Karin S.
Straley
a and
Sarah C.
Heilshorn
*b
aChemical Engineering Department, Stanford University, 466 Lomita Mall, Moore Building, Room 271, 94305-4045, USA
bMaterials Science and Engineering Department, Stanford University, 476 Lomita Mall, McCullough Building, Room 246, Stanford, CA 94305-4045, USA. E-mail: heilshorn@stanford.edu; Fax: +1-650-498-5596; Tel: +1-650-723-3763
First published on 23rd October 2008
A key attribute missing from many current biomaterials is the ability to independently tune multiple biomaterial properties without simultaneously affecting other material parameters. Because cells are well known to respond to changes in the initial elastic modulus, degradation rate, and cell adhesivity of a biomaterial, it is critical to develop synthetic design strategies that allow decoupled tailoring of each individual parameter in order to systematically optimize cell-scaffold interactions. We present the development of a biomimetic scaffold composed of chemically crosslinked, elastin-like proteins designed to support neural regeneration through a combination of cell adhesion and cell-induced degradation and remodeling. The design of these engineered proteins includes cell adhesion sequences to enable neuronal attachment as well as sequences sensitive to cleavage by urokinase plasminogen activator (uPA), a protease locally secreted from the tips of growing neurites, to enable highly localized and tunable degradation properties. These engineered proteins are produced using recombinant techniques and chemically crosslinked into highly swollen hydrogels with controllable mechanical properties. Through a modest 3% change in the chemical identity of three otherwise identical engineered proteins, we can modify the uPA substrate specificity resulting in tunable changes in protease degradation half-life over two orders of magnitude. Under high uPA exposure, the designed scaffolds exhibit systematic variation of scaffold lifetime, from being fully degraded within a single day to showing no noticeable degradation within a full week. In vitro studies using the model PC-12 neuronal-like cell line show that the crosslinked proteins support tunable cell adhesion and neuronal differentiation. Increasing the density of RGD peptides present in the protein substrates leads to increased cell adhesion and more extensive neurite outgrowth. These engineered proteins offer the ability to independently tailor the mechanics, degradation properties, and cell adhesivity of scaffolds for the study of central nervous system regeneration.
Biodegradable materials are the preferred choice for construction of CNS regeneration scaffolds.3,6–8 These materials eliminate complications resulting from a permanent implant, such as compression of regenerating nerves or a prolonged inflammatory response, which may necessitate a second surgery for removal.3,7,9 In addition, biodegradable materials aim to promote nerve growth by providing a less obstructive regeneration environment that can be replaced by cells and their matrix.7,8 The most common biodegradation strategy involves materials that degrade uniformly over time at the bulk level due to hydrolysis.6,10–12 For example, by creating PEG-PLA scaffolds with faster degradation kinetics, the outgrowth of neural processes was shown to be enhanced.13 In contrast, natural scaffolds such as chitosan, fibrin, and collagen degrade in response to enzymes prevalent in the extracellular matrix (ECM).14–16 Similar to the synthetic scaffolds, enhanced fibrin matrix degradation via enzymatic action of serine proteases has been linked to increased neurite extension.14 Taken together, these results suggest that tailoring the rate of biomaterial degradation may be a useful strategy to control the rate of neuronal outgrowth in CNS regeneration scaffolds.
Synthetic mimics of the naturally degradable ECM environment have been designed by incorporating short, protease-sensitive peptide sequences into synthetic polymeric scaffolds.17–20 By increasing the protease sensitivity of these polymers to matrix metalloproteinase, the outgrowth of fibroblast cells and migration of osteoblasts have been enhanced.19–21 A key advantage of this technique over traditional hydrolytic degradation is that the biomaterial can respond to local changes in cellular behavior, which may vary from patient to patient and site to site, while hydrolytic cleavage cannot be tuned post-implantation. However, because the protease-sensitive peptide sequences are also used as crosslinking sites within these scaffolds, the degradation properties and the initial mechanical properties of these materials cannot be independently tuned.
Because neural cells are known to respond to the mechanical properties,22–25 degradation properties,13,14 and cell adhesive properties of scaffolds,26–29 our goal is to design a family of biomaterials that allows independent tuning of all three variables. Current biomaterials, including synthetic polymeric matrices, harvested natural biopolymers, and synthetic/natural hybrids, generally cannot independently tune the initial mechanical properties, degradation rate, or cell adhesivity without simultaneously affecting other material properties.30,31 For CNS nerve grafts, it is particularly important to fabricate a scaffold that allows neurons to locally degrade a material at the site of regeneration while simultaneously maintaining the bulk structural integrity of the implant. This approach is aimed at enhancing neurite outgrowth and preventing material collapse, which has been a confounding factor in many biodegradable peripheral nervous system and CNS guidance channels.32–34
To achieve this goal, we have designed a scaffold composed entirely of engineered proteins that mimics many of the essential characteristics of the natural ECM (Fig. 1). To our knowledge this is the first application of full length engineered proteins in the construction of nerve regeneration scaffolds. Recent work with self-assembled peptide amphiphiles has demonstrated the efficacy of using peptide containing materials to inhibit glial scar formation and promote neurite outgrowth in mouse spinal cords.26,27 Our protein polymers are synthesized using recombinant protein technology in order to exercise exact molecular-level control over the polymer composition. In addition, protein materials release no cytotoxic degradation fragments, can easily incorporate bioactive functionalities, and can be chemically crosslinked to form hydrogel scaffolds.35–37 A key advantage of recombinant protein engineering is the modular design and templated synthesis that allows creation of an entire family of polymers with similar amino acid sequences and precisely altered material properties. Here we demonstrate this advantage by designing a family of biomaterials with independently tunable mechanical properties, degradation rates, and cell adhesivity.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Amino acid sequences of the engineered proteins (EK refers to enterokinase, ↑ refers to the predicted uPA protease cut site). |
Specifically, the engineered protein polymers detailed in this paper are composed of alternating elastin-like structural sequences and bioactive peptide sequences.38–40 To promote cell adhesion, the extended RGD sequence of fibronectin was designed into the protein. This sequence has been previously shown to promote neurite attachment due to interaction with integrins displayed on the surfaces of neurites.41 To induce local neuronal remodeling of the engineered protein, protease cleavage sequences of varying sensitivity to the enzyme urokinase plasminogen activator (uPA) were designed into the protein. The uPA enzyme is a member of the serine protease family, has been shown to be locally secreted from the tips of neuronal growth cones, and is thought to provide a mechanism for remodeling the natural ECM.42,43 We hypothesize that neurons may be able to degrade these engineered proteins specifically at the site of neurite elongation to create tunnels for neurite extension without compromising the bulk integrity of the scaffold. By varying the rate of scaffold degradation, it may be possible to influence the speed of neurite elongation to promote nerve regeneration.
These materials are intended for eventual use as pre-formed, implantable nerve grafts, either with or without the pre-seeding of exogenous cells. This type of implant is designed to link severed nerves to their original contacts, serving as a bridge across the inhibitory CNS injury site. In the peripheral nervous system, nerve grafts are commonly used to provide a regenerative growth environment and guidance for growing neurons.44–46 Initial successes using peripheral nerve graft implants in the CNS have led to substantial interest in designing artificial, cell-free nerve grafts for the inhibitory CNS environment.4,45
In this paper, our engineered protein polymers are shown to be easily produced in Escherichia coli bacteria, purified, and chemically crosslinked into protein scaffolds with tunable elastic moduli. The protease sensitive proteins are shown to exhibit controlled degradation in both their uncrosslinked and crosslinked forms. A 3% change in monomer sequence at the protease cleavage site was shown to result in a greater than 200-fold change in protease degradation half-life of the uncrosslinked protein polymers. This same amino acid change was also shown to result in crosslinked films that ranged from fully degraded at one day to virtually non-degradable after seven days of constant uPA exposure. In vitro studies using the model PC-12 neuronal-like cell line indicate that crosslinked protein scaffolds containing the RGD domain from fibronectin support cell adhesion, neuronal differentiation, and neurite extension. We demonstrate direct control over the cell adhesivity and neurite outgrowth by tuning the density of RGD peptides within the scaffold.
Unlike most biomaterials, this new family of scaffolds has the distinct advantage of allowing the initial mechanical properties, the degradation properties, and the cell adhesive properties to be tailored independently without adversely affecting the other material properties. These biomaterials provide an ideal framework for conducting systematic studies into the optimal scaffold material properties required for CNS repair.
The tag domain was ligated into pET15b (Novagen, San Diego, CA) to form Tag-pET15b. The bioactive domains were ligated into pUC18 to form Bio-pUC18. The elastin-like monomer domain was multimerized using T4 DNA ligase at 4 °C for 3 min and the trimer reaction product was isolated by gel electrophoresis and ligated into Bio-pUC18 to form Bio-[Elastin]3-pUC18. The bioactive and elastin-like domains were removed from Bio-[Elastin]3-pUC18 with SalI and XhoI and ligated into Tag-pET15b digested with XhoI to form Tag-[Bio-[Elastin]3]-pET15b. This reaction was repeated three times to form Tag-[Bio-[Elastin]3]4-pET15b, and the final plasmid content was confirmed by sequencing (Stanford PAN Facility).
The compressive elastic modulus of each protein was determined in triplicate using a TA AR2000 Rheometer (New Castle, DE), compressive rate of 2 µm/s, 22 °C, in PBS buffer (pH = 7.4). Compressive elastic moduli (E) were determined by measuring the slope of the initial linear portion of the stress-strain curve (0–15% strain).
The average molecular weight between crosslinks (Mc) was estimated using rubber elasticity theory according to Equation 1, where ρ is the protein density (approximated as 1.35 g/mL),47 R is the ideal gas constant, and T is temperature.48 Mc was used to estimate the percentage of lysines reacted during protein crosslinking.
![]() | (1) |
The water content (W) was measured in duplicate using Equation 2, where ms is the weight of the hydrated sample and md is the weight of the dehydrated sample. Dehydrated material was prepared using a vacuum oven operated at 50 °C for 24 hrs.
![]() | (2) |
The volumetric swelling ratio (Q) was determined in duplicate using Equation 3, where ρpolymer is the density of the protein polymer (approximated as 1.35 g/mL) and ρsolvent is the density of the solvent (approximated as 1.0 g/mL).
![]() | (3) |
Protein bands were transferred to a PVDF membrane in 1x CAPS buffer (100 mA, for 1 h, at 4 °C). The membranes were stained with Coomassie for 45 s and destained (45% methanol, 45% water, 10% acetic acid) for ∼1 h. The desired bands were cut from the membrane and submitted for N-terminal Edman degradation sequencing at the Stanford PAN Facility (Stanford, CA).
All samples were thawed at 4 °C, and 10 µL of sodium borate buffer and 20 µL of 0.05% 2,4,6-trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBSA, Pierce Biotechnology, Rockford, IL) were added to each well. The TNBSA was allowed to react with the primary amines contained in each sample at 4 °C with agitation for ∼1 h. The absorbance at 425 nm was determined for all samples using a Molecular Devices SpectraMax Plus384 Spectrophotometer (Sunnyvale, CA). The kinetic data was fit to the Michaelis-Menten equation by applying an iterative Levenberg-Marquardt algorithim using KaleidaGraph version 4.03 software (Synergy Software, Reading, PA).
To prepare collagen control surfaces, glass coverslips (12 mm diameter) were sterilized with 100% ethanol for 20 min, rinsed three times with cold PBS, and incubated with rat tail collagen I (50 µg/mL in PBS, Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO)) overnight at 4 °C.
All coverslips (including plain glass controls) were then rinsed three times with PBS, blocked with BSA (fraction V, 0.2% in PBS, heat inactivated at 85 °C for 10 min) to prevent non-specific binding, and rinsed three more times with PBS.
PC-12 cells (passage 6) were plated onto films at a density of 10,000 cells/cm2 and cultured in F12 Kaighn's complete media for 6 days. Cultures were then washed 1x with PBS buffer, stained with 1.5 µM Calcien AM in PBS (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA), and fluorescently imaged (20 fields per sample, field size = 0.36 mm2, in triplicate) with an inverted Zeiss Axiovert 200 microscope (Oberkochen, Germany, 20x objective) and a CCD camera. Statistical significance between data sets was determined using a paired, two-tailed Student's t-test.
To prepare control surfaces, collagen I from rat tail (50 µg/mL in PBS) and 0.1% Poly-L-Lysine (PLL) hydrobromide solution (Polysciences, Inc. (Warrington, PA)) were incubated in wells overnight at 4 °C. All wells (including plain wells) were then rinsed three times with PBS, blocked with BSA (fraction V, 0.2% in PBS, heat inactivated at 85 °C for 10 min) to prevent non-specific binding, and rinsed three more times with PBS.
PC-12 cells (passage 6) were plated in each well at density of 15,000 cells/cm2 and differentiated in F12 Kaighn's differentiation media for 6 days. AlamarBlue® reagent (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) was added directly to the media in each well at 1/10 volume and incubated at 37 °C for 13 hrs. Absorbance readings were taken at 570 nm and 600 nm. The fraction of reduced alamarBlue® reagent was calculated according to manufacturer's instructions. Statistical significance between data sets was determined using a paired, two-tailed Student's t-test.
The fluorescently labeled cells were visualized following 6 days of differentiation with an inverted Zeiss Axiovert 200 microscope (40x objective) and digital images were captured with a CCD camera.
The structural domain included in each protein mimics the repeated VPGVG sequence found naturally in elastin, a fibrous protein present in connective tissue that is known to provide both elasticity and resilience.37 Elastin-like polypeptides have been previously shown to be biocompatible, to express well in bacterial fermentation, and to be easily and inexpensively purified using a simple thermal cycling technique.39,50 In addition to providing our scaffolds with elasticity and resilience, the elastin-like sequences provide a relatively bioinert backbone for the presentation of bioactive peptides.39
Bacterial expressions of these polymers resulted in un-optimized protein yields that ranged from 25 to 50 mg/L. Amino acid analysis of the purified protein products confirmed that the sequences were within 2% of that predicted from the primary sequence (see supplemental data). The proteins were purified using a simple thermal cycling technique made possible by the thermodynamic properties of the elastin-like sequences.35,50 The hydrophobic elastin-like sequences cause the proteins to exhibit lower critical solution temperature (LCST) behavior.51 Below the LCST, the proteins are readily soluble in water while above the LCST, the proteins aggregate to form a protein-rich coacervate that can be separated by centrifugation. Based on previous work relating specific elastin-like sequences to LCST behavior, the elastin-like sequence VPGIG was chosen to facilitate purification by thermal cycling between 4 °C and 37 °C, temperatures commonly found in a molecular biology laboratory.51 The LCST values for each protein were evaluated and found to be between 31 °C and 34 °C (see supplemental data). These LCST values supported the use of 4 °C for solubilization of the protein and 37 °C for precipitation of the protein in the thermal cycling purification technique.
Crosslinking Stoichiometric Ratio | Water Content (%) | Volumetric Swelling Ratio (Q) | Compressive Elastic Modulus (kPa) | Mc × 1000 (g/mol)a | Reacted Amines (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Complete amine consumption yields an approximate Mc of 2,700 g/mol. | |||||
0.75:1 | 87.2 ± 0.1 | 10.2 ± 0.1 | 45.7 ± 7.2 | 26.8 ± 4.2 | 10.2 ± 1.6 |
1.5:1 | 85.4 ± 0.3 | 8.9 ± 0.2 | 63.3 ± 3.6 | 19.4 ± 1.1 | 14.1 ± 0.8 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Compressive stress versus strain curves for u1 protein crosslinked using two different crosslinking reaction stoichiometries. |
Tunable mechanical properties as evident in our materials are hypothesized to be an important characteristic in the design of a material implant. It is conjectured that matching the mechanical properties of a material to that of surrounding native tissue more closely mimics the natural cellular environment and may encourage cell movement across the implant-native tissue boundary.13,53–55 Furthermore, recent experimental evidence indicates that the mechanical strength of a material can directly affect cell growth and differentiation.22–25 There is some disagreement in the literature concerning the appropriate elastic modulus value which effectively imitates spinal cord tissue; the most common values reported range from approximately 3 kPa to 300 kPa.56,57 Our crosslinked material presently exhibits an elastic modulus within the range measured for spinal cord tissue.
Another key attribute of our crosslinked protein scaffolds is their highly swollen, hydrogel structure. Highly swollen networks allow for diffusion of nutrients and growth factors and provide open space for the migration of cells through a material implant.58 The water content of the swollen u1 materials was measured to be 85–87% and the volumetric swelling ratios of the materials were calculated to be from 8 to10 (Table 1). The water content of these materials are comparable to other nerve regeneration scaffolds constructed from PHEMA (85% water content) and are slightly less swollen than degradable PEG hydrogels previously used for neural applications (Q ∼12–16).13,55
The degradation properties of these proteins were first characterized without chemical crosslinking in the presence of uPA under physiological conditions. The high enzyme concentration (528 U/mL) used in these reactions was not chosen to mimic in vivo concentrations of uPA, but was instead selected to be similar in range to previous uPA kinetics experiments in order to create more manageable experimental time points.59 Gel electrophoresis of the degradation fragments present at a range of time points for a representative u1 degradation reaction is shown in Fig. 3. As shown in this gel, the full protein degrades to smaller fragments throughout the course of the reaction and predominantly results in the formation of one final fragment, approximately 10 kDa in weight (circled). This band was excised from the gel and sequenced to determine the specificity of the degradation reaction. The band was found to possess an N-terminal sequence of SASPASSA, which is present directly after the predicted protease cut site, arginine, (Fig. 1), thus confirming the degradation reaction specificity.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Representative SDS-PAGE gel of u1 protein fragments generated by degradation with 528 U/mL uPA enzyme (circled band was analyzed by N-terminal sequencing). |
A more thorough analysis of the multiple degradation bands on the gel further supports the reaction specificity. Evident in Fig. 3 is the presence of very distinct protein degradation bands, as opposed to blurred bands, indicating highly specific cuts. The full u1 protein (37.7 kDa) contains four engineered cut sites (Fig. 1) allowing for the possible formation of 11 different sizes of specifically degraded fragments (see supplemental data for detailed mapping of gel fragments). The presence of less intense minor bands on the gel are likely due to uPA cleavage at lysine residues in the protein, which has been previously shown to occur at a much slower rate than cleavage at the engineered arginine cut sites.59 Many of these lysine residues will be consumed after chemically crosslinking the proteins, thus limiting the occurrence of these minor reactions.
Densitometry analysis was performed on SDS-PAGE gels run in triplicate to directly compare the degradation rates of u1, u2, and u3. The u1 protein degraded approximately 200-times faster than u3, and the u2 protein degraded approximately 11-times faster than the u3 protein, Fig. 4. The proteins were shown to have the following half-lives: 0.1 hours for u1, 1.1 hours for u2, and 20.6 hours for u3, when exposed to high uPA concentrations (5 U/mL). The results of this analysis were further corroborated using a colorimetric reaction to detect the newly created amine groups upon each peptide bond cleavage event for the two proteins with appreciable degradation: u1 and u2. Engineered protein u1 was shown to produce free amines at a significantly higher rate than u2, corresponding to a faster degradation rate (Fig. 5). The uPA enzyme is known to follow standard Michaelis-Menten enzyme kinetics, and plots of cleavage rate versus substrate protein concentration fit well to the Michaelis-Menten model. For the u1 protein, kcat and Km were determined to be 14.5 ± 2.2 s−1 and 327.7 ± 24.9 µM, respectively. We were unable to determine exact values of kcat and Km for the u2 protein due to significant fitting error, likely resulting from high viscosity (and hence poor mixing) of protein solutions above the predicted Km. However, the observed maximum reaction velocity of u1 was approximately 10-times greater than u2. Taken together, these results demonstrate that molecular-level design of the engineered proteins can vary the degradation rate over two orders of magnitude and substantiate the transfer of bioactivity from a short peptide sequence to the full-length protein polymer.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Relative degradation rates of uncrosslinked u1 and u2 (inset of u3) generated by SDS-PAGE densitometry analysis of the degradation fragments produced over time upon exposure to 528 U/mL uPA enzyme. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Rate of primary amine production from degradation of uncrosslinked u1 and u2 protein with 270 U/µL of uPA enzyme. |
To confirm that these differences in protein degradation would result in altered degradation of the bulk scaffold, each engineered protein was chemically crosslinked to form a three-dimensional sheet (1:1 NHS esters: primary amines crosslinking stoichiometry). Each bulk scaffold was exposed to 300 U/mL uPA in buffer at room temperature. This high enzyme concentration was chosen to create manageable timepoints to accurately measure the compressive elastic modulus of each sample. The degradation of the materials was evaluated by monitoring the change in compressive elastic modulus over time. Crosslinked scaffolds displayed tunable degradation properties similar to the uncrosslinked protein polymers; the u1 protein fully degraded at around 24 hours, the u2 protein fully degraded at around 164 hours, and the u3 protein showed no detectable degradation after 164 hours (Fig. 6). These results demonstrate that by changing only 3% of the amino acid side chains in the engineered proteins, scaffolds with similar initial mechanical properties and dramatically altered degradation rates can be created.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Change in compressive elastic modulus due to degradation of crosslinked u1, u2, and u3 scaffolds with 300 U/mL uPA enzyme. |
PC-12 cell adhesion was evaluated after 6 days of culture in growth medium without differentiation cues on the crosslinked protein scaffolds using calecin AM staining (Fig. 7, see supplemental data for detailed statistical comparison). Collagen, a material commonly used to promote PC-12 adhesion,61 was used as a positive control, while the negative control was bovine serum albumin (BSA), a common blocking agent to prevent adhesion. Cell adhesion on the RDG scaffold and BSA negative controls was significantly less than on all other substrates. This result confirms that the elastin backbone represents a relatively inert background upon which biofunctional peptides can be presented. Cell adhesion on scaffolds with a 1:1 ratio of RDG:RGD proteins is significantly greater than adhesion on RDG scaffolds, confirming that cell adhesion is due to specific cellular interactions with the RGD peptide sequence. All scaffolds comprised of 50% RGD protein (with remaining 50% of u1, u2, u3, or RDG), showed similar cell adhesivity. This result implies that the protease degradation sequences do not interfere with nor contribute to cell adhesion; thereby allowing independent tuning of cell adhesivity and scaffold degradation.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Comparison of PC-12 cell adhesion after 6 days of growth without differentiation medium on various substrates. *BSA and RDG are statistically different (p < 0.05) from all other substrates. |
Next, PC-12 cell adhesion was evaluated after 6 days of culture in differentiation medium (in the presence of 50 ng/mL NGF) by monitoring the reduction of the alamarBlue® reagent (Fig. 8, see supplemental data for detailed statistical comparison). An increase in reagent reduction correlates to an increase in metabolic intermediates (e.g. NADH, NADPH, and FADH) produced by viable cells; therefore reagent reduction is commonly used as a quantitative measure of the number of cells present.62 An adsorbed poly-L-lysine (PLL) coating is included as an additional positive control. PLL is a commonly used substrate that promotes neuronal adhesion through electrostatic interactions.61 Most evident from this assay is the dramatic decrease in cells present when RGD is replaced by RDG (u1:RGD vs. u1:RDG (p = 0.027), u2:RGD vs. u2:RDG (p = 0.028), u3:RGD vs. u3:RDG (p = 0.067), and RDG:RGD vs. RDG (p = 0.002)). Also, the number of cells present is similar in u1:RGD, u2:RGD, u3:RGD, and RDG:RGD, again confirming that scaffold degradation can be tuned independently from cell adhesivity.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Comparison of PC-12 cell adhesion after 6 days of differentiation on various substrates. *Substrates are statistically different, p < 0.05. |
In addition, these results suggest that the degree of cell adhesivity can be tuned by controlling the density of RGD cell-binding domains within the crosslinked scaffold. Scaffolds comprised entirely of the RGD protein are estimated to contain ∼ 9,300 RGD binding sites/µm2, while 1:1 RDG:RGD scaffolds contain ∼ 4,650 and RDG scaffolds contain 0 RGD binding sites/µm2; assuming the scaffold density is 8.2 µg protein/mm3 (estimated from swelling data in Table 1 and the concentration of protein in the spincoated crosslinking solutions) and cell integrins can penetrate a depth of 18 nm into the scaffold.63 Comparing PC-12 cell adhesion on these three protein scaffolds, we observe that cell adhesion is directly related to RGD binding site density, Fig. 8. Therefore, by tuning the relative ratio of RGD and RDG proteins, we can tailor the cell adhesivity of the scaffold.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 Representative fluorescent images of PC-12 cells differentiated for 6 days on a) u1:RGD b) u2:RGD c) u3:RGD d) RDG:RGD e) RGD f) Collagen g) RDG h) BSA; nuclei stained with DAPI in blue, cytoplasm stained with neuron-specific β-tubulin in green, scale bar = 50 µm. |
To quantitatively assess the morphological differences caused by RGD binding site density, 94 images of each engineered scaffold were analyzed in triplicate, (Fig. 10, see supplemental data for detailed statistical comparison). By increasing the total amount of RGD present in the film, the number of adherent cells, the percentage of cells possessing neurites greater than one cell diameter in length, and the percentage of cells possessing neurites greater than two cell diameters in length were all found to increase. The RDG film was statistically less adherent to differentiated cells than all other scaffolds (Fig. 10a). The percentage of cells with neurites greater than one cell diameter (Fig. 10b) and the percentage of cells with neurites greater than two cell diameters (Fig. 10c) were statistically different on scaffolds with 0; 4,650; and 9,300 RGD binding sites/µm2. The scaffold comprised solely of RGD protein differentiated fewer cells than the positive collagen control, indicating that further optimization of the cell adhesion ligand density and the addition of other adhesion sequences should be investigated to further enhance the ability of these designed materials to support cell adhesion, neuronal differentiation, and neurite outgrowth.27,41
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 Comparison of PC-12 cells after 6 days of differentiation on RDG, 1:1 RDG:RGD, RGD, and collagen films in terms of a) cells/mm2 b) percentage of cells with neurites greater than one cell diameter and c) percentage of cells with neurites greater than two cell diameters. *Substrate is statistically different from all other substrates, p < 0.05. |
The tunable cell adhesion, neuronal differentiation, and neurite outgrowth properties displayed by our engineered proteins encourage further use of these scaffolds to study the optimal initial mechanics, degradation rate, and ligand content to encourage nerve regeneration. While several groups are investigating the effects of elastic modulus and ligand density on neurite outgrowth,24,25,27,28 at present the optimal degradation rate to promote neurite outgrowth is largely unknown. Furthermore, the potential cross-talk between these multiple points of cell-scaffold interaction are only just beginning to be explored.30,64 These types of important studies require the design of biomaterials that allow the systematic tuning of specific material parameters without impacting other material properties.
In specific, by using the precise protein synthesis machinery present in bacteria, we have designed a family of biomaterials that mimics cell-adhesive and cell-responsive properties of the regenerative nerve environment. Here we report the crosslinking of these proteins into scaffolds with tailored initial elastic moduli. We also report the tunable biodegradation of these engineered scaffolds in response to enzymatic cleavage by uPA, a protease known to be secreted by the tips of growing neurites. By exploiting the sensitivity of uPA substrate specificity to slight changes in the neighboring amino acid sequence, we synthesized three proteins with highly variable degradation rates. The uncrosslinked proteins were shown to exhibit a greater than 200-fold change in protease degradation half-life as a result of changing only 3% of the total amino acid content. This same change in sequence translated into scaffolds with degradation lifetimes that varied from full degradation after one day of constant uPA exposure to no detected degradation after one full week of uPA exposure.
Through the design of three different scaffolds (u1, u2, and u3) with identical cell adhesion properties, identical initial elastic moduli, and significantly different degradation rates, we aim to provide a mechanism to study the optimal degradation rate for neurite outgrowth. The three uPA degradable proteins can be further combined together at different ratios to create an even larger set of materials to be studied for regenerative properties. Previous work has encouraged the development of this strategy by showing that cells attempting to grow through quicker degrading materials often grow faster and extend longer projections.13,14,19,21 Despite these advancements, we hypothesize that in order to maximize the benefit of a supportive scaffold, the degradation rate must closely match the cell regeneration rate and the site of degradation must be highly localized to prevent collapse of the bulk scaffold. Therefore, we have specifically targeted a protease secreted locally by the tips of growing neurites, which are the sites of regeneration in neurons, in order to more closely mimic what is believed to occur in the natural ECM environment.42 Future work will evaluate the rates of uPA secretion, neurite extension of neuronal cells in two-dimensional and three-dimensional scaffolds of varying mechanical properties and degradation rates, and the immunogenicity of implanted scaffolds.
A composite scaffold of the uPA-sensitive engineered proteins and an RGD engineered protein was shown to support cell attachment, neuronal differentiation, and neurite extension of a PC-12 neuronal-like cell line. The total amount of RGD present in the proteins was found to directly control both cell adhesion and neurite outgrowth. Taken together, these data demonstrate that the initial elastic moduli, degradation rate, and cell adhesivity of the scaffolds can each be systematically and independently tuned. These engineered proteins will be used to identify the combination of optimal material properties that promotes neurite outgrowth. Ultimately, knowledge obtained from these proteins may be applied to the construction of a biodegradable material that delivers a combination of beneficial stimuli at the site of nerve injury. Together with a combined approach involving the delivery of cells and growth factors, these multi-component protein polymers offer a new approach to spinal cord repair.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Plasmid cloning procedure, amino acid anlaysis of purified protein, lower critical solution temperatures of proteins, analysis of u1 protein degradation fragments, representative full stress-strain curve from compression testing, comparison of protein compressive elastic moduli with similar crosslinking conditions, and Student's t-test p-values for PC-12 cell experiments. See DOI: 10.1039/b808504h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2009 |