Irina
Estrela-Lopis
*a,
Stefano
Leporatti
b,
Daniel
Clemens
c and
Edwin
Donath
a
aLeipzig University, Institute of Medical Physics and Biophysics, D04107, Leipzig, Germany. E-mail: irina.estrela-lopis@medizin.unileipzig.de; edwin.donath@medizin.uni-leipzig.de
bNational Nanotechnology Laboratory, University of Lecce, Italy. E-mail: leporast@in.dii.unile.it
cBerlin Neutron Scattering Center, Hahn-Meitner-Institut, D14109, Berlin, Germany. E-mail: clemens@helmholtz-berlin.de
First published on 9th October 2008
Silica-templated polyelectrolyte (PE) hollow capsules with various template diameters and PE layer numbers were fabricated by using the layer-by-layer technique and subsequent core dissolution in hydrofluoric acid. The properties of the resulting freestanding polyelectrolyte multilayers (PEM) were characterized in an aqueous environment by means of SANS and compared with scanning force microscopy (SFM) data. The thickness of the capsule wall was found to be about 25% thicker and with correspondingly higher water content than the template-supported PE layers. The wall thickness increase as a result of core dissolution was anisotropic. The average single layer thickness of hollow capsules was independent of the surface curvature and decreased slightly with increasing PE layer number. SANS was used to determine whether the capsules were empty or contained the rest of the core. An annealing at 70 °C for 4 h induced capsule shrinking by about 20% at an ionic strength of 1 mol L−1. Furthermore, the capsule wall upon annealing increased in thickness by about 38%. These changes corresponded to a wall densification of about 13%.
A particular feature of PEM hollow capsules is that their composition, internal structure, thickness, density, porosity of PE layers, mechanical properties and capsule geometry can be tuned, depending on the core, the protocol of core dissolution and the coating materials.6–22 Ionic strength and subsequent annealing were found to be quite important for controlling the permeability of capsule shells.11,23–32 These novel capsule architectures have hence found large interest because of their possible use as drug-delivery systems with controlled release function, for diagnostic and sensing purposes.33–42
Among the various possibilities colloidal silica spheres have been intensively used as templates after some chemical modification.38,39,43–51 Particles with a narrow size distribution are available in a wide range from less than 102 up to 104 nm. The silicon dioxide core can be easily removed in hydrofluoric acid. A particular advantage of using silica templates is that during core dissolution in hydrofluoric acid the capsule wall experiences less mechanical and chemical stress in comparison with such templates as melamine-formaldehyde (MF) particles, polystyrene (PS) latex beads or erythrocytes.38
In view of the envisaged applications of PEM capsules, information concerning capsule wall thickness, structure and density of the film is highly desirable. It would be interesting to compare these data for freestanding polyelectrolyte films such as in capsules with supported PE layer on the colloids and flat surfaces. Such knowledge would be essential for optimising the wall properties with regard to stability, thickness and permeability.
Supported planar PE multilayer films have been extensively studied by neutron reflectivity.52–56 This technique is most appropriate to obtain data on thickness, structure and density of polyelectrolyte multilayer films. As a matter of fact, most of the current knowledge on thickness, density profile, water content and regularity of stratification of multilayers has been derived from neutron reflectivity studies. This powerful high resolution technique is not applicable to colloidal systems, such as PEM-coated colloids and capsules. Instead, SFM,9,16 applied in the dry state on collapsed capsules; single-particle light scattering,3 a combination of flow cytometry, confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) with quartz crystal microgravimetry (QCM)49 have been used as techniques for the structural characterization and build up of PEM-covered colloids and capsules. However, for example, the thickness of PE layer derived from these techniques rests on a variety of assumptions, e.g. the water content of the capsule walls, their refractive index, assuming complete collapse etc. Quite recently, full-field transmission X-ray microscopy (TXM) has been applied for the determination of water content and thickness of the wall of hollow polyelectrolyte capsules50 and polymeric microballoons.57 This novel scanning imaging technique with a resolution currently between 10 and 40 nm is a perfect complement to the diffraction-based high resolution techniques, such as SANS.
Small-angle neutron scattering has proved to be a powerful method for the ultrastructural characterization of polymer-decorated colloids58–65 and core–shell nanoparticles.66–70 SANS has been applied to PEM-coated polystyrene latex58 and more recently to PEM capsules templated on human erythrocytes.71 Beside measuring the wall thickness and the density profile with nanometre precision, SANS is capable of providing the water content of the wall and detecting remains of the core in the capsule interior.
We studied PEM capsule walls consisting of the 8, 12 and 16 layers of poly(styrene sulfonate (PSS) and poly(allylamine hydrochloride) (PAH). Sacrificial silica templates of 130 nm, 1.2 and 3 µm in diameter were used. The wall thickness and the content of the lumen of hollow capsules were characterized in an aqueous environment by means of SANS. The measurements were compared with SFM data. The layer thickness was determined as a function of layer number thus providing a detailed quantification of growth. We were further interested in how the capsule parameters depend on ionic strength and annealing.
If the capsules were completely hollow, the capsules interior would then have the same scattering length density (nc) as the bulk solution (ns), and thus only the Spp form factor contributes to the scattering intensity.
Spp(q) = 2π(S/V)q−2|∫eiqz〈ϕ(z)〉dz|2 | (1) |
Spp(q) = 2π(S/V)q−4(2ϕ2)(1 − cos(qh)). | (2) |
q2Spp(q) = 2π(S/V)ϕp2h2(1 − q2h2/12) | (3) |
Fig. 1 represents the scattering profiles of hollow capsules templated on small and large silica particles with eight deposited polyelectrolyte layers. For the sake of comparison, the scattering intensity provided by bare silica colloids is also shown. The position of the scattering minimum of the bare silica particles is consistent with a diameter of 102 nm, which is close to the size provided by the manufacturer obtained by means of dynamic light scattering. The slope of the scattering intensity curve from the bare particles is equal to −4 in the q-range corresponding to qR ≫ 1. The curve behaviour in this q-range satisfies Porod's law and proves the absence of an adsorbed layer on the surface of the colloids. An adsorption layer would give, according to eqn 1, a contribution in the scattering intensity scaling as q−2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Small-angle neutron scattering intensity profiles corresponding to small (■), large (▲) silica-templated hollow capsules with 8 PE layers, and to small bare silica colloids (●). The solid lines denote the best fits of the experimental data including device resolution and polydispersity. SLD here and in subsequent fits was fixed at 4 × 10−6 Å−2.58 |
The scattering intensity profiles of the hollow capsules in Fig. 1 reveal a q−2 law in the range of small q. In the particular case of small capsules the scattering minimum related to the size of the spherical colloids can be clearly observed in the q-range smaller than 0.2 nm−1. The fitting procedure applied to the data in Fig. 1 yielded a diameter of the capsule lumen of 106 nm being consistent with the template size. As one might expect, fringes were not observed for the 1.2 µm templated hollow capsules. The large diameter of the templates would yield very small separations between scattering minima in q space. These minima are strongly smoothed by the finite device resolution and the capsule polydispersity. Thus, only for the small capsules there is a chance of determining the diameter of PEM capsules after core dissolution.
At q values larger than 0.2 nm−1 at least one minimum occurrs as a result of the interference between the waves reflected from the two interfaces of the polymer shell (eqn (2)) can be distinguished. The position of this minimum is related to the layer thickness. This minimum is observed at the same q value independent on the size of the capsules indicating an independence of capsule wall thickness on curvature.
The wall thickness can be estimated either from the position of the minimum or by applying eqn (3) to the scattering function ln(q2I(q)) vs.q2. Both estimations of the thickness were used as initial parameters for subsequent fitting.
A non-linear least square fitting protocol to a model function for polydisperse spherical particles with a core–shell structure was applied to the experimental data.73–75 The polymer volume fraction profile was described by a step function. The polydispersity of the radius of the particles together with its coat was described by a Schulz–Zimm distribution and taken into account for fitting. The instrument resolution was also included by convoluting the scattering function with the device resolution function approximated by a Gaussian distribution. The variance of the resolution function was calculated from the wavelength distribution, finite collimation, aperture, and spatial resolution of the scattering instrument.76,77 The solid lines in Fig. 1 denote the best fits of the experimental data. The fits reveal in the case of 8 polyelectrolyte layers a wall thickness of 180 ± 6 Å for the large, and 170 ± 7 Å for the small capsules, respectively. The empty capsules (nc = ns) model yielded the best fit to the experimental results.
SANS data can also reveal whether there will be remains of the core after dissolution and capsule fabrication. In this way it can be useful as an unambiguous quality check of the fabricated hollow capsules. Fig. 2 demonstrates an example of “bad” hollow capsules with a silica rest in their interior after core dissolution. The solid line indicates the core–shell model (nc ≠ ns) fitted to the experiment data, where all three scattering contributions are present. The dashed line refers only to the core contribution. At the I(q)vs.q presentation the scattering profile of the capsules clearly reveals a deviation from the slope “−2” at very small q values, contrary to what one would expect for empty capsules. Presenting the scattering data as ln(q2I(q)) vs.q in Fig. 2 gives the possibility to observe most clearly the influence of eventually present core scattering as a deviation from linear behaviour (eqn (3)) at q2 < 0.02 nm−2. In the particular case shown in Fig. 2 the scattering length density of the capsule interior obtained by fitting was about 5.86 × 10−6 Å−2. Considering the core SLD as superposition of the contributions from deuterated water and the silica rest, and taking into account the SLD value of dry silica the volume fraction of silica rest after core dissolution in the capsule interior can be calculated. For example, the sample presented in Fig. 2 reveals incomplete core dissolution, as 18% of the silica is still found in the capsule lumen. In contrast, the silica content of the capsules investigated in Fig. 1 was below the detection limit.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Scattering intensity plotted as ln(Iq2) vs.q2 from incompletely dissolved silica-templated hollow capsules with 8 PE layers (●). The silica template diameter was about 1.2 µm. The solid and dashed lines denote the fits to the core–shell (nc ≠ ns) and core models, respectively. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Small-angle neutron scattering intensity profiles from 1.2 µm in diameter silica-templated hollow capsules with 8 (●), 12 (■) and 16 (▲) PE layers (from top to bottom). The solid lines denote the best fits. The inset shows the scattering intensity from the same experimental data plotted as ln(Iq2) vs.q2. The solid lines in the inset denote linear fits at a small q. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Average thickness per single layer of hollow capsules as a function of the total PE layer number. The capsule wall thickness data obtained from templating 102 nm (○) silica particles, 1.2 µm (●) silica particles and that of supported PEM on 168 nm PS latex particles58 (■) were derived from SANS data. ▲ indicates thickness per single layer of 3 µm silica templated collapsed capsules derived from SFM data. The solid lines describe the linear fits to the thickness data. The horizontal line, located left at the hs axis, denotes the corresponding thickness obtained from neutron reflectivity measurements of PEM deposited onto silica wafers in an aqueous environment.58 |
As can be seen the thickness per single PE layer of the capsule wall does not depend on the diameter of the silica core. This is consistent with the absence of a curvature effect of supported layers, as demonstrated earlier.58 Furthermore, the average single layer thickness decreases with the number of adsorbed PE layers both for supported and freestanding layers with approximately the same slope. This apparent decrease of the ratio of layer thickness to layer number can be related to a decreasing SLD value of the step function density profile of the shells, and, respectively, implies that the water content decreases with growing layer number. This assumption is based on the experimental fact, that the deposited mass itself, after the second pair of polyelectrolytes, in most cases increases linear with layer number.3,4,49,78 An alternative explanation would be a slightly decreasing mass increment with layer number. Fig. 4 further reveals that the hs value of dry hollow capsules as determined by SFM is only slightly smaller than the thickness of PEM supported on PS latex particles. This is consistent with dense supported layers with a water content of 42%.58 The layers do not shrink notably upon drying. This comparison proves that, at least for empty capsules, SFM measurements on dried capsules provide a good estimate for the PEM layer thickness in solution.
Two observations made with capsules have attracted special interest. 1) The thickness of the freestanding layers in capsules was about 25% larger for all studied samples as compared with supported layers (Fig. 4). 2) The diameter of the capsule lumen was an almost exact match of the diameter of the bare silica particles, which were used as templates. Indeed, SANS data fitting yielded an average internal diameter of hollow capsules of about 104 nm, while the bar silica particles had a size of 102 nm as determined from the scattering data provided in Fig. 1. The water content of the freestanding layers was 52%, while in supported layers it was only 42%. Therefore, silica core dissolution is accompanied by a layer thickness increase and a corresponding density decrease.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 SANS intensity profiles from 102 nm silica-templated hollow capsules with 8 PE layers before (●) and after (■) temperature treatment at 70 °C during 4 hours in 1 mol L−1NaCl solution. The solid lines denote the fits to the core–shell model. The inset shows the scattering intensity from the same experimental data plotted as ln(Iq2) vs.q2. The solid lines denote linear fits at small q. |
Furthermore, the position of the first minimum at higher q values corresponding to the layer thickness itself shifted toward smaller q, and the slope in the ln(q2I(q)) vs.q presentation (see inset) was correspondingly increased. This is consistent with a capsule wall thickness increase from 168 to 232 Å. Hence, the capsule wall became thicker by about 38% as a result of the annealing at high ionic strength.
Shell thickness and capsule diameters before and after temperature treatment can be converted into wall volume changes. We found that the volume of the wall decreased by about 13% as a result of the annealing in 1 mol L−1NaCl. The water content of the capsule wall decreased to 45.7% after temperature treatment in 1 mol L−1NaCl, which is quite similar to the water content of supported PE layers.57 The observed silica-core-templated capsule shrinking and the corresponding densification of the wall correlates thus with SFM and SANS annealing studies conducted on melamine-core-templated31 and cell-templated capsules.11,70
A remarkable result was that the diameter of the capsule interior coincided with the template size. This behaviour is different from that of melamine-templated capsules where an osmotically induced swelling during core dissolution results in capsules somewhat larger than the template size.38 We further found that the capsule wall thickness is significantly larger than that of the multilayer originally deposited onto the silica cores. This finding together with the constancy of the lumen size has an interesting implication. It demonstrates that the increase in wall thickness occurring upon dissolution is strictly anisotropic. The wall expands only in the radial direction but not laterally. As it can be easily shown, a lateral expansion of the capsule wall comparable in extent to the increase in radial direction would result in a larger capsule lumen, which was, however, not observed. Without knowing the details of the kinetics of core dissolution one may only speculate about the reason for this interesting behaviour. A possible explanation would be that during the silica core dissolution large osmotic pressure differences are not built up, and, that the attachment of the bottom layer to the silica core surface prevents lateral expansion. The absence of lateral layer expansion in the case of silica cores is consistent with a smaller number of defects being created during capsule preparation, as compared with the case of melamine-templated capsules, where large pores and defects have been frequently reported.
The measurements of the annealed capsules showed that the induced transition of the wall topology was possibly achieved by simultaneously decreasing the electrostatic interactions between the oppositely charged layers constituents brought about by high ionic strength together with increasing the mobility of the layer constituents induced by the elevated temperatures.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2009 |