Jerzy W.
Wiench
a,
Gregory
Tricot
b,
Laurent
Delevoye
b,
Julien
Trebosc
ab,
James
Frye
c,
Lionel
Montagne
b,
Jean-Paul
Amoureux
b and
Marek
Pruski
*a
aAmes Laboratory, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 50011-3020, USA. E-mail: mpruski@iastate.edu; Fax: 515-294-0266; Tel: 515-294-2017
bLCPS, CNRS-8012, Université des Sciences et Technologies de Lille, FR-59652, Villeneuve d’Ascq, France
cVarian Inc, Ft. Collins, CO 80525, USA
First published on 27th October 2005
The recently introduced concept of soft pulse added mixing (SPAM) is used in two-dimensional heteronuclear correlation (HETCOR) NMR experiments between half-integer quadrupolar and spin-1/2 nuclei. The experiments employ multiple quantum magic angle spinning (MQMAS) to remove the second order quadrupolar broadening and cross polarization (CP) or refocused INEPT for magnetization transfer. By using previously unexploited coherence pathways, the efficiency of SPAM-MQ-HETCOR NMR is increased by a factor of almost two without additional optimization. The sensitivity gain is demonstrated on a test sample, AlPO4-14, using CP and INEPT to correlate 27Al and 31P nuclei. SPAM-3Q-HETCOR is then applied to generate 27Al–31P spectra of the devitrified 41Na2O–20.5Al2O3–38.5P2O5 glass and the silicoaluminophosphate ECR-40. Finally, the method allowed the acquisition of the first high resolution solid-state correlation spectra between 27Al and 29Si.
While the MQMAS-based HETCOR methods offer considerable improvement in resolution, until now their applications have been restricted to samples with a relatively high abundance of ‘friendly’ spin pairs, such as 27Al and 31P. Herein, we demonstrate that the sensitivity of the MQ-D-HETCOR and MQ-J-HETCOR methods can be enhanced by implementing the soft pulse added mixing (SPAM) scheme which uses previously unexploited coherence pathways.14,15 We used these methods to acquire the 27Al–31P spectra of the AlPO4-14 molecular sieve, which has been used as a standard in our earlier reports.12,13 In order to illustrate the effectiveness of MQ-HETCOR in structural studies of new materials, we report the 27Al–31P 3Q-D-HETCOR spectrum of devitrified aluminophosphate glass 41Na2O–20.5Al2O3–38.5P2O5, and the 27Al–31P 3Q-J-HETCOR spectrum of the silicoaluminophosphate (SAPO) ECR-40. Finally, we demonstrate that these experiments are not limited to aluminium and phosphorus by reporting the 27Al–29Si 3Q-D-HETCOR spectrum of potassium feldspar mineral (microcline).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Pulse sequences used in (a) MQ-D-HETCOR11,12 and (b) MQ-J-HETCOR13 experiments with SPAM.† The coherence pathways for 2I = |p| and 2I > |p| are shown at the bottom. |
The excitation of p-quantum coherence in I spins is carried out via a single pulse of strong magnetic RF field. The signal enhancement by SPAM is achieved by using three coherence pathways
(see the bottom of Fig. 1), where PT denotes the polarization transfer and R
=
p[36I(I
+ 1)
− 17p2
− 10]/[36I(I
+ 1)
− 27], instead of a single pathway
. Thus, the pQ →
−1Q conversion sequence consists of a strong (hard) continuous wave (CW) RF pulse followed by a period of much weaker (soft) CW irradiation. The time interval between the hard and soft pulses should be as short as possible in order to avoid the dephasing of magnetization at the non-zero quantum levels. In the standard SPAM-MQMAS experiments, the role of the soft pulse is to maximize the total transfer of coherences from p
=
{−1, 1, 0} to p
=
−1. Since most of the SPAM signal originates from the pathway 0Q →
pQ → 0Q →
−1Q, the efficiency is at a maximum when the hard mixing pulse is optimized for the pQ → 0Q conversion and the flip angle of the soft pulse corresponds to 90°.14 Although the 0Q →
pQ → 0Q →
−1Q transfer alone is slightly less efficient than in the 0Q →
pQ →
−1Q scheme used previously, the added contributions from routes 0Q →
pQ →
±1Q →
−1Q lead to significant gain in overall sensitivity. In the case when |p|
= 2I
(as in 23Na 3Q-HETCOR or 27Al 5Q-HETCOR experiments) this gain in signal-to-noise (S/N) is about 1.4, according to our calculations using PULSAR.16 When |p| < 2I, as in 27Al 3Q-HETCOR experiments, the expected gain increases to about 1.7. This is because in the latter case the standard echo pathway follows the ‘upper route’ 0Q → 3Q →
−1Q, which compares less favorably with the SPAM scheme. Since the HETCOR schemes require the use of the echo pathway alone,17 the sensitivity gains generated by SPAM are expected to carry over to MQ-D-HETCOR and MQ-J-HETCOR experiments.
The phase cycling is straightforward, as shown in Fig. 1. For the 3Q experiment with spin-5/2 nuclei the echo pathway is selected by shifting the phase ϕ1 of the first pulse 12 times between 0 and 360° with 30° increments, while assuming ϕ3
=
ϕX. In addition, the phases applied to the CP (or INEPTR) pulses in the 27Al channel are cycled to achieve the spin temperature inversion, which increases the number of different phase sets within the cycle to 24. The 5Q-HETCOR experiment with spin-5/2 nuclei, which uses the pathway
, also requires 12 phases, while assuming ϕ3
=
ϕ−X. The receiver phase is set at −3ϕ1 in 3Q- and 5ϕ1 in 5Q-HETCOR experiments. The phase sensitive detection is performed using the hypercomplex method, which involves acquisition of a second set with the phase of the CP pulse shifted by 90° or, equivalently, the phase ϕ1 by 90°/p.
All experiments were performed with rotor synchronization during t1.18 For spin-1/2 nuclei, the spectra are plotted using the chemical shift values δX (X = Si and P), which are referenced to tetramethylsilane (29Si) and aqueous 85% H3PO4 (31P), both at 0 ppm. The indirect dimension (27Al) is referenced using the isotropic shifts δAl,ISO19 to aqueous solution of Al(NO3)3, also at 0 ppm.
The 27Al–31P correlations between Al1, Al2, Al3 and phosphorus observed at 9.4 T using the SPAM-3Q-D-HETCOR scheme are shown in Fig. 2. Also shown, at the top of the figure, is the 31P projection of an analogous spectrum acquired without SPAM. As expected, the correlations P2–Al3 and P3–Al2 were not observed. The sensitivity gain afforded by SPAM was between 1.6 and 1.7, which is in good agreement with our theoretical predictions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The correlations of tetrahedral and five-coordinated aluminium sites with phosphorus in the 3Q-D-HETCOR spectrum of aluminophosphate AlPO4-14 recorded at 9.4 T. On top of the spectrum are shown the 31P projections (in skyline mode) observed (a) without and (b) with SPAM, under otherwise equivalent conditions. Spectra were acquired using νR = 12 kHz, νAlRF = 150 kHz during hard pulses, νAlRF = 20 kHz during the soft pulse, νAlRF = 7 kHz during CP, νPRF = 9 kHz during CP and τCP = 3.5 ms. Total acquisition time was 20 h per spectrum. |
The complete 27Al–31P SPAM-3Q-J-HETCOR spectrum observed at 14.1 T is shown in Fig. 3. Again, all expected Al–O–P connectivities are revealed, including the previously undetected resonance between sites Al1 and P2.13 The distinction between sites P1 and P4 is not apparent in Fig. 3, but can be made upon closer inspection. In this experiment, the S/N ratio has increased by a factor of 2.1 (±0.1) upon the introduction of SPAM.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 27Al–31P 3Q-J-HETCOR spectra of aluminophosphate AlPO4-14 recorded at 14.1 T (a) without and (b) with SPAM under equivalent conditions. The standard MAS spectrum of aluminium is also shown on the right. Spectra were acquired using νR = 15 kHz, νAlRF = 210 kHz during hard pulses, νAlRF = 5 kHz during the soft pulse and INEPTR, νPRF = 64 kHz and a delay of 0.2 s between scans. Total acquisition time was 12 h per spectrum. |
The 27Al resonances in the devitrified sample cannot be resolved under MAS (see Fig. 4a, top projection), however no less than six octahedral Al sites can be identified by 3QMAS. Numerous correlations between these sites and phosphorus are observed in the SPAM-3Q-D-HETCOR spectrum (Fig. 4b). The three peaks between 27Al site at δAl,ISO = −4 ppm and 31P sites at −28.7, −15.9 and −12.5 ppm are characteristic of the crystalline phosphate Na7(AlP2O7)4PO4. Although the complete spectral assignment will require additional experiments involving homonuclear correlation methods, such as 31P double-quantum, RFDR and INADEQUATE, we can already infer the presence of aluminophosphate network, rather than a sodium phosphate network in this sample. The presence of aluminophosphate phases is important for the chemical durability of the matrix and its use as a host for radioactive materials.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) 27Al SPAM-3QMAS and (b) 27Al–31P SPAM-3Q-D-HETCOR spectra of 41Na2O–20.5Al2O3–38.5P2O5 glass. Spectrum (b) was acquired in 23 h under the conditions described in the caption of Fig. 2. |
The 27Al 3QMAS spectrum of the as-synthesized sample (Fig. 5a) showed four resonances, located at δAl,ISO = 52, 47, 41 and −10 ppm. To assign these resonances, we also performed 27Al MAS and 3QMAS on a sample calcined overnight under vacuum at 400 °C (spectra not shown). In the 3QMAS spectrum, the resonances at −10 and 47 ppm vanished, the peaks at 52 and 41 ppm remained unchanged, and a new resonance was observed at 56 ppm. The peak at 41 ppm comprised about 25% of total intensity in the MAS spectrum, which suggests that it represents T1 site while the peaks at 52 and 56 ppm (52 and 47 ppm in as-synthesized sample) correspond to T3 sites. The resonance at δAl,ISO = −10 ppm observed in Fig. 5 is characteristic of octahedral Al sites associated with phosphorus,27 which result from (partial) hydration of the T3 sites. In agreement with the earlier report,25 the 31P MAS spectrum (shown on the top of Fig. 5b) consisted of a strong resonance at −24.5 ppm and a smaller peak at −17 ppm.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) 27Al 3QMAS and (b) 27Al–31P SPAM-3Q-J-HETCOR spectra of as-synthesized SAPO ECR-40 recorded at 14.1 T. The 27Al and 31P MAS spectra are shown for comparison on top of images (a) and (b), respectively. Spectra were acquired using νR = 16 kHz, νAlRF = 210 kHz during hard pulses, νAlRF = 5 kHz during the soft pulse and INEPTR, νPRF = 64 kHz, and a delay of 0.1 s in 2D spectra. Spectrum (b) was acquired in 7 h. |
The result of the SPAM-3Q-J-HETCOR experiment on the as-synthesized sample is shown in Fig. 5b. The spectrum clearly shows that all Al sites detected by MQMAS are chemically bound to phosphorus resonating at −24.5 ppm, which indicates that it occupies the T2 site. The 31P resonance at −17 ppm must be ascribed to structural impurities, as it was not detected in the HETCOR spectrum. Again, the efficiency was essentially doubled (the S/N gain was measured at 1.9 ± 0.1) by SPAM, which reduced the acquisition time to 7 h.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (a) 27Al–29Si D-HETCOR and (b) 27Al–29Si SPAM-3Q-D-HETCOR spectra of microcline recorded at 9.4 T. The 1D 29Si MAS spectrum is shown for comparison on top of image (a). Data were acquired using νR = 10 kHz, νAlRF = 70 kHz during hard pulses, νAlRF = 5 kHz during the soft pulse, νAlRF = 1 kHz during CP, νSiRF = 11.5 ± 1 kHz (ramped), τCP = 100 ms and a pulse delay of 10 s. Spectra (a) and (b) were obtained in 80 and 72 h, respectively. |
Site | δ CS | Connectivities | |
---|---|---|---|
Microcline | T2m | −94.0 | 2Si, 2Al |
T2O | −96.4 | 3Si, 1Al | |
T1m | −99.5 | 3Si, 1Al | |
Albite | T2m | −91.8 | 2Si, 2Al |
T2O | −96.1 | 3Si, 1Al | |
T1m | −103.9 | 3Si, 1Al |
With regard to overall sensitivity, further enhancement is possible by increasing the intensity of the central transition prior to the excitation 0Q → ±3Q. This can be accomplished regardless of SPAM by double frequency sweep (DFS),36 rotor assisted population transfer (RAPT),33 fast amplitude modulation (FAM)37 or hyperbolic secant (HS) pulses.38
A question arises as to whether the demonstrated enhancement of the transfer ±3Q → −1Q, generated by SPAM with a CW nutation pulse, could be achieved by incorporating the alternative conversion methods, such as FAM, DFS, HS or RIACT,39 into the HETCOR scheme. An earlier study has shown40 that in the case of spin-3/2 nuclei FAM was more efficient and less sensitive to the magnitude of the quadrupole coupling than CW nutation and RIACT, even in schemes that did not involve the 0 → −3 → −1 (echo) pathway favored by RIACT. Therefore, it is possible that FAM and DFS could be competitive with SPAM, or even used jointly to further improve sensitivity of HETCOR. Such schemes are more likely to be competitive for spin-3/2 nuclei, where they work best (or exclusively, as in the case of RIACT) and where SPAM offers a lower gain. Indeed, our attempt to use the SPAM scheme with FAM conversion in 27Al–31P MQ-HETCOR did not result in further increase in sensitivity.
The utility of MQ-HETCOR experiments is critically dependent on the efficiency of polarization transfer. It is well known that the CP transfer involving quadrupolar nuclei is often demanding due to the complex spin dynamics involved in spin-locking and the capriciousness of the Hartmann–Hahn condition.41–43 This may lead to considerable spectral distortions, which add to the quantitative inaccuracies inherent in MQMAS. In principle, the difficulties associated with the CP transfer could be circumvented by using techniques that do not require spin-locking, such as TEDOR44 or PRESTO.45 While we previously demonstrated the feasibility of 1H–27Al TEDOR-based MQMAS,46 this method proved to be considerably less sensitive than CP, especially in the presence of strong quadrupolar interactions and fast transverse relaxation. As to the INEPT-based methods, in samples with favorable relaxation rates their sensitivity compares well with standard solid-state NMR methods.13 For example, in AlPO4-14 and SAPO ECR-40, INEPTR yielded better sensitivity per unit of experimental time than direct polarization of 31P nuclei. The observed sensitivity was comparable with cross polarization, which showed that transverse relaxation was not of major concern in these samples.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Program codes used during NMR measurements. See DOI: 10.1039/b512246e |
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2006 |