Montserrat
Gómez
*a,
Karine
Philippot
*b,
Vincent
Collière
b,
Pierre
Lecante
c,
Guillermo
Muller
a and
Bruno
Chaudret
*b
aDepartament de Química Inorgànica, Universitat de Barcelona, Martí i Franquès 1-11, 08028 Barcelona, Spain. E-mail: montserrat.gomez@qi.ub.es
bLaboratoire de Chimie de Coordination du CNRS, 205, route de Narbonne, 31077 Toulouse Cedex 04, France. E-mail: phil@lcc-toulouse.fr, chaudret@lcc-toulouse.fr
cCentre d'Elaboration des Matériaux et d'Etudes Structurales du CNRS, 29, rue Jeanne Marvig, BP 4347, 31055 Toulouse Cedex, France
First published on 10th December 2002
The reaction of Pt2(dba)3 with CO in toluene leads rapidly to the formation of platinum nanoparticles which can be further stabilized by addition of aminoalcohol or oxazoline ligands. The coordination of the oxazoline ligands at the surface of the particles is demonstrated by IR after purification of the colloids. The fcc structure of the particles is evidenced by WAXS investigations, a statistical method which also gives information about the degree of crystallinity of the particles. TEM and HREM micrographs reveal surprising organisations of the particles into super-structures depending on the nature and/or position of the substituents present on the ligands. In addition, these particles are catalytically active in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate, even if the preliminary results are modest.
(i) If these particles are to have a future in chemistry, is it possible to tune their reactivity and selectivity in a way similar to that achieved in organometallic chemistry with mononuclear species? This will need development of the surface chemistry of the particles and of the ligands necessary for this purpose.
(ii) If these particles are to be employed for physical applications, how can they be addressed? The first and most studied answer to this question is to promote their self-organization through an organized medium or long chain ligands acting as surfactants. This approach has allowed the formation of crystalline arrays of self-assembled particles in 2 or 3 dimensions. Another answer can be, in a similar way to (i), to develop ligands adapted to the particles and able to interconnect through, for example, hydrogen bond networks. This approach has been extensively studied in coordination chemistry (molecular tectonics)10 and recently extended to platinum nanoparticles via bifunctional thiolato ligands.8j
In both cases, it appears necessary to develop coordination chemistry at the surface of the nanoparticles and to find adapted ligands. Asymmetric ligands appear particularly appealing since they can induce an interesting catalytic activity and since, in the case of asymmetric induction, this would help to understand the coordination of ligands on the particle surface.11 Furthermore, asymmetric ligands may promote the formation of anisotropic networks of hydrogen bonds. We have been interested in nitrogen based ligands such as chiral mono- and bis-oxazolines.12 These ligands are easily prepared from β-aminoalcohols and nitrile or carboxylic acid derivatives13 and display a widely studied chemistry14 because of their potential applications to different enantioselective homogenous catalytic processes.15 They have recently been tested as ligands for ruthenium nanoparticles used for catalytic hydrogenation reactions.12 An aminoalcohol, namely 2-aminobutanol, which is a very simple asymmetric ligand, was also studied.
We report in this paper the synthesis of platinum nanoparticles stabilized by chiral ligands bearing various functional groups and the formation of super-structures induced by the ligands.
Scheme 1 Colloids synthesis with ligand structures. |
Colloids | Ligand L* | IR (KBr) νCN in free ligand/cm−1 | IR (THF) νCO,νCN in colloid/cm−1 | IR (KBr) νCO,νCN in colloid/cm−1 | TEM type of association and approximate mean size | WAXS structure coherence length/nm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Colloid 2 | (R)-2 | — | 2054 | 2031 | dendrites #1.6–1.8 nm | — |
Colloid 3 | (R)-3 | 1653 | 2045, 1653 | — | disks and nanowires and bundles ca. 1.5 nm | — |
Colloid 4 | (R)-4 | 1642 | 2045, 1642 | 2025, 1651 | disks ca. 1.5 nm | — |
Colloid 5 | (R)-5 | 1636 | 2047, 1636 | 2034, 1633 | disks and dendrites #1.2–1.3 nm | fcc #1.2–1.4 |
Colloid 6 | (R)-6 | 1641 | 2051, 1643 | 2044, 1617 | nanotubes ca. 1.2 nm | — |
Colloid 7 | (S)-7 | 1640 | 2052, 1644 | 2044, 1617 | dendrites and nanocrystals #1.8 nm | fcc #1.8 |
Colloid 8 | (S,S)-8 | 1636 | 2052, 1642 | 2042, 1633 | monolayers and disks #1.2 nm | fcc #1.2 |
Colloid 9 | (S,S)-9 | 1648 | 2047, 1672 | 2037, 1650 | monolayers and dendrites #1.2 nm | fcc #1.2 |
Colloid 10 | (R,R)-10 | 1651 | 2050, 1604 | — | dendrites #1.5–1.8 nm | fcc #1.5–1.8 |
Colloid 11 | (S,S)-11 | 1640 | 2047, 1654 | 2033, 1641 | disks ca. 1.5 nm | — |
TEM and HRTEM studies show that in every case, in contrast to ruthenium nanoparticles of slightly larger size but stabilized by the same ligands,12 the particles are not isolated but gather into super-structures. High resolution images, typical examples of which are shown in Figs. 1 and 2, demonstrate that the individual particles have kept their integrity, namely original size and structure, inside the super-structures. This therefore demonstrates that the super-structures result from the supramolecular assembly of the nanoclusters composed of one particle and the corresponding ligand shell, probably via the interaction of the surface ligands through hydrogen bonding. The morphologies of these super-structures are diverse, in some cases elegant and/or very surprising. They depend upon the nature and/or the position of the functional groups present on the ligands.
Fig. 1 TEM (a) and HRTEM (b) micrographs showing, respectively, the “neuronal” super-structures and atomic plans of the nanoparticles observed for Colloid 2. |
Fig. 2 TEM micrographs (a) and (b) at 2 different magnifications (5 and 20 K, respectively) and HRTEM micrograph (c) showing the nanotubes and their individual constitutive nanoparticles obtained for Colloid 6. |
One of the most common super-structures is a disk which includes monodisperse particles regularly separated by 1 nm or less. This suggests the presence of an isotropic arrangement of the ligands around the platinum nanoparticles and the presence of a statistical hydrogen bond network. Such structures have been observed for Colloids 3, 4, 5, 8 and 11 (Figs. 3 and 4). In these cases, the bidentate ligands firmly coordinate to the surface of the particles and contain a bulky apolar lipophilic environment. The disk shape presumably results from an isotropic arrangement in solution building spheres which upon deposition onto the microscopy grid give this “disk” appearance. The weak interaction observed between nanoparticles may result from Van der Waals contacts between large lipophilic entities, or alternatively but less likely from the presence of traces of water which interconnect the oxygen atoms of the oxazoline ligands.
Fig. 3 TEM micrograph of disks resulting from the preparation of Colloid 4. |
Fig. 4 TEM micrograph of Colloid 8 showing nanoclusters organized in disks. |
The second common super-structure adopts curious shapes which can be likened to dendrites, arborescences, sea-anemons (see Figs. 1, 5–8). The wires are generally connected at one extremity of the super-structure and are widely spread at the other extremity giving rise in many cases to monolayers. These wires are constituted of linearly connected particles, which means that the diameter of a typical nanowire is that of one nanoparticle (ca. 1.5 nm). This suggests strong hydrogen bonding in one direction and weak interactions between the nanowires. The ligands which generate this type of assembly (L*2, 5, 7, 9 and 10; see Scheme 1) are typically bidentate ligands containing multiple polar groups able to give rise to hydrogen bonding. The most beautiful wires and arborescences are observed for ligands which can be associated through strong hydrogen bonds, typically “O–H⋯O”, “O–H⋯N” or “N–H⋯N” (Colloids 2, 5, 6 and 7). This suggests the presence of both strong coordination of the ligands at the surface of the particles and of a second “coordination sphere” involving ligands able to build strong hydrogen bond interactions between particles (see Scheme 2). The monodimensional character of these interactions is at first sight striking. It results most probably from the need to combine the polar regions where hydrogen bondings are present and the apolar ones which could be at the periphery of the wires. The presence of lipophilic regions at the periphery of the strong hydrogen bonds can explain the weak interactions observed between the nanowires.
Fig. 5 TEM micrograph of Colloid 5 evidencing the abundant formation of dendrites. |
Fig. 6 TEM micrograph of Colloid 7 showing nanocrystals (a) and an enlargement of a 2 nanocrystal junction (b). |
Fig. 7 TEM micrograph of dendrites corresponding to the Colloid 9 assemblies. |
Fig. 8 TEM (a) and HRTEM (b) micrographs showing, respectively, some dendrites and their constitutive nanoparticles noticed for Colloid 10. |
Scheme 2 Illustration of possible interactions between particles through strong hydrogen bonds between ligands in the case of Colloid 7. |
In this respect, it is interesting to compare the results obtained with ligands 6 and 7. These ligands are both constituted of a phenol group substituted in the ortho position by an oxazoline moiety. Furthermore, the oxazoline bears either an ethyl substituent (L*6) or an isopropyl one (L*7). In the case of L*7, in addition to the dendrites, very large rectangular super-structures of crystalline aspect are present; they account for most of the objects observed on the microscopy grid (Fig. 6). The simple substitution of the pendant isopropyl group by an ethyl one has a major effect on the assembly of the nanoparticles. This gives rise to very curious super-structures which at first sight resemble snakes displaying spots (Fig. 2). The high resolution image shows individual nanoparticles of 1.5 nm, i.e. of standard size, severely agglomerated. It is therefore possible that the ethyl substituent allows the formation of an isotropic hydrogen bond network which explain the presence of the small spheres (spots). The orientation of the snake body is more difficult to understand. In the case of L*7, the presence of the unidirectionality discussed above may explain the formation of the rectangular structures. Somewhat similar organisation into tubes has been previously observed when using p-hydroxy- and p-amino-thiophenol as stabilizers of similar platinum particles.8j
The case of the two bidentate bis-oxazoline ligands is also interesting. As stated above, both give rise to “neuronal” structures. However, whereas L*9 shows standard individual particles linearly connected, a high resolution image of Colloid 10 (Fig. 8) shows the presence in some areas of large coalesced particles displaying a high aspect ratio. This may be due to the presence of some mono N-coordinated bis-oxazoline (L*10) which could favour nanoparticle interconnexion and then coalescence. This process would be less probable in the case of L*9 which contains only two carbon atom linkers.
Finally, the use of the chloro substituted ligand 3 as stabilizer leads to the formation of long and aligned nanowires (Fig. 9). The reason for this observation is not known. One hypothesis could be the activation of C–Cl bonds by platinum generating charges on the particles. Formation of ionic associations of surfactants (for example amine–carboxylic acid) have recently been found to be excellent for either the formation of monodisperse assemblies of nanoparticles or for controlling their aspect ratio.6
Fig. 9 TEM micrographs of Colloid 3 showing the platinum nanowires and their assemblies (the inset of (a) is presented at a higher magnification in (b)). |
WAXS investigations on Colloids 2, 5, 7 and 8 (Fig. 10) revealed in each case a pattern consistent with a fcc structure. The metal–metal distance is similar to that of bulk platinumin in agreement with the metallic nature of the particles but reduced by ca. 1% in all but one of the samples. In the case of Colloid 7, the reduction of the metal–ligand distance is more important (1.6%). These observations match previous ones17 and suggest the presence at the surface of the particles of ligands not giving rise to strong metal–metal bonds. This is corroborated by an extended coherence length which matches the size deduced from TEM observations in the case of Colloid 7. In the other cases, the peaks become broader and broader when considering successively Colloids 2, 5 and 8. This may be indicative of a decrease in the degree of crystallinity, although we must be careful in the interpretation of such data. For Colloids 9 and 10 (Fig. 11), the strong decrease in intensity observed for the first peaks suggests a variation of the metal–metal distance between the core and the surface of the particles and therefore a strong coordination of the surface ligands. Such behaviour has previously been noticed for octanethiol stabilized platinum particles. Indeed, in this case, a coherence length of 1.2 nm had been measured while a mean size of 1.6 nm was revealed by TEM. This discordance had been explained by a strong coordination of octanethiol ligands.8c Such good donor ligands would modify the metal–metal distances and the arrangement of the surface atoms in a way similar to molecular clusters. This had been confirmed by HRTEM investigations, showing for the octanethiol protected platinum particles a good crystallinity only in their core. A similar, albeit less pronounced, effect may be due in the present case to the chelate effect of the bis-oxazoline ligands.
Fig. 10 RDF of particles of Colloids 2, 5, 7 and 8. |
Fig. 11 RDF of particles of Colloids 9 and 10. |
The infrared spectra of all colloids were measured both in the solid state (KBr) and in solution (THF). In both cases, it is clear that the most important shift in the νCO frequency is observed when using ligands 3, 4, 5, 9 and 11 which for various reasons have the best coordination ability (presence of, respectively, pyridine, amino or thioether groups, chelate effect). This has also been previously observed upon coordinating thiols at the surface of platinum particles.
As a further characterization of the coordination of the chiral ligands described hereabove, we investigated their reactivity for catalytic ethyl pyruvate hydrogenation. We found however in each case a low activity without asymmetric induction. This can result from the fluxionality of the oxazoline ligands at the surface of the particles. The presence of CO ligands at the surface of the particles may also be detrimental as they can act as a catalytic poison. Further work is presently in progress to avoid the presence of CO at the surface of the particles and then to obtain better catalysts.
It is thus possible with simple ligand engineering to orientate the connexion between particles and to adjust the inter-particle distance. This kind of approach towards the supramolecular arrangement of nanoparticles is only at the beginning but may prove fruitful for exploiting the physical properties of such nano-objects. In contrast, the catalytic properties of these particles appeared disappointing but more relevant systems will be studied in the future.
Infrared spectra were recorded on a Perkin-Elmer IRFT GX 2000 spectrophotometer as colloidal solutions transferred into a KBr cell or using KBr pellets after isolation of the products as solids. The reference spectrum of the solvent was systematically subtracted.
The oxazoline-stabilized colloidal solutions were all prepared following the typical experiment described hereafter.
In a first step, a solution of Pt2(dba)3 (100 mg, 0.091 mmol) in 40 ml of freshly distilled and degassed toluene in a Fischer-porter Bottle was pressurized with 1 bar of CO during 20 min under vigorous stirring. During this time the solution changed from deep purple to brown and a reddish-brown solid precipitated. The solution was removed by filtration and the precipitate was washed with pentane (4×20 ml) until the solution turned colorless, to eliminate dba, and dried under vacuum, giving then rise to Colloid 1. IR Colloid 1 (KBr, cm−1): 2052, 1811.
In a second step, a THF solution of the chosen chiral ligand (10 ml THF; 0.5 eq./Pt) was added to Colloid 1 involving its redissolution and the obtention of a dark-brown colloidal solution. The mixture was left under vigorous stirring in solution for 12 hours at room temperature leading to Colloid 2–11. After that time, a small quantity of a black precipitate or sediment on walls of the schlenk tube was generally observed. Infrared spectra were recorded during this period of time (THF solutions), and also after isolation and purification of the colloids (KBr pellets). The CO and CN stretches are given in Table 1. TEM and HRTEM analyses were performed after deposition of a drop of colloidal solutions onto holey carbon covered copper grids. The mean sizes, in a range 1.2 nm–1.8 nm, were estimate through a manual analysis of enlarged micrographs by measuring a number of particles on a given grid. After evaporation to dryness, the Colloid 2–11 were isolated as dark brown powders and some of them could be analyzed by microanalysis: Colloid 2: %Pt=70.42, %C=20.50, %H=2.20, %N=4.82; Colloid 4: %C=14.59, %H=1.04, %N=1.13; Colloid 5: %Pt=61.33, %C=26.65, %H=2.38, %N=3.20; Colloid 7: %C=12.92, %H=0.91, %N=0.38; Colloid 8: %C=38.16, %H=2.82, %N=1.96; Colloid 9: %Pt=70.60, %C=23.69, %H=2.40, %N=1.68; Colloid 10: %Pt=45.76; Colloid 11: %Pt=21.45, %C=50.09, %H=3.57, %N=2.31. WAXS (Wide Angle X-Ray scattering) experiments were performed on Colloid 5, and Colloids 7–10 evidencing the fcc structure of particles similar to that of the bulk platinum.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique 2003 |