Marolop Dapot Krisman
Simanullang
*a,
G. Bimananda M.
Wisna
*b,
Koichi
Usami
a and
Shunri
Oda
*a
aQuantum Nanoelectronics Research Center, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 2-12-1 Ookayama, Meguro, Tokyo 152-8552, Japan. E-mail: marolop.simanullang@gmail.com; soda@pe.titech.ac.jp
bDepartment of Engineering Physics, Bandung Institute of Technology, Bandung 40132, Indonesia. E-mail: wisna.gde@gmail.com
First published on 11th March 2020
Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowires were synthesized in three consecutive steps. Nominally undoped crystalline Ge nanowires were first grown using a vapor–liquid–solid growth mechanism, followed by gold catalyst removal in an etching solution and deposition of a thin layer of amorphous silicon on the nanowire surface using a chemical vapor deposition method. Catalyst removal is necessary to avoid catalyst melting during temperature increase prior to a-Si shell deposition. Field effect transistors based on Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowires exhibited p-channel depletion-mode characteristics as a result of free hole accumulation in the Ge channel. Scaled on-currents and transconductances up to 3.1 mA μm−1 and 4.3 mS μm−1, respectively, as well as on/off ratios and field-effect hole mobilities up to 102 and 664 cm2 V−1 s−1, respectively, were obtained for these Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowire FETs. The minimum subthreshold slope was measured to be 300 mV dec−1. The present work also demonstrates for the first time the conductance quantization in one-dimensional Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowires at low temperatures. The quantization of conductances at discrete values of G0 = 2e2/h at low temperatures suggests that our Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowires are multi-mode ballistic conductors with a mean-free-path up to 500 nm. The results provided here are relevant for the synthesis of high-quality Ge-core/Si-shell nanowires for high-mobility devices with transparent contacts to hole carriers.
To fabricate nanowire FETs, substrates that contain Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowires were suspended in isopropanol and ultrasonically agitated to remove the nanowires from the growth substrate. The nanowires were then drop-cast onto pre-patterned substrates (100 thermally grown SiO2/Si substrates). Electrical contacts to the nanowires were made by defining source and drain electrodes separated by 400–1200 nm with JEOL-JBX5FE electron-beam lithography, evaporation of 100 nm-thick Ni, and subsequent lift-off in acetone. Before Ni evaporation, the sample was dipped in buffered hydrofluoric acid for 3 s to remove any native oxides from the nanowire surface. 5 nm-thick hafnium oxide (HfO2) (dielectric constant = 24) was then deposited on the devices using the atomic layer deposition process. Finally, the top-gate electrode was defined by electron-beam lithography, followed by evaporation of Ni/Au (5 nm/50 nm) and lift-off in acetone. The top-gate electrode forms an omega-shaped gate that is partly wrapped around the nanowire. The electrical transport properties of the devices at room temperature and low temperatures were measured using a probe station (Cascade Microtech) and a physical property measurement system (PPMS, Quantum Design), respectively.
Fig. 2(a) and (b) show typical output (Idversus Vd) and transfer characteristics (Idversus Vg), respectively, at room temperature of top-gated FETs fabricated from a single Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowire with a channel length of 800 nm. A well-defined transition from a linear to a nearly constant Id with an increasing |Vd| can be seen in the Idversus Vd family of curves. The transfer characteristics show that the drain current Id increases as the gate voltage Vg decreases from +2 to −2 V, and therefore the device is a p-channel depletion-mode FET.2 The ambipolar behavior of all devices measured in the present work is due to the similar transfer characteristics. The devices fabricated from Ge-core/crystalline Si-shell have also been observed to exhibit the p-channel depletion-mode (normally on) FET because the Fermi level lies below the Ge valence band edge in the absence of a gate.9 This result is distinct from that in our previous report on the devices fabricated from undoped Ge nanowires that show characteristics of a p-channel enhancement-mode FET (normally off).12 In the present study, the a-Si layer that coats the Ge nanowire surface causes the Fermi level to be pinned below the Ge valence band edge. As a result, the free holes will accumulate in the Ge channel at zero gate voltage. The valence band offset in the Ge-core/a-Si-shell structure was calculated to be ∼0.87 eV, which is larger than that in the Ge-core/crystalline Si-shell structure (∼0.51 eV) (see Fig. S1 in the ESI†). Amorphous Si is known to have a high defect density due to its disordered structure. The surface states of a-Si contribute significantly to the Fermi level pinning at the Ge-core/a-Si interface. A larger valence band offset and more pronounced Fermi level pinning create a deeper quantum well of holes at the Ge-core/a-Si-shell interface. We also mentioned above that the transfer characteristics show ambipolar behavior. At large positive gate voltages, the Id currents are observed to increase from Vg +1.4 to +2 V due to electron conduction.13 One may believe that the ambipolar behavior is linked to the gold catalyst etching process that introduces nominal impurities into the Ge nanowires. However, we argue that the ambipolar behavior is due to the sole effect of gate voltage application. In the on-state, electron conduction does not occur in the channel because the electrons are located at the conduction band and the Fermi level is way below the valence band of the Ge-core/a-Si-shell system; however at large positive Vg in the symmetrical gate configuration in our device, the electron carriers could be injected via tunneling from the drain due to large conduction band bending. This injection of electrons or minority carriers is indeed a disadvantage during the operation of FETs and can be fully resolved by using asymmetric gate configuration.9 More investigations are needed to know the nature of this minority carrier, such as lifetime and diffusion lengths.
The Idversus Vg transfer characteristics recorded for Vd = −1 V reveal that the Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowire FET has a maximum transconductance of 46.6 μS and subthreshold slope (SS) of 300 mV dec−1. To obtain the on and off current (Ion and Ioff), the values at Vg(on) = VT − (2/3)Vdd and Vg(off) = VT + (1/3)Vdd were first calculated using the metrics defined in ref. 14, where VT is the threshold voltage and is determined from the intersection of the tangent to the maximum slope and the x-axis of the Id–Vg curve and Vdd is the supply voltage, equal to Vd = 1 V in this case. VT, Vg(on), and Vg(off) were calculated to be 0.62, −0.047, and 0.953 V, respectively (Fig. 3). The values of VT > 0 and Vg(off) > VT are consistent with the characteristics of a p-channel depletion mode FET. From the Id–Vg curve in Fig. 3, the on current is 30.2 μA with a maximum drain current of 92.2 μA. The off current is 0.87 μA with a minimum drain current of 0.12 μA. The on/off ratio is ∼35 calculated from the on and off current. We also estimated the field-effect hole mobility (μh) of this device at different bias voltages using the analytical expression15
(1) |
Fig. 3 Transfer characteristics for Vd = −1 V on the linear scale (blue curve) and logarithmic scale (black curve). The red line is the tangent to the maximum slope on the linear scale where the intersection of this line and the x-axis denotes the threshold voltage. The on-off currents were calculated using the metrics defined in ref. 14. The subthreshold slope (SS) is 300 mV per decade. The dashed blue line indicates the physical limit of SS (60 mV per decade at room temperature). |
Fig. 4 (a) Field-effect hole mobility versus gate voltage (Vg) at Vd = −0.01, −0.1, −0.5 and −1 V. (b) Histogram of Ge-core/a-Si shell nanowire FET mobility. |
To study the effect of the number of nanowires in our device, we fabricated top-gated FETs consisting of a single nanowire and three nanowires with the same channel length (1 μm). This length is chosen for comparison with the 800 nm channel length device discussed above. The Idversus Vg characteristics of these devices are given in Fig. 5. For the device with a single nanowire, the calculated gm, Ion, Ioff, and on/off ratio are 27.1 μS, 17.3 μA, 0.17 μA, and 100, respectively, and for the device with three nanowires, the calculated gm, Ion, Ioff, and on/off ratio are 44.1 μS, 28.3 μA, 0.71 μA, and 40, respectively. These results show that the devices with shorter channel lengths or multiple nanowire channels exhibit improved gm and Ion but the on/off ratio is compromised. The on current is an important parameter to determine the intrinsic device speed or gate delay (τ), which represents the frequency limit of transistor operation. The intrinsic device speed is calculated using the relationship τ = CoxVdd/Ion.13Fig. 6 shows the intrinsic device speed of seven representative FETs fabricated from a single Ge-core/a-Si nanowire in this work versus the gate length for gate lengths of 500–1200 nm. Planar Si p-MOSFETs14 and Ge-core/crystalline Si-shell nanowire FETs17 are also shown for comparison. The Ge-core/a-Si and Ge-core/crystalline Si-shell nanowire FETs have a quite similar intrinsic device speed although the latter exhibits a steeper slope. Further research is needed to study the intrinsic device speed of the Ge-core/a-Si nanowire FETs as the gate length is further scaled down. Both device types, however, exhibit a much steeper slope (faster intrinsic device speed) than planar Si p-MOSFETs.
Fig. 6 Intrinsic device speed or gate delay of Ge-core/a-Si shell nanowire FETs versus gate length. Planar Si p-MOSFETs from ref. 14 and Ge-core/crystalline Si-shell nanowire FETs from ref. 17 are included for comparison. |
We also carried out temperature-dependent electrical transport measurements to further characterize the Ge-core/a-Si-shell nanowire. To examine the temperature dependence of the field-effect mobility, Vg was first swept from −2 to 2 V (|Vd| was kept constant at 0.1 V). The transconductance was then derived using eqn (1) and the field-effect hole mobility value was selected at a Vg of 0.88 V for each temperature condition (the field-effect mobility at room temperature reaches its peak value at a Vg of 0.88 V). Fig. 7 shows the relationship between the field-effect hole mobility measured at |Vd| = 0.1 V and temperature for a 1 μm channel length device fabricated from a single nanowire. The temperature range in Fig. 7 can be divided into three regions: I (4.2 to 175 K), II (175 to 310 K), and III (310 to 350 K). Region III will be discussed first. In region III, as temperature further increases from 310 to 350 K, the peak mobility decreases due to increased hole-phonon scattering. In region II, as temperature increases from 175 to 310 K, sufficient thermal energy is available to accelerate the hole velocity (the peak mobility increases and reaches its highest value at 310 K) overcoming the surface state scattering. In region I, the peak mobility decreases as temperature increases and reaches its lowest value at 175 K. This can be explained by the dependency of the surface state scattering rate at the boundary between Ge-core/Si-shell on temperature. The surface state is dependent on temperature; as the temperature increases from 4.2 K to 175 K, the ionization of the surface state will increase and the hole carrier will occupy higher radial sub-bands resulting in more hole fractions near the boundary. This increases the scattering rate between hole carriers and the surface state leading to decreasing mobility.18 The temperature-dependent mobility in one-dimensional Ge-core/a-Si-shell systems is distinct from that in two-dimensional hole gas (2DHG) mobility systems studied using planar heterostructures where the mobility decreases monotonically with increasing temperatures due to increased phonon scattering,19–22 whereas in 1D heterostructure systems, the surface state plays an important role at low temperature due to the surface to volume ratio being greatly enhanced compared to that of 2D systems. To the best of our knowledge, temperature-dependent mobility in one-dimensional Ge-core/a-Si-shell has never been reported before. Our result demonstrates a unique feature of one-dimensional hole gas.
Fig. 7 Field-effect hole mobility versus temperature calculated at Vd = −0.1 V. The field-effect hole mobility value was selected at Vg 0.88 V for each temperature condition. |
We also fabricated a 500 nm channel length device and studied its temperature-dependent electrical transport. The low-field transfer characteristics of this device with various bias voltages (Vd = −2, −4, −5, −6, −8, and −10 mV) at 4.2 K are shown in Fig. 8(a). Current oscillations are observed at each given Vd, probably corresponding to the quantum transport behaviors of holes in confined one-dimensional structures. To further explore this phenomenon, we calculated the conductance by dividing the measured drain currents by the applied drain voltages and plotted it against the gate voltages in units of G0 (Fig. 8(b)). The stepwise features are observed in each conductance plot and they correspond to the quantization of the channel density of states. The stepwise features become negligible at Vd = −10 mV which can be attributed to carrier-heating effects.
The mean free path of Ge-core/crystalline Si-shell is calculated to be 540 nm.8 Ballistic conduction is expected to be observable when the channel length is comparable to or shorter than the mean free path. Low-temperature measurements are desirable to suppress scattering due to thermal vibrations. We could expect that the transport in our Ge-core/a-Si shell nanowire approaches ballistic conduction at low temperature. Our claim is supported by the conductance values near the zero source-drain voltage that show stepwise features at 1G0 and 2G0 (Fig. 8(b)). This suggests that the mean-free-path in our Ge-core/a-Si nanowires is equivalent to the channel length which is up to 500 nm. These steps agree with the Landauer formula of multi-modes of ballistic conductors23
(2) |
Although we do not measure the plateau of conductance at higher values of G0 due to our data limitation with −2 V ≤ Vg ≤ 2 V (higher values of G0 are useful to determine the maximum transverse mode value), we conclude that our Ge-core/a-Si nanowires are a multi-mode ballistic conductor at low temperatures. This result is distinct from that obtained in the Ge-core/crystalline Si-shell study in which the characteristics of a single-mode ballistic conductor with a maximum conductance plateau at 1G0 are observed.8 In Fig. 8(b), as Vd varies further from 0 V (−2 mV to −6 mV), the plateaus of 1G0 and 2G0 are slightly shifted upward. The effect of the source-drain voltage on the upward shift of the curves was also observed by other researchers in 1-D quantum wires as well as in quantum point contacts (QPCs).24,25,29 The deviation from the discrete value of G0 at high |Vd| is attributed to the sub-band energy separation at the Fermi level approximately close to the value of |Vd|.29 In our experiment, the conductance plateaus at 1G0 and 2G0 start to deviate upward after |Vd| = 2 mV. This suggests that the sub-band energy separation in our Ge-core/a-Si nanowires is between 2 and 4 meV. The finite (non-zero) Vd also contributes to the evolution of the “0.7 structure” approaching a value of ∼0.9G0 at |Vd| = 10 mV.30 The quantization plateaus also become broadened as we increase the temperature from 4.2 K to 50 K (the Vd is kept constant at 5 mV) as shown in Fig. 9. This broadening is also known as thermal smearing. Thermal smearing has been extensively studied theoretically and experimentally in QPCs. The underlying mechanism of this phenomenon is that at high temperatures, the electron states at the lower sub-band are no longer fully occupied because some electrons occupy the electron states in the next sub-band with higher energy. This mechanism leads to energy-averaging of the conductance with an effective energy-averaging parameter ΔE = 4kBT where T is the absolute temperature at which the plateaus almost disappear and kB is the Boltzmann constant.31,32 From Fig. 9, energy-averaging becomes significant above 7.5 K and the stepwise features almost disappear at 10 K. These absolute temperatures correspond to energy-averaging parameters between ∼2.6 meV and ∼3.5 meV, close to the value of the estimated sub-band energy separation mentioned above.
Fig. 9 Conductance versus gate voltage at Vd = −5 mV measured at various temperatures. The x-axis has been shifted to the right for clarity of comparison. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0na00023j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |