Kenji
Nomiya
*,
Yoshitaka
Sakai
,
Yoshiteru
Yamada
and
Takeshi
Hasegawa
Department of Materials Science, Faculty of Science, Kanagawa University, Hiratsuka, Kanagawa 259-1293, Japan. E-mail: nomiya@chem.kanagawa-u.ac.jp
First published on 13th December 2000
A novel Keggin polyoxotungstate-based 1∶1-type Cp*Rh2+ complex (Cp* = C5Me5), [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3]H2[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40)]·3DMSO·0.5MeCN 2, was synthesized by reaction in MeCN–DMSO mixed solvent at 80 °C under nitrogen, of the α-Keggin-type 1,4,9-trivanadium-substituted polyoxotungstate (NBu4)4H2[α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40] 1 with [Cp*Rh(MeCN)3]2+. Characterization was performed with complete elemental analysis, TG/DTA, FTIR, and multiple (51V, 31P, 1H and 13C) NMR spectroscopies. Complex 2 contains two different types of Cp*Rh2+ groups; one is covalently bonded to the surface oxygen atoms of three edge-shared vanadium octahedra while the other is present as a DMSO-solvated counter ion. The composition of complex 2 is unique and can be compared with previous Keggin and Dawson polyoxotungstate-based organometallic complexes.
Examples of vanadium-substituted polyoxoanion-supported organometallics are [(CpTi)(β-1,2,3-SiW9V3O40)]4− (Cp = C5H5) 3 [Fig. 1(c)],3 [(Cp*Rh)4V6O19],4a [{(cod)Ir}V4O12]3− (cod = cycloocta-1,5-diene)4b and [{(cod)Ir}2V4O12]2−.4b One example of a Dawson trivanadium-substituted polyoxotungstate-based organometallics has been reported as an unusual site-bonding 1∶1-type compound (NBu4)6[(CpTi)(α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62)] 5 with Cs symmetry,5 and not the initially anticipated C3v symmetry. In relation to this complex, we have very recently been successful in isolating a novel Dawson polyoxoanion-supported 2∶1-type Cp*Rh2+ complex, i.e. (NBu4)5[(Cp*Rh)2(α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62)] 6 with Cs symmetry.6 These complexes are in contrast to the Dawson triniobium-substituted polyoxotungstate-based 1∶1-type organometallic complexes with C3v symmetry such as [(Cp*Rh)(α-1,2,3-P2W15Nb3O62)]7−71a,b,d,f and [{(C6H6)Ru}(α-1,2,3-P2W15Nb3O62)]7−8.1a,d It has been proposed that either the Dawson-type trimetal-substituted polyoxometalate-support [P2W15M3O62]9− (M = VVvs. NbV) or the organometallic group with different charge (CpTi3+vs. Cp*Rh2+), or both, are variables for kinetic control process (Cs symmetry) vs. thermodynamic control process (C3v symmetry) of the organometallic group in the support chemistry of [α-1,2,3-P2W15M3O62]9−.5
Fig. 1 Polyhedral representation of the Keggin polyoxotungstates [β-1,2,3-SiW9V3O40]7− (a) and [α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40]6− (b). In (a) and (b), the three vanadiums are represented by hatched octahedra in the 1,2,3-positions (A-site) and 1,4,9-positions (B-site), respectively. The WO6 octahedra occupy the white octahedra, and an XO4 (X = Si or P) group is shown as the internal, black tetrahedron. One of the two most plausible Cs symmetry structures of [(CpTi)(β-1,2,3-SiW9V3O40)]4− is shown in (c) and the other most plausible structure involves bonding of the organometallic moiety to two bridging W–O–V oxygens and a terminal VO oxygen. Polyhedral representation of [(Cp*Rh)(α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40)]4−, prepared in this work, is shown in (d). Although the sites of two protonations in 1 can be assumed to be bridging oxygens in V–O–V or V–O–W sites, the observed single 51V NMR signal has suggested the presence of rapid proton-transfer in solution. In 2, although the bonding of Cp*Rh2+ group on the V3 surface implies two protonations at V–O–W sites, it is not determined whether the symmetry is Cs or C1. |
To verify the interaction of the Cp*Rh2+ group with three edge-shared vanadium octahedra (B-site V3 surface), we aimed at synthesizing a novel Cp*Rh2+ complex supported on a Keggin-type α-1,4,9-trivanadium-substituted polyoxotungstate (NBu4)4H2[α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40] 1 [Fig. 1(b)]. The α-1,4,9-substituted Keggin polyoxotungstate 1 was first reported as an isomer of an α-1,2,3-substituted compound by Domaille and Watunya in 1986,7 but its development to a polyoxoanion-support for organometallic complexes has not, as yet, been studied. In this work, we have successfully prepared a novel Keggin polyoxotungstate-based 1∶1-type Cp*Rh2+ complex [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3]H2[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40)]·3DMSO· 0.5MeCN 2 as an analytically pure, yellow–brown powder by a 1∶3 molar ratio reaction in MeCN–DMSO mixed solvent at 80 °C under nitrogen of 1 with the [Cp*Rh(MeCN)3]2+ ion. In 2, one Cp*Rh2+ group is covalently bonded to, i.e. directly supported on, the V3 surface oxygens [Fig. 1(d)], and the other group is present as a counter ion with coordinated DMSO molecules. The unique composition of 2 can be compared with the previous Keggin-type organometallics family (NBu4)4[(CpTi)(β-1,2,3-SiW9V3O40)] 33b–d,5 and (NBu4)5[(Cp*Rh)(β-1,2,3-SiW9Nb3O40)] 4,8a,b and also with the Dawson-type family (NBu4)6[(CpTi)(α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62)] 5,5 (NBu4)5[(Cp*Rh)2(α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62)] 66 and (NBu4)7[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,2,3-P2W15Nb3O62)] 7.1a,d,f Examples of polyoxometalates with organometallic counter cations have previously been reported as bifunctional solid catalysts based on the classic Keggin polyoxometalates, i.e. [(Ph3P)2Rh(CO)(MeCN)]n[XM12O40] (M = P, Si, X = Mo, W).9 Herein, we report full details of the synthesis and spectroscopic characterization of 2.
Complex 2 was formed by a 1∶3 molar ratio stoichiometric reaction, in MeCN–DMSO mixed solution under nitrogen, of the Keggin polyoxotungstate-support 1 with the separately in situ-derived [Cp*Rh(MeCN)3](BF4)2, and was purified by repeated reprecipitation from DMSO solution, initially with excess EtOAc and then with excess MeCN. The molecular formula of 2, obtained in 69.2% yield (0.31 g scale) as a DMSO-soluble, MeCN-insoluble yellow–brown powder, was consistent with all data [complete elemental analysis, TG/DTA, FTIR and solution (51V, 31P, 1H and 13C) NMR spectroscopies]. The formation of 2 is shown in eqns. (1) and (2).
(1) |
(2) |
In the present synthesis, there are several key points. (i) The appropriate solvent for preparation is a MeCN–DMSO mixed solvent, because the starting polyoxotungstate-support 1 is MeCN- and DMSO-soluble but CH2Cl2-insoluble, while the product 2 is soluble only in DMSO. In fact, the Cp*Rh2+ complex supported on 1 was formed only in lower yield under refluxing conditions in pure MeCN. (ii) The synthetic stoichiometry to obtain 2 in good yield is a 1∶3 molar ratio of 1∶[Cp*Rh(MeCN)3](BF4)2. (iii) The most interesting point is the fact that all NBu4+ counter ions of 1 are completely replaced with [Cp*Rh(solvent)3]2+ (solvent = MeCN, DMSO). This phenomenon has not been found previously in the formation of organometallic complexes supported on both Keggin and Dawson triniobium-substituted polyoxotungstates.1,8 (iv) The by-product NBu4BF4 in the formation of 2 was completely removed by repeated reprecipitation with EtOAc and then with MeCN, and 2 was isolated in an analytically pure form.
For control experiments relating to point (iii), the 1H NMR spectrum in DMSO-d6 of the MeCN-insoluble orange powder obtained after 17 h refluxing of the starting 1∶3 molar-ratio mixture in MeCN revealed that the compound did not contain the counter cation NBu4+. 31P and 51V NMR spectra in DMSO-d6 of the orange powder showed that it contained two major species with an intensity ratio of ca. 1∶2 (δP −10.95 and −12.02, and δV −547.9 and −562.6); one is probably [Cp*Rh(MeCN)3]H2[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40)] 2 (δP −12.02, δV −547.9) and the other is probably [Cp*Rh(MeCN)3]2H2[α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40] (δP −10.95, δV −562.6). By dissolving the orange powder in DMSO-d6 and monitoring variable-temperature 31P NMR (from room temperature to 90 °C), we found that the 31P NMR signal due to the supported Cp*Rh2+ complex increased as the temperature is elevated and the 31P NMR signal due to the single species at 90 °C appeared at δ −11.31. Thus, in polar solvents such as DMSO and MeCN, the following reaction is presumed to occur [eqn. (3)].
(3) |
These facts are also in contrast to the recent preparation in less-polar CH2Cl2 of the Dawson-type species (NBu4)5[(Cp*Rh)2(α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62)] 6 isolated as a brown powder which is unstable in MeCN,6 in the preparation of which the CH2Cl2-soluble, deprotonated form, (NBu4)9[α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62], was allowed to react with an equimolar amount of [Cp*RhCl2]2 in ice-cooled CH2Cl2 without the use of AgBF4.
The purity and molecular composition of 2 were established by complete elemental analysis (all elements including oxygen, and adding up to 100.53%). No presence of NBu4+ ions is evidenced by 1H NMR in DMSO-d6. The evidence for the presence of the coordinating and/or solvated DMSO is also obtained by FTIR as multiple intense vibrational bands at 1500–1300 cm−1 region [Fig. 2(b)] and also by 13C NMR as a signal at δ 40.2. The presence of the two different types of Cp*Rh2+ groups has been evidenced by 1H NMR with signals at δ 1.64 and 1.84 due to the methyl group of Cp*, and also by 13C NMR with signals at δ 8.16 and 8.97 due to the methyl carbon and signals at δ 93.0 and 95.3 due to the quaternary carbon of Cp*.
Fig. 2 FTIR spectra (KBr disks) of (a) (NBu4)4H2[α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40] 1, (b) [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3]H2[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40)]·3DMSO· 0.5MeCN 2, (c) Na5[(Cp*Rh)(β-1,2,3-SiW9Nb3O40)]·3DMSO·2H2O, (d) Na7[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,2,3-P2W15Nb3O62)]·7DMSO·5H2O, and (e) (NBu4)5[(Cp*Rh)2(α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62)]·0.2NBu4Cl. In (a) and (b), the observation of the characteristic Keggin-type polyoxoanion IR bands in the range 1100–700 cm−1 demonstrates that the [α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40]6− support-ion remains intact under the conditions of the synthesis. In spectrum (b), in place of the very intense C–H vibrations due to the NBu4+ counter cations in (a), very intense and broad bands are observable in the range 1500–1300 cm−1; these are attributed to the vibrations of the coordinating DMSO molecules on the Cp*Rh2+ group. The bands due to the supported Cp*Rh groups and the solvated DMSO molecules have been observed as very weak and broad bands in the 1500–1300 cm−1 region, as shown in the sodium salts (c) and (d).1b,8d In (e),6 the vibrational bands due to the two Cp*Rh2+ groups supported on the B-site V3 surface of the Dawson polyoxotungstate could not be observed, owing to the presence of intense vibrational bands characteristic of NBu4+ (1490–1370 cm−1). |
In the FTIR spectrum of 2 in the polyoxometalate region [Fig. 2(b)], the major change relative to 1 was seen in the polyoxometalate region; the (969 and 956 cm−1) bands of 1 assignable to M–Oterminal and the 809 cm−1 band of 1 assignable to edge-sharing M–O–M oxygens,10 changed to bands at 954 and 802 cm−1 of 2, respectively, and the 882 cm−1 band of 1 assignable to corner-sharing M–O–M oxygens10 shifted to a lower energy band at 876 cm−1 of 2. The (1152, 1123 and 1090 cm−1) bands of 1 seem to be shifted to the 1111 cm−1 band of 2, and the 1054 cm−1 band (P–O) of 1 seems to be shifted to the (1038 and 1019 cm−1) bands of 2.
Fig. 3 51V NMR spectra in DMSO-d6 with reference to external VOCl3 of (a) (NBu4)4H2[α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40] 1 and (b) [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3]H2[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40)]·3DMSO·0.5MeCN 2. |
The 31P NMR spectrum in DMSO-d6 of 2 showed one resonance at δ −12.7 (Fig. 4), substantially different from the δ −11.0 resonance of 1. The 31P NMR spectrum confirmed the homogeneity of 2 and, thus, the support-site regiospecificity in 2.
Fig. 4 31P NMR spectra in DMSO-d6 with reference to external 25% H3PO4 in H2O of (a) (NBu4)4H2[α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40] 1 and (b) [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3]H2[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,4,9-PW9V3O40)]·3DMSO·0.5MeCN 2. For both, a very high level of purity is indicated (i.e., with respect to any other, P-containing polyoxoanions such as the 1,2,3-isomer or other materials). |
Further evidence for the single product nature of 2 came from the Cp* resonances in DMSO-d6 seen in the 1H NMR at δ 1.84 (Cp*Rh group supported) and at δ 1.64 (Cp*Rh group as counter ion) and in the 13C NMR at δ 8.16 (Cp*Rh group as counter ion) and 8.97 (Cp*Rh group supported) and their quaternary carbon resonances at δ 93.0 and 95.3, respectively. These assignments are based on our control experiments, i.e.1H and 13C NMR measurements of the DMSO-d6 solution of [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3](BF4)2, which was derived by a reaction in DMSO-d6 of [Cp*RhCl2]2 with stoichiometric amounts of AgBF4, followed by filtering off AgCl. The 1H NMR signal of the methyl proton of the Cp* group in [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3](BF4)2 was observed at δ 1.55, and the 13C NMR signals of the methyl carbon and quaternary carbon were found at δ 7.13 and 92.0, respectively.
Compared with the recently prepared 2∶1 type complex (NBu4)5[(Cp*Rh)2(α-1,2,3-P2W15V3O62)] 6,6 the reason why only one Cp*Rh group is supported on the V3 surface in 2 is probably attributable to the presence of surface protons and hence a lower surface charge in 1; it is related to the points (2) and (3) above.
It has also been elucidated that the complex 6 is stable in CH2Cl2, but unstable in MeCN; for 6 dissolved in MeCN, the supported Cp*Rh group is removed from the polyoxoanion surface to produce [Cp*Rh(MeCN)3]2+, which is present as the counter cation.6 Such phenomena have not been observed in the supported Cp*Rh complexes on triniobium-substituted Keggin and Dawson polyoxometalates such as (NBu4)5[(Cp*Rh)(β-1,2,3-SiW9Nb3O40)] 48a,b and (NBu4)7[(Cp*Rh)(α-1,2,3-P2W15Nb3O62)] 7.1a,d,f It should be, therefore, noted that the bonding interaction between the Cp*Rh2+ group and the edge-shared M3O6 triads (M = NbVvs. VV) is significantly different. This difference may be more pronounced in the bonding of an organometallic group with higher positive-charge such as CpTi3+ on the M3O6 triads.
1H (399.65 MHz), 13C-{1H} (100.40 MHz), 31P NMR (161.70 MHz) and 51V NMR (104.95 MHz) spectra in DMSO-d6 solution were recorded in 5-mm outer diameter tubes on a JEOL JNM-EX 400 FT-NMR spectrometer and JEOL EX-400 NMR data-processing system. 1H and 13C-{1H} NMR spectra were referenced to internal TMS. Chemical shifts are reported as positive for resonances downfield of TMS (δ 0). 31P NMR spectra were referenced to an external standard of 25% H3PO4 in H2O in a sealed capillary and the 51V NMR spectra referenced to an external standard of VOCl3. Chemical shifts were reported on the δ scale with resonances upfield of H3PO4 (δ 0) as negative and with resonances upfield of VOCl3 (δ 0) as negative, respectively.
Complex 1 is soluble in MeCN and DMSO, but insoluble in CH2Cl2. All attempts at preparing an unprotonated species, expected to be CH2Cl2-soluble, such as passing through a NBu4+-type ion-exchange resin column and reaction with NBu4OH, were unsuccessful. In such work-ups, a conversion to the α-1,2,3-isomer was observed.
The hygroscopic, yellow–brown powder obtained in 69.2% (0.31 g) yield was soluble in DMSO, but insoluble in EtOAc, MeCN and diethyl ether {Found: C, 11.74; H, 2.05; N, 0.21; O, 21.3; P, 0.93; S, 5.93; V, 4.71; Rh, 5.66; W, 48.0; total 100.53%. Calc. for C33H69.5N0.5O46PS6V3Rh2W9 or [Cp*Rh(DMSO)3]H2[(Cp*Rh)PW9V3O40]·3DMSO·0.5MeCN): C, 11.50; H, 2.03; N, 0.20; O, 21.36; P, 0.90; S, 5.58; V, 4.43; Rh, 5.97; W, 48.02%}. TG/DTA data: weight loss due to adsorbed water was observed below 50 °C, suggesting that it is hygroscopic; decomposition began around 228 °C with exothermic peaks at 228 and 373 °C. FTIR bands (KBr disk) in the 1500–400 cm−1 region (polyoxometalate region): 1419m, 1318m, 1111m, 1038s, 1019s, 954vs, 876vs, 802vs, 592m, 506m cm−1. 1H NMR (DMSO-d6, 21.5 °C): δ 1.64, 1.84 (C5Me5). 13C NMR (DMSO-d6, 22.0 °C): δ 8.16, 8.97 (C5Me5), 93.0, 95.3 (C5Me5). In the 1H and 13C NMR spectra, the lower-field signals are assigned to the Cp*Rh group supported on 1 and the higher-field signals are assigned to the Cp*Rh group as counter ion. 31P NMR (DMSO-d6, 22.0 °C): δ −12.7. 51V NMR (DMSO-d6, 22.0 °C): δ −546.7 (Δν1/2 586 Hz). The 183W NMR measurements were unsuccessful, due to the low concentration of the saturated DMSO-d6 solution.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2001 |