escaped from the surface.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 AFM images of EX30Npeptide. (a) At room temperature, elongated structures are present; b) after 1 h incubation at 50 °C. |
The molecular studies highlight the important role of PPII conformations for the prefibrillar state, suggesting that aggregation takes place through addition of the monomer in the PPII conformation with the preformed β-sheet aggregate.
Some authors proposed glycine residues as an evolutionary strategy to avoid amyloid aggregation,49 our data conversely suggest that the presence of a high number of glycine residues, prompting the adoption of PPII conformation, can induce amyloid fiber formation either through cross-β structures or directly through interaction of PPII helices. Obviously, the two processes are not necessary mutually exclusive. Once again the simplest amino acid in nature, glycine, shows a highly flexible behavior that could not be easily rationalized.
The supramolecular studies revealed a complex nano-aggregation profile that starting from globules evolve further in a compact film through an amyloid aggregation mechanism. For the first time this evolution has been monitored in detail by different microscopy techniques, that is TEM, AFM, and mainly ESEM, pointing out a complex self-assembling mechanism where globules are the starting point for the production of a thin nano-film. Some other amyloid-forming proteins are able to form spherical structures, called spherulites or simply spherical aggregates formed after proper evolution, often as an alternative aggregation pathway.20 Conversely, EX30N elastin peptide shows spherical aggregates, composed of amyloid fibrils, as a starting point, evolving later into a complex three-dimensional network, which cumulates in a film layer, obtained by side-by-side interacting fibrils.
These peptide-nanostructures have many potential applications in various fields including tissue engineering, and materials science. For instance, the propensity to form a thin film could be exploited for a biocompatible coating of artificial grafts, in order to improve the performance and potency of small-diameter vascular grafts. Further studies in this direction are still in progress.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Proton resonance assignments of EX30N in H2O–D2O (90 : 10) and in TFE-d3–H2O (80 : 20); NOE ratio analysis. See DOI: 10.1039/b811286j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2009 |