Fangyan
Liu‡
a,
Tong
Yu‡
b,
Jieqiong
Qin
*c,
Liangzhu
Zhang
a,
Feng
Zhou
a,
Xiong
Zhang
def,
Yanwei
Ma
def,
Feng
Li
*b and
Zhong-Shuai
Wu
*a
aState Key Laboratory of Catalysis, Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Dalian 116023, China. E-mail: wuzs@dicp.ac.cn
bShenyang National Laboratory for Materials Science, Institute of Metal Research, Chinese Academy of Science, Shenyang, 110016, China. E-mail: fli@imr.ac.cn
cCollege of Science, Henan Agricultural University, 63 Agricultural Road, Zhengzhou 450002, China. E-mail: qinjieqiong@henau.edu.cn
dInstitute of Electrical Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China
eSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
fInstitute of Electrical Engineering and Advanced Electromagnetic Drive Technology, Qilu Zhongke, Jinan 250013, China
First published on 4th June 2024
Li-ion capacitors (LICs) are promising to simultaneously achieve battery-level energy density and supercapacitor-level power density, but the slow kinetics of diffusion-controlled battery anodes lead to unmatched two-electrode kinetics at the device level. Herein, we report a capacitive-dominated anode of two-dimensional (2D) crumpled nitrogen-doped carbon nanosheets (N-CNS) with tailored nitrogen incorporation and abundant mesopore distribution, exhibiting large capacities and superior rate performance. The optimized N-CNS delivers large reversible capacities of 620 and 121 mA h g−1 at 0.1 and 100 A g−1, respectively. The introduced nitrogen is found to contribute to providing additional pseudocapacity and high Li+ diffusion coefficients in the medium–high voltage region and enhancing the capacitive-dominated charge storage process. The structural reversibility and “adsorption-intercalation” mechanism are supported by in situ and ex situ measurements. Furthermore, it is theoretically revealed that N-CNS with superior electrochemical properties benefits from the increase in Li+ adsorption energy and the decline in the Li+ diffusion barrier. A LIC coupling the N-CNS anode with a porous carbon cathode outputs a high energy density of 75 W h kg−1 at an ultrahigh power density of 65 kW kg−1. This study provides a novel and effective approach to developing high-performance carbon-based anodes for constructing advanced LICs featuring high energy and power density.
Hard carbons (HCs) are disordered non-graphitic carbons that are composed of randomly stacked, rumpled graphene sheets that are in a “house of cards” arrangement.3–5 They are generally considered to be a promising anode choice for realizing Li-ion fast charging. In general, Li ions can be stored in HCs via intercalation between graphite-like layers, adsorption on the surface, defects, and nanopores.6,7 Accordingly, the galvanostatic discharge/charge voltage profiles of HCs usually present sloping lines followed by a plateau representing a diffusion-controlled process with slow kinetics that restrict the rate capability.8–10 Hence, some HCs still face the dilemma of being unable to meet the high demands from LICs that simultaneously achieve high capacity and superior rate capability.
Surface-controlled charge storage behavior with a high capacitive contribution demonstrates excellent rate performance and reversibility.11,12 Increasing the surface defects by techniques such as nitrogen doping has been demonstrated to be effective in promoting the capacitive contribution.13–16 The doped-N acting as active sites can adsorb ions and produce reversible extra pseudocapacity to enhance the total capacity of carbon materials to satisfy the requirement of high energy density of devices.16,17 Being different from the sluggish ion diffusion within a crystalline structure, the doped-N reacts quickly on the surface or in the near-surface region while well maintaining the carbon structure, enabling great rate performance and cycling stability.18 It has been experimentally confirmed that the Li-ion storage performance has a strong correlation with the N-doping species.13,14 The adsorption ability of N-doping species for ions in carbon materials has been extensively studied from the perspective of theoretical calculations;19,20 however, the effects on Li-ion diffusion still need further investigation.
Although capacitive-dominated behavior exhibits faster kinetics than a diffusion-controlled Li-ion storage process, it is still not enough to achieve supercapacitor-level rate performance just via surface modification. To overcome this limitation, the adjustment of the pore structure especially mesopores is indispensable since abundant mesopores could shorten ion transport paths and largely buffer the ion diffusivity constraints at high rates,21 playing a critical role in determining the rate capability of carbon materials. The generation of mesopores usually comes from etching, template methods and self-arrangement of structural units.22–26 The first two methods are usually accompanied by some complicated processes, and the acquired porous carbons possess huge specific surface areas (SSAs), leading to limited initial coulombic efficiency.27,28 The last one could produce abundant mesopore size distribution with a limited specific surface area by taking advantage of the structural features of structural units, such as the folded pore structure of crumpled graphene.25,29,30 As inspired by the wrinkled structure, 2D crumpled carbon materials could be proposed to get abundant mesopores and a limited SSA. Taking all these considerations into account, it is imperatively demanded to take advantage of the synergistic effect between N-doping and 2D crumpled structures to realize large Li-storage at fast charging rates.
Herein, we report a capacitive-dominant graphene oxide@polypyrrole (GO@PPy)-derived anode of 2D crumpled N-doped carbon nanosheets (N-CNS) prepared by a structure-designed and nitrogen-tailoring strategy. The unique 2D crumpled structure featuring abundant mesopore distribution guarantees fast ion diffusion, while N-doping offers lots of active sites for Li-ion storage. Benefiting from the synergistic effect of the 2D wrinkled structure and N-doping, the as-synthesized N-CNS delivers a large specific capacity of 620 mA h g−1 at 0.1 A g−1 and incredible rate capability with 19.5% retention after a 1000-fold current density increase from 0.1 to 100 A g−1. The surface-controlled capacity contribution dominates in the charge storage process and can be significantly improved with increasing N-5 and N-6 contents, which is mainly attributed to the N-doping producing additional pseudocapacity and high Li+ diffusion coefficients, both of which occur in the medium–high voltage region. The charge storage mechanism is also investigated by in situ Raman and ex situ XRD. Furthermore, it is theoretically revealed that the N-5 and N-6 doped at the nanopore-defect sites can improve the Li+ adsorption energy and lower the Li+ diffusion barrier. The as-prepared N-CNS-Ar-20 could function as an outstanding anode for a LIC full cell. The resulting device could offer a large energy density of 75 W h kg−1 even at an ultrahigh power density of 65 kW kg−1 within an extremely short time of only 4.2 s, along with stable cycling ability with 91.5% capacity retention after 5000 cycles at 5 A g−1.
The morphologies and microstructures of 2D crumpled GO@PPy and N-CNS materials were examined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). GO@PPy has a 2D sheet-like wrinkled morphology with a thickness of about 25 nm (Fig. 1c and d). The sharp wrinkles are formed owing to the in-plane partial restacking of nanosheets, which plays a vital role in maintaining the structural stability of GO@PPy.31 After carbonization, the obtained N-CNS materials show similar morphologies to those of GO@PPy, maintaining the 2D crumpled structure (Fig. 1e, f and S1, ESI†). These 2D nanosheets are randomly arranged accompanied by graphene shrinkage, resulting in a paper-ball-like shape with opened channels outward and wide voids inside the crumpled nanosheets (Fig. S1, ESI†). Fig. S2, ESI† displays the microstructure of the N-CNS sample, which mainly consists of many wrinkles and relatively flat parts. High-resolution TEM (HRTEM) images further present that the relatively flat part consists of a dominantly disordered amorphous region and some distorted carbon lattices (Fig. 1g, h, S3 and S4, ESI†). Especially, the microstructure of N-CNS-Ar-20 tends to be more disordered than that of N-CNS-Ar (enlarged sections of Fig. 1g and h). The wrinkled parts present apparent lattice fringes and the corresponding average d-spacings of N-CNS-Ar/H2, N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar-5, and N-CNS-Ar-20 are measured to be 0.362, 0.354, 0.358, and 0.359 nm (Fig. S4, ESI†), respectively. These average d-spacings are higher than 0.335 nm of graphite, which highly favors Li-ion diffusion and storage. Moreover, the high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (HADDF-STEM) elemental mapping images suggest that carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen are uniformly distributed in the N-CNS materials (Fig. 1i and S5, ESI†).
The structural properties of 2D crumpled N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar/H2, N-CNS-Ar-5, and N-CNS-Ar-20 were characterized using X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns. The broad diffraction peak (002) in Fig. 2a is attributed to the amorphous structure in the partially graphitized samples and the imperfect alignment of graphitic carbon.32,33 Compared with N-CNS-Ar, the (002) peaks of N-CNS-Ar/H2, N-CNS-Ar-5, and N-CNS-Ar-20 show no obvious shift, indicating unchanged average interlayer distances for (002) planes. The interlayer distances of N-CNS samples are calculated to be around 0.352 nm, which is almost consistent with HRTEM results (Fig. S4, ESI†). The similar interlayer spacings of N-CNS materials suggest the structural stability of sharp wrinkles against the attack of hydrogen and urea during the pyrolysis process. All crumpled N-CNS materials present I/IV isotherms, showing meso/macroporous structures (Fig. 2b). The specific surface areas (SSAs) of N-CNS-Ar/H2, N-CNS-Ar-5, and N-CNS-Ar-20 are measured to be 115, 123, and 164 m2 g−1, respectively, larger than that of N-CNS-Ar (102 m2 g−1). It can be explained that the reactions of H2 and urea with the precursor increase the SSA of N-CNS, especially the micropore areas (Table S1, ESI†). This is because H2 can react with the nitrogen-containing functional groups in polypyrrole to produce NH3, which will decompose to free radicals such as NH2, NH, and atomic hydrogen and nitrogen.34,35 When carbon materials are treated with NH3 at elevated temperatures, these free radicals attack the carbon, forming nitrogen-containing functional groups and etching the carbon fragments, resulting in an increase in porosity.36 As for urea, it will decompose into carbon dioxide and ammonia at high temperatures, both of which can work as pore-forming agents and react with carbon materials to form porosity to increase the specific surface area.36,37 These samples exhibit abundant and similar mesopore/macropore distributions as well as similar external surface areas, which suggests that these mesopores are mainly the interior pores formed from the original arrangement of these crumpled carbon nanosheets and are not significantly affected by the additional treatments (Fig. 2b). It is worth noting that the micropores could store Li ions to produce sloping capacity,6,7 while the mesopores could provide wide channels for fast ion adsorption/diffusion, contributing to high specific capacity and superior rate capability.21,38 Raman spectroscopy was used to further investigate the microstructure of the resulting carbon samples. As shown in Fig. 2c, the two typical peaks of the D band at 1352 cm−1 and the G band at 1588 cm−1 fitted by using the Gaussian function are assigned to the disordered or defective graphite (sp3) and graphitic lattice structures (sp2), respectively.39 The integral area ratios of the fitted D- and G-peaks ID/IG continuously increase from 1.83 of N-CNS-Ar/H2 to 1.90 of N-CNS-Ar, 1.98 of N-CNS-Ar-5, and 2.08 of N-CNS-Ar-20, indicating that more defects are created in these carbon materials with increasing nitrogen doping (Fig. 2e). X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was conducted to analyze the surface composition of N-CNS materials (Fig. 2d, f, S6 and Table S2, ESI†). Compared with a N content of 6.3 at% in N-CNS-Ar, the treatment in the Ar/H2 atmosphere leads to a lower nitrogen content, while the N content increases markedly up to 13.2 at% when GO@PPy is carbonized with urea (Fig. 2e). As the N content of N-CNS samples increases, the pyridinic N (N-6) located at around 398 eV gradually dominates (up to 45.5% for N-CNS-Ar-20) (Fig. 2f and Table S2, ESI†), which together with N-5 was formed predominantly by substituting a carbon atom on defect sites or edges in the plane. The N-5 and N-6 act as highly active chemical sites and reversibly react with Li+ to enhance the surface-controlled pseudocapacity and improve fast Li+ diffusion.14,40,41 The quaternary-N (N-Q) proportion of N-CNS materials shows a downtrend with N content increasing. Although the N-Q is conducive to the electrical conductivity of carbon materials owing to the electron donor characteristic,42 it is more prone to breakage after lithiation than the N-6 and N-5.43 Additionally, oxygenated species such as CO can also react with Li+ (Fig. S6, ESI†), resulting in enhanced capacity.44
The electrochemical performance of 2D crumpled N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar/H2, N-CNS-Ar-5, and N-CNS-Ar-20 was measured by assembling half cells with lithium foil as the counter electrode and reference electrode. Fig. S7, ESI† presents the first four cyclic voltammetry (CV) curves of 2D crumpled N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar/H2, N-CNS-Ar-5, and N-CNS-Ar-20 within 0.02–3 V vs. Li/Li+ at a scan rate of 0.1 mV s−1. There are two cathodic peaks observed during the first lithiation process, corresponding to the irreversible reaction between Li+ and surface functional groups (first peak)45,46 and the formation of a solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) film (second peak),47 which together with the trapped Li+ in the pores can well explain the first-cycle capacity loss. As depicted in Fig. 3a, the first galvanostatic charge/discharge (GCD) profiles of N-CNS-Ar-20 deliver the maximum initial reversible charge capacity of 765 mA h g−1 at 0.1 A g−1, which is much higher than the 554 mA h g−1 of N-CNS-Ar/H2 with the lowest N content and also twice the theoretical capacity (372 mA h g−1) of graphite. The initial coulombic efficiency (ICE) of N-CNS-Ar-5 is 68%, much higher than those of N-CNS-Ar/H2 (58%), N-CNS-Ar (60%), and N-CNS-Ar-20 (59%), respectively. To further increase the coulombic efficiency, the prelithiation strategy provided in the ESI† has been adopted for N-CNS samples before utilization. Notably, in the first charging curves of N-CNS samples (Fig. 3a), a significantly increased capacity can be observed in the voltage range above around 1.0 V with increasing nitrogen content. Correspondingly, their CV shapes gradually tend to be more rectangular in the medium–high voltage range above 1.0 V with the increase in nitrogen content and a rising tendency of the integrated area of CV curves in the medium–high voltage region (highlighted by a black dotted box) is visually presented (Fig. 3b). It is suggested that the increased surface-controlled pseudocapacity offered by N-doping mainly occurs in the medium–high voltage region. Since the binding of ions at defective sites in graphene is energetically favorable,48 the increased capacity in the medium–high potential region is ascribed to the ion adsorption on active sites, especially N-doping locations. It should be pointed out that the nitrogen content is not the only factor that affects the sloping capacity, while other factors, such as SSA, also influence the electrochemical performance.
Significantly, the 2D crumpled N-CNS material as an anode exhibits an excellent ability to store and release capacity. At a current density of 0.1 A g−1, N-CNS-Ar-20 shows a large reversible capacity of 620 mA h g−1 in the 10th cycle. With further increasing current densities from 0.2, 0.5, 1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 40 to 60 A g−1, the corresponding specific capacities of N-CNS-Ar-20 decrease from 552, 484, 445, 410, 365, 327, 277, 219 to 173 mA h g−1, respectively, higher than those of N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar/H2, and N-CNS-Ar-5 at the same current densities (Fig. 3c–e and S8, ESI†). Impressively, even at an ultrahigh current density of 100 A g−1, the reversible capacity of N-CNS-Ar-20 can still reach a high value of 121 mA h g−1 within a charge time of 4.4 s, showing an ultrahigh rate capability with a capacity retention of 19.5% after a 1000-fold increase in current density from 0.1 to 100 A g−1. The most important merit of 2D crumpled N-CNS-Ar-20 is that it simultaneously achieves supercapacitor-like power output rate and battery-like specific capacity. This remarkable rate capability is among the best reported for carbon anodes (Fig. 3f and Table S3†).19,22,23,27,32,46,49–56 When comparing the charging profiles of N-CNS-Ar-20 to those of N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar/H2, and N-CNS-Ar-5 (Fig. 3c, d and S8, ESI†), it is observed that the slope of their outlines in the medium–high voltage range gradually becomes smaller due to the increase in specific capacity. Such slope-dominated curves could avoid the possibility of Li metal plating and dendrite formation for safety that concerns high-power LICs.57 The linear-capacity-dominated electrochemical behavior enables N-CNS-Ar-20 to be well-suited for high-capacity and fast-charging LICs. In brief, the high-rate capability and large capacity of 2D crumpled N-CNS-Ar-20 can be attributed to the synergistic effect of (i) the 2D structure with abundant mesopore size distribution that favors Li-ion diffusion, guaranteeing superior rate capability, and (ii) the introduced more defects especially the N-5 and N-6, which can contribute to extra capacitive capacity and still store Li ions at high rates. Furthermore, N-CNS-Ar-20 presents excellent cyclability with a capacity retention of 90% and 95% after 3000 cycles at 2 and 10 A g−1, respectively (Fig. 3g). Besides, N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar/H2, and N-CNS-Ar-5 also exhibit outstanding cyclability at a high rate of 10 A g−1 (Fig. S9, ESI†).
The structural evolution of N-CNS-Ar-20 during the first discharge and charge process is investigated by in situ Raman spectroscopy. As shown in Fig. 4a, there is no obvious position shift of the D band without peak fitting during the discharge process, but its intensity gradually weakens, which is attributed to the lithium adsorption on the defective sites and nanopores of N-CNS-Ar-20.32 As for the G band, its position shifts downward and its intensity decreases with the drop in discharging potential, which is attributed to the insertion of lithium between the graphene layers, and the increase in electrical conductivity caused by lithium insertion.58 As the voltage decreases further from 0.2 to 0.02 V in the lithiation process, lithium continues to intercalate between graphene layers, and therefore the variation of the G band is continuous, and no change suggesting staged graphite intercalation compound (GIC) formation was observed.58 It can be seen that the position and intensity of the D and G bands of N-CNS-Ar-20 can return to their initial state after full charging, suggesting its reversible structural stability, which is also proven by the ex situ XRD patterns. As presented in Fig. 4b, the (002) peak shifts to a lower position upon discharging and recovers back to the pristine angle after delithiation, suggesting an enlarged interlayer spacing caused by lithium-ion intercalation in the graphitic lattices and also its reversible structure. In situ Raman spectra and ex situ XRD patterns support the adsorption-intercalation mechanism for lithium ion storage in N-CNS-Ar-20.
Electrochemical kinetics analyses were performed based on the CV curves and galvanostatic intermittent titration technique (GITT). As shown in Fig. 4c and S10, ESI†, these samples exhibit different CV shapes at the same scan rate, and the CV curves tend to be more rectangular especially in the voltage region above 1.0 V, which is attributed to the increased pseudocapacity caused by nitrogen element doping. To quantitatively distinguish the contribution from different mechanisms, the current at a fixed potential (V) can be regarded as a combination of capacitive (k1v) and diffusion-controlled (k2v1/2) parts.59,60 The calculated results show that the capacitive charge storage process dominates in the N-CNS materials owing to their high capacitive contributions, greater than 60% at different scan rates (Fig. 4e). In particular, N-CNS-Ar-20 has the highest capacitive contributions ranging from 71.0% to 84.3% at scan rates from 0.2 to 1.0 mV s−1. For example, when comparing the capacitive fractions of N-CNS samples at 1.0 mV s−1, N-CNS-Ar-20 possesses the highest capacitive proportion of 84.3% (Fig. 4d, S10b and d, ESI†), indicating that N-CNS-Ar-20 has fast Li+ transport kinetics and can achieve excellent rate capability.
Furthermore, Li+ diffusion was evaluated through the GITT (Fig. 4f). The Li+ diffusion coefficient (DLi+) of N-CNS-Ar-20 is significantly greater than that of N-CNS-Ar before voltage discharging to 0.7 V and after charging to 1.2 V (Fig. 4g), due to the higher capacitive capacity of N-CNS-Ar-20 in the medium–high voltage region, which is mainly contributed by N-doping. The substantial enhancement of DLi+ for N-CNS-Ar-20 is extraordinarily favorable for high-rate capability. However, there is no obvious difference in DLi+ in the low voltage region, revealing that N-doping has no significant contribution to Li+ diffusion in the low potential region.
To understand the higher capacitive contribution of 2D crumpled N-CNS-Ar-20, the correlation between the electrochemical performance and physicochemical parameters (nitrogen configuration and content, d002, ID/IG, micropore/mesopore area, etc.) is further explored. Generally, the defects, heteroatoms, and SSA are regarded as the critical factors that can influence the capacitive capacity.57 It is disclosed that the specific capacity and capacitive contribution display positive correlations with the N-5 and N-6 content, ID/IG, and micropore area, while no apparent relationship is observed with the mesopore area and d002 (Fig. 4h and S11, ESI†). Compared with N-CNS-Ar, N-CNS-Ar/H2 possesses a slightly larger SSA but lower N-5 and N-6 contents, presenting a lower specific capacity and capacitive contribution, demonstrating the importance of N-5 and N-6 in achieving capacitive capacity. Based on the 2D crumpled structure with the abundant mesopore distribution, N-CNS-Ar-20 displays higher N-5 and N-6 contents, ID/IG, and micropore area, and these combined features result in a larger capacitive contribution together with higher specific capacity.
It is clearly demonstrated that Li-storage occurs in the highly N-doped CNS with both large specific capacity and excellent rate capability endowed by a surface-dominated charge storage process. To further unveil the experimental results, first-principles calculations based on density functional theory (DFT) were performed to illustrate the Li+ adsorption and diffusion abilities of the N-doped carbon structure. The optimized graphene models and their Li+ adsorption energies (Eads) are provided in Fig. S12 and Table S4, ESI†, and their corresponding charge density differences are calculated (Fig. 5a–c, S13 and 14, ESI†). The lower the adsorption energy value, the more favorable it is for Li+ adsorption. Compared with the Eads of −1.61 eV for pristine graphene (P-G) (Fig. S13a, ESI†), the Eads of nanopore-defect graphene (ND-G) is calculated to be −4.05 eV and the transferred charge gathersaround the defect, implying that the presence of nanopore defects contributes to Li+ adsorption (Fig. 5a). After incorporating N-Q into P-G and N-6 and N-5 into ND-G, the Eads values are calculated to be −1.33, −4.33, and −4.94 eV (Fig. S12b, d and e, ESI†), respectively. As a result, the charge density tends to accumulate more around the N-5 and N-6 sites, and a less favorable electron transfer for N-Q occurs (Fig. 5b, c and S13b, ESI†). It is indicated that the N-5 and N-6 located at nanopore defects can provide stronger chemical Li+ adsorption ability and are more favorable for improving charge transfer kinetics, while the N-Q exhibits an adverse effect on Li+ adsorption. When the doping number of N-6 is increased to two and four, the Eads values are −5.38 and −6.20 eV, respectively (Fig. S12f, g and S14, ESI†), implying that the defective N-CNS with more N-6 has stronger adsorption ability to grab Li+ at high rates and thus to produce large capacitive capacity. Therefore, it is confirmed that the higher capacity of N-CNS-Ar-20 could benefit from the enhancement of Li+ adsorption energy through the introduction of more defects such as N-6.
Given the importance of heteroatoms and nanopore defects in Li+ diffusion energetics, the diffusion of Li+ near active sites is explored. As presented in Fig. 5d–i and S15, ESI†, the designed diffusion pathways of different models along with the arrows are analyzed, and the corresponding diffusion energy barriers (Ed) are listed in Table S5, ESI†. For P-G, when the distance between Li+ and the hollow site H1 is 1.17 Å, the system energy reaches the maximum value (Fig. 5e), which suggests that Li+ diffuses between adjacent H sites by crossing the C–C bridge site B1 and the Ed is 0.38 eV, which is close to the reported value.61,62 The Ed values between H1 and H2 sites are 0.24, 0.20, 0.33, and 0.42 eV for nanopore-defect, N-5, N-6, and N-Q doped graphene, respectively. It is suggested that nanopore-defect, N-5, and N-6 are good for nearby Li+ diffusion along with carbon hexatomic rings, while the higher Ed value of N-Q manifests its adverse effect on Li+ diffusion (Fig. 5f–i, S15 and Table S5, ESI†). Comparing the Ed values from the H2 (H3) sites to the destination (D) (Fig. 5f–i, S15c, d and Table S5, ESI†), it can be found that Li+ diffusion can be very fast with negligible barriers as small as 0.04 and 0.07 eV for N-5 and N-6 models, respectively,63 indicating the ability of N-5 and N-6 to further reduce the diffusion barrier of ND-G. Besides the investigation of Li+ diffusion in planes, the diffusion energy barriers of Li+ along the direction perpendicular to the graphene were also explored (Fig. S16, ESI†). In comparison with the virtual impossibility of Li+ diffusion in the direction perpendicular to P-G due to a large Ed of 7.71 eV (Fig. S16a and Table S6, ESI†), the defects with nanopores and N-6 allow Li+ to diffuse easily towards themselves and go through the pore to the opposite surface or adjacent graphene's surface (Fig. S16b, c and Table S6, ESI†). Therefore, the N-doping, together with the nanopore defects, is validated to promote Li+ diffusion and contribute to improving the rate capability of highly N-doped carbon nanosheets.
To verify the practical applicability of 2D crumpled N-CNS-Ar-20, a N-CNS-Ar-20//porous carbon LIC (Fig. 6a) was fabricated with pre-lithiated N-CNS-Ar-20 as the anode and porous carbon as the cathode (Fig. S17, ESI†) and operated in the voltage range of 0–4.5 V. Considering the double match of capacity and kinetics between the two electrodes especially at high rates, the mass ratio between the anode and the cathode is selected as 1:
2. As displayed in Fig. 6b–c, the reversible capacities of the N-CNS-Ar-20//porous carbon LIC are measured to be 99, 93, 88, 80, 72, 67, 62, 54, and 46 mA h g−1 at the current densities of 0.5, 1, 2, 5, 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 A g−1, respectively, demonstrating its excellent rate capability. It is noted that the capacity retention of 46.5% of the N-CNS-Ar-20//porous carbon LIC is much higher than the 29.6% of the N-CNS-Ar//porous carbon LIC, which delivers the specific capacity of 98 mA h g−1 at 0.5 A g−1 and 29 mA h g−1 at 40 A g−1. Furthermore, the N-CNS-Ar-20//porous carbon LIC offers highly stable cycling performance with 91.5% capacity retention at 5 A g−1 after 5000 cycles (Fig. 6d). Significantly, our N-CNS-Ar-20//porous carbon LIC provides a high energy density of 223 W h kg−1 at a power density of 1.13 kW kg−1 and still maintains an impressive energy density of 75 W h kg−1 even at an ultrahigh power density of 65 kW kg−1, outputting in a very short time of 4.2 s (Fig. 6e). Such high energy density and power density of the N-CNS-Ar-20//porous carbon LIC outperform those of most previously reported LICs (Fig. 6e and Table S7, ESI†), including high defect mesopore-dominant porous carbon (HDMPC)//HDMPC,28 nitrogen atoms into carbon nanospheres (ANCS)//ANCS,54 Fe2N//activated carbon (Fe2N//AC),64 cyclohexanehexanone//activated carbon (C6O6//AC),65 NbN@C//activated carbon (NbN@C//AC),66 hierarchical pore structural graphene//edge-carbonylated graphene nanosheets (MP-G//G-COOH),27 Co4Fe-BDC//self-made activated carbon (Co4Fe-BDC//SMAC),67 FeSe2@carbon nanofibers//carbon nanofibers@activated carbon (FeSe2@CNF//CNF@AC),68 and nitrogen-doped carbon nanosheets (NCNs-2)//NCNs-2.22
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ta02681k |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |