Moritz
Rauschenbach†
,
Moritz
Meier-Merziger†
and
Holger
Frey†
*
Department of Chemistry, Johannes Gutenberg-University Mainz, Duesbergweg 10-14, 55128 Mainz, Germany. E-mail: hfrey@uni-mainz.de; Web: https://www.ak-frey.chemie.uni-mainz.de/
First published on 2nd October 2024
Polymers based on 1,3-diene monomers play a pivotal role in many commercial elastomers and thermoplastic elastomers. This perspective summarizes the state of the art and recent developments in the living anionic polymerization of dienes, permitting to finely tune the properties of the resulting polymers. An emphasis is placed on novel biobased diene monomers (myrcene, farnesene, etc.) and polymerization solvents, which bear promise for more sustainable elastomers in the future. Furthermore, statistical copolymerization of dienes with vinyl monomers and the in situ monitoring of monomer gradients and formation of tapered di- and triblock copolymers due to disparate reactivity ratios is also reviewed. Thermoplastic elastomers based on tri- and multiblock architectures as well as recently reported diene-based polymer architectures are discussed as well. A summary of current challenges and future options for carbanionic diene polymerization concludes this short review article.
Moritz Rauschenbach was born in Bad Homburg v. d. Höhe (1996) and graduated in Chemistry (2021) from the Johannes-Gutenberg-University, Mainz in Germany. During his studies he spent 6 months in the labs of Rachel O'Reilly at the University of Birmingham working on the synthesis of antimicrobial hyperbranched polymer-complexes. In his PhD he focusses on the anionic polymerization of non-conventional 1,3-dienes. Hence, he is interested in the kinetics of those new monomers in comparison to established systems with the aim of elucidating their potential as thermoplastics or functional precursors. |
Moritz Meier-Merziger was born in Darmstadt, Germany (1995), and graduated in Chemistry (2021) from the Johannes-Gutenberg-University, Mainz in Germany. He spent 6 months abroad at the University of Toronto, Canada working on the post-modification of gelatine and hyaluronic acid for their application in hydrogels. His current research during his Ph.D. in the research group of Prof. Holger Frey focusses on the carbanionic polymerization of terpene derived dienes and bifunctional initiators as well as biobased thermoplastic elastomers. His interests comprise sustainable polymers, kinetic investigations, and polymer analytics. |
Holger Frey studied Chemistry at the University of Freiburg/Brsg. He obtained a Ph.D. from the Universiteit Twente, NL (1993) following a stay at Carnegie-Mellon University in Pittsburgh, PA (USA). From 1994 until 2001 he worked as a senior lecturer and assistant professor at the University of Freiburg. Since 2002, he has held a full professorship at the Johannes-Gutenberg-University, Mainz, Germany. His research interests are centered on anionic polymerization of epoxides, dienes and vinyl monomers as well as the catalytic polymerization of carbon dioxide. His current interests include the development of a non-crystalline and non-immunogenic alternative to PEG for medical applications, designated rPEG. Further interests are thermoplastic elastomers, kinetic investigation, branched polymer architectures and silicon-based polymer chemistry. |
Polydienes are commonly synthesized by anionic or catalytic polymerization techniques. Catalytic polymerization strategies are employed on a large commercial scale. Recently the long-time challenge of incorporation of polar monomers was achieved by the groups of Cui and Mecking, who also introduced the catalytic polymerization of functional dienes.24,25 We emphasize that a detailed overview of the catalytic polymerization of 1,3-dienes will not be covered in this short review. Readers are referred to recently published, excellent summaries in this area.26,27 Characteristic polymer properties found and discussed for polydiene materials naturally apply, regardless of the polymerization technique used. The main advantage of the catalytic polymerization is the precise control of stereoselectivity.26 The development of a Gd-based catalyst enabled similarly high 99.9% cis-1,4-polyisoprene stereocontrol, as known from natural rubber.28
Due to the high basicity of the carbanion, the highest extent of control in anionic polymerization is achieved by the challenging break-seal method.29 This requires not only a synthetic skillset, but also glassblowing skills. The more accessible high vacuum technique, that has long been established, still enables exceptional control over the polymerization. This allows to synthesize new polydienes and to investigate the impact of polymerization conditions. Besides the established production of polydienes via batch synthesis, also continuous flow reactors for the carbanionic polymerization can be employed for the polymerization of dienes.30–33 Recently, Haddleton and coworkers reported on the anionic diene polymerization without monomer/solvent purification steps, making it more widely applicable, albeit for lower molar mass polymers, e.g. for polymer additives and surfactants.34,35 With respect to precision, anionic polymerization surpasses the catalytic approach, thanks to its distinctive living character, which enables to synthesize of a wide range of polymer architectures and also tailormade gradient and tapered chain compositions in copolymers.8
In recent years, there has been a notable shift in academic research as well as in industry towards bio-derived monomers. Efforts to tailor material properties for enhanced performance accompany this research direction, with the aim of matching or surpassing the properties of established fossil fuel-based materials. In this review we will cover 1,3-dienes beyond the classical representatives, butadiene and isoprene. A selection of the discussed mono- and disubstituted 1,3-dienes is shown in Fig. 1. While some can be found in nature, additional synthetic modification steps are required for others. The number of synthetically accessible 1,3-dienes for the anionic polymerization is steadily increasing.
Fig. 1 Overview of a selection of 1,3-dienes discussed in this perspective, including recently introduced diene monomers. Reactive diene moieties are marked for each monomer. |
(1) |
Scheme 1 (a) Aggregation equilibrium of polyisoprenyl lithium in nonpolar solvents in analogy to Müller and Matyjaszewski; (b) possible microstructures of PI and their respective glass temperatures.38,40 |
k app gives the apparent rate constant of the propagation, [Ini]0 the initial concentration of the initiator and n the number of aggregating chains. Importantly, the aggregates are in an equilibration with the unimers, which are considered to be the active species capable of sustaining the propagation mechanism, see Scheme 1. M. Szwarc already reported that the relative rates of propagation for isoprene and butadiene are ordered as isoprene > butadiene, while both exhibit a number of aggregating chains of n = 4.10,39 However, it was found that polyisoprenyl lithium aggregation also depends on the concentration of active chain ends. An overall equilibration between tetramers and dimers was observed, with n approaching ∼2 with decreasing concentration.10,38 β-Myrcene and β-farnesene, although kinetically investigated under the assumption of tetramer formation, have not been explored with respect to their aggregation behavior.19,22 The observation that their propagation rate surpasses that of isoprene suggests the presence of an equilibrium solely between dimers and unimers. It should be noted that this assumption has not yet been empirically confirmed.
The coordination of the counterion to the incoming monomer and its spatial orientation mainly dictate the regioselectivity, see Scheme 2. In nonpolar media, it has been reported to undergo a six-membered transition state, where the diene is added in a cis-form, explaining overall high amount of 1,4-addition. The final cis/trans ratios have been extensively elucidated by Gebert et al. who suggested an isomerization of the cis-oriented chain end to a trans-form before the next monomer addition.38,41,42 Worsfold and Bywater further proposed that the isomerization occurs in competition with the monomer addition.10,43 Based on these fundamental studies, the final ratio of cis and trans 1,4-units can be explained.
Scheme 2 Proposed mechanism of the polymerization of isoprene with lithium as a counter ion in apolar or polar media, respectively; image is reproduced from Frey et al.41 with permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry, 2022. |
By changing the counterion from Li+ to Na+ or K+, for instance, the interionic distance increases, which reduces the 1,4-content of polydienes.10,44 Based on the industrially most popular diene representative 1,3-butadiene, Carlotti and coworkers have investigated the impact of bimetallic initiator systems with lithium and potassium or calcium, respectively. They studied the influence of the additional coordinative center on the microstructure. While the addition of potassium led to an expected increase of 1,2-units, the designed calcium-lithium initiators enabled high control towards trans-1,4-units.45,46 Reviewing the accessible microstructures of polybutadiene, Carlotti et al. also reported on the combined effect of both variation of the counterions as well as changing to polar solvents.9 The polymerization in polar solvents, e.g. THF, or the addition of polar modifiers are both associated with suppression of the coordination between the chain end, the counterion and the diene. In consequence, the resulting increased vinyl content enhances the backbone rigidity of the polydiene, which is reflected by an increase of the glass temperature (Scheme 1b).38,41 The influence of solvents on the anionic polymerization will be discussed below in greater detail.
A rather new aspect in this field is the examination of the orientation of the double bonds with respect to each other in the 1,3-diene scaffold. In this regard, DFT calculations can give mechanistic insights beyond the mere conversion in a copolymerization. In a recent publication we investigated rotationally constrained dienes.41 Two model compounds were synthesized to obtain a cisoid and a transoid monomer as shown in Fig. 2a. DFT calculations identified deviations of the torsion angle in both monomers and allow for an assumption regarding the reactivity given by the electron densities. A crucial finding from the simulation is that if a fixed transoid geometry is present, only one of the double bonds can coordinate with the lithium counterion. This crucial step should prevent the polymerization. In contrast, the cisoid model compound coordinates with both double bonds, albeit a distortion of the ring is required. Consequently, only homopolymers with the cisoid 1,2-dimethylene-cyclohexane (DMCH) were obtained and copolymerization with isoprene was achieved. DFT calculations show that the energy required for the polymerization of DMCH is significantly increased compared to isoprene due to a required distortion of the ring, see Fig. 2b. Empirically, this was observed via in situ1H NMR kinetics. In the copolymerization with isoprene, isoprene is consumed predominantly, resulting in a gradient structure along the chain. The homopolymerization of DMCH itself required unusual conditions to keep the growing chain in solution: high temperatures of 140 °C were applied in the high-boiling solvent tetralin. Noteworthy, the analysis of PDMCH confirmed the exclusive formation of 1,4-units and a Tg of 53 °C. In contrast, no polymers were obtained with the transoid monomer IMMCH. In 2015, Ishizone and coworkers described the anionic polymerization of the transoid-fixed benzofulvene in both polar and apolar media.47–49 This can be attributed to the conjugation with the aromatic ring that leads to a planar cross-conjugated π-system resulting in a higher reactivity. The removal of the aromatic ring, e.g., in methylene cyclopentane resulted in the expected reduction of the reactivity. For this monomer 70 °C and a reaction time of 4 days were required to achieve full conversion.50 Consequently, it can be concluded that transoid dienes are not suitable for the living anionic polymerization in nonpolar solvents at mild conditions.
Fig. 2 (a) Rotationally constrained dienes with a cisoid (DMCH) and a transoid (IMMCH) geometry; (b) reaction pathways for the four possible propagation steps of the copolymerization of isoprene and DMCH (addition of DMCH, blue; addition of isoprene, green), image is reproduced from Frey et al.41 with permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry, 2022. |
Moreover, already a methyl group can interfere with the coordinative process and prevent the formation of a narrow molar mass distribution. This was shown for the two isomers trans- and cis-pentadiene. They exhibit rate constants in the order cis > trans, while only the trans-isomer gives well-defined polymers (Đ ≤ 1.09).51 Surprisingly, the polymerization is gradually decelerated, if both isomers are mixed, leading to the order of the rate constants as follow: cis > trans > cis/trans.52
Taking these recent results of geometrically constrained dienes together, one can tentatively answer the initially raised question: the classic anionic polymerization shows indeed many features of a coordinative process in apolar media. Various parameters can be changed to influence the coordination, either by relying on a solvent that coordinates the counter ion or by changing the substitution pattern of the diene, which was found to influence the mechanism drastically as in the diastereomers isoprene and cis-pentadiene. These strategies are being further pursued by various groups at present.
Fig. 3 Correlation of glass temperature of polydienes with the vinyl content. The values are combined from several original works.60–63 |
In addition to altering the system's polarity, it is well-known that increasing bulkiness of the substituent results in an almost exclusive formation of cis-1,4-units. This was demonstrated for the anionic polymerization of 2-substituted 1,3-butadiene derivatives with a methyl, ethyl, n-propyl or isopropyl group.64–66 Pendant phenyl groups, as seen in 1-phenyl butadiene (PhB), 1-phenyl isoprene (1PhI) and 4-phenyl isoprene (4PhI), have demonstrated a predominant occurrence of 1,4-addition (>80%), even in the polar solvent THF.67–69 Furthermore, Ishizone and coworkers achieved control over the incorporation by designing rather unusual allylidene monomers.70,71 The reported butadiene-derivatives were 1,1-disubstituted with increasing bulkiness of the pendant group. Various substituents, ranging from two methyl groups to a bornane ring and even the bulky adamantyl group, were attached to the dienyl-unit. Hence, the sterically hindered 1,4-addition could be further prohibited with increasing bulkiness, which is underlined by the absence of 1,2-units. The structures shown in Fig. 4a were sufficiently effective to increase 3,4-units to more than 20% in apolar media. The bulky substituents of the structures in Fig. 4b result almost exclusively in 3,4-incorporation. As a result, these polymers turned out to be very rigid materials with high glass temperatures of nearly 200 °C in case of the pendant bornane-ring. In theory, this might allow for application in high temperature resistant thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs) as a hard segment, but on the other hand this will also necessitate extremely high processing temperatures.
Fig. 4 1,1-Disubstituted 1,3-dienes studied with respect to their behavior in the anionic polymerization, reported by Ishizone et al.70,71 |
The monomer 1-vinyl cyclohexene (VCH) serves as a model compound with one double bond that is sterically constrained within a cyclic structure. The key question is whether VCH behaves as a 1,3-diene or as a styrenic vinyl monomer in the anionic polymerization in nonpolar media. In analogy to other diene structures, the homopolymerization in cyclohexane (CHx) lead to a predominant formation of 64% 1,4-units.72 The extent of 1,4-incorporation is comparable to the allylidene cyclohexane with a reported 66% 1,4-units when polymerized in benzene.71 However, the added rigidity from the ring in the backbone increased the Tg to 78 °C. The microstructure of PVCH was adjusted to enhance the vinyl content, reaching up to 78% of 3,4-PVCH upon addition of the polar modifier THF. The resulting material properties, with a Tg of up to 89 °C, are much closer to those of PS (Tg = 100 °C).73 Likewise, hydrogenation leads to a high amount of polyvinylcyclohexane (PVCH) segments, as obtained by hydrogenation of PS.
Fig. 5 Different copolymer architectures for TPEs based on block, tapered and branched triblock structures as well as graft-copolymers.22,75–78 |
Due to the increasing length of the side chains in PMyr and PFar that do not contribute to the polymer backbone length, the entanglement molar mass strongly increases from 7 kg mol−1 for PI, 18 kg mol−1 for PMyr to 50 kg mol−1 for PFar.79–81 This effect has considerable consequences for elastic mechanical properties that are strongly dependent on the entanglements of the polymer chains. Therefore, higher molar masses compared to PI are required for PFar to obtain similar mechanical properties.
The first report on the anionic polymerization of β-myrcene by our group focused on the behavior in statistical copolymerization with isoprene, styrene and 4-methyl styrene (4MS), respectively.23In situ1H NMR kinetics was performed, revealing β-myrcene to be a suitable substitute for isoprene with similar behavior in the copolymerization with styrene. Both systems show a steep gradient, as discussed later in this perspective. This was further investigated using the in situ NIR method.19 A series of S/Myr-copolymers were synthesized to investigate the impact of an increasing amount of THF on the nature of the gradient structure of the copolymers. It was shown that the gradient structure can be tuned by a variety of modifiers, even to complete inversion of the reactivity ratios, similar to the behavior observed earlier for isoprene.17 Furthermore, we showed that Far forms a gradient structure in the statistical copolymerization with styrene and that the polymerization in cyclohexane became significant faster when moving up the homologous series of terpenes: kp,I < kp,Myr < kp,Far.16,19,21
Although renewable feedstocks are one of the most important current research fields, their impact on nature and, above all, the possible competition with food sources should always be considered as well. β-Farnesene, relatively price competitive, as shown by its use as sustainable jet fuel besides its application in materials, is mainly derived from sugar cane.82 PFar products are already widely available in industry, e.g., PFar-diol is used for the preparation of polyurethanes.60,83 Therefore, additional feedstocks are being sought. It was already shown that heterotrophic as well as lithoautotrophic bacteria are capable of producing Far from cultivation on a variety of substrates.84
Furthermore, the additional double bonds in the side chain allow for further post-modification with respect to thiol–ene click chemistry and epoxidation, respectively.85,86 Thereby, these monomers offer the possibility of introducing functionalities along the polydiene chains, which would require suitable protecting groups if introduced prior polymerization. This will be addressed in a later section of this overview. In addition to these aforementioned examples, there are also less known representatives in the field of terpenes. For instance, our group reported on the anionic polymerization of β-ocimene (Oc).87 As Oc resembles a 1,2-disubstitued diene it naturally occurs as a mixture of the cis and trans-isomer, similar to 1,3-pentadiene. The anionic polymerization in cyclohexane resulted in an unusually high dispersity up to 2. In situ1H NMR kinetics revealed a preferred consumption of the trans-isomer over the cis-form (rtrans = 3.16 and rcis = 0.316) turning the apparent Oc homopolymerization into a copolymerization of the two stereoisomers. Surprisingly, the addition of styrene inverted the trend to an accelerated consumption of the cis-isomer. Taking advantage of these findings, both isomers were isolated by polymerization of the respective other isomer. Consequently, the NMR kinetics with styrene could be elucidated separately. The values given in Table 2 reveal the presumed consumption of styrene over the trans-isomer (rtrans = 0.628 and rS = 1.59), while unexpectedly the cis-isomer showed an almost random incorporation of both monomers (rcis = 1.01 and rS = 0.98). This phenomenon is quite uncommon in the field of carbanionic polymerization, as mostly gradient structures are obtained. An overview of a broad range of diene copolymerizations and their respective reactivity ratios is given in Table 2. For reference, the established S/I-copolymerization in cyclohexane shows a steep gradient, characterized by rI = 10 and rS = 0.015.17
1,3-Diene structures offer potential beyond low Tg and high elasticity, as their structures can be highly diverse. Ishizone et al. presented a variety of 1,1-disubstituted dienes that possess cyclic structural elements and were already discussed in more detail earlier in this perspective.70,71 Their unusually high Tgs are attributed to the rigidity of the ring structure and the resulting high content of 3,4-units. Cyclic elements can also be incorporated by 1,2-substitution as mentioned for the monomer VCH.72 With the monomer nopadiene (Nopa), 1R,5S-2-ethenyl-6,6-dimethylbicyclo[3.1.1]hept-2-ene, our group recently presented a sterically even more demanding structure, due to its bicyclic structure. Thereby, a strikingly high Tg of 160 °C for PNopa can be achieved. Nopadiene was therefore presented as a potential biobased substitute of styrene in TPE materials. Nopa can be derived from myrtenal or nopol, again originating from β-pinene. An exclusive diene structured and fully biobased TPE can be obtained using the monomers Myr and Nopa.88 Furthermore, we also developed a one-step synthesis for TPEs. By precisely controlling the reaction conditions, we achieved reactivity ratios that favor the incorporation of low Tg PFar, followed by high Tg PNopa. Since a bifunctional initiator was employed for this reaction, a telechelic polymerization was realized and thus, two-sided tapered ABA-triblock structures are accessible in a single polymerization step, enabling an extremely rapid strategy for the synthesis of biobased thermoplastic elastomers.78
The diversity of natural sourced compounds, e.g. terpenes, offers vast potential to customize material properties. However, many parameters must be considered. As many biobased monomers have expanded the portfolio of polymers accessible via carbanionic polymerization, a compilation of a variety of the resulting diene polymers in terms of their glass temperature is listed in Table 1. The data show the enormous diversity of diene structures and their potential in the field of materials science, as they can be tailored to a wide range of thermal properties. Among those listed, 4,8-dimethylnona-1,3,7-triene (DMNT) has not yet been presented in an original work yet.
Polymer | 1,4 [%] | T g [°C] | Ref. | Polymer | 1,4 [%] | T g [°C] | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a 2-Allylidene-adamantane (Aad). b 2-Allylidene-1,1,3,3-tetramethylcyclopentane (ATMC5). | |||||||
PB | 72 | −86 | 60 | PDMNT | 74 | −30 | — |
PFar | 91 | −75 | 60 | POc | 15 | −26 | 87 |
PFar | 61 | −73 | 60 | PB | 10 | −21 | 60 |
PFar | 48 | −70 | 60 | PI | 15 | 0 | 60 |
PMyr | 94 | −67 | 61 | PMyrDOL | 67 | 11 | 89 |
PI | 91 | −67 | 60 | P4PhI | 94 | 48 | 69 |
PFar | 37 | −66 | 75 | PDMCH | 100 | 53 | 41 |
PMyr | 72 | −58 | 63 | P1PhI | 35 | 65 | 69 |
PMyrOSi | 69 | −53 | 61 | PVCH | 22 | 89 | 72 |
PB | 30 | −45 | 60 | PNopa | 51 | 158 | 88 |
PMyr | 30 | −39 | 62 | PAada | 0.0 | 178 | 70 |
PI | 44 | −32 | 60 | PATMC5b | 0.0 | 194 | 71 |
Further, the awareness of sustainability and a shift towards more biobased systems has led to a reconsideration of solvents, as they make up for a large proportion of a synthesis. Consequently, biobased, more sustainable solvents are currently under investigation, see Fig. 6.
Looking beyond butadiene and isoprene, other new and often biobased monomers may require the use of more polar solvents. As introduced above, PFar maintains a low Tg when polymerized in a polar medium, whereas the syntheses of other polydienes require an apolar solvent to achieve similar material properties. Schlaad and coworkers investigated the polymerization of isoprene and β-myrcene in a variety of “green” solvents, i.e. limonene, 2-methyl tetrahydrofuran (2-MeTHF) and cyclopentyl methyl ether (CPME).56,94 On the one hand, 2-MeTHF appeared to have almost the same impact on the microstructure as THF, affording a majority of 3,4-incoorporation (54%). On the other hand, CPME yielded a major fraction of 1,4-units of 64%. The apolar solvent limonene strikingly resulted in 90% 1,4-incorporation. In all solvents, moderate to low dispersities below 1.15 were obtained. Recently, CPME has also been employed for the copolymerization of styrene with isoprene or 1,3-pentadiene, as well as for the copolymerization of isoprene and 1,3-pentadiene. Kinetic studies were conducted to assess its suitability for use in anionic polymerization.95 Additionally, 2-MeTHF and CPME were both evaluated as additives in the anionic polymerization of 1,3-cyclohexadiene. Notably, CPME in a toluene system demonstrated promising results, with quantitative yields and successful achievement of targeted molar masses, while maintaining low dispersities of Đ < 1.12.96 In addition, Haddleton et al. investigated the use of squalane, bearing a C30 framework, in its unpurified form as a polymerization medium. Despite the high dispersity (Đ = 1.84), attributed to the avoidance of purification steps, the low polarity yielded 94% of 1,4-incorporation.35 In one of our recent works we showed that the moderately polar solvent methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE) is ideally suited to solvate the bifunctional initiator 1,3-diisopropenyl benzene (DIB). A synergy can be found, as MTBE enables a reliable bifunctional initiation, as it prevents aggregation, while the associated increase in vinyl content does not affect the properties of PFar.75,78 MTBE, besides being cheap due to industrial scale production for petrol-additives, can also potentially be obtained from renewable feedstocks, i.e. bio-methanol and bio-isobutylene.97 It is therefore somewhat surprising that it has not received more attention in carbanionic polymerization to date. This can certainly be attributed to the prevalence of the “classical” solvents established over decades. Recently, we investigated MTBE in-depth as moderately polar solvent and additive in homo- and copolymerizations.98
Scheme 3 Proposed mechanism of the backside-collapse, as described in the works of Takenaka et al.100,101 |
Our group reported on two approaches for functional diene-monomers. Both are based on β-myrcene as a precursor that was converted to a hydroxyl-functionalized structure. As free hydroxyl groups are incompatible with the carbanionic polymerization, suitable protecting groups must be employed. A single hydroxyl group was protected using a siloxy functionality (MyrOSi), and a dioxolane-based structure (MyrDOL) was used to incorporate two protected hydroxyl groups. Both functional monomers had a modifier effect on the polymerization, as the masked polar functionalities can interact with the counterion and thereby influence the polymerization mechanism. In this case, the diene acts both as a monomer as well as a modifier. The functionalized β-myrcene derivatives, MyrOSi and MyrDOL, showed 31% 3,4-units when polymerized in cyclohexane.61,89
Copolymers offer vast possibilities to tune, combine or design materials properties. A variety of copolymers exclusively synthesized via anionic polymerization were discussed before. Beyond this, there is a broad field of copolymers that are composed of monomers that require different polymerization techniques. This can be accomplished by preparing a macroinitiator from monomer A. Subsequently, Poly(A) serves as a macroinitiator for monomer B to form Poly(A)-b-Poly(B) block copolymers in a second reaction using a different polymerization technique. For this purpose, functional groups, e.g. hydroxyl groups, have to be incorporated at the polydiene framework. Controlled end-functionalization of carbanionic living chains is a suitable pathway. For this purpose, lithium, commonly present as a counterion in carbanionic polymerization, has the advantage of forming highly stable ion pairs with oxygen. Hence, by using an epoxide for the termination step of a carbanionic synthesis, lithium alkoxides are formed that are not capable of polymerizing any further. As a result, a single epoxide monomer reacts with the each chain end, leading to a degree of hydroxyl functionalization of up to 99%.102,103 Based on the large variety of epoxides available, this method offers vast potential for complex polymer architectures. We recently applied this method to a bifunctional system to simultaneously introduce hydroxyl groups at both chain ends. Whereas ethylene oxide is known to introduce one hydroxyl group, ethoxy ethyl glycidyl ether (EEGE) and isopropylidene glyceryl glycidyl ether (IGG) can be used to introduce two and three hydroxyl groups, respectively. Ultimately, this yields telechelic OH2-polydiene-OH2 and OH3-polydiene-OH3 macroinitiators. Via subsequent organocatalyzed chain extension relying on the ring-opening polymerization of L-lactide, elaborate architectures, e.g., H-, and super-H-shaped triblock copolymers are rapidly accessible.75,104
Another example for the subsequent formation of a second polymer is grafting from a macroinitiator bearing suitable functional groups at the chains. The high abundance of unsaturated groups present in polydienes was used to introduce functionalities in a post-polymerization pathway. This was demonstrated by the group of Li et al. using epoxidation of PMyr.77,105 Another efficient pathway is based on the use of polymers derived from functional monomers, e.g. PMyrOSi, that can be exploited as a macroinitiator after the cleavage of the protecting group. Again, by L-lactide grafting so-called bottlebrush structures are accessible.61
The coupling of polymers offers a third option for producing block copolymers, and particularly for complex polymer architectures. Coupling in the carbanionic polymerization can be achieved directly by introducing multifunctional coupling reagents, e.g. chlorosilanes, at the living polymer chains.106 In this manner, complex branched structures can be prepared, enhancing the material properties in terms of lowering viscosity in melt and solution. Coupling strategies are also employed for commercial products like Styrolux.11 Our group introduced a distillable tetra-functional chlorosilyl compound to produce well-defined multiblock star polymers.107,108 In the past, this has been pushed to the limit, with reports of up to 128-arm star polymers.109 The versatile chemistry of polydienes has recently been exploited by Hirschberg et al. in elegant work, who used epoxidized PI to couple with living polystyrenyl chains to obtain pom–pom architectures.110
Diene | Solvent | T [°C] | r diene | r S | Molar gradient | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Myr | CHx | 20 | 40 | 0.024 | 19 | |
β-Farnesene | CHx | 23 | 27 | 0.037 | 22 | |
Butadiene | CHx | 25 | 15.5 | 0.04 | 10 | |
Isoprene | CHx | 20 | 10.1 | 0.013 | 16 | |
4PhI | CHx | 25 | 9.2 | 0.109 | 69 | |
MyrDOL | CHx | 25 | 5.2 | 0.19 | 89 | |
1PhI | CHx | 25 | 3.38 | 0.3 | 69 | |
Nopadiene | CHx | 25 | 3.26 | 0.31 | 88 | |
cis-Ocimene | CHx | 23 | 1.015 | 0.985 | 87 | |
trans-Ocimene | CHx | 23 | 0.62 | 1.59 | 87 | |
VCH | CHx | 25 | 0.39 | 2.56 | 72 |
The copolymerization of two 1,3-dienes, mostly with isoprene as a comonomer, has also been investigated, see Table 3. Generally, rather weak gradients in comparison to diene/S-systems are observed. The β-myrcene derivative MyrDOL has been found to form the steepest gradients when copolymerized with either isoprene or β-myrcene, respectively. However, this monomer can hardly be compared with other systems due to its increased polarity resulting from the functional side chain, which is expected to reduce the formation of aggregates, similar to a polar modifier. Noteworthy, the copolymerization of isoprene with the DMCH and VCH, which are both rotationally constrained, results in a favored consumption of isoprene.
Diene 1 | Diene 2 | Solvent | T [°C] | r 1 | r 2 | Molar gradient | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MyrDOL | Isoprene | CHx | 25 | 9.22 | 0.11 | 89 | |
β-Myrcene | CHx | 23 | 4.4 | 0.23 | 23 | ||
Butadiene | n-Hexane | 20 | 2.82 | 0.42 | 118 | ||
1PhI | CHx | 25 | 0.865 | 1.155 | 69 | ||
VCH | CHx | 25 | ≪1 | ≫1 | 72 | ||
DMCH | CHx | 25 | 0.087 | 11.51 | 41 | ||
MyrDOL | β-Myrcene | CHx | 25 | 6.22 | 0.16 | 89 | |
Nopadiene | CHx | 25 | 0.13 | 7.49 | 88 | ||
Nopadiene | β-Farnesene | CHx | 25 | 0.155 | 6.50 | 78 |
More recently, we also implemented NIR-spectroscopy to track monomer consumption.16 The reactions can be monitored directly in the stirred polymerization solution in the reactor, which means that the product formed is directly characterized with respect to its monomer gradient in the chains. Using in situ NIR spectroscopy, we studied the influence of polar modifiers, i.e. THF and DTHFP, in the copolymerizations of I/S and Myr/S. Gradually increasing the ratio of [THF]/[Li] can be used as a tool to control the molar composition of the copolymer chains, as indicated by the profiles shown in Table 4. Both isoprene and β-myrcene are incorporated to a reduced extent, when the polarity of the system increases, resulting in the preferred consumption of styrene.17,19 In case of the copolymerization of β-myrcene and styrene, the chelating modifiers DTHFP and TMEDA were shown to have a much stronger impact compared to THF. Already 0.5 eq. of [DTHFP]/[Li] influences the copolymerization stronger than 20 eq. of THF. Only 2 eq. of either DTHFP or TMEDA already lead to an enhanced incorporation of styrene, as indicated by reactivity ratios of rS ≥ 17.5 and rMyr ≤ 0.15, respectively.19,59
Diene | Polar modifier | eq. | T [°C] | r Diene | r S | Molar gradient | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Isoprene | THF | 0.5 | 20 | 2.856 | 0.093 | 17 | |
Isoprene | THF | 2 | 20 | 1.06 | 0.262 | ||
Isoprene | THF | 20 | 20 | 0.374 | 0.925 | ||
Isoprene | THF | 240 | 20 | 0.148 | 4.196 | ||
β-Myrcene | THF | 0.5 | 20 | 12.3 | 0.082 | 19 | |
β-Myrcene | THF | 2 | 20 | 4.38 | 0.23 | ||
β-Myrcene | THF | 20 | 20 | 0.87 | 1.15 | ||
β-Myrcene | THF | 240 | 20 | 0.17 | 5.77 | ||
β-Myrcene | DTHFP | 0.5 | 20 | 0.41 | 2.42 | ||
β-Myrcene | DTHFP | 2 | 20 | 0.056 | 18.0 | ||
β-Myrcene | TMEDA | 2 | — | 0.15 | 17.52 | 59 |
An aspect not to be neglected is the responsibility of the industrialized countries to regulate the usage of the available farmland between the production of renewable raw materials and agriculture for food production. For this reason, many different feedstocks are under investigation to obtain dienes via truly sustainable pathways. One approach relies on utilizing bacteria in fermentation processes that are capable of turning waste streams into valuable resources.84 Another approach addresses turpentine oil as a feedstock, which does not compete with food production. This shows that the future holds many challenges when fossil fuel-based isoprene and butadiene are to be replaced as standard diene building blocks. New routes are therefore mandatory to adapt the new monomers to specific material properties. Other aspects such as more sustainable solvents or more efficient processes are also driving current research.
A major challenge for the polymerization of novel dienes is the transfer of innovations from academia to industry, as this sets the starting point for economic considerations of more sustainable solutions. This involves a shift from only three primarily used monomers, i.e., styrene, butadiene, and isoprene at present towards a variety of biobased diene structures.
Footnote |
† All authors have contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |