Sunhwi
Eom
,
Dong Won
Kang
,
Minjung
Kang
,
Jong Hyeak
Choe
,
Hyojin
Kim
,
Dae Won
Kim
and
Chang Seop
Hong
*
Department of Chemistry, Korea University, Seoul 02841, Republic of Korea. E-mail: cshong@korea.ac.kr
First published on 16th January 2019
Elaborate control of wettability in a single platform is essential for materials’ applications towards oil–water separation, but it still remains challenging. Herein, we performed postcoordination modification of Mg2(dobpdc) with monoamines of various alkyl chain lengths, enabling both long-term hydrolytic stability and facile fine-tuning of wettability. An efficient separation of oil–water mixtures was achieved by using the octylamine-appended framework (OctA). We also prepared an OctA/reduced graphene oxide aerogel that showed exceptional absorption capacities towards organic solvents and oil as well as superb recyclability with maintained absorbency.
Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are a new class of crystalline solids with a large surface area and tunable pore properties. Most MOFs show hydrolytic instability and are unsuitable for oil–water separation. Therefore, the design and synthesis of hydrophobic and water-stable MOFs are imperative for their potential application in oil–water separation. The construction of such frameworks was attempted by introducing hydrophobic moieties into the backbone. When long alkyl and/or fluorine-containing organic linkers were utilized, MOFs became hydrophobic.10–14 In addition, the incorporation of polymers into the frameworks or exposure to corrugated aromatic hydrocarbon surfaces induced hydrophobicity of MOFs.15–17 Nonetheless, these approaches associated with ligand modification by hydrophobic side groups may require expensive ligand components or multistep synthetic procedures. For practical application in oil–water separation, facile synthesis of a water-stable and hydrophobic framework is ultimately desirable.
Recently, the combination of MOFs with hydrophobic polymeric materials was explored to create MOF-based hybrid composites. Only a few hybrid MOF composites with hydrophobicity have been reported to date, exhibiting diverse functions such as photocatalytic ability, removal of toxic substances, and oil–water and hydrocarbon separation.12,18–21 ZIF-8 has been exclusively utilized as a pillar component for the fabrication of such hybrid composites. However, the reported ZIF-8-based composite materials have shown very low absorption capacities for organic solvents or oil in comparison with other hydrophobic materials.22
The expanded version of MOF-74, Mg2(dobpdc) (dobpdc4− = 4,4′-dioxidobiphenyl-3,3′-dicarboxylate) with a high density of open metal sites, has been investigated mostly to capture CO2 from flue gas emissions after diamine functionalization.23–29 Herein, we report a facile yet unique method for postsynthetically inducing hydrophobicity of the hydrophilic Mg2(dobpdc) framework. The platform is readily transformable from hydrophilic to hydrophobic by appending monoamines with various alkyl chain lengths to the open metal sites, which has not been demonstrated before. This simply modified hydrophobic framework with long-term hydrolytic stability enables effective separation of oil (hexadecane) and water, leading to successful oil removal. Moreover, the composite MOF/reduced graphene oxide aerogel (rGA) provides significant absorption capacities for organic liquids, which are much greater than those provided by MOF-based composites and comparable to those of top-performing materials,12,18–20,22 and excellent reusability without capacity loss.
The N2 isotherms at 77 K were measured to determine the BET surface areas (Fig. 1b). The surface areas gradually decreased from 1476 m2 g−1 for PA to 772 m2 g−1 for OctA and then abruptly decreased to 28–53 m2 g−1 for DcA, TdA, and HdA. The values are much smaller than that (3280 m2 g−1) of the non-modified framework, which is attributed to the amines grafted onto the open metal sites of the Mg2(dobpdc) framework. In the pore size distributions (Fig. 1c), pores were observed at 18.4 and 15.6 Å for PA. It is interesting to note that the pores at 15.2 Å emerged from n = 4 (BA) and remained until n = 8 (OctA). This result indicates that the alkyl chain lengths ranging from n = 4 to 8 do not affect the smaller pore size of the framework. No pores existed with n larger than 10 because all pores were blocked by the amines with long alkyl chains. The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images of monoamine-functionalized Mg2(dobpdc) were similar to that of Mg2(dobpdc) (Fig. S4†).
To examine the hydrophobicity with amines appended onto the open metal sites of the framework, we measured the contact angles of water droplets dropped on the solid surface of each sample (Fig. 1d and S5†). No contact angle was observed until n = 5, implying that the surface of the solids remained hydrophilic. The modified framework became hydrophobic at n = 8, and the contact angle was larger than 110°. Hydrophobicity was maintained until n = 16. After the contact angles were saturated, they slightly decreased with increasing n. This is likely due to the grafting of few monoamines onto the open metal sites as the chain length increases (refer to elemental analysis results in the Experimental section). We further investigated the hydrophobicity by measuring water adsorption isotherms (Fig. S6†). For PA, water vapor was adsorbed above P/P0 = 0.4 and desorbed with hysteresis, suggesting hydrophilicity. In comparison, negligible water adsorption occurred in OctA and DcA, which is consistent with the hydrophobicity confirmed by the contact angle measurements. The structural integrity was checked by PXRD before and after water adsorption (Fig. S7†). We also tested the long-term stability in water, and found that the solids with n ≤ 6 were unstable after 24 h immersion, whereas the samples with n ≥ 8 were stable even after immersion in water for 7 d (Fig. S8†). The incorporation of longer amines into the pores of the framework promotes both hydrophobicity and water stability. This result indicates that wettability and water stability are readily controllable by such simple modification of the pore surface using the open metal sites, which has been demonstrated for the first time in this study.30,31
The hydrophobicity was further investigated by immersing the pelletized samples in a mixed solvent system with a water layer (bottom) and an oil layer (top) composed of hexadecane colored with a yellowish Sudan I dye (Fig. S9a†). The hydrophilic sample pellets were dispersed over the water layer. In contrast, the hydrophobic sample pellets floated on the water layer and moved into the oil layer, indicating that organic pollutants can be readily extracted. We carried out a sorption test of hexadecane using an OctA pellet. After the pellet was placed on an oil droplet, the yellow oil diffused into it (Fig. S9b†).
Oil–water separation was conducted using the hydrophobic MOF OctA. To visually distinguish between oil (hexadecane) and water, we stained the water with Acid Orange dye (Fig. 2). The separation membrane was fabricated by sandwiching MOF powder between two gauze layers. A mixture of oil and water was poured into a syringe. The syringe was slightly tilted so that the oil part touched the membrane and selectively penetrated through the film. It is obvious that only oil was filtered down, while the orange water part remained in the syringe, suggesting that this membrane made of OctA provides effective oil–water separation. The other hydrophobic materials also showed similar separation behaviors (Fig. S10–S12†). Moreover, we attempted to separate water-in-toluene emulsions using this framework. The opaque emulsions indicate the existence of colloidal water (Fig. S13†).32 After the separation of the emulsions by an identical membrane, we obtained a clean solution only containing toluene. Thus, the hydrophobic OctA enables the successful separation of oil–water mixtures. Furthermore, we carried out the time-dependent separation process to obtain the permeation flux and separation efficiency of the membrane (Fig. S14†).33,34
A MOF/rGA composite was synthesized by a one-pot reaction of graphene oxide (GO) and a MOF in the presence of hydrazine hydrate (Fig. 3a). To prepare proper aerogels, the MOF should be well dispersed over water. The dispersion tests showed that OctA was the most homogeneously dispersed, but the other hydrophobic MOFs were partly dispersed or rapidly precipitated (Fig. S15†). After the one-pot reaction, OctA only produced a well-formed aerogel with a uniform distribution of OctA over rGA (Fig. S16†). Therefore, we concentrated on the properties of the OctA/rGA aerogel. According to a previous report, GO contains hydroxyl and epoxide groups located above and below the GO plane, and carboxylic groups at the edge.4 These groups could be reduced by hydrazine hydrate.35 To examine the compositional changes after the reduction, the IR spectra were measured. CO stretching at 1723 cm−1 was visible in GO but disappeared in the OctA/rGA aerogel, which indicates that reduction of the corresponding functional groups occurred (Fig. S17†). As seen in the X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) results, the intensity ratio of C/O for rGA was smaller than that for GO, further indicating the reduction of CO groups by the reducing agent (Fig. 3b). Binding energies (50 and 88 eV) were present in the XPS spectrum of OctA, which are assignable to Mg 2p and 2s peaks, respectively. These peaks were also seen in the XPS spectrum of the OctA/rGA composite, which indicates that OctA was impregnated in rGA. Notably, the N 1s peak (351 eV) emerged in the XPS data of both OctA and OctA/rGA. In the narrow scan of the XPS spectra of the core-level C 1s peak, the CO peak in GO was absent in rGA due to the reduction, while the CO and C–N peaks appeared in OctA/rGA, confirming the presence of the dobpdc4− ligand and octylamine group in the composite (Fig. S18†). Given that N atoms only originate from octylamines grafted onto the open metal sites of the Mg2(dobpdc) platform, this result implies that the amine groups appended to the platform remained intact even in the composite formed by one-pot synthesis.
The existence of OctA in the aerogel was additionally verified by examination of the surface morphology by SEM; the image of OctA/rGA shows that rod-shaped OctA particles were well incorporated into the rGA (Fig. 3c). Moreover, the homogeneous distribution of OctA over the aerogel was confirmed by energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) mapping (Fig. 3d). The PXRD pattern of OctA was discernible in OctA/rGA, suggesting that the phase of the MOF remained in the composite gel (Fig. 3e). The OctA loading, determined by TGA, was consistent with the nominal values, indicating that all MOFs added to the suspension were incorporated into the aerogel (Fig. S19 and Table S1†).36 The porosity was checked using the N2 isotherm of OctA/rGA at 77 K (Fig. S20†). For GO, there was no water contact angle because of the hydrophilic character arising from hydroxyl, epoxide, and carboxylic groups. The contact angle (25°) of rGA increased slightly with respect to GO, which is associated with the reduction of the functional groups (Fig. S21†). The enhanced hydrophobicity allows the aggregation of rGO sheets. When Mg2+ was used as a cross-linker, the gel Mg2+/rGA showed an increased contact angle of 69°. It is interesting to note that the inclusion of OctA facilitated the rapid gel formation of OctA/rGA and a high contact angle of 134°, which is greater than that (110°) for OctA. The hydrophobic OctA particles with functional groups could favor extensive interaction with reduced GO sheets, leading to enhancement of the water contact angle. These results demonstrate that the reduction of some hydrophilic functional groups in GO leads to the effective crosslinking of rGO with OctA and the subsequent self-assembly of the reduced GO sheets, resulting in the formation of the consequent hydrophobic hydrogel.
To investigate the composite aerogel's absorption behavior with various organic liquids, we stained hexadecane with Sudan I (Fig. 4a–c). The yellow hexadecane was rapidly absorbed by the aerogel when the liquid was touched by the OctA/rGA composite. The absorption capacity was estimated using the formula 100(Wwet − Wdry)/Wdry, where Wwet and Wdry denote the weights of wet and dry samples, respectively. Fig. 4d presents the weight gain upon solvent absorption by the composite aerogel. The absorption capacity of OctA ranged from 423 to 1012 wt%, while Mg2+/rGA exhibited a capacity in the range of 1900 to 4600 wt%. Notably, the absorption capacity of the OctA/rGA aerogel was much greater than that of OctA and Mg2+/rGA, and ranged from 4700 to 16122 wt%. We also investigated the absorption capacities of DcA/rGA, TdA/rGA, and HdA/rGA, which were smaller than that of OctA/rGA (Fig. S22†). The distribution of MOF particles was probed using SEM images of the composites (Fig. S23†). Contact angle measurements revealed that hydrophobicity was maintained (Fig. S24†). These results demonstrated that the reduced capacities could be due to the poor formation of aerogels, as shown in Fig. S16.†
The different densities and viscosities of the corresponding organic substances contribute to different absorption capacities. There was no swelling in the size of OctA/rGA even after absorbing the pump oil with the highest capacity value, suggesting that the oil diffuses into the pores of the aerogel (Fig. S25†).
The capacity values of OctA/rGA exceed those of conventional resins, sponges, and foams as well as MOF-incorporated composites, and are comparable to those of top-performing porous materials.12,19,37–40 The reusability of the aerogel was assessed through recycling tests on the organic solvents (Fig. 4e). We ran 10 cycles of absorption–desorption processes. The absorbed samples were activated for 30 min at the boiling temperature of each solvent except for hexadecane which was desorbed at 100 °C for 24 h. For benzene, the adsorption capacity remained significant between 11500 and 13100 wt% during the repeated cycles. The other organic liquids also maintained their capacities within narrow variation ranges. The compositional distributions in the aerogel were examined by SEM-EDS elemental mapping analyses (Fig. S26–S32†). Mg elements were observed in the images together with N atoms from monoamines, highlighting the strong binding affinity of the OctA particles to the rGA platform during absorption–desorption cycles. The contact angle measurements confirmed that the hydrophobicity was well maintained throughout the cycles, and the IR and PXRD data of the samples corroborated the structural integrity after the cycling tests (Fig. S33–S35†).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8sc04581j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |